Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

In this patreon exclusive, Breht reads and reflects on Buddhist writings including Thich Nhat Hanh's letter to MLK Jr. regarding Buddhist monks in Vietnam engaging in self-immolation and how it differs from suicide,  and a response by John Peacock to criticism by Slavoj Zizek of so-called Western Buddhism wherein he argues that mindfulness meditation is merely a way to cope with the depravities of capitalism; a new Opium of the Masses. 

Along the way, Breht takes many detours, and touches on the self-immolation and martyrdom of Aaron Bushnell, the ongoing multi-faceted evolution of the human species, and much more.  


Check out other Rev Left episodes on Buddhism and related topics, including the ones mentioned in this episode HERE 

Files

Comments

Jose Alvarez

Thank you Breht, I had so much pent up energy in my body and my mind had been overwhelmed with emotions ever since I saw the video, and hearing you describe what I had seen helped me release all of it in a stream of tears

Cookie

Intrigued to hear your take as always on this Breht. and I wasn't aware of the Thich Nhat Hanh letter. as you prob know, approx 160 Tibetans have self immolated over the past fifty years in protest of all the various oppressions of the cultural revolution and subsequent Chinese occupation of Tibet. HH Dalai Lama has always roundly denounced this as an acceptable method of protest--"nobody's death is worth more than their life" is kind of the attitude. Martyrdom is a Christian concept, but Bodhisattvas who have attained the bhumis are supposed to not hesitate to offer their bodies to solve trolley problems, feed starving Tigresses and so on. So long as they are capable of supernatural powers anyway

Cookie

the Slavoj Zizek criticism is, I think, a really unfortunately accurate zinger for most Western Buddhists. They're liberal at best, but if you scratch at their actual politics they are nihilists. In January I was talking with a nun and a few other buddhists about the bullshit politics of the BJP in India. A Monk literally shut our conversation down by saying "What can we do about any of that anyway. All we can do is practice." To which I had some strong responses.

Saya Clarke

I am gutted. It’s hard to express how much this video has affected me. His display of extreme mental clarity as he marches towards his inevitable death. His brief words about the situation that are concise and tell you everything you need to know about why action like this has become necessary to him. The fact that he walks first past the Ghana embassy. Another nation with a long history of colonial interference whose beloved leader was murdered at the hands of the US death machine. The way he executes on his plan without a lick of hesitation. You can tell that in his mind there is no other option for him. The way he shouts “Free Palestine!” over and over in a tone and manner indicative of military salutes, so proudly. Even when he is completely engulfed in flame already suffering life threatening injuries he still tries with what little life is left inside him to shout one last time “Free Palestine!” And the response… That tells you everything you need to know about how such extreme an action can be possible in the world we’ve built. The man is lying on the ground unconscious, engulfed in flames and the officer responds with a gun pointed at him. As if the man is going to stand up in a blaze of fire and attack him. Some people might chalk it up to police protocol or fight or flight response but to me that just speaks to the cruelty of our country and the values of brutality, cruelty, violence, injustice and hatred that we’ve imposed on the rest of the world at the barrel of a gun. RIP Aaron Bushnell. A kind soul was lost and I am certain the world is worse off without him in it. Free Palestine!

Dominick Marrone

Great episode Breht! Also, you're input on the article is why I'm here... You could easily have just linked these articles but I value the insights you take the time to add to them as you go.

Rev Left Radio

It took me a while to fully confront it. I didnt want to watch the video. Still processing it. But his screams will never, ever leave my mind. Nor will the image of his sacrifice. He grabbed the whole world by the collar and made us look. Its profound.

Rev Left Radio

Yes, we discuss one recent case of a Tibetan self-immolating. Politics aside, I am stunned into silence and existential reflection by such acts. Good points about Martydom in Christianity as well as the Bodhisattva point!

Rev Left Radio

Yes, you find this sort of detachment in all religions sadly. Christians who are supposed to live like Christ and cultivate universal love can be republicans in the US supporting putting barbed wire at the border and bombing other countries. Hypocrisy and a lack of responsibility abound in the human condition and its traditions, sadly.

Rev Left Radio

Really movingly stated, Saya, as usual. Brought me to tears reading your description. His screams will never leave my mind, they are imprinted upon it until the day I die. All we can do is do everything to can to ensure his self-sacrifice was not made in vain. We must carry on the fight he lit himself up to highlight.

Rev Left Radio

THank you very much, I appreciate your support, and I am happy you find this useful. <3

J Hagler

Aaron’s courage and sacrifice will never be forgotten. For those of us wanting to start practicing Buddhism where would you recommend starting Mahāyāna and putting ourselves on the bodhisattva path (book recommendations or specific meditation practices etc.) ?

Rev Left Radio

Three Recs: 1) Mindfulness and Insight by Sayadaw 2) Mindfulness by Joseph Goldstein 3) A Path with Heart by Jack Kornfield All three teach you the practice, but each do it in a different way and from different perspectives. I would look into each of them and see which interests you the most and start w that one!

J Hagler

Thank you, I’ll give those a read and go from there!

Something Occidental

Thank you for bringing in this context. That letter is a great rebuff to liberals who weaponize mental health discourse to dismiss Aaron's sacrifice.

Deven Toast

I really love your Buddhist focused episodes and find the dialectical relationship between Marxism and Buddhism very helpful. All that to say, Brett likes magazines and this is irrefutable proof he is a Trotskyist

Nick

Ah, so happily we live, Without hate among those with hate. Among people who hate We live without hate. Dhammapadda (197) I really enjoyed this episode and wanted to share a few thoughts because I am a Buddhist and its a central part of my life. I do find it unfortunate that in a lot of Buddhist spiritual circles there seems to be a desire to not take sides and take some kind of nebulous position of "I stand on the side of peace," not really understanding that there are conditions that give rise to peace and conditions that give rise to violence. Of course we want peace, but Palestinians living under a settler colonial apartheid state will never be peaceful basically by definition. The Buddha calls on us to not only refrain from violence, but to actively develop compassion and kindness. To not speak out against the genocide of Palestinians is cowardly and compassionless. However, I also think that people are horribly misinformed due to our insane media and Americans generally have a horrible political education. What Aaron Bushnell did was an act of unbelievable compassion that has touched me deeply. May he rest in peace 🙏🏼

Jolene Bresney

this was brilliant. grateful to share this space with you. 🍓🙏❤️‍🩹

Chase

Love this episode

Bill

Such an inspirational talk that I finally took the dive into Patreon membership. Thank you!

Milene

Loved this episode! Just got around to it so I'm not sure if you'll see this question: I heard you groan when the article mentioned Hannah Arendt and it made me laugh although I don't know much about her. I was trying to read one of her books a while back because my philosophy professor recommended her book to me. Found the book felt stiff to me. Am just curious about the scoff and the reason for it lol.