Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Please use this comment section to ask Breht any and all questions you might have for him, and he will pick a few to respond to in upcoming patreon episodes!

We want to have an ongoing mailbag segment for the new weekly patreon episodes, so keep an eye on the patreon for these Mailbag submission posts going forward!

Thank you all so much for supporting the show,
- Breht and Dave

Comments

DD

I'm part of a couple of political groups in my city based on mutual aid and anti-racist organising. These groups are good in that they're run by principled leftists and they've been able to talk to and recruit ordinary people who weren't politically engaged before (instead of just drawing on a small pool of people who are already leftists). However, we're finding that it's difficult to engage with these new members to encourage them to get more involved- while people will come to individual actions to help with food aid or workshops to challenge border police, they don't seem to engage with running the groups or helping to plan what we will do in the future. As a result, virtually all the management, recruitment, organising and planning of these groups is done by a small cadre of communists, and we're constantly running on the edge of burnout. Do you have any advice for educating and politicising new activists so that they can see the long-term visions we have for these groups, share it and develop their own political education? We're finding some success with asking relatively new people to take part in the day-to-day running of the events so they get practical experience of organising and building local power, but it would be good to have other ideas as well.

Joseph

Have you considered doing anything by Trotsky for Red Menace? Just started a graduate program in political science and seems like Trotskyists are the majority of academic Marxists. Would love to hear more conversation between MLs and Trotskyists and to wrestle w Trotskys work from a ML or MLM perspective.

m

Would you consider doing media focused episodes in the future, maybe as patreon content? i enjoyed what you've had to say about Steven Soderberghs Che movies and Sorry to Bother You, and i would find your commentary on things such as Andor, The Last of Us, etc. to be interesting

Deven Toast

I would like to hear your thoughts on the various left organizations in the United States. DSA/CPUSA/PSL etc. In my opinion the United States is not in any position for the left to be so divided. Ideological differences are definitely something to be discussed at some point, especially amongst the higher leadership of these orgs. But most rank and file members I've met in many different orgs are similar, trying to improve material conditions and create frameworks for the future. Very committed organizers in general. I've personally seen CPUSA and DSA work together on joint actions, and wonder why there isn't more of this nationally. I also see many people online who refuse to join any organization because none of them fit their ideological niche perfectly. Or they are still arguing about figures from 100 years ago that in all reality won't fit into a Socialist United States, which would have incredibly different material conditions than any socialist country so far.

Quém é

Do you think it's possible for leftists in professions to be of use to the broader communist (ML and MLM) project in the US? This seems like a pertinent issue given how many millennial communists have been funneled into the white collar world by necessity or desperation caused by neoliberalism.

Jack Hall

Hi Breht! I love your work. I’m getting some of my friends into Communism and they seem to be catching onto the intro level theory pretty quickly. However, they often ask, “but how do we get there?” It is a broad question, but what do you tell someone who wants to know how Communism can be achieved?

spinitch

firstly, eternal love to you and all you continue to give 🙌 i struggle grappling with artistic pursuit being a strong enough role in revolutionary action. my friends and i (musicians) are extremely devoted to our crafts, push far left messages in our work and have done mutual aid efforts.. but sometimes i almost feel like it’s a cop out to avoid the front lines and more direct action. as for you, hiphop has had a perennial impact in my radicalization. participating in it, i hope to honor, spread and further evolve that art and specifically incorporate communist rhetoric. anyways, it’d be helpful to hear your meditations on the role(s) of the artist going forward, some strategies for how we might navigate (unionize?), etc. 🧡

J Hagler

Given NATO’s escalation in Ukraine, saber rattling with China, and Blinkin’s recent comments in a speech saying “no country can be neutral”; you are either with us or against us… What lessons should the left take away from the US anti war movement? What has it done right or wrong in the past and how can we mobilize in the here and now to more affectively stop the war machine?

Logan

I just wanna know what your favorite cereal is.

Brad James

Breht, your show has had a profound affect on the course of my life, and I've worked to share your stuff with as many people as I can. My question is: - What's your take on the Kennedy Assassination, in terms of both the who/how/and why, but also how the implications of the answers to those questions can shape our understanding of the American State (or deep state), and our efforts to fight against it?

Brooke Fitchett

Are you following the Atlanta Forrest situation?

John Brown Did Nothing Wrong

First of all thank you so much for all that you do. Rev Left and Red Menace have been immensely important to my political development. Thoughts on the Rage Against The War Machine Rally? I personally feel like anyone who actually knows history and is rooted in Marxist theory should know better than to ally themselves with opportunists and borderline fascists yet I saw so many people I have respect for fall for this. I’d like to hear your take and if you think my position is off it would be nice to hear your rebuttal.

