I'll Be Getting Laid for Christmas: A SYM Holiday Special (Patreon Exclusive Story) (Patreon)
Content
Hello patrons! It's time for another Patreon Exclusive Story, all thanks to you and your fantastic support! I hope you're all having an amazing and safe holiday season, full of love and joy, and keeping warm!
I meant to get this one out in time for Christmas of 2022, but with the holiday season as busy as it is, it wound up a couple days late. Sorry for any inconvenience, but I like to hope that you'll enjoy this belated Christmas present! Your votes solidified Haley's starring role, and Faqt3 won the drawing to name the male lead, Conner, so this is one that I really owe to all of you. Of note, at the time of posting, my editor only had a chance to go over about 2/3rds of the manuscript due to holiday obligations, so once I get those remaining edits, I'll be adding them to this posting. So, if you see any slight tweaks down the line, well, that's why.
And, as always, it goes without saying, please do not distribute this story in any fashion outside of Patreon, since, well, it would defeat the purpose of making it exclusive here, and it would make me sad. And of course, special thanks to my editor, Lil_kitty, for her diligent efforts making sure my stories make sense.
From me to you during this season, happy holidays!
-aimingtomisbehave33
-------------------------
It was not an uncommon joke around town that there weren’t that many hills in Regan Hills. They did exist, though, and a couple of them even did manage some height, but all in all they still remained one of the less remarkable corners of town.
The only thing of note about the hills (save for the tall, white water tower with REGAN HILLS written on the side), was that they were where most of the richer families in Regan Hills resided. To be clear, Regan Hills wasn’t exactly a rich town, and certainly not one that was full of old money. Those who lived in the hills were mostly imports from other towns wanting to stretch their wealth even further by taking advantage of Regan Hills’ more affordable real estate, and those who had been in town for a significant period of time tended toward the elderly.
There was, however, one “old money” family that had been in town for generations and were about as close to royalty as Regan Hills got: the Shaws. The Shaw family had lived in a mansion near the top of one of Regan Hills’ higher hills since the early 20th century. Nobody was quite sure where the fortune originally came from, though the family had dabbled in mining and aerospace and freeways and Hollywood over the generations. The most recent family patriarch was a lower-level mover and shaker in some tech interest or another, and while he hadn’t a success to his name, the family wasn’t at risk of running out of money anytime soon.
While nobody could truly stand the Shaws, no one could deny that the family knew how to throw one hell of a party. For special occasion and holiday, there they were, their estate decked out with tasteful, professional decorations, and just enough entertainment to keep things lively, yet not raucous. The food was never anything to write home about, but the booze was always decent, and things were usually lively enough that people kept coming back for more.
And no party was more important than their annual Christmas Eve bash, the one where all the stops were pulled out and all the “best” families from Regan Hills and beyond were invited.
It is at this party where this story is set, on an eventful senior year for many a Regan Hills youth, where the season of joy and light intersected well with sweaty debauchery.
Even if some of the participants were none too happy with how their nights began.
***
Standing off to one corner of the party was a young woman who would captivate at any engagement. A 5’6”, 18-year-old redhead, with long, straight hair and nearly porcelain pale skin, her gorgeous face, full lips, and big green eyes would have stolen most any man’s attention on their own, had she also not had some of the most insane curves you’d ever seen. Her chest had a pair of expansive H-cup tits that threatened to burst any top she wore, and her equally large ass and fit dancer’s body gave her a distinct hourglass figure. On this night she wore a tasteful red gown that looked positively obscene on her for how tight it was (and was far more tasteful than anything she would normally choose to wear), lipstick that was nearly as ruby red as the dress itself, and would have looked positively festive if it weren’t for the absolutely bitchy sneer on her face.
“I fucking hate this party… I always hate this party… every fucking year it gets worse and worse; the food sucks, the music sucks, nobody around here is any fun, and I gotta hang around Peyton Shaw and pretend to be nice with her for one night because my parents like her parents? No fucking thanks. Don’t know why my parents always make me come,” Haley Campbell huffed, polishing off her flute of sparkling cider and wishing it were something much harder. “I should’ve stayed at the charity thing with Jade…”
Haley was, at the best of times, a girl with an attitude that could charitably be called bitchy, but spending Christmas Eve here had put her in a particular mood.
But, if misery loved company, Haley had some of the best company to be a complete and utter bitch with. The 5’8” brunette who stood next to her had a similarly disinterested look on her face, and while her dark green dress didn’t hide curves nearly as insane as Haley’s, her tight cheerleader’s body still showed through.
“If I’d have known you’d be this insufferable about it, I’d have suggested you stay there too,” Dakota Lewis said, smiling wryly.
“Would’ve if I could’ve, but there’s no escaping family this time of year,” Haley complained.
“Oh, don’t I know it, Haley… it’s not all bad, though,” Dakota said.
“Yes, it is,” Haley replied.
“No, it’s not,” Dakota tried to explain in the usual firm, vaguely condescending way that Haley was all too used to. “We’re eighteen now. That creates a massive difference in what we would have been capable of doing last year, and it can sure as hell be a lot of fun if we stop complaining for a little while and allow it to be fun.”
“How?” Haley asked, though she was starting to get an inkling of Dakota’s points.
“Well, for one, if we get caught sneaking some of the liquor, they’ll be far less inclined to get angry at us than they did when you tried that two years ago,” Dakota replied. “Now it’ll be something along the lines of, ‘hey, it’s the holidays, you kids have fun, just be careful and try to go easy on the hard stuff’.”
“That’s… okay, that’s a point,” Haley admitted.
“And now that we’re all legal and such,” Dakota said, adjusting her dress slightly over her boobs for emphasis, “Our options for how we want to end the night are wide open. I’ve seen the way some of those dads are looking at you… a slut like you could really clean up around here.”
A soft “humph” erupted behind them, as a scandalized, middle-aged society woman with a full Karen haircut turned her nose up at the two girls, then strode away, silently judging them.
“What?” Dakota called after her. “She could! Better keep an eye on your man!”
Haley rolled her eyes. “A bitch like that’s gonna complain about us to all the old ladies around here.”
“Probably. I should see if her husband is hot, show her what that kind of complaining really gets you,” Dakota said.
Haley couldn’t tell if Dakota was joking or not, and decided on the way she looked that Dakota was telling the truth. This was enough to make Haley laugh, if just a little.
“I’m right though, we could get all kinds of ass tonight without really having to try,” Dakota said, looking around with some interest.
“We could get ass anywhere without having to try,” Haley corrected. “And this isn’t the kind of place I really want to be getting some, anyway.”
“Oh?” Dakota asked. “Why not?”
Haley sighed, not wanting to put any more thought to this subject than she had to, but feeling like her hand had been forced by Dakota. “My parents are still trying to hook me up with Conner Berriman, so I’m trying to stay the fuck away from them and any guy who might be him. I’m not trying to get with anyone, I just wanna get the fuck out of here.”
Dakota shrugged. “More for me, then. Conner’s really that bad? He’s not one of those that I’ve had the pleasure of meeting…”
“His family usually travels during the holidays, so I haven’t seen him in three years, but I doubt those years have made him any better. I know he’s supposed to be here this year, and that Mom and Dad are still trying to get us together because ‘we’re a good match’…” Haley replied, annoyed.
Dakota nodded sympathetically. She too had been in her share of attempted matchmaking attempts by overenthusiastic and well-intentioned parents who wanted them to date within a certain social standing, and knew Haley’s plight well.
“Good luck with it. There’s plenty of trust fund studs wandering around in clouds of cologne that might be him, and it’s not like you’re exactly dressed for stealth…” Dakota observed.
“Don’t remind me,” Haley said, looking down at her dress. “But, fuck, I do look hot, don’t I?”
Haley had already gained the attention of many of those “trust fund studs” that Dakota warned of, but found none of them to be terribly interesting. Nevertheless, it was always good to have confirmation that she looked as hot as she felt.
“Certainly; your rack looks amazing,” Dakota replied. “Believe me, if I weren’t supposed to be making a good impression here, I’d take you somewhere and motorboat the fuck out of you for a long, long time.”
Haley snorted. As ever, Dakota knew how to charm and irritate her in equal measure.
“I’m a few steps away from taking you up on that,” Haley replied.
“Yeah, but, I still gotta make an impression, network with important people, you know how it goes,” Dakota said, sympathetic. “But if Conner’s still bothering you, why don’t you try focusing on something good instead?”
“Like Christmas?” Haley suggested. That wasn’t inherently the worst idea; Haley’s parents were always good at spoiling her and getting her almost whatever she wanted for Christmases and birthdays and the like, and that did give something to look forward to.
Dakota laughed, smirking, “Actually, I was thinking about my little New Year’s Mouth Party.”
Haley had to give that one to Dakota. “Okay, fine, that’s fine, I’m really looking forward to all that, but it’s not that good a distraction now. We still have all this shit to deal with.”
