Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

Breht went onto The Antifada podcast recently to discuss a wide range of topics, from the end of the neoliberal era, to a lively disagreement about China, to Breht's interest in jumping into ice cold lakes, and much more. 

Shout out to Andy and Sean from The Antifada, its always a pleasure to speak with them. 

Files

Comments

Josh Ruston

That was a fantastic episode, it’s always fun to hear you being asked questions as opposed to the other way around…

The Fine Art Revolution

I think Breht answers Andy's rebuttals about china in his latest episode quite well. They are capitalistic as andy says, but that's still lockstep in marxist theory as they have to first build up their modes of production and play within the game so to speak.

Rev Left Radio

Yes, I see it as a different but still legitimate socialist strategy... So much will ultimatley depend on where they go from here, but I am not willing to cross them off as irredeemable, wholly cynical, or simply opportunistic. Socialism with Chinese Characteristics is totally in-line with ML theory... Its not surprising that other tendencies disagree, but from a ML perspective, nothing China is doing or say that they are doing is anathema to basic ML theory. If they literally never move forward and remain capitalist indefinitely, then their critics on the left will have been right. But that remains to be seen...

Jack

This is a very thought provoking conversation, I think this approach of open-mindedness and being open to uncertainty about the future is very healthy and it's something we should be more open to personally and in our organisations. We are in a new era in a lot of ways and if we want to stay relevant and succeed we need to take an open an experimental approach

oranjest1

what the guy who said theres an exact equal chance of that ridiculousness happening is forgetting is that the fight isn't between the state and the working people, it's between differing material/class interests. The CPC is not guaranteed to fall into moneyed interests' camp (especially with the recent focus on purging corruption) and therefore not guaranteed to suppress a militant working class movement and as Breht said could easily work as a dual/transitional structure That "it's impossible" is frustrating to hear, he's thinking in the context of pure capitalist bourgeoise government that absolutely would turn fascist and suppress a working class movement with all its might, rather than an ideologically communist one that MAY allow a principled, powerful working class movement to start to organise in a truly communist sense

oranjest1

I listened slightly further and I'm sorry but Andy is a clown that needs to educate himself before speaking. None of what he said comes with any qualifying context, I can't imagine being a serious communist and having so little respect for understanding or nuance, coupled with "oh you disagree? Get in the totally real massive prison system". Comrade, you are being ridiculous, reevaluate

Mexican Stalin

I think China is cushioning as much as possible for a second revolution. Revolution doesn't mean a giant civil war the Bolshevik Revolution was relatively peaceful when they received the backing of the Russian Armed Forces this time the second revolution in China could be even more peaceful with the popularity of the Communist Party and full control of the Chinese Armed Forces so if any reaction pops up they have the full backing of the PLA. This might be the first time in history that a Communist Party has the full backing of the people and the military and government enact a revolution instead of having ideologues and peasants scrambling to keep the revolution alive and the people alive they have a working bureaucracy already in place

Quinn

Andy says "Chinas sprawling prison system", that is still somehow dwarfed by the American. Wild how that works.

Gord

cHiNa'S sPrAwLiNg PrIsOn SyStEm does this mf actually think Adrian Zenz is telling no lies?

Klaus Zimmermann Mayo

Thanks for sharing this great conversation y’all. Much respect. I do love the characterization of the two presidential choices presented to us. Regarding China I must say that myself having an 8 year old who is obsessed with trains just having Chinese infrastructure propaganda videos has been educational and inspirational, and says more to me about the orientation of the CCP towards meeting the needs of the people than any western speculating about the future of such a dynamic organization. Not to mention the prefect way to get the next generation interested in the superiority of a Marxist approach. https://youtu.be/SF3Tie2C720

Jordan Scheibel

My 3 year old loves trains and said the other night he wants to drive a bullet train. I said “you’ll have to move to China! (Or Japan)”

Jordan Scheibel

I would have loved pushback on this especially to have him cite numbers and sources. Materialist analysis should run off objective analysis and comparison, not regurgitated media narratives and vibes

Jordan Scheibel

I noticed the petulant and accusatory tone he took in this section, which contrasted with the measured tones of the other two. To say the Chinese people live terribly under the CPC is a completely idealist And non-dialectical way of thinking. In comparison to what? You can’t hand wave away China’s development because of the contradictions you don’t like.

Abram Zewuster

For anyone interested in China there's the Silk and Steel podcast with Carl Zha very interesting lots of deep dives into Chinese history 👍

Mason Holloway

At the top of the episode there a brief discussion about folk-punk being problematic. While I can imagine a few reasons, can someone elaborate? truly curious!