Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Alyson and Breht discuss the Russia-Ukraine conflict, and wrestle with the following questions: Is Russia imperialist, and is this an inter-imperialist conflict? What is the nature of the Ukrainian State? Is Ukraine really fighting for democracy? Are we entering a multipolar world order? What do these events tell us about NATO and US hegemony? How should we understand revolutionary defeatism in this conflict? What role do nazis play in all of this? What is Putin's endgame?

Support Red Menace and get access to bonus monthly content on Patreon here: https://www.patreon.com/TheRedMenace

Files

War in Europe: Understanding the Russia-Ukraine Conflict

amp;nbsp;Alyson and Breht discuss the Russia-Ukraine conflict, and wrestle with the following questions: Is Russia imperialist, and is this an inter-imperialist conflict? What is the nature of the Ukrainian State? Is Ukraine really fighting for democracy? Are we entering a multipolar world order? What do these events tell us about NATO and US hegemony?

Comments

MLDad

Please help intervene to free them and save their lives. Could you shout out to the Federations twitter where instructions are provided on how to help? More than ever the people of Ukraine need these people to help rebuild the country and heal the very deep wounds inflicted bu the nazi beast.

From The River To The Sea 🇵🇸

Russia’s biggest mistake during this conflict had been not accounting for the propaganda war the West had waged. The West controls the media and social media. What will be interesting is how this conflict plays into the midterms and the next presidential election. Will voters and/or candidates connect this conflict to the ongoing inflation crisis like they should? Both political parties are treating this as a necessary evil. This is why we need a legitimate third party.

Yohance

I liked this episode but I am curious about which, if any, European comrades you engaged with on the topic before recording this. You’re both in America where the ruling class has a long standing opposition to Russia, but here in Europe (especially the UK) the Russian ruling class is completely integrated. For example, Sergei Lavrov’s real family live in London. Leftists in Europe, and particularly the UK where I’m from, have been campaigning for years against the influence of Russian capital on working people, especially with regards to real estate and funding for right wing parties and causes. The equivocating about whether or not Russia is imperialist because it is on a smaller scale than the US is a bit of a cop out and doesn’t really address the aims and operation of Russian capital. You also asserted that the Ukrainian state is particularly beholden to the fascist right in a way that neither Russia nor the US is. I think that, beyond aesthetics, this doesn’t stand up to scrutiny. Again you would benefit from talking to particularly central and Eastern European comrades but I assure you far right movements, including those with armed or violent street movements, are worryingly present and are occasionally defeated by more centre right parties integrating their ideas (see Fidesz neutralising Jobbik in Hungary). The controlled far right “opposition” of the Russian Liberal Democrat Party generally proposes “extreme” policy positions which are later adopted by the Kremlin. I obviously don’t have to mention Dmitry Utkin and the Wagner group because I know those are known in American social media circles too. I greatly respect you both as comrades and educators but I don’t think you’re immune to American exceptionalism in your analysis, I know writing from the seat of the British empire definitely clouds my worldview whether I like it or not. Solidarity!

MLDad

Russia's exports are over 60% raw materials, way under 10% capital exports, the rest is products and weapons. Saying it is "imperialist" in a marxist leninist sense is just throwing words around...

Yohance

That’s completely fair, I more meant to highlight the role and aims of Russian (offshored) capital, and that I’d like to hear more of that kind of analysis. The main enemy is at home and where I am that has long included the post soviet bourgeoisie.

MLDad

Thank you. Communists in Europe are under attack. The Portuguese Communist Party's positions regarding this conflict very much overlap with your own. We are very isolated nationally, and internationally there is intense debate among communist parties on this issue. There is absolutely no substitute for study and principled reflection amd debate. No to white chauvinism, no to imperialism, workers of ALL the world, unite! Solidarity with the workers of Ukraine, Russia and the whole world! Even if Russia has imperialist ambitions, they are absolutely not required, and maybe mot even useful, to EXPLAIN what is happening, nor is Putin's personality and mental state.

L-ō-rion

Upon clicking this posted link here it gives me a choice to stay on YouTube of which then takes you to podcast, or go off YouTube, probably to red menace site, of which is apparently being blocked?

