Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Videos

  • fvne devlog2.mp4

Downloads

Poll

New environment + vlog + AI discussion/poll

  • Keep the new map and keep TropicalIsland. Blacky stays as environment designer for another couple of months (until we get custom maps) 102
  • We will not release the new environment. TropicalIsland will also be removed. Blacky resigns as environment designer. 33
  • 2026-11-07
  • 135 votes
{'title': 'New environment + vlog + AI discussion/poll', 'choices': [{'text': 'Keep the new map and keep TropicalIsland. Blacky stays as environment designer for another couple of months (until we get custom maps)', 'votes': 102}, {'text': 'We will not release the new environment. TropicalIsland will also be removed. Blacky resigns as environment designer.', 'votes': 33}], 'closes_at': None, 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2026, 11, 7, 11, 41, 38, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 135}

Content

Hi all!

odes here (founder and programmer of FVNE).

Got a devlog and a poll for you here today. I'm gonna try and keep this as short and straight to the point as possible, so it's clear that we're not trying to obfuscate or influence the poll or anything.

New environment

Blacky has made a new environment, BathHouse. Here are some screenshots:

Community sentiment regarding Artificial Intelligence

TropicalIsland and BathHouse (new environment shown in the pictures above) were made by Blacky using AI assisted workflows. In the video in the main post, I'm discussing my views on Blacky, AI and how we ended up in this situation to begin with. It adds some context. Watch it if you like, or don't. Either is fine.

You now have two choices. What you choose will decide Blacky's role going forward.

Files

Comments

Monterrio Ashmore

For as long as AI is used as a tool, as it should be, then I see no problem. For as long as the AI isn't used to generate the whole thing and isn't leeching off the work of others to do so, what's the harm?

BtheDestroyer

Using GenAI is plagiarism unless it's a private model you make using basically exclusively your own content as training data. If "AI is just a tool," then plagiarism is also "just a tool." I will be cancelling my subscription; even *considering* "maybe we benefit from labor theft" is abhorrent.

Foceker (edited)

Comment edits

2026-11-11 08:00 I rather not have the AI really. I don't know how to explain it well, since I suck with words, but it just feels wrong. Knowing that it was just a shortcut, that many people works were used without their permission by something that just copied it. I wish I was better with words but yeah, I'm voting for no AI. I rather have working harder than go with shortcut really. As for stuff, I can wait for new maps even year if needed. As long as there is no AI.
2026-11-07 12:07 I rather not have the AI really. I don't know how to explain it well, since I suck with words, but it just feels wrong. Knowing that it was just a shortcut, that many people works were used without their permission by something that just copied it. I wish I was better with words but yeah, I'm voting for no AI. I rather have working harder than go with shortcut really. As for stuff, I can wait for new maps even year if needed. As long as there is no AI. EDIT: After reading what Blacky said/was explained, as long as those things AI did are replaced (mainly the texture thing), I will be fine with it. Blacky can stay as map creator.

I rather not have the AI really. I don't know how to explain it well, since I suck with words, but it just feels wrong. Knowing that it was just a shortcut, that many people works were used without their permission by something that just copied it. I wish I was better with words but yeah, I'm voting for no AI. I rather have working harder than go with shortcut really. As for stuff, I can wait for new maps even year if needed. As long as there is no AI. EDIT: After reading what Blacky said/was explained, as long as those things AI did are replaced (mainly the texture thing), I will be fine with it. Blacky can stay as map creator.

Crab

I understand the use of it, however if I was to fully make a decision properly, I'd have to ask what the actually AI assistance is? I'm a major opponent of AI, especially generative AI. So I'm not exactly sure how to feel about this as of right now, but I'm leaning towards no just because of how icky it makes me specifically feel. No shade to Blacky, I know he's a talented guy. I think custom maps will truly be the best next step in terms of content for FVNE, and I honestly can't wait for it.

