Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

Breht analyzes the lyrics of - and the ideology undergirding - a recent viral country song being presented as a working class anthem.

Files

Comments

Matt Pierce

Oh God I can't wait to listen to this when I'm done with the family abolition reading ep lol

Ryan Smith

Ryansmith3479@gmail.com. Fantasy league

Jonathan Rogers

bucky64@gmail.com thanks for putting these leagues together!

Matt Pierce

The midsentence cuts at the end of these are so iconic lol

Andrew Davis

Hey Breht, 100% agree on all takes on this. I actually thought he was saying "I wish politicians would look out for minors" as some anti trans dog whistle rather than miners but I looked up the lyrics and I guess it says miners. But honestly it could be both and whichever anti trans person hearing that would probably make that association. I saw this on Twitter but someone investigated and learned that this is most likely a astroturfed song and was basically confirmed by Dan Bongino. I'd search for it to confirm your statement that some billionaire made this shit, 100%. It's meteoric popularity all at once from right wingers is basically confirmation alone. This shit never takes off organically. The complete right wing takeover of country or folk music is downright sickening, where if I hear the mainstream stuff it's code for listeners that they're racist. It's all like I'm an ignorant dude who drinks beer and wishes America just catered exclusively to white people again. Hope the Vienna trip is a blast

_tarrvis

I felt the same way about this song. I've been off almost all social media for awhile now but saw this popping up in news feeds. Listened to it. Felt the exact same way. The line about the people milking welfare really sent me. Lazy analysis on part of the songwriter. When major newspapers are pushing your song and highlighting how insightful it is, probably not the working class anthem people think they are listening to Also, as an aside. The Epstein stuff is starting to implicate JPMorgan Chase as an institution and how they facilitated the payments to victims and traffickers, used their own jets to traffick victims, in return for business deals Epstein would bring them. So while the Epstein and Maxwell parts are over, the case is still ongoing and unearthing some huge shit.

Eric Laleer

Hey Breht I recommend you check out the history of Red Vienna while you’re there - specifically the socialist housing projects like Alt Erlaa and Karl Marx Hof, lots of cool municipal socialism in that city!

Max

I like the song. I don’t understand why you (and many on the left) are so condescending towards it. You can barely suppress a chuckle carrying out how this dumb yokel’s musing does not meet your poetic standards. There is an error of posture within the contemporary left. A worker pours his heart out which gets immediately branded as “façade of concern for the working people”. Even if the singer is a malign actor paid by a billionaire, that would not matter, since the song appears to speak to a lot of working-class people. Their class consciousness may not yet be very developed; focusing on the surface of corruption: the parasitic state apparatus of the monopolies, the burden of tax diminishing an already lacking paycheck or morbidly obese people in the supermarket using a shopping scooter as they have become unable to even walk through the halls of ceaseless consumption. But it is an expression of struggle. One that is unfiltered, abridged and may be spun by reactionaries in a way that ends up only punching down. However, the way the left is handling this, it is assured to be.

Matt

Yeah, completely agree with you. Most people have chaotic politics and hangups, but the left does not want any part in winning them over. I don't blame people in America for being republicans or voting for reactionaries because they are the only ones who don't speak down to them, complete paternalism from the left all the way down..

JK

Great breakdown. I was thinking all the same things when my parents linked the song in our family group chat. Im sad the reactionary and insane lyrics (300 lb people on welfare?) go right over their heads....my mom even wanted to send the dude a check cause she believed the singer was a rough miner type. I'd love to get more quick breakdown episodes like this on your patreon, keep em' coming

Ryan Campbell

Imagine a game show of being trapped in a room and you could only listen to “rich north of Richmond” and “try that in a small town” on repeat but if you survive 24 hours you win 10k

oranjest1

oh yea if we all just band around wilful, astroturfed and politically convenient ignorance the left could win so much more often

Sean the worker

I hear the cut too, it happens to me on the app, but NOT the website.

