Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

In this patreon exclusive, Breht discusses the full-spectrum assault on Trans people, their basic existence, and their human rights, then he discusses the US electoral spectacle and how most americans hate both parties and their candidates, then he responds to a bad review of the podcast which scoffed at the idea that the US is a white supremacist society...


Contrapoints response to the Witch Trials of JK Rowling here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EmT0i0xG6zg&ab_channel=ContraPoints

Files

Comments

DancerXfox

❤️ Masterful timing. Now I can listen while I work. ^^ thank you for this

Quinn

LETS GOOOOOOOO

Saya Clarke

Thank you so much for this Breht I can’t express how happy it makes me to hear you speak out on this issue. I struggled with drug abuse and alcoholism through my teenage years and my twenties. I was raised in a strict conservative home, adopted by white parents after being taken from my mother by CPS as a baby (I am mixed Mexican/Native). I struggled with my identity, my skin color, my sexuality and my gender to the point of suicide attempts and my father being physically and mentally abusive didn’t help either. I didn’t feel safe speaking to my parents about my struggles, about being bullied at school for my voice and my comportment. After many years of being ground down continually by societal expectations and becoming homeless and dependent on heroin use, I finally decided to face some harsh truths and really contemplated my mind and my existence and came to the conclusion that I am bisexual and transgender. I cannot tell you how quickly my life turned around once I finally accepted those things and started to live authentically. I overcame my drug addiction, got good employment and a new place of my own with all the responsibilities that comes with that. It changed my whole frame of reference for life and what is possible for me and what my values are. Despite all the hatred, the vitriol and the constant attacks on us, I would never go back in the closet. Death before detransition as they say. I am happier than I’ve ever been since I made the decision to finally be myself a couple of years ago. When people say gender-affirming care saves lives, that is real and it is the truth. Jules Gill-Peterson said something that resonated with me recently. She said “Transition is self-abolition” and I believe that. If you want to create a better world, ask a trans person how that world should look and they will most likely have some very good answers for you. Excellent episode! Thanks again Breht for all you do.

Seamus

Breht, I am saying this is in a constructive and kind way and I believe this needs to be said. The reason a lot of Gen-z leftists are weary about the transgender issue is because we have noticed a rise in trans-trenders at school and in social media. Quite a few young women who are fully female presenting (long hair, dresses, makeup, etc) are getting mastectomies and testosterone, who did not present any symptoms of body dysmorphia during childhood or were not even “tomboys”. There is no concern in the evaluation process for other traumas or pathologies which could cause difficulty around one’s body. However, I support individuals in the trans community who are truly trans and experience body dysmorphia. I have followed trans stories like Jazz Jennings who experienced symptoms of body dysmorphia as child. I support transgender people, but I and many gen-z individuals who are LGBT are concerned about people who are getting transgender treatment without sufficient evaluation. There is an unfortunate rise in de-transitioners. I am coming from an informed position and one of empathy and respect, not of hate or reaction.

Andrew Davis

Thanks for this Breht. The hysteria is reaching astronomical proportions now and we're approaching genocidal rhetoric against trans. Last month I went in support of a drag queen reading against these bigots. I agree with your assessment of the situation. I had to go even if I don't really get or understand being LGBT. What I do know is that they are under attack and we need to step up. I imagine myself in this situation if I was under threat. I'd hate it and I'd defend myself. I fear we'll see more vigilante attacks among the legal genocide being planned. That quote about first they came for the communists, is especially resonate. I don't hesitate for one second knowing these people would come for me and my family should they get their way