FurryVNE Team

Thanks for sharing your opinion and standing firm in your beliefs.

addy

AI is certainly a difficult subject, and it's hard to convey thoughts and feelings accurately in that regard, especially when the landscape is ever evolving on such a broad spectrum. I don't personally have an issue with AI assisted workflows as long as it's accompanied with reasonable oversight, reviewed and understood internally, and disclosed with some detail as to how for the end user to put it succinctly. I think BathHouse is absolutely BEAUTIFUL! 😍

Lolo

Came for AI disclosure, stayed for the VNE 2.0 announcement 👀 Jokes aside, My question is to where is the line to be drawn? Yes, AI shoulders a lot of the creative burden. Who is to say character models, shouldn't also be AI generated (for "efficiency's sake")? Not to be that guy, but something about a slippery slope comes to mind. So again, where will the line be drawn?

Lolo

Updated my comment, need your thoughts

Blair

Are we hearing form god 😳😳😳😳 😂😂😂 jk but love the way you did this announcement blacky you better start selling your maps like a real estate agent 😂😂😂😂 and as far as the AI thing goes, in my opinion go for it, I mean gods only knows how long it took blacky to make the island map and this one looks even more complex then that was so yeah, I mean I get the whole AI problem but for this I can’t understand why some people would get so upset over it.

SoanoS Barcoded

I am not a fan of GenAI content. Personally. I'd rather the maps were handcrafted instead of "hey google, build me a bathhouse environment!" (I may be exaggerating a bit but that's how I understand GenAI works). Seeing this in a commercial product just doesn't feel right.

Jeanna Faux

I've never been a scenery type of artist. Don't get me wrong, I can see vivid landscapes and architecture in my mind but trying to get it to paper... or screen for that matter, probably not happening so much. Using generative Ai here is fine is when it comes to more intricate and delicate stuff, characters, interactions, motions, reactions, ques... there i go no.

Mobius Scarf

Slight tweak. It would also be perfectly fine to train on anything with appropriate GitHub licensing, code shared on StackExchange, public domain content, publicly available content without a copyright. It doesn't have to just be your own content, it just can't be content you don't have a right to replicate. Obviously, no such models currently exist, and no one is seriously building one, but hypothetically, if one did exist, you would not consider using it as a coding tool to be plagiarism, correct? I'm just trying to find where the line is here. Under capitalism, all technology is built on labor theft to one extent or another. If you've ever used an Adobe product, if you've ever bought a smartphone, if you've ever eaten chocolate, if you've ever bought clothes you didn't make yourself. We all consciously and unconsciously decide what labor we're complicit in exploiting just by living in a system build on labor exploitation. This is a new frontier of labor exploitation, and it requires frank and honest discussion about if and how it is utilized. The fact is, LLMs have become an incredibly powerful coding tool, so the question of whether or not the team should leave that tool on the table for even that specific use-case because it was built on a mountain of technically-legal (for now at least) plagiarism is a reasonable question to ask.

BtheDestroyer

Yeah, I wanted to be more concise, but you're correct about licensing. In general, it comes down to respect and permission. If you take someone's image from their website and use it without permission, that's plagiarism. If you lie and say "I didn't know I couldn't use it," it's still plagiarism. If you *legitimately don't know the source*, it's still plagiarism. The idea that you could use genAI which was trained on material without the permission of the creators and then try to say "now that I can't determine the specific sources for any component anymore, it's ok" is ludicrous to me and should be to anyone else as well. Regarding "it's here, it's a tool, and so we need to determine how to use it, not if we use it;" that's disingenuous. For centuries around the world (and *still* in some places) you could say "look, slavery and child labor are here and they're very efficient, we can't waste our time arguing about *if* we should use it" and it has the same effect. The idea of "but it's an effective tool" is ridiculous to consider if it's completely unethical to use.

Akujiki

For AI, I think it's main use should only ever be for a laugh and shitposting. Considering peoples opinions about it, weather they don't give a shit or dislike it, you're just inviting a divide into your community by using it. I can understand why really small teams might use AI. But it feels like to me at least even as a small team, do you even need to be using it? The TropicalIsland and BathHouse do look nice, however I also can't help but think that I can go in-game right now and load an environment someone made for the community from the cloud lol.