From The River To The Sea 🇵🇸

Seriously? In one line the guy pretends to care about the homeless then in the next line shits on welfare recipients. Doesn’t take someone well versed in theory to know that shit doesn’t square. But you’re the real leftist? 🤦🏻‍♂️

Saya Clarke

I stopped getting on Twitter so I hadn’t heard about this. I didn’t know what to expect when I started this episode and let me tell you when I heard this song I was screaming. Of course everything I think is wrong with the song is exactly what Breht talks about and at least that was cathardic to hear. The bit about taxes really got me. As if getting that extra $120 bucks from your paycheck would suddenly mean you’re no longer destitute living in a country that makes you beg like a good little doggie for scraps and then pearl-clutches when you dare to suggest you might deserve a bit more of what you’ve worked to create. All I heard were racist dog whistles, punching down, tired old tropes and an utter void where class consciousness should be. SHAME on any “marxist” who thinks we should have any sympathy for the type of person who listens to this and feels seen. As far as I’m concerned they are enemy combatants and they can all go fall on a sword.

crowbar9

I agree that it may be an expression of struggle, but there is no need to speculate on whether it may be spun by reactionaries - the song itself IS reactionary so there really is no other path for it. I don’t know if you disagree with the content of the critique given here or you are just tone policing, but don’t you think its time we stop infantilizing those on the right and pretending that the reason they choose their politics (as chaotic as they may be) is because the left says mean things to them online? I’m not saying we should be insufferably smug bastards all the time, but playing nice all the time is not going to work either. To the other commenter who believes republicans and reactionaries are the only ones who don’t speak down to the working class - wow! I’m sensing some real right wing plant vibes here… kind of joking, but seriously?

The Fine Art Revolution

Great analysis Breht! My only addition to your critique would be that the singer dudes main point is about the suffering, and not so much the causes. The libertarian bs felt more like throw away lines to appeal to that audience. Perhaps that makes it even more insidious? I do know this guy could make good music with a good leftist lyricist. The energy is there, it just needs to be honed and sharpened, and maybe that’s what we can do

Kevin Li

It’s a decent song but Breht’s right. It doesn’t really say anything that challenges the status quo except maybe “Fuck the government.” I could get the same feelings from listening to NWA songs. Whatever class consciousness exists is extremely surface level and questionable because the guy criticizes people on welfare.

Max

As a worker, on a surface level, you produce all the values while a significant part of the population seems to contribute nothing or dubiously little in return. Only eat. Financial analysts, loan sharks, drug dealers, state bureucrats, landlords, realtors, business coaches, NGO officials, college students, instagram influencers, welfare recipients; the list could go on. And the latter are only symbols of a larger disease, picked out because they are close by and provide ample surface to project onto. As symbols for a stratum of parasites that have nested in the inflated superstructure of a global empire. Of course, the obese guy is not really the enemy, he is a victim of this hellhole and probably not even on welfare; a bit of political work and compassion could iron that out. But the feeling in itself is not wrong. Currently, it is blind ire lashing out to the ones closest, but think of the beautiful targeted hate it could be when turned towards the real welfare kings and queens, who leech of government bailouts, arms contracts and last but not least: profit. You all quickly got whats wrong with the song. I applaud you. You are very smart and just. But unless you understand what is right about the song and why it carries so far within working class, you will have a lot of trouble connecting to this part of the society. But maybe you dont want to anyway and you seem to be very quick (and ferocious) in finding excuses for that. Maybe "they are enemy combatants and they can all go fall on a sword." After all they are all worker aristocrats and settler colonialists (unlike our liberal academic circles). How convenient! But I dont think you are going to get far without them. How the left has been conditioned to despise is blue collars is truly breath taking. This whole comment section reads like an allergic reaction.

Pablo

Enjoy your time in Vienna! I would recommend you go to a "Heuriger". They are an Austrian venue where you eat roast pork, salads and drink the local fresh cheap wine. There are many vineyards just outside the city where you can go for a hike between the vines and then walk to one if these for lunch. Many even have huts with wine in the middle of the vineyard! Here is an example https://maps.app.goo.gl/35hcBvr5Me3jeuAc6

Cameron Plath

I don’t understand why you and others on the left are so ready to settle for shit. On my way home from work yesterday I heard “Hunger Strike” by Temple of the Dog, and it was the perfect example of class consciousness. I doubt Chris Cornel or Eddie Vedder had a perfect Marxist analysis while writing this, but even on the surface, it’s about struggle without blaming the “powerless” “Well I don’t mind stealin bread from the mouths of decadence. But I can’t feed on the powerless when my cups already overfilled. But it’s on the table the fires cookin. And they’re farmin’ babies while the slaves are all workin’. And the blood is on the table and the mouths are chokin’” Like come on! Imagine a line shitting on welfare in a song like this🤣 We’re not asking for perfect analysis in a song, just not shitty reactionary lines that punch down at the ppl you supposedly claim to care about in the same breath. Raise your standards a little and stop tailing.

