Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

In this episode, Breht (while acknowledging this a fluid situation that can change on a dime) gives his thoughts on the recent invasion of Ukraine, the role that US-led NATO has played in bringing us to this point, what China is (probably) thinking, what Putin's goals might be, the role Nazis play in all of this, the response from the Ukrainian and Russian masses, and how we should think and talk about Russia during this crisis.

Our deep history of Ukraine and Russia on Guerrilla History here: https://guerrillahistory.libsyn.com/history-of-russiaukraine-relations-w-alexey-sakhnin-dispatch

RealLifeLore video on Russia, Ukraine, and NATO here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=If61baWF4GE&ab_channel=RealLifeLore


Files

Comments

Major bit me

I wonder how western sanctions will affect China and Russia’s relationship. If Russia is truly locked out of western finance and capital, then who is left for Russia to do business with? Only China - so I’m purely speculating but this might be one reason the invasion of Ukraine will be beneficial for China. They will get Russian goods for premium prices, and Russia could be far more dependent on China in the future.

Rev Left Radio

I think in that specific way, you may very well be correct. I know the two economies are already pretty deeply tied in various ways, as one would expect. But a deepening of that relationship would have some benefits. I would only suggest that when we zoom out, and look at the broader global geopolitical context, a post-invasion world will likely be MORE hostile to both Russia and its allies; and a more energized NATO will be bad for everybody (except the US and its allies ofc). Might well have bad implications for US aggression toward all of its enemies, including china. But again, there are so many trajectories that things could take from here, its very hard to call any shots at all haha. Difficult to see through the fog of ones own historical moment!

Matthew

Thank you so much for this Breht! It's essential that we don't mess up about Taiwan, so to underscore the point: Not only did the Kuomintang flee to Taiwan in 1949 after their defeat at the hands of the PLA, they also worked with the US from early in their occupation. From what I've read, the relationship was predicated on the KMT allowing the US to use the island as a staging ground for its assault on the Korean peninsula. The KMT ruled by martial law from 1949-1987 first under Chiang Kai Shek and eventually under his son Ching-kuo (who had been the director of the KMT's secret police) who took over as leader in 1978. Even before all that, though, the KMT staged a massacre in Taipei in 1947 that reportedly killed somewhere between 18000 and 28000 people. And even today, the KMT still operates in the Taiwanese government - as far as I know, they're currently the opposition party. Given the historical relationship between the Communist Party of China and the Kuomintang, not to mention the role of the US in all of it, it's easy to see why this is such a complex matter. It's also easy to see why Western media wishes us to believe that this is as simple as an independent bourgeois or people's republic under threat from a foreign juggernaut. It'd be great if you could have a guest on to explore this in more depth, especially the topic of KMT-US relations in the twentieth century! Like everyone else, I'm catching up on all this stuff - it's important that we learn it thoroughly!

colby johnson

breht, dawg, i love you and respect you, and I agree with you 100% about the character of the Ukranian people- the majority are certainly not fascists and deserve our support. That being said, I really think you’ve misread the situation about Ukraine’s government. The Nazis are not fringe, they are the ones who hold power. After the Maidan coup, Azov Battalion was folded into the Ukranian National Guard. I cannot see how a government that legitimizes fascist paramilitaries is not a fascist government. this fascist government is not representative of the average Ukranian. The Ukranian government represents the American Imperialists which installed it.

Rev Left Radio

Spot on and great background info. Id love to have such an episode, please lmk if you can find a guest thats well suited to such a topic!

oranjest1

the very first thing I thought about when I heard China is supporting Russia's stance is that this is exactly what US/NATO interests have been begging for. Ukraine is a perfect staging ground for starting to ramp up global tensions like this in order to secure popular support for the next forever wars

oranjest1

personally feeling a bit like I'm losing my mind with all the "We support the Ukraine!" sentiments coming from all sorts of popular figures, maybe because they absolutely cannot imagine or reveal that states and people generally are indeed seperate entities with quite seperate interests, revealed by a lot of the fuckery going on with the defense against Russia. I do not support the Ukraine in the general sense that is being popularly declared. I have heard pathways are being made for Ukrainian immigrants in some European countries, which is the best possible answer, but this also provokes extreme cynicism in me due to popular attitudes toward any and all middle eastern refugees it's a huge exercise in nuance and the only way to keep sane for me is entirely ignoring daytime TV/mainstream media, and knowing the only real enemy is at home

