Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

Breht reads and comments on the opening chapter of Domenico Losurdo's "Stalin: History and Critique of a Black Legend", translated only very recently into English from the original Italian by Henry Hakamaki and Salvatore Engel-Di Mauro.

Files

Comments

KB

I’m reading this now, too. Hard to put down.

Daewoo

Where's the episode of you interviewing Henry and Salvatore? Can only find the Guerrilla History discussion between them and David Peat. Great reading!

Quinn

Loving this book so much

Upstream

Came here to ask the same question!

Rev Left Radio

sorry folks, this patreon was ready way before the public ep, but it is coming in the next week or two. I record this sort of out of order of their posting, and public eps always take more time to edit than patreon eps. But it will out shortly, and in the meantime, you can check out the GH ep on it OR the Millennials Are Killing Capitalism ep with Henry if you so desire!

Upstream

thanks breht ✊

VivaLaXVBrigada

One of the most impressive books I’ve ever read!

Brett

I gotta say, the excerpt that was read is extremely frustrating. There’s valid criticisms to be made of both Trotsky and Kruschev, but to blame their criticisms of Stalin as “monster-making” and self-serving - and therefore wrong - is fairly stupid IMO. Were their criticisms of Stalin in fact self-serving? Sure. But that doesn’t really determine the truth value of the claims made against Stalin. Also, complaining about Trotsky’s criticisms of Stalin is really quite rich considering that Stalin himself invented the (very) self-serving term “Trotskyist” to libel and defame all of his opponents and to associate every evil with Trotsky. Stalin was a master of the very thing the author declaims. Let’s also not forget that it was Trotsky who was murdered by an agent of the USSR under Stalin’s (presumed) orders, and not the other way around. I short, the book seems to have done the exact thing it accuses everyone else of doing.

Chaim Jones

I’m reading the book now. It’s challenging: both because it demands close attention, and because it calls into question the received “truths” about Stalin that those of us raised in the USA have been marinated in. An outstanding example of historical materialist analysis. It’s helping me to learn and develop. Thanks for letting us know about it!

lescassowaries

bought the book! excited to get into it