crowbar9

You ask us to understand what is right about the song and suggest that the feeling itself is not wrong. Sure, but there is nothing ever good about misdirected anger and in this context specifically, this anger is dangerous to any leftist project to build solidarity. The song’s lyrics actively punch down - there is no subtlety there - and will absolutely encourage others to do the same and reinforce already existing beliefs. You ask us to understand why it carries so far with the working class. I’d say many of us understand perfectly why it does and these reasons are spelled out in this very podcast, not to mention the literature (ex. Gramsci), and other forms of media, or just talking to friends and family that like the song. That doesn’t mean we should tail the working masses misguided into thinking this is anything but bourgeois propaganda. I don’t know much about this genre of music specifically, but im sure there are plenty of working class musicians within it creating actual working class music that will never go viral or be marketed to the masses by major news organizations and talking heads simply because they don’t carry the same pro-bourgeois ideological baggage. If you subjectively like the song, great - i’m sure we all at some point have listened to an artist with less than ideal politics from a leftist point of view. But you shouldn’t be so defensive when that same song is subjected to a very much needed critique, especially on a leftist podcast.

Seany G

Great analysis. Part of the problem in my view is that the most objectionable parts are mumbled (eg. "5'3" and "welfare" lines) so at first it's easy to miss the reactionary stance of the song. Maybe someone should re-write the lyrics ("Rich Men IN Richmond"). Sometimes/often this was done with folk music in the Woody Guthrie era to give a more progressive /militant message. It probably wouldn't take too much effort. Also - in line with your recent announcement about shifting focus to more topical subjects for Rev Left Radio, you could do a variation of this with either a) the politics of select songs (I always thought that Billy Joel's "We didn't start the fire" had fascistic aesthetics....) or b) popular movies: not just historical or political ones like "Oppenheimer", but even blockbusters like "Mission Impossible". Just a thought. Good work on this one, in any case!

Mexican Stalin

I'm glad you made a breakdown of this song. The number of so-called Marxists who fall for rightwing "working class" dog whistles is depressing. I understand why some Marxists like Patsocs are becoming more reactionary and falling into this vortex of identity politics. It seems like the only victories the left have made recently have been only in the identity politics space. For example, in the reduction of Islamophobia or the acceptance of Lgbt+ people, the Liberals are wielding these victories as their own and using them as weapons of imperialism. This gives the right wing a tool to deflect responsibility for causing imperialism away from capitalism to left-wing identity politics. I've seen right-wing "Anti-Imperialists" say that imperialism happens because America wants to force countries to be lgbt+ friendly of course as Marxists we know it's ridiculous. Now to bring it back to your breakdown of this song, it is a great example of how a few leftist slogans can make right-wing reactionary propaganda palatable. That's why I'm glad you made this breakdown.

MLDad

Yeah and in which side are you on lyrics the guy's father was not a minor either

MLDad

Max there's genuinely good music with genuinely good takes and views of the social and political situation, no need to write a whole chapter to say it's ok for poor people to use miserable people as ample surface to project their discomfort with the system onto just to salvage a seemingly working class song writer.

The Leninist Lawyer

There is so much actually existing proletarian music. Great breakdown. Folk music is my passion. Love all the episodes you’ve done on the topic.

Andrew Davis

Let anyone who reads this understand this is tailing the reactionary working class. This is appealing to the backwards, racist, and anti-communist elements. Is this progressive? No it's not. The political line is everything and if it's like this then it it isn't advancing anything

Dylan

If you want some really great left-wing working class country songs check out Croy and the Boys out of Austin TX. Randomly saw Croy perform in a small bar and the slow reveal that he was a communist cowboy was fucking great. Very witty songwriter. I don’t think he has a recording of it yet, but he had a song called Class Analysis that really hit.

Max

You do not understand. You are treating this as if you are in court, having to pass judgement on wether it is ok to say certain lines or how good a piece of music is compared to alternatives. But what actually matters is, how this song and its treatment reflects society. It tells us something, both about political consciousness of a certain section of the working class (including its deficiencies), as well as the relation of leftists towards this kind of people. And I would argue it reveals a condescension and hostility that hampers our ability to connect to the class as a whole and not just to the section we might feel culturally more aligned with. Many of you have been very quick to condemn this man as racist, reactionary, astroturfed and possibly hostile to trans people (wtf). I can only imagine how you behave towards people like him in real life. Most people I have met are not 100% politically correct. You don’t have to cater to every hot take they utter, but a bit of respect and patience usually go a long way. If that is tailing for you, then good luck getting anything done. Just be careful that you don’t end up tailing the liberal left/right distinction in the end.

