Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Please use the comment section below to ask any question that you want to for Breht - and probably Alyson from Red Menace - to answer on an upcoming patreon exclusive episode!

Comments

J Hagler

Despite the large anti-war protests the US saw at the beginning of the Iraq War the war happened anyway. What did the anti-war movement do right and wrong? What needs to happen to build an effective anti-imperialist movement here in the states?

Josh Ruston

This may be a tough one but I’ve been mulling over Hegels lord and bondsman dialectic and a correlation to Fanons “concerning violence”… I feel like there could be some serious implications that link social sciences, psychoanalysis, and radical left theory together in a potentially interesting and difficult way… I’m kind of just tossing a thought to some more practiced minds to center myself on a recent brain haunt… I know it’s not really a question but I’d love to hear thoughts

fleshmech

Hi Breht, Im working on setting up my own podcast that follows a similar trajectory to the pods early tendency focus, including Mob (First Nations) & environmental/climate direct action as that’s a big thing here in so called ‘Australia’. I’d love to know any key technical advice that could help, such as how you get quality audio interviews over phone or internet, and any other tech/software stuff that a newbie might not consider. I’d also like to understand how you pick and reach out to guests before you were well known, as well as understanding what groups were not worth interviewing due to their size, sectarianism, niche micro tendency split, overt antagonism or potential train wreck interviews due to performative ranting etc. Perhaps I’m seeking too much control on those aspects and I should be seeking to let those things happen regardless so viewers can experience it for themselves? Are there interviews like this in RLR or have some not made it to air due to the issues I’ve mentioned? Love and solidarity, D

Sparrow

Corollary: what are historically effective anti war direct actions?

Meltedpiano

Could you clarify psychoanalysis for me? I'm a mental health therapist and to me psychoanalysis is a very particular approach to psychology but I know that some people use the term in a more general way to describe psychological thought. I know this is a splitting hairs question but I've heard many people on different leftist podcasts and platforms use the term and want to know if I'm missing something. I ask with genuine curiosity.

Sparrow

How can you reform an org that is supposed to be an umbrella org but which has allowed in a maybe 5% of members who absolutely refuse to have solidarity with people expressing the most milquetoast of core ML/M positions? Even in the face of no attempt at convincing but rather just explaining “this is how we think and approach problems, or history, or political questions.” This is with regard to a particular chapter of the SRA. Alternately, same question but flipped, how do you attract a diverse membership who are at many levels of political development and varying tendencies, but ensure a structure where you are forced to struggle together and constantly reaffirm solidarity *before* (or in between) terrible events? It’s heartbreaking to find an org that has that magic spark and watch it siphoned off by infighting.

Connor P Shadle

Do you think the continued globalization of major corporations will eventually diminish the power of major capitalist states? (For example, the privatization of currencies and militaries) Or will private enterprise always need state forces to reinforce its power? On a related note, what impact do you think continued globalization will have on international proletariat solidarity? Will it help combat patriotism? Or will chauvinism among labor aristocracy grow and general alienation heighten?

SaintSappho

What is the most influential book/thinker in your life and growth as an activist and person that you've moved beyond/outgrew/now don't agree with?

Quém é

What do you think of the CCP's recent crackdowns on China's private sector?

oranjest1

i've seen people claiming you are a SWERF, could you clarify your position on sex workers?

EspressoCinephile

What are your favorite films and/or directors? Sorry if it's simple compared to a lot of the other questions, but as a cinephile I just have to know 😇 (And as a side, I think a Soviet cinema episode would be really rad ... Just a thought ☺️)

oranjest1

@ Meltedpiano psychoanalysis is referred to by leftists generally as a way of rationalising or drawing conclusions about events and situations by applying psychoanalysis (or pseudopsychoanalysis) to the major players in the event, whether the players are people or countries for example saying "Trump is a narcissist" and using that to explain why he's terrible I could be biased because this is also my opinion, but I think the most common position on the left is that psychoanalysis for this purpose is liberal brainrot bullshit

Matt Pierce

Hello to both of you! I've been really interested lately in studying the role of state crimes and covert action and it's relationship to the imposition and maintenance of imperialism/Neoliberalism/anti-communism historically and in contemporary conditions. How do you all think that we as Marxists and communists can integrate serious study of the role of security state apparatuses into our political education and organizing work in a useful way that is actually empowering for us and not simply conspiracy hunting, if at all?

