Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

In this Dispatch episode of Guerrilla History (and crossover with Revolutionary Left Radio), we discuss the newly leaked draft opinion from the Supreme Court of the United States what would overturn Roe v. Wade and strip the right of access to safe abortion to millions of American women. We try to frame this historically, and discuss the politics of this draft, which is set to be finalized and voted on in just over a month. A critical topic for us all to focus on right now, and to think together about what steps to take next.  The full text of the draft opinion can be found here: https://www.politico.com/news/2022/05/02/read-justice-alito-initial-abortion-opinion-overturn-roe-v-wade-pdf-00029504

Files

Comments

Demarchic Communism Podcast

I know you're all cis-hetero men, but you should know better than to conflate being capable of becoming pregnant and therefore the potential to need the legal right to an abortion with being a woman. After the recent episode of Guerrilla History about "female" development in western Africa, I'm just...???

Rev Left Radio

I appreciate the feedback! I can definitely understand the criticism of the use of the word "female" in general. I obviously didnt pick the title, but ill talk to the GH folks about it. No ill intentions though, I promise. Just a clunky language choice. As for talking about women and mothers and reproductive rights, i do not think using terms like women and/or mothers in this context is necessarily excluding of anyone, nor is it intended to be. Its using common, colloquial and widely accepted language that specifies the primary targets of this ruling. Are there trans men or nonbinary people who dont identify as a woman but can still get pregnant, of course. and my love and solidarity extends to them, without a doubt. But I genuinely do not see how using terms like women when discussing reproductive rights is flagrant, bigoted, or excluding of anyone in and of itself. My friend and Red Menace co-host Alyson had this to say on the subject: "While it is obviously true that abortion is an issue that effects more than just women, it is equally obvious that overturning Roe is an attack on women. Now is not the time to nitpick over the need for gender neutral language, its the time to discuss the need for women's liberation which is a project that has always implicated and benefited more than just women". I find that argument and framing very persuasive and helpful personally.

Phoebe Chilton

Thanks for this episode, I really appreciated listening to it yesterday. Will this be available on other platforms in the upcoming days, or will it be Patreon only? It’s one I definitely want to share with some people who don’t subscribe.

Davis Pajek

Gotta agree with Sazha here, I've got a lot of trans/NB comrades that feel alienated by the exclusionary rhetoric widely practiced online and at rallies. The "nitpicking" over language isn't so tough and could go a long way, especially when the national spotlight is on the issue.

Demarchic Communism Podcast

Thanks for replying, and for taking my concerns seriously. I have no doubts that no ill intentions were involved. I want to clarify that I did not mean to imply that any of you were being bigoted. It was obviously more of an oversight than a slight. It’s been a week now. When I listened, and when I wrote the comment, I must admit that I was reacting emotionally to some extent rather than responding thoughtfully. I wasn't sure if I should respond, but as a comrade, I think we owe it to each other to offer criticisms when they are warranted. I hope you, the other GH hosts, and Alyson, will take my comments as comradely. I disagree with a few things. First, I think it's incorrect to say it's not “excluding of anyone.” Even though I'm not a person capable of becoming pregnant, I am nonbinary, and have some difficulty getting others to acknowledge that, and sometimes, these frustrations build up. So, this episode stung me emotionally, albeit in an indirect way, but I immediately sympathized with all the listeners who may have felt disrespected in those moments. Nevertheless, stepping back for a more objective view, it was apparent that it was – as a “dispatch” rather than a full episode – more hastily organized, and it just didn't cross your minds to make a nod toward those other segments of the population, even if only to stipulate that you might use “women” throughout the discussion as a shorthand for “women and other persons who might become pregnant” or something along those lines. Additionally, I take issue with the argument that “Now's not the time to...” when the thing being discussed is fundamental to our goals, unless it's in reference to something that's clearly commandist/adventurist. This smacks a bit of liberals saying the same thing in regard to not voting, voting for a candidate to the left of their neoliberal darling, or even just criticizing them. We also see something very similar with revisionist MLs who argue that criticizing China's capitalist reforms and social-imperialism needs to be set aside until some unspoken milestone is reached. When is the time? As Adnan pointed out, the attack on Roe is not new, so it's a bit hyperbolic to assert that now is the time that we must respond. The time to fight back was yesterday, last year, ten years ago. It is of course also now, but it is also next year and forward into the future, until the revolution, and through the class struggle that persists under socialism. Additionally, even if Roe is overturned this year, the choice of language among the far left is not going to be decisive in countering that, or failing to. What it might do, though, is signal to our trans comrades, even those not directly affected by abortion laws, that some of our public voices are aware of us, are willing to take a few extra seconds to recognize us, will not brush past us without a word. The struggle for women's liberation, as of course you know, is intimately intertwined with that of LGBTQ2+ liberation, as well as decolonization, anti-imperialism, abolition of police, prisons, and pimps, etc., and helping comrades recognize their oversights, as well as bringing all of these struggles to the fore is not nit picking; it is part of our overall task. This particular oversight on your part is not itself a major transgression. It is however a sign of how far we have yet to go collectively. If the three of you - who are far more progressive than most public voices - could miss it, that actually says a lot more about how much work is yet to be done in our society more broadly than it is an indictment of any of you.

Rev Left Radio

Thank you so much for the kind appraoch and comradely constructive criticism. I hear you, and I actually agree with your basic argument here - well articulated, and persuasive! I think you are 100% right that we could at least make a caveat up front addressing those concerns that would make it more inclusive and welcoming to people with different gender identities while also not erasing terms like "women" and "mothers" from our argument/rhetoric/analysis. The point about stipulating a broader definition up front, is an easy and totally doable thing that I will keep in mind going forward! We recorded another episode on the dismantling of Roe over at RM that we recorded before I read your reply, so forigve me if those changes arent present in that episode - but going forward I will absolutely keep it in mind and do my best. THank you for not assuming the worst about us, and for being charitable in your criticism. I hope all our listeners know where our hearts are, and that no malice is ever intended. Thank you again for your feedback and continued support of the show. Love and Solidarity!

MLDad

I guess woman is a dirty word

MLDad

I hope for a society where humans are not so self identified with their sexual orientation and social gender roles as to feel like they don't exist if these are not acknowledged. We are ever changing and expanding, infinitely complex and interdependent creatures. Gender being a social and thus ever evolving role will always be a limiting factor to our existence, fixating the boundaries of expected behaviours in space and time and to innate biological characteristics. The concept itself oppresses us, and we would benefit from stopping to grasp at particular instances as if our Self depends on their fulfillment. That Self itself is an illusion.

MLDad

Not playing down violence against and oppression of LGBT people, but the focus should be on fighting the actual violence and oppression and not on exacerbating and grasping for difference. If one gets offended by the use of the word woman as person susceptible to getting pregnant, how will they face COINTELPRO and win?