Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

Alyson and Breht reflect on the recent online stir caused by "MAGA Communism" and analyze the ideas of some of its main represenatives and proponents.  

Together they discuss and clarify core marxist concepts, criticize and explain the specific errors being made, shine light on its intellectual influences, explore its connection to previous iterations in american history (like the movement that formed around Lyndon LaRouche), laugh at the extremely predictable response they recieved from Trump supporters, and then they reflect on what it all means and what we can learn from it.

Files

Comments

Nicholas Rubin

Breht, I would really love a follow up to this episode now that the ACP has been established. This episode came with an assumption that the MAGA communism movement would be short lived, and that doesn’t seem to be the case here over 2 years later. Admittedly I am a member of the ACP, formerly PSL for a couple of years. I have also been a long time rev left listener and patreon member. Rev left has helped shape my politics so much, it pains me to think that your position on ACP might still be the vehement opposition expressed in this episode. If you would be open to a dialogue between us, I would love to have a conversation about the state of communism in the USA and the conditions of which we organize within. I hope this comment is received in good faith, again I am a long time fan and was completely geeking out about todays crossover episode with upstream!

Jordan Scheibel

I’ve never really been able to take Maupin or especially Hinkle serious but Brigid O Coileain from the Probably Cancelled podcast and her partner Hasan Ali are two pat-Soc adjacent communists that I was drawn in by for awhile. Brigid’s anti-trans stuff and treating queer culture as a psy-op was what soured me, but it was also their promotion of Dugan recently as an anti-imperialist. And lo and behold a few days ago they defended MAGA communism. Listening to this episode helped me see their deviation in context. It’s been tried before! And it never works!

Matt Pierce

So refreshing. Great work, as always.

Arbor

This so so good ! Thank you! Enjoyable and informative

Mexican Stalin

What sucks is some MLs are pulling to the right because the CPUSA are liberal tailists. Even principled comrades who joined the CPUSA are starting to follow the tailist line of voting for Democrats. Ever since the proles of the round table ended MLs lost their ideological center and are joining anything just for the sake of organizing. Their no concentration of communists so these different tendencies are arising at least with the proles we had an anti-revisionist critical support line. The bottom line is MLism in America has been corrupted by defeatism now you have MLs arguing on whether we should support the Republicans or the Democrats 😰

Major bit me

Gonna read What is to be Done, can’t believe I haven’t gotten around to it yet

NukaDirtbag

I'd prefer people join something over just posting online, but I do think it defeats the point of joining CPUSA if you're just gonna have DSA's line on electoralism.

Mexican Stalin

I don't necessarily think the CPUSA is the main problem but I think MLism is very ideologically isolated in America with literally no allies from other leftist tendencies so MLs only have two choices to either become very defensive and embrace electoralism or lash out like the maga communists did. Either way, I think principled comrades will overcome the defeatist tendencies that developed

Mackenzie parvin

Wow nationalist ideology and some socialism where have I heard that before !

Rev Left Radio

Yea, Ive seen that too. Its sad to see folks take that road. I dont hate or dislike them personally as people are allowed to have different opinions and to grow in different directions, but watching their rightward descent has certainly been informative and interesting. I feel like people who dont organize and spend too much time online are particularly susceptible to this stuff, and Alyson hit the nail on the head in the ep when she said that a lot of this comes from the despair of being on the left in the US and taking L after L after L. I sorta understand the restlessness and the search for an alternative, any alternative, that might reignite some hope and passion. But ultimately this trend too will pass away into oblivion, and they will have the chance to either recommit to Marxism or simply embrace right wing politics fully. Trying to keep one foot in both worlds is simply unsustainable.