Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

In this episode, Alyson and Breht introduce, teach, and discuss the philosphy of two giants in western philosophy: Arthur Schopenhaur and Friedrich Nietzsche.

They discuss their respective philosophies, how they relate, how they differ, the subsequent thinkers and movements they inspired or influened, their relation to politics right, left and center, their connection to eastern philosophies and religions, and much more!

Support Red Menace: https://www.patreon.com/TheRedMenace

Files

German Philosophy: Schopenhauer and Nietzsche

In this episode, Alyson and Breht introduce, teach, and discuss the philosphy of two giants in western philosophy: Arthur Schopenhaur and Friedrich Nietzsche.  They discuss their respective philosophies, how they relate, how they differ, the subsequent thinkers and movements they inspired or influened, their relation to politics right, left and center, their connection to eastern philosophies and religions, and much more!  Support Red Menace: https://www.patreon.com/TheRedMenace

Comments

Jamie Sims

Very interesting and timely for me as I'm doing a bit of a Nietzsche deep dive having not really explored his work before apart from a week on an intro to philosophy module several years back when I was at uni. Also timely given that a book trying to read Marx with Nietzsche recently came out (How to Philosophise With a Hammer and Sickle). Intrigued to understand Nietzsche as he seems to be used by people across the political spectrum - communists, post-structuralists and other "French" theorists, Ayn Randian libertarian capitalists, and ofc fascists.

Rev Left Radio

You are 100% correct about his use across the spectrum, in fact we talk about exactly what you said, as well as its relationships to existentialism and psychoanalysis! I hope you find this episode helpful in deepening your knowledge! :)

DD

This was an outstanding episode and I'm looking forward to the next one! Do you know if/when we'll get a new Q+A on red menace/rev left?

Joely

Your intro to Schopenhauer was incredibly well done, Breht. Could hear the care you put into it writing the script & reading it. Really enjoyed this episode!

Rev Left Radio

Thank you! Glad you dig it. And yes, very soon! Ill make a AMA post soon.

