Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

Breht reads a speech he recently gave at Arizona State University on the topic of dialectial materialism, Buddhism, and Marxism. 

Huge shout out to the ASU Zen Devils and MECHA for inviting Breht out to Arizona to give this speech, meet listeners, and visit the Sonoran Desert for the first time!

Learn more about MECHA here: https://linktr.ee/MECHAdeASU

If you are interested in having Breht give a speech at your university, contact us at TheRevolutionaryLeft@gmail.com with the header "Speaking at our University", so that we can siff out the invites from the other messages!

Files

Comments

Adam Schendel

This is a wonderful speech, Breht. Thank you for your insight into the merging of Buddhism and spirituality with Marxism into a sense of inner and outer liberation that very few others on the left take time to speak of. Any chance that you could attach a PDF/written copy of your speech here to be able to read and digest that way as well?

Saya Clarke

Beautiful speech Breht. I got choked up during the conclusion. I hope one day I have the honor of meeting you. Thanks for all you do comrade!

Jack Hall

This is by far the most succinct, articulate summarization of Marxism, historical materialism, and dialectical materialism that I’ve ever heard. Amazing, amazing job, Breht. I’m even sharing this with my non-Buddhist friends

Jonathan Wade

This is huge and I'm so happy for you, man!

Landis Brown

This was so good. Thank you for sharing!

Mirazh

Really awesome speech that’s renewed my desire to learn about Buddhism! Anyone have any recommendations for starting out? Specifically podcasts or audiobooks would be great for me.

Lefty In Training

Loved the speech. I always enjoy hearing connections between socialism and Buddhism, since I am trying to integrate both of those into my daily life more.

Max

More and more I start to understand how the specific focus and viewpoint of Buddhism can complement other religions and philosophies. There is a fundamental truth in recognising your unity with the world and your buddhist insights have given me really interesting impulses to think about problems with ‘separateness’. I wonder however, if there isn’t a danger to fall into the opposite one-sidedness, where the role of the individual falls under the table. I have a bit of a problem with the goal of trying to get rid of desire completely or fully ‘uncovering the veil’ of identity. I find the analogy to communism as a classless society very fitting, because I do not think of classlessness as an absolute end state, but rather as an ideal guiding the process of continuously creating new ‘classes’ (or contradictions) and breaking them down again. Communism should not be thought of as a state of social entropy where all contradictions dissolve, but rather the foundation for new and better contradictions. More fundamental Star Trek shit, instead of the rotten old sludge of poverty, racism and exploitation. In a communist society I don’t want to hunt in the morning and fish in the afternoon or whatever. I still want to specialise and find my individual role in society. But at the same time, I would want to be challenged and engaged in other ways, breaking routines to avoid calcification. Similarly, while I do want to experience my unity with the world and the people around me, I want this not to dissolve me but rather to anchor me as a more complete individual. I think the proper category for this is – as cheesy as it may sound – the category of love (or solidarity when applied to the collective). In love, we negate our self in favour of the other while at the same time finding ourselves in them. We mirror ourselves in their eyes and this act of selflessness becomes at the same time the most complete (and beautiful) instance of our identity as a concrete being. Our partner (or our collective) become a higher purpose, that we devote ourselves to, but which, at the same time, reaffirms us as individuals and anchors our concrete existence. What could affirm your existence better than finding yourself in the world in your absolute concrete representation? To take relationship advice form Mao: In a good relationship two do not become one unified existence but instead two single individuals duplicate themselves through the perspective of the other; seeing the world through four eyes. As a Christian, I wonder what role does the concept of love play in Buddhism? I very much agree that there is no self inside me. Instead, my self is around me within the relationships I have and through the people I love and who love me. People are made up of other people. And as a communist, on some level, I love every single one of you.

Matt Pierce

We LOVE a Modest Mouse needle drop folks

Matt Pierce

Great way to start the 6 - 3 shift at work today.

Hesham Hassan

Question for Breht, or anyone else here who practices Buddhism and meditation, how do you feel about teachers who have bad politics lol? I was looking to go to a retreat near me and so I looked up the teachers and one of them cited the "Effective Altruism Movement" as a guiding philosophy. Part of me wants to be able to compartmentalize the teachings but another part of me just can't. I think one thing that is so beautifully highlighted in this speech is how capitalism is so inherently antithetical to everything Buddhism tries to teach us. So, I don't know if I can fully open myself up to teachers who are ideologically bought into the system.

Rev Left Radio

Thank you so much, my friend. I really appreciate that, and I hope I get the opportunity to meet you IRL as well! <3

