Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hey everyone, please use the comment section to ask any and all questions for me that you may have, and I will answer as many as I can in the next patreon episode!

Thank you all so much for your continued support of the show, and I look forward to navigating this uncertain and chaotic year with you all. <3

Comments

Jack Hall

Hey Breht! I was wondering, do you consider yourself a Maoist or MLM?

Jackson Duke

Can you share your thoughts on the Great Proletarian Cultural Revolution? I live in China and it seems like the current government doesn't want to discuss it much.

Stephen S.

Hey Breht, when you teach, if you were to teach any class at HS (or for question’s sake), college level, what would you teach?

Quém é

Hey Breht, thanks for doing these! I'm curious if you could elaborate on your thoughts on the state of the PRC and its current revolutionary potential / whethet you think its planned transition to democratic centralism is authentic. Further, who was influential in developing your current stance?

Kyle A.

What can I do to help the people of Palestine? I’m working to be able to donate more money, but other than that + learning/reading about the conflict, I’m not a doctor and I don’t have reach on social media, so I’m not sure what I can do.

Colton Burross

Hey brother I recently got fired from my job at Starbucks after working there for over four years and the incident I got fired over was a minor incident for saying “dumbass” on the mic. No customers heard me so it wasn’t an issue with that. The supervisor sent me home over it without warning and I waited two weeks to see what would happen. I thought maybe we moved on from it but my store manager was pressured to terminate me. I can’t help but be mad at myself but also the situation over a petty incident. It hurts because I live away from my family and all of my close friends were at my store. I’ve lost my sense of community and unfortunately I live in TX so my store isn’t unionized. I have autism as well so I try harder to filter myself. I’ve been thinking lately about how cruel this system is, how corporations don’t value human life and will rob us of our livelihoods and sense of community over petty things. I understand that my self-worth is not dependent on my job, but it’s almost hard to not feel that way when we live in a system that conditions us this way. I’ve been reading Lenin more lately and thinking about how employers don’t value human life. Is there any advice you could give me Breht from a fellow comrade in dealing with this crisis moment in my life?

Elliott Becker

Breht, will you get coffee with me and talk about Buddhism and meditation when I next visit my partners family in Omaha?

Andrew Blake

Can you give a brief overview of contemporary (North American) Marxist organizations and your estimation of the likelihood of each becoming a true leninist vanguard? I'd love to just know what is out there, what each does, how big they are, and what the most common criticisms of each are.

Terra

I understand this may be personal so to the extent you feel comfortable- what has been your family’s reaction (either family of origin or family you’ve chosen/created) to your political radicalization journey? ie are they aligned or at least supportive? has it changed your relationships?

Lana

We always hear calls on the left for "organizing" and for us to "get organized" and I'd love to hear from you on what exactly does that look like? What real, tangible steps can people take to make that happen and move the needle? Are there any national organizations out there that we can actually put our support into? I see a lot of people on the left calling to support PSL but a lot of others on the left oppose PSL, so as someone newish to the far left, it's tough trying to figure out who to follow. Would love some clarity.

m

i came here to ask this question as well!!

Alfred

I want to second the comment above asking for an assessment of orgs on the left. Even if criticism is avoided, maybe explaining what criticisms there are even if don't agree would be rad.

m

hey Breht! i've long been a listener of the whole rev left podcast family, and i always like the handful of times you've given your thoughts on tv and movies. recently you said you're more of a star trek person than star wars, so on that note, have you watched star trek: strange new worlds? i've found it refreshingly collectivist in its political ideology, and is unabashed in it being an explicitly communistic version of the future. additionally, if you haven't got around to watching star wars: andor, i highly recommend it. it's very far left, and has a lot on its mind regarding revolutionary violence. love and solidarity!!

Foko

Hi breht and dave (and everyone else on patreon!) i love you all, everyone here and around the world working to build a better future.

Liv

As did I! I’d love to learn some key takeaways from organizing locally and successfully, what that looks like for the people on Rev Left who have those experiences, as well as possible solutions to move past 2020-era reactive mobilization and towards a deliberate and strategic destruction of US empire.

Meltedpiano

Hey Breht, long time listener, first time commenter. I've been thinking about the many forms censorship takes toward the left and particularly the more subtle forms like shadow banning on social media platforms and making things harder to get unnecessarily like music with left messages. For example, the band Thrice has an album ( To be everywhere is to be nowhere) that YouTube doesn't allow access to which other platforms do or putting a content warning on the first Rage against the machine album so it won't play through. I know it doesn't seem like much but I'm noticing more and more of, what I'll call, covert censorship. I would love to hear your thoughts on this.

