Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

Breht discusses the UAW strike (and recent street fight), Trump and Biden pandering to working people, the 2024 election, "accelerationist resignation", how Covid impacted and traumatized people on the left and right, Jimmy Dore V. Cornel West, the beautiful sport of American football, and Friedrich Engel's The Principles of Communism.

Files

Comments

Saya Clarke

Great episode and I'd like to comment on some points you've made here. First I'd like to say that I too have started to prepare for a Trump victory. Last time around I fell pretty hard for the Trump-Russia conspiracy nonsense. I suppose I just really wanted to see him taken down because it really was that difficult for me to believe that anyone could have voted for the man. He did a lot of damage last time by single-handedly upending the federal judiciary and setting back the Liberal rights-based order by decades. This time around the only thing I am scared of is that there might be some national restriction on transition related healthcare or at the very least, continued escalation of scare-mongering and venomous attacks on me and others like me who are just trying to survive in a country that doesn't fundamentally believe we should exist. My next comment is about your views on Covid. While I do agree that the virus is not as widespread, not as dangerous for the vast majority of the population, I can't help but feel that we still have a responsibility to understand how the state utterly failed to protect us from a deadly virus. A million people died needlessly at the altar of Capital and it wasn't just because right wingers refused to fall in line. The most vulnerable people were, and still are, black people, poor people, and disabled people for obvious reasons. And after everything that happened, has anything changed? Absolutely not and some of us feel the need to organize along these lines to push for change after the government's catastrophic failure and subsequent unloading of responsibility to vaccinate/test/etc. to the private market right as the Medicaid "Unwinding" is taking place and millions of people are purged from the program for no other reason than clerical errors or failure to respond to a letter in the mail. The sociological production of the end of the pandemic was/is just one vector by which the state has responded to the 2020 uprising by clamping down broadly on people's bodily autonomy. The vectors being a gestator's right to abort, trans people's (kid's) and their families right to seek treatment, and a disabled person/immunocompromised person's right to not get sick. Perhaps it is a bit woo-woo conspiracy of me to think that but I do feel like attacks along these vectors are a direct response to the 2020 uprising and have proven much more effective for the state than a direct response. There was also a recent court ruling in California (Kuciemba V Victory Woodworks) that denied a covid worker's compensation claim because recognizing employer liability would have "the potential to destroy businesses and curtail, if not outright end, the provision of essential public services." So the court basically ruled that Covid is so widespread and ubiquitous that we couldn't possible expect employers to take precautions, lest they lose profit. All I'm saying is that it didn't have to be this way. We shouldn't have to live in a society that forces us to get sick, by Covid or any other way and then denies us care, forces us to work anyways and shames us for wanting to protect ourselves.

Saya Clarke

“…its deed is murder just as surely as the deed of the single individual; disguised, malicious murder, murder against which none can defend himself, which does not seem what it is, because no man sees the murderer, because the death of the victim seems a natural one, since the offence is more one of omission than of commission. But murder it remains.” -Engels on Social Murder I typed my first comment quickly at work so to clarify here: Covid has been and should be a site of struggle. Indeed there are few people who are still deeply affected by the ongoing pandemic, it is ongoing wether people believe it or not, but just because they are a minority of people doesn’t mean that we shouldn’t fight for their right to participate in society and having a healthy, well-informed populace is the key factor limiting their participation. That person you see still wearing a mask at work or in public? Call them neurotic or dramatic but they might be or know someone who is particularly vulnerable and perhaps they want to protect that someone, their child, their parent, their friend or themselves. We shouldn’t be shaming them or alienating them, we should have solidarity with them and see them as fellow humans who are only trying to protect themselves. As we all know, most people are just one emergency health episode away from finanial ruin and catching covid, a disease that should have and still could be prevented not just through appropriate masking but through a broader network of community health advocacy, could upend their life or their family’s lives. Health justice concerns everyone. You know how liberals worry that Medicare for All might lead to communism? Well some of us believe this to be true and also believe that Capitalism fundamentally relies on keeping us sick and without proper healthcare. That is where some of us are struggling and Covid is just one aspect of that struggle. I do not think if you don’t mask you are a bad person or you don’t care about people but if you are shitting on people who still mask or advocate for populations that are particularly vulnerable to disease and injury you are being counterproductive and it goes against everything we believe as Marxists who want to live in a society where everyone is welcome and has voice. For me, that includes disabled, immunocomprimised individuals and those without proper health care. I say Medicare for All NOW Solidarity Forever!. ALL care for ALL people and nothing less.

