Brotherly Blunder - Chronicle #1: Underwear Hierarchy (Patreon)
Content
Welcome to Brotherly Blunder. These are a series of tales where Sonic tried to assert himself as Tails’ older brother and ended up looking like the younger one as a result. Welcome.
The time Tails discovered what kind of underwear Sonic wore was a situation that the fox never once thought would be something worth telling in a “once upon a time” format but low and behold, here we are. Let’s recount the tale.
Chronicle #1 - Underwear Hierarchy
Sitting on a couch within Tails’ Workshop, located at the edge of a cliff-side within the Mystic Ruins, sat Sonic the Hedgehog. He was munching on a bag of potato chips while lounging and staring at the television set. The show he was watching wasn’t that interesting to him so he was mostly just staring at the screen while getting lost in thoughts he found more interesting.
He was jolted out of his stupor when Tails slammed the door open. Sonic looked to the side extraordinarily fast to catch wind of his buddy, unsure of why he’d slam the door open with such force.
The instant his eyes laid on his buddy, Sonic scrunched up his face with puffed out cheeks, trying to hold back laughter.
“So uh… how was your day bro?” Sonic asked, snickering a tad.
Tails stood there with an unamused expression on his face, pouting with disdain as he leered ahead with his tighty whities thrusted over his forehead. It was an atomic wedgie and boy did it look painful.
“I’ve been tugging at it… for 40 minutes,” Tails began, his voice sounding as though it was returning to normal after spending those 40 minutes stuck in a higher pitch than normal. “I can’t fix my underwear.”
Sonic blinked and let out another snicker. Tails’ eyes flashed at him, obviously aware of how much Sonic was amused by his manner of dress. “S-So…” The Hedgehog started, “What would you like for me to do about it?”
Tails felt his face flush a tad red and his eye twitched. “... Would you… please… help to unhook the undies off my head…”
Sonic patted his knees and then stood up, belting out a hard chuckle as he stepped behind Tails and grabbed the whities at the top of his head. “Alright… stay calm. I’m gonna thrust downward really fast.”
“Just hurry and do IIIIIIEEEEEEEEK~!” Tails’ eyes crossed when Sonic’s barely registered warning hit his ears and his butt was assaulted with an intense sharp pain as Sonic un-wedgied the fox and let the briefs snap back against his bottom. “Owww…” Tails whined and rubbed his behind.
“Atomic wedgie eh? Classic.” Sonic smiled.
Tails pouted and rubbed his butt, looking to the side. “I was piloting my latest invention in the park when some kids came up behind me, pulled down the back of my pants, and then gave me a wedgie. Like, seriously. What’s the deal? Why bother pulling the back of my pants down to check? At least spare me that humiliation. It was like being checked to see if I messed my pants or something. By kids younger than me no less!”
Sonic laughed. “They were most likely checking to see what kind of underwear you had on.”
Tails was confused. “Why would that matter?”
“Oh buddy,” Sonic shook his head. “Don’t you know? People who wear tighty whities ask for it. They’re like wedgie magnets. You seriously need to get yourself some boxers.”
Tails grumbled and crossed his arms.
Sonic smiled. “You only own briefs?”
“... Yes.” Tails looked to the side. “Some are colored briefs… some even have cartoon prints on them…”
“What…?! Seriously dude?” Sonic snickered.
“Oh come on!” Tails fired back, fists clenched. “It’s just underwear! Underwear isn’t MEANT to be seen! Why should anyone care what I’m wearing?”
Sonic shrugged. “That’s just the way of the world. Briefs are for wedgie magnets. Those cartoon undies are called underoos and they’re even worse.”
“That doesn’t make any sense to me.” Tails said with a glare.
“People like to connect briefs to diapers. Therefore, if you wear them, you’re basically a baby.” Sonic stated, rubbing a finger under his nose. “I mean, you’re 8, so it’s fine… sort of.”
Tails’ pouting got even more pronounced. “This is the most ridiculous thing I’ve heard in my life. There’s an underwear hierarchy?”
“Yup. Underoos, Briefs, Boxer-Briefs, and Boxers are at the top.” Sonic said, counting down on his fingers. “Underoos are the lowest of low, unless of course you wear actual pull-ups. Sorry buddy but that’s just the way it works.”
Tails rolled his eyes. “Ugh. That’s SO stupid. I wear briefs cause they’re comfy. I don’t wanna wear boxers or boxer-briefs. It’s like wearing shorts under your pants. That’s not comfy.”
“I agr-Uh. I mean, too bad. That’s just how it works.” Sonic shrugged.
Tails’ ear perked up. “Come to think of it… I don’t think I’ve ever seen your underwear before.”
Sonic blushed a bit. “Eh? Is that so? That’s weird… we’ve known each other for so long, you’d think it’d happen by accident at least once.”