Jason L

Can you compare the different styles of governance that exist in different socialist states? What’s the difference between the Chinese political system vs Cuba’s vs North Korea’s vs Vietnam vs Laos?

online Leftist Archive Project (LARP)

Hey Breht. My girlfriend and I were having this conversation recently and I realized this would be a great question for one of your AMAs. So North European countries with strong welfare states, as Marxists we realize that these are built on the backs of third world peoples via economic imperialism and a history of violent colonialism. But other countries that have strong legacies of imperialism as well -- the United States in particular, but also Canada, Australia, increasingly the United Kingdom, primarily English-speaking countries as it turns out -- these imperialist core countries do NOT have strong welfare states that buy off their domestic working classes to keep them from revolting. How do we account for these differences within imperial core countries and why (or why not) are these differences significant? Thank you!

Austin Miller

Marxist analysis of urban and rural in the context of american politics? Is it more than democrat vs republican? Rural areas like (st Mary's Ohio) had a socialist mayor a hundred years ago and the movement seems impossible today. Can this ground be regained? Is organizing the only answer? I know it's a lot of questions but I don't see rural areas or people mentioned in a lot of left/marxist leaning podcasts or media. Love the show so much, keep up.the great work. ♥️♥️♥️

Comrade Dodo

This very topic is talked about in depth on the recent feminist episode 😊

DD

Any suggestions on changing the culture inside an organisation? I'm part of a mutual aid group, where almost all the organising and important decisions are made by a small group of terminally over-worked activists. It feels like the main problem isn't as much the explicit politics in the group, but the assumption that most members seem to make that "someone else will fix it" and that they don't need to make plans or take on responsibility. It feels very much like the beginning of "The Parable of the Sower" in that it feels like there's a need to get people ready for the challenges they have ahead of them, but there's a real risk of being met with either apathy or panic. How can we change the culture in our organisation to inspire our members to think that radical change is possible and that they can be a real part of it?

Ian Stockdale

I take it as given that Russian attempts to de-Nazify Ukraine, regardless of method or degree of success, will inevitably result in Nazification of NATO countries. There will be no need for 'rat lines' - fascists will be among the legitimate refugees with no attempt to screen them out. Members of these grotesque parodies of international brigades will return from Ukraine as hardened veterans with real world training in combat and hate crimes, as well as with deep networks of personal connections. These fascist foot soldiers will be turned against us in our own countries in the years to come. Do you agree? If not, why not? If so, what is to be done?

Ryan Spencer

A few questions: Regarding Mao, I’ve been very interested in the ideas and philosophy he has put forward in works discussed on Red Menace/Rev Left. I am confused about some of the common tropes I hear against him here in the US (mainly the Great Famine) and his thoughts on them along with his contemporaries. Maybe this is more grounds for a whole episode similar to one you guys did on Stalin, just figured I’d ask. Similarly, what’s the deal with the Tiananmen Square Massacre? Along similar line, could you explain and expound on the Cultural Revolution idea and what that looks like for us as Revolutionary Leftists Finally, could you discuss what Materialism is and is not, common misunderstandings about it etc? I get unclear about it fairly often and just need a refresher that I’m sure would help others

Ryan Spencer

I know you are not really on the Discord, but would you be at all able to hop back on there just to name a few people moderators? The server is having a tough time at the moment without it

Ryan Spencer

I’m by no means qualified to give a really in depth answer, but I can tell you what just about all of us on here would say. Yes it is definitely a lot more than D vs R. In my understanding, both parties are essentially Capitalist, merely appealing to different strategies for Capitalism moving forward as represented by different bases. To irresponsibly oversimplify it, Democrats are generally appealing to the “big bourgeoisie,” who are able to afford social safety nets more that placate worker struggles and class consciousness, where Republicans represent the petty bourgeoisie who cannot* as easily afford the social safety nets *(while maintaining their current profit margins). Democrats advocate for policies called “socialist” by Republicans because it is more effective at quelling a Left Wing uprising than brutally crushing them. For example, Dems may support a bill to require employers to provide moderately decent healthcare while Republicans would oppose it, because workers feel less exploited when they have decent healthcare (even though their wages are still being appropriated basically just as much). The petit bourgeoisie has smaller margins to play with and is threatened more by that kind of proposal. Dems may support Government subsidized healthcare or single payer healthcare or whatever else, mainly because it placates worker rage. Republicans want to lower taxes for the “middle class” (read “petit bourgeoisie”) and they demonize Dems as hurting the middle class. It gets trickier than that because of specific donors and industries backing each party. I typically see Republicans in favor of “old school” Capitalism (ie factory work here with extremely low wages, if you’re poor it’s cuz you didn’t work hard enough, bosses can fire anyone anytime for any reason, no regulations) where Dems are in favor of “new” Capitalism (overthrow governments to install ones that will remove the minimum wage for instance, export our labor there for cheaper production, use the excess money here to create labor aristocrats who feel not exploited and tell them to stop complaining because they all have iPhones, maybe even use some of that excess to create social safety nets so they have something to point to when people complain). I the Dem strategy as a much more insidious and sneaky while the Republicans are very blatant and “retro”. I think in my experience also Republicans tend to favor landlords more because Landlords and the petit bourgeoisie tend to benefit from similar forms of Capital relations. Landlords are even older school than the petit bourgeoisie, they’re like a holdover from feudalism in my view. I would love to hear other opinions if anyone sees any issues with what I’ve said Edit: if I may, most “socialists” in American politics are Social Democrats. In my view and the view of others, SocDems are basically just Capitalists. Regular democrats are down to reform Capitalism til the cows come home just to keep it alive, SocDems are willing to do more than regular Dems to keep it going. They’re both reformist in nature