Rev Left Radio

Introduction: Hello, everybody, and thank you all so much for coming out today. My name is Breht O’Shea and it is a genuine pleasure and sincere honor to have been invited to ASU to speak on two world-historic traditions that have not only long fascinated me, but have been foundational in shaping who I am and how I see the world; those traditions - which we will be talking about today - are, of course, the centuries-long social, political, and economic tradition of Marxism and the millennia-long psychological, spiritual, and existential tradition of Buddhism. Now, on their face, these two traditions seem to be worlds apart, fundamentally concerned with two totally different terrains of human knowledge and experience, and at times historically they have even been at ostensibly direct odds with one another, whether in the tensions between Chinese communists and Tibetan Buddhists, or Japanese Zen practitioners turned kamikaze fighters allied with Nazi Germany against the Soviet Union in WW2. But I believe that once we start digging deeper, below the top soil of recent history, and beneath the sediments of cultural distinctions and separate academic fields of study, we can find philosophical overlap and profound synergy between these two traditions. Now, let me tell you what I aim to accomplish in this speech: In part 1 I intend on briefly outlining the basic ideas and aims of Buddhism and Marxism so as to give you a basic grasp on these two traditions and their orientations. In Part 2 I want to explore some of the ways in which the seemingly different philosophical outlooks of Marxism and Buddhism overlap and dovetail with one another in surprising and quite profound ways. I will focus primarily on the philosophical framework of Dialectical Materialism, and the ways in which the Buddhist concept of the Three Poisons can help illuminate the problems within capitalist institutions. In Part 3, after highlighting the ways in which they are similar, I will touch on some of the ways in which they differ in an attempt to lay out what Buddhism can offer Marxism as well as what Marxism can offer Buddhism. Finally, in the concluding chapter, Ill put forward the archetype of what I call the Bodhisattva Revolutionary, and attempt to show how, through embodying this archetype, we can work toward real liberation via inner and outer transformation. And with that said, lets move into Part 1: the basics of Buddhism and Marxism. Part 1: The Aim of Buddhism and Marxism is Liberation I think liberation is a great starting concept for exploring these traditions, because both are aimed, in very different ways perhaps, at a form of liberation. Lets start with Marxism. Marxism is, of course, a tradition stretching back to the work of Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels who lived in Europe during the Industrial revolution and who developed 1) a world-historical and hitherto unmatched apprehension and critique of the capitalist mode of production, 2) a new theory of history and how human societies evolve over time, and 3) an economic and political program aimed at the liberation of humanity from the division of societies into class hierarchies - and the exploitation, injustice, inequality, and brutality that class society necessitates. Together, they developed Historical materialism – a scientific analysis of history and society and their development over time – which asserts that the institutions and dominant ideologies of a society are an outgrowth of its economic activity, and its economic activity – the way in which humans produce and reproduce the necessities of life – is the primary locus of social organization, influencing or outright determining the other structures in society. They traced human development from ancient and tribal forms of what they call primitive communism, up through early slave societies, through feudalism, and to capitalism, illustrating how the way in which these societies produced the necessities of life and divided themselves into castes or classes created contradictions that spawned conflict between classes, and eventually created the conditions for that mode of productions transcendence, and the arrival of a new, more advanced mode of production and set of social relations that itself generated new contradictions that in turn created the conditions for its replacement. In addition to this historical materialism, Marx and Engels began to develop what is now the Marxist philosophical framework: dialectical materialism. Dialectical Materialism provides the structure for thinking through historical materialism, for generating social analyses, and for strategizing movements and organizations dedicated to the transcendence of the current mode of production, namely capitalism. In simple terms, Historical materialism is the scientific aspect of Marxism, and dialectical materialism is the philosophical framework of Marxism. Socialism, according to Marxism, is what we would call the transitionary period between capitalism and Marxism’s ultimate goal of communism; a stateless, classless, moneyless society where human beings are no longer stratified into castes or class hierarchies. In the same way that the transition from feudalism to capitalism is often referred to as Mercantilism, with features of both the old feudalism as well as the emerging capitalism, socialism is the transition from capitalism to communism, with features of both the old capitalism and the new communism. In summary, Marxism is a scientific approach to history and human social development, a philosophical framework, and a socio-politico-economic movement aimed at the construction of socialism out of the contradictions present within capitalism – all toward the ultimate goal of a human civilization no longer divided into classes at all. Marxism seeks to liberate humanity from the exploitation, the inequity, the utter irrationality, and the brutal injustices of capitalism. Buddhism, on the other hand, seeks a totally different type of liberation – that of nirvana, or liberation from the cycle of birth, death, and rebirth, known as samsara. Buddhism is a tradition going back 2,500 years to the life and teachings of an erstwhile Hindu Prince turned spiritual seeker and ascetic who, once introduced to the sufferings of the world – sickness, old age, and death – after years of being sheltered from the vicissitudes of life in his Palace, left his family and life of luxury in search of deeper truths about the nature of reality, suffering, and the human mind. After years of wandering and fasting and meditating and engaging in all sorts of spiritual practices, and finally fed up with all of them, the story goes that he sat underneath a Bodhi tree and refused to get up until he finally knew the minds true nature. Day in and day out he sat under the tree and went to war with his own mind, overcoming all forms of struggle, of suffering, of temptation, one by one, until finally he reached what we now call “enlightenment”, and became the Awakened One, or the Buddha. After his awakening, he spent the next 40 years before his death walking around the Indian subcontinent offering his teachings to anyone who was interested. He built a huge following, and upon his death, generated a new world religion, spiritual path, and philosophy. This religion-philosophy, known as Buddhism, would migrate out of India and throughout the rest of Asia, morphing and evolving and mixing with the cultures of different societies, eventually producing the beautiful traditions and various schools of Buddhism. The core of Buddhism however revolves around the Four Noble Truths (life is suffering, we suffer because