Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

Alyson and Breht discuss the ongoing national liberation struggle in Palestine. Together, they discuss the incredible shift in public opinion on Israel and Palestine, the internal and external contradictions culminating in unison for Israel, the discussion about whether or not what Israel is doing is technically a genocide (it absolutely is), international law, Frantz Fanon on the psychology of national liberation, the prospects of a broader regional war, the possibilities of Turkish or Iranian engagement, the history and core elements of Zionism, the analytical importance of the settler colonial and decolonization frameworks, the disgusting role that Biden and the Democratic Party are playing in manufacturing consent for Israel's civilian mass murder campaign, the "lesser of two genocider" arguments being trotted out by liberals, how Hamas is basically an orphan army of men who have had their families killed by Israel in previous assaults, why we should reject the "terrorist" framing of the western ruling elites, what the Palestinian resistance has managed to accomplish, and what might emerge from the Ruins of Gaza when all is said and done...

(recorded Oct. 30th 2023)

Files

Comments

Landis Brown

My morning commute is looking way better tomorrow.

Gabriel Alvarado

You and Alyson should be proud, it is exactly these podcasts this alternative media that has made a significant difference in combating the status quo narrative. Thank you both for all the hard work you put into these episodes. Seriously though my comment is a understatement

The Fine Art Revolution

Breht you had an episode about two months ago about your ideas on the fourth american crisis. You gave a timeline of 10-25 years, but I can't help but feel that was optimistic. It might be here, in its entirety, right now.

Rev Left Radio

It genuinely means so much to me (and her) to hear that, my friend. Its high praise and I am humbled by it. I deeply appreciate your longstanding support of the show, Gabriel. Truly. P.S. Ill make sure she sees this too! :)

Rev Left Radio

Im so glad you remember that! Because yes I am thinking the same thing... I had it pinned to the late 2020's, but this escalates and accelerates everything. In any case, its totally in line with the idea of the Fourth Great American Crisis, absolutley!

Meltedpiano

Breht I've learned so much from you and your comrades on all three podcasts. I feel like I see things so much more clearly and I love the passion you all bring to this. Thank you so much. I'll be listening!

Spiderdijo7

Not sure if it's just me but the Libsyn thingie didn't work. Luckily Imma patron 😏 Thanks cdes!

HailZeus

How can i contact Breht? I messaged through here when i first signed up as a patron over two years ago, and when the discord was still up and running AND the private facebook group and I've never had a reply. I can understand being busy, but so busy in two years i can't get any response? I mean how does anyone get a hold of you? I don't support you at a high level, but it still feels very cheapening that i have been a long time supporter and began to do so before i even had a stable job. I see other ppl on these posts asking for how they can get ahold of your or your discord and no one seems to know. Will re-post this to youur DM on here, hopefully you answer. I'd like to be able to at least once in a blue moon get some tangible acknowledgement that i exist from someone i'm paying money to. (sorry, not sorry)

Foko

Great episode, thank you both so much!

kylewiebe

The sense of urgency you have reminds me of Stan by Eminem, lol. He's said in the past he can't respond to everyone. If you want to reach him either upgrade your membership to Engels level or just try and be the first to respond to a new episode.

From The River To The Sea 🇵🇸

In the past he has commented that his DMs are so full he can’t respond to everyone. Sometimes he responds to comments on here but given the high quality of the episodes, he naturally gets a lot of comments too. I think at one point he recommended emailing the show. I think the address is available on the website. I wouldn’t take the lack response personally.

crowbar9

Great analysis, really appreciate the work you both put into this. I think it would be beneficial to consider doing a segment on a future update episode clarifying what you both believe would be a principled marxist position towards hamas as an organization, specifically ideological differences and tactics but whatever else comes to mind as well. I suggest this not as a way to condemn hamas, who marxists should support insofar as they are fighting a struggle for national liberation, but as a way of orienting ourselves correctly to an ongoing situation and combatting reductive liberal arguments that have appealed to many on the left who would otherwise agree with the majority of the content in this episode. For example, if marxists (or the “radical left” as we are more commonly called) do not unequivocally condemn hamas, it means we endorse the killing of civilians as a valid tactic in any struggle, which in turn justifies their continued hatred of “tankies” and pushes them further towards the center and less likely to engage with the rest of our analysis on this situation or any other.

Rev Left Radio

Hm, It seems to work for me? Hopefully it was just a glitch on your end. Glad you got to access it regardless though! Appreciate you listening.

Rev Left Radio

Hey Hailzeus, Apologies for any frustration. I have said on a few occasions that the one place where I can definitely respond is here in the comment sections of our patreon. DMs on here, social media tags, and anything else I am simply unable to keep up with. We do not have a staff or anything, its all literally just me when it comes to maintaining all of our accounts, media pages, and responding to people. Its not that I am literally busy 24/7 (though I do have three kids, go to school for my masters, and have 4 podcasts, im doing my best!) its just that I cannot keep up with messages from everywhere and so I prioritize the comment sections of patreon posts as the one and only place that I can keep up with! Def never take it personally, as it is not personal whatsoever. At the beginning of the show, I went out of my way to respond to everybody on every platform and as the show has grown, that has become utterly impossible. That's all. NO disrespect intended. Please feel free to tell me whatever you want to tell me here and I will make sure I return to this page and respond in full to whatever you have to say. I appreciate the support and the long time listening.

Spiderdijo7

Yeah probably an issue my end, it was a good ep., always enjoy you two getting together. BTW have you considered doing the PFLP pamphlet for an episode. I'm reading it now and it's really helping my thinking on the Palestine issue. It was written in '69 but carries through to now obviously. It's called "Strategy for the Liberation of Palestine" and they are Arab Marxists, Mao inspired ones.

