Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

When you think about the philosophies and practices of Buddhism and Marxism, you might not immediately think that they have much in common. However, you might be surprised at how much overlap and complementary resonance there actually is between these two rich and beautiful traditions.

In this conversation, we’ve brought on Breht O’Shea, a Buddhist practitioner and Marxist political educator based out of Omaha, Nebraska. Breht is the host of the podcast Revolutionary Left Radio and co-host of the podcasts Red Menace, Guerrilla History, and, most recently, Shoeless in South Dakota. You might remember Breht from when he was on the show about a year ago to talk about revolutionary leftist theory.

In this conversation, we explore how both Buddhism & Marxism offer helpful pathways to liberation and provide a spot-on analysis of the root causes of suffering. We also explore some of the potential tensions between Buddhism and Marxism, as well as what each tradition can learn from the other. And we end with a powerful invitation to embark on the path of the Bodhisattva Revolutionary to both end the internal and structural causes and conditions of suffering and to bring forth the systemic changes necessary for the transition to a socialist and eventually communist economy based on liberation, equity, and justice for all.

This interview was inspired by an episode of Revolutionary Left Radio titled Dialectics & Liberation: Insights from Buddhism and Marxism where Breht read a speech he gave at Arizona State University on the topic of dialectical materialism, Buddhism, and Marxism. Definitely check that episode out when you’re done listening to this — it’s a great complement to this conversation.

Thank you to Carolyn Raider for this episode’s cover art and to Mount Eerie for the intermission music. Upstream theme music was composed by Robert Raymond/Lanterns.

Further Resources:

This episode of Upstream was made possible with support from listeners like you and by Resist Foundation. Upstream is a labor of love — we couldn't keep this project going without the generosity of our listeners and fans. Please consider chipping in a one-time or recurring donation at www.upstreampodcast.org/support

If your organization wants to sponsor one of our upcoming documentaries, we have a number of sponsorship packages available. Find out more at upstreampodcast.org/sponsorship

For more from Upstream, visit www.upstreampodcast.org and follow us on social media:

Facebook.com/upstreampodcast

Twitter.com/UpstreamPodcast

Instagram.com/upstreampodcast

You can also subscribe to us on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you listen to your favorite podcasts.

Files

Buddhism and Marxism with Breht O'Shea (In Conversation)

When you think about the philosophies and practices of Buddhism and Marxism, you might not immediately think that they have much in common. However, you might be surprised at how much overlap and complementary resonance there actually is between these two rich and beautiful traditions.  In this conversation, we've brought on Breht O'Shea, a Buddhist practitioner and Marxist political educator based out of Omaha, Nebraska.

Comments

The Leninist Lawyer

I really appreciate you doing these form videos. It has broadened my spiritual view and given a lot of meaning to feelings I’ve had for as long as I can remember. Thank you. Also! Quick question, and no worries if you don’t get to it in time, but I am driving through Nebraska in a day or two and wondered if you had recommendations on things to see or any nature parks/fishing/camping. Never been to the state, just through it.

Mike Sannito

Another great episode, I love you exploring these intersections. Really encouraging me to get into buddhism and peaking my interest. Might fuck around and….meditate😂 Do you having any recommendations for videos or teachers that do entry level basic Buddhist teachings on like YouTube or something?

Tater

First time I heard that Mount Eerie record I was shook to my core. So much so I haven’t been able to listen to it much since. When that song came on in the episode I got chills even despite currently working outside in 100+ degree weather. Profoundly sad, wonderful piece of art. Fits nicely within the topic of this episode. Respect to Upstream and yourself, Brett. Always interesting to hear you speak on how Buddhism and Marxism can be entwined.

Rev Left Radio

Thank you, and I could not agree more about Mount Eerie! When I stumbled upon "A Crow Looked At Me" it made me weep unlike any music I have ever heard. I remember laying on the couch soaked in tears while I listened to the whole album from start to finish. When art can move you on THAT level, it borders on spiritual.

