Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

These are the questions I was asked by Jared from MaKC, and Im VERY excited to release this episode in a week or two, as I truly l think its one of the better episodes I've done in a while!

Here are the questions Ill be answering in detail:


- One of the things I find interesting is that supposedly earlier versions of this were known as the Communist Catechism or Confession of Faith. And I find that really interesting, because obviously I know that Engles is famous for advocating a scientific orientation to communism to differentiate it from idealistic notions. But I do think it’s really important to situate that Marx and Engels came up in a world where there were a lot of faith-based advocates of a socialism of one form or another. I know we’ll get into that a bit more later as we talk about some of the differentiation Engels makes between types of socialists. I know you’ve spent many years now studying communist history and philosophy through the work you do on your podcasts as well as I’m sure through your organizing. So I was just curious if you had any thoughts on these ideas of faith, and catechism and even manifestos as documents often coming out of certain religious traditions in Europe, and maybe if it doesn’t say something specifically about Marx & Engels, perhaps it does say something about the people they were seeking to relate to in their own efforts at building a revolutionary movement.


- So to kind of continue on this point and to get us into the text a bit. What are some of the important interventions or clarifications you think that Engels is making in this piece? (and feel free to just quote or read aloud portions of the text or just summarize whatever works best for you)


- For folks who may not have as much of a background in the rationale behind the centrality of the proletariat in communist theory, can you say a bit about Engels’ remarks on the proletariat here in the text. He spends some time laying out what is meant by that term, explaining why it is central to the communist program, and then comparing the proletariat to various other kinds of groups of workers, artisans, serfs, slaves, and so on. Obviously today we could add even more categories to this document, and many folks get very focused on this idea of who is and who is not the actual proletariat, and then many folks probably don’t spend enough time thinking about this at all. What do you think was the importance of Engels doing this in this text and how useful of an exercise do you think it is for folks today?


- The Abolition of Private Property is central to communism and as such it makes sense that it would be central here. What stood out to you in this discussion of private property, the rationale behind that horizon, and the method that Engles lays out for achieving that in the text? Obviously he can’t lay out everything in terms of what a communist society would entail or a transition to communism, but he does lay out some key principles here. So what stood out to you in this discussion of the abolition of private property.


- I wanted to read one quote here: "Just as the peasants and manufacturing workers of the last century changed their whole way of life and became quite different people when they were drawn into big industry, in the same way, communal control over production by society as a whole,and the resulting new development, will both require an entirely different kind of human material." This was a passage we discussed a bit with China Miéville last year regarding his book on the Communist Manifesto. And Engels goes on to talk a bit more about what he means here. What do you see within this text and within your broader engagement with communist thought as the implications for humanity and the type of evolution or revolution in human development that would be enabled by communism?


- There’s not a lot of discussion here about the implications for familial relations and patriarchy, but there are some important comments made which have significant implications. I know you have also done episodes along with your co-host Alyson on the Red Menace on Engels’ text, "The Origin of the Family, Private Property, and the State," and I wondered if you saw seeds of that text here or perhaps some really important comments that Engels would further elaborate in that text. 


- So there is a section also where he delineates between socialists and communists. And from my understanding this distinction might be a bit specific to the period, because socialists in that period - at least as I understand it - were a bit different from the ways we might use that term today. As in, the socialists he describes here it seems to me are not scientific socialists but a range of groups who held on to certain idealistic notions of socialism or regressive or reactionary or bourgeois ideas. Now even though distinguishing between these groups as “socialists” on the one hand and “Communists” on the other, may no longer be as common, I think his critiques of these groups do still apply to many groups on the left today. What were your thoughts on this section? 


- Obviously this is a text that was written almost 180 years ago and it is a text that was written primarily through consideration of capitalist development in England and Germany. Are there parts of this document that you think if read dogmatically could lead to bad practice? In other words are there any formulations by Engels here that you took issue with in reading this text or think, well maybe that applied well to the concrete situation he was analyzing, but it might need to be supplemented or reformulated in other contexts?


Comments

Philip M

Stoked for this!!!

Cookie

Looking to the revleft sphere and possibly breht for suggestions— A young person in my life is really on the cusp between radicalization to the left and… the man-o-sphere. Joe Rogan, new age spirituality, and even more sordid influences are in his life. Fortunately he also has some anarchist friends and intuitively grasps that capitalism is bullshit. Looking for suggestions on podcasts that are even more accessible than revleft for basic historical and political education. He’s only got a high school diploma and I know that unfortunately revleft and red menace will prob leave him in the dust.

Rev Left Radio

Ah, thats a tough one. It may seem weird to some but my knee jerk thought was something like Chapo? Their somewhat edgy humor might appeal to him, they are much more accessible as they tend to focus on current events and electoral politics instead of theory or history, and overall might funnel him away by the worst of those influences you named by their brutal mockery of such right wing figures and movements. Accessible theory is kinda an oxymoron, as theory implies some level of difficulty and pre-requisite knowledge to some extent. as for the new age spirituality nonsense, there must be some episodes ive done on spirituality and buddhism that could be accessible to him and would work in the opposite direction of the worst impulses of new age grifting gurus and the right wing grifitng political stuff they often sneak in for clout. I wish there were more good influences on the radical left specifically for young men in particular that could address some of what young men are interested in while also pushing them away from the dead end that is the manosphere reactionary bullshit as well as the libertarian Rogan conspiracy-brained machismo stuff (tho rogans moderation *sometimes* pushes in the opposite direction of the hard right on certain important issues). Overall I dont have any great answers, maybe others will. But thats the stuff that jumped to my mind fwiw. I know Chapo can be divisive for some, but as a general intro to left-of-liberal politics for young guys w an edgier taste in humor, it might genuinely be helpful instead of harmful. Some on twitter argue Chapo is a funnel to the right, and I honestly laugh at that. That seems totally incorrect.

crowbar9

Citations Needed (citations with an “s” at the end as there is another similarly named podcast without it) is a more accessible left podcast. It focuses more on the media and contemporary topics but also provides some historical context without being heavy on theory. There may even be episodes on rogan and new age stuff somewhere in their back catalog, I can’t remember for sure - but if not, they still have a lot of good stuff

Jose Alvarez

Second Thought is a YouTube channel,not a podcast, but I think it’s a good start

Cheffo Zacho

I'd second Chapo for the reasons Breht laid out (I also really enjoy it most of the time tbh). If your friend has Spotify, someone has uploaded audio recordings of a bunch of Michael Parenti's lectures/speeches, they're mostly around an hour long and he was a great public speaker, quite funny, very passionate yet speaks in pretty plain language. I found that as a younger person anti-imperialist stuff really drew me further left as the contradictions and brutality of the imperial war machine are so blatantly monstrous that anyone who spoke eloquently against it appealed to me. Ironically Ron Paul in his heyday helped push me left (I was like 18 and he was good at saying the quiet part quiet if you know what I mean). I hope you can help your friend see the light, there are so many confused young people out there who know instinctively that the system is fucked beyond belief and are searching for answers, it's tragic that so many of them find the wrong ones.

Cookie

Homeboy listened to the sword and the dollar the other day and LOVED it. Michael parenti is def the ambassador we needed