Rev Left Radio

Thank you for listening! Ill say this: If a zionist says support for Palestinian resistance means support for killing innocent people, then you can easily say support for zionism ENSURES children on both sides will die. We hate innocent people being killed anywhere in the world for any reason. Which is why we want to end the process that makes violence, and the deaths of innocents, inevitable: colonial apartheid oppression. We seek to create a world that addresses such oppression at the root level and, well, roots it out of the world, such that we have the global material basis for true, lasting peace and cooperation. In the material reality created by, in this case, colonialism, violence results and will always result. Moreover, Zionism makes the world less safe for Jewish people and Israeli occupation puts Israeli people in real mortal danger. So instead of spending time condemning the symptoms of oppression (ie. innocent people dying), our goal is to address the disease that causes the symptoms (the occupation and oppression of Palestinian people). If someone is truly concerned for innocent people and their well being, then they are forced to support decolonization and the end of the occupation. Since that is literally the way out to end the cycle of violence. If they dont want to end the occupation, then they dont care about innocent people at all. I often use this analogy to slavery: if during slavery there is a slave revolt and the slave owners house is burnt down in that revolt, resulting in the death of him and his family, is the solution to condemn the slaves for revolting, or is the solution to condemn and end slavery and the bringing of children into the context of slavery? If someone wanted to hyper-focus on the family that was killed, while still wanting to maintain the system that resulted in that violence, then that person really doesnt care about that family or protecting other families. The only solution is to end slavery. Same basic logic here imo.

HailZeus

Edit : this original comment response was aimed at the person who said I sounded like the Eminem song." Yeah keep mocking because there isnt enough infighting." I was trying to share a way to help someone doing some very difficult Praxis currently. I checked the tiers and currently none of them listed private message priority. I mean are we really going to resort to a paywall in order to say "here are some principled marxists trying to unionize and have been retaliated against, if you can help them out please do"? Are we really going to nickel and dime THAT? Edit #2...............This is the only thing I really wanted to share before that other person tried to be dismissive. ................... For anyone interested in helping here is the link: https://gofund.me/2c94ab24 .

HailZeus

To Breht, im sorry if there was a miscommunication about my replies, this particular comment is for you. The the only thing I really wanted to share before that other person tried to be dismissive was the fundraising link and to ask if you would not mind mentioning it on one of the next few episodes whicheverone it feels appropriate if you decide to do it. ................... here is the link: https://gofund.me/2c94ab24 . It was setup by a Marxist Leninist who goes by Polinkazh online. In any case there was some miscommunication with the way replies loaded on my end and I'm sorry about that. Also I deeply appreciate you responding to me. I just wanted to ask for some help on someone else's behalf is all, and the first reply I got was someone implying I was deranged like the eminem fan. Lastly I enjoyed the recent episode where you gave your takes on the current Palestinian genocide. Keep up the good work we need to keep shifting the Overton window.

Behniji

Hi! First time commenter long time listener. I must say, that Palestine on Fire episode should be required listening for anyone on the left. Brett (sp?), would love to hear a breakdown of the Hannibal directive and the samson option. I believe more people need to know about these. 🙏🏼

crowbar9

Thanks for the response - agreed on all points. The hyper focus on a specific event instead of long term historical processes is for sure a hallmark of liberal thought. To elaborate on my original comment, the issue of targeting and killing civilians was only an example, and probably the most pertinent one given the media focus on this one event. Given the knowledge and theory we have gained from previous resistance movements across the world, how should marxists orient themselves towards the ideology and tactics employed by hamas both currently and historically? Does it change because they are operating in a colonial context as opposed to an internal struggle? Will ideological differences be a cause for concern in the future? Are their tactics likely to be effective or counterproductive long term? To be clear, i’m not trying to moralize or act as an armchair critic, but just throwing out some questions for consideration. Every resistance movement can provide us with a situation to analyze and learn from, both the good and the bad and although it may be too soon to answer any of the above with certainty, i’d love to hear a future discussion on this if you are both willing.

blursville

Been a Kim fan since her metal blogging days. Happy to support her vital work in extreme music and labor politics.

Rev Left Radio

Hey Hailzeus, no worries my friend! Shit happens, but i am glad we are able to connect. Yes, I will plug the fundraiser in an upcoming episode or two for sure! Thank you for the kind words and your long-standing support of the show!

Rev Left Radio

Great point! Ill try to weave that into future discussions on the topic! Thank you for listening and for the kind words!

Ryan

Excellent episode. Thanks to both of you for your work.

Finn 415

I can't remember if I heard it on this episode or another recent one on Gaza, but Breht, I remember you saying somewhere that 80% (or some figure like that) of Hamas fighters are orphans. Can you (or anyone reading this) point me to where you read that so I can cite it in a school assignment I'm working on? I'm not finding it online, but of course google skews everything towards Western/Zionist sources. Thanks!

Rev Left Radio

Hey Finn, Im racking my brain over the original source. Ive heard it several times, perhaps from the Palestinian resistance itself, but can't remember where! I think it was from Hamas leadership? Perhaps try pursuing that and see what you can find, but yea Google really obscures such searches. LMK if you have any luck, and I'll keep trying to remember and find it myself! Apologies.

Finn 415

Okay well I appreciate the reply anyway! I'm gonna see if some of my friends who are better at the internet than I can find it. I'll let you know if it's unearthed. As an aside, boy do I appreciate the work you and Allyson do! It's really done wonders to my political development these past few years. I'm greatly indebted to you two!