Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

In this Patreon exclusive, Breht reads and responds to a recent piece in New York Magazine arguing against revolutionary socialism and Marxism, and for reformist liberalism.

Breht also discusses his recent trip to Las Vegas and offers some advice for those disheartened by the current state of American politics. 

Files

Comments

Saya Clarke

Awhile back when I finally got a job that came with healthcare I was so excited! YES! Finally! I can go to the doctor and have some peace of mind! Then I found out about “deductibles.” I’m like, are you fucking kidding me? Sure technically I have insurance, but they won’t pay for anything until I’ve shelled out $2,000 of my own damn money first. I was honestly shocked. What a joke of a system.

gavin curran

You don’t have to be a revolutionary to see all the milquetoast liberal and social democratic reforms made in the past 100 years be eroded and explicitly rolled back by the reactionary Supreme Court and state governments. Clearly reformism is itself a failure

Landis Brown

Really needed to hear those last couple of minutes of this. Thank you!

Nathan

are you familiar with the youtube channel Crime Pays but Botany Doesn't? if you're interested in desert ecosystems, he has a lot of videos regarding desert ecology and geology. he also seems like a pretty solid dude with some good social commentary, could make for an interesting guest on the show

Micah Worth

Great episode once again Breht. I love when you end shows on outro music thematically aligned with the content - I feel like this episode could’ve used Taking Water by Billy Strings. Not explicitly revolutionary but certainly inspires some of those emotions in me. Also love bluegrass music

Mike Sannito

Thank you Breht for another great episode. I’m only a relatively recent Patreon subscriber and one thing I’ve really love is hearing you sort of let loose and kinda drop the super respectability you conduct yourself with on the main feed. You’ve made me laugh so hard in these Patreon episodes and I love this little insight to your humor and personality. Especially the part when you were reacting to the “ultra-leftism” thing 😂😂

Mike Sannito

Side note if I were to write you a longer form letter ab 5 or so pages would you have the time to read it? Just seeking a genuine answer it’s okay if not I understand that you are very busy and can’t possibly get to all responses from people and writings or suggestions and stuff. It would be concerning the theory of African Internationalism as put forth by the African Peoples Socialist Party. I really believe this theory has so many points of clarity and genuinely had so much to offer the global socialist movement. And I wouldn’t be asking for your time and you consideration of this if I was not THOROUGHLY convinced of it’s historical importance. Being that I am so convinced of this, I’m going to continue reaching out like this regarding this party. So I’m sorry I’m advance if this gets annoying

Raegan Davis

Loved this episode! One thing about the article you discussed that tripped my ears was its obsessive focus with constructing more housing and its use of this issue as "reform" in the false dichotomy of reform vs revolution. When I'm bored and looking for intellectual stimulation, I'll sometimes pick a fight with YIMBYs on twitter and their rising prominence in the DSA lately, as well as this article's rhetorical similarities, makes me think that astroturfed deregulatory ideology is probably what was really at root in the article. To the extent that I had seen this article you posted previously on YIMBY twitter, with the DSA YIMBY Caucus retweeting it and the tagline "housing now, revolution later." Which adds a whole layer to the discourse I'd love to see you touch at some point. Essentially, the movement looks to construct homelessness and housing insecurity as products of a housing shortage, ignoring that many luxury housing complexes sit empty because it is more profitable to rent out just a few at a higher price than lower rents and rent out more. YIMBYism insists that laws of supply and demand work in the "housing market" as they do anywhere else and, thus, the solution is to simply increase the supply and force landlords to lower rents, because they understand tenants will relocate in search of cheaper homes. As someone who has also been a lifelong renter, I'm sure you understand the impracticality of this assumption. But it fundamentally undergirds arguments like the one you argue against here, which is why the writer must necessarily construct his proposal of deregulating the housing market and allowing developers to build whatever they'd like, wherever they'd like, as "progressive reform" which will reduce harm. By contrast, communists generally fall into the "PHIMBY" camp, advocating public housing as the solution. We argue for increasing the supply of well-maintained, publicly owned housing that is tied to a portion of income rather than a fixed dollar amount for rent. If you'll notice, THIS IS ALSO A REFORM! The difference is, this reform is also revolutionary in that it pushes us closer to removing capital from housing, but it is not a revolution in and of itself. That's the biggest thing I wanted to contribute to this conversation-- that not only is this author mischaracterizing communists in general, but also in specific. When public housing advocates argue for increased affordable housing, even if it isn't public, the YIMBY camp's go-to response is that some housing is better than no housing, because to them the issue is all about supply and demand and, since the movement's origins can be traced back to developers and Silicon Valley, it is to their ideological and material benefit to make it seem as if THIS REFORM is the only reform on the table, and the only other options are calls for revolutionary overthrow of capitalism, which is impractical, hoping that no one will actually investigate the PHIMBY proposals. Through this light, they can then very easily explain away gentrification that occurs necessarily as a result of their policies as a temporary issue which will eventually level out to cheaper housing, but still paint themselves as the ones concerned with the immediate needs of working people suffering from poorly-maintained and unaffordable housing. They also tend to advocate against rent control, even as every tenants union I've ever organized with has that as its demand, based on technocratic think tank studies which claim it's actually bad for renters in the long run. TLDR you hit the nail on the head.

