Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

Professor Matt McManus returns to Rev Left to talk about his newest book, a collection of essays from various authors that he put together and edited titled "Nietzsche and the Politics of Reaction: Essays on Liberalism, Socialism, and Aristocratic Radicalism".

Together they discuss the book, the philosophy of Friedrich Nietzsche, his actual political beliefs, ways in which he has been sanitized or misinterpreted, what he thought of socialism and Christianity, how the political left and right get Nietzsche wrong, what the left can actually learn from him, the Death of God and the various forms of Nihilism it has generated, and much more!  

Check out more of McManus' work HERE 

Pre-order Matt's upcoming book HERE 

Files

Comments

Max

Great episode, love the poetic ending. Nietzsche’s historical class background is also very interesting. For a long time, Germany had been relatively backwards compared to France and England. National unification came very late (in the 1870s) and the petty bourgeoisie has always played (and still plays) a more important role here than in other countries. At the time of unification the main ideological current was still the rather passive Biedermeier, which was apolitical, small-minded and with a modest religiosity. After the expansion of the imperial core to include Germany and a rapid industrialization, the newly formed German nationstate suddenly found itself as the strongest economy in Europe, but without a corresponding empire. Nietzsche appears right during this time, as Germany shifted towards a more aggressive imperialist stance and needed to shed the ideologies it had outgrown. And because Germany had not “grown” to be a big empire, but had to assert itself, there is a big focus on sentiments such as the will to power, decisive action and disregard for the established world order. The two violent attempts of Germany to rectify this imbalance are forever etched into everyone’s mind as well as this cursed bloody soil. Of course, there are different ideological offers for different stratas, as there were still a lot of religious people. Nietzsche in particular captures young intellectuals who fell through the first bourgeois net, by offering a possible way to defend their own privileges under the edgy guise of a rebellious pose. At university, it is often said that Nietzsche cannot be a fascist because he was not an antisemite (or a consistent racist), but I think that is taking fascism too seriously. The thing is, jews are not truly an inferior race, therefore one should not expect consistency among racists. Whoever is targeted depends on the imperialist strategy and at Nietzsche’s time it had not yet fully crystallized for the German empire to seek its colonies in Eastern Europe. Its early politics were still occupied with internal struggles against Catholicism and nascent socialism, therefore you get the abstract slave race. Nietzsche certainly isn’t a complete fascist as he lacks the mass appeal (in fact he explicitly rejects it), but he provides a potent ideological basis for the fascist leaders, the fascist aristocracy in a sense. Also, as intellectuals tend to come from the petty bourgeoisie, their ideal conception is usually not a corporate dictatorship per se. Instead, less edgy characters than Nietzsche tend to champion a kind of Harry Potter/ Stardew Valley parallel universe, where only the petty bourgeoisie exists, everyone has property and can pursue a craftsmanship as well as authentic relationships within a small community; all while the fruits of industrial labour magically appear on the market shelves. That’s why they tend to critique modernity and often brandish some kind of romantic anti-capitalism. You can see that even more pronounced in Heidegger, whose “anti-capitalism” focusses much more on the productive forces (technology) outcompeting “authentic” petty bourgeois labour than on the exploitative relations of production. Like how every NFT/crypto-bro today desires nothing more than to be a petty landlord themselves, instead of truly changing the system. Nietzsche still is a genius, but one that should be handled with care as his works can flatter a reactionary impulse in those that tend to come across him, i.e. dissident intellectuals. His personal tragedy reflects this conflicting nature very well.

Meletios

Well written, thank you for this context.

From The River To The Sea 🇵🇸

Great episode! Bret, what are some good beginner resources to learn about the basics of philosophy? I’ve been desiring lately to get a better handle on philosophy as a whole.

KB

Speaking of Quakerism, you should check out “The Fearless Life of Banjamin Lay” by Marcus Rediker. Reads quick and covers the life of a radical English Quaker who was a revolutionary abolitionist, author, vegan, and guerrilla performer in the early 18th century. He called out the wealthy Quaker merchants leading Philadelphia, and disrupted Quaker meetings that became increasingly compromising to slavery. He lived in a cave and produced his own food. He also happened to be a dwarf, so he combated ableism as well.

Rev Left Radio

90 Minute Philosophy series by Paul Strathern is great. Its on audible and probably other places, covers every major philosophers bio and major ideas, and is a great introductory doorway into philosophy.

Gaige

Hey, Breht! Completely off topic, but I remember you saying that you read Patreon comments, so I will put this here and keep it short. By the grace of god I managed to get a job as a public union organizer in Northern California, specifically in Shasta County. The reason I am reaching out this time is that it looks like our largest (over 800 employee) bargaining unit is going to go on strike soon. This is the lowest paid bargaining unit in the County consisting of Eligibility Workers, Office Assistants, Community Health Advocates, etc. I could go into detail about how conservative Shasta County is and the make up of the Board being complete reactionaries. I'm positive if you google Shasta County you will get a good idea. I could also explain to you how utterly screwed the workers are at the moment. If they settled with the County at their final offer, it would lead to a 9% pay cut for our lowest paid without even factoring in inflation. When you factor in the money that comes out of their checks for insurance and retirement, a lot of them are taking home less than California's minimum wage. It is quite dire here. Long story short, if we go on strike, could you shout out our GoFundMe? We have a savings account for a strike stipend however we are looking at the numbers and realizing we need more. If you would like more information, please message me here or you can email me at meyergaige@gmail.com. If you can't shout out the GoFundMe when the time comes, that's okay! I'm just trying to help our union with outreach.

Rev Left Radio

Absolutely will help when/if you go on strike! My personal email is andersonbrett2011@gmail.com, if you want to hmu if/when you are ready for my hellp! Solidarity fr.

Joy

What’s the outro song?