Meltedpiano

I'm interested in this as well and to piggyback, what do you think about revolutionary media like this preventing people from doing something in real life from a capitalist realism kind of perspective?

JK

Bumping these questions as well. I finally got organized this year with the IMT, Socialist Revolution. I’ve met so many great comrades and it’s given me new meaning and optimism. The biggest hurdle I’ve had is the wide spread disdain simply cause I read Trotsky. I just listened to your older episode, speaking with a trot and clarifying the misunderstandings. I really enjoyed it. We are starting to see huge growth on our end and was curious what you think about orgs like mine.

anna

I second or third the questions on finding good socialists organizations. The farthest I’ve gotten is googling organizations near me, finding the PSL, then subsequently seeing a lot of people being very critical of the PSL. Even if you don’t want to name specific organizations I think it would be helpful to hear some things to look out for while searching. Thank you! I know how important organizing is and without that I just consider myself a reader/scholar and not a communist and I would love to change that haha.

Beefdrip

OP, let me preface this by saying that I don't have much on the ground work and that everyone's experience is different. Two people might have great or horrible experiences with a single org. Personally, I'd see what party's active in your area and try joining based off of that. I'd read into the platforms on their site and see if that's something that you agree with and go from there. Recommendations are hard because every party has a unique line and requires a lot of time investment, and joining an org that doesn't work out for you can be a large emotional drain. It happened to me (no fault of the org) and I'm now just getting active again after a few years. I'd probably stick to the larger orgs like CPUSA, PSL, and FRSO (again, investigate them, their lines, their local activity, etc.) as a starting point. Where I live, they all work together more or less. DSA is also an option too and has the largest member base, though they're more demsoc, if I remember correctly. I probably wouldn't put too much stock onto what reddit or other pseudoanonymous online communities say unless there are some serious allegations or systemic issues that need to be investigated or addressed. I would tend to avoid smaller or lesser known parties for two reasons: 1). party building, especially when you're new, is very difficult and draining. 2). You might run into some weird cults of personalities or toxic situations. I believe PCUSA is suing a split from the main org, the American Council of Bolsheviks (ACB) over trademarks.

Beefdrip

1). Hey Breht, do you play many video games? With a family, I know you probably don't have a lot of time, but there are some great class conscious titles like Spec Ops: The Line, Suzerain, and Disco Elysium out there if you ever want to check them out. 2). As someone who also has OCD and severe anxiety issues, how have you reconciled your internal mental contradictions with on the ground class struggle/organization, or feeling that you're not doing enough? For example, I feel that I haven't been attending or keeping up with enough Palestine rallies, especially when they're out of state. The OCD in me feels like this is just an excuse on my end, that I could find some way if I truly wanted to, but part of me is saying that I'm being too hard on myself. So I end up getting in this cycle of self hatred/flagellation. 3). How do you personally deal with leftist infighting among mutual friends? It's kind of hard for me when I have confrontation issues and when every argument turns into an ideology battle over phraseology. It's tiring and I feel like I'm wasting my time since these debates never go anywhere, but it inevitably pops up again over minor stuff. 4). Growing up introverted in a toxic household has left me feeling unprepared for adult life. While I have a small friends group and have been making more, I don't really have any deep or meaningful relationships as the OCD makes it hard to trust people and this insecurity self sabotages me. I've been getting into new hobbies, but some of the people there are reactionaries which complicates things, as I don't want to hang out with misogynists. This is not to mention sexuality, as I'm still trying to figure that out, as I never really got the chance to explore that growing up in a traditional religious household (I think I'm ace, but I don't really know where to go from here). So I guess, how do you figure all of this shit out on your own, especially when you can't turn to family for advice?

Finn 415

This is going off of previous questions about finding organizations to join. Maybe I'm overly picky but I have reservations about all of the groups that currently exist. (As does my unorganized radical community - who are largely mellenials, veterans of the last 20 years of street based protest movements, Occupy, anti globalization, anti police, etc, but not in formal orgs) Do you think it's problematic to start new organizations? I could see arguments against because that's a lot of heavy lifting to get started and it might contribute to the feeling that the left is so dispersed all over the place. But then, on the other side, it could be an opportunity to have an org less bogged down in old dramas and questionable historic stances. Thanks for your thoughts and consideration!

