Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

In this episode, Breht plays clips of, and responds to, a recent podcast put out by Sam Harris and Yale Historian Timothy Snyder on the Russia-Ukraine war in which they advance several liberal, pro-american criticisms against dissident thinkers on the topic. He also responds to an absurd Horseshoe Theory ass claim made by Sam Harris regarding anti-Semitism. Then Breht plays a clip from a NYT podcast about Cuba and launches into a classic Red Hot Take style rant on the topic.

Files

Comments

Jay Def

This is what I’m paying for, Breht subjecting himself to liberal nonesense so I don’t have to.

Jen Ten

Loved this so much. Thank you!

Danny Boy

Holy shit save some awesome for the rest of us. Amazing Episode.

oranjest1

not a "debate bro" at all but I listen to Trashfuture and related podcasts for the comedy and tech-pessimism and one of the hosts, Milo (who professes some kind of further than centre leftism), has the exact liberal take types like Sam Harris advance with all the "Putin is just a mad man, people saying NATO is a big part of this are stupid" type points and I would love to see a proper dressing down play out between him and you

Matt Pierce

Absolutely brutal lol. What did Michael Brooks call Sam Harris? The "hysterical man speaking calmly" or some shit lol.

Rev Left Radio

Glad to carry forward Brooks' anti-Harris campaign lol

Saya Clarke

God damn I am fired up after this

Saya Clarke

Also possible extra Patreon episode??? I’m about it

sharkfortytwo

scratch a liberal and a fascist bleeds

Lefty In Training

I really want to understand the anti-communist Cuban immigrant mindset, but just cannot wrap my head around it no matter how much I hear or read about it aside from those who fled because they were capitalists not liking the dictatorship of the proletariat. Even if Cuba was all of those bad things the immigrants claim they fled from, how is not having health care, a house, and safety in your schools guaranteed by the government better? It has to be the spectacle (I believe that's the word Marx or Lenin uses) that the US exports, right? The show of two-party elections, and capitalist excess, etc. that people think proves we are the freest country in the world? I just can't understand it in any way other than people either falling for the spectacle or opportunistically escaping a system that suddenly didn't cater to their capitalist interests.

Rev Left Radio

Yea I agree with you; id also say its a result of american hegemony and its ability to export its culture, its narratives, its mythology around the world in tandem with its military and economic empire. Many places in the global south are impovershed and have dysfunctional governments ( not cuba, but more generally), but in many cases that poverty and dysfunction can be traced back to US impacts on the global south, and espeically latin america, in the last century. So the combination of real problems in these countries and the exportation around the world of americana and out narratives are a huge part of the picture here.

Rev Left Radio

Thinking about 3-4 patreon eps a month, but still working out details, and I have something with MEANS TV in the works as well that might help this possiblity become reality. :)

Quinn

insane to me that Harris, a guy who came to prominence by dehumanizing arabs and muslims in the wake of our wars in the middle east, has the gall to lose his mind over the Russian invasion of Ukraine. He will never be anything more than a cheerleader for empire, as long as its ours.

Jordan Scheibel

I have really come to dislike Timothy Snyder. Him and Anne Applebaum (who is definitely worse, sits on board of National Endowment for Democracy, a CIA front) are crazy opportunists when it comes to Russia and Ukraine. They have both weaponized the history of the Ukrainian famine and Stalin’s purges to seamlessly connect modern Russia to Soviet Russia, which is what most Americans do reflexively anyway. When the invasion kicked off my dad called Putin a communist and when I corrected him he said “you know what I mean”.

Jordan Scheibel

That’s so true, he has this disarming tone that masks the hysterics underneath

Jordan Scheibel

I think trashfuture folks are connected via friendship / collaboration with a whole series of podcasts that I have listened to that I have enjoyed but yes their politics is left liberal or rad lib when it comes down to it. No materialist analysis. They’re better than say NPR by correct it pointing out that what they are describing is indeed a consequence of capitalism but their analysis of capitalism is generically anti-capitalist and reformist. I often think the highest form of government in their mind is the social democracies of Scandinavia. One of the people I associate with this group did an episode on Jim Jones and compared him to Mao as both being cult leaders. Which in retrospect was the entire point of the CIA fostering Jim Jones in the first place.

Rev Left Radio

couldnt agree more, in fact i thought of Applebaum so much when i heard this interview with Snyder - same liberal bullshit. But theres LOTS of money in providing an intellectual sheen to the imperial ambitions of the US empire, and so they get rewarded fantastically for their efforts

Jordan Scheibel

It’s true, and someone like Timothy Snyder who actually started out as a serious scholar regardless of his ideological bent clearly is grasping after that brass ring, vs. applebaum who has been an anti communist shill and insider from the start