Dakota stroked her chin, thoughtful. “Wanna see how unguarded that hard wassail bowl is?”
Haley grinned. “Now you’re talking.”
As the two Regan Hills High School cheerleaders snuck through the crowd toward the back of the party, Haley had to admit that Dakota wasn’t normally someone she would have considered a friend. For every bit a bitch that Haley could be, cheer captain Dakota could always match her and so much more. She was a pain in the ass and a taskmaster (not that it stopped the two of them from fooling around like all the rest of the squad), and was one of the few people who really knew how to put Haley in her place while simultaneously pushing her to be better.
But, call it the spirit of the season (and knowing well very few other people in the house), but whenever their families forced them together under the roof of a Shaw house party, they held out an olive branch and worked well as partners in crime.
Fortunately for them, the hard wassail bowl was thoroughly unguarded. Each of them took a glass and filled it high with the mix of cider, orange, cinnamon, spices, wine and some harder liquor. Haley took a long sip from her glass, looking forward to it burning its way down and finding only a light tingling instead.
“This hard wassail isn’t that hard,” she noted.
“No,” Dakota admitted. “But if we do enough of it, I think it’ll work eventually.”
Haley liked that idea. She liked that idea a lot. The wassail may not have been as hard as she was looking for, but it was damn good, and certainly tasted of the fine Christmas that she was used to. She could see herself standing by the punch bowl, knocking out glass after glass with Dakota until her parents claimed her, having hidden herself thoroughly away from Conner Berriman and all her parents’ attempts at matchmaking and-
And that plan was going to have to jump out the fucking window, probably followed not long after by Haley.
Approaching their table with the fakest damn smile on her overly made-up face was one of the few people that Haley might have legitimately hated: Peyton Shaw. The Shaw family “heiress”, and richest girl at Regan Hills High School (why, oh, why didn’t her parents send her to a private school?), she was the very definition of vapid bimbo. At 5’3”, with shoulder-length platinum blonde hair that nearly matched her gold-colored dress, she was pretty even with the extra layers of makeup and light spray tan she’d put on for the occasion, and had curves that were not nearly as obscene as Haley’s, while still much fuller than Dakota’s. The look in her bright blue eyes was utterly empty, almost as dumb as that goofy grin on her face, and Haley couldn’t handle it.
Not tonight. Not on Christmas.
“I’m out of here,” Haley said, dropping her glass on the table a little too heavily.
“I’m staying,” Dakota said, amused.
“What? Why?” Haley asked, not wanting to ask Dakota not to leave her alone.
“She has connections!” Dakota chuckled.
“But you hate her!” Haley exclaimed.
“Doesn’t mean I won’t make small talk with her! You should too, we graduate in a few months, and the more connections, the merrier!” Dakota suggested.
Between the incoming Peyton, and getting life lessons from Dakota (even if she did want to stick by her), Haley couldn’t extricate herself from the moment quickly enough.
“Hiya!” Peyton said cheerfully, opening her arms for a fake hug. “Haley, it’s been so long since I’ve, like, seen you at a party!”
Haley tried to dodge the hug, but couldn’t. Peyton held the hug slightly too long in what could have been either overexuberance or an attempted power move. If it was the latter, it didn’t work, since no matter how massive they were (and they were pretty damn massive), her tits couldn’t compare to Haley’s.
“That’s by design,” Haley replied, extricating herself from the hug.
Peyton’s smile faltered slightly, something other than her false cheer showing through for a moment, before she continued, “Well, thanks for showing anyway! Christmas wouldn’t be complete without a little of that festive… color… that you can bring. You do look awfully cold in that dress, though… and this is supposed to be a real classy party… you sure you don’t want to get your jacket?”
Haley looked to Dakota for support, and found only amusement.
So, playing off of Dakota’s earlier jokes, she improvised. “It is a little chilly… good thinking. Say, your dad was standing by the coat room, wasn’t he?”
Haley had absolutely no interest in Mr. Shaw, but Peyton didn’t need to know that.
Peyton spluttered, “I… that’s not what I was-“
“Bye-a!” Haley replied, sliding past Peyton and squeezing her way through the crowd before Peyton could get in a good counter, and while giving Dakota a chance to change the subject.
Though she’d disappeared into the mob of Christmas revelers, Haley could still hear Dakota and Peyton going through all those high-pitched, squealing and girly pleasantries. No doubt Dakota would be thoroughly satisfied with herself for what “networking” she’d pulled off tonight, leaving Haley to fend for herself in this goddamn pit of rich vipers and, and…
Haley humphed, crossing her arms under her breasts. This was turning out to be a much worse night than even she’d expected, and all of her escape routes seemed to be dead ends.
She couldn’t go to her parents and ask to go home, since they’d no doubt try to introduce her to some business associate or another she didn’t care about, or some family friend she hadn’t seen in ages who she of course was expected to remember.
She couldn’t go to Dakota without getting roped into a discussion with Peyton Shaw, and there was no way in fuck she was going to allow that to happen.
She couldn’t get a ride from any of her close friends, because they were all spending Christmas Eve with their families by this point.
She could always call an Uber, which seemed the most tempting option yet, but that would mean taking hell from her parents when she got home, which was not how she wanted to spend Christmas…
No, she was going to have to survive this party one way or another, but that didn’t mean she was going to have to actually be all that present at the party, did it?
It wasn’t a very detailed plan, but it was quick to execute. Haley snuck her way through the crowd, past the string quartet that was playing easily the worst version of “All I Want for Christmas Is You” that she had ever heard, and made her way toward one of the grand staircases leading upstairs. A cordon had been set across it to remind the guests that upstairs was off-limits, but, when had that stopped her in the past?
She made her way upstairs, toward the much quieter, darker upper corridors of the Shaw mansion. Of course, now that she was up here, she had no idea of what she was going to do here. It wasn’t like she could text any of her friends if they were all busy with family, and playing games on her phone the whole damn time didn’t sound all that good…
A wicked grin formed on her face with almost the same speed as the mischievous idea that accompanied it.
Haley knew she couldn’t have fun talking to Peyton Shaw… but she could sure as shit have some fun searching through her room and finding any secrets the bimbo might be hiding. It would be nice, after all, to have something to throw back at her the next time she was being a real cunt around school.
Since Haley had never actually been to Peyton’s room, finding it was easier said than done in a place as palatial as the Shaw’s mansion, with every closed door looking more or less identical to every other closed door, with its upper halls quiet and dark and looking positively haunted compared to the party.
So, she might have quickened her pace as she scoured the halls, but that didn’t mean she was afraid. It just meant she was… eager, yeah, that’s it, eager to find Peyton’s room. Eager to find something, anything that might justify ditching the party and hiding up here, it didn’t mean she was-
Haley stopped by a door that had a pink, framed sign hanging on it.
PEYTON’S ROOM
Dim light crept out from under the door, as if Peyton had forgotten to shut off a lamp before going to the party.
Grinning, Haley said, “Jackpot.”
She turned the knob, quickly opening the door, stepping inside and closing it behind her before anyone might be able to see her.
This was another one of those “easier said than done” situations, as she was quickly spotted by the guy who was kneeling on the floor and digging through one of the lower drawers of Peyton’s dresser. For a second, they each looked at each other like a deer caught in headlights, before Haley returned to a bitchy sneer, and the guy smiled cockily.
Standing up, he straightened himself out and said in one of the smoothest, proudest voices that Haley had ever heard, “I’d say this isn’t what it looks like, buuuuuuuuuuttttt…”
Haley had to give him this, he was pretty good-looking. Easily her age, maybe slightly older, he stood an easy 6’0”. His dark suit, with its white shirt unbuttoned at the top and tie rakishly undone and hanging on either side of the collar, barely hid the fact that he kept in shape, not too bulky, but still clearly muscular and fit. His dirty blonde hair was cut in that more on top, less on the sides look that Haley personally found rather annoying, while not as nearly annoying as how he had it slicked back… but it almost looked good on him. Just like his light tan, or those light blue eyes, or that strong jaw with its light coating of stubble and that damned arrogant grin… fuck, she half wanted to smack that grin off his face, and half wanted to sit and grind on it.
She didn’t even mind his cologne that much, which was prominent, but not too objectionable.
“What does it look like you’re doing?” Haley asked, crossing her arms under her breasts.
His eyes fell down to her impressive chest. “Well, right now I’m staring at your tits… but right before that, it probably looked like I was searching through Peyton’s underwear drawer in search of something lurid, when in fact, the only thing I was searching for was justice.”
Even the way he defended himself had that faint vibe of a slick, used car salesman trying to make a pitch. On any other guy it would have been an immediate turn-off and would’ve had her turning on her heels, but the way he looked, it kinda worked. He was a pig, to be sure, but some pigs could be fun.
The way he didn’t take his eyes off her chest made Haley both angry and proud at the same time, causing her to point two fingers at her chest, and bring them up to her face. “You do know where my eyes are, right?”