Malvaceæ Jain d'Nimbuæ

¿What needs to change to turn the multipolar world into a multinational world, in the sense of its use by the policies of Cuba.

Breakerofchains

I don’t remember which episode it was but a while back you mentioned how capitalism is a necessary step in the process of the eventual goal of transitioning to communism. Would you be able to explain this point a bit further? I was a bit confused after I heard it. Someone could easily hear that point and argue that technically that would make someone a supporter of capitalism even if it’s only for this moment, so it would make sense to support it in this life time. Maybe in terms of industry and innovation? But we know labor is responsible for that. Idk I was a bit confused but it would be great if you can explain further! Thank you

Ty

Hey Brent, if we had a time machine, what historical figure would you bring to present day? Also, what are your thoughts on Gabor Mate and his writing? I feel like his views on addiction and mind body connection would be very in line with your understanding of the world.

al

Hi Breht! Really appreciate you and your work. Sorry if this has already been answered, but I'm interested to hear more of your thoughts/reflections on modern day China, as it seems to be quite politically polarizing, even in leftist circles and orgs. The US/Western world in particular is rabidly sinophobic, and navigating through what is just imperialist propaganda and what isn't can be confusing! I was wondering if you had a response (or suggested readings) about the ambivalence/criticism regarding China and how it does/doesn't connect to revisionism within MLM. I imagine China's role will be integral to the revolutionary struggle...? But it can be confusing to navigate. Also, any advice in regards to burn out?

Michelle Levin

Do you ever find it difficult to maintain familial relationships and friendships because of your Marxism? How do your radical views affect your personal life? Liberals seem to be able to get past ideological differences have healthy relationships in spite of them, as a Marxist for me I find it almost impossible and downright suffocating to live in the same house as Zionists

Seany G

Hi again Breht. I would like to know if you have considered other ways for people to financially support your shows beyond Patreon subscriptions. How did you decide on that mechanism, given their high fees (so I've heard; correct me if I'm wrong!)? eg. Have you considered Go-fund me, or other, options? Is it a question of convenience/ tax considerations /ethics/ politics? I have broached this topic before a couple of times but haven't heard a response / heard it addressed. I'm positive there are many people who would love to know whether there are more DIRECT ways to support your shows financially, rather than through a capitalist intermediary....... Please respond, here in the chat if not on AMA.... Thanks!

Ian Stockdale

Hey Breht, Malcolm X addressed the so-called Shakespeare Authorship Question in his autobiography, on p. 185: "Another hot debate I remember I was in had to do with the identity of Shakespeare. No color was involved there; I just got intrigued over the Shakespearean dilemma... In the prison debates I argued for the theory that King James himself was the real poet who used the nom de plume Shakespeare. King James was brilliant. " One of my pet peeves is the ad hominem 'argument' that anyone interested in the Shakespeare authorship question is a classist snob. As a doubter and a revolutionary leftist, I personally disprove this load of bollocks (but you don't know me personally). I actually not only doubt 'Shakespeare''s identity, but I agree with Malcolm that James was the real poet. I would love to hear your thoughts. Do you think Malcolm X was a closet monarchist? Why do you think he chose to include it in his autobiography?

Lana

Thanks, I appreciate your comment!

Josh

Would love to hear an episode dedicated to how we should go about building a dictatorship of the proletariat led by a vanguard party, whilst at the same time taking measures to prevent the rise of an individual dictatorship and / or party devoid of democratic centralism. This would get at the heart of why a lot of people are reluctant to embrace actually existing socialism. I think it’s important we take this question seriously and show that we have strategies to address it. Your comrade Josh from Perth, Western Australia

xander

Hey Breht, I think you're doing really cool work. and I really appreciate what you do. I am still somewhat new to your show, but have listened to maybe 50 or so episodes. I'm not sure if you're familiar with the anarchist Cindy Milstein. She talks a lot about the concept of creating a new world in the shell of the old. Do you have thoughts on that? Would you consider interrogating contemporary anarchist ideas and both their overlap and contrast with the philosophy and praxis you focus on? Much love

From The River To The Sea 🇵🇸

Great question. The more I’ve learned about China the less I believe it is communist at all. I do know Bret did an episode way back about whether China was communist or capitalist. You might look for that.

From The River To The Sea 🇵🇸

This doesn’t have to be answered specifically by Bret but why so much criticism about PSL? They seem like they do good work to me and I follow Brian Becker, Eugene Puryear, etc. journalism and it all seems pretty legit.