Saya Clarke

not to be rude but you are just wrong about some of the stuff here. first off, it is incredibly rare, less than a hundred a year if even that, for a minor to receive a masectomy. i don’t know if this is where you got the info butt matt walsh spouted this nonsense on the joe rogan podcast and got fact checked immediately proving he was wrong. on top of that, for the few masectomies that do happen, not all of them are related to transition. some are done for other medical reasons unrelated. surgery like this on a minor is gatekept by medical institutions near to the point of impossibility and requires consenting parents and this would be after months, most likely years of hormone treatment and therapy before a doctor will even entertain the idea of a masectomy on a minor. there is a pervasive myth that a kid can just walk into a clinic at 16 and get their dick or boobs cut off on day one but that’s a right wing fascist lie spread by the NYT. i also take issue with the framing of “rise of detransitioners” the NYT love to elevate voices of these few astroterfed people who are trying to scare the public into believing there is a crisis but in reality 97% of people who transition are perfectly happy and do not experience regret, the research is out there if you look. don’t listen to matt walsh or the NYT. and lastly, i could be wrong about this because i haven’t looked (it seems obvious), but i’m pretty sure gen z is more unapologetically supportive of trans and other LGBTQ+ people than any other demographic.

Seamus

Hi respectfully, I am worried anyone who could be rushed into transition, I don't listen to Matt Walsh, I just worry about people who may experience body dysmorphia for a variety of reasons or who will grow out of it. Allegedly, 90% of children with body dysmorphia grow out of it, many of whom are LGB children who don't fit gender roles. Are you concerned at all about gender affirming care? From my knowledge doctors or psychologists aren't entirely questioning reasons for body dysmorphia such as trauma or simply not fitting in gender roles as a cis person. I am here in a place of concern for LGBT people who might regret this process, but I support people happy with their decision.

Brad James

I also listened at work this morning, thanks for that, Breht! I did notice that there doesn't seem to be any audio for the third segment from about 00:50:43 to 01:06:46 in the version that I got. That seems to be the case in the Patreon audio above as well. Anyone else having this issue?

Saya Clarke

Breht makes the point about letting children experiment with identities and as he says there is nothing wrong with that. And as I said doctors are not handing out surgeries hormones like candy so no, I don’t believe that kids are being rushed into transitioning (that is a right-wing talking point)as gender affirming care for minors always involves consulting with therapists to address issues like trauma, depression and anxiety. Again, only after months to years of extensive therapy and doctor meetings and with the parents involved, do kids get the opportunity to try hormones. Also, body dysmorphia doesn’t happen because children are depressed or traumatized, in fact it is the opposite. Body dysmorphia leads to these symptoms. Doctors who are specialists know this to be true and are actively thinking about these things. You will not find a legitimate medical association (a lot of the ones presented by republicans in court are fake institutions specifically made to sound authoritative) that doesn’t recommend gender affirming care for minors who are experiencing severe body dysmorphia and symptoms that are related to that dysmorphia. I understand that you have concern but ultimately the decision to transition should at the end of the day be between that person and their doctor. Other people(especially cis) shouldn’t be weighing in on wether or not they think someone is ready, or should be allowed to transition. I can tell you are a good person so if you genuinely want to learn more about trans people and the economy of health surrounding gender affirming care in the US I recommend the Death Panel podcast. They have a trans woman on their panel and focus specifically on this topic and various other medical related commentary like disability studies and stuff like that. I recommend the episode The Gray Lady vs Trans Life. It is a patreon episode but they recently unlocked it and they have many more episodes that are related in their catalogue.

Brad James

Seems to be fixed now. Thanks Breht and Dave!

Rev Left Radio

Beautiful and tragic story, but I am so happy to hear you found your way out and are living authentically and happily - free from addiction and homelessness. I send all my love and solidarity, Saya. <3

Seamus

I'll take a look at that podcast. From anecdotal examples like interviews, some detransitioners say they are victims of negligence. They went to do the doctor, received a referral to gender clinic and then at the follow up appointment they received hormones that day, no psychological consideration. Some people would say that gender clinics do hand out hormones like candy. Doctors in the US already hand out antidepressants, antibiotics, opioids, benzos like candy. I don't think it is the job of society to decide whether transitioning is possible. But it is the job of society to make sure medical negligence does not take place.

Rev Left Radio

I appreciate both of you being sincere and mature in this back and forth. As I said in the episode, it is okay not to understand everything and to have genuine questions and concerns. Its our ability to ask and respond in good faith and comradely respect - while always centering our defense of the humanity of trans people - that elevates this conversation away from the hate and vitriol and misinformation that define these discussions in the mainstream culture (NYT, Rogan, etc.). Thank you both for engaging here in the mature way you are, I appreciate it.