“Uh-huh.” Tails said, with a nod of agreement. “What do you wear?”
“Boxers. Obviously. I’m the coolest guy you know after all, right?” Sonic said, pointing at himself.
Tails raised a brow. “Reeeeally…?”
“Yes. Really.” Sonic said, leaning forward a bit. “...I’m not showing you them though. That’d be a little weird.”
“Right. This whole underwear talk is kind of dumb if I’m being completely honest.” Tails said. “Although, if it’s true, you could probably use your superior boxer power to punish those brats who gave me that wedgie for me.”
Sonic laughed and put a hand to Tails’ head, patting it down. “Sure thing! No problem! I was bored anyway!”
--
In the park, Sonic and Tails had arrived to a crowded open field. People were flying kites, playing tag, kicking soccer balls around, and enjoying bottles of lemonade and soda in the hot sun.
Tails brought his latest RC plane to fly around after this whole mess was sorted out. Luckily, the fox managed to find the two kids that gave him the wedgie earlier. Two little brats that were a kitten and a walrus child.
The two of them were busy trying to untangle the string on their kite when Sonic tapped their shoulders from behind. The two of them turned around and gasped.
“Oh hello there.” The walrus boy said.
Sonic waved at them. “Hi. I’m Sonic. This is my buddy Tails.” He said, pointing behind him. Tails stood with his hands clutching the control pad of his RC plane. He was leering down at the two of them in a way that showed he wasn’t amused. The two kids frowned, knowing what this probably was.
“H-Hello.” The cat said, waving at Tails.
Tails said nothing.
“Yeah. He’s kind of mad at you guys.” Sonic said. “He came home with a wedgie over his head. You wouldn’t have had anything to do with that would you?”
The boys caved immediately.
“S-Sorry…! We just… it was just a stupid prank.” The cat boy said, shaking a bit.
“We didn’t think it’d be that big a deal.” The walrus boy responded.
Sonic laughed. “Oh yeah. I agree.”
“WHAT?!” Tails gasped. The two boys were surprised as well.
“Hey, I get it. Giving a wedgie to a boy in tighty whities is fun. That’s just how the hierarchy goes right?” Sonic shrugged. “Just don’t be as persistent about it. I’m a generally cool guy but the next person you do it too might not have a big brother that’s as forgiving as me.”
The two boys nodded.
“Okay.”
“Sorry sir.”
Sonic grinned.
Tails’ jaw was hanging open.
That was it?
“Well… we’ll be sure to remember that.” The cat said. “It was still funny though. He was playing with his plane and he didn’t see it coming.”
“Haha. Yeah!” The walrus added. “He shrieked like a little girl when we gave him the wedgie! It went over his eyes and nose! We kept pulling and pulling. He was jittering about like he was malfunctioning.”
“Bwhahahaha~! Oh really? That DOES sound funny!” Sonic laughed, still bending over with his hands on his knees and his butt out so that he could be at eye-level with these kids.
“Yeah! And then he danced about like a nerd, swinging his arms and legs about everywhere!” The cat said.
Tails was flushing red from embarrassment.
“HAHAHA~! Was it a funny dance?” Sonic asked.
“SUPER funny!” The walrus added. “He even grabbed at his pee pee and was like “AAAH! MY BALLS!” and I think he cried a little.”
Sonic and the kids shared an even heftier laugh together at that while Tails fumed with intense rage behind them, shaking all over. He then raised a brow when he took notice of something.
Sonic’s pants sagged just a teeny tiny bit while he was shaking with laughter. Because of that though, Tails could make out what looked like a waistband… or an elastic. A red elastic actually…
Tails stood with wide-eyes and then zeroed in on Sonic’s butt.
“That… doesn’t look like the waistband of a pair of boxers…” Tails said. It could have been some colored boxer-briefs… but even then, Sonic said he wore boxers. Either way, this would have meant he lied to him!
Tails felt anger shoot through him. He couldn’t handle the laughing anymore. He stomped over towards them and grabbed at the hem of Sonic’s pants!
The two kids and Sonic stopped laughing when they noticed Tails do this. Before they could speak, Tails gave a harsh tug downward and let Sonic’s pants pool around his ankles!
Everything was silent.
Sonic slowly leered down at himself. His pants were indeed on the ground… the soft breeze that blew by his waist was proof enough of that. His white t-shirt wasn’t long enough to cover the undies he had on either. It was out in the open just what kind of underwear he had on.
Elmo from Sesame Street’s smiling face was plastered all over his underwear. The underwear was, in fact, not a pair of boxers or boxer-briefs. They were straight up underoos!
Sonic’s face flushed red. “I… uh… T-Tails I…”
Tails leered at Sonic, still standing behind him as the hedgehog slowly turned his head to look at his angered fox friend.