Beefdrip

Of the ones I've seen: - SocialismForAll (S4A) on YouTube criticizes them for their stance on multipolarity, IIRC. I think he is a bit too rigid about this topic and I think Breht & co's stance is a lot more nuanced. - I believe the modern PSL is a split of a split of a Marcyist group known as the Worker's World Party. I don't know much about the WWP or Marcyists, so I can't comment on that, but it's a criticism I've heard pretty commonly among circles.

Beefdrip

EDIT: I found S4A's rant in livestream #108 at the 2 hour and 4 minute mark where he talks about Ben Norton and Breakthrough News and their stances towards multipolarity. Not sure if I can link videos in the AMA here, but I'd check that out as a starting point. Like yourself, I enjoy BT news as well as PSL's liberation news, but it's something to consider for criticism from the left.

Chaim Jones

Hi Breht. In light of U.S. unions ignoring Palestinian workers’ urgent calls for action, and the UAW’s endorsement of Biden, what role do you see unions playing in revolutionary struggle in the USA? And do you think soviets (workers’ councils) might be relevant and useful here in the belly of the beast?

Jon Silver

Hi Breht, thanks for the work you do on this and your other podcasts! I've been listening to your content including back catalogue for a few months now, and I feel like I've learned a lot from you and your show both in terms of theory and in terms of modeling a "good communist" life. I have a few questions: 1. What do you think the near future (i.e. the next 10-50 years) holds, especially given the war/ genocide in Gaza seemingly spiraling toward a regional war? I know no forecast is infallible, but it seems to be like US imperialism might be on the verge of receiving the greatest blow in its history, and I would love to hear your thoughts on what you think the ripple effects will be (even just the ripple effects from what has happened so far, if you don't think there's going to be a broader war), also taking into account things like the possibility of a 2nd Trump term and rapidly worsening effects of climate change. 2. Would you consider doing a more in depth look at China's politics and economy? I would particularly be interested in seeing you host a comradely debate between informed representatives of the pro- modern PRC vs anti-revisionist ML/ Maoist perspectives. I think anti revisionists tend to be ignorant of a lot of aspects of modern China, while pro-Chinese people tend to hand wave the cultural revolution and don't acknowledge the fact that Mao would have definitely considered the entire Reform period to be revisionist and counter revolutionary. I think a discussion of the type I'm suggesting would help keep everyone intellectually honest and present a fuller picture. 3. More episodes analyzing the the development and collapse of 20th century socialist countries would be amazing, especially for comparing and contrasting different countries to reach conclusions about how we can prevent this from happening in the future.

Gabriel

Hi Breht, Could you do an episode explaining in detail why you think China is socialist as opposed to state capitalism like Richard Wolff and Ho Fung Hung say? Also, do you have a book list for China on your website or somewhere?

Mexican Stalin

Do you think popular socialists have a hard time explaining socialists' economics because they reject past socialist projects? I've seen popular socialists fumble the question of how a restaurant or a hotel would work in a socialist system and how people would be compensated. This might be a broader question for all socialists I feel like economics is neglected in our popular online education.

Gaybe

Hey Breht! I’m an avid listener of the Revolutionary Guerrilla Menace podcasts, and I deeply appreciate all the hard work you all put into the information you share with us. My question is more of an accessibility inquiry that I haven’t been sure how or where to pose. I have an auditory processing disorder that makes it extremely difficult to follow along and retain information I receive verbally, and was wondering if there was a way to get transcripts of the podcasts or show notes or something along those lines? I don’t wish to add to the mountain of work you already have to do! I just love the impactful, knowledgeable, and passionate energy y’all put into your podcasts and you’ve helped me to grow so much with my understanding of the world and my place in it, and I just want to keep learning. No matter what your answer is, thank you for everything you do. Solidarity comrade!

Lawrie Coombs

Hey This guy (Ben Lewis) is mega interesting and his work in translating important contributions from early German Social Democracy into English is illuminating. He's also got an interesting take on well being and running/sports from an Marxist perspective. https://marxismtranslated.com/

Sleeper_Waves

One of the few bright spots of the last few years have been the UAW and their victories against the big 3 auto makers. I'm curious about your thoughts on Shawn Fain and his call for a general strike on May Day of 2028, as well as the potential for leftist content creators promoting, coordinating, mobilizing and building the movement alongside the UAW. It feels like an incredible opportunity to unite all different factions of the left behind a common cause.