we crave or desire, there is way out of this suffering, and the 8-fold path is the way out). The 8-fold path is a set of 8 practices – both ethical and meditative - that, when done correctly and consistently, lead one to enlightenment. In addition to this, Buddhism highlights the Three Marks of Existence: Impermanence (Pali: annica), suffering or unsatisfactoriness (Dukkha), and No-Self (annata), and argues that we humans are subject to delusion regarding these three intrinsic qualities of our existence, that we try to protect ourselves from them in a myriad of ways and thus escape them, but these attempts just create more suffering. Through meditation practice specifically, and following the 8-fold path generally, we can come to see the ubiquitous presence of these three marks of existence with increasing clarity and liberate ourselves from the immense suffering we create for ourselves by denying or running from them. In short, Buddhism seeks to liberate human beings from the unnecessary suffering that stems inevitably and inexorably from our constant desiring, our ego-delusions, and our desperate clinging and attachment to things that, by their very nature, change and dissolve away. We are always talking to ourselves in our heads, we are always grabbing at pleasure and trying to push pain away, we have this nagging sense of always being not quite satisfied, never quite complete, and so we spend our whole lives leaning forward into the future, and backwards into the past, searching for something external to us that will finally make us happy and fulfilled, and trying to protect ourselves from all the pain and tragedy and despair in our lives by building up our psychological defense mechanisms and reifying our sense of separateness. We are always extracting ourselves from the present moment, what is right here and right now, in anticipation for whats coming or in nostalgia for what we once had. We are a mess, and the world is a mess because we are a mess. Buddhism seeks to liberate us from our delusions, our self-inflicted suffering, our desperate clinging and craving, and the faulty idea that we are located somewhere behind the eyes and between the ears looking out at a world that is not us, and acting as a trembling little commentator to our own lives. To be liberated from all of this is to feel ourselves to be completely at home in the world, to be the very cosmos we think is outside of us, to neither cling to pleasures nor run from pain, but to live our lives in the present moment, in deep equanimity, and to accept life and death as they come, on their terms, with love and compassion and joy in our hearts. So now we see what, at a basic level, these two traditions are all about, and we can see how each one is concerned with a certain type of liberation from certain forms of suffering. And that sets us up quite well for Part 2: the interesting ways in which these seemingly very different traditions overlap. Part 2: Dialectics and Transformation It is my contention, which I will defend throughout the rest of this section, that the philosophical framework of dialectical materialism found and developed within the Marxist tradition and summarized above has profound overlap with core Buddhist concepts and with a Buddhist worldview overall. After exploring dialectics, I will turn to an investigation of the Three Poisons found within Buddhism, and attempt to show how these poisons of the individual mind manifest themselves in capitalist institutions and social structures, which in turn create and exacerbate massive suffering for all sentient beings like ourselves. To begin, let me remind you what dialectical materialism is, as it can be a difficult concept for people to wrap their minds around – especially those who are new to the idea. The first thing to say here, briefly, is that Marxism is not a dead doctrine, it is not a dogma, and its core concepts are always being revisited and revised generation after generation. In this respect, it is scientific – meaning it is open-ended, non-dogmatic, experimental, open to new evidence, and in a constant state of evolution itself, advanced by real movements, revolutions-as-experiments, and the empirical data they generate. Marxism is not what Marx thought, Marxism is an ever-evolving tradition that Marx and Engels inaugurated through their work, but which is then developed by successive generations of Marxist thinkers and revolutionaries. Marxist concepts, like Dialectical Materialism, are also subject to debates, differing interpretations, and evolution. The philosophical framework of dialectical materialism arose initially out of Marx’s study of Hegel, was taken in new directions by Engels, updated and revised by figures like Lenin and Mao, and handed down to us today. Without getting into the nuances and complexities of these differing interpretations, which would take us too far afield, let me just focus on the basics of dialectics. A dialectical approach to the world is one that apprehends all phenomena as fundamentally in motion, as inexorably interconnected and in relationship with all other phenomena, that higher levels of existence are rooted in and emerge from lower levels, that contradictions between phenomena propel their evolution, and that this process of evolutionary advance is governed by laws which are knowable. Friedrich Engels argued that there were at least three basic laws of dialectics: 1) the law of unity of opposites which is the source of development 2) the law of the passage of quantitative changes into qualitative changes which is the mechanism of development, and 3) the negation of the negation which is the direction, form, and result of development. This is, admittedly, quite complex and can be very confusing to people new to the subject of dialectics. To help understand a bit better, let me use an analogy to Darwinian evolution, which will help bring these concepts to life. Evolution by natural selection is a great example of dialectical materialism. First and foremost, it shows that all life on earth is in a constant state of evolution and development. Contrary to, say, creationists who believe god made all the animals and plants as they currently are and put them on earth, evolutionary biologists know that is not true. In reality, life evolves and develops in profound relation to its external environment, and is constantly being morphed by natural selection via its relationship to everything else in its eco-system. So already we can see some basic dialectics at play: biological life is in a constant state of motion, never static, it is interconnected and literally shaped by its relationship to other life forms as well as its external environment in general, the higher levels of life – say, humans for example – are rooted in and emerge from lower levels of life – most recently hominids, then primates, and then mammals generally, and evolution is spurred on by contradictions between an organism and its environment. Penguins losing their ability to fly, a bumble bees ability to see ultraviolet, humans developing language, a bat’s ability to echo-locate, the insane speed of Gazelles and Cheetahs alike - all of these are products of contradictions between the organism and its external environment. Taking the analogy even further, we can see how, for example, small quantitative changes in an organism over time - like genetic mutations and various adaptations - eventually stack up to create a qualitative change in an organism. For example, Polar bears and brown bears share a common ancestor, and scientists believe that at some point, either by brown bears traveling to the far north or by periods of glaciation, a