Rev Left Radio

Thank you!! Here is the transcript. LMK if you want me to email it to ya: Arthur Schopenhauer was born in February of 1788 to wealthy mercantile parents of German-Dutch descent in Danzig – today called Gdansk – on the northern Baltic coast of Poland. Neither of his parents were particularly religious, were supporters of the French Revolution, and would be what we call upper middle class liberals today. I don’t want to spend too much time on his biography, that information is plentiful online for those interested, but I do want to point to two important events in his childhood. At 15 years old, he went along with his parents on a trip around Europe during the beginning of the Napoleonic wars. As he traveled with his parents, he saw firsthand the wreckage, destruction, and impoverishment caused by the European conflict, and this had a deep impact on him at a crucial age. In addition to that, only a few years afterwards, Schopenhauer’s father committed suicide by throwing himself off of the roof of the house into an adjacent canal, where they found his body. Arthur’s dad struggled with anxiety and depression throughout his life, which intensified as he got older, and Arthur believed he had inherited his gloomy melancholic orientation from his father. After his father’s death, him and his mother were increasingly at loggerheads with one another which ultimately culminated in them parting ways as Arthur entered adulthood, and aside from some letters, never saw each other again. There is much more to say about Arthur’s life, including his relationship with Goethe, but it escapes the parameters of this episode. IN any case, he wrote his masterpiece, The World as Will and Representation, in his late twenties, and that will be the focus of the rest of this introduction. Arthur Schopenhauer was living, thinking, and writing – as all intellectuals of his time and place were - in the shadow of a famous philosopher whom he had nothing but disdain for: Hegel. Hegel dominated German philosophy at the time, and Schopenhauer saw him as more or less a charlatan who hid a lack of substance behind a nearly impenetrable wall of unreadable obscurantism. Instead, Schopenhauer looked back to another giant of European philosophy at the time: Immanuel Kant. Schopenhauer used Kant as his starting point, and brought on board Kant’s Transcendental Idealism as well as much of Kant’s epistemology, including his essential distinction between phenomena and noumena, or the world as we perceive it vs. things in themselves. Kant believed that we could never know things in themselves, only our representation of things – or how they appear to us. When we look out at the cosmos, when we use our scientific tools, when we try to comprehend the universe, we can only look at, study, and comprehend the world of phenomena or “representation”, never the world of things in themselves, as they are external to human perception and literally impossible for us to know. Schopenhauer agreed with the basic distinction, but argued against Kant that we can know the world of things in themselves, not by trying to look outwardly at the external world, the world of phenemona, but by looking – or feeling our way – inwardly. For example, if I try to understand my hand as a part of the phenomenal world, I hold it up before my eyes, I objectify it as an external object, and I can describe it using language: what it looks like, how its shaped, what color it is, how it evolved, etc. But can I ever know what my hand is in and of itself, as a thing in itself? Kant said no, but Schopenhauer said that we could, and we could do it by feeling or experiencing the hand *from the inside*. By opening up this internal avenue or investigation, of looking and feeling inwardly in order to have access to things in themselves, Schopenhauer made a relatively new and exciting move in the history of modern western philosophy. By looking inwardly, Schopenhauer argued that what was found was not, as Kant suggested, a plurality of separate things in themselves, but a unified oneness that permeated the whole of nature, and he called this mysterious life-force The Will or The Will to Live. In his philosophical masterpiece The World as Will and Representation, which he wrote in his 20’s and spent the rest of his life shoring up or elaborating on, he laid out the epistemic, metaphysical, aesthetic, and ethical dimensions of this singular Will to Live that permeated and animated the whole cosmos. Since the Will is the centerpiece of Schopenhauer’s philosophy, it deserves some further explanation. When you think of the word “will”, you probably think of it in terms of an individual’s personal will power, or free will. A sort of inner agency that a person can exercise in the world to get what they want. For Schopenhauer, however, the will is not something specific to a singular person – though it does manifest through all individuals – rather, it’s a universal force that animates and drives on the whole cosmos; its in plants as they burst forth from soft, dark soil, its in animals as they ruthlessly compete within an ecosystem for food, water, shelter, and reproductive opportunities, its in stars as they explode, glow, and burn bright for billions of years, and its in human beings, just another animal after all, as we go about our lives, growing, changing, pursuing our goals, and reproducing ourselves via sex. It is infinite, it is blind, it is meaningless, and it is always striving forward with no end goal or point in mind. It is not historical like Hegel’s absolute Spirit, nor does it teleologically lead anywhere in particular. In its violent indifference to human life, it is terrifying, dark, and in Schopenhauer’s estimation downright evil – not because it seeks to cause suffering, but because its totally indifferent and blind to it *as it causes suffering*. As individual humans, we feel this universal Will to Live working within us internally as the never ending succession of desires and cravings that plague us - once one is met, another arises relentlessly in its place. For example, you can spend years striving for wealth and status in society only to find that, once achieved, there is no respite, no real ability to sit back and simply enjoy what you strove so hard for. Instead new, never ending desires continue to rise and fall away; more wealth, more status, more security… the game never ends. Internally, we feel this Will as a constant restless striving, a sense that we never quite arrive, that we are never quite content or satisfied. And when we do have a moment of satisfaction - sexual, hedonistic, vocational or whatever – that satisfaction soon fades and gives rise to boredom, followed by yet more demanding desires. Its this oscillation between desire, a sort of suffering, and boredom, another type of suffering, that makes up the bulk of human existence, according to Schopenhauer. Moreover, since the Will is a unified, singular force that unites all of nature into its Oneness, it has the added brutality of