Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

The Hobbit Trilogy: Should we react to them? 🗯️

  • Yes! ✔️ 165
  • No. ❌ 61
  • 2025-09-29
  • 226 votes
{'title': 'The Hobbit Trilogy: Should we react to them? 🗯️', 'choices': [{'text': 'Yes! ✔️', 'votes': 165}, {'text': 'No. ❌', 'votes': 61}], 'closes_at': None, 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2025, 9, 29, 11, 59, 50, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 226}

Content

We're filming LOTR Return of the King this week which means we have to decide what comes next!Would you like to see us react to The Hobbit Trilogy? 🗯️Let us know your thoughts on the trilogy and which movies are your favourites!

Comments

Will Berry

In my opinion they aren’t on par with Lord of the Rings, but still important for the lore and very good in their own way. More fantastical in my opinion

Steven Jump

I'd watch it, but they aren't as good.

Lisa - Marie

Not as good as others have said but I agree worth a watch for the lore and background of some characters. I would rewatch if reacted to it

PoeSenpai

I'd say either Hobbit or Fantastic Beasts would be good

Rebecca Furlong

I'd watch them if you enjoy learning more lore about the world. In my opinion though, The Hobbit should have been one movie instead of spread into three

Jessi

Meh.

DragonQueen

Personally, I did not like The Hobbit adaptation… they relied heavily on CGI instead of practical makeup/effects

Coral of Bread

The first one? Ace! The rest get worse fast. If you haven’t read the books then you won’t be as mad. Fantastic Beasts falls off a cliff after the 1st one as well. But, you’re a react channel, so get that bread!

Jess

Maybe watch the animated Hobbit, too or instead! I prefer the animated to the live action! Although it’s just 1 single movie

Michael W

No where near the quality of the LOTR trilogy. My opinion is that they take too much liberty with the story line, but not in a cohesive way LOTR did. That being said, they can be fun in their own way.

Benjamin Hütz

dont listen to all those people arguing against watching them because they are "not as good as lotr". A 11 out of 10 is still better than every other movie, despite not reaching the 13 out of 10 like lotr does xD

Jake Banks

Apparently the pre-production/ production was pretty fucked up. And you can see it. I personally didn't like the first or second installment & opted out of the third. But I'd rewatch them through you two to see your take. Have fun with it.

Bee

Mannn so much negativity in the comments. They’re a fun time for a ton of us who read The Hobbit as kids. No, they’re not 100% book accurate, but neither is LOTR. It’s also important to note that the story was never meant to feel as heavy and high stakes as LOTR. The book wasn’t like that either. It was a story Tolkien made up for his kids every night at bed time 😅. So many people base their expectations on LOTR and just trash The Hobbit without understanding what it actually is.

Kate

I love the hobbit movies the biggest problem with them is too much reliance on CGI and art design at a 7/10 instead of a 15/10. But the acting is great, the story is entertaining, Howard Shore returns for the soundtrack, and they are worth watching imo.

Raoic

Worth the watch, as long as you go into them with zero expectations. They're cgi-heavy, but what isn't these days? They're also really fun, campy, quirky, and there's good humour. Pure entertainment.

Ash

They're stuffed to the absolute brim with fluff and are very reliant on CG effects. They are not tonally the same as LoTR. They're fun movies and the original story is intact in there somewhere. Just don't go in with LoTR expectations.

J Martin

They're definitely not on the level of LoTR but they are pretty fun the first time through. I feel like the problem is they tried to turn The Hobbit book into LoTR 2.0 by stretching it out into a huge epic trilogy, when the source material is just not meant for that tone/length lol. Just go in with reasonable expectations I would say

AdamPacio.art

They are great fun for the non-Tolkien fan. :) Real fans seem to find it harder to go along for the ride with the Hobbit than we did for LOTR's changes. /shrug. It is known, Khaleesi.

Robert N. De Santis

The Lord of the Rings trilogy, as filmed brilliantly by Peter Jackson, is certainly not a word for word adaptation. However, it retains the base principles of the book and certainly of the author. The Hobbit trilogy, which is based on one relatively short book is filled to the brim with filler and made up battles and other encounters that are very much NOT part of the original story. It is entertaining in its own way, but not anything like The Hobbit as it was written by Tolkien. Martin Freeman's performance is great and I thought that he was perfectly cast. I enjoyed many of the other performances, but the movie should have been one movie rather than three.