Sleeper_Waves

If we're allowed a second question, I'd love to get your thoughts on Project 2025 and whether you think the left is capable of organizing a similar playbook, in the hopes it can be put to quick use upon collapse/seizing power. The idea that the right are pre-screening candidates for government positions, drafting policy in advance so it's ready to go on day one and basically inventing a fascist version of LinkedIn to hire like-minded individuals all seems like something the left should be doing as well.

Calli

And touching on China’s connection with Israel

Calli

Would you consider doing an episode on the PCP/Gonzalo? That topic seems very divisive between online leftists, from what I’ve seen, so I could see it being difficult to tackle. I could see Alex Aviña or JMP being great guests for it!

Quém é

I definitely understand where folks in your camp are coming from, though currently I find myself more on the fence. I'll check that episode out though

Quém é

That is truly odd, yeah

Mark M

Hi Breht :) I had my radical awakening recently and I’m in a partnered relationship and with two young kids. How do you incorporate your revolutionary politics into parenting, being a good partner, and generally having to exist not only for yourself but as a figure in the lives of these other people you care about?

From The River To The Sea 🇵🇸

Bret, can you comment on the ICJ ruling in the AMA episode? As every knowledgeable person expected, the court stopped short of calling for a ceasefire.

Jo Vinova

I second this request. My dad and uncles were around during these times and have a handful of stories of their experience living through it. An episode with Professor Aviña would be amazing on the topic. I'm planning to read the Peruvian history text book my great aunty sent me as a kid as a primer to learn more about the Sendero movement

Gabriel Alvarado

I’ve been seeing a lot of push back against what the decolonial indigenous community (on turtle island) are calling settler marxists. Your name has been mentioned quite a few times. What’s up with this dynamic? They think you are a Marxist chauvinist. Specifically, decolonizedbuffalo seems to have beef with your platform. Not sure if it’s worth addressing. My only pushback against them would be that they are contradicting themselves because they are being chauvinistic because they essentially label anyone who doesn’t agree with their perspective/world view as “settlers”

Jon Self

Have you delved into any forms of North American indigenous governance or would you be interested in doing an episode or a few in the future on specific forms?

Benny Boy

Hi Breht, what is your opinion on the danger of authoritarian personalities (as per Adorno's thesis) to creating a better world and how to deal with this effectively when there could likely be a unitary source of political and economic power? As you have probably noticed yourself no matter what the ideology or power structure there are those who cynically attempt to exploit that system for selfish desires. It is in this context that the question is posed.

Joseph

Hey comrade, would you be willing to drop a name on who does this? I don't think I'm familiar at this point in time with many popular socialists and I'd like to be on the lookout for this/try to see how it correlates w their views.

Mexican Stalin

The most recent example was Hasan trying to explain to Ethan (from the H3 podcast) how small businesses would work in socialism the only example Hasan could come up with was his cooperative podcast He didn't do a terrible job but still failed to explain why a socialist system is preferable to a liberal welfare state. There are more examples of leftist influencers doing this throughout the years but there's so much content it gets lost.

MLDad

Was previously discussed several times in JMP episodes, although not focused on the particulars of Gonzalo or the movements achievements, but on the theoretical contributions to MLM.

MLDad

Breht, from across the Atlantic it seems that Cornel West's campaign, despite our differences with his platform and onthology, would be the first chance in a while for communists to show up more often in mainstream contexts (to recruit and gain solidarity), to create nationwide connections between communist organizations and individuals and to test existing relations, organizations, individuals and political stances. Do you agree? Are communists doing enough to take advantage of Cornel's campaign? What are do you think are the challenges, the opportunities and the significance of his bid?

MLDad

Visit Red Menace and RevLeft episodes on Mao, JMP episodes and others. Mao's solution was to invite the masses to confront the party. But fundamentally get yourself a Fidel Castro or a Che and don't let them die. Hope it helped!

MLDad

Oh and a chance to connect the international situation to the big strikes last year and to indigenous struggles and black liberation struggles. It's so important to weave these things together in the minds and politics of each group...

MLDad

China Mieville wrote a story with Keanu Reeves, please get them both on thanks

Josh

Cheers. What’s JMP?