the recognition that the suffering of others is ultimately your own. You not only suffer as an individual, but, when properly understood, the suffering of all sentient beings is also yours to bear, because there is no separation from or within the Will. The best we can hope for are fleeting moments of being distracted from all this, but ultimately there is no escape. One on hand, this Will is sort of beautiful - a mysterious, animating force that gives rise to the majesty of the eternally unfolding cosmos; but on the other hand its blindness, radical indifference to human life, its relentless production of suffering and misery with no end point is terrifying. Kant introduced the idea of the Sublime into modern philosophy, the dual feeling of awe and terror that strikes someone as they gaze into the enormity of nature and its machinations. For example, looking up at the starry sky on a totally clear night can be both awe-inspiring and gorgeous, while also imbuing you with a sense of terror at its sheer size and your utter insignificance in the face of all that cosmic enormity and indifference. I think Schopenhauer’s will is Sublime in this sense, though Schopenhauer definitely emphasizes its terrifyingly indifferent aspects more than its, at least plausible, beauty. Standing back a little bit, we can now see what Schopenhauer has done: using inward investigation, a unique combination of influences from Plato to Eastern mysticism, Schopenhauer overcame the Kantian Prohibition on being able to ever know things in themselves by claiming to come into contact with the ultimate Thing in Itself, at least according to Schopenhauer: The Will To Live. This thing in itself suffuses the entire cosmos, is totally blind and indifferent to suffering and pain, and has no point, no meaning, no end goal. Most humans, Schopenhauer thought, were totally helpless in the face of this Will, being thrashed around the stage of their measly, meaningless little life like its demented finger puppet without ever knowing how or why. 99% of people, subject to this will they don’t know or understand, simply widdle away their life mindlessly jumping from desire to desire, never really understanding whats happening, and never arriving anywhere but their own grave. This insanely bleak worldview would set Schopenhauer apart from all other philosophers, and mark him as the godfather of Philosophical Pessimism. Schopenhauer says: “It would be better if there were nothing. Since there is more pain than pleasure on earth, every satisfaction is only transitory, creating new desires and new distresses, and the agony of the devoured animal is always far greater than the pleasure of the devourer”. In another instance he asserts: “to obtain something we have desired is to find out that it is worthless; we are always living in expectation of better things, while, at the same time, we often repent and long for things that belong to the past. We accept the present as something that is only temporary, and regard it only as a means to accomplish our aim. So that most people will find if they look back when their life is at an end, that they have lived their lifelong ad interim, and they will be surprised to find that something they allowed to pass by unnoticed and unenjoyed was just their life — that is to say, it was the very thing in the expectation of which they lived. And so it may be said of man in general that, befooled by hope, he dances into the arms of death.” For Schopenhauer, happiness as something to strive for and be achieved is a bitter illusion. What we call happiness is nothing but the temporary absence of that much more permanent background suffering and dissatisfaction. Nothing is added, just momentarily subtracted or subdued, only to reemerge again and again and dissolve whatever momentary sliver of happiness one might have briefly had. Now before we get into Schopenhauer’s advice for how to deal with this horrific state of affairs, I want to talk about something that, some of you at least, may be thinking: damn, doesn’t this Will to Live resemble, in some interesting ways, Darwinian Evolution via Natural Selection? You would be quite correct. Schopenhauer’s masterpiece was written in 1818, and Darwin’s On the Origin of Species didn’t drop until the 1859 – and while Schopenhauer spent the vast majority of his life with little to no acclaim or recognition of his work (one publisher told him they had to turn the copies of his first addition of the World as Will and Representation into pulp cuz nobody was buying it), he did eventually get noticed, read, and became genuinely famous in the last decade of his life, dying in 1860, only a year after Darwin’s groundbreaking work burst onto the scene. Schopenhauer’s followers, as one might expect, immediately seized on the work as profound evidence for Schopenhauer’s Will. After all, what is Evolution via Natural Selection if not a blind, indifferent, striving force of nature that permeates all life, drives it on indefinitely without meaning or purpose, in a fundamentally uncaring, atheistic cosmos? Interestingly, Marx and Engles also saw Darwin’s Origin as profound scientific evidence for their idea of dialectical materialism, for what is evolution via natural selection if not brutally materialist in its red tooth and claw foundations, and intrinsically dialectical in its all encompassing interrelatedness, in the contradictions between organisms and their environments that drive biological change, and in its abject historicity. In any case, there is a whole world of arguments and interpretations here that will take us too far afield, but suffice it to say the followers of Schopenhauer saw The Will to Live immediately in the pages of Darwin’s world-historical work, and I think it helps us grasp the Will to think of it in terms of the force behind evolution by natural selection. Its also worth noting that Schopenhauer, like Marx and Engles, was a committed atheist, so while the rest of the Christian world wrestled with Darwin on that theological level, it seemed totally in line with their already-existing atheism. In fact, its been said that, in terms of modern philosophy, Schopenhauer’s philosophy was one of the only major philosophies to be deepened by Darwin’s discovery, instead of challenged or bypassed as irrelevant. Okay, so now we have grasped the core concept that Schopenhauer introduced to philosophy – and what Nietzsche would later seize on and turn on its head, like Marx seized Hegel’s dialectical approach to history while turning it on its head. But before we move on to Nietzsche, lets explore Schopenhauer’s solution, if such a word can be used, which is available only to the very rare and very intelligent person who can actually grasp and understand the reality of the will. As we said earlier, Schopenhauer, ever the misanthrope, believed most people are and would remain clueless to this reality and widdle away their meaningless lives dominated in a constant parade of desire, boredom, dissatisfaction, and suffering. There