Mobius Scarf

My current thoughts on AI are nuanced. I'm 100% opposed to using existing models to produce writing and art assets for profit, because I don't accept the fair use argument in regards to training on unlicensed copyrighted content especially when the model is effectively aiming to compete with the producers of that content. If Anthropic or whoever wants to invest billions of dollars into paying an army of artists to create their own proprietary training dataset so they can create these models without mass theft, then we can talk about that, but for now, if you use AI to generate art assets for anything other than your own personal private entertainment or education, I consider that to be theft. Code becomes a lot less clear-cut, however. The fact is, there's a LOT of freely-available source code on the internet. We programmers love sharing our dumb projects on GitHub, and virtually every programmer searches for code on StackeXchange and GitHub to snag for our projects all the time. The sharing ecosystem isn't the same as with other artists because the value isn't in the ability to replicate the code, it's in what the code can teach the model about how the programming language works. In my opinion, a programmer using a free Qwen model locally with Hermes isn't the same as the person cranking out slop with a Grok+ subscription or whatever. If they aren't using datacenters, if they aren't paying the big AI companies to use their frontier models or their compute, and if they aren't generating sloppy derivative content that blatantly infringes on intellectual property, then I kind of don't have a huge problem with that. It's probably still not "ethical", but if it's providing value to their labor and it isn't directly contributing to the most pressing problems created by the current AI bubble (mass art and data theft, useless datacenters, slop without disclosure, etc.), it honestly doesn't bother me more than any other form of ethically fraught consumption under capitalism. End of the day, if Blacky used a GenAI model to produce any of the art assets, I would ask that he redo those from scratch in blender, because I know he's capable of making those himself. But if he just used an AI tool to help him understand how to work with Unity and FurryVNE and to streamline repetitive processes, then I appreciate the disclosure, but I think I'm fine with it. I would just ask that in the future he try to avoid using frontier models as much as possible.

rugarou

thats a convoluted understanding of plagiarism. AI is in fact a tool, using it for 3D model creation does NOT in any way shape or form "plagiarize" someone elses work. IDK what your understanding of AI is but that is not how it works. even if you were to point AI at an existing model with the intent to "plagiarize" it what you would end up with would still be a deviation. its also fairly hypocritical to cite that when ppl do re-makes of popular and OC's models and such in FVNE as it sits. the only time AI "samples" images is when you feed them to it while training, but to use a coder or model builder AI agent or even an LLM does not require outside input aside from text prompts. artistic talent, comes from your mind, your ability to create. AI is no threat to any true artist anyway.

Mobius Scarf

Oh, also, I love the VRC avatar idea for these kinds of videos! Do that more often!

rugarou

if you are threatened by AI then you are a bad artist. full stop. the maps blacky produced are great. Im here for a game and tools not virtue signaling.

One of a kind pepper

I don't mind AI assisted workflows, as long as it's not being used to make generated things(3d models, art, etc.). if it's being used to get the best performance possible like more than 2 or 3 characters on screen, or heavy areas that have a bit too much polygons or textures, then it's completely ok. that's what i think at least.

Plunk

Gen AI does not belong in any creative process, period.

doodooballs

most major game companies have used AI assisted workflows in their own games and is just going to be a reality of game development. like some others are saying using it to generate the like entirety of the map is horrible tho

THe GERio

I’m all for using AI. I think it’s part of our future, and it’s already part of our everyday lives. We use it for little things all the time, often without even realizing it. What matters to me is that someone checks what the AI creates and decides what to use. If AI helps Blacky bring his imagination to life and create beautiful places for us to explore, I’m happy to see him keep using it. Blacky’s a cool dude. You can tell he puts his heart into what he makes and wants the best for our community.

R C

The maps are beautiful, and they're the reason why I subscribed again. You have to be dumb to fall for the "AI = bad" discourse. We got two new maps and the possibility of updating them even more. Please let Blacky continue to work on more environments, they are perfect. It gives the game a lot of new and fresh scenarios to build on (otherwise shit gets stale really quickly lol). Anyway, the community seems smart enough judging by the votes, so looks like we'll continue to enjoy new environments. Cheers

DurradonXylles

rugarou, you don't seem to understand one very crucial detail: how does "generative" AI "generate" content? Literally everything that major models utilize to write, code, and create imagery are scraped off of the internet as a whole without any permission of the people who submitted stuff online. There's no inspiration behind what LLMs generate, no creative process behind typing stuff on a prompt. That's why they're considered plagiarism machines. That's one of the largest reasons people are against it: it spits in the face of what it means to own and create.