Christopher Noble

Appreciate and agree with your perspectives around the lack of anything close to principled leftist electoral options. Curious your thoughts, Breht, on the Workers Strike Back movement lead by Kshama Sawant out of Seattle. She would be a super interesting guest for a future podcast!

Tyler Pollitt

Love your response to the bad review you received regarding the US being a white supremacist country. I encounter so many folks whom dismiss white supremacy in the American context for the reasons you addressed here, often it comes from those who don’t want to look reality in the face, not from any serious analysis on the issue.

Quinn

gen z leftist here and your analysis does not line up with mine. I have only ever seen my peers become more joyful, present, and generally healthier after they transitioned or began their steps in that direction. Do you know how much a mastectomy costs in the US? Not exactly something done on a whim without conversation. And as other have said the happenstance of these things you brought up are minimal. Speaking from my work in archaeology now though, trans people (including children) have always existed. In the material remains we have found so many cases of a spectrum of genders and identities in the ancient and near past. We have found bodies of "anatomically male" skeletons with all the skeletal and cultural remains of what is typically thought of as "womanly" or associated with the "anatomically female". There are also many peoples that we have documented that have no gender binary. Not to mention the wide array of intersex people that exist. Trans history is deep and so so interesting, but we are so blinded by the conversations of today when we discuss and conceptualize them (and again, a group that is minuscule and would not like to have their existence be part of public debate). You reference a lot of interviews or "people have said" type stuff but that kind of just doesnt cut it and actual references to what you have said are sparse. I can find the archaeological and anthropological papers ive mentioned for you. And like the other person said, it is tremendously hard to get any type of gender conforming care, especially as a minor. Maybe there are outliers like you have alluded to, but outliers are outliers for a reason. But yeah like i said, were both gen z here, and if that is the basis for our analysis, going off those around me i have not seen one case of regret or detransition. Especially in those who seek gender affirming care. Many of those closest to me would fall under this category, and again i have only seen them flourish in the people they are, when theyre allowed to be who they are.

NukaDirtbag

You're more generous to Contrapoints than I would be but that was actually her best video in a long time

Saya Clarke

One last thing and I will stop I promise. Here is a link to a study but just some of the relevant info presented here, “in the UK a survey of 3398 attendees of a gender identity clinic found that just sixteen – about 0.47% – experienced transition-related regret. Of these, even fewer went on to actually detransition and become detransitioners.” As for the US, “In the US, a survey of nearly 28,000 people found that 8% of respondents reported some kind of detransition. Of this 8%, 62% per cent only did so temporarily due to societal, financial, or family pressures..” This (https://www.gendergp.com/detransition-facts/)source also scrutinizes other studies that find detransition rates to be higher and finds their methodology to be flawed and addresses the fact that this has lead to false impressions about how common detransitioners actually are. And to learn more about how this is all connected to a moral panic surrounding trans people with the detransitioner myth playing a large role in that, I recommend Khadija Mbowe’s video where she also cites this study and other sources related to this topic as well as destroys the myth(and other myths) that doctors are overprescribing hormones. You can find that video here: https://youtu.be/eAy-s0h2i-8 Okay I’m done. Thanks for talking in good faith on this subject.