“Oh, I definitely know where your eyes are… but you’ve seen your tits, right? I’d be doing them a disservice if I didn’t stare at them. I mean… fucking WOW! You can’t blame me for looking when they’re just that magnificent and so fucking huge, right?” he continued, somehow managing to be defensive and smooth at the same time.
Haley tapped her foot on the ground tentatively, thinking this through before she dropped her arms to her side. “You’re lucky I hate Peyton, or I’d have called her up here a while ago.”
“And that means you’re less inclined to call her now?” he proposed.
“Eh,” she said, noncommittally.
“Much obliged,” he said. “And I’d apologize for the ogling, but that would not be genuine, and I can tell by the look on your face that you enjoyed it, so, I thoroughly and unreservedly regret absolutely nothing about what I just said to you, Miss-“
“Haley,” she replied, holding back a smirk.
“Haley?” he laughed, throwing his head back. “Haley Campbell?”
Haley nodded. He only laughed harder, slapping his hand on his leg. “Oh, of all the ex’s bedrooms in all the world, you, and it had to be you, just had to walk into the one I was currently liberating my possessions from. Oh, if this isn’t a sign that there’s a greater and more twisted plan in play, I don’t know what is…”
He seemed to be finding a great bit of amusement from this, which only confused Haley further, much as she was getting a distinct vibe that she might actually be familiar with this stranger.
“Do I know you?” she asked.
“Know? No. Knew in a way, once, but oh how our parents would wish that knew were present tense!” he said, taking a dramatic bow. “Conner Berriman. I know it’s been a time since our paths have crossed… and it does seem that we’ve changed a fair bit, hasn’t it?”
Haley’s heart skipped a beat. Conner Berriman. The same Conner Berriman that she was doing her best to avoid at the party. The little boy who’d always been as much a bully to her as she had to him, the same little shithead she hadn’t seen since they were fifteen had grown up… and now he was fucking hot? Like, really, really fucking hot, even if it was in kind of a douchey way?
Well, this was just her fucking luck.
“Doesn’t seem like you’ve changed in any important ways,” Haley shot back, lying through her teeth as she couldn’t help but admire the way he wore his suit.
He saw right through this.
“Oh, please. Puberty was a fucking treat for me, and mix that all together with years of water polo and lacrosse and the best dental work money can buy, I know I’m a fucking treat right now. I’m fucking jacked, got all the friends in the world, and I’ve neverleft a girl less than satisfied, and would be happy to show you all the glowing reviews I have from satisfied customers… but, fuck, let’s be honest, even youknow I’m a fucking treat right now the way your eyes got all shiny when you first saw me here,” Conner said, terribly confident as he put his hands in his pockets and smiled a devilish smile that probably got all the girls squirming in her panties.
Alright, maybe it worked a little on Haley, too. Okay, more than a little, but it would take a lot for Haley to admit that out loud.
“My eyes weren’t… shiny,” Haley replied, lamely, rolling her eyes to hide her true expression.
Conner laughed. “They were shiny!”
“No they… well, you can’t fucking prove it, anyway,” she huffed.
“My, my, you get testy when challenged, don’t you. If I’d have known you were this much fun, I’d have sought you out at the party instead of hiding from any girl who mighta been you,” he replied, clearly loving every moment of this.
Well, this was a surprise, especially to a girl as irresistible as Haley. Knowing that he’d been hiding away from her, that might’ve bruised the ego a little, but was something she could at least relate to.
Sighing softly, she replied, “I wouldn’t even fucking be here if I wasn’t trying to avoid anyone who might’ve been you at the party.”
Conner seemed to find their mutual predicament amusing, by the look of his cheeky grin. “Ah, is this for all the crimes of my past? Because I was just that much of a brat?”
“Yes. Has that changed too?” she asked.
Conner laughed. “No. But I have access to my trust fund now, so, I guess that doesn’t really matter, does it?”
He said this with a casual smarminess that made him seem even more like a used car salesman than before. He should have been absolutely fucking disgusting to Haley… but why was he looking so fucking yummy right now? She hadn’t drunk that much of the alcoholic wassail, had she?
“You’re fucking insufferable, has anyone ever told you that?” Haley proposed.
Conner said, “Constantly. Yet I can’t help but notice that you still aren’t leaving the room, so either I’m not as insufferable as you want me to think you think I am, or there’s something else keeping you here.”
She did not want to give him the high ground. “Or I could just be avoiding the party.”
He nodded, considering this point.
“You could be… but there’s dozens of rooms up here you could’ve hidden in if that were the only case, and yet you find yourself in here. Considering that Peyton hasn’t showed up yet, I doubt you came up here with her for a meeting either wholesome or naughty, and while I’d like to think you’re here because of me, since you looked surprised at my presence, I’m of the mind that you’re up here for something that’s not exactly above board. Now, either you’re really committed to whatever naughtiness you meant to commit in here, or you’re staying here because of me,” Conner said.
Haley didn’t like how quickly he read her, and liked it even less that she actually enjoyed how accurately he’d done it. There was something… exciting in his insufferableness, and she was willing to stick around it for just a little bit longer. It wasn’t that she liked Conner beyond any cosmetic level, no, but given where she was and what she could be doing, she rationalized that he was far more interesting than any of her alternatives.
Not that she’d tell her parents, of course.
“You first,” she said. “You tell me why you were here, and I’ll tell you how right you are.”
Conner licked his lips, and held his grin. “Three months ago, Peyton and I dated for a minute or two. It was less dating than it was nailing her, and I admittedly lasted a lot longer than two minutes-“
“I get the picture,” Haley interrupted on instinct, much as she would have liked to actually see a little more of the picture.
He nodded. “Very well. Well, we broke up after about a month of this, and she kept a lot of my stuff that I’d left around here without any intention of giving it back. Nothing that couldn’t be replaced, mind, I’ll go back to casually mentioning that I’m filthy rich again, but getting it back is more a matter of principle to me. I could have gone to the proper authorities about this and informed them that my ex robbed me, but think of her reputation… and how much more fun it is to take it back while attending her family’s lame-as-hell Christmas party?”
Haley couldn’t help but snort in laughter. Conner joined her, and as obnoxious as his laugh was, she liked it in the moment.
“You’re robbing her,” Haley said, amused.
“Only of what is mine, sweet Haley,” Conner said, looking back at her tits and grinning.
Unconsciously, Haley turned toward him slightly, bending over just a little to give him a better look at her cleavage. If he was going to be looking, and she was going to enjoy him looking, she might as well make sure it was a good look, right?
“Your turn,” Conner replied. “Just what the fuck were you doing in here?”
Since she got the feeling that he was telling the truth, Haley stepped forward into the room and decided to be honest, “Peyton’s always such a fucking bitch around school, thinking she’s all high and mighty because she’s so fucking rich and she’s a Shaw and all that… I’m not saying I’ve got the high ground or anything either, but, I’ll fight fire with fire, and I was gonna look to see if I could find any secrets that I could use to throw back in her smug, cunty face in case she ever comes after me or my friends again.”
Conner smirked, nodding slightly. “Her diary’s in the bedstand, second drawer. There’s a box of sex toys and weed in the trunk at the end of her bed, and some sexy underwear in these drawers right here that I doubt Mommy and Daddy would be happy to find… but if you wanna sort through those, you’re gonna have to wait, I’m still claiming what’s mine.”
Haley didn’t need to think about this much. “Fair; I’m gonna check out her diary, then.”
“Go nuts, though I assure you, it’s not nearly as interesting as you’ll hope. Only mention of you is on her ‘Enemies List’, and the rest is her talking about boys, football players mostly, whining over what happened to that little bitch Kyle Bowman so much you’d think she was in love, and gushing over the cock of some guy named Brian King… whoever that is,” Conner explained.
She shivered slightly at the mention of that name, then said softly to herself. “Well, I guess Peyton does have some taste.”
“What’s that?” he asked.
“Nothing,” Haley replied, shaking her head, “It would take too long to explain.”
She crossed Peyton’s room, taking it in properly for the first time and trying not to laugh. It was like there was a pink explosion amidst all the gold and white of the rest of the house, but unlike Brooke, who knew how to put pink together, Peyton’s room was as tacky as the rest of the house. There were racks of trophies and awards above her king-sized bed, though if you looked closely enough, most were participation trophies and awards from places that had accepted donations from her parents. The bed itself was almost entirely consumed by decorative pillows and plushies, while the rest of her room was mostly made up of clothing storage that she couldn’t fit into her enormous, walk-in closet.
Even though she didn’t doubt Conner’s assessment of the diary, Haley sat on the bed and pulled it out anyway, flipping through its pages and finding that his description was pretty accurate, even if he did skip mentioning how she dotted her I’s with hearts (but had infuriatingly good handwriting).
“So, I have to ask…” Haley said, flipping through the pages idly.