FurryVNE Team (edited)

Comment edits

2026-11-11 08:00 To have an AI generate characters in FVNE we would have to implement an MCP server. Currently there are no such plans. Of course, perhaps future AIs will be so powerful that no MCP protocol will even be necessary (it would use the app like a human), in which case there's really nothing we can do to prevent an AI from essentially generating a character from scratch. I think there are uses where AI usage can be OK. I know for example that some FVNE users have take screenshots from FVNE, put them into an AI, and then generate variations and ideas using those screenshots. Some of those ideas were genuinely good, and the user incorporated them into their FVNE character (manually). I thought that was pretty cool usage of AI.
2026-11-07 16:09 To have an AI generate characters in FVNE we would have to implement an MCP server. Currently there are no such plans. Of course, perhaps future AIs will be so powerful that no MCP protocol will even be necessary (it would use the app like a human), in which case there's really nothing we can do to prevent an AI from essentially generating a character from scratch. I think there are uses where AI usage can be OK. I know for example that some FVNE users have take screenshots from [their own finished character in] FVNE, put them into an AI to see what would happen, and then generate variations and ideas using those screenshots. Some of those ideas were genuinely good, and the user incorporated them into their FVNE character (manually). I thought that was pretty cool usage of AI.

To have an AI generate characters in FVNE we would have to implement an MCP server. Currently there are no such plans. Of course, perhaps future AIs will be so powerful that no MCP protocol will even be necessary (it would use the app like a human), in which case there's really nothing we can do to prevent an AI from essentially generating a character from scratch. I think there are uses where AI usage can be OK. I know for example that some FVNE users have take screenshots from [their own finished character in] FVNE, put them into an AI to see what would happen, and then generate variations and ideas using those screenshots. Some of those ideas were genuinely good, and the user incorporated them into their FVNE character (manually). I thought that was pretty cool usage of AI.

PseudoSamurai

This is rather disheartening. The maps looked so good initially and it was hitting the right feel of needing tropical settings. But now feel tainted and wrong knowing what was used to achieve it. AI assisted workflow is still considered plagiarism even if it was used for conceptual ideas and coding. I don't code but I am an artist. Initially I was okay with AI being used for coding assistance as long as you went in to adjust as necessary. However talking with a coding friend changed my views. Coding is still considered an art form. Code was still created by someone. If it was used consentually that's one thing, but to scrape it with AI feels wrong and reaches the same level as GenAI art. As much as these maps look very pretty, I cannot in good conscience, use them at all or endorse their usage in the app.

Canitoo (edited)

Comment edits

2026-11-08 03:00 I don't mind If you guys use AI or not, I use AI my self for some stuff that I lack the knowledge or tools for. AI can be really use full in some situations, I know some people dislike AI and I can see why. Well I don't mind as long as it's clear what what content was made with help of AI or generated by AI im cool with it.
2026-11-07 16:55 I don't mind If you guys use AI or not, I use AI my self for some stuff that I lack the knowledge or tools for. AI can be really use full in some situations, I know some people dislike AI and I can see why. Well I don't mind as long as it's clear what content was made with help of AI or generated by AI im cool with it.

I don't mind If you guys use AI or not, I use AI my self for some stuff that I lack the knowledge or tools for. AI can be really use full in some situations, I know some people dislike AI and I can see why. Well I don't mind as long as it's clear what content was made with help of AI or generated by AI im cool with it.

Tarles_Xeno

Ai is a tool for help to everyone use, i dont care about it was made by ai or being used to help in the project, if is good i will pay for it just fine and use just fine, more things for us like maps mechanics and stuff is a big win, even if ai is being used, i see no problem with that.

SteelCrow13

I feel AI has a place in the workplace, but only as an assistant, never as a replacement for actual work by real people, especially for creative works. I know AI can create text, images and videos but I don't know if it can create 3D models. If Blacky used AI to make images that served as concept art/inspiration for the enviroments then still made the actual 3D models himself, then I'm okay with it.

