Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

James from Prolekult joins Breht to discuss the nuances and complexities of various forms of reductionism and capitalist-breakdown theory within the Marxist tradition. Their discussion leads them to touch on many other topics and issues that are important for the Marxist left today, including advice for those who are relatively new to Marxism. 

Check out and support Prolekult here:

YouTube: http://youtube.com/prolekult

Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/prolekult

Ko-Fi: ko-fi.com/prolekult

Twitter: https://twitter.com/ProlekultFilms

Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/prolekultfilms/

Coalition of Disabled People (as mentioned in the episode): https://gmcdp.com/new-paul-hunt-ebooks

Outro music "Your Dog" by Soccer Mommy

Files

Comments

shea kahmann-taylor

Hey does anyone know how to contact Brett re a guest? I’ve tried messaging them on here but no luck. Thanks

Rev Left Radio

The only thing I have time to check regularly are these comments. I apologize. With three little kids my days are beyond hectic and Ive had to stop responding to emails and patreon messages cuz there are hundreds of them. But usually, if you say something in these comments within the first week or two of me posting something here, ill see it and respond to it! Whats up?

shea kahmann-taylor

Not a problem I was trying to contact you regarding a guest that you might want to interview. Comrade Bob Briton who is the general secretary of the Australian communist party, 40+ years in the movement. they said they would be willing to come on the show, i think it would be a great interview. thanks - Shea

shea kahmann-taylor

i sent there email to you via patreon message hope it works out keep up the great work thank you

Rev Left Radio

OKay, cool. Sounds super interesting! Not scheduling any eps for the next month or so, but I will absolutely add him to my list of future guests to reach out to. Thank you.

Seamus Keane

Cracking episode, has anyone any reading suggestions on how WWI resolved the crisis of profitability for Capaital?

Max

This „reductionism“ isn’t primarily a methodological error, it is an error of insufficient practice. Every sentence is a reduction, because it is abstract. It abstracts from the concrete (“woven together”) world and thereby necessarily bleeds content. Every analysis (“cutting apart”) is also a mutilation. Cut apart a pig and it loses its life, its totality and development. Same with a living concept. Now, with dialectics we possess a powerful necromantic tool, bringing our analyses back to life by incorporating their coniditionality, their logical (and real) movement, development, relations etc. This, however, requires intuition with which we are able to put abstract thoughts together to form a concrete “picture”, a totality. Intuition in turn is accumulated through practice. If you cook a lot, the individual, abstract steps of a recipe form into a process, in which you are able to adjust steps according the concrete situation and depending on their internal logical relations and conditions. You need that for politics, too. Every book of theory is like a ZIP-File, that you need to extract, fill in the gaps, adapt it to your concrete situations etc. The problem of those ”patriotic left” type of guys is, I would argue, not primarily one of scientific method. They are just plain stupid. And by stupid I do not mean an biological inhibition, but a social one. The petit bourgeois viewpoint is the most narrow, muddled and confused, or in other words: the most stupid viewpoint. Petit bourgeois outcasts are especially stupid, because our intelligence depends on our peers; it is created socially. The more isolated, the more alone we are, the stupider we become. If those people “unpack” a Lenin text, for example, they tend to shit all their petit bourgeois garbage between the lines. The blame for that does not always lies with the text. Dogmatism itself does not rely such much on the domgas (although terms and conditions apply), but on how those pillars are used (i.e. in a dogmatic way). The worst of “reductionist” and dogmatic Marxism tends to come out of (Western) academia, not so much out of the movements. Better theory is always desirable, of course, but if you want to be a better cadre, you neet to get out there and learn to swim in the masses like a fish. Let it not be an excuse to remain in your dry study. The latter part about breakdown theory and the examples he gives are excellent, though.

Joy

incredible interview, what a breadth of knowledge