Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

David Icenogle returns to the show for another super long patreon exclusive where he and Breht talk relationships, their volatile and amusing teenage years, and the complexities and contradictions of online dating before shifting toward an interesting discussion on January 6th and Israel/Palestine based on some of Dave's musings and questions; with plenty of laughs and absurdities along the way.

As always, take these episodes in the jocular and relatively light-hearted spirit in which they are intended! 

Check out Dave's YT channel: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCrmDFdoZQU0CgAZm67Do4BQ


Files

Comments

Alex

Love whenever Dave comes on the podcast!

Grace

Welcome back, Patreon Exclusive King 🙏

Jonathan Fonk

Glad to see Dave back. Definitely a fan of these more "informal" episodes. They make the day go by a bit quicker

Keelan Swift

Love it when you get Dave on!

kylewiebe

Congrats mate on the wedding!

Matt Pierce

Glad to have this to put on for the beginning of my 6 - 3 today lol

Matt Pierce

It's also worth noting that the US and Israel funded the creation and ascendancy of Hamas to displace the PFLP and other left wing formations that were popular and had democratic power in Palestine.

Joely

Just speaking as a queer person here - making a comment completely in good faith, as I have appreciated this show quite a lot! In my unfortunate experience, abusive behaviour has come almost exclusively from people who adhere to some mythologized monogamy, treating me (and other friends & loved ones) like their property. There's some posturing in this episode, overstating tropes about polyamory as some kind of significant harmful arrangement in a society where, we know, the most heinous abuses almost exclusively take place in monogamous homes (as partners / children are generally, if unconsciously, perceived as men's property under patriarchal monogamy), which was kinda disappointing. I would strongly disagree that retaining exclusive access to a person’s affection / body is superior to... not having exclusive access to your loved ones' affection or intimacy. I wish this conversation had been less speculative and better considered, though I understand that the defence is it was “off the cuff”. Unfortunately, it kinda did come across as a little reactionary honestly - we know that monogamous pair bonding developed as class society took shape, producing patriarchal family structures to indenture women to men & secure inheritance to men's ‘real’ children. Prior to class society, though, I believe group marriage is presumed to be the norm. If folks feel more comfortable & happy being monogamous, totally go for it, but please avoid drudging up lazy tropes / anecdotes about polyamorous people. I think it’d be in the interest of people (women, children, and lgbtq folks in particular) to also avoid downplaying the harm that monogamy has caused much of humanity for millennia. We can do better to not slip into conservative patriarchal takes on relationships, and while pointing out how a pretense of polyamory can be twisted by douchey guys, it isn't actually a full reflection of polyamory as a principle (of clear communication & consent). Thanks for reading, and all the best.

NukaDirtbag

Actually met my GF of 4 years through a Tinder hookup. We agreed to have an open relationship and then we just.... went years without adding partners

Joe B

As another queer person, I was also irritated by the discussion about polyamory. Honestly, it sounded like the random (and ill-informed) opinions of two cis straight men. It was telling that the examples they gave always seemed to assume heterosexual relationships (eg, that “the man” in a polyamorous relationship is usually manipulative).

NukaDirtbag

Also makes me think of a clip I saw of that Haz guy from Infrared sounding super vulnerable about how he feels empty doing hookups and it's like maybe if he would drop the Manosphere shit for 10 seconds and stop fanboying Andrew Tate he'd realize he preaches tradition all the time and connect the dots that what he actually wants is a wife

Joely

On the particular question of polyamory - yes, that portion of the convo was reactionary. It is possible for communists to have reactionary lines on various questions and progressive / revolutionary lines on others - even someone as obviously compassionate and well-meaning (and generally consistently holding a progressive / revolutionary line) as Breht. I'm sure Breht would rather have people challenge his biases / prejudices, even if he ultimately disagrees, than have folks unquestioningly sing his praises (or silently give him a pass) for being their favourite Marxist podcaster or what have you. As I said in the first comment, the message was in good faith. I have thought quite highly of Breht over the years. Soooo.. try to let go of being unnecessarily offended on behalf of a parasocial bae, and focus more on the substance of good faith critiques folks lay out. We all have reactionary lines we struggle with, and it's good to have people point them out. None of us are perfect. I genuinely made the comment with the best of intentions.

Rev Left Radio

Might need an actual expert, as we were just riffing a bit here. But yea I think its really interesting and the irony of dating and connecting being MORE difficult in the era of the internet is wild to me.