Duane Barry

Breht I just want you to know that I have massive amounts of love for you and the work you’re doing. My question is about media literacy, we all understand that the U.S. is the most propagandized country in the world and it serves those with power to keep the population media illiterate. I just struggle wrapping my mind around the fact that the average person can not recognize what is propaganda and straight up bullshit. So do you think you could break down how exactly we got to that point? My worry is that people have become so alienated from each other they just don’t care.

Alexander

I would love some advice on organizing, structuring, and running theory reading groups, by and for non-academics. Maybe some resource recommendations.

DD

In your recent episode about Marxism and Buddhism, you mentioned that it can be helpful for organisers in these spaces to work to develop healthy mental states, keep their egos in check and behave ethically and compassionately towards their fellow organisers. What are 4 or 5 practical steps that organisers can take to start working on their own minds and their relationships with others?

diachectics

Listen to the Red Menace episode on Lenin's "What Is to be done?"!

Jack Hall

Thanks! Will definitely put that on the list

diachectics

Hi Breht, thanks for all your content! Could you please talk about higher-stage communism and the process of how an advanced socialist country gets closer to that? I understand the concept of the withering of the state and that the less class struggle there is, the less you'll need the proletarian state to keep advancing the revolution. And I consider myself an ML but tbh, the concept of a moneyless, stateless society sounds kind of utopian to me, or at least I think getting to that point won't be as smooth-sailing as it sounds like when we say that the state will naturally wither away. I think the closer we get to actual communism, the more we'll need to think as anarchists (which I guess makes sense) and distrust authority and be weary of corruption in the party/government. I think these issues happened in the Soviet Union (Stalin's purges didn't go far enough, lol). And it probably was also happening in China but hopefully comrade Xi's corruption purges took care of that for now. Do you know if Chinese marxists have developed more theory in this area? Also, I think it's probably not possible for any country to really get to this point while there still are powerful imperialist countries like the US trying to prevent that from happening.

Mike Sannito

First of much love to you and Dave for this show. It has had a profound impact on not just my life but the world more broadly. Just wondering if you’re aware of or following the ongoing FBI attacks on the African Peoples Socialist Party. And secondly if you had the means or connections would you consider having Chairman Omali Yeshitela on to talk about the situation, the party, and their work, to get the word out and offer solidarity and support with this struggle. Thank you comrade, uhuru!

Mike Sannito

Or having on anyone from the organization rather, chairman Omali is likely very busy

Brett

Breht, fellow Brett here. Short time listener, but in just a couple years you’ve managed to significantly broaden my political horizons. Two questions: 1) Can you do a Red Menace deep-dive on a Trotsky work? As a relatively new communist, I understand there’s a lot of bad blood with Trotsky, his body of work, and followers of his internationalist initiatives, but I don’t think anyone could argue that he wasn’t extremely impactful (especially early on) to the Bolsheviks and Russian Revolutionary movement. 2) I recently finished Trotsky’s History of the Russian Revolution and he does an excellent (in my opinion) job of delineating between insurrections, coups, and revolutions, and how any successful revolutionary movement must tie together popular movements and party organizations to be successful. Can you elaborate a bit on how this ties into why things like the J6 insurrection ultimately failed (IMO due to lack of purpose/cohesion and political leadership) and how similar movements on the left can avoid that particular fate? Also, why the need for left coalitions (not with Democrats, but maybe with DSA for example) is necessary to achieve a popular critical mass?

Danny Boy

I would love to see a series of deep dives on different socialist or "socialist" revolutions- what they got right or wrong, and what we can learn from them. Burkina Faso Peru (Shining Path) Khmer Rouge Phillipines India Ireland I'm sure I'm forgetting some.

Dylan

Just a kinda random thought on the mail bag concept….would you ever consider creating a sort of FAQ-type catalog or document? I frequently find myself wanting to comment with questions about what your take would be on a given (likely elementary) concept, but I talk myself out of it, assuming you’ve probably already addressed that thought somewhere in the backlog (of which I missed the first couple years). I, personally, would love some kinda of page or document to skim through, with maybe links to past episodes, when a given concept I got stuck on seems likely to have been addressed already. It also seems like it could maybe help unclog your incoming messages, or at least make it easier to address many of them (eg. “see our FAQ”). I already use the tags and keywords for the episodes to sift through the back catalog, but there are plenty of topics I’m certain you must have addressed and I just can’t seem to search the right words to find them. Anyway…big fan of the show. Got a rev left shirt that’s getting pretty worn out. Saw they weren’t on the ‘means’ store anymore. But I want that shit whenever it becomes available again.