single species of bear got separated, some going further north and some staying put or going south to warmer climates. The contradiction between these brown bears far up north and the brutally cold, white environment they found themselves in generated, over long periods of time, the mutations and adaptations (i.e. quantitative changes) that eventually boiled over into qualitative changes, separating the single species into the two distinct species we know today. The point here is that we can understand the jump from quantitative change (tiny mutations and adaptations over time) piling up to create a qualitative change (in this case an entirely new species of bear). The materialism part comes in via the fact that no metaphysical or supernatural cause need be referenced. Biological evolution via natural selection is a wholly materialist process, it happens in the natural world and has laws that govern it that we, through scientific investigation, can come to know and understand. In this same way, Marx and Engels argued the evolution of human societies through time is also a materialist process, also has laws that govern its development, and through scientific investigation we can come to know those laws and understand how they work to produce the social phenomena we see today. Human society is constantly in motion, never static. All the elements of it are deeply interconnected and interact with all other elements. The current mode of production, capitalism, is a higher form of social organization than feudalism which capitalism is rooted in and evolved out of, and the evolution of human societies over time are propelled by contradictions inherent in them. Today, the contradiction between the bourgeoisie and the proletariat forces various forms of class conflict that can only be resolved by transcending this division altogether. Moreover, like the law of the unity of opposites tells us, the bourgeoisie cannot exist without the proletariat – they are opposites that necessitate one another like night and day, or up and down. Every class struggle, every attempt to build socialism in the capitalist epoch, every person who consciously embraces socialism and sets themselves the task of helping others learn and apply it, all constitute relatively small qualitative changes that, eventually, create ruptures and thus the possibility of quantitative change: the change from capitalism to socialism. And Just as the capitalist mode of production and its social relations negated the social organization of feudalism, socialism and eventually communism seek to negate the negation. To expropriate the expropriators. But importantly, dialectical negation, in line with the idea that higher forms are rooted in lower forms, doesn’t annihilate the entirety of what it replaces, but brings forward the elements of the old that are positive and viable, while shedding all those elements of the old that are exhausted, played out, and only serve to hold humanity back. So we should expect, for example, socialism to carry forward those aspects of capitalism that are still viable, while rupturing from all those aspects of it that no longer are, whatever those turn out to be for a given society at a given time in history with a given set of specific conditions. Here we can start to get a grasp on dialectical materialism and how that way of thinking stands in contrast to so much “common sense” today. For example, when someone says “capitalism is just human nature”, or “this is just the way things are”, or “god ordained these hierarchies, ergo they are just”, or “you are born with a gender and cannot change it”, or “socialism has failed everywhere its been tried, it simply doesn’t work and never will”, or a billion other little platitudes and cliches used by those who are invested in the status quo – when they say such things, they are conveying the idea that the way things are in society today are static, metaphysically ordained, or natural, and thus they are conveying an anti-dialectical way of thinking. You can see why those who think capitalism is the best system, or those who profit from society being organized this way, want us to think that capitalism is here to stay. They want us to think that we have arrived at the pinnacle of socio-economic organization, and while we might have some tweaking to do around the edges, the basic thing is in place and is here to stay. But dialectically, we understand that capitalism as a mode of production arose out of historical conditions, is in a constant state of flux and development and evolution, and like every single mode of production before it, will also eventually be displaced and transcended, just as it displaced and transcended feudalism. To see capitalism as historically contingent and ephemeral is to grasp dialectical and historical materialism, and you can see rather easily why those invested in maintaining this system are not interested in people thinking in these terms. Just as earlier dogmatic Christians were not very excited to see people start embracing Darwin’s theory of evolution via natural selection. Both capitalists fending off socialists and fundamentalist Christians fending off Darwinian evolutionists must reject a dialectical way of apprehending the world, or risk their relatively cozy spot in the current order. They must put their hands up and scream STOP in the face of the inexorable march of history. Okay, now that we hopefully have an understanding of dialectical materialism within the Marxist tradition, the question arises: where does Buddhism fit in here? Well, I would argue that core concepts within Buddhism are profoundly dialectical, and that Buddhist philosophy applies a more or less dialectical framework around its entire worldview. The core concepts I want to explore through this lens are the following: No-Self or Emptiness and dependent origination. To begin, I first want to make clear that both Buddhism and Marxism are process philosophies; meaning they apprehend all phenomena as processes instead of things or objects. Capitalism is an ever-evolving process, as is socialism. The natural world is a process. The cosmos itself is a process. You and I are processes. In both traditions, nothing is static and change is the only constant. This leads to the first concept of Buddhism: no-self or annatta. When people first get into Buddhism and come across this concept, especially those of us in the west where Ego is Everything, it can seem weird, alien, even downright scary. But fundamentally, the Buddhist concept of no-self or emptiness means simply that nothing, including us, has a permanent essence. There is no unchanging, abiding self at the center of our subjective experience. This is quite a radical claim, because the feeling of an unchanging self, or soul, is deeply ingrained within people, especially those of us in the west where no such philosophical analog to no-self really exists. But right now, as I speak, I am willing to bet that you feel as if there is a self inside you. Sure, over your life, you have changed. 