best bet was to simply focus on minimizing suffering as much as they can and lower their expectations of what they can ultimately get out of life. But a rare few could rise to the level of the Schopenhowian Sage: one who utilizes his or her high-powered intellect to understand how the Will to Live operates and, with no other choice available to them, decides to simply resign from the whole game. The Sage wages an inner war against the Will to Life, denying all worldly desires for sex and status and wealth, and simply refusing to play along. This Sage turns to asceticism, aesthetics, and self-denial. In its ascetic and self-denying aspects, Schopenhauer’s Sage comes to resemble an austere Buddhist monk. But in its aesthetic dimension, the Sage is unique to Schopenhauer. Here Scophenhauer argues that, in addition to the desire-denying asceticism mentioned above, the Sage also makes great use of art, music and literary fiction as a vehicle through which to turn away from the Self and its Desires altogether, if only temporarily. When one is standing in a museum looking at a gorgeous painting, or at a classical music concert immersed totally in the soundscape, or entranced in a work of literary fiction, one can forget oneself, and that feeling of momentary self-transcendence gives art much of its meaning and power. “For Schopenhauer, human "willing"—desiring, craving, etc.—is at the root of suffering. A temporary way to escape this pain is through aesthetic contemplation. In aesthetic contemplation, one no longer perceives an object of perception as something from which one is separated; rather "it is as if the object alone existed without anyone perceiving it, and one can thus no longer separate the perceiver from the perception, but the two have become one, the entirety of consciousness entirely filled and occupied by a single perceptual image". Subject and object are no longer distinguishable, and the Idea comes to the fore. From this aesthetic immersion, one is no longer an individual who suffers as a result of servitude to one's individual will but, rather, becomes a "pure, will-less, painless, timeless, subject of cognition". The pure, will-less subject of cognition is cognizant only of Ideas, not individual things: this is a kind of cognition that is unconcerned with relations between objects according to the Principle of Sufficient Reason (time, space, cause and effect) and instead involves complete absorption in the object.” Music in particular was essential to Schopenhaur, as he believed Music was the only art that didn’t copy ideas, but actually embodied the Will to Life itself - directly. The famous composer Richard Wagner would be mightily influenced by Schopenhauer on this point in particular, and would later go on to be friends, and then bitter enemies, with Fredrich Nietzsche – another deep admirer of Schopenhauer. In any case, this focus on the arts was another thing that set Schopenhauer apart and many argue that he was the first modern philosopher to introduce the philosophical analysis of art as a unique branch of Philosophy. Schopenhauer was and remains a truly remarkable and unique thinker in the history of western philosophy, his dark, pessimistic, and atheistic philosophy is still appealing to modern people, and his work went on to influence many fundamental thinkers of the next century, especially Niezsche, Freud, Jung, and Wittgenstein, among others. His conception of the Will to Life would not only be turned into the unconscious by Freud, but would also prefigure concepts in Science like Dark Energy, that mysterious and hypothetical property in cosmology that causes the expansion of the universe to accelerate. He also was the first major philosopher in human history to integrate the highest of western philosophy with the insights of Eastern philosophy in a systematically comprehensive way. In particular he was deeply influenced by the Upanishads, the ancient scriptures of Hindu philosophy which explore meditation, consciousness, the self, and ontology, and later came to an awareness of Buddhism. He loved the story of the Buddha, he named his pet poodle Atma, which is a Hindu term meaning roughly the World Soul, and his conception of the Sage, as well as his emphasis on suffering, the illusory nature of the self, the role of desire in creating suffering, and more were obviously imported from his engagement with eastern philosophy. Its worth noting that translations of Hindu and Buddhist texts were only just beginning to trickle in to Europe, and translations were often pretty rough at that time, so while its safe to say he was hugely impacted by eastern philosophy, its also fair to point out that his understanding was probably limited to some extent by this reality, and I think it shows up most obviously in the absence of much of the positive and redemptive spiritual aspects of these traditions. We will dive deeper into the connections to Buddhism and Hinduism as well as the impacts on later thinkers in the discussion part of this episode, but for now suffice it to say that Schopenhauer was a truly brilliant and genuinely unique thinker, and in the pantheon of philosophers east and west, he is up there among my absolute favorites. This is not to say that he was above criticism of course, much less that he was correct in identifying the Will as the foundation of the cosmos. He makes grandiose and unprovable claims about the nature and value of existence, he does not explain the origin of the will, and he does not wrestle with the complexity created by his self-denying Sage: for how can the will ever turn against the will if the will is doing the turning? Where ever one comes down on the ultimate value of Schopenhauer’s philosophy, he was a unique and talented thinker that helped usher in the modern world and the modern mind, and The World as Will and Representation is still seen as one of the most interesting works of western philosophy of the last several hundred years. In fact, one copy of Schopenhauer’s masterpiece would eventually find itself in a used bookstore sitting on a dusty shelf unperturbed for who knows how long, until one day, a young man by the name of Friedrich Niezschte would stumble into that bookstore, and as he casually roamed the aisles, aimlessly looking through the books on offer, he would eventually come to rest his eyes, and then his hands, on this book: The World as Will and Representation. Reflecting on this moment later in life, Nietzche said: “I took the unfamiliar book in my hands and began leafing through the pages. I don’t know what demon it was that whispered in my ear “take this book home!”. So, breaking my principle of never buying a book too quickly, I did just that. Back home, I threw myself into the corner of the sofa with my new treasure, and began to let that dynamic, gloomy genius work on my mind. I found myself looking into a mirror which reflected the world, life, and my own nature with terrifying grandeur. Here I saw sickness and health, exile and refuge, hell and heaven.” Alyson…

