Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Please submit any and all questions in the comment section below; Alyson and I will answer some of them on an upcoming public episode of Red Menace!

Comments

Joseph

would you recommend getting an advanced degree to enter academia to study this kind of material, or do you see it as a waste of time? I love political economics, and i’ve been strongly considering applying for European programs in either political economics or PPE(philosophy, politics, and economics). I considered doing so in the US at the New School or somewhere similar, but I can’t reconcile paying the price when it would be much cheaper or even free if I went overseas to do it.

Connor P Shadle

On the topic of dialectics: Todd MacGowan describes the purpose of Hegelian dialectics as “reckoning” with contradiction — instead of overcoming it. I have a bit of trouble with this framing because it feels pretty passive. Can you give some thoughts on what it means, in a practical sense, to “reckon” with contradiction? How might this “reckoning” be applied in a revolutionary context?

Stress Builds

What thoughts do you have to offer for people starting their own revolutionary organizations? What texts should be read? What are some first actions that can be taken? What do you believe should be the immediate goals for revolutionary orgs (this year or in five years or in ten years)?

Everett Woolsey

What do you think can or should be done to Intelligence agencies in the U.S.?

Major bit me

What are the best Marxist organizations in the United States, in y’all’s opinion? The best branches of these organizations? What makes America’s most admirable Marxist organizations successful, and what are common issues Marxist organizations face here? What should be immediate goals for American Revolutionary orgs in general?

Jameson McKee

Not so much a Red Menace question but a question for Breht: Have you read the book "Corona, Climate, Chronic Emergency: War Communism in the Twenty-first Century" by Andreas Malm? I know you've had him as a guest on Rev Left Radio before, but maybe have him on to talk about his new book?

Spooky Scary Socialist

In “Decolonization Is Not A Metaphor”, Tuck and Yang have a footnote on page 4 that claims colonialism is not just a symptom of capitalism but also of “socialist and communist empires,” citing Chinese colonialism of Tibet as an example of settler colonialism. They also have a quote that says “both Marxists and capitalists view land and natural resources as commodities to be exploited, in the first instance, by capitalists for personal gain, and in the second by Marxists for the good of all.” What are your thoughts on (1) their assessment of Chinese actions in Tibet and (2) of how communists orient themselves to land and resources? Are their assessments incorrect or do they contain a kernel of truth?

Keelan Swift

Hi Breht, I hope you had a rad time in France! I’m asking this question out of genuine curiosity and I’m not being critical here. As someone on the radical left, how do you feel about hunting / fishing? I’m personally against it, but I know it’s something you enjoy (especially fishing). I think having the politics we do requires high levels of empathy and a serious concern about the well being of nature. And it’s obvious that you yourself are a very compassionate and kind person. So I’m interested to know how you square your politics with hobbies that involve killing animals/fish? In Britain, where I unfortunately live, fox hunting and game shooting are considered to be very right wing and brutal sports. I know what you do will involve elements of providing food for your family etc., but there are meat free alternatives that we can eat. Lots of love and solidarity to both of you❤️

Comrade Dodo

Hello there 😊 Love all your work 🥰 What are your thoughts on the so called Gonzalo's contributions (jefetura, concentric construction and militarized party)? Do you comsider them to be universally applicable and an inherent part of MLM? I personally do not view them as such and I consider myself a maoist. For some MLMs of the the so called "principally maoist" line, it's a deal-breaker. Where do you personally stand in this line struggle? 😊

Naomi

How would you define proletarian from the standpoint of political economy? What types of workers qualify for this category and which would not? What terms should be used to describe other non proletarian types of workers?

J T

Do you think Columbia could be headed for even more turmoil at the hands of the U.S. due to the election of a left wing president? Is another subversion of democracy imminent? Also, how do you think this process of subverting and breaking up democracies over our business interests, toppling regimes that don't play ball or invasions for resources will evolve as the climate crisis begins to squeeze ever harder?

Aksel B

I would be very interested in hearing your thoughts on Graeber and his New Anarchy. I’m of the belief that his books are the most accessible modern leftist literature, and his work, “The Dawn of Everything” does a lot to dispel historical falsehoods stemming from Eurocentric historical control over intellectual fields such as history and anthropology, which has implications for every western political system, including all Western Leftist movements.

Shane

Do you guys think the masses are slowly coming around? I seem to feel that ever so slowly, ordinary folks are becoming more and more conscious, but it feels like we still have mountains to move.

Lefty In Training

Love the podcast and all the guests. How do you evaluate a protest, uprising, revolution, etc., so as to make sure you are critically supporting "good" (for lack of a better word) ones while not blindly supporting all revolutionary action, some of which may be "bad" (ie. color revolutions)?

Neil C

In adopting Hegel and Lacan for politics, I think McGowan is suggesting that because an individual's existence is contradictory (I am what I am and what I am not), and no individual can even coincide with herself, on a societal level nobody can "fit in". Since this is a universal claim, there is no justification for any person/entity to have authority over others. It's an ontology consistent with both preserving differences and eliminating hierarchy.