Rev Left Radio

I love and respect you too, my friend. I am open to the criticism that I might have under-stated their influence in the government itself, and I agree entirely with you that the government as a whole has helped legitimize them and worked with or parallel to them in various ways. I still think the state itself has a variety of ideologies and political parties, many of which contradict or oppose the outright neo-nazi position. Its just not as simple as being able to say its a nazi state like Germany was under Hiter imho, and there is a real risk in over-applying important terms. I do not dispute your general point though, and I even agree its a right wing state, as the US and Russia are. Is the state itself dominated and operated primarily by outright fascists? I dont currently see that. But I am open to any resources or links you want me to check out to learn from.

Ian Stockdale

Cheers, Breht - thoughtful and well reasoned, as always. Thanks for the video recommendation - worth watching for the Russia POV maps alone. The most puzzling question it raised for me was why Russia didn't intervene more directly on Armenia's side in the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict, since they are both members of CSTO. Am I missing something obvious?

Eoghan

I think the question of whether fascists are in positions of power in Ukraine is almost irrelevant in the context of this crisis (though obviously is worrying in its own right) because it's clear that that is not the reason that Russia is invading, as is outlined by Breht in this episode and the RealLifeLore video that Breht recommended. The idea that Putin genuinely cares if there are fascists in the Ukrainian government is laughable, he has had no problem with cosying up with right wing governments up until now, and his mention of "denazification" is honestly a pretty successful propaganda move because it has caused a lot of e-ink spilled on the subject since the invasion began. It strikes me as uncomfortably similar to the "humanitarian intervention" arguments made by Western governments to invade countries that we all rightly know are bullshit 99% of the time. imo the position leftists should be taking today is that of the anti-WWI socialists in 1914: "Neither King nor Kaiser"/Neither NATO nor CSTO

Jacob Bucci

I'm starting to think a good rule of thumb is when a celebrity is elected to power it's probably because a deep state has co-opted the political system. Zelensky won 3:1 on a peace mandate, yet has since openly expressed desire for nuclear weapons if not admitted into NATO. He was happy to hype up the Russia threat when he thought it would get him resources from the west, but then days before the invasion he was begging the west to tone down invasion hysteria because it was crashing their economy. It's like if America elected Jim Halpert instead of Obama as a response to the hell of the Bush years.

Matthew

I've been looking around and found this collaborative Qiao Collective/PSL seminar from 2020 called: "From Opium Wars to Trade Wars: China's Long Path toward Socialism" (https://youtu.be/-6CNxu91vvU) in which they cover Taiwan among other key issues. Qiao Collective openly welcomes inquiries and contributions, so maybe you could reach out to them for an episode: qiaocollective [at] gmail [dot] com. Perhaps one or both of the comrades who conducted this seminar could come on the show, who knows!

BlackDeath Mushroom

As an American I have to ask…. What is this map thing, you speak of? Comrade across the river.

Rev Left Radio

I am not caught up on that particular case, so I cannot speak to it unfortunately. But I will look into that for sure.

terry c

Breht, what is the song at the end? Thank you. Great work as always.

Ian Stockdale

It's strange. On its face, it would seem to be a deliberate show of weakness and counter to the Russian project of solidifying its defenses against NATO.

Rev Left Radio

Masters of War by Bob Dylan! and Thank you for listening and for the kind words!

Raphael

Hey Breht,I wonder if the Map in your room is a Peters projection map in order to see the real proportions of how small the so called western world is. And thanks for your view in the current situation.

The Mass Line

Interestingly and perhaps in support of your speculation on Putin's strategy in splitting Ukraine, the USSR used this tactic in the First Soviet-Finnish War. Also, in a precursor to invasion, neighbouring regions declared their independence, aligning themselves with the USSR. (Also, I am now cancer free 👍🏻🙏🏻). Hope you and yours are well bro

Rev Left Radio

Wow, I am so happy to hear about you being cancer free, that is so wonderful, my friend!