Keelan Swift

Hey Breht, this is a question I have wanted help with for a while and I am sure other people have experienced something similar. I feel like I’m surrounded by nasty dumb people who are exclusively right wing. Where I work, I’m often ridiculed for being a Marxist or for not finding offensive jokes funny. Despite the fact that I go to the gym, have always been athletic and am completely comfortable with my masculinity, I get told that I have too much oestrogen, that I’m a soy boy, a beta male, a weak lefty etc etc. When I push back against racist comments, classism, sexism and homophobia, or if I (god forbid) I dare to defend Palestine, I get lambasted, sworn at or made out to be deluded. I’m also a vegan, which I know you aren’t and that’s completely fine, but just for admitting that I’m a vegan, I’ve been threatened - one guy even told me he was going to grab his gun and kill me (and this is in England!). I often feel mentally battered by being around these awful people all day and at times I come close to losing my shit. I feel desperate anger and sadness raging inside me. Do you have any advice on how to not got insane when dealing with absolute morons who seem to support and enjoy nothing but causing suffering, oppression and inequality? How do I stay sane while not compromising my values? As a side note, the really ironic part of all this is that when some of these men (and it is men) say something racist and I push back against them, they get overly upset and moody with me. It’s like I have to humour their racism because if I don’t, they’ll have a little paddy and complain that I don’t like them or some shit - which tbf, I don’t.

Rev Left Radio

Yes, I dont do online drama (and I genuinely think that's what this amounts to), but he seems to be into doing this type of thing all the time. Hes seemingly always shitting on someone , calling someone out, and spending most of his time pretending his interpersonal dislike of other people is really about principled politics. I actually had invited him on the show a few months back, and he agreed (at this point I was unaware that he had talked shit about me, if he even had at that point) but then the Merrimack Three incident happened, and I came out in favor of their direct action and pushed back on the idea that it was reckless adventurism - not pushed back on THEM btw. I made a general statement from stuff I was reading on twitter. He and others took the opposite position and seemingly personal and instead of being normal about having a disagreement, they started calling me names, speaking hyperbolically about me, etc. I dont engage in that shit, so even though I see it from time to time, I dont engage. Its not substantive. Anyone who listens to my show knows who I am and what I stand for. I have 7 years of work people can look at and decide for themselves if their accusations (which amount to me being wrong about adventurism and being a "chauvinist", as far as I can tell) are anything more than weird and baseless. Im proud of my work and stand by it 100%, and I accept the random waves of hate and criticism that come my way because of it. Thats part of the territory of being active in any political scene, and I accept it - but I dont personally behave that way and dont respond to people who do.

Gabriel Alvarado

In the context of my locality, I would say yes and no. Cornell West actually held a campaign fund raiser in my area the other day. He did several QAs with local community members (of which some belong to local socialist/communist orgs). Hopes are high but with a healthy skepticism, we definitely have a lot of work ahead of us. Pretty sure he just got on the Oregon ballot

Rev Left Radio

lol that would be amazing... Had no clue they wrote something together.

Tim Fitzgerald

Hi Breht, You've made it clear that you believe some type of vanguard party approach is necessary for successful revolutionary system change, with the goal of taking and maintaining state power. Although I can certainly appreciate the scale of the challenges associated with achieving and maintaining revolutionary change, is there any reason not to aim for a political structure that maximizes bottom-up participation and includes extremely robust checks on abuses of power, e.g. discrete powers provided to fully-recallable positions, rather than ongoing leadership positions of broad scope given to elected individuals? Is it not possible to both acknowledge and contend with material circumstances while also acknowledging the risks and undesirable possibilities stemming from allowing entrenchment and consolidation of political power into a small number of hands?

Lawrence G Trovinger

What is your name? What is your quest? What is your favourite colour?

Grace

Also really interested to hear your opinion on China, Brett! A new book out called The East Is Still Red published by Praxis Press supports China’s socialism with Chinese characteristics model, but I generally find non-bias info on China rock hard to find

Gabriel Alvarado

Couldn’t agree more. Btw I’m sorry if me bringing this up started any unnecessary drama or strife. That was not my intention.

Matt Pierce

Real late to the party on this questions post but hopefully you'll see these: 1. Who/what are some of your favorite literary authors and works? 2. Would you consider having someone like Jodi Dean on to talk about the Socialist Reconstruction text that came out of PSL a year or so ago? The text is very interesting but I haven't seen it discussed really at all by folks who aren't directly affiliated with PSL.