Rev Left Radio

Yes! Great point. I was speaking extemporaneously and def missed crucial stuff, but yea, this is super imporattn point.

Rev Left Radio

Joely, fair points. I can see how our riffing and super casual discussion of this could land harshly for some, and I agree with your points about monogamy. Dave brought it up and wanted to shoot the shit about it, and I ran with it, knowing its just for patreon, and we can loosen up a bit (since thats the whole point of having dave on in particular), but I also knew it would probably generate some totally legit criticisms and critiques that quite honestly I was already ready to accept. Even though we are riffing and shit talking and just trying to be amusing/funny in these episodes in particular, I should have tried to be MORE clear about the over generalizations we were making and help articulate the other side of this specific debate. Ultimately, if it works for you, thats great. People who want to and sincerely consent to polyamory, and do it in a healthy, non-harmful way, should be able to, and getting over one's feelings of jealousy and possessiveness is genuinely admirable. No disrespect AT ALL. Quite the opposite in fact! Moreover, as a related note, over at Red Menace at the beginning of next year we are going to work through Engels "The Origin of the Family, Private Property and the State", which you might find interesting. AS to Joe's comment, while Im sympathetic to the overall criticism, we were specifically talking about and criticizing polyamorous relationships where the straight guy is being manipulative to a wavering and hesitant partner - which def does happen and while it isnt all that poly relationships are or can be, it is a real world phenomenon that many of us have seen personally and cant be denied. It deserves some skepticism and criticism, even if there are many other types of poly relationships that don't take that form. AS for being cis straight guys, I dont think that disqualifies us from talking about relationships, poly or not. We have them too, after all. Many of the straight people in my life have experimented with being poly, swinging, open relationships, etc. In any case, I appreciate both of your feedback and criticisms, and take them to heart. And I apologize if I let ya down on this one! I am experimenting with these dave patreon exclusive episodes in particular by trying to shift more toward being entertaining and amusing while also talking to a non-communist "normal" person to highlight, in part, the lefts need to stay tethered to regular people, remain able to speak with them, and not get lost in the echo chambers and lose touch. That experiment with casual, laid back, humor-inflected episodes does come with some potential downsides and risks (as proven by our out of pocket riffing on a topic that some take very personally) and ill do my best to navigate those difficulties a bit better going forward.

Rev Left Radio

So many of these more reactionary men, espeically in the manosphere, elevate values they themselves fail spectacularly to approach, let alone meet. The manosphere is not populated with healthy, well adjusted men in meaningful relationships, lmao, and thats the fundamental problem right there. A community of people who dont have what they say they want listening to other people who dont have it either.

Joely

Breht, thanks so much for the thoughtful response and consideration. Appreciate it. While I'm currently not in a polyamorous relationship, I've found myself surrounded by a large community of polyamorous friends, and they have been some of the most considerate, communicative, and emotionally mature people I've met. I've learned far more about healthy relationships from them in recent years than I ever have from monogamous folks in my life. So, my concern is mainly that a mischaracterization of polyamory in general could paint a target on this community's back, particularly for people in, say, the patsoc realm who uphold "traditional family values" or whatever, y'know? Queer folks, who make up a large portion of the poly community, aren't deserving of any more reaction than they already experience. Also, I've had "The Origin of the Family, Private Property, and the State" high up on my to-read list! The essays I've read based on it have all been absolute bangers, particularly in advancing the line on questions around gender & sexuality from a historical materialist perspective. My reading pile just keeps growing, but I will get around to it. And I'm excited to hear there'll be an episode on it in the new year! Again, thanks for your response. Take care!

Joe B

I appreciate the reply, but as to the claim “we were specifically talking about and criticizing polyamorous relationships where the straight guy is being manipulative to a wavering and hesitant partner,” it wasn’t at all clear or stated that you were only talking about one type of polyamorous relationship. Also, being cis and straight of course doesn’t preclude you from having an opinion, but when you’re shitting on someone else’s life choices, it could be nice to acknowledge your positionality.

From The River To The Sea 🇵🇸

That’d be really cool if you could. I know your show isn’t really about dating but I’m sure you could tangentially connect it to anti-capitalist politics in some way if that matters to you. I feel like as I round out my twenties, I increasingly become aware of my feelings of isolation, whether love-based or platonic and I believe capitalism has a lot to do that. I don’t think I’m alone in these thoughts either.