Ben Tracy

Feel compelled to add: Trump didn't even go to see any worker from the UAW! He went to a non-union plant

Gage Bayless

Got carried hard by Allen and the Zack Moss guy that I snagged from you 😉😂

dare

great episode, only concern is ur conversation around mask wearing on the left, at least from the sphere that im in this conversation comes from disabled comrades talking about ableism within the left and how we should be wearing masks not only to show solidarity but as a way to allow these comrades to participate in our communal spaces. I would love to see an episode on the topic of disability and marxism :)

Danny Boy

Love your "op-ed" episodes, maybe even more than your normal eps.

Lefty In Training

NGL, I lost count of the brain cells I lost listening to that Jimmy Dore clip. "Cross Fire" style shout-fest interviews were dumb in my day, and I find them even more tiresome now. As far as COVID, I think we can still present rational, evidence-based arguments for why we should still be taking COVID nearly or as seriously as we should have at the outbreak. At least in the US, cases are going up even though it's not winter yet and reinfection can lead to some debilitating mid- and long-term conditions that I feel are underestimated in the mass discourse. Obviously, the finger wagging and bad-faith arguments on the right and so-called left only hurt things, but you might want to check out some COVID update streams from Socialism For All. I feel they do a good job at giving sober and appropriately stressed evaluations of the current state of COVID in the US.

Chaim Jones

About COVID, I find the People’s CDC a good source of info, and the Death Panel podcast has analysis from a rev left perspective.

Rev Left Radio

I agree with virtually all of that, my friend. I totally understand the states colossal and ONGOING failure on this front, I understand some are uniquely and sadly still very at threat of it, and I agree with your solutions. I also understand that people wear masks for various reasons that I may not be privy to. The only things I attacked in this episode are the hyper-moralist finger waggers who think everyone everywhere should still be wearing N95s or else they are just as bad as fascists, and yes I did poke a little fun at the lady walking totally alone outside wearing one - though admittedly I do not know her situation. I just cant imagine a scenario in which going out to walk your dog alone requires such. But again, I fully support peoples right to do that if they feel its best for them. My main argument on that front was merely that the pandemic has traumatized lots of people, and for some that trauma has needlessly and without scientific basis prompted them to continue acting like its May of 2020, that we dont have an array of vaccines and treatments now, that most people already have natural immunity plus multiple vaccinations, and that these things really do decrease the risk SUBSTANTIALLY for the vast majority of people. Of course there are some who are and will remain vulnerable, just as they are to other common diseases like the flu - which itself kills tens of thousands of people yearly and yet doesn't prompt the same response. In any case, we agree on the things that need to be done to help people in general and those still at risk from covid!

Rev Left Radio

Yes I was actually unaware of that at the time. I thought he had or had said he was going to speak to the strikers, but of course later that die I saw he didnt even do that lol. Classic trump

Rev Left Radio

That is totally fair and important for sure. Certainly worthy of discussion and important in organizational spaces.

Rev Left Radio

Thank you, I can certainly let my hair down on these patreon episodes in a way I am hesitatant to do on the public feed since that requires me to be able to bring in guests, some esteemed and professional ones, that might not feel as comfy with a fire breathing, cussing, angry Breht lmao

Rev Left Radio

Thank you for the recommendation and Ill check it out. Im familiar with S4A too. I agree its still an issue that needs to be taken seriously, I just think it can and often does go too far from certain camps on the left and right in their own uniquely overwrought way

Daewoo

Listening to this after the Packers got their ass kicked was pretty funny. Combat Orcas owner, he/they, and I forgot about the draft, but put together a good pre-draft ranking I guess. I do want to add a bit of criticism about the person walking their dog wearing a mask. There could be any number of reasons a person would wear a mask alone outside, including a finger-wagging person that thinks non-maksers are bad people, who I think you're directing your ire, but another could be that they are themselves sick with COVID and don't want to spread it to others while they care for their dog. Or they are immunocompromised and dont want to come across . Who knows? But I don't think you gotta bring them up and poke fun at them, unless they are truly deserving. But great episode overall!

Ana

Hi Breht, first I’ll say thank you for all the effort you continue to put into this project. Rev Left has been an instrumental resource to my own political education since 2020, and I respect your work a lot. I want to offer some well-intentioned but blunt criticism of your segment on Covid and masking: I found it shockingly ignorant and dismissive. You are in fact out of touch with the science on a number of key points, which I won’t get into here. I am more disappointed that you seem to have a massive blind spot in your politics when it comes to health and disability under capitalism? It has been a site of struggle since before Engels wrote about it, and will continue to be a huge factor in every other future crisis you mentioned. And your response to seeing someone wearing a mask is to say they’re participating in “insanity”? Where is the empathy and solidarity? Very disappointing lack of critical analysis compared to what Rev Left normally produces. I’ve seen others recommending the Death Panel podcast and their book Health Communism. I sincerely hope that you engage with these and other resources. We cannot afford to include readymade eugenic frameworks in our politics.