Daewoo

I always comment on these pretty late, but here goes. I'm gonna repeat my unanswered question from the last time an AMA happened, concerning Roger Waters (of Pink Floyd fame). Last time I asked about your thoughts on him with the context of Rally Against the War Machine event in DC last year, and his participation in it. Now, in the wake of the Al Aqsa Flood, Waters has stood firm in his support of Palestinian liberation, and has continued in his denouncements of the Zionist entity, withstanding the usual onslaught of antisemitism accusations that he's no stranger to. There are a lot of avenues to tackle him and thoughts around him, so I'll lay them out a bit better. What are your thoughts on celebrity and how celebrities use their social (and monetary) capital (specifically pro-human celebrities defending Palestinians and denouncing Zionism)? Roger Waters is someone who follows many principled Marxist lines (his stance on Ukraine/Russia, Taiwan/China, Palestine/Israel, his anti-ruling class messaging), but isn't openly a socialist or communist or Marxist. Do you have any thoughts on how someone could act "Marxistly" without defining themselves as such? Roger Waters often holds firm to the line of anti-war politics in all contexts. What use could engaging in progressive, yet liberal positions such as that have in advancing socialism? Then for fun, what do you think of his music? I know you're a hip hop head (so am I), but don't think you've much mentioned other political artists outside of hip hop and punk. I personally argue Pink Floyd was pretty punk (not in their music ofc), which pissed off actual punk bands (Johnny Rotten would wear a Pink Floyd t-shirt with the members' eyes crossed out).

Daewoo

Another question directed toward you personally. You and indigenous comrades (some connected to the Chunka Luta Network) got into it on social media a few months ago. It stemmed from an action against Elbit Systems in Merrimack, NH in October. Three comrades were arrested during the action, spawning debate about their actions and their connection to Fergie Chambers and how he fits into the movement. It seemed there was an important discussion to be had about the effectiveness of the action, whether it hurt or helped, and whether it amounted to adventurism, and specifically regarding Fergie, whether he's a rich trust fund kid cosplaying a revolutionary. Now a few months removed, can you address the incident, the disagreements that arose, and the seeming refusal, right or wrong, to engage with the indigenous comrades who, right or wrong, took issue with the way you engaged with it at the time. I'm not taking sides, just saw comrades I admire taking different sides on an issue and I don't think it was resolved. Thank you.

Daewoo

I should probably read the other comments before asking my own questions. I asked a question regarding the online drama surrounding the action the Merrimack Three took. I understand not wanting to engage with personalized attacks and drama-baiting, but there could still be good discussion about some of the points Decolonized Buffalo and Sungmanitu brought up regarding the effectiveness of Merrimack Three action, as well as the influence of Fergie Chambers, the issue of settler chauvinism (I don't agree that you are a chauvinist of any sort) in Marxist/decolonial movements. I don't want to misrepresent their concerns, but I think the biggest issue the indigenous comrades took with the discussion around the Merrimack Three is Fergie using his inherited wealth on the Merrimack Three and the action they took, how they believe it was an ineffective action, and how they could've used that money better, since they are the colonized peoples of this land who believe they have the structure/know-how to decolonize. Outside the drama-baiting and personal attacks, I think these are worthwhile discussions to be had, that I wish you could talk about.

Daewoo

Would like to second the first question about Video Games. Disco Elysium is such a fantastic Marxist video game and would love to know Breht's thoughts on it if he knows about it.

Daewoo

I loved that part in the autobiography! They had a kind of debate club when he was in prison that would debate that and other questions. And the Shakespeare question of authorship is a 300 year long debate about the most influential English works of literature. It is a pretty important question even today.

Daewoo

Also football. When we gonna get a football episode? Lotta shit going on in the gridiron football world, both college and NFL. Who winning Super Bowl? (I want anyone but the 9ers).

Gabriel Alvarado

Right, I think they have really insightful criticisms that the Marxist left and others really need to wrestle with more and weed out as many contradictions as possible. It seems though the current dynamic is one of resentment and ego.

Marxist Librarian

Hey Breht. I love Rev Left and am a long time listener. I have been thinking about your and Allison's "What Is To Be Done?" episode a lot lately [among others episodes] and its got me thinking about the limitations of union organizing. It has made me want to organize beyond issues relating to my workplace, however I am not sure where to start. As you mention, there is not really anything close to a vanguard party in the US today. Do you have any advice for MLs/MLMs who want to organize pending party formation? Do you think we should join local organizations, like a local PSL chapter, or do you think the left should be trying to build others kinds of organizations/coalitions? If so, what would those look like?There is also a small but growing Maoist organization in my area and have considered moving closer to be able to organize with them. I would love to hear about some of the work you and Allison do with your organizations, and what you think is most strategic for the left.