Joely

Wow. This is incredible. Thanks so much, Breht!

oranjest1

gday, was curious which episodes feature guests who have credibly experienced enlightenment? have heard this a few times over your episodes, and i am uncertain if i have already heard from these people

liminal_CJ

Curious if you've ever heard of another pessimist philosopher named Philip Mainlander? He’s arguably even more radically pessimistic than Schopenhauer, yet he ironically has some very virtuous beliefs. He took Schopenhauer’s idea of a Will, but with a Hegelian twist. He pluralized the Will into individual wills that came to be from the origin of God, which was an all metaphysical unity, that shredded itself apart in its quest to annihilate itself. Hence, the universe is the rotting corpse of God and the our deaths are the goal of all existence. Yet, he was said to be a very kind soul in writing and in person and was even a self-identified communist with sympathy for suffering workers. Though he held positive views of the state and didn’t think revolution was necessary. It makes him unique among many other pessimist philosophers, who tended to rather reactionary. He unfortunately took his philosophy to the its final conclusion in his own suicide, yet I find him an endlessly fascinating obscure thinker in the history of philosophy and the contradictions in his pessimistic outlook of existence, yet his very apparent compassion for humanity. Cuck Philosophy has a great video on him if you want to know more: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nnJmA9_dkP0&t=1s