Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

  • Deep Dive 4.mp3

Some files exceed the archive size limit and weren't saved: 1 file. Please note these limits are in place to keep this site running long term, without costing a fortune. You can favorite the creator though, certain milestones increase the limit.

Content

EARLY RELEASE - UNLOCKED -: Matthew Furlong returns for the fourth installment of our Dialectics Deep Dive series.

Today, we finish off our study of Spinoza, and begin our dive into Deleuze and Guattari.

In the next installment, we will go deeper into Deleuze and Guattari, as well as their relationship to Hegel, dialectics, and much more. 

Files

Comments

Givon

seeing the title followed by the 3.5 hour timestamp literally made my week lmfao. can't wait to listen to this! matthew is so fun to listen to

Rev Left Radio

hahaha, hope you enjoy it! These Deep Dives tend toward the extremely long but hopefully some segment of our audience loves it.

Sparrow

Hey I had sent you a question on Deleuze to the Red Menace Patreon account a little while ago. Is it better to just always message the Rev Left one?

Sparrow

Omg 3.5 hours 🤩🤩🤩

Rev Left Radio

A whole other installment on Deleuze will be up next! This is just the inital foray into his work! :)

Rev Left Radio

i have a very difficult time keeping up on all the messages on the various platforms, and I apologize for that. You can ask the question here tho!

Sparrow

Okee doke! Friend I would hate to have to be as plugged in as you have to be. So I can’t understand the deleuzean non-dialectical materialism. How do you get rid of the negation? All the things I can find are from Jordan Peterson types or in one case an anti capitalist trying to redefine accelerationism Maybe a better question is how would post capitalism resolve without synthesis? Just death and rebirth? But we still have forms of old political economy like feudalism and slavery even today. Wondering if maybe I’m fundamentally misunderstanding

Austin Miller

Anybody else get Pho for dinner after listening to this episode? 😂😂

Seth Dalton

Loved loved loved this episode (actually still going, but 3 hours in I can say it's excellent). As someone currently diving into Bergson, and referencing him for a creative project, I was wondering if Matthew could give the source to what he paraphrases of Bergson about 38 min to ep, about how the impossibility of living forever due to the paralyzing effect of memory accumulation.

Seth Dalton

I watched some Todd May Lectures on Deleuze that spoke to this...let me see if I can find.

Seth Dalton

About 2 hrs 15 min into this lecture May gets into Deleuze's critique of Hegel and "the labor of the negative". With D's ontology of difference being primacy to identities, things don't emerge out of opposition (negation), but affirmation. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pgh9hMgSKEM&t=2s

Matthew

Oof, I pulled that one deep out of my memory-basement. I'll try to hunt it down for you!

Matthew

@Sparrow - I just typed out a response to you and seem to have accidentally deleted it, so I'll give it another shot! In short, Deleuze doesn't propose to abolish the category of negation but rather to re-position it in thinking about the genesis of nature, the genesis of beings within nature, and the genesis of thinking beings. Chapter IV in Difference and Repetition, "Ideas and the Synthesis of Difference" gets into this question and I'll be looking to that text for our next episode, the working title of which is "Hegel, Deleuze, and the role of negation in the concept of dialectical materialism". Hopefully that will make things more clear for you, and I'll try to incorporate some points about the role of synthesis in Deleuze's thinking, which is very important for him. I'll also try to show, in response to your question, how there is more than just death and rebirth at work here. Aside from primary texts, particularly the Phenomenology of Spirit and the Science of Logic, I'll be looking to at least these two texts for interpretive support: Jean Hyppolite's Logic and Existence (1952) and Pierre Macherey's Hegel or Spinoza? (1979). The former in particular is a landmark text in Postwar French thinking, to the point that it's been asserted that Deleuze's concept of difference is impossible without it. Additionally, I'll be looking at Engel's discussion of negation, fundamentally double negation, AKA "the negation of the negation" in Anti-Dühring. Interestingly, he defends it as a very general descriptive or analytical tool for understanding how change happens in nature and history, but also notes that the closer you get to actually dealing with actually-existing singular things the less applicable it gets. This is where I think Deleuze, with Guattari, comes in. It seems to me that their primary concern is the treatment of negation as a first category in psychogenesis, for example in the Freudian topology. They find negative individual and social outcomes in such an application--toxic masculinity being one such possible outcome--which I think is what fundamentally underpins their discourse in Anti-Oedipus. Lastly, the fact that Deleuze doesn't use the terminology of dialectics does create some difficulties for interpretation. It seems to me that, for him, that terminology in his context had become what McLuhan calls "an overheated medium" and he moved away from it to articulate some fresh conceptions. Nonetheless, the logic of his thinking converges very closely to somebody like Mao's which is called "dialectics". To address this difficulty I'll probably talk a little bit about how the rise of analytic philosophy, for example in Frege's landmark paper "Sense and Reference" alerted people to greater complexities in the relationships between terms and concepts than they had previously investigated. I hope that this helps a little bit, and that the episode will help further. I wanted a little more development time than usual for it, since it's a difficult topic, so we'll probably be recording in January sometime. Thank you for your question, and for your interest!

