Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

Matthew Furlong joins Breht for another round of listener questions! Breht tells a story about his recent back and forth with a Zionist Rabbi, then Matt and Breht discuss the debate around China, Anti-Revisionist Marxism-Leninism, the Great Proletarian Cultural Revolution, the philosophical importance of Mao, how to cope with the suffering we see in Palestine while doing all we can to help, and the alienated anxieties that surround employment, self worth, and community in Late Capitalist society.  

Files

Comments

Ian Stockdale

Hey Breht, just a friendly suggestion that the strategy you outlined of answering the 88 current AMA questions chronologically "in a handful of monthly AMA's" doesn't seem likely of success. You answered 6 questions. At this pace, you wouldn't be finished by 2025 (and that would preclude answering any new questions in 2024).

Seany G

Very informative, on a wide array of topics. The format is very respectful of people's questions and I liked how you use them as a launching pad to address broader and deeper issues as well. It was also nice to hear about your personal goals in teaching (as a former teacher of social sciences, mainly history, civics, law, economics, world issues, philosophy, among others, at high school,it was interesting to me, personally). (check out "Shop Class as Soulcraft" by Matthew B. Crawford: the blurb says "A philosopher/mechanic's wise look at the challenges and pleasures of working with one's hands"). Finally, your and Matthew's very personal, honest approach to the posted questions and sympathy for people's humanity is very inspiring. Kudos !

Seany G

Perhaps group some questions that are thematically similar (eg. China) and answer them together. This is often the strategy of public forums with Q & A s

Rev Left Radio

haha yea, I thought about that. But Ill still try and in future episodes Ill go through many many more questions at a quicker pace!

Rev Left Radio

Thank you Seany, ill def check out that book, looks interesting! And thank you for your service (being a teacher!).

Pink Panther

iirc Xi said his goal is peaceful reunification with China. Violent reunification seems to be a last resort…

Brant

I had a similar encounter in a classroom setting at the University of Houston back in 2017, when the head of the local Israeli consulate was invited to my class (we had no idea until he walked in the room). It's not easy to have that debate in front of other classmates. Obviously our situations were a little different (mine was a an ex-Israeli military officer), but I appreciate the story and showing other students how to challenge that narrative in that particular setting.

Jo Vinova

Cool to hear how you navigated that conversation in the classroom. I still find myself having issues with social situations with family and friends that have right leaning positions but I feel like sometimes my lack of knowledge leaves me being unable to continue past the point of opening up discussion. I also don't know a lot about the current state of China so it was nice to hear yalls analysis. Look forward to more AMAs.

Beefdrip

It's interesting that Matthew brought up home economics/cooking. I was wondering if either of you had any insight on the relation of colonialism to cuisines? Two of the worst examples that come to mind are Frybread for the indigenous Americans, which was forced upon them through colonialism in lieu of their more traditional nutritious foods. The other example is how Israeli cuisine has coopted Palestinian, Yemeni, and Syrian foods and completely removed their national origins.

SprocketMusic

In 10th grade, my history teacher opened on the first day by telling us, "When you write an essay, I don't want you to regurgitate what I tell you. You can express any position, and read it from any angle so long as you adequately back it up with facts.". History went from being my least favorite subject to my favorite subject. I even started writing all of my homework assignments from a Marxist perspective - crudely understood, since I didn't have access to texts other than the Manifesto. I got straight A's from improvising my own take on historical materialism based on my understanding of the "haves and have nots." I've since become a much more principled, and well-read Marxist, but the simple act of letting me explore class history pointed my entire outlook on life in a whole new direction. It also helped that I was taught the industrial revolution in terms of its horrors rather than its triumphs. Schools won't let you teach Communism, but most will let you teach about the Radium Girls, and the Haymarket Affair, and the Triangle Shirtwaist Factory, and the Battle of Blair Mountain. Kids will radicalize themselves if they know labor history.

Grace

Really needed to hear your advice in the last question in this moment. Thank you Brett ♥️

Foko

i have an ongoing research project on this topic right now that i'm considering making a podcast on -- if you want any resources i've come across i would be happy to share them!

Irene

I’m so excited for you to become a teacher. I know this is a parasocial relationship, but it’s clear you have a love for humanity and kids can feel that. I had a track coach in HS who was a radical English teacher and he was so important in my adolescence! I teach (younger) kids now and I am so inspired by them every day. Work under capitalism is still shit, but teaching is hella meaningful and promising.

nickw

I enjoy your conversations with Mathew, hope to hear more comrades.

Brett

I’ve shared parts of my wife’s teaching story before, but it seems relevant to your discussion at the end about teaching and being open while doing it. She taught high school English for 7 years in Indiana and Minnesota at small schools, which are communities in themselves. She fortunately had the freedom to choose her own lessons and texts, so she used texts like Elie Wiesel’s “Night”, Fredrick Douglass’s autobiography, Marjane Sartrapi’s “Persepolis”, and the Vietnam novel “Things They Carried”. This caused much controversy with the parents, and even led to the principal tossing the whole set of Persepolis (which we paid for out of pocket) in the trash after my wife quit. Her experience came to a head when some parent found my wife’s name on some obscure Howard Zinn Foundation teacher’s pledge, and my wife’s name and address ended up on several right-wing news sites. That same parent used that publicity stunt to begin her political campaign; she is now a MN State House Rep in fact. None of this is me saying “don’t do it”; we need a thousand Brehts to go into teaching. It sounds like you’re well aware what is coming your way given your podcasting history and you’re as prepared as any of us to deal with it. Good luck, comrade.

Beefdrip

That sounds good. I've read a couple of articles from mainstream outlets, but nothing academic.

Scott

In regards to the ‘what can I do for Palestine’ question: It doesn’t have to happen now For clarity, I’m not saying that anyone shouldn’t be actively advocating and fighting for a free Palestine. I’m saying that your inability to stop what’s happening in this immediate moment shouldn’t leave you feeling hopeless I struggled for months with the fact that I couldn’t go Hulk Mode and put an end to everything that’s happening. I want to stop this NOW. None of us have that ability, and that’s not a personal failing What we can do is influence the perspective of those who are close to us. We can wear a keffiyeh in solidarity. We can protest to bring public attention. We can disrupt supply chains. We can disrupt social media. And we can look down the line to see how we can help in meaningful ways that we can control I’ve been a mechanic for most of my working career and dabbled in machining. I’m changing my career path to focus on prosthetics and mobility aids, and I’m also in the early stages of learning Arabic. I know I can’t stop the onslaught that’s happening at this very moment, but I can call it out and work towards helping those who are affected by it. Someday I will be fully capable of working with the thousands of Palestinians who have lost limbs in this genocide. What I’m doing isn’t happening now, but staring now is what makes the long term difference Solidarity with Palestine is a full spectrum of struggles. There isn’t one single solution to how you can make a difference. The struggle may take decades or extend beyond our lifetimes. The whole point is that you keep pushing for what you believe in. Don’t give up because what you believe in isn’t happening now

T

Obviously a big commitment as you mentioned but a Red Menace series on Capital would be incredibly useful