“L-Listen… th-there’s a perfectly logical explanation f-for-EEEEEP!” Sonic shrieked, facing forward instantly when Tails grabbed the hem of his briefs and yanked them up into a sharp, angry, painful wedgie!
“Whoa!” The walrus boy spoke up, snapping out of his mild shock. “He’s wearing UNDEROOS!”
“The fox had on white briefs… he’s even MORE babyish!” The cat kid stated.
Tails smirked. “Hear that? You’re MORE babyish!”
“T-Tails… I-I d-don’t-EEEP!” Sonic yelped again when Tails gave a sharper tug. He was stretching his briefs even higher now. Tails spun the appendages on his butt and began to float off the ground to help carry Sonic’s wedgie even higher. The blue hedgehog was now on his tippy-toes!
“You don’t what? You don’t wear Elmo underoos?!” Tails snapped. “What was that about you wearing BOXERS?!”
“AAAIEEEEEE~!” Sonic screeched, eyes crossing and mouth ebbing out drool as the pain shot through him. The wedgie was so painful it had him frozen in place. The loud shrieks also caught the attention of all the other kids playing in the park.
“Whoa! He’s a LOSER!” The walrus kid laughed and pointed. “Make it atomic!”
“Sure thing!” Tails smiled. He stretched the underwear even more and watched as Sonic’s legs buckled and his knees knocked.
“T-TAILS! STAAAAAAHP!”
“Why should I?” Tails grinned. “You lied to me. How much did you lie? How many boxers do you own?”
“N-NONE!” Sonic shouted, flailing his arms about.
“How many boxer-briefs?” Tails demanded.
“NONE!”
“How many WHITE briefs?” Tails pressed on.
“NONE! I DON’T OWN ANY!”
Tails was surprised to hear that. “Wait… not even regular briefs? JUST underoos? This whole time? No wonder I’ve never accidentally seen your undies before. You made sure that I didn’t because you knew that put me higher than you on this underwear hierarchy!” Tails chuckled. Tails owned some underoos too but the simple act of owning white briefs made him higher than Sonic on this cool kid ratio. How neat!
“AAAAAAUGH! I’M SORRY! I LIED! I DID! PLEASE DON’T GO ATOMIC!” Sonic pleaded, teary eyed as he saw the underwear start to go over his head. “I CAN’T LET ANYONE FIND OUT I’M THE LOWEST ON THE UNDERWEAR HIERARCHY! COME ON BUDDY! HAVE A HEART!”
Tails laughed and muffled up Sonic completely when he got the underwear over his face and snapped it under his chin. Sonic grunted and moaned, trying to tug at it with his butt sticking out. He wiggled about and stumbled, hating how the pain was radiating through his body.
Tails smirked as he watched this display of embarrassment unfold before him, fists on his hips as the kids pointed and laughed at the dancing hedgehog.
“You guys are gonna need to help me out with these wedgie techniques. I only know so many.” Tails said, zipping in front of Sonic again.
“Okay!” The cat and the walrus kids said in unison.
Tails gripped Sonic’s atomic and took the undies off his head, making Sonic gasp when the underoos were free from his face.
“AUGH!” Sonic sputtered, blushing like crazy. “T-Tails! Look! Let’s just go home alright! I wear underoos okay! They’re comfy and I like the cartoons alright? I admit it! Let’s just-!”
Tails gave another tug on his briefs!
“YEEEEEEP!” Sonic yelped and grabbed at his crotch. “AAAAH! MY BALLS!” The hedgehog shouted.
The kids laughed and clapped at that. “Try a frontal wedgie!” The cat shouted.
“Ah. A frontal. I assume that’s…” Tails flew around to the front of Sonic and grabbed the front of his briefs.
“NO NO NO NO AAAAAAAAH~!” Sonic screamed again, his voice going higher pitched when Tails wedgied the front of his briefs up. Sonic was suspended from the ground and whimpering, feeling light headed.
“Oh uh… Bouncing wedgie!” The walrus suggested.
“Bouncing… if I recall that one is…” Tails let the front of Sonic’s briefs snap against his crotch, which made the hedgehog whine and fall to his knees while nursing his front. Tails then stood behind Sonic and grabbed the back end again, yanking them up and making Sonic dangle from the ground. “BOUNCE! BOUNCE!” Tails shouted as he began to bounce Sonic up and down.
“AH! BWAH! AGH! AAAH!” Sonic grunted with a pained cross-eyed look, drool and snot flinging everywhere as this continued.
“Yo-Yo Wedgie!” The cat shouted next.
“Hup!” Tails grinned and thrusted Sonic hard to the left.
“EEEEEP!” Sonic screeched as he bungeed hard to the left and then was yo-yoed back towards Tails. Tails smiled and smacked Sonic hard in the butt to send him shooting back out again. Sonic’s butt wiggled with each smack and it started to steam when Tails’ spanking strikes kept yo-yoing him back and forth.