Max

"The Hunger" is so good tho

Seamus

This is a reply to Quinn I can't see if it's a reply to the entire thread. I believe real trans people exist and of course have existed since the neolithic age. The issue is not the existence of trans people, the issue is the medical context in which there could be negligence. Social trends exists and so do problematic situations in the medical field. It's not a debate, it's more of a questioning, we can agree as leftists it's important to analyze social phenomena. There was an instance where young women's uteri were removed for hysteria. There is also a history of treatment of mentally ill people which we would now consider unethical. There is also a history of trends among teens, cutting and anorexia spread by contagion. In my own personal observation which is anecdotal, a lot of former straight women exist on gay dating apps. Girls who appear completely feminine are transitioning to male. One can say gender and sex are not connected, but this simply is not true. It may sound harsh, but is not surprising when a butch woman transitions to male or feminine male transitions to female. But when people who exhibit no symptoms of cross dressing as a child, exhibit no opposite gender characteristics growing up, transition to the opposite gender, it is concerning. Body dysmorphia is more common among young cis women, some hate the uncomfortable experience of having a period, uncomfortable with their breasts, or perhaps dislike the experience of the male gaze and attempt to escape those experiences. It's not a conversation of whether trans should exist, it's a conversation of whether rapid onset gender dysphoria exists, is social contagion or social media a factor? Is there medical negligence? Could gender dysphoria be caused by trauma or discomfort during puberty? I think many people in the LGBT community agree but are too afraid to say something, why are there so many more ftms compared to mtfs? I believe in the future we will see more ftm detransitioners.