VaguelyLeftist

It’s commonly said that it’s easier to imagine the end of the world than it is the end of capitalism. How do we make it easier to imagine a world without capitalism? It seems the working class has lost hope in any form of revolution, and that reform is the only way to survive. It seems as though the political and economic machinery of the bourgeoisie is far too large to overcome.

Melissa

adjacent to a suggestion up thread re: pop culture analysis, would love more episodes with and about fiction writers, film makers, artists, musicians that are making radical, leftist, class-conscious art. I personally find fictional storytelling to be a really helpful tool in getting my mind around complex concepts and it can often be the springboard for me to engage deeper with theory and a really amazing tool for activating political imagination. I've loved the past episodes you've done on these topics. This is also on my mind because The Last of Us is driving me nuts thematically (anti-human, anti-collective, libertarian fantasy) and I recently listened to Chris Hayes interview China Mieville and was very annoyed by it - I just kept thinking how much better it would be if Breht was doing the interview, lol.

Daewoo

Hey so I want to ask kind of out of left field question, but I've always had a urge to ask it. Someone else commented about the Rage Against the War Machine rally and someone involved with that was Roger Waters, the former Pink Floyd member. And I'd like to know your take on him, his music, and his activism. He's one of the few ultra famous people that has correct take on Ukraine, is very pro Palestine, to his own detriment sometimes. He also critiqued Bernie Sanders back in 2020 when I was on that hype train. So, are you aware of his activism and the music of Pink Floyd? Particularly the police of Dark Side of the Moon, Animals, The Wall, and The Final Cut. Thanks and keep it up!

Daewoo

And just to add, because the first comment wasn't long enough, Waters isn't a Marxist by any means and also talks positively about Orwell, but then takes Orwell's animal classifications from Animal Farm and turns them into a commentary on neoliberal Thatcherism. He's more anti-war and pro-human rights than anything which leaves a lot to be desired, but he still seems to have a more grounded understanding of the world than the typical ultra wealthy musician/celebrity. I mean he advocates for China to reunify the island of Taiwan! But again, he's not a commie, so...

MLDad

Dude you should be getting prosthetics for the other two

Alex Pollard

Preface: this is kinda complex topic and sorry for the wall of text Breht :) We find ourselves living in a time where capitalism is butting up against the finite limits of the earth/biosphere. Renewable energy is often green washed as a magic bullet solution to the transition away from fossil fuels, but emerging research is demonstrating the flaws of this reasoning. Research published by Simon Michaux for example shows that there are not enough rare earth materials (lithium, cobalt, copper, nickel etc.) for even one generation of renewable energy production to supplant that done currently by fossil fuels (more realistically there are enough viable resources to build the infrastructure to generate about half of current energy production). As is the nature of imperialism, these increasingly scarce resources won’t be equitably distributed to the global south. It's often said capitalism in the face of terminal crisis will yield either to socialism or barbarism. Given how integral food security has been to prior proletarian revolution, the global south is likely to first be affected. As one component of many, what do you think would be the flash point for these revolutionary conditions? Fossil fuel/natural gas inputs in nitrogen fertilizer becoming more difficult to produce, soil degradation from industrial farming, water scarcity etc. What do you think the dialectics/contradictions of these destabilizing effects of energy and resource scarcity (compounded by climate change of course) shaping the overarching material conditions under which we will be building the left project?

m

coming back late again to ask another question, or maybe its not much of a question. i try my best not to fall into revolutionary pessimism, but this article shook my optimism extremely deeply. i have been acutely aware that the US left has been deeply damaged especially since the '70s, but this article put just how out-organized we are by the far right into sharp relief. this, more so than even the tepid responses by the left (not to discount the work done by left organizers in these areas) to issues facing us regarding anti-trans policy and growing genocidal sentiment, or the furthering of the war in ukraine, and the continuing heightening of warmongering with china, has really shaken my belief that we could even begin to effectively organize against the rising fascist right. how do we even begin to equal their level of organization? i'm terrified that it's insurmountable. https://www.vanityfair.com/news/2023/02/new-right-civil-war

Seth Dalton

Hi Breht, I think I remember you saying you were feeling a bit inundated by guest recommendations, but wondering if you've ever considered bringing on Saito Kohei. He's someone I've gotten to know a bit while living in Tokyo (a genuinely nice and gracious person), and I think his ideas resonate well with your own. His latest book has touched off a bit of controversy about if there can even be such a thing as a degrowth version of Marxism.