Daniel Gay

Billy Bragg made a perfect counter song. I highly recommend it!

CoolBusDriver

Well I’m behind but disgruntled99guy@gmail.com if there’s any late latecomer spots on the fantasy leagues. Opsec, ya know, gotta give out the old ill-fated union drive email

Tiffani McCoy

Wishing you an incredible time in Vienna. I am slightly obsessed with that city. Make sure to hit up the street sausage stands!

Rev Left Radio

XD lmao - genuine torture. Seeing the guys face over and over again the past few weeks has been torturous enough!

Rev Left Radio

Yea, the chorus of despair and the longing for something better is def the redeemable part of the song for sure. I dont hate the guy, I just dont like how it was astroturfed and weaponized by all the worst people.

Rev Left Radio

Wow, cool. Thank you for this recommendation. Ill have two days totally alone in Vienna and will add this to my schedule!

Rev Left Radio

interesting! ill dl it now and check it out. thank you

Gabriel Alvarado

Brother if you would listen to the rest of the Revleft catalog you would see the amount of humility Breht approaches the guests he has on, even the ones he doesn't ideologically align with, and conservative working class folk. He mentioned many times that not all conservatives are the enemy, etc. This is a hot take and a opinion episode. This is strictly his own analysis. I agree with what you are saying, but I have seen it go both ways. I have a very conservative and reactionary family. Some of them get the class analysis and some of them quite literally don't care and would rather be bigoted assholes, for various reasons. Solidarity comrade, I wish you the best.

Comrade Hesher

I'm sure I'll get shit for this comment but ya kinda lost me towards the end of the episode. No this isn't a proletarian anthem, but like it or not, this is the mindset of a lot of working class people. There is a lack of critical analysis of our system among working people but they can feel it failing them. So yeah, it's very surface level to blame the government or welfare queens because that's what we've been told is the problem since I was born. It is good to breakdown their misconceptions and offer an alternative view but you get very aggressive towards the end and even throw in some off the deep end remark about this being a psyop. If you watch any of this dudes other stuff, he's just a white working class dude feeling the squeeze of late stage capitalism. He seems to genuinely care about the well being of working class folks and admits that he's a shit song writer, he was just writing about what he feels. The Internet is riddled with people like this expressing their desperation any way they know how. We shouldn't approach them with vitriol but rather embrace them and their frustrations while combating their reactionary tendencies. I have many friends that enjoyed this song because they felt the desperation being conveyed and I wanted to send them this episode but it gets to be too hostile to be productive in my opinion. Love and solidarity and keep up the good fight.

Rev Left Radio

I hear you, and maybe I did get a little aggressive toward the end but I was thinking more about the ecosystem of discourse than the guy himself. My disdain was towards those promoting it more than the guy who made it. The guy seems decent enough, kinda like most americans: a random mix of ideas, some good, others not so great. He voted for Biden and shit on the right who were trying to appropriate him for their ends which is interesting. As for the psyop, i stay away from making that claim too much. What I was trying to get at was the seemingly astroturfed out-of-nowhere virality of him and his song, not that it was a deep state CIA intel op or anything of that sort! But that was speculation. In any case, I hear you and dont totally disagree. I apprecaite the critical feedback, my friend, and the support for the show!

Niki Hanson

I would be interested on your take of "Sounds of Freedom"... I haven't watched it, because it's not new to me. I personally feel like it's new to those who know privledge... It pisses me off as an advocate for housing, education and health, that some crisis' turn into the flavor of the day or trendy and all of a sudden something people care about for a few minutes. Ffs this is happening all around the world for decades, even in my little 75,000 northern BC, Canadian home! Btw, I had no idea about this song,, it's not my jam. I love the show though. Wishing you and your family the best!

Steven Phillips

Thanks for this!!! And what’s your IG??

Dustin Deane

As a working class man in the Northside of Richmond, I can confirm that Oliver didn’t come close to addressing the influx of capital from Northern Virginia/ DC to the Richmond area. The petty bourgeoisie of NoVA are coming here to set up shop and gentrifying the city at a rapid rate.