“Ask away,” he said, pulling a shiny Zippo from the back of her underwear drawer and pocketing it. “Yes! Thought I’d lost you forever…”
“Why Peyton?” she asked. “Gotta be plenty of top tier girls at your private school you could screw around with… why her?”
Conner chuckled. “It’s more of a ‘why not’ kind of thing. I’d been with all the girls at school who mattered, and when I was in town here it was like… well, she’s a smoke show even if she ain’t too smart, and I could see if she had it where it mattered.”
“Did she?” Haley asked, curious.
“Better than you’d expect, actually. She’s a wild one… flexible, stacked (though not as stacked as you), open-minded… but too fucking clingy. I like it pretty casual,” he said, pushing the drawer shut. He stood by the dresser for a moment, looking at Haley as if sizing up various options, before strolling over and sitting down beside her.
Haley thought about moving off, but didn’t. She didn’t sense any danger from him… well, not any danger she wasn’t curious about, anyway.
She set the diary on the bedstand. “Yeah, you seem the casual type.”
He laughed. “Oh, don’t pretend you’re any better than me; I’ve fucked Regan Hills girls, I know how things are around here.”
Alright, he had a point there. “And that’s a problem?”
Conner’s eyes dropped back to her tits again. “Oh, not in the slightest. In fact, I could see myself finding reasons to stay here full time, honestly.”
Haley rolled her eyes. “Oh, yeah, how many reasons?”
“Two at the moment, but I’m sure you have plenty more that I haven’t seen yet,” he shot back.
She had to struggle to hold back a laugh again. “God… you’ve always been such a pain in the ass, you know that?”
“I could be one now too, if you’re into that kind of thing,” Conner replied, grinning.
“I’m serious… though I can be into that kind of thing… but you were always such a little bully. I always fucking hated you, you know? I hated the way you thought you could get away with anything, how you always used to pick on me, and how our parents always fucking tried to put us together like we were breeding pandas because they just thought we had to get together one of these days? Fuck, you always made me so fucking miserable,” Haley explained.
He continued, “Oh, I assure you, the misery was quite mutual. You could give it as well as you could take it, Haley, and you weren’t the only one to hate parental pressure. I like slinging my dick around like any other guy, but if my parents had their way, it’d only be with a list of pre-approved girls who ‘fit my standing’, and let me tell you, that’d be a short fucking list.”
“Ouch,” Haley commiserated.
“Tell me about it,” Conner replied, before bringing the subject back around to the direction he’d clearly wanted. “But, let’s be honest with ourselves, aside from how we’ve… developed over the years, not a lot’s changed for either of us. I’m still my little old charming self-“
“A smarmy fucking douchebag?” she interrupted.
“Exactly,” Conner retorted.
“While I’m charm and grace and beauty personified?” Haley teased, blinking at him cutely.
“If you mean a complete and utter bitch, yeah, that’s right,” he replied. “But, what the hell, we’re probably better enough than we were then. Got all that puberty shit sorted out, did some mental growing, becoming slightly better people who are slightly less crazy and all that.”
“Slightly,” she agreed, finding the sudden closeness with him a little… heated. While his eyes kept moving between her lips and her chest, she looked over his strong frame, down toward his lap. She’d have had to be blind not to see that bulge growing… and it looked like one hell of a bulge.
This wasn’t something she could think about. No, she’d spent so much of the night wanting, trying to avoid this exact thing, but a little while in a room alone with Conner and suddenly she was going all goo-goo eyes over him. It was disgusting. He was disgusting… but he was also so fucking hot. She wasn’t sure if she believed him about all of his satisfied customers, but suddenly she was curious about what it would be like. The guy was an athlete, he had to have stamina and muscles for ages, assuming he actually earned his spot on those teams…
And the way he looked at her, so hungrily yet so confidently, was new in a pleasant way. With few exceptions, most boys and men she knew were intimidated by her body. They would look at her, to be sure, and they would want her, but they wouldn’t have even the slightest idea of what they were doing with her. The way Conner eyed her… he didn’t see her as a challenge, or a problem. He looked at her like they were every bit the match made in heaven their parents always wanted them to be, and it was infuriating to find them so right about this guy she was still pretty certain she couldn’t stand.
“So, in the spirit of Christmas, and both of us learning and growing and all that, wanna say we forge a truce and stop being such assholes to each other?” Conner proposed.
Haley thought about this. “Sure, what the hell?”
He smirked. “Awesome… awesome, that is fucking fantastic, because if we’re alone in this room, looking for things that might make Peyton miserable if we ever sought to use them, it’s for the best that we’re friends-“
“Allies,” she corrected. “Let’s not go crazy here.”
“Alright, allies is a relationship status change that I can enjoy…” he said, smiling that charming smile and looking her back in the eyes in a way that made her feel exceptionally warm.
There was a silence between the two of them, one that could’ve become any number of things if they let it go on any longer. With both of them being the kind of people who could command whatever room they were in, both knew that this silence could not last forever, and that it was just a matter of seeing who would say something first.
“So…” he said, choosing his words carefully. “You wanna do something we’ll never tell our parents?”
Feeling that delicious heat growing inside of her, Haley replied, “You mean, fuck?”
His eyes widened, slightly, as his grin grew to be toothy and excited. “Actually, I was gonna suggest we smoke all of Peyton’s weed… but I might like your idea better.”
She rolled her eyes at him. “Just shut up and kiss me, asshole…”
With that, Haley tackled him to Peyton’s bed, landing on top of him and nearly smothering him with her tits. He grunted in surprise, and she laughed as his head seemed to be dwarfed by her massive boobs. It wasn’t how she’d intended to land, honestly, but it sure was a lot of fun watching him struggle, his eyes wide as he looked up at the insane curves of her massive tits.
“You’ve been staring at my tits since I walked into this room… you wanna get a good, up-close view of them? Well, take them in…” she teased, forcing them against his face.
Conner wriggled his neck enough that he was able to get a breath of air, nestling his chin in her cleavage as he looked up at her. He tried to push around her, but she held him in place decently, for the moment.
“How the fuck are you so strong?” he asked, giving up on fighting her off for the moment and reaching his arms around her so he could unzip the back of her dress.
Since the dress was tight, and annoying, and his strong hands felt pretty damn good, she let him. Haley sighed with relief as she felt the zipper go down to her mid-back, releasing impressive amounts of pressure on her chest and upper back.
“Cheerleaders… we’re stronger than we look,” she answered. “And I know you’re stronger than this… you wouldn’t let a girl dominate you like this unless you wanted her to… you’re just being a big baby about this because you love being smothered in my tits, aren’t you?”
“Maybe…” Conner replied, keeping one hand behind her as he was able to miraculously unclasp her bra in one try. “Or maybe I just liked having you on top for starters, because it’s way easier to get you topless in this position.”
He smiled up at her with an impressive shit-eating grin, but Haley couldn’t argue that it was a pretty good move. Her bras tended to be pretty damn strong to hold in her enormous tits, with clasps to match, and here Conner was, able to not only unclasp her bra blind, but one-handed.
Haley shifted her position, hiking her skirt just enough to allow her to straddle his hips. It was impossible to miss the insistent pressure of his impressive erection beneath her, and this was a pleasure that she meant to unleash for herself very, very soon, but for now she had the ultimate opportunity to tease.
There was no way in hell she wasn’t going to take advantage of it.
“So, you really want to see my tits, don’t you?” Haley said, gently grinding against his clothed cock as she teased the fabric at the front of her dress, using both hands to hold both it and her bra in place.
“You really gotta ask?” Conner chuckled. “I don’t think there’s any guy alive out there who likes tits who wouldn’t want to see yours. Or, see ‘em for starters I should say. I could get a lot of good ideas of what to do with ‘em with a better look.”
She rolled her eyes. “And that’s the kind of line that usually works for you?”
“Actually the ‘trust fund’ line usually works for most of the girls fate and upbringing tends to place me around,” he admitted. “But since that doesn’t work for you, I’ve gotta try a little harder. It’s working, though, isn’t it?”
Haley wouldn’t admit that it was, not when he was being this kind of arrogant prick. “No.”
“Yeah, it is,” Conner replied, gently grabbing hold of her hips in his hands for traction, allowing him to better grind against her tantalizingly. “You’re getting off on this. Fucking around in Peyton’s room when you’re supposed to be at some boring-ass party, with this guy you think you hate but you can’t help but grind on his cock (and let me tell you, it is an amazing cock), you’re fucking loving this. You can’t wait to show me those huge titties… fuck, you probably wanted to show them to me the second you saw me, didn’t you?”
“No!” she replied with a little more indignation, though at this point she had a difficult time being certain that this was true. Her hands might have slipped slightly, revealing a little bit more of her creamy, huge tits.
