Home
Creators
Search Recent Missing Random
Posts
Search DMs Popular Hash Lookup Tags Random
Importer
Import FAQ
Register Favorites Keys Review DMs Logout
Community
Telegram ThePornDude
Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

[Tier 3] SEVENTEEN - Getting Closer (2018 MAMA + 2019 Gaon Chart Music Awards) (Patreon)

Published:
2026-11-07 13:00:32
Imported:
2026-11
Tags:

Videos

  • 777950984.mp4

Downloads

Content

LAST BUT NOT LEAST!
This is Getting Closer, many people's favourite track from this album, and a track we've heard a LONG time ago when we first discovered Seventeen on HS! :D

We're back with it, this time, checking out their MAMA performance, as well as 2019 Gaon Chart Music Awards performance!!

Before we state our verdict for You Made My Dawn, PLEASE let us know if you have extra links you want us to get to for tracks from this album :):) (It almost became a HS tradition at this point to go through some more links before we move on to the next album XD)

And again, do not worry about Un Haeng Il Chi, because we'll be getting to it separately :D

Aight. That should do :D In the meantime, if you want to let us know YOUR favourite track from the album, feel free to do so ! We'd love to know :)

Enjoy <3

Files

Comments

SVT's Riza

THIS IS HOW YOU PERFORM LIVE.

Jade V

Imagine Carats' reactions when Seventeen unveiled this completely new track and performance out of nowhere during MAMA, prior to YMMDawn release. We were all like "WTF !? Dark Seventeen era ? Omg they look so hot ! But also wtf !? Damn the choreo ! Wtf !? Will their next title track be dark too ?" lol.

ros

Correct me if I'm wrong, Carats,, but I'm pretty sure the 2018 MAMA performance was the surprise premiere. Might explain the technical stuff you talked about? They performed Getting Closer before the digital/MV release, and it was a pre-release single. The8 was in China during Gaon chart music awards, he was filming for a survival show like idol producer where he was a dance mentor. And Happy Ending… well there's nothing I can say that won't be a spoiler 😆

konekochan

Getting Closer just has to be one of the most tiring choreos they have ever... the amount of precision and power that they have to balance is crazyy I don't really have another set of performances to recommend for the album, and the 2019 Gaon Charts is already a pretty good wrap up~ But if you want to check it out, I think it'll be interesting to see the Caratland unit switch recording behind: https://youtu.be/zzGru7Ohj9s (There's a part 2 video for the dance practices, BUT it has spoilers for songs you haven't heard yet) My vote goes to moving onto Happy Ending tho! I'll drop some links here: - MV: https://youtu.be/cA1b99JSQq0 -Choreo Video: https://youtu.be/CJZ8xUA2aYk - Ode to You Japan: https://youtu.be/fnziJLYfFSQ - MCD Korean Ver: https://youtu.be/LBC5KKeMXYY ps. Favorites for this album in no particular order are Good to Me, Shhh and Chilli. I think YMMDawn isn't a strong album by itself (relatively!), but it's a solid 2 in 1 package deal with YMMDay. I really like the opposing themes of the albums where we got both freshteen and darkteen, and I think the next album is like a product of balancing the two together!

Brianna E

Love starting my Saturdays with a few "F you Mnet!"s XD. This song hits just as hard every single time I watch/hear it! Will never get tired of it, it's one of those songs that could come out tomorrow and it would still work perfectly and not sound dated/out of place (at least to me, maybe to those more musically knowledgeable it does sound more specific to the time it came out, but if it does I don't hear it the way I can more easily associate other tracks with the eras they came out). The way I also hadn't clocked Minghao being missing for the Gaon Chart performance, I saw they had a masked dancer performing with them but couldn't figure out who he was subbing in for. The downside of such a large group, higher chances of a member being out (but I guess the upside is that it's less noticeable bc there are so many members?? Idk). Also, my potentially controversial take, I could've done without Oh My from the Gaon performance, I just felt like it was such a different vibe from the other tracks that it seemed out of place (which sounds so crazy considering that's arguably the sound they were most well known for). Not that I dislike the song/thought they didn't perform it well, just that they other songs and the overall styling of the performance was more powerful/charismatic/dark, and Oh My is very much not that vibe. I'd love to see a HS reacts to HS of your original Getting Closer reactions (especially the dance practice!) before we move on to Happy Ending (another amazing track, looking forward to your take on that!).