Z0N1C

I'd prefer no ai used whatsoever because this kind of thing deserves to be made by human hands. I will be canceling my sub until I know the team never touches AI for this software at all

Ace Husky

i personally don't mind the use of ai to a certain degree because sadly its kinda the future and as it advances as a tool it makes jobs easier and get done more efficiently than manual labor in some cases. Really what I'm more impressed about is that you guys came to the community first to ask about their opinion on the step forward from here, i respect that more than anything. Blacky is also right when it comes to the game sure a new head would be nice or some kind of preset we don't have already would be cool but honestly with the resources that we already have we can basically create anything any head with enough knowledge of our own experience. an atmosphere makes a big difference especially with a tool or experince such as FVNE. i will further continue my support.

B Y T

To be honest, I'm not particularly opposed to artificial intelligence. On the contrary, I think the issue is how to use this technology correctly. As long as the final product meets the author's expectations and conveys the intended information and ideas, then I believe this is good art and creation. The discussion of its moral and ethical issues should not be the creators who use them, but the ones who hand them over to the public. No one should feel ashamed for using AI. The AI-related debates caused by individuals are merely acts of violence against the creators. So, based on the current finished product of this map, the effect looks really great. Therefore, I strongly support Blackly and FVNE using AI for creation! I think people actually prefer to see AI arts rather than lazy creators. And the laziness of ideas cannot be compensated for or covered up by AI.

Static_snowflake

I really appreciate the honesty and openness from the dev side, if a bit late, considering the issue at hand. I'll give my thoughts on this as is. I consider Artificial Intelligence as fire. A good worker but a terrible host. Rein it in, and it may help you with menial tasks. Let it run loose and it will sloppify everything it touches. There is a whole different conversation about analytical and generative AI, but I won't get into that. In capable hands, it can be a useful tool to offload more repetitive and menial tasks so the worker can concentrate on the most important aspects of the project or work. Of course, AI can and will make mistakes that have to be gone through and fixed, but offers a net benefit considering the workflow. But that is not how AI is currently being used. What we mostly see from it is general slop, not made with artistic vision or idea, but quantity and profit-seeking. Creative works get stolen in this giant content heist of the century where all the benefits go to the AI and their mother companies. Any way to see benefit from this is to partake in its use. No one will own anything, and AI has everything. This is detrimental to anyone who has creative ideas, for once they are in public eye, anybody can copy them with little to no effort. But there is no putting this genie back in the bottle. AI is here, and while we can run circles around it, we have to live with it one way or another. In my personal opinion, considering game development with AI, the golden middle lane is the Steam approach. Everything AI-related on the dev side should be just to aid and enhance the team's creative vision, as a tool described earlier. Absolutely none of AI should leak beyond the "veil" to the user side to keep things clean and slop-free. This way AI stays as a tool, and users get to experience the dev's creative vision as intended. With code, it's easy since it works silently in the background and is in a binary state, either working or not. With visible parts, it's much harder to have AI be invisible thus, the use of AI as a tool in visible parts should be minimised. Either way, the use of AI should absolutely be disclosed and to what extent. Not in detail, but in what parts of development. Honesty and openness are the key. Considering the current disclosure of Blacky using AI on the recently published map and another one in store, I cannot see the question in the poll as unbiased. I sincerely hope this was not intentional but rather an error in phrasing. If there are two options, with one that takes away a thing already given and a latter one that keeps it and gives one extra, people are going to naturally gravitate towards the latter one, for it offers them net benefit, sidestepping the issue itself. People have been starving for maps for a long time, so this feels like a bribe. The poll itself should have been just about AI tools and their use. This leads to the final paragraph, after this Ill keep my silence. I think Blackys intention was good and for the benefit of the user base from the beginning, but they should have been more open about the use of AI tools way before. This way the question of AI use could have been dealt at the moment and not after the publication of the first map. But that is spilled milk under the bridge. My personal opinion is that going forward with FVNE, use of AI tool should be minimised or completely removed from player-facing content. What happens beyond the veil on the dev side, we cannot know, but AI should always just support the devs creative vision, not overtake it. These are my thoughts on this issue. I have been on this ride for a long time and FVNE has grown on me. This is why I care about this issue as much as I do because I don´t want this game to become another slopfest we have seen many times before. But I´m just a voice in the crowd and should be taken as such. I'll wait and see what the will of the people is and then move accordingly.

thedamncat

My general stance on AI (being a software engineer myself) is if it's used to help with coding and bug fixes in that arena: sure. That's an ideal use case for it. For Audio/Visual assets, it's a bit more murky. If the AI is generating the output outright, it's a hard no. If the AI is more guiding on how and effectively a tutor or guide on how to create the output, this could be acceptable.