“Yeah, you did… I’ve seen that look, I know that look… you’re teasing me, you’re having your fun, but you’re gonna show me your tits like you always wanted to. You’re gonna show me those big fucking tits, let me squeeze them, lick them, suck them… hell, I’ll probably fuck ‘em, won’t I? ‘cause a bitch like you with tits like those, I know you fucking love wrapping those tits around a guy’s cock and making him cum aaaaaaaaall over you. Tell me I’m wrong, make me believe it,” Conner continued, smiling and laughing at the faint discomfort on her face.
It was true, of course. Maybe it wasn’t at first, but it sure as hell was now, and why deny it any longer.
“Fine, you wanna see my tits?” Haley continued, dropping the front of her dress, then shrugging out of her bra.
With her bare, H-cup tits now fully exposed, and her pink, hard nipples standing out invitingly, Haley knew she made quite a sight. Most people who saw her naked for the first time were left utterly agog at the sight, and she’d seen many men and more than a few girls rendered speechless by the body she was packing. It gave her a great sense of pride, and a distinct feeling of raw power, witnessing their reactions when they saw her for the first time.
And Conner fucking Berriman did not disappoint on this front.
His eyes widened and his jaw dropped open as he took in her topless form. Haley saw his lips working, either trying to form words or imagining what it felt like to suck on her nipples, it was difficult to be sure, but whatever it was, she saw that he was held captive by her boobs, and she chose to enjoy this moment.
Silencing guys who thought they were god’s gift to women, like Conner clearly thought, was the fucking best.
“Admit it. These are the best fucking tits you’ve ever seen,” Haley commanded, wriggling in his lap in a way where she now had thorough control.
“I, uh… well, they’re certainly the biggest,” Conner said, trying to keep diplomatically in charge of the conversation.
Haley didn’t feel like allowing that, leaning forward slightly so that her breasts were tantalizingly close to his face, without touching. “That’s not what I fucking said, and you know it. Admit it, these aren’t just the biggest, but they’re also the best fucking tits you’ve ever seen… probably the best you ever will see. You’ve been with plenty of girls before, but none of them are like me. None of them could be like me, because I’m the best…”
She dropped her hands to his chest, undoing a button on his shirt. “…you’ll…”
She undid another button. “…ever…”
Finally, she undid three more buttons in quick succession, giving herself a nice view of his fit chest. She’d have to finish unbuttoning it to see the full package, but she liked what she saw, and she knew she would be very happy seeing more.
“…have!” Haley finished, smiling down at him arrogantly as she pressed her boobs together with her upper arms. The effect gave a massive valley of cleavage between her bare tits, one that held his eyes enraptured.
Smiling at her captive audience, she continued, “All you have to do is admit it. Admit that these are the best fucking tits you’ve ever seen… and I will rock your fucking world. You know I’m good for it… just fucking say the words, and I’m all yours, Conner.”
Conner licked his lips uncertainly, but quickly found his smile again. “What we’re about to do, we were gonna do no matter what I said.”
“Probably,” Haley admitted with a tilt of her head. “But I want to hear the fucking words anyway.”
“Alright…” he mused, before quickly half-sitting up, wrapping his arms around her waist, and twisting her around so that she fell onto her back on the bed, with him on top and her head almost buried in a mess of pillows and stuffed animals.
Haley might have squealed indignantly, just a little, but truth be told, she enjoyed where she was, so she wasn’t going to complain too hard.
“Your tits, sweet Haley, are the greatest I’ve ever seen, and probably will ever see…” Conner said, leaning his face tantalizingly close to her face. “And you and me are gonna do some great and terrible things in this room.”
Before he could elaborate on what these great and terrible things would be, he leaned down and kissed her. It was a hot, forceful kiss, but not the kiss of some boy trying inexpertly to overpower her. No, it was one of experience, of heat and passion, his lips melding to hers, exploring them without pushing too hard, his tongue brushing gently against hers without forcing its way in. It was a good kiss, almost too brief for her liking, one that made Haley lean in and kiss him back harder, more forcefully. She put her plump, skilled lips to work, moaning softly as she made out with Conner heatedly.
Of course, in this time, he managed to get his hands on her tits because, honestly, how couldn’t he? He reached for them, squeezing and massaging them, flicking her nipples with his thumbs before pinching them between thumb and forefinger. In the heat of the moment, she couldn’t deny that it felt fucking good to get groped by him while they made out.
And this is not to say that her hands weren’t busy either, no, she quickly found them dropping to his ass… his firm, athletic ass that on touch alone she knew would make her mouth water when she’d get to see it. As he groped and pleasured her, she took her every opportunity to get her own groping in as they passionately made out.
Conner broke their kiss for a moment, looking down at her with some awe. “You’re so fucking hot…”
“You’re alright too… but why are you talking when you could have a mouthful of tit?” Haley complained, rolling her eyes at his brief moment of sentimentality.
“Alright, alright, keep your panties on…” he replied, lowering his head to her epic tits. “And by that I mean, don’t… I’m gonna get you naked, or near enough, soon… and ‘keep your panties on’ is officially a really dumb thing for me to say right now. Pretend I didn’t say anything.”
“Yeah, I’m definitely gonna do that,” she replied, amused but trying not to look amused at this annoyingly confident jackass stumbling over his words like a horny first-timer simply because of his proximity to her bare tits.
Nevertheless, Haley did enjoy that eager mouth of his once it actually found her tits, with his kisses and sucks and nibbles every bit as gentle and forceful as she liked, especially when he showed the proper attention to her nipples. He took to those like a starving man, often getting close to going too hard, but never crossing that boundary, always making sure she got exactly what she wanted. Pleasure arced down her back and to the tips of her toes from his exquisite efforts, and she was more than happy to reward that in kind.
Haley kicked off her shoes, then arched her back, pulling her dress and bra down, then off of her body, pushing them toward the foot of the bed. The dress was certainly going to be wrinkled in a way that would upset her parents, but, fuck them for making her come here tonight, right?
Besides, Conner certainly seemed to think this was an improvement, seeing Haley dressed only in her lacy panties, garter belt and stockings.
“My, my, my… it’s like you came here tonight looking to get laid. Not very Christmas-y if you ask me,” he teased, sucking one of her nipples into his mouth after he got a good view.
Haley gripped his head to her tit, “Oh, fuck you and keep sucking… just because a girl wears some nice lingerie to a party, it doesn’t mean she was trying to get some… maybe she just likes the feel of it…”
Letting go of Haley’s nipple with a nibble that sent her groaning, Conner replied, “I can think of some other things you’d like to feel.”
A warmth grew between Haley’s legs. “Yeah?”
“Yeah…” Conner replied, climbing off of Haley and the bed. “Slide up to the head of the bed.”
“Fine,” she replied, an exasperated sigh in her voice even if she actually found herself anticipating this moment excitedly. Haley slid to the head of the bed, pushing her way through Peyton’s stuffed animals and decorative pillows until her shoulders rested against the headboard.
“Complain all you want,” Conner said, bending over to take off his shoes and socks before he stood up again. “But something tells me you’ll like this next part.”
“What tells you that?” Haley asked.
He took off his jacket and tie and tossed them onto a nearby chair. “The way you’ve been making goo-goo eyes at me since you got in here.”
Haley crossed her arms under her tits, pouting slightly. “I don’t make ‘goo-goo’ eyes.”
“Yes, you do,” Conner continued, laughing confidently. “Even after you found out who I was. Even after you remembered how much you hated me. Your eyes were positively ‘goo-goo’ for me. Which, you know, is fantastic for my already swollen ego. You want to stare at me, I want you to stare at me… I don’t see where the problem is in this.”
Haley didn’t like that he seemed to have this good a read on her. There was something about this arrogant prick’s confidence that really did it for her. If he was half as good as he thought he was… then this might not be that much of a wasted night after all.
Still, she had an image to maintain.
Haley humphed. “You know, if you really wanted me to look, you could be showing me a little more. I feel like I’ve been more than generous here.”
For emphasis, she spread her legs slightly, allowing him a better view of her lacy panties, and a hint at her bright red pubic hair that managed to sneak around the skimpy underwear. The way his eyes fell between her legs made her smirk with her own well-earned arrogance, but he quickly looked her back in the eye as he finished unbuttoning his shirt.
Conner made an unhurried show of getting undressed, something that Haley found equally exciting and infuriating. She doubted he was the kind of guy who was averse to rushing when he was with a girl, and yet here he was, drawing it out because he knew how it drove her crazy.
Still, Conner clearly wasn’t the kind of guy to deny himself, either, as soon he pulled off his shirt and dropped it to the floor.
Haley had to give him this: he took care of himself. He was well-muscled without being frighteningly bulky, a definite swimmer’s body, built more for purpose than being there to impress anyone (though he certainly understood how easy it was to impress girls with it).
“Is that more of what you were looking for?” he asked.
Haley licked her lips, trying not to make it too obvious how much heavier her breathing had gotten in the last few moments. “It’s a good start.”