Connor P Shadle

Any plans to explore anarchist texts/thinkers in the future?

kylewiebe

I feel like I have just barely touched the surface on what Alyson and Breht have put out there. Although been listening for a few years now. I love your work! It has put me on a path of studying more theory and inspires organising practice. I have lived in Australia for the last 7 years, but for the rest of my life was in Canada and USA. Here it is very common to do an Acknowledgement of Country whenever we meet with work/organise in the non-profit space. For those that don't know - An Acknowledgement of Country is a practice that allows for any individual to pay their respects to Aboriginal people, country, culture, heritage and the ongoing relationship Aboriginal people have with the land. I also know in some parts of Canada, depending the type of work, they also pay respects to First Nations People. I have really thought this is a wonderful journey to develop your own story. So I would like to challenge you both to develop an Acknowledgement of Country, and maybe consider asking guests to do this too. We all should know who were the care takers of this land before us, understand their story. My question is, what are your thoughts about 'defunding the police' and what that could look like in practice? I recently discovered Solidarity Talks : Vikki Reynolds & Sacha Medine and wanted to hear your thoughts on their discussion. Thanks Comrades!

Flynnit

I always wanted to ask what would happen with bosses who are very passionaye about their shop and work fulltime in their own shops but have a few people employed to help them. If the state ceases the means of production will they be able to continue working their shop?

Gary Belgrod-Marshall

Can you discuss how the exploitation of the third world ultimately benefits sections of the US working class? This has become a contests topic of late

Comrade Stu

Hello comrades, love your shows! Would it be possible to do another ‘Defence of Marxism’ episode responding to Marxist critic and Austrian Economist Eugen von Böhm-Bawerk? Cheers and solidarity ✊🏻

Zach

From my partner and I who listen to your shows: What are some ways you find hope, big or small, about the future of this country and humanity’s predicament in your daily lives? Additionally, how can we bring this into daily practice and organization consolidation to ensure that what we are doing is not only important but has longevity to ensure continued organizing amongst those who risk falling into nihilism? Do you think starting a family has shifted any of your worldviews? If so, how has this impacted the work you do and politics you advocate? For Alyson (as I dont know her familial status beside partner and if this is not applicable then ignore it), does the current state of the world discourage you from starting a family or how would you plan to do so in light of the current state of Amerika (please remove this part if she doesn’t care to answer and use the rest of the question if chosen)

From The River To The Sea 🇵🇸

I’m curious what your thoughts are on Chris Hedges? In light of the SCOTUS ruling on Roe v. Wade and many of the justices’ openly Christian stances on various issues, I decided to read Hedges’s book American Fascists: The Christian Right and the War on America. Much of what he wrote back in 2007 seems more relevant than ever right now. I know he’s an open socialist, but he also regularly claims that the Soviet Union and China were/are authoritarian regimes. So anyway, I’m just curious if you have any thoughts on Hedges as an intellectual given that he has produced numerous quality works (another being America: The Farewell Tour). Thanks in advance!

From The River To The Sea 🇵🇸

I know you’re not asking me but as an American, I think vast swaths of the American population are becoming increasingly proletarianized, especially with Biden simply fanning the flames of the Russia-Ukraine conflict. This kind of inflation crisis has not been seen in a generation. People in the Biden Administration have gone on the record saying that basically Americans must suck it up and pay $5-$10 p/gallon for gas as they continue to funnel billions of dollars of aid to Ukraine, a place most Americans can’t even find on a map. In fact, I think Jen Psaki said “we have to pay for our values.” She left the administration shortly thereafter. Coincidence much? Also, where I live we’re seeing lots of people from coastal regions and the Front Range (I-25 Colorado metro area) move to rural Western Nebraska because it is cheaper so there is a profound population shift underway (it was already happening post-2008 recession, but it is accelerating at a rapid pace now). The bad thing is that it’s artificially inflating property values in a location where there is little housing already. I’m paying $750 p/month (excluding utilities) for a 2 bedroom apartment in a town of 5,000 people. That’s way above the real market value of housing around here. Idk. There’s lots of problems being exacerbated by NATO’s war on Russia. And even if Trump comes back into office, he will almost certainly have to cease operations in Ukraine or Americans will come to realize the reality that neither wing of the war party gives a shit about them.

Ian Stockdale

Why is the legacy of Karl Marx not considered confirmation of the liberal 'great man' theory of history by Marxists?

Daewoo

There's a lot I'd love to ask, but I'll ask about a current discourse in the twittersphere that is doomed to re-emerge every few months. Are Starbucks workers proletarian? I know they are, but for those that are terminally obtuse on the matter, I feel that a nice explainer could be useful. And to broaden it out, what is productive and unproductive labor, and how can labor be productive for the capitalist (making them a profit), but be unproductive for the consumer (immediately consuming a cup of coffee). Thank you both for your amazing work in educating the masses.

Joseph

breht, have you ever considered writing a book? How do you feel about doing that generally?