Saya Clarke

I know I said I would stop but I can't help but to call out your response here Seamus. Your language and framing here comes across as (probably unintentionally) problematic, uninformed and some of it is frankly horrifying. "Social trends exists and so do problematic situations in the medical field." - If you're equating trans people transitioning to a "social trend" then I think you need to rethink what you think trans people actually are. Replace the word Trans with Gay and you can see how framing it this way is problematic. If you accept that trans people have always existed, have you considered that more people are transitioning because they feel safe enough to openly declare themselves as trans? Same for gay people, if you were around in the 80s one might say "There are more people coming out as gay then ever before and that is a trend that people are following. There have never been this many gay people." This would be similar to your use of the term "transtrenders" which I have only heard a certain conservative youtuber use this phrase. People didn't follow a trend of becoming gay because everyone else was doing it. Gayness was inside of them and Gay Liberation allowed people to freely explore that part of themselves and come out of the closet. Thus, the rise in gay people is illusory. "There was an instance where young women's uteri were removed for hysteria. There is also a history of treatment of mentally ill people which we would now consider unethical" -I don't think you can compare people transitioning to the violence inflicted on on women by pathologically insane men. These women didn't choose these treatments, it was forced upon them. Activists fought and shed blood to stop these practices. This also applies to people who were taken forcibly against their will, locked up in institutions by a state apparatus that believed them to be a threat or frankly, just an eyesore to society. Again, activists fought to deinstitutionalize our system and in the end, institutionalization ended more because fiscal austerity than anything else. So to compare people choosing of their own free will to transition with hormones and/or surgery to people who had violence forcibly inflicted upon them is ghoulish. "There is also a history of trends among teens, cutting and anorexia spread by contagion." -Honestly it makes me ill to read this sentence. I don't know enough on these subjects specifically to say whether or not social scientists consider these things to be "spread by contagion," but frankly to even imply that trans people and transitioning is spreading like a contagion is disgusting. There is a tweet trending right this very minute where Ben Shapiro also says LGBTQ+ people are a social contagion so you are in bad company on that one. You are comparing transitioning, a beautiful and harmonizing, euphoric experience for most people (As I demonstrated in my previous post) to teenagers cutting and starving themselves. You need to rethink this unfortunately. It is culturally common to think that teens who are cutting or anorexic are doing it for attention in some misguided way. I don't know how true this is personally but again, if the implication is that people come out as transgender for attention then you need to stop and think about how wild that sounds. Attention you will get, absolutely. But it won't be the good kind. It won't be pity, or gentle counseling and intervention. It will be the entire country trying to eradicate you from existence through legislation, hateful rhetoric and physical violence and being looked upon as a freak of nature, abhorrent to even lay eyes upon, a disgrace to God and Nature. It is unrealistic, to put it lightly, that a person would come out as transgender because they want people to like them. "It may sound harsh, but is not surprising when a butch woman transitions to male or feminine male transitions to female. But when people who exhibit no symptoms of cross dressing as a child, exhibit no opposite gender characteristics growing up, transition to the opposite gender, it is concerning." - You are making a lot of wild assumptions about what kind of people choose to transition and revealing your personal bias. Why does a woman have to already be a "butch" as you put it, for it to be considered normal for them to transition? Have you considered that people, (myself included) were terrified when growing up of even appearing to fall outside of the social norms? When so much as wearing a dress to school as a boy, or shaving your head as a young girl could be met with ridicule and vitriol from your peers? What if you knew your parents would never approve of your experimentation with cross dressing? With makeup (again, this was the case for me)? My point is that not everyone exhibits outward signs of gender dysphoria before deciding to transition. You couldn't possibly know what has gone on inside their head up to that point. For you to say it's concerning is to me, concerning. "Body dysmorphia is more common among young cis women, some hate the uncomfortable experience of having a period, uncomfortable with their breasts, or perhaps dislike the experience of the male gaze and attempt to escape those experiences." -I won't dispute that this is true, but you are are talking about Body Dysmorphia, which is not necessarily the same as Gender Dysphoria so you bringing it up here is only tangentially related. "It's not a conversation of whether trans should exist, it's a conversation of whether rapid onset gender dysphoria exists, is social contagion or social media a factor? Is there medical negligence? Could gender dysphoria be caused by trauma or discomfort during puberty? I think many people in the LGBT community agree but are too afraid to say something, why are there so many more ftms compared to mtfs?" - Honestly none of this is relevant to our argument here. Should these things be studied? Yes, absolutely. Who knows how Gender Dysphoria works, what the causes are for it, or whether social media plays a role? If you agree that people should have autonomy of their bodies then you should also agree that trans people should have the same access to hormones and surgery that cis people do. Just because someone is trans they are being gatekept from hormones and surgery? A man can walk into a hospital, tell the doctor his balls are in severe pain and receive an orchiectomy. A woman can decide she doesn't like her breasts anymore and get a mastectomy. But tell them you are a trans person and you want to transition and all of the sudden there is "concern" and people are worried they will experience "regret." The distinction here is clear, some things are socially normalized and others are not. This is the case with adults transitioning. And I will venture a guess as to why there are supposedly more mtf transitioners. Now this is going to sound completely wild and speculative but maybe it's because... being a woman in a patriarchal world that constantly subjects you to violence and austerity, rapes you, forces you to bear children and then shames you for it, insults you, doesn't believe you, pays you less, etc. is something that one might want to escape? That's my guess anyways but good luck pinpointing an exact reason. On the topic of kids transitioning with hormones, even some conservatives will admit that the suicidality rate among trans teens is, relative to the whole population, very high. This has been studied by doctors for decades and the conclusion that they came to, through peer-reviewed research and studies, is that gender-affirming care, i.e. hormones and in incredibly rare circumstances surgery, lowers the suicidality rate significantly. Everyone is worried about kids that might "regret" transition but no one is worried about the huge amount of kids who are gatekept from transition, go through puberty which causes permanent, non-reversible changes in their body and go on to... well you know what happens a huge amount of the time. I have already linked you to multiple studies that show the detransition rate is incredibly low. I won't go so far as to say there is never a case of medical negligence, but if you listen to trans activists and what we are fighting for it is full bodily autonomy for trans people and to DE-medicalize us as a group. Now if we are talking about kids receiving surgery, I believe that topic is more nuanced and requires asking a lot of hard questions like, should parents even play a role? How does this relate to child liberation? In America and in most of the world, kids are little more than the property of their parents, is that just? How much freedom should kids actually have? What happens in a case where the kid is shown to have intense Gender Dysphoria but the parent won't allow transition, against all medical guidelines to treat such a symptom (this already happens)? Should the parents have that amount of control over their children? What ages are appropriate? There is room for discussion here, but we've got a long way to go. "I believe in the future we will see more ftm detransitioners. " - You are free to predict the future in any way you see fit but rhetorically I don't know why it matters to state this. It doesn't line up with current studies on the subject. So maybe there will be a complete reversal of the numbers but if you were betting I'd say you were making a bad bet. Some final thoughts: Not everyone is ready for this conversation but when you get deep into the activism you will come to understand that Gender Dysphoria is real but not every trans person experiences it. And in my ideal world, you wouldn't have to prove to a doctor through a series of interviews and diagnoses that you are worthy of modifying your body as you see fit. I'm sorry if I come across as aggressive, I'm just very involved with and passionate about trans liberation. I truly hope you will come around and see things from my perspective and the perspectives of trans teens who just want to transition in peace. Read the studies and listen to activists, we know this topic better than anyone. We come from a long line of people fighting for liberation and it's demoralizing having to bust the same old myths and talking points over and over again to well-meaning people who are afraid that things are changing too fast. At the end of the day we represent a fraction of a percent of the population, despite the media pretending that we are overrepresented. All of this chaos, all this worry over an incredibly small group of people who are choosing to live outside of the societally assigned roles forced upon us.

