Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

If you havent heard this one yet, definitely check it out!

I think its a genuinely unique and interesting conversation, and I get the bonus of getting to talk about China *at length*. If you disagree with something I say, please let me know your critique and position! China is an infinitely deep and genuinely complex topic, and I am trying my best to understand its rise and its dynamics like anyone else; as such I am open to being corrected if I get something wrong.

Also, Immanuel is a real treat, and Adnan and Henry are *great* as always!

Subscribe to Guerrilla History on your fav podcast app.

Support Guerrilla History and get bonus monthly episodes and early releases here: https://www.patreon.com/guerrillahistory

Files

China, and the "Western Left" w/ Immanuel Ness (IB Part 2)

We have another fun Intelligence Briefing this time, with a special guest!  For this conversation that takes a look at China, and once again takes aim at the "Western Left", we bring back our good friend and comrade Professor Immanuel Ness.

Comments

Justine Rojas

I really enjoyed this conversation. I too have been attempting to learn more about China’s history, politics and contradictions over the last year. Carl Zha’s Silk and Steele podcast has been an excellent resource in that regard. But something I listened to recently kept giving me reflection and context as I listened to your conversation with Elliott Ness. It is a three part episode called “Has China Won” on “After “the end of history”” (hawks and sparrows project on patreon). It is an exploration of Kishore Mahbuhbani’s work titled “Has China won? The Chinese challenge to American Primacy.” It gave me so much more context in how the US is conducting itself in the face of China’s rise and the inevitable clash as US faces down its impending hegemonic decline. I’ve been recommending it to everyone who has even the slightest interest in China or US imperialism (and even those who don’t HA)

MLDad

This is the intl paper of the CCP. I don't pretend to agree w/ everything, and it'd be nice if they had this type of insight regarding some of their mistakes in the same period, but this is interesting: "Li Shenming, former vice president of the Chinese Academy of Social Sciences, told the Global Times that "there are many different explanations from around the world about why the Soviet Union collapsed, but the one which holds that 'Stalinism,' or 'the socialist model of the Soviet Union,' is the root cause continues to dominate." "But in China, we have reached common ground after much research and many discussions that Stalinism is not the root cause, and the real reason is that, from Nikita Khrushchev to Mikhail Gorbachev, the leadership of the Soviet Union gradually deviated from and eventually betrayed Marxism, socialism and the fundamental interests of the overwhelming majority of the people," Li noted. To blame Stalin, or the socialist model built by Lenin and Stalin, for the collapse of the Soviet Union is irresponsible, Li said. "Although the model was not perfect and needed reforming, the Soviet Union achieved great goals such as industrialization, victory in World War II and a successful post-war reconstruction under this model," Li said. The starting point of the Soviet Union's collapse was the reform initiated by Khrushchev, because it failed to address the problems. Instead, it gradually denied the basic political and economic system of the Soviet Union's socialism, and when it came to the Gorbachev era, the leadership of the country fully betrayed Marxism and chose a path with no turning back, experts said. "

Squiggle

Wonderful episode! I love how Huck keeps bringing up specific events to make his points. Breht's command and eloquence of theory and analysis was really profound and insightful, too. Adnan provides such a calm and thorough view into the historical details, the contrast is wonderful. Manny Ness was great, too. Looking forward to hearing more from him. One question Breht posed that went unaddressed is where will the conflict between the US and China get hot, if at all? I'd ask, maybe the Pacific rim? Maybe South America? Africa (probably already underway)? I'm so worried for Cuba. Any thoughts?

online Leftist Archive Project (LARP)

Dude, truly excellent episode. Nuanced analysis, but with no false pretense of neutrality. But this is par for the course for you three! My two cents. China's buliding a global economic alternative to American and European hegemony. No matter where you stand on the debate as to whether or not China is socialist, this is a huge force for good, at least in the medium term. I think that that's next to indisputable if you're even a little on The Left. Once China has built this alternative economic network, I think we'll see whether they stick the landing and transition to global socialism, or ossify into Necrotic Capitalism in the same way the United States did. A couple months ago wrote this substack piece on NPR's insane fearmongering viz China and taking a cursory look at possible connections to the weapons industry, if anyone's interested you can check it out here: https://algavone.substack.com/p/npr-amplifies-ludicrous-military

online Leftist Archive Project (LARP)

Africa definitely. US special forces are more and more active there, and as we continue to use more and more electronics in our consumer economy (especially with planned obsolescence by companies like Apple and the lack of right to repair, but also the increasing computerization of cars and basic appliances) those mineral zones in Africa and South America too will increasingly become zones of conflict.