Major bit me

Lmao there are people out there who say they aren’t proletarian? Smh

Rev Left Radio

wow i didnt know he had a new one, ill absolutely see if I can get him back on!

Rev Left Radio

Great Q, ill make sure this makes it to the final cut so I can answer it as best I can!

Rev Left Radio

Idk if this will make the final cut, but suffice it to say that I (and probably alyson tho I cant speak for her) generally agree with you. I am very skeptical of the "Principally Maoist" types, have never considered myself apart of that faction, and in our episode with JMP on dogmatism and eccentricism, he raises many critiques of this faction that I largely agree with! If you havent heard that ep yet, def check it out, and all our episodes with JMP (Joshua Moufawad-Paul)!

Rev Left Radio

This might require a whole episode! alyson and I have wanted to wrestle with anarchist thinkers and texts over at RM for a while now, and very well may move in this direction soon. If so, we will definitely try to give this Q the full answer it deserves (i.e. a more or less full episode exploring Anarchism and New Anarchy!). I havent read DawnofEverything quite yet, but I do have it and intend on reading it asap (having multiple young kids make any reading difficult, but i try!)

Rev Left Radio

YES! We did have an old series on RLR called "In Dialogue with Anarchism" in which I talked to three different anarchists in three different episodes and contrasted and compared our views in a friendly way. Check those out if you havent already. BUT we are also planning on diving into anarchist texts over at RM now that we are leaving our reactionary texts series after the next ep, so make sure your subscribed to Red Menace as those will start coming out this fall (hopefully!).

Rev Left Radio

I havent heard of him! Might you post a link here for me to check out?

Comrade Dodo

Thanks for your answer 😇 Heard all the JMP episodes 😁 Loved it all 🥰

Rev Left Radio

Yes, I can discuss that here. I do like Hedges and have found his work very useful over the years. LIke Cornel West, he brings in a spiritual, existential, and religious dimension to his critiques and solutions that I appreciate deeply and which resonates with me profoundly. But, i think largely given his religious obligations and basic belief in non-violence, that he functionally becomes a democratic socialist - neither anarchist nor even really Marxist, but which pulls from both, while angering both (his comments on antifa piss off anarchists and marxists, while his attacks on Lenin and the SU and China turn off marxists of most stripes). Like many thinkers, he can be very useful and his analysis can often be quite deep and penetrating, while in other areas he might disappoint or have bad takes. THis is not unlike Chomsky. For both Chomsky and Hedges, I still have lots of love and respect for them and their role in my development that makes it impossible for me to join in with some other marxists in totally writing them off and even seeing them as enemies. When Chomsky dies for example, I will not be dancing on his grave like, I can only imagine, many online MLs and MLMs very well might be. I will mourn the loss of an imperfect but hugely impactful thinker that radicalized countless people leftwards around the world. A true contribution to humanity, imo.

Rev Left Radio

Because Marx himself merely started an open-ended, experimental tradition that transcends him completely. We can honor individuals that have made historic contributions, while also seeing them as historically-placed figures, limited by their own epoch, shaped by their material and ideological circumstances, and ultimately mere vehicles through which larger historical forces are discovered and articulated. None of Marx's work can be separated from the toiling masses he was inspired to liberate nor the capitalist economic system he understood and critiqued at a level never seen since or before. If Marx had never been born, these processes would have eventually been grasped and articulated by someone else. So our love and appreciation for him as a thinker and revolutionary figured can also be tempered by the realization that he was a product of multiple variables over which he had no control - as we all are.

Ethan

probably too late for the AMA, just wondering if you've had a chance to listen to/had thoughts on the fascinating series on the history of psychedelics Abby and Robbie Martin are doing over at Media Roots Radio. would love to hear you have a conversation with them about it if that's ever feasible (maybe with Mexie as well - I know her and Abby have collabed before)

DD

Hope I'm not too late for the AMA, but I've made it in time, I have an organising question: I'm part of a couple of political groups in my city based on mutual aid and anti-racist organising. These groups are good in that they're run by principled leftists and they've been able to talk to and recruit ordinary people who weren't politically engaged before (instead of just drawing on a small pool of people who are already leftists). However, we're finding that it's difficult to engage with these new members to encourage them to get more involved- while people will come to individual actions to help with food aid or workshops to challenge border police, they don't seem to engage with running the groups or helping to plan what we will do in the future. As a result, virtually all the management, recruitment, organising and planning of these groups is done by a small cadre of communists, and we're constantly running on the edge of burnout. Do you have any advice for educating and politicising new activists so that they can see the long-term visions we have for these groups, share it and develop their own political education?

Rev Left Radio

We did an early episode with Abby actually, and we have kept in touch! I am ALWAYS down to talk with Abby (and Robbie too ofc!)

Aksel B

I feel that, I’m only adjacent to multiple young children and it’s exhausting! Thanks for taking the time to respond to my comment, solidarity and love!

Keelan Swift

I massively appreciate it. Thanks to both of you for your answers. Amazing episode as always.