Rev Left Radio

This is all really great feedback and questioning! I am on the run ATM, but we will address this stuff in the next installment for sure! We will dive deep into it!

Sparrow

@Matthew F., Wow wow wow thank you so much!!! I’m even more excited for the next installment in this series! Also Matt, I would absolutely love to hear more about Newfoundland (from any angle) like you discussed a long time ago. I got to visit once for a job interview in 2017 and very much enjoyed it (at the refinery, which I’d also love to hear your thoughts on).

Sparrow

I loved the novels and they’re so prescient but I just don’t understand the religious element of the second book.

Sparrow

Shiiit +1 for your Soviet thinker series, Matt!

Cody

Hey Breht, my condolences to your loss. Thinking of you and your family ❤️

Megedon

Deeply sorry for your loss. Keeping you and your family in my thoughts.

Sparrow

What happened? 🙁

Rev Left Radio

My father passed away this week at the age of 55. It was mentioned on twitter I think. I appreciate the kindness and support.

Rev Left Radio

Thank you to everyone for the kind words and support regarding the loss of my father this week. I really appreciate it.

Demarchic Communism Podcast

Matthew, I'm extremely impressed by the depth and breadth of your reading and understanding, not only of philosophy, but of various communists theorists. The fact that you were able to bring up a relevant and non-derogatory excerpt from Trotsky while also quoting Mao and Hoxha suggests your ability to read without allowing ideological barriers (I was similarly impressed by Breht's statement that he listens to Jordan Peterson and various liberals to understand their ideas and where they are going - I've always had difficulty listening to right wingers or even centrists). Combined with your citations of a few Soviet philosophers, I'm going to go out on a limb and suggest that you might have been able to interpolate from your various readings (including, I would imagine, perhaps others not mentioned here: novels, magazine articles, etc.) a much better idea of what life was like in the USSR, perhaps even how it evolved through the different periods, from NEP to ostensible socialism under Stalin, to the revisionist period, and the denouement under Gorbachev. Additionally, I'd guess that your research abilities would enable you to quickly find additional sources if you were to, say, be a guest on a podcast trying to expose a far more human picture of life in the USSR and/or in China while Mao was alive, etc. than most of the English-speaking world would currently understand. Does that sound like something you'd be interested in? (not that I have a podcast, though I am thinking of starting one, or two...?)

Squiggle

Whitehead shout-out!💪

Squiggle

I wish I could come sit with you through these days of mourning, Breht. May you be comforted and well cared for.

Seth Dalton

Matthew - any luck with this sourcing? I'm just getting more and more into Bergson (and his influence on Deleuze, particularly with the cinema books), so eager to know. But no stress! I may poke around Matter and Memory to see if it's there somewhere.

Matthew

Hi Seth, sorry for the very very late reply! I looked and looked and wasn't able to find it in any of the material I have, and I was sure it was in Matter and Memory. It could have been quoted or referenced by Deleuze somewhere. Apologies for coming up short for you. I'll keep it on the radar and hopefully come across it again eventually, because now it's driving me nuts haha