Arbor

Episodes like this are so helpful for discussing revolutionary politics with my liberal friends. Thank you so much!

Rev Left Radio

Its really a crime... I cant believe people can afford it and/or that people just accept it.

Rev Left Radio

sometimes I say stuff that I myself need to hear too, my friend. You are welcome. Glad it resonated.

Rev Left Radio

NIce, love cool educational YT channels. Great way to learn, ill check it out and sub to it ASAP.

Rev Left Radio

Thank you! Ive always loved that as well - unfortunately this week both spotify and our hosting RSS site emailed us and told us if we dont stop playing copyrighted music at the end of our eps, our entire show will be taken down on every podcast app... We are trying to solve the problem while still being able to maintain the music-dynamic which is a long standing feature of our show, but we shall see. Ill check out Taking Water tho for sure! Thank you.

Rev Left Radio

Hey Mike, yes, Ill def check it out! Might not respond immediately, but will get to it if you email it to me at: andersonbrett2011@Gmail <3

Rev Left Radio

And thank you for the kind words! I have a new project coming soon that will double-down on the exact things you mention here as being endearing and entertaining! So stay tuned! ;)

Rev Left Radio

Really great arguments here, my friend. You are a talented writer as well, and I really appreciate this feedback/analysis. Your point about revolutionary reforms, and seeing reforms through a revolutionary lens, is really essential and I couldn't agree more. Id like to maybe try to apply this logic to other issues like healthcare, where there are liberal reforms and revolutionary ones that challenge capital at its roots while also making substantial improvements in the quality of life for working people here and now.

Mike Sannito

Thank you so much! That’s awesome. And I will definitely stay tuned I am more than eager for any new content you put out or new projects

Raegan Davis

Ooooh healthcare would be a fascinating place to apply that framework! If it's at all relevant, I originally got it from a prison abolitionist context, where reformist reforms are those which reduce harm but retrench the system (ex. improving prison conditions, further legitimizing the carceral state), while revolutionary reforms are those which both reduce harm and chip away at the system (ex. releasing prisoners and decriminalization of certain offenses). Though, in the YIMBY context, I'm not entirely sure the reformist reforms even reduce harm at all, given the immediate gentrification they feed and the yet-to-be-seen nature of the supposed rent decreases they create.

Matt Pierce

"OK then do it" lmao exactly. These freaks are always just shadowboxing chapo fans roasting them in their mentions from fucking 2016, they don't ever have anything useful to offer in terms of a real theory of change, even in a reformist sense.

Kaede Butikofer

great episode as always, comrade. if you come to idaho at some point, dont make Boise your main stay, you especially would love our wilderness. come during late july/august and tent (or car) camp in the middle idaho wilderness. beautiful lakes, hiking, floating, and awesome fishing. very montana-esque. salmon/challis area is amazing, but watch for bears :) if you're ever curious, feel free to reach out for advice! love your stuff, you're truly an important revolutionary of the moment.

Rev Left Radio

Hell yes! id love to come visit Idaho sometime, and you definitely know my interests by leading w the wilderness and natural beauty angle! <3

Cookie

I’m going to try to get the University of Utah to give you a gig 🤔🤔🤔

Traci Spratt

TY as usual Breht for cutting thru the crap and preaching truth...we're all so gas lit on the regular...its so isolating...you bring such sanity and it is greatly appreciated!!!!