Rev Left Radio

What are the critiques of her? I dont follow it much and I know she isnt a marxist, but is there anything else? Just genuinely curious!

Max

From what I gather, there are three main vectors. One centers around her personal wealth, one around her political ideology and one concerns Twitter Drama. She seems to have made a lot of money from her videos and couples this petty bourgeois class outlook with a kind of detached left cynicism, that will probably falter to right opportunism when pressed (i.e. Social democracy). She sometimes makes fun of Twitter left wing radicals, which is not without merit, but does come from a right vantage point. However, she produces well-made philosophical essays. I find it very interesting how she blurs the line between philosophical essay and artwork by her use of visual aesthetics. She has more philosophical substance than for example Philosophy Tube, but sadly her topics are all over the place, falling back on dissecting some Twitter bullshit too often. She definitely lacks a political movement as an anchor, but what she says is usually intelligent. A year ago she produced a video titled “The Hunger”, which resonated a lot with me. There is a hole in most of us, a hunger that we fail to satisfy by consumption. What, at the start, seems to be a debate with right wing strawwomen, turns into a conversation between id, ego and super-ego. The right wing religious figure seems to, despite all her vileness, possess something we lack and it is not just the opium of religion. Or maybe Religion is not just an opium. It lacks a conclusion. There is supposed to be a second part. I don’t think she is the one to give it, and she seems to have trouble with it considering how long it's been, but she poses the question in an intuitive way. Would definitely recommend.

NukaDirtbag

The Hunger was good too, I blanked on that one because it felt less like a video essay and more like an art house piece. But I haven't cared for any of her essays since The Apocalypse. I'd cut her channel broadly into 3 eras, the first being the Antifa era (Decrypting the Alt-Right up to her video on Incels), then her culture war era for lack of better name (The Aesthetic to Opulence) and then when her Canceling video came out it seemed like a new Cancel Culture era because all the videos after that except the Voting one and The Hunger veered into that basically, with the Envy one being the worst and I think people are kinda burned out on watching a lady that makes 100k a month on Patreon keep making videos about people being mean to her on Twitter instead of logging off.

Rev Left Radio

This feedback and explanation was very helpful! Thank you both for this. It clarifies a lot for me! Makes sense. But Ill def at least check out The Hunger as that does sound interesting and kinda down my alley a bit.

Chase

Listened to this teaser on the regular episodes and had to immediately jump to Patreon to get the rest of the analysis. Stoked to be here comrades thanks Brent and the rest of the Rev left team!

Rev Left Radio

Nice! Thank you so much for the support, Chase, I appreciate it!!!!

Mike Sannito

This was fantastic and really helped me after hearing some transphobia comments at my job today. Thank you Breht for everything you and your analysis

Mike Sannito

On your conversations about the US being white supremacist have you studied the theory of African Internationalism put forth by the African Peoples Socialist Party? I think you would really appreciate the insights and take a lot from it. It is profoundly dialectical and does the best job of using historical materialist to analyze the origins of capitalism. Also please look into that party and the work they are doing specifically the black power blueprint they are doing brilliant things on the ground. Also they are currently under attack by the FBI and there’s a lot to look into there

Jose Alvarez

That “brothers, sisters, and SIBLINGS” @ 31:30 was really sweet 🫶🏼