L-ō-rion

The redirect to YouTube took me to a 2 year old episode of red menace episode called: “The civil war in France - Karl Marx”

L-ō-rion

Finally found the episode. My thoughts? The argument on Imperialism seemed narrow and dogmatic to me. Telling dialectical thinkers how “principled marxist” should think in 21st century or anytime for that matter? Ooof, that has some really bad authoritarian, gonna send you to a re-education gulag or line you up on a wall, if you don’t agree with us vibe. Just because a liberal or a conservative says something, does not make them wrong. That is the partisan hackery I thought many of us were trying to escape. No propaganda has ever been effective without it being based in generally understood truths. Imperialism and Russia undeniably existed before Lenin, as Putin at the beginning of this mess felt confident enough to explain to us all. The argument being made here, sounded like bad mental gymnastics attempting to defend Lenin’s definition of Imperialism. I’m sorry, it sounded like the partisan “spin” we should all be so tired of by now on MSM. It seems maybe Lenin’s doctrine is helpful for context. But is it outdated and does it help modern socialists navigate the full blown resurgence of reactionary/liberal red scare hysteria today? Much of the Bolshevik ideology would be suicidal today. It doesn’t seem based in reality considering the level of surveillance we are all under currently. This sounds like bubble / echo chamber analysis to me unfortunately. The continued McCarthyite scapegoating of socialists by the MSM and both dems and repub operatives is a trap that has been well seeded and laid in the news, on TV, in movies, music, it’s everywhere and amplified by the corporate platforms all used today. Those seeds of hysteria are only beginning to hatch in mass numbers. Instead of waking people up, it appears the media is using cognitive dissonance as a tool to fuel backlash against revolutionary’s. And yes War is another force multiplier for reactionary movements. The obvious place this occurs most is on social media for at least the past five years in earnest. We’ve got Fascists working hard everywhere it seems, co-opting left populist social movements in Conservative land, Neoliberal Democrats stopping any reformative socially democratic leaders from coming to power… Heard someone on YouTube a few days ago literally trying to pull some Weimar Nazi propaganda bs, framing Marx as the father of Fascism and communism, without mentioning Nietzsche or Darwin or how hard the Nazi’s worked at convincing working class socialists and unionists that they were the true path to overthrowing their corrupt democratic leaders. Those same forces are at work today. The Bannon machine. History does repeat, especially political strategies attempting to hypnotize people into becoming hysterical and irrational group thinkers lead by their emotions and instinctual psychological behavior, not long term self interests for themselves and their families. The willingness to participate in rabid nationalist/racist/sexist/xenophobic… hate crimes appears to be getting worse. And as in the poll just mentioned, a super majority of people with power, now apparently believe they can start WWIII in the Nuclear age without such verified military concepts like the knock on and or domino effects occurring, even though they are currently in motion as we speak. Many are referring to it as a realignment in a multipolar world. This realignment has been underway for many years. The US empire’s disregard for international and domestic law is at the very core of the US’s decline as the sole hegemon. Yada Yada, Bla Bla bla Please Consider Lia Tarachansky’s recent analysis. I found her discourse honest and nuanced. Made me feel a little less alone in this world. https://youtu.be/aDjPMMD8qwA There are more articles worth considering. If you haven’t read this article in the New Republic yet, it’s also worth taking into consideration. https://newrepublic.com/article/165603/carlson-russia-ukraine-imperialism-nato Keep it going? This article also made me pause. https://www.opendemocracy.net/en/odr/a-letter-to-the-western-left-from-kyiv/

MLDad

Great thing you guys support Breht's work financially. Everyone can find their way of contributing to the struggle.

Samuel Jesse

Ultimately, I hold no sympathy for any state. They're all enemies of the working class. The Russian /state/ is concerned about NATO on its borders and the European and American /states/ are pushing NATO. The Russian, Ukrananian, and all other working peoples have no interest for or against NATO. Still, they're the ones who really lose, no matter how this war ends for the states. Unless the states are demolished, we will continue to lose. At the least, be careful when saying "Russia wants X" or "Ukraine is Y". Be specific: people are not their governments or borders.

Quinn

late to this but definitely happy u brought up johnny harris and his batshit approach to international affairs