Ryan Spencer

How should we engage with people on the Social Democrat pipeline and try to help them move away from the Reformist camp?

H

CHINA: 1. What are your thoughts on class struggle re-emerging in China? I’ve heard Alyson and Breht say before that they think the Chinese working class and peasantry will play a defining role this decade in the fate of world socialism. Are you optimistic about class struggle in China? 2. How do you feel about the Belt and Road initiative? What do you make of accusations that it is a form of social imperialism?

Blargh

Hello!! Just wondering if you will ever do an episode on the civil war in El Salvador? I wrote a historiography paper about the war during my undergrad, but I am definitely no expert. I recently got admitted to grad school, and El Salvador is a research of choice for me when I begin. Off topic, have you seen any good movies lately? Just saw the Batman and it was fantastic!

Joe B

I've started to notice a kind of capitalist realism trend among certain mainstream abolitionist efforts, and I'm curious if you have any thoughts about this. For example, the widely circulated #8toAbolition document says that "police and prisons will not disappear tomorrow" (true enough), but then goes on to argue that non-reformist reforms can get us there slowly. Capitalism doesn't get mentioned, and I feel like any honest appraisal of abolition needs to acknowledge that it will not and cannot be wholly achieved under a system of capitalism. The ruling class will simply not allow it, any more than they would allow capitalism itself to be dismantled under their watch. Another example I saw recently was a police abolition zine that highlighted "jobs" as what people need rather than policing. I feel like "jobs" is the capitalist realist (or just capitalist) alternative to saying that what people need is guaranteed food, housing, medical and mental health care, etc. I think every serious abolitionist understands that capitalism is incompatible with abolition, even if they don't always mention it. And I say all of this as someone who considered myself an abolitionist years before I considered myself a Marxist or communist. So this is not meant as a criticism of abolition overall, but merely as a critique of certain mainstream efforts at popular education around abolition, which elide the necessity of completely getting rid of the capitalist system if true abolition will ever be a possibility. I realize there's not a direct question here, but I would love to hear any thoughts you have about this!

Max M

Can yall talk about Trotskyism? People in left orgs love to call each other trots, and I do see some common patterns of behavior but I have struggled to articulate what this tendency really is all about and why they do what they do. I have been thinking about labels recently, usage of 'tankie' has been rising recently and you also hear 'stalinist' and 'dengist' and these seem like obfuscations or distractions to what we are really after which is the science revolutionary communism (thanks JMP). I also read losurdo's stalin book recently and it really does seem like during the USSR you were either a stalinist or a trot and like it just confuses me when comrades call people trots, others stalinists, and still others dengists, like what is left after you exclude those traditions? Just eclecticism and spontaneity? Also I'm wondering about the "multipolar good therefore russia is the least bad actor in ukraine" vs "both NATO and Russia are imperialist and equally bad" debate going on around the ukraine situation. As a baby leninist it feels like revolutionary defeatism to hope for the reduction of US/NATO hegemony, especially if Russia links up with China and the other socialist-ish existing states in the global south. I realize there's not much we can do here to like "do multipolarity" but I'm just wondering where y'all land on the situation.

Flynnit

I find destruction, and/or complete neglect of cultural heritage, like paintings, architecture, ancient writings to be terrible. I understand why it was done in China and also somewhat why the Soviets had other priorities at the time. Nevertheless- it is, in my opinion, our responsibility to preserve these things for future generations even when the world changes and especially because it does. I don't think a ban on religious practices like specific traditions and holidays is a necessity. Contrary to what Engels argues, people practice religion not only when in peril. It's also a way of habit, of spending time with family, of coping with anxieties. What do you think about a cultural revolution happening without neglect/deliberate destruction/banns of cultural heritage, especially works of art and architecture?

Hamsterdam

How many people are involved in each show (Rev Left/Red Menace/Guerilla History) and in what capacities?

Sparrow

Why does the lib dismissal of nuanced argument as whataboutism sit so poorly as an ML/M? The concept feels fundamentally disingenuous.