7 year old you is different mentally, emotionally, and physically than the you sitting in front of me right now. No one would deny that. But when I ask you what about you has not changed since age 7, what would you say? Well, we feel as if there is a thread running through all our experiences and all the changes in our lives, and that is the “me” looking out from behind my eyes. Sure, what I see in the mirror changes all the time. My opinions change. My interests change. My clothes and car and job change. But we really feel as if there is something within us that was looking out the eyes of our 7 year old selves, out of our 15 year old selves and is still looking out of the eyes of our current selves. This is an illusion. The relentlessness of change in the cosmos spares nothing; including you and I. Moreover, we talk to ourselves in our heads all day long. Constantly commenting to ourselves, blabbering on about this or that, thinking about something in the past, worrying about something in the future. If you had to go sit in your car right now, totally alone, in silence, what would your mind do? It would start talking itself. In fact, if I stacked a million dollars on this podium and told you that if you can sit in silence and just not think a thought or talk to yourself in your own head for 60 consecutive seconds you can have this million dollars, I can almost guarantee none of you could do it. The mind is incessant. The mind is like a monkey swinging from tree to tree, thought to thought, babbling to itself. And its this incessant inner dialogue that we mistake for a separate self. The sense of a real, permanent self inside your skull looking out of your eyes is an illusion, it is the product of incessant inner dialogue, of non-stop mental chatter. Everytime you think without knowing you are thinking, everytime you talk to yourself in your head without being fully aware that that’s what you are doing, you are reifying the illusion of Self, because the illusion of Self is literally generated by thinking without knowing you are thinking. Add on top of this psychological fact, probably a product of evolution and our capacity for language, cultural ideas just as the eternal soul from Christianity and the cartesian dualism between mind and body from western philosophy, and we all fall prey to the illusion of separateness, the illusion that deep down, behind our eyes and between our ears, is a little, unchanging, permanent self or soul. We say we have a body, not that we are our bodies. That too is a product of having the illusion of a little homunculus behind the control panel in our brains, using the vehicle of the body to move itself around space, but fundamentally separate from it. This trope shows up time and time again in our pop culture, in our movies, and in our TV shows. And this little, fragile, separate self feels monstrously insecure in this world of change and decay and death. The ego, our sense of a separate self, strives to prop up all manner of defense mechanisms to protect itself, to make itself feel safe. It clings to pleasures; it wants to run from pain. It worries about the future, it fixates on the past, it can’t fathom its own annihilation at death. This illusion of a permanent self is at the root of all existential crises. For some, this sense of a separate self is torturous, for most of us though, it manifests as a perpetual feeling of not being complete, of not being fulfilled, of never quite arriving. In short, this illusion makes us suffer. So Buddhism not only tells us, but shows us how to see for ourselves, that this sense of a separate, abiding self at the center of our experience is an illusion, a product of incessant self-talk, and when we build the capacity through meditation to become aware of it, to see how it manifests, and to see all the ways in which this little voice in our heads makes us suffer, when we can place our attention on the breath and keep it there, when the mind calms down and gets real quiet, we can see through the illusion. And when we see through it again and again and again, eventually it gives up the game. It stops being our master, and becomes our servant. We can pick it up when its practical to do so, and we can set it down when its not needed. This ability alone alleviates massive amounts of internal suffering, lets us see with extreme clarity the mechanisms of the mind and how they work, and no longer burdens us with the feeling of separateness. We begin to see, with astounding beauty and depth, how there is no me inside here looking out at the world over there, but there is just the world, and the barrier between subject and object falls away, at least for a time, revealing the profound interconnectedness and non-duality of everything in the cosmos. You feel as if you are no longer placed into the world, only to one day be taken out of it; but that you are the world, and the world is you, and there is nothing to be born and there is nothing that dies. Liberating oneself from this illusion is a core feature of enlightenment in the Buddhist tradition, and it radically reorients your entire moment to moment experience of your own existence in a profoundly beneficial and healing way. But Emptiness is not just about the self or ego, it’s the claim that nothing in the universe has any abiding essence. Everything is flux, everything is a cascade of relentless change. Nothing is permanent. Nothing is a static thing or object. We are all just temporary whirlwinds of atoms coming together for a time as this process I call “me”, and then dissolving away, coming together with different atoms to form another temporary process, and on and on and on. To cling to the idea of a stable, permanent “me” is to suffer enormously. The atoms in our bodies were forged inside stars, have been at the bottom of the ocean, passed through dinosaurs, and have come together here and now to form us. All of the cosmos, based on the latest science, can be traced back to an infinitely small and dense single point of origin, meaning we all literally were one with everything in the universe, and the big bang expelled everything outward into space and time to dance and play and swirl, taking on infinite forms. Science, in some respect, is just catching up with ideas that Buddhists put forward two millennia before the invention of the scientific method itself. Its quite astounding when you sit back and think about it. In any case, this concept of no-self or emptiness in Buddhism not only fits perfectly with phenomena-as-processes, but with dialectics itself: everything is in flux, everything is intimately interconnected with everything around it, there are no things and no one who stands outside the flux, nothing is permanent or fixed, everything is in a constant state of development and transformation, and nothing supernatural or metaphysical need be advanced to explain material reality. On this last point, there are certainly forms of Buddhism and many Buddhists who do not subscribe to materialism, and there can be dialectical philosophies that are neither ontologically materialist or idealist, as well as ones that remain agnostic or neutral with regards to what is primary (known in philosophy as Monism), but none of this subtracts from the idea that the concept of emptiness and no-self is perfectly in-line with a dialectical apprehension of the world and that one need not resort to non-materialist explanations of this reality, though some may choose to do so. Now let’s move on to the Buddhist concept of Dependent Origination or Dependent Arising. In simple terms, this means that everything in the cosmos is dependent on other things for their existence. The late Vietnamese Zen Buddhist Thich Nhat Hanh was great at giving examples of this. Let’s take his example of the flower. When you hold a flower in your hand you have a concept for it and a word that sits in for the thing you’re holding. We understand it at first as a static object, but dig a little deeper and we can see its interconnectedness with the whole universe. Try to imagine that flower without the soil from which it sprang, without the sun which helped it grow and allows you to see it with your eyes, or without the rain which watered and nourished it. Another easy example would be something like a peach. When