Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

(Lmk what you think about this as a patreon offering in the comments please. Is seeing the outline of an upcoming episode interesting / worthwhile to you?)


Context and Methodology:

- This is a work of Marxist historical materialism, as you say in the introduction of the text. Our audience will certainly be familiar with historical and dialectical materialism, but for those who are still learning: Can you remind us what historical materialism is, why you applied it to the life and story of Jesus Christ, and why its important to reject the Great Man Theory of history as Historical Materialists?

- Given this is a work of historical materialism, it is obviously important to try and grasp Jesus as an actually existing historical figure, which in itself can be difficult and even controversial. So, did he even exist (some atheists claim he didn’t), and how do we know?

o The gospels play an essential part in trying to understand the life of jesus, but they themselves have inconsistencies, were written by different people at different times, rely on different sources, etc. So how should we understand and relate to the gospels as sources of historical events, and what important differences exist between the gospels and their authors (especially Mark vs. Luke and Matthew vs. John / Synoptics v. John)?

Jesus, His Movement, and First Century Palestine:

- What mode of production existed in Jesus’ time, what were the major classes, the dominate political structures, and how was class conflict manifesting at this time?

- Can you talk about Jesus’ childhood and the context into which he was born and raised and how that shaped him?

- In chapter three you focus on John the Baptist as a famous millenarian figure and sort of ideological mentor. Who was John the Baptist, and what role did he play in the life of Jesus?

- In the book you argue: “for a first century non-elite Jew like Jesus, there were two obvious and related options available for framing or interpreting social, economic, and political discontent and antagonism is rural Galilee: Jewish Millenarianism and Banditry”. Can you tell us what those terms mean, how they related to one another, and then tell us how Jesus was a “revolutionary millenarian”?

- Can you talk about the Jesus Movement (which you refer to as vanguard party of sorts in your book), its revolutionary as well as its reactionary aspects, and what its aims and tactics were?

- In chapter 9, “Passover in Jerusalem”, you talk about entering Jerusalem, the temple, the Last Supper, and the “defection of a comrade” referring to Judas. Can you talk about these events and summarize this part of the story?

- All of this inevitably resulted in a brutal crackdown on the Jesus Movement and the eventual crucifixion of Jesus. Can you talk about Jesus’ crucifixion and martyrdom, what happened after, and how the movement evolved after Jesus’ death?

- What is the ultimate legacy of Jesus and the Jesus Movement and how has it shaped the world that we live in today?

Comments

Rev Left Radio

Note: in actual conversation I may add questions, skip questions, phrase things differently, etc. But I make a basic outline like this for every episode and use it to shape and guide discussion.

Dakota

I'm sure you've come across it while researching this topic, but in case you haven't, there's a great book on this subject called Class Struggle in the New Testament, edited by Robert J. Myles

Josh Green

Very interested in hearing this episode and love seeing the notes.

Joe Brown

I really enjoy reading your questions/notes. It helps give perspective on your process

Saya Clarke

Absolutely this topic is deeply interesting and valuable to me. Understandably a lot of comrades have a sort of Christophobia and would balk at the suggestion that there is anything to learn about class struggle from the life of Jesus of Nazareth. But for me personally, having grown up in the southern US, I still find meaning in Jesus’ message of love and compassion and have only began to consider how it might intersect with Marxism because of this very podcast. So yes! I look forward to this and seeing a preliminary outline of the episode feels awesome!

big al

very interesting, and yeah i love seeing an outline

Joseph

I think releasing outlines is great. It can provide an easy structure for taking notes on an episode that is particularly complex or important to somebody

Daewoo

I love seeing outlines or other foundational works for whatever media I consume. I think this is really great for podcasts and especially yours because when you talk with guests I feel like I can sense (when you don't point it out) when you ask a question not in an outline, or are forced to choose among whichever remaining questions you have. I get quite a curious thought about what's left in the outline. It's also valuable so those of us that do our own investigation (can't be me) into whatever subject or work is covered and can get a better sense of the takeaways and questions you yourself had and they can serve as a kind of basis for a better understanding.

Keelan Swift

Definitely interesting and worthwhile!

Matt Wiggins

I think it would be valuable to post a brief outline/synopsis of a show before actually listening. Gives the listener something of a teaser and expectations of the content. (Plus it’s no extra work for you!) “it is easier for a camel to go through the eye of a needle than for someone who is rich to enter the kingdom of God.” A whole lotta “Christians” like to gloss over that passage these days…

Teri

It's super worthwhile to see! For me personally, it makes me a lot more interested in the episode and usually, knowing what to (roughly) expect next and having a structure to 'follow' also makes it easier for me to keep paying attention whilst listening. And besides that, i also just in general love to see the process behind things i.e. how episodes come into being.

Rashad Duckett

I love this I’ve written sermons and have always given testimony about Jesus being a class struggle revolutionary.

Landis Brown

I was hoping you’d cover this one

Gabriel Ellison-Scowcroft

This is great! And a nice way to prepare to listen & get curious about what the guest is going to say. This is an unsolicited question, but I’d be curious to hear the guest talk about the links between the severing of Jesus’ revolutionary legacy from the historical record & how his teachings are so often used towards reactionary ends today, particularly in the US. Maybe that will come up organically anyway, but either way stoked for the episode!

Joan Guenther

Grew up in a working class home w a devout catholic father who often pointed out that Jesus was a socialist … so often and in so many relevant settings that we regularly received a home visit from the parish priests bearing a warning delivered to my parents in front of their seven children that their offspring would grow up to be communist and doomed in the manner only Irish Catholics can be doomed. The priest would be offered tea and a cookie would leave satisfied and my dad and the kids enjoy fifteen minutes of various forms of comradely eye roll. Worried my mom a bit.

Rev Left Radio

Nice, he is one of the authors who i interviewed for this episode actually! Will def wanna have him back on at some point.

Rev Left Radio

It def came up in the episode (we recorded last night). Maybe not in the depth youd ideally want, but we def touched on it, and i want to have one or both authors back on to talk more about exactly that.

Let’s go

Love getting to see the outline prior. Excited for the ep!

rock man

I’ve been waiting for an episode like this. Have you read Jesus and the Disinherited by Howard Thurman?

Rev Left Radio

I have not! Sounds very interesting though. Ill go check it out now!

Ian

Outline is cool; bibliography of anything read in preparation for the episode would be even better!

Jonathan Wood

This is very helpful and has me very excited for this episode in particular. I grew up in a very religious household and went to church every Sunday and have read the bible several times in my youth. I no longer consider myself religious (but I am in a constant exploration of non-religious spirituality) but took a few religion courses in the liberal arts university I attended (they approached Christianity from a historical perspective) and found them fascinating. I've always been intrigued by Jesus the revolutionary historical figure and would love to see him explored through a Marxist lens!

Alex De Marco

Left AF and still devout Catholic. The worldview that truly internalized every person as created in the image and likeness of God, if pressed to be politically applied, will invariably turn very sharp left. Nobody who is truly a disciple of Christ could see what is happening in the USA and not see the evil and suffering being wrought upon the backs of the very people our Lord tells us to prioritize. He doesn't tell us to give them spare change or soup. He calls on us to lift them up, and acknowledge our own role, our own selfishness, that contributes to their suffering. Nobody wants to digest that part. We are responsible for it as well, and we must atone.

Joedie Sawyer

Definitely an interesting topic! Our society is so influenced by Jesus, and so many people I know are, on so many levels, would love to learn more from a left perspective!

Adam Virga

Can’t wait for this episode