Conner laughed. “I’ll grant that my chest isn’t nearly as impressive as yours, but I like to think I do well by myself… but I won’t leave you in too much suspense for the next part, since I know you’re positively dying to find out what happens next, aren’t you?”
“Oh, is it that obvious?” she replied, watching as he unbuckled his belt.
“Yeah. You’re pretty much broadcasting your feelings so loud, it’s a miracle nobody downstairs has heard,” he said, dropping his pants to the floor.
His legs were every bit as nice as the rest of his body, but that much was obvious even with his clothes on. Haley’s eyes were soon drawn to the front of his boxers, seeing the impressive bulge straining them. His cock didn’t look nearly as impressive as Ryan’s… but she had to admit, he still looked pretty fucking huge.
That brought another nice quiver to Haley’s body, and a spreading, tingling warmth to her pussy.
Stepping out of his pants, Conner climbed onto the bed and crawled toward Haley, knocking to the floor a number of Peyton’s pillows, and pushing in for another deep kiss. Haley accepted this kiss readily, running her hands over his chest and muscles and finding herself pleasantly pleased by what she found.
And then, unable to help herself, she laughed.
“That doesn’t usually happen at this point,” Conner said cheekily, kissing her neck. “What’s the laughter for?”
“Just wondering what my parents would think if they saw us now,” Haley sighed, amused. “I feel like they’d be jumping up and down for joy and saying, ‘finally!’”
“I mean, I won’t say it wouldn’t be the same with my folks, and it is the kind of funny thought that is worth laughing about at the appropriate time, but, I’d say that this is a far more appropriate time for other diversions,” he replied, kissing her neck again.
She nodded. “You’re right, you’re right, I just got a little silly, and- OH!”
Haley gasped as Conner’s fingers found the front of her panties, insistently pressing against the damp fabric and exploring the outer folds of her pussy.
“See? Isn’t this a whole lot better than thinking about how stupid our parents can be?” Conner said, kissing her on the lips with a greater intensity.
Fuck, he was good with his fingers. Haley had to bite her lip to hold back a sudden, intense moan of pleasure as his quick, strong fingers continued rubbing her through her panties more firmly.
He kissed her again, then reached down with both hands and hooked his fingers into the waistband of her panties. Haley arched her back against the headboard, pulling her ass off the bed long enough to allow him to pull off her panties, his fingers taking their time as he ran them down her shapely dancer’s legs. Conner took a moment to look down at her pussy with some pride, taking in her full, glistening pussy lips, and her thick patch of red pubic hair.
“And here I thought I was gonna have to wait until tomorrow to open up any presents,” he said cockily. Still holding her panties, he balled them up in one hand, taking a quick sniff of them, and smiled.
“You’re fucking wet…” Conner murmured, pleased with himself. “And you smell fucking great… you know I’m keeping these, right?”
“Asshole,” Haley grunted as he pressed the fingers of his other hand against her sensitive folds. “Those are nice panties.”
Rather than immediately answer her, he fingered her with a greater insistence. He moved over her pussy with an expert precision, proving that he could at least some of his confidence was well earned. His fingers were just thick enough, just nimble enough, just strong enough to please the limited depths of her pussy that he explored, never delving too deep as he just teased her entrance, before going back to running quick yet firm little circles over her clit.
Conner was quite quickly putting her in a position where she would have had a hard time arguing with whatever he wanted.
“And they’re mine now… call it a trophy, or a backlog of Christmas presents you never got me… whatever makes you sleep better at night, hating me or fucking loving what I can do to you and offering them to me in gratitude, I’m keeping those panties…” he replied, tossing them onto his pile of clothes on the floor.
Haley dropped her head back, groaning heavily as her breathing increased. She rocked her hips against his hand, grinding more firmly against his increasingly amazing fingering. Words were beginning to cease to have meaning, and much as she might have wanted to be a bitch to him, it was kind of hard to do that when he was making her feel this good.
“Fine… whatever… asshole…” she moaned, rocking her hips against his fingers more intently, wanting more of the pleasure he was giving her.
Feeling this, Conner slowed his pace, grinning malevolently as he pulled back from pleasuring her. He didn’t stop, though, not fully, edging her slowly as she whined and stared daggers through him.
For this, Conner was unfazed.
“You know, you can be a real cunt sometimes, Haley… always have been…” he said, keeping his pace slow, but never once backing off.
Groaning, Haley rocked herself against his hands with greater force, close to cumming and desperate to get off. “Fuck you… always such an asshole…”
Gently, he squeezed her clit. “An asshole who’s holding your clit… so if I were in your position, I’d be a little nicer, beg a little, maybe even apologize for being such a bitch to me?”
She reached down for her pussy with her hands and growled, “No.”
Deftly, Conner grabbed her hands with his free hand and pinned them to the wall above her head before she could do anything. Needy and outmaneuvered, Haley whimpered, rocking against him. She was achingly wet and so very hot, desperately needing a release he seemed all too content to deny from her just to prove his own playfully sick point.
With a desperation that she knew she had to give in to, Haley thought that a soft surrender might be in order.
“Please…” she moaned, her full lips parting as the air in her lungs felt decidedly ragged.
“Please, what?” Conner teased, giving her a little relief as he sped up his fingers slightly.
“Please, let me cum… please make me cum…” Haley moaned, looking at him with the most lustful eyes she could muster.
He rather seemed to enjoy this suddenly submissive side of her. It wasn’t one that she planned on showing him much of, but it was hard to deny how much hotter this soft voice of hers made Haley feel.
“And that apology I was asking for?” Conner teased, giving her a little more pressure, then backing off again.
“I’m sorry, alright?” she groaned, her eyes darkening as she still fought giving in. “I’m sorry I can be such a cunt, and that you were such an asshole I had to be that cunt…”
This was one of those things she knew could have gone any number of ways, and if he’d decided to be an asshole then and there and leave her hanging, well, at least that would have been predictable. What she couldn’t have predicted, however, was that Conner would then laugh, smiling a surprisingly genuine grin at her fight.
“Alright, you got me there. You’ve earned your cum,” he said, speeding up the pace of his deft fingers again as he let go of her hands and went back to pleasuring her.
Haley groaned from deep within, reaching down to massage her tits, squeezing them to help build the pressure in her pussy, pinching her nipples, writhing and moaning as the pleasure began to overtake her. Though she wanted to close her eyes tightly, she forced herself to look into Conner’s blue orbs. They were the cockiest eyes she’d ever seen, above the most arrogant smirk she’d ever known… fuck, everything about him made her hate him all the more, especially how he’d gotten her to this point, made her feel so fucking good… how could an asshole like him be so fucking good, anyway? How could he look so much better the worse he was? Seriously, how was he doing this to her, making her feel…
The buildup within her was too intense. Haley dropped her hands, grabbing tightly onto whatever she could find in the pile of pillows and plushies.
“Oh fuck, oh fuck, oh FUCK YOU, YOU MOTHERFUCKER!” Haley cried out, gushing against his fingers as pleasure exploded inside of her.
It was a powerful cum, a blinding cum, one that tensed every fiber of every muscle in her body and sent them to a world of floating pleasure. Her body bucked as everything was set alight, and all of this while she still looked into the painfully confident eyes of this man she hated so.
This hatred didn’t die out as her orgasm faded, or as he leaned in to make out with her. She kissed him back hungrily, wanting more of what this asshole had to offer.
“Still hate me?” Conner asked, taking his fingers from her pussy.
“Of course… but I could learn to love this,” Haley groaned, taking hold of his hand and bringing it to her lips so that she could suck her juices from his fingers.
He hissed pleasurably at this contact. “What, squirting all over Peyton’s stuffed animals? Because I gotta admit, that’s pretty fucking impressive…”
“Shut up,” she replied, pushing him onto his back on the bed. “Just shut up, for once in your fucking life, stop being such an ass and shut the fuck up and let me do what I want…”
Haley reached for his waistband and began to tug at it. Amused, he asked, “And I’m guessing you’re wanting cock?”
“Fucking duh,” she replied, rolling her eyes as she leaned in and pulled his underwear down around his knees.
Haley gasped as all eight inches of his thick cock bounced up and hit her on the cheek. Her surprise was only temporary, though, as she soon took in the sight of what had to be one of the best cocks she had ever seen. Firm and thick, with a nice, flared and purple cockhead, already leaking a generous amount of slippery precum. His balls looked large and impressively full for how much sex he claimed to have, and she knew that he probably came like a fucking firehose.
“So, that’s an amazing fucking cock, right?” Conner asked, holding back a gasp of his own as she wrapped her hands around the base of his cock, slowly jerking him as she explored his size.
Smirking with her own amusement as her hands reached the top and she ran her thumbs over the head, spreading the precum around, Haley replied, “I’ve seen bigger, honestly.”