you bite into a peach, there is a sense in which you are biting into the whole world, for innumerable conditions and factors had to come together to produce this fruit, as well as the sensation you get when biting into it. We can zoom out a bit and use ourselves as examples. The iron in our blood came from exploding stars billions of years ago. The water in our blood used to be one with the ocean. The breath we breathe is utterly dependent on plants and trees across the globe. In a real sense, plant life is as essential for our existence as our lungs are. The sun is as essential for our existence as our own beating hearts are. The moon stabilizes Earth’s orbit, making it habitable for relatively advanced creatures such as ourselves. Without it, there would be no us. In this way we are profoundly, deeply dependent on everything else around us, and everything else in the cosmos, for our own existence. We can also apply this idea to politics. The billionaire is not, as we are often told, a rugged individualist who, through grit and hard work, built his empire and is a self-made man. Rather, he is utterly dependent on scores of working and poor people to generate even a single dollar. Put a billionaire on a deserted island and he is nothing. Everything we value, from schools to hospitals to roads to air conditioning, are all the products of countless people working over huge swaths of time stretching back generations. All are dependent upon a variety of factors and conditions coming together to create them. All wealth in the world is the product of centuries of human toil, of which all of our ancestors contributed. Yet today, all that wealth is stolen and hoarded by a tiny amount of people who claim its rightfully theirs and not ours. The entire capitalist paradigm and the hyper-individualism that it necessitates, is built on the rejection of the idea of Dependent Origination; it is built on a delusion. Similar arguments of this type could be made for other core concepts within Buddhism, including impermanence, non-duality, and more! Here we can see how an idea that is central to Buddhism is intrinsically dialectical and can usefully be applied to socio-economics and politics in a way that directly undermines, instead of bolsters, the capitalist mode of production and its ideological superstructure. On the other hand, the core orientation of socialism and communism is perfectly in line with the concept of Dependent Origination, because we understand that everything we have is a product of countless people’s labor, as well as the product of our relationship with the natural world. WE understand how cooperation is essential, how solidarity with others can massively benefit ourselves, and how we are ultimately dependent on one another. There is no me in a vacuum, and there is you in a void. We are products of the human species, of planet earth, and of the entire fabric of the cosmos itself. We are literally the cosmos becoming conscious. We, like all sentient beings, are literally the entire cosmos waking up here and now, in this form, from this standpoint. We understand the deep, underlying interconnectedness of human civilization and of the world in which we live, and our politics, at its best, honors that interconnectedness and centers it as essential. I hope thus far I have made it quite clear why this dialectical way of approaching and apprehending the world is not only correct, but a real threat to the status quo, to the ruling elite and their ideology, and to the capitalist mode of production itself. This is why Marxism, dialectical materialism, and ideas like no-self and Dependent Origination must remain fringe and must be undermined. We are simply not taught to think this way, and for rather obvious reasons. One more area of philosophical overlap I want to touch on before moving forward is the concept of the Three Poisons in Buddhism. These three poisons are 1) Greed, 2) Ill Will, and 3) Delusion. When they are present in the mind, and when one is identified with them, they wreak havoc on an individual’s psyche, bolster the ego-delusion, and create suffering for all involved. And while Buddhism talks about this almost exclusively in terms of the mind, I think it’s quite natural to argue that if most people are susceptible to these poisons, they can be instantiated not just at the individual psychological level, but also on the collective socio-political level. And it is my argument that capitalism, in many ways, institutionalizes these Three Poisons, attempts to naturalize them, and then exacerbates their intensity on the individual and collective levels. What, for example, is capitalist profiteering and exploitation if not unbridled greed presented as natural and good? What is imperialism, colonialism, and fascism – all manifestations of capitalism – if not institutionalized and structural ill-will, connected of course with the inherent greed of capitalism and its incentive structures. What is capitalist ideology if not hegemonic delusion? On every level, it seems that these three poisons which Buddhism identifies are taken to their structural and intuitional extremes within capitalism. Moreover, if Buddhism is correct in arguing these three poisons are prevalent in the unenlightened human mind, it stands to reason that putting millions of humans together might take these individual psychological traits and turn them into collective institutions. And this is an insight derived precisely from investigating the ways in which Buddhism and Marxism dovetail and overlap. Buddhism, by illuminating certain truths about how the human mind works, can offer Marxism useful concepts that can be applied to society as a whole. Marxism is, after all, not focused on individuals and their minds, and there are things to learn about individual psychology and the machinations of the human mind that are illuminating and helpful to a broader social analysis and critique. In this way, these two traditions, focusing on opposite ends of the individual-vs-collective spectrum, can be brought together to deepen already existing insights, as well as generate new ones. What I am doing here is hardly exhaustive on this front – rather it’s more akin to a first pass in the hopes the Buddhists might take an interest in Marxism, that Marxists might take an interest in Buddhism, and that more connections and useful synergies might be discovered and utilized to work toward the shared goal of ending suffering and pursuing liberation. Part 3: What Can Marxism and Buddhism offer one another? Now that we have discussed what Marxism and Buddhism are, as well as some of the ways in which their basic dialectical approach to the world overlaps and can even deepen one another, I want to touch on some concrete things that each tradition might be able to offer the other one. To keep it simple and concise, I believe that what Buddhism can offer Marxism is an inroad to a form of dialectical analysis of the individual, their mind, and its mechanisms. Marxism is not fundamentally concerned with these things, but as good dialecticians we understand there is a profoundly important dialectical relationship between inner and outer, between the individual and the collective, between psychology and ideology. As such, it can only benefit us Marxists to take that side of the coin, as it were, seriously, particularly in the context of political education, organizing, meeting people where they are, and – importantly - constructing healthy, non-toxic activist spaces and organizations. And this is important because if any of you have had the experience of visiting Marxist internet sub cultures or even many organizations, I am