Rev Left Radio

hahah hell yea! I would def check out Joseph Goldstein's work for a really solid introduction into Buddhism, both theory and practice. Ram Dass and Alan Watts for an entertaining, inspiring, and deeply compelling approach to spiritual practice (Ram Dass more coming from Hinduism and Watts from Zen Buddhism). Trudy Goodman is good and features in an episode of "Midnight Gospel" that I highly recommend, Jack Kornfield "A Path With Heart" is also a wonderful and moving introduction to buddhism that really centers Mahayana emphases on loving kindness and compassion (hence a path with heart title!). Those are recs I give to Americans raised in the American context to help orient themselves to a tradition that can be challenging to get into without context given the radically different cultural signifiers, language barriers, and time differences. But ultimately, if you fall in love with it, engaging with primary sources in the tradition will become really useful and important. All the people mentioned tho were instrumental in bringing real buddhism to the West, after years spent learning and studying it under the great Buddhist masters of south east Asia. So the connection to the authentic thing is there and is essential imo, as opposed to appropriated and half digested psuedo-forms of eastern spirituality, mysticism and philosophy that were prevalent in the West and America before them.

Mike Sannito

Thank you so much for taking the time to sort this out for me, this is great and so helpful. Thanks again Brett!

Mike Sannito

Also I threw up a comment on the Shakur episode but I watched it pretty late so you may not have seen it. If you have time check it out, I’d love for you to read it!

spinitch

mannnnn what an ep… so many gems. you’re always extremely well spoken, but this was s-tier articulation and clarity of ideas. loved the part juxtaposing mao/che on violence and love and how we might navigate that. def gotta have upstream on for another ep!

Mike Sannito

Thought of another question😬 this is something I’ve been wondering about and you mentioned it in this episode. Do you have any recommendations for learning about the tension and conflict between the Tibetan monks and the Chinese communists? I’ve tried to poke around on the internet to learn but I’m finding it very hard to find good information about it.

Rob Marsh

Great conversation and some really interesting and insightful back and forth on the question of violence for Buddhist Marxists, in many ways it's really the core tension between the two. Wondering Breht, if you've had much exposure to Thich Nhat Hanh and the Plum Village sangha? Thay's proximity to conflict throughout his life places his reflections on violence in deeply lived experience, and I've found his concept of the teachings as a "north star" helpful in going some way towards resolving the contradiction. Also been meaning to read Senoo Girō, who you might be familiar with, a Buddhist Marxist from early 20th century Japan, his work gets right at the intersections between the two systems. As someone who's been deeply interested in both worldviews for a long time now, it's a genuine joy hearing you share your thoughts and feeling a sense of camaraderie from that, cheers!

Cookie

This is def an area of interest for me. I think it's fair to say that "conflict" is a weird way of framing it. The monks were more or less passive and unarmed, and got wiped. Maoists pulled a full like, Robespierre style French revolution where they axed the clergy and aristocracy, along with tons of ordinary people. I would love to find some communist data that really proved that the common people were there with them helping, but it doesn't seem like a reflection of reality. It may be necessary for us to accept that this was, in a most ways, a pretty nasty atrocious colonial takeover.

Max

Tf are you talking about?? Passive and unarmed parasites of a brutal feudal system you mean. Not to mention the decidedly less passive CIA-sponsored terrorists. (And what could you possible have against comrade Robespierre but aristocratic lies and propaganda?) There is plenty of communist research on that topic, I am quite sure. Most of it Chinese, of course, but dont portray it like this topic has yet to be discovered. There is also more popular english literature on that topic: By Anna Louise Strong https://www.marxists.org/reference/archive/strong-anna-louise/1959/tibet/index.htm Also by Michael Parenti https://redsails.org/friendly-feudalism/ If you find solace in religion, thats great and all, but you cannot just forget that religion has been the main ideological bedrock of class exploitation for ages. You are wielding very strong accusations here without providing much of a basis.

Deven Toast

Hi Breht! I have been loving your works on Buddhism and Marxism. It's been something I've been thinking about over the last few years. I recently have been trying to incorporate meditation and mindfulness into my daily life and have started reading Thic Nhat Hanh to help with that. I don't know if I'll ever be a full blown Buddhist, at least on the metaphysical side of it, but I think incorporating it's practices goes hand in hand with dialectical thinking. And is a much better stress reliever than other methods. Do you have any recommended readings, podcasts, or daily activities to assist in this development? Thanks and again, I love and appreciate what you do

Deven Toast

Nevermind I saw your previous comment!