He hissed. “Cheerleader like you, all the jocks at your disposal… I’m not surprised…”
She laughed. “Actually, the biggest I’ve ever seen is on a nerd; probably the best fuck I’ve ever had, and someone who’s quite frankly a better guy than you’ll probably ever be…”
Eyes widening, confused, Conner asked, “Wha-“
Before he could finish, however, Haley leaned in and sucked his cock down to the root.
This was enough to quiet any objections he had, as getting deepthroated by a huge-titted, redheaded cheerleader had a way of doing.
While Haley was happy with what the “shock and awe” approach offered, she wasn’t going to stop there, no. When Conner thought he was this kind of hot shit, she was going to show him that she wasn’t any slouch either. If she had her way, he’d be comparing all the other girls he fucked after this to her, and she was going to ensure the impression she left was lasting.
And so, she gave him her best, energetically bobbing up and down on his cock, stroking him with one hand at the same time, while using her other hand to play with his balls. On every pull back, she would swirl her tongue over his cockhead, making deep eye contact with him before dropping back down until he was buried deep down her throat. After enough experience on Ryan, Conner wasn’t that much of a challenge, but even that didn’t prevent her from gagging a little every time she took him deep inside.
The way he began to thrust up against her, moaning and groaning and breathing heavily, she knew that she’d managed to surprise him.
“Fuck… fuck, you’ve sucked a lot of cock before, haven’t you?” Conner asked, catching his breath. “I shouldn’t be surprised… fucking Regan Hills girls, you know your stuff… holy shit… fuck, that feels so fucking good… such a fucking slut… should’ve hit you up earlier…”
Haley pulled off of his cock briefly, kissing the head before she smiled mischievously. “You should’ve… wouldn’t have wasted all that time on Peyton…”
“God, no… don’t get me wrong, she was good… a helluva lot better than you’d expect… but not half as fucking good as you… and your tits, goddamn… I can’t wait to cum on your tits…” he moaned, grabbing a handful of her hair.
“You won’t find any better. And they look fucking amazing covered in cum,” Haley said, cocky and proud in that brief moment before he shoved his cock back down her throat again.
“Fuck, I bet… I think I’d like to find that out soon…” Conner groaned, thrusting into her mouth as he forcibly bobbed her head up and down on his cock. “You know, I’ve been with a lot of sluts, all shapes and sizes, all kinds of skills, but I think you might be the best of the bunch… you’re sucking my cock so fucking good… god, I don’t know what I did to get on Santa’s good list this year, because you ask any of my exes and they’ll tell you I’ve done everything to get on the naughty list, but I’ll fucking take it…”
There was little gentleness in the way that Conner fucked Haley’s throat, but she didn’t mind. She loved knowing that she could drive a guy this crazy, and while he was rough, he wasn’t hurting her in any way she didn’t want to be hurt. No, he used her like she wanted to be used, as if she were his own personal sex toy. It was a kind of freeing moment, surrendering to his control like this, licking and sucking and slurping while he controlled the pace of this rough face fuck. With one hand between her legs, teasing her pussy and keeping her nice and excited, Haley was positively pleased with how this was going.
But that didn’t mean she intended to stop here.
No, while she would have been fine to just blow him and make him cum on her tits here (especially since they’d been gone a minute, and people from the party might start to wonder where they were), she was too invested at this point to give up and stop now, and Conner was clearly the same.
No, there was no way this night was going to end without the two of them fucking.
So, while it may have taken a little convincing, Haley got Conner to let go of her hair. She pulled off of his cock, strands of drool and precum connecting her lips messily to his throbbing erection as she coughed and caught her breath. Without a word, while still locking her eyes on his, Haley wiped her mouth with the back of her hand and crawled on top of him. Her heart beat heavily with anticipation as the size of his immense cock hit her, pressing against her belly as she straddled his legs, then squatted so his cock was only a few inches below her pussy. The heat between both of them could be felt, a radiant excitement that threatened to actually make this moment mean something, which might have been a problem if they still hadn’t been showing off to each other.
Conner looked up at her with some kind of awe (and with boobs like hers, how couldn’t he?), but he tried to cover it with another smirk. “Fucking finally.”
Sneering, Haley reached between her legs to take hold of his cock and lined it up with her pussy. She brushed the head lightly over her lips, causing both of them to groan softly at the electric contact.
“You’re such a fucking asshole,” she said, her voice full of venom as she began to drop down onto his cock.
His cockhead was wide, and her pussy was tight, so it wasn’t exactly an easy entry, but enough pregaming between them prevented it from being impossible. Haley grit her teeth as she felt his cock begin to spread her lips, trying to keep a look of absolute superiority as she let him into her cunt, but the way he looked up at her said that was a losing battle. Nothing she could do could keep him from looking like the cockiest bastard on Earth, and try as she might, he wouldn’t be giving up anything anytime soon.
She could keep fighting him, or she could just give in and enjoy herself…
“Fuck it,” Haley whispered, lifting up slightly, then dropping down some more, finally forcing his cockhead, and nearly half of his cock inside of her.
“Fuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuck…” Conner groaned, chuckling to himself slightly. “You’re fucking tiiiiiiiiight.”
He reached up at that moment to grope her tits with both hands, something that felt quite delicious as she was getting used to the feeling of being so exquisitely stretched by his impressive cock.
“And you’re still an asshole… but this is also still a nice fucking cock…” Haley groaned, grabbing one of his hands so she could suck his finger while she settled down on his cock. She took inch after inch without complaint, suckling his finger harder as she mewled and moaned. Each inch brought her greater satisfaction, but she would never be truly satisfied until she had every inch buried deep inside of her.
She had to make him understand, after all, that her pussy was the best he’d ever find… and if she enjoyed herself in the process, well, so much the better…
Finally, she settled down in his lap, his cock buried completely inside of her. Part of her wanted to cry out, embrace that particular ecstasy that came with being filled with one of the nicer cocks she’d ever had the chance to sit on… but she didn’t. No, Haley wanted to make sure that this was going to be something that he would never forget, and that Conner would treat this with every bit of awe that being with a girl like her required.
And so, she sat up on him as regally as if she were a queen sitting on her throne, pushing his arms down at his sides and pinning them and looking down at Conner smugly as she crossed her arms under her tits proudly.
“Well?” Haley asked, expectant.
Conner looked up at her, licking his lips before forcing something that resembled his usual cocky grin. “Well, what? You just sitting there in the expectation that I’m going to start worshipping you, offering some supplication as if you were my own personal goddess just because you got me beneath you, looking up at your epic beauty and even more epic tits, whilst you… oh fuck… while you massage my cock with those impressive cheerleader pussy muscles?”
Cocking her head tauntingly, she squeezed his cock with her pussy again and said, “Yeah. Yeah, I was expecting exactly that.”
He stayed where he was for a while, shifting his arms, seemingly hoping for a chance to change positions and take control, but Haley used her deceptive strength to keep his arms pinned.
“Well, seems you’ve got me in a bit of a bind here,” Conner said, smiling up at her roguishly.
“You can get out of that bind pretty easy, you know…” Haley said, gripping his wrists a little tighter. “Come on, suck up your stupid fucking pride, and I’ll be happy to rock your fucking world…”
“Well, when you put it like that…” he chuckled, clearing his throat and twitching his cock inside of her. “Miss Haley Campbell, I do formally bow to your godly beauty, throwing myself at your mercy with all appropriate supplication in front of your awesome and overpowering beauty. Grant me the boon of thy body, and I promise to fuck you every bit as good as you fuck me, plus a little extra interest as payment of the asshole tax that I seem to owe you for years of punishment and annoyance. There, that about what you were looking for?”
Haley let go of his wrists.
“It’ll do,” she replied, leaning down to kiss him deeply as she shifted her knees onto the bed, then began to rock her hips rapidly.
Haley knew that Conner wasn’t the kind of guy who would take a fuck like this slowly, and horny as she was, she was happy to fuck him with every bit of brutality that her body could summon. Her hips were a blur as she bounced up and down on his cock, taking almost every bit of his cock with each swift rock before slamming back down against him. While they made out at first, soon Haley arched her back and thrust her tits into his face as she rode him, crying out pleasurably as he suckled on one of her nipples.
“Fuck, yes, fuck!” she moaned, savoring how his cock stretched her pussy toward its limits and how it set all her nerves alight.
“Yeah, that’s goddamn right…” Conner grunted, chuckling and briefly biting down on one of her nipples. “How’s this fucking pussy still so fucking tight?”
Haley laughed in pleased superiority. “Because I’m the best you’ll find, duh! You know I’m better than Peyton in pretty much every way, right? Better tits, better body, better fuck… hotter, smarter…”
“Hands down,” he replied, “I mean, she’s not bad, fun in her ways and not as terrible as all that some of the time, but goddamn, this is the fucking best I’ve had in a long time… maybe the best ever… maybe we should’ve listened to our parents after all, could’ve been doing this for a while.”