sure you’ve noticed there tends to be a LOT of Ego. Marxists tend to be intellectual types, and without a sort of psychological ballast and ethical structure offered by Buddhism, those egos swell to sometimes insane proportions. People want to be right more than they want to be effective. Entire organizations doing good work will split up and disintegrate based on members inability to navigate interpersonal conflict or because of the fixation on minor disagreements that are irrelevant to the current struggle. Buddhism offers an ethical structure and behavioral guidelines that Marxism often lacks and they can be applied in a secular way if needed. For example, while some of the eight principles in the 8-fold path are fundamentally about Buddhist meditation (right mindfulness and right concentration for example) the vast majority of them can be applied to anyone from any religious, spiritual, or cultural background – which is different from something like the 10 commandments for example. Right intention, right speech, right action, right effort, right view, and right livelihood are all fully applicable within the context of a socialist organization or cadre. They are ready-made ethical guidelines with millennia of history that not only help create a healthier organizational culture and healthier individuals, but are also fundamental to the sort of awakening process within buddhis that, while not necessary for Marxists, could only be a positive thing if pursued. In Summary, Buddhism offers up an analysis of individual psychology, a universally applicable ethical structure, a systematic way of addressing egoism in ourselves and our comrades, and can help us relate better to ourselves as well as others in our community and beyond. On the flip side, we must ask: what can Marxism offer Buddhism. Well, I would argue that it would be something like the systematic, scientific analysis of social, economic, and political phenomena, which is the outward, collective application of the systematic and scientifically rigorous analysis of psychological and emotional phenomena that Buddhism already excels at. IN addition, Marxism offers a political methodology for overcoming institutionalized and structural forms of the Three Poisons. Buddhists will often talk about healing the world by healing one self, and while I find that to be useful and even true, I don’t find it to be sufficient. We do not have the time to sit around and wait for enough people to get into Buddhism and become enlightened to make the sort of collective change that is so desperately needed. With climate change, the risk of nuclear war, the rapid advancement of society-shaking technologies that under capitalism become mechanisms of further destitution and unemployment and misery, the many ongoing imperialist conflicts, the rise of neo-fascist authoritarianism around the world, and many more crises piling up every day, we simply do not have the luxury of waiting for everyone to do the necessary individual work required to reform human civilization - THAT can only be done through international, organized and revolutionary political movements with a totally different vision for the world. While socially engaged forms of Buddhism do exist, they often default to the liberal center and to weak forms of reformism. Defaulting to lukewarm liberal activism does literally nothing to move the needle in the direction it needs to be moved, and since it is liberal, it seeks not to create a different world, but to reify and replicate the very ideological hegemony that keeps things as they are – often without knowing that’s what they are doing. This is because liberalism is the dominant ideology of capitalism itself, they go hand in hand. If Buddhists are serious about alleviating suffering, then they have to take politics seriously. And if Marxists are serious about becoming the sort of people that are capable of creating a truly new and better world, they need to take the inner work that traditions like Buddhism offer seriously. Conclusion: The Bodhisattva Revolutionary Today, I have argued that Marxism can benefit from a sincere engagement with Buddhism, and Buddhism in turn can benefit from a sincere engagement with Marxism. I hope I have outlined effectively the primary goals of each tradition, the ways in which their philosophical orientations share a deeply dialectical lens, and the ways in which each tradition could benefit and deepen the other. To end, I want to leave you with an image – an archetype if you will – that synthesizes everything I’ve said here today into a template that each of us, insofar as we are more or less convinced of what I’ve been arguing for, can adopt and strive to fulfill. This archetype is what I call the Bodhisattva Revolutionary. We all know what a revolutionary is: it is someone committed to confronting the injustice and inequality and suffering that are ubiquitous in class society, and working to build a better, more just, more equitable, egalitarian world. The revolutionary is self-less, dedicated to the people, and shaking with indignation at every injustice. Figures like Che Guevara, Thomas Sankara, Rosa Luxemburg, and many others jump to mind. All of these people mentioned were also willing to pay the ultimate price for their vision of a better world – all three of them were brutally murdered by agents of the status quo, of capitalism, of fascism, of imperialism. Their images are seared into our brains, and we strive to contribute even a fraction of what they did to the project of building a better world. Now we must combine that with the image of the Bodhisattva; that figure within Mahayana Buddhism who, in one telling, is an already enlightened being who, out of pure loving compassion for other sentient beings, remains in the cycle of samsara and forgoes nirvana simply in order to save others. That version might be too ideal for many of us who are anything but enlightened – and of course I count myself among the unenlightened. The other version of the Bodhisattva is a little more realistic; it is someone who is on the path towards Buddhahood and who commits themselves to dedicating their entire life and their whole being to the alleviation of suffering in others. The Bodhisattva is self-less in an even deeper sense than the revolutionary, because she seeks to actively dismantle the illusion of a separate self, and uses the insight gained from that endeavor to better understand and thus help other sentient beings. Bodhisattvas set for themselves the impossible task of ending all suffering and helping all beings to awaken. They vow not to enter nirvana themselves until all beings can enter it together, hand in hand. By combining these archetypes – one Marxist, one Buddhist – we can create for ourselves a well-balanced ideal to strive for. Instead of dedicating our lives to careerism, the accumulation of wealth, and the pursuit of high status within the capitalist framework, as we are trained to do, we reject all of that and dedicate our lives instead to alleviating the suffering of other beings, confronting courageously the forces of oppression and hate and greed, and toppling structures of domination and exploitation and suffering in order to build an egalitarian civilization rooted in interconnectedness, justice, truth, beauty, and solidarity. A world where no one sleeps in the gutters, a world where no one goes without healthcare or food, a world in which no one goes without an education, and a world where no one suffers in totally avoidable and unnecessary ways, so that others may live lives of extreme opulence. Let us all strive to embody within ourselves the Bodhisattva Revolutionary ideal.