H

Second this!

Jack Hughes

What are the prospects for an operational communist party here in the US? What will be our biggest obstacles in organizing this party and what actions should we start taking to support a future party endeavor? Also, I know you are have your hands-full as is, but if you ever found the time I think an eco-socialist specific podcast would do wonders in educating Marxists on the climate science, environmental struggles through the history of the left, and cultivating discussions of strategy during climate breakdown. It would also be a powerful point of radicalization for the younger generation like me who came to the Marxist position through the realization of the necessity of Marxism in the climate struggle.

Ethan

copying and pasting my comment on Mr. Robot from the Sopranos episode: Breht, I'm wondering if you've ever seen and would consider doing an episode on Mr Robot. Like The Sopranos, it has a heavy component of psychoanalysis (the main character is dealing with psychological issues due to repressed childhood trauma), but it also deals openly with anti-capitalist politics, being about a group of radical hackers fighting to bring down an evil conglomerate (literally called Evil Corp). It’s a pretty smart and self-aware show that like the Sopranos also deals with the cultural decline of late capitalism and neoliberalism, and different theories of radical change. SPOILERS AHEAD . . . There’s a great scene where, after they succeed in hacking the global banking system, only to cause chaos and the eventual readjustment towards a more repressive crypto economy, a sex worker tells one of the revolutionaries that this did nothing to change the inherent power structures, and that they need to “read some Marx”. I think it starts to go downhill in the later seasons after 2016 (the creator is a liberal and like many libs I think the Trump election melted his brain a little bit) and pivots to make the main villain the “evil Chinese hackers” (who are also part of the Chinese government – implying the CPC is evil and runs the world) instead of the American corporations – but I think the psychological aspect of the main character’s journey at least stays strong til the end.

Ethan

also how great is the new big thief record? I remember you saying you were a fan of them and used one of their songs to close an episode iirc

Matt Pierce

Fwiw, I spend a lot of time on discord so I would be happy to help out if it's needed and Breht sees this comment thread!

Dorrian Weber

Thoughts on China's annexation/liberation of Tibet and how it relates to Maosim and the national question? I would love to hear your thoughts on this as a Maoist with a deep connection to Buddhism, but mostly because you are so good at handling topics like this with nuance.

The Ashevillager

If the revolution within the imperial core is something that regardless of effort put forth, simply won’t come to pass, how do we as individuals come together to help gum up the gears of the imperial machine to further make space for China and the Global South to grow communism strong enough to cast off the grip of capitalism in a sustainable way?

Yohance

Would you move to Cuba?

H

Second this

Rev Left Radio

It is! But I will try to address it again in a RLR patreon ama soon, just to reiterate and clarify!

Rev Left Radio

I would love to! Do you have any possible guests for such an episode?

Rev Left Radio

Hey Max, so for the last part of your question regarding multipolarity, I think Alyson and I's last episode on War in Ukraine covers those questions explicity, including the "is russia imperialist?" question, in depth! I dont think we fit neatly in the binary you set up between russia least bad and NATO - Russia equally bad, but that nuance is fleshed out in that ep! :)

Rev Left Radio

RLR: Breht (host, sets up all episodes, chooses topics, music, etc.) and Dave (audio engineer, does our taxes, hosts all the recording equip at his house, basically does everything else. So two of us. RM: Breht, Dave, Alyson GH: Breht, Henry, Adnan, Dave In every case, Dave is rarely if ever on air, but does all the editing, publishing, budgets, etc. In the case of GH, these tasks are split between Dave and Henry. But overall, we have always wanted to keep this project as small as possible, with as little overhead as possible. The larger a show gets, the more people it requires to make it work, the more unweildy it gets, and the more susceptible it is to the ebbs and flows of financial support. I like to keep things as simple as possible.

Rev Left Radio

I remember when it first came out, I watched the first season, but fell off! Id be interested in diving back into it for sure. I guess it just comes down to finding time for that specfici topic and a good guest for it!

Rev Left Radio

Oh yea, I think ive used them a handful of times as outros actually. I like the new album, but havent heard it from front to back quite yet. But hte tracks I have heard I love. I basically got introduced to Big Theif on a set of mushroom trips I took a few years back, and it welded a love of that music into my soul haha. I cant help it!

Rev Left Radio

This is such a great question, and I really wanna do a full episdoe on it. I still have questions myself. Suffice it to say, many in the Buddhist community, particualry those with connections to tibetan buddhism, are very anti-china, and it comes up all the time in various dharma talks and shit. I gotta put together a full ep on it, just need a proper guest that can navigate this nuance with me, without falling into dogmatism on either side of this very touchy and complex issue.