Quwarichi

GETTING CLOSER! SUMICHA!!! I just love this song so much - the choreography, the vocals, the music, the stage presence, IT'S ALL SO GOOD!!! I just love it so much. First fanchant I learned too! I think it has a sort of feral energy that really connects well with my tastes. The music video is really good too. Also the outfits. And the line distribution. I can actually talk about it for hours so let me stop right now. (PS, if I remember the time correctly, Minghao was out with a back injury during the Gaon Chart performance.) FAVORITE ALBUM TRACK! It has to be Getting Closer. The only other one is Good to Me and they're fighting for the number one spot in my heart, but Getting Closer eeks out the win by a centimeter more. Then Good to Me, then Home. Of the unit tracks... hmm... I think Chili! To be honest none of them really overwhelmed me the way I feel about Moonwalker or IF I or Habit. But Chili was definitely the one I liked the uniqueness of. Shh should maybe try a different type of uniqueness. As for any other peformances I can think of for this album wrap up - not really! I'm sure others have better links so I'll just go ahead and talk about HAPPY ENDING!!! I'm so excited for you guys to check out this track it's a SLEEPER AGENT! You don't think it's going to get you then all of a sudden WOAH! You're battling for it on the front lines. I'll leave some links for it below! LINKS: MV: https://youtu.be/cA1b99JSQq0?si=iV4zfs0yj5wojK75 Dance Practice: https://youtu.be/CJZ8xUA2aYk?si=7mMI9ZPWzn7Zw81I Japan TV show performance: https://youtu.be/vtmQ5AhVzzU?si=UzIAX9MhGGlc-YlW

Jade V

I'd love if you guys checked out the recording behind the scenes as a wrap up for this album. It's quite interesting watching Woozi guide the members through the recording to get exactly what he wants. I think someone linked them in a previous reaction but if not I can link then again. I personally tend to think of YMMDay and YMMDawn as a package deal, like a mirror of each other. So it's be interesting to see you guys rate both albums against each other, and rate all the songs in both albums. My picks would be Good To Me, Our Dawn Is Hotter Than Day, Hug and Moonwalker. In terms of album as a whole I tend to lean towards YMMDay as the brighter but still chill vibe suits my usual everyday mood better.

Janice

My favourite tracks on this album are Good to Me, Home, and Getting Closer. As for next week, I’m fine with either moving on or staying on this album. Happy Ending is one of my favourite SVT songs ever! In case y’all decide to wrap up the album, I’ll leave a couple of behind-the-scenes videos because I couldn’t find any good quality clips for each track.: Sausages have been recommending “The Manager” for a while. It was recorded during home era, so i thought it would be a great post-album watch. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qy80Rl67mBM Also the first episode of GOSE 2019 is also a behind-the-scenes of this album (recording, practicing, etc) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YDtviH8q2OQ&list=PLcWqRod5qrFoqaFie2OLtKnI4-27NNvDy&index=56

캐럿입니다 💎

Oh man after this album I would very much like to recommend concert reaction maybe one of the old ones Diamond Edge or Ideal Cut. Diamond edge is my favourite and I fee l like its a must, it still holds a spot in top 3 SVT concerts for me or maybe even one of the old Caratland reaction that would be fun too. But either way I am also excited for the next album!! Also I don't know if you guys have seen this already or not but this the one where you will be able to hear the amazing and very hard Fanchant by Carats (13 full names, age vise and in reverse) Mnet - https://youtu.be/CCFy1K9CixE?si=HRa4nr_Df2k75oVg

Alex

Carat fanchants are next level! You can really feel the tension and desperation matching Seventeen’s energy from that era ^^ So many classic reaction videos of other idols watching Carats are from this period too. (as example of this Gaon perf.: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fMhCwwcbcXk&t=499s - you can hear carats here) And of course, hearing the legendary Closer fanchant of the SVT names in order backward and forward! ^^ I love their live stages :) p.s.: also if you remember recent leaders' ep., they didn't have much time for performances, so they always tried to prioritise and include more music, thus the transitions might not be the smoothest.

HISA

The Gaon stage in 2018 saw both the members and CARATs giving it their all! I’d like to recommend a special video of ‘HOME’—it’s a performance with some gifted young BOY&Girl talents. The singing part starts around the 7:50 mark. https://youtu.be/yLXuoAmymFk?si=UeurYtsdkMj_yDSC 2018のガオンのステージはメンバーもCARATも気合いが特大でしたね！ お勧めしたい「HOME」の特別な映像があります 天才少年少女とのステージです 7:50あたりからが歌う部分です https://youtu.be/yLXuoAmymFk?si=UeurYtsdkMj_yDSC

noura

Yess i would love to see u guys react to the behind makings of their albums!

spn_caratiny

Getting closer and this album are so good!!!!!

konekochan

I cant believe i forgot about the manager ep, i just rewatched it recently!! recommending that as well~

Misz Nana

YES.. They should check out this link. and they will know how carat become rapper.

Janice

Thank u, I couldn't find it! We should watch this version.

kermitsvt

i really went back to check but han-c said THE EXACT SAME THING for run to you wonwoo in their run to you stage mix reaction 😭😭 it was for the same clip too lmaooooo

syfrzip

can't wait for you to react to Un Haeng II Chi! at this point am wishing for you to both react to their Diamond Edge & Ideal Cut concerts coz they're full of unreleased songs. only problem is which specific concert stop to watch coz every stop has its own charm.