Dave Lunn

Random question, is there a reason all your Patreon episodes cut out while you're mid-sentence?

Brian

For all the criticisms I have of Jimmy Dore, he did make some valid points in other areas of the interview. He calls out West for his pandering to the lesser-of-two-evilism crowd that he knowingly engages in. Calling trump fascist without extending the same title to Biden is just ahistorical. I wouldn’t be so quick to completely dismiss Jimmy Dore and his viewership. He absolutely has reactionary views but he’s one of the loudest anti-war voices in our media landscape and is constantly calling out capitalists (as seen in his recent address to the UN Security Council). For that alone his platform is a vital instrument for spreading class consciousness. We can’t let purity get in the way of organizing based on class. Lenin argued against it for good reason. There would have been no revolution in history if we dismissed reactionaries out of hand.

Thomas Sankara

1,500 Americans are still dying per week from Covid yet “it’s so over” in your view. Who exactly is the one that’s traumatized here? If I wanted to listen to heartless leftist commentary I would tune in to chapo.

Irene

Hi Breht, curious about the Jonathan Melrod interview. Do you have to be in a specific Patreon tier to access that one? Thanks!

Ellie Jane

Hi breht, first off I love rev left radio and have learned so much from you and your comrades. I normally never post on Patreon comments but i was disappointed to hear your takes on Covid and was puzzled to find it unaligned with most leftist views . Covid is much more serious than the flu and the two shouldn’t be compared so closely! The pandemic has turned my life completely upside down. In august 2022, My partner caught Covid right before his chemo treatment and was not able to get chemotherapy in time because of contracting Covid. Weeks later he passed away unexpectedly despite being 41, fairly healthy and being told he would have a good survival rate. He wasn’t able to die with dignity in palliative care because that unit had a Covid outbreak of people dying of Covid taking up the rooms so that in itself was highly traumatic. So he had to spend his last days stressed out in the ER. it makes me insane knowing that most hospitals in the US don’t require masks now and our govt is still handling it so poorly. Also My dear friend and comrade who used to be a farmer and coworker of mine got Long Covid and now is disabled and cannot work. I am not a strict mask-er and I still go to social events although weary of it but I try to mask regularly at grocery stores and public transportation (and hospitals ofc) for the bare minimum. Also I’m not sure what treatments you are thinking of for Covid? Anyways, I’m also weary of what the long term effects will be of our population getting Covid multiple times . So I do think countries like China are on to something about being much more strict and community conscious . From what I understand they are protecting their population from something much more sinister us Americans don’t want to or bother to think about - the virus’s long term effects we’re still very much in the dark about . My comment isn’t supposed to claim bad intentions on you or an attack but rather where I’m coming from with my own Covid experiences and why people like myself would be upset by your messaging on it. Sending much gratitude for your work . Please don’t stop doing what you’re doing I am still a dedicated Patreon fan .

Yohance

It’s on guerrilla history public feed

Joseph

I think it's something weird with Patreon, if you rewind by like 20 seconds and then hit play you'll get the full closing. It cuts the audio short 15 seconds, at least for me on mobile

Rev Left Radio

I really appreciate and take to heart your feedback and constructive criticism. I am willing to admit when I get something wrong. I was speaking extemporaneously and so was probably not as precise or as careful as I should have been. I am so sorry to hear about your partner, and I send you nothing but my love and support. When my father was dying of alcoholism during covid, he too would be in over-crowded hospitals and I remember him calling me and crying that he was left in a crowded hallway - the indignity and lack of privacy and general feeling that he was not important really fucked him up and made him suffer needlessly in his last days. Your points are totally valid and I will reassess my position on Covid going forward by going a little deeper into the current science and where things are at currently. My comment about the flu was not to compare it with covid in a vacuum, but to assert that at this point, with the vaccinations, natural immunity, and other factors that it has a similar endemic place in our society for better or worse. The flu kills tens of thousands of Americans every year still, so that comparison was not meant to downplay either of them, just to assert (perhaps wrongly but sincerely in the moment) that they are similar threats in general at this point. However, your point about long covid stands, and the uncertainty about its long term effects is definitely a good point and reason for concern. In any case, I will, as i said, genuinely reassess my position and speak more carefully on the topic in the future. Thank you for your support and from teh bottom of my heart I am again so sorry for your loss. <3

Rev Left Radio

Yes it is on both the GH feed and the RLR public feed!

Chase

Another banger