Rev Left Radio

I DM'd Carl to see if come on the show, but havent heard back unfortunately! Also, I just dl'd the Has China Won episodes, looking forward to it!! :)

Rev Left Radio

Very nice, and I agree with it. I need to read more internal documents and Xi Jinping's recent books tbh.

Rev Left Radio

Thanks for the really kind words about our contrasting and complimentary angles, thats really cool to read and I shared it with the guys. As for your question, Its anyones guess, but id wager that if it gets hot itll be in the South China Sea, and/or around Taiwan (and possibly Hong Kong). The FIRST step for building and consolidating counter-hegemony is to assert regional dominance, and thats happening right now in the south china sea, within which Taiwan sits. So if it gets hot, or hotter, itll likely take place in that area as China increasingly demands that the US GTFO their region. We have already seen Taiwan and Hong Kong being ground zero for ramping up anti-china rhetoric, so China will likely continue to make aggressive moves there, but be more cautious in other areas of the world - for now at least. The ball will continue to be put into the US' court wrt these tensions, and the US will have to decide how far its willing to go to stop Chinese regional dominance. If they back down, and China locks in regional command, then the locus of conflict might shift to some of the other areas that you and Matt mention above!

Squiggle

China doesn't have Manifest Destiny as their current mythos. They have the 100 years of shame and the revolution. I'd say that's a far better footing for global socialism and eventually communism in our lifetimes, ב"ה

oranjest1

when Manny brought up the concept that Xi isn't doing those books on how socialism is the end goal because he believes it but rather that there are a hundred million communist party members, with many holding him to account, that just cracked wide open the common western propaganda that China is brainwashed and lead from the top toward "evil gommunism 100 bajillion dead"

Rev Left Radio

Exactly. I often argue that China itself is, in many ways, more meritocratic and even more democratic than the US is. China has its problems, like all societies, and they are FAR from ideal, but their primary goal is the uplifting of their billion + people, while the US' goal is to plunder everyone and everything, and shove the winnings into the fewest pockets possible. A truly spiritually dead, visionless, empty nihilist society...

PowStruggg

Love this episode. Overall huge fan of the show. I think this topic is super important considering the US has been saber-rattling against China and looking for a new target to justify its unjust "defense" budget. Good points around China being a counter-hegemony to the US and providing a development alternative to the 3rd world particularly the continent of Africa. However, I think the episode failed to criticize China's growing imperialist behavior. One example is the Philippines. To exert more control over the seas of SE Asia the Chinese navy has been using intimidation tactics to push fisherfolk out of areas they've been fishing in for generations. Additionally, Jingping's willingness to court and work with the Duterte regime, a fascistic regime that's killed 30,000+ in a drug war that targets the poor, and continues its all-out war policy with the countries internal MLM movement. This behavior is def more oriented toward building their global power than promoting proletarian rev solidarity.

Rev Left Radio

Thank you for the thoughtful and comradely reply! I agree that China is seeking to more or less dominate its region, particularly the south china sea, and that puts it at loggerheads with other countries in the region. Thats one contradiction to continue to monitor for sure, and when and where it hurts regular working people from different countries, it should be pointed out and criticized. The Duterte regime point is also an important point, and there are criticisms to be made there for sure. From China's perspective, the Phillipines is a regionally important country and I can see them trying to get along with whatever government is in power, if for nothing else than to keep that country from fully falling into the hands of the US. Having US bases all over the region is a direct threat to China, and if they scorned and attacked the Philippines it would ultimately be to their geopolitical disadvantage and to the US (and its allies) clear advantage. Its a very difficult tightrope to walk, which doesnt excuse China's excesses and errors, but does point toward explaining it. My ultimate sympathies are with the MLM comrades in the Philippines, and hopefully their internal struggles can topple the duterte regime and advance a more progressive or revolutionary political structure. I think if they did that successfully, China would seek to work with that government as well for the same reasons I mentioned above. AS for imperialism, I am open to arguments on this front. I hear conflicting stuff out of Africa itself and amongst African comrades on this question. Imperialism has a clear definition as set out by Lenin, and if China meets that definition in any given place or time, then it opens itself up to that anti-imperialist critique. I would love to have some more resources on that question in particular. In any case, I can see them doubling down on their nationalist interests to the exclusion of the interests of other people, other nations, and their self-determination, as you argue. I can also see them being pushed by internal factions and external mass movements and pressures away from that and toward a revitalized revolutionary footing. I think the jury is still ultimately out on that question in particular, but as I said, I could be wrong! Thanks again for the constructive criticism and overall feedback. I really do appreciate and value your perspective, my friend.