Ian Stockdale

Oh to have been a fly-on-the-wall for those prison debates!

Calli

J. Moufawad-Paul, he’s been on the show quite a few times.

David Adamson

Abso-effing-lutely, thanks Daewoo! Except I like the 49ers. Nice red uniforms! How about a comparison of owners'/coaches/players earnings per capita. Let's get a good replay of that from a variety of angles! How about interviewing Packers' fan/owners and revealing their class consciousness : "The Packers are the only NFL club that is a publicly owned corporation, the only major professional sports franchise in the United States that is a nonprofit entity, and one of only a few such teams that are not privately held.[a][1]" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Green_Bay_Packers,_Inc.#:~:text=The%20Packers%20are%20the%20only,that%20are%20not%20privately%20held.

Rev Left Radio

Daewoo, I agree with that. And re-reading my first statement it comes off harsher than I intended. I actually think both of those people you mentioned are smart people with fair points. Its the way they carry themselves and treat people. There is never a sense that they want to have a constructive dialogue, or even that they respect you on a basic level, but rather that you are fodder for them to grind their axe too. Thats how I feel anyway, and that isnt a foundation from which a serious, respectful dialogue can occur. Ive disagreed with many people on many things and have even debated others on the show, but the basis to those discussions was always rooted in some level of mutual respect. When that is glaringly absent, as i feel it is in this case, its hard for me to engage. But regarding the details, for me the entire Fergie thing was irrelevant. I wasnt talking about the organization or him at all. I didnt know about either. I addressed the adventurism point (NOT because of their takes or them them, btw, but from random shit I had seen on Twitter. I had no clue what their takes were on the topic, but they took it personally when I made my post on IG - as if they interpreted me talking about it as calling *them* out.) and expressed a basic statement of solidarity with the three activists arrested, one of whom I had interviewed before. They added all the fergie shit and background beefs, and I saw all that as having nothing to do with me or with what I had said. So it feels like they never approached me in anything like good faith, and to the contrary, take enjoyment from constantly calling other people out and insisting aggressively that they always have the superior analysis to everyone they disagree with, and that approach to other people is abrasive and counter-productive imho. Calling me names like a chauvinist is the cherry on top for me, and just proves that these people are not relating to me in good faith or from a place of baseline human respect, but from a place of (bewildering) spite.

Gaybe

Well that’s rad! Thank you so much for sharing this info, I’ll definitely have to give it a try!

Clint Blakely

Hey Breht, wondering if you’d consider doing an episode on what is actually going on with the Uyghurs in Xinjiang? Hard to parse out fact from fiction. Thanks!

Ian Perry

Very late to the party, not sure if this still applies but writing anyways. Just relistened to your Red Menace episode on What is To Be Done?, and you joke about Karl Kautsky at one point. Having never read him, and not really understanding his ideas, I was wondering if you could detail a critique on him, or even do a Red Menace ep on him if there's anything worthwhile. I know he's a significant figure, but that's about all I know. Thanks!

Stu Malcolm

Yes please! I’d love to see an ep with Jodi Dean!!

Stu Malcolm

Thanks for that, Calli!! Acronyms!! Oy!

Stu Malcolm

I’ve had similar thoughts about how to cut out the rapacious capitalist middleman! I’d love to find a way to get $$$ you Rev Left w/o them stealing a chunk.

Liliya

Hi Breht, do you have any upcoming podcasts planned about current geopolitical situation/ world events? Thank you!

Seany G

It's a tricky question. One has to respect Breht's decision to fund his show. That said, it'd be good to have more options for support. Sometimes people have irregular sources of income and can't commit to a monthly donation. And sometimes people would like to act on the spur of the moment, perhaps after a particularly good podcast episode. Perhaps you could write a direct note to Breht to ask about this. If he sees that there is more than one person inquiring about this it may prompt him to set up other avenues for support, or at least explain his thinking on this point.

AJ

Very late to this but I just joined as a member! I'm curious whether owning stocks makes someone a member of the bourgeoisie since in a way you own a piece of the means of production (even if very small)? About 60% of people in the US currently invest in some capacity, so I'm not sure where one would draw that line with a Marxist analysis. Thanks!