She laughed again, the sound only just cutting through her moans as she continued her wild, bouncy ride. “God, don’t let any of them hear that, can’t let them know they were right after all this time… FUCK! This really is the best fucking Christmas party ever! I thought it was gonna be a waste, that I’d have to get drunk to be able to put up with all the bullshit, but here you are, such a fucking asshole… a hot fucking asshole with an amazing cock! I couldn’t have asked for better for Christmas!”
Haley sat up on his cock regally again, riding his cock impressively and sending her titanic tits bouncing wildly. She reached down between her legs, fingering her clit as she eyed him appreciatively, while Conner looked up at her, fucking back as best he could while utterly enjoying the sight of this hot, huge-titted slut taking his cock.
“That makes two of us… I was hoping for a new car, but this? Way better. For now, anyway… fuck, you ride like a fucking champion,” he growled, reaching behind her and smacking her on her epic ass.
Haley yowled, squeezing his cock with her pussy. “Guys always love it when I’m on top… girls too… nothing quite like watching these tits get moving…”
“Girls, huh?” Conner asked, intrigued.
She knew that would get his interest. Guys always loved hearing stories of some good girl-on-girl action.
“Uh-huh… you know us cheer sluts and our ‘slumber parties’,” she teased, riding him harder.
Confidently, Conner reached up and grabbed her tits, squeezing them and pinching her nipples. “Oh, I know all about them. Attended a handful myself… being the only cock in a house full of hens has its charms, after all.”
Haley rolled her eyes, but didn’t stop riding him any harder. “Wow, farm metaphors, way to get a girl nice and wet…”
Truth be told, she was already pretty fucking wet, and as she absentmindedly reached between her legs and began to play with her clit, she was all too aware how good this was feeling. It probably wouldn’t take her a lot to explode a second time, but she was going to try to hold off as long as she could.
Conner had already pushed her over the edge, and she was looking to make him do the same.
“I know how to get you wet… I bet I know how to make you scream,” he replied, grinning up at her darkly. “I’ve been with plenty of sluts like you… I know how you tick, what gets you going, what really gets you going, and if I wanted to, I could make you fucking explode with just a single finger, and my cock’ll put you into fucking orbit. You know I could, so don’t you dare try to fucking fight me on this…”
His confidence, normally quite irritating, was working well for her while she played with her clit.
“Show me…” Haley said, her voice suddenly low and husky with hunger. “You’ve shown me what your fingers got, now show me what your cock can do…”
“You asked for it,” Conner replied.
Without warning, he wrapped his strong arms around her and pulled her in close, before rolling Haley onto her back so that he was now on top of her.
This was a bit of a surprise for Haley, who was really enjoying the pace of the fuck so far, but the way he looked and felt on top of her, she realized she didn’t have much to complain about. Leaning back briefly (but not enough to pull out of her), Conner took hold of her left leg.
“You’re flexible as hell, right?” he asked, a brief bit of courtesy breaking through his ravenous hunger for her.
“Oh, yeah,” Haley confirmed.
Conner kissed her passionately. “Good.”
He seemed to take great pleasure in lifting her leg up and bracing it against his shoulder before he leaned back down against her, effectively forcing her into a vertical split before he began to fuck down into her again. Haley moaned deeply, and loudly at the intense change in pressure that spread pleasure throughout deep corners of her body it felt were rarely touched. She was so loud, in fact, that she even worried briefly that she might have been heard downstairs, but certainly not worried enough to stop when it felt this delicious.
Conner fucked her with an efficient roughness that had Haley bathed in ecstasy, and with that feeling of another orgasm building, she knew that she wanted it to be a nice and hard one. She reached down between her legs again, fingering her clit as he roughly plowed into her. They knew well at this point that this was a fuck that neither of them would forget, and one that had gone well past words. Oh, sure, there were still the occasional grunts, the occasional curses and bits of name-calling, but by this point they were both sweaty and breathing heavily, driven by lust and an animalistic desire to cum.
Haley knew that he wasn’t going to wait for her to get off before he finished, and so she decided against giving him a choice in the matter. Fingering herself harder, she pushed herself closer to the edge.
Conner grinned. “You’re gonna cum… you’re gonna cum soon, aren’t you, slut?”
Nodding slightly, Haley replied, “Uh huh… not like you’re all that far off either… you finally ready to cum for me too, asshole?”
He smiled. “Come on, do it, cum for me… you cum for me, and I’ll cum for you… make you a fucking mess… fuck, do it, do it, fucking do it, cum for me, cum for-“
Haley’s body jerked and her legs shuddered uncontrollably as she was taken by another, stronger orgasm than the last. Pleasure exploded through her body, nearly blinding her and stealing her consciousness as she cried out and wailed uncontrollably, gushing on his cock. There was something to the thrill of cumming this hard on the cock of a guy she still didn’t like very much, though the sex itself had been fucking amazing. This hadn’t been the Christmas she had expected, not by a long shot, but as her orgasm ran its course, she found herself contented by where it had gone.
She found this to be the case even more as Conner finally pulled out. Panting from exertion and need, he climbed over her, straddling her stomach and stroking his cock, aimed at her tits. With a loud grunt and a sharp spasm of his body, he came on her tits. If her tits had been smaller, he might have covered them, but even so, Conner painted them pretty well, the force of some shots splattering against her neck, one even hitting her cheek. The feeling of his hot cum coating her, that dirty, thrilling excitement that sometimes came with the feeling of being completely and utterly used, sent a thrill through Haley’s body, almost setting her off for another, lighter cum.
Conner climbed off of her, collapsing to the bed on his back next to Haley. Grateful to be free, she dropped her aching leg out of the splits he’d put her in, finally able to relax after the devastating orgasm he’d given her. They both lay there like this, breathing and trying to figure out just what the fuck had happened between the two of them. Looking over at him, Haley still recognized everything in him that she found utterly obnoxious and annoying, but fuck if he didn’t look hot.
He laughed once, amused. “So, I’m thinking we play this one coy with our folks. Don’t give them too many details, but let them see us reentering the party together a little mussed up. Make them make some guesses at what had happened, but never confirm or deny anything. Keeping them guessing… I think that’s got a lot of potential for fun, don’t you?”
“A lot of fucking potential,” Haley agreed, sighing contentedly. “And Peyton too, right? She’s gotta see us… God, I can’t wait to see the look on her face when she sees this…”
Looking down at her cum-covered, nearly naked body, she amended, “I mean, not all this, but-“
“Yeah, I dunno if I’m ready for that headache yet,” he answered. “She’s gonna text me like you wouldn’t believe, and you too, and she’s gonna unleash the crazy, and-“
Haley motioned her hands down at her body and said in a forceful tone, “You ever want a shot at any of this again, you better make sure she sees.”
Conner raised an eyebrow. “Oh? You’re thinking you wanna make this more than a one-time thing?”
Haley was about to say something else, then stopped herself as she thought this over. Truthfully, she hadn’t really been thinking much about anything past this room, but now that the thought hit her, she realized that the raw attraction she had for Conner fucking Berriman made her want this to not be the last time she was with him.
“What, like you don’t want another piece of me?” she replied, not wanting to show her true enthusiasm.
Conner must have read something in her tone, because he didn’t push the matter. “We do make sense… maybe not as long-term marriage and kids material or anything like that…”
“Though our parents would fucking love it,” Haley admitted.
“Oh, that they would, keep the legacies alive and all that,” he mused. “But I could see this working between us… a long-term, torrid affair, hate-fucking the shit out of each other when we’re forced together by circumstances and whatever kinds of dull social engagements our families cross paths at.”
“Sounds like something out of a soap opera,” she said.
“I can make a soap opera work for me,” Conner replied, smiling that roguish grin again, that grin that made her hate her almost as much as it made her want to fuck the shit out of him again.
“Me too,” Haley replied, shivering slightly, then looking toward the door. “I think we should be making our way back to the party soon.”
“Yeah, we should,” he replied, sighing. “People are probably wondering where we are, and we do want to make that dramatic reentrance, after all…”
Another moment of silence passed between the two of them as they actively did not return to the party. He kept smirking that damned smirk…
Haley bit her lip. “We could do that… or we could smoke Peyton’s weed and fool around some more before we return. Everyone’s so wrapped up in their own holiday shit so much that I don’t think they’ll be that eager to find us… and the music’s loud enough that we can probably get even louder this time without getting caught. And dirtier. Emphasis on the louder and dirtier parts, especially…”
Conner’s cocky little smirk became a broad, toothy and unrestrained grin.
He reached over and wiped his cum off her face with one hand. “Why, Haley, how’d you possibly know what I wanted for Christmas?”
She leaned over and kissed him. “From one person on the naughty list to another, let’s just call it a hunch.”
Haley fell back on the couch, laughing with him, though probably for different reasons. Never in a million years could she have seen this party going this way, but as holiday surprises went, she had to admit that she could’ve done a lot worse.