“AAAAAAAAH! MY BUTT! IT BURNNNSSSSS~!” Sonic screamed, tears pooling in his eyes.
“Uhm… Around the World wedgie!” The walrus shouted next.
Tails stood in place and began twirling Sonic around and around.
“Round and round you go!” Tails shouted.
“AAAaaaaAAAAaaaaAAAAaaaaAAAAHHH~!” Sonic’s voice reverberated up and down the more he spun around thanks to Tails’ wedgie.
The more wedgies that were shouted out, the more of them Tails did for the forming crowd.
“Jock Lock Wedgie!”
Sonic was face down in the dirt while his legs were harshly folded back to fit through the leg-holes of his briefs!
“Messy wedgie!”
Sonic’s eyes were rolling and he wobbled about like a drunkard. The pain making him about ready to pass out. Tails pulled the front of Sonic’s briefs out and dumped scoop fulls of mud down his undies! He then gave him another wedgie and watched as the mud seeped down his legs. It even got on his butt and made it look like he messed his briefs!
“BANANA HAMMOCK WEDGIE!”
Tails grabbed the sides of Sonic’s briefs and yanked them up, splicing into his crotch and dangling him like a grocery bag!
“HAAIIIEEEEEEEEK!” Sonic screamed, eyes rolling around and face covered in tears, snot, and drool by this point.
“DRAGGING WEDGIE!”
Tails pulled on Sonic’s underwear and watched as Sonic screamed in pain while his butt was literally dragged across the ground, getting his butt caked in more dirt and mud than before.
“DIZZY WEDGIE!”
Tails had Sonic suspended above the ground and began spinning him around, tightening his underwear up… before letting his underwear unravel so that Sonic spun the opposite direction like a mini cyclone.
“WAAAAAAAAAAAAUGH!” Sonic screamed before he ended up winding up again in the opposite direction. He then unwinded and was sent spiraling around and around yet again.
“FIREMAN’S CARRY WEDGIE!”
Tails lifted Sonic over his shoulder and patted Sonic’s dirty butt… then grabbed his undies and gave him a demeaning wedgie that looked like he was administering it to a baby.
“SQUEAKY CLEAN WEDGIE!”
Tails and the Walrus kid did this one together. Tails grabbed the back of Sonic’s briefs while the walrus kid grabbed the front and started to sharply tug up and down on his underwear, making it look like they were ringing a towel in between his legs… only it was his briefs.
Sonic was way out of it by this point.
Eventually, they stopped.
Tails dusted his hands off and approached Sonic.
The blue hedgehog was standing with his hands dangled at his sides, eyes rolling, with stars and birdies circling his head. He was soooo dizzy and disoriented. The pain was making him so light-headed… he was about to faint.
“One last one we want to try…” Tails said. “Give yourself a Self-Wedgie.”
“Okaaaayyysss…” Sonic, now loopy and dumb in the head, reached over and gave himself a wedgie! “HEEEEEEEEEK!” Sonic gasped before his eyes went white and he passed out, smacking his face into the dirt with his wedgie bum sticking out.
Tails patted his bottom and grinned. “That was fun. Maybe next time you won’t lie to me and tease me about my underwear when you’re lower on your dumb underwear hierarchy than me.”
The walrus and the kid sighed. “Sorry about that Tails.”
Tails smiled, beaming with happiness. “It’s alright. Hey. I think I’ve got another idea Just to show that there’s no hard feelings…!”
---
“AAAAAAAH! COME ON! LET ME DOWN!” Sonic screamed and flailed his arms and legs about. He was blushing and crying as the kids below him laughed and pointed at him.
Tails’ RC plane had Sonic’s undies attached to them and he was now being flown around the park by the cat. The kids were enjoying Sonic’s humiliation quite a bit.
“PLEASE! I GOTTA PEE! THIS ISN’T FUNNY! I CAN’T FEEL MY BUTT ANYMORE!” Sonic whined, grabbing himself and trying to keep from leaking…
Tails laughed as he observed them having fun. “Now that’s a happy ending if I ever saw one.”
The walrus kid stopped laughing and then spotted Tails as he kept giggling. The walrus kid snickered and tip-toed over to Tails before pantsing him!
Tails yelped and stood in his plain tighty whities, shocked.
The fox blushed and covered his front with his hands, smiling nervously outward.
“Ah… eh… heheh...th-that’s all folks…!” Tails muttered.
He was still pretty low on the underwear hierarchy after all...
--
That’s the first tale in this saga of role reversal. Tune in next time where another subject matter will be explored between Sonic and Tails in Brotherly Blunder.
I'll provide key words in the poll below and you guys vote for the one that sounds the best to you. I'll write a story around it.