Rev Left Radio

thanks man! Its dope we have known eachother for so long and are still connected! I appreciate it a lot.

Rev Left Radio

Great recs above, Id also recommend anything by Joseph Goldstein, Jack Kornfield, Pema Chodron, and Adyashanti, especially for westerners/Americans trying to get into Buddhism. Goldstein and Kornfield have their own podcasts, and Chodron and Adyashanti have good books and talks on audible. Id recommend Mindfulness and Insight by Mahasi Sayadaw as a great introduction to the practice of meditation. The Waking Up app also has a bunch of great buddhist thinkers, a wide range of guided meditation, and a whole theory side of the podcast that informs the practice side. For pure inspiration, Alan Watts and Thích Nhất Hạnh are poetic and have bunch of stuff online. Those should be a good start and jumping off point!

Rev Left Radio

Thank you! You and I are on similar paths it seems!

Rev Left Radio

Thank you for this feedback. You are SPOT ON when you say: "Communism should not be thought of as a state of social entropy where all contradictions dissolve, but rather the foundation for new and better contradictions." I totally agree. I also understand your point about dissolving the self, BUT, and this is important: you are only dissolving that false sense of a little self. When seen through, you dont become a robot or an NPC or a non-individual -- in fact, its the opposite. The uniqueness of the form that is you is amplified and extended when the small self is seen through. Your felt connection to the whole world doesnt destroy the fact that in relative terms you are an unique, individual expression of the whole. When no longer burdened by ego delusions of separateness, I think you become a more full human individual. It sounds almost paradoxical, as all relative truth juxtaposed to ultimate truth does, but its really not. Love is the ground of being when the ego is seen through. Its the ego-delusion that robs us of our interconnectedness and the love that naturally arises when we feel ourselves to be one with everyone and everything else. An unconditional love, that is deeply different from the conditional, transactional love that the ego demands. Its precisely when the false sense of self is transcended that real, universal love pours in, and you become that love. I am not enlightened and never claim to be, but after years of practice I am no less of a unique individual than I was before I started, in fact I am more in tune w the unique and natural blossoming of my being and form than I was before. But yea, I think we actually totally agree haha. and your last paragraph about your self being around you, in others, and made up of your relationships is perfectly in line with the buddhist view and the dialectial view. It stands in direct contrast to the ego sense that we are fundamentally seperate, placed in an alien world, confronting other beings who are NOT us, etc.

Rev Left Radio

Hell yea! Im a long time MM fan, and love all their shit, from the earliest to the most recent. They dont miss.

Rev Left Radio

I feel you 100%. In some cases, teachers go to great lengths to distance themselves from all ideologies, politics, and movements to focus on the core of the Buddhist tradition, but at the same time, we are all conditioned in this society by its ideological hegemony and we cant escape that or ignore it - only understand and confront it. But many people arent willing or able to do so, thus ideology always comes thru. The effective altruism movement sounds great, and they have some pitch guys that really make it seem like a movement free from ideology -- but of course its not. The FTX scandal shows how this movement is just another form liberal capitalist ideology is taking. Ive heard it be pitched as: earn as much money as you can so you can give it away and help people" but earning as much as you can in capitalism often means exploiting others, hoarding wealth, contributing to suffering, etc. So with no critique of capital, capital's rule is implicitly reinforced. Id remain very skeptical of that movement and anyone trying to marry buddhist practice to it, because it replicates the logic of capital accumulation while masquerading as selfless philanthropy.

Max

Thank you very much for taking the time and clearing this up. I have since listened to an episode about meditation and it seems to exemply this fundamental contradiction. Because on the one side it appears as a method of total seperation, first from outside impressions, and then even from yourself turning into its opposite of experiencing unity with the world. Kinda like all individuality is dependend on other people to differentiate from. 10 people on 10 lonely islands are more or less the same, all hunting coconut and buidling a shelter. 10 people on one not so lonely island and people can specialise and develop personalities. No individual without the collective.

Rob Marsh

Hi A Cooper! The podcast from Thay Thich Nhat Hanh's community in Plum Village is a great place to start, it's called "The Way Out is In" If you're interested in the fundamentals then Thay's book, "The Heart of the Buddha's Teaching" is a great starting point and should be available as an audiobook Bhikku Bodhi's lectures were also helpful to me when first trying to understand the basic concepts and ideas in Buddhism But best of all is to learn to sit and practice meditation, there are plenty of guided practices you can find which will help you get a direct experience of what is being spoken about in the writings and Sutras Best of luck on your journey!