Tobs

I see there are already a couple of Trotsky requests… I know he is a figure you are probably not super into and I know many of your guests have dunked on him before but it would be interesting to hear you wrestle with some of his ideas. I think a couple full episodes would be great on the topic. One episode could include having ML folks on to have a good faith critique of Trotsky. Another episode with a Trotskyist giving Trotsky the full treatment he deserves. Akin to the Stalin episode. As both a fan of Trotsky and this show that would be incredibly interesting to me.

Dave Lunn

Is the ASU speech available anywhere online?

Dave Lunn

Oh damn I don't know how I missed that. Thanks!

KungFuKenny

I second this inquiry, and I am curious where Breht has mentioned ‘Sorry to Bother You’ and similar titles?

Hasani Gunn

Would you be open to connecting with some economics faculty at Bard College for future episodes on heterodox economics for listeners unfamiliar with the material? I did my BA in Econ there and am still in touch with faculty. I think folks could really benefit from getting a crash course in a part of academia that’s sadly (and strangely) far out of the mainstream.

Benny Boy

Hi Breht, I'm not sure on the current podcast approach to suggestions from supporters (especially in relation to issues discussed in the UK rather than the USA) but i would be interested on your thoughts on this Conservative feminist thinker's (if this is not an oxymoron) take on the current state of feminism in the same way you gave your thoughts on that China 'expert's' opinion recently. Check out this Podcast: Why 'Progress' is Bad for Women - Mary Harrington https://player.fm/1BVNqnr.

Keelan Swift

Hi Breht, I hope you are well! After hearing you mention White Noise a few times, I have just started reading Underworld by Don DeLillo. Are there any other fiction writers/books that you would recommend?

Rev Left Radio

I may answer this on air, but a few quick recs: Kafka on the Shore by Murakami Three Body Problem by Liu Cixin anything by Cormac McCarthy (The Road, Blood Meridian, etc.)

Kevin Garlick

Hey man idk if you've been following Cameron Maupin lately but he's hanging out with the actual Larouche Institute and citing Lyndon Larouche as one of his top 3 (Karl Marx didn't even make the cut). Also videos about Larouchian gangs cropped up on YouTube literally a day ago. I don't really know how any of this patreon stuff works hope you get this. That was a great episode btw might be time to make more. Edit: here's a link of that Larouche channel btwhttps://youtu.be/J9Oz-QZQvbI

Keelan Swift

Awesome, thanks so much. I will give them a go 😊

Seany G

I hope this response is not so much after the original that it will go down into a rabbit hole and be lost in space. Nevertheless, I would like to second that emotion! There are several good Trotskyists who can explain the basic tenets of Trotskyism without getting into dogmatism. Yes, there have been/ still are a lot of splits within Trotskyism itself, but that is perhaps why it's so important to sort it out - they are often based on fundamental questions of strategy. I heard one episode on Guerrilla History, from October 2021 with Prof. August Nimtz, in which he discussed electoral strategy in Leninism. He was billed by Henry H. (in a later episode) as a Trotskyist, but there was no mention of Trotsky at all. So it would be good to have a targeted episode.

Seany G

[I'm not sure how this platform organizes new replies to old comments: whether it posts them at the top of this section as a recent post (and therefore more likely to be read) or posts them next to the original, tucked in hidden sections (where you have to click "Load Reply" in order to see it and therefore easily overlooked). In case it's the latter, I'm referencing it as a response to Tobin Mitchell's post 1 month ago in a new comment. Apologies in advance...]

Seany G

While I'm on the computer, I would also like to make another suggestion. I recently heard your Intelligence briefing unlocked episode on religion on Guerrilla History. It was excellent, objectively speaking, of course! Coincidentally, immediately afterward, I heard an interview with Tricia Hersey, the "Nap Bishop," who talked about similar themes of what it is to be human, and how capitalism robs us of our humanity. I know, I know: it sounds dorky (napping as resistance) but here is the link to the interview, AND the transcript of some of the 1st 20 minutes or so. If you doubt the author's revolutionary perspective, skim through what she says. Here are a couple of her quotes: "I believe in saying to the systems [of] white supremacy, capitalism, patriarchy, ableism, all the systems that really degrade our humanity and degrade our divinity, and don't see us as human beings, [that] we can push back and disrupt against them.." AND "I believe that these toxic and violent systems are brilliant. They are fast-paced, they are flexible, they are inventive, they are subversive, they are imaginative and they use all of these different powers to be able to continue to keep us oppressed and suppressed about who we really are. And so I think that the system has done a really good job of making us hate ourselves, and that it's really stripped the culture of their self worth." She develops more anti-capitalist arguments, but they're not in the transcripts (e.g. @ 12:30mins). https://www.cbc.ca/radio/tapestry/the-nap-bishop-explains-why-rest-is-a-form-of-radical-resistance-1.6797668