Hamsternator

"AI-assisted" is such a vague term it's really challenging to make an informed decision. I'm not a fan of AI in any capacity but I also know that I'm a damn hypocrite that needs AI agents at work for troubleshooting some rather complex systems. If any models or textures have been generated then I'd rather not have them at all. If AI is merely used to implement created objects into a map then in theory that might be okay, but once AI use is known to us as users we're always going to wonder what else is made with generative AI, even if you claim it isn't. It poisons the well, basically. It's going to be a shame to lose the new maps, since locations is something that's severely needed in FVNE, but I'd rather have less options made ethically than a bunch of content made of amalgamations of other peoples creations.

Dr.Stain

I don't care if it's AI if you made cool shit with it. (͠≖ ͜ʖ͠≖)

Pet

i am personally 100% against the use of AI, with that said i dont want anything bad to happen to Blacky.

BongleDong

As someone stuck in the grey middle in terms of the limits to what is "OK" with AI. I would say that the maps could remain, but perhaps best to move on from making any more maps, for now at least. My two cents being, if the goal was to add one or two environments, then alright we got there, now let's put the Ai aid and Tools down and move on back to our human strengths towards 2.0 and beyond. Blacky seems work minded and has good intentions, but the reactions are greatly mixed and having heard them we should probably re-focus away from the use of Ai as a tool going forward.

Raptex

As long as it's not a crutch for future projects. I do want to see some human made things. Once custom environments are a thing, I would like AI not to be used.

paowuf

I'll try to be as be direct as I can be. Why wasn't the use of AI stated clearly when the island environment was first shown in September? I went back to check, but it was never disclosed in any of the posts covering the environment. Why release the environment, wait two weeks, and then make this post? For a lot of people, that's unfortunately going feel like a "gotcha" moment that a lot of bad faith actors use with AI-generated art or create the impression that you were hiding it intentionally and then got caught. Why hasn't the exact use of AI been disclosed? Did it help with physics generation? Coding? Or was it used for asset generation and map art? Why be vague about that information? This subscription is probably the most expensive I'm willing to donate for, but with how evasive information is properly being disclosed and provided about this situation, I can't justify the cost I'm willing to spend. For a development Patreon, that feels like a massive breach of trust in what I was spending my money to see developed. Whether your team decides to continue using AI in your workflow or not, I cannot in good faith for the quality of your product continue supporting you without proper disclosure going forward. All I can ask is, please provide proper clarity and disclosure going forward or I will no long support this project.

Biscuit (edited)

Comment edits

2026-11-11 08:00 I think you are over-reacting/overthinking. Just stick an (AI Content) tag on the environment names. Have any interactions using that environment have an (AI Content) tag so nobody's forced to get their rocks off while looking at an AI Jacuzzi or whatever. Or have an "opt in" that dynamically loads AI content from the cloud and if you aren't opted into AI, won't show you interactions that contain AI content. With that said, I am not a fan of AI. I would rather eke out the few hours a week I have to work on my stupidly detailed interactions than let AI steal my fun. AND you better not make version 2.0 break my stupidly detailed interactions because that would probably make me give up. I have thoughts about the environments. I feel they are too big, you're loading this huge asset into memory and using maybe one small area of it for an interaction. Nobody's going to animate a character walking down from the house to the beach, not even me. I would prefer to see smaller assets that can be loaded fast with scene changes. Take for instance RLD. Yeah it would be nice to have the doors open and show characters walking from the bar to a hotel room but it's not necessary. A "Fade Out" would be way more important here, you could "Fade Out" in the bar and "Fade In" in the hotel room. Those could be different scenes with different smaller environments. I guess I'm saying you don't need to use AI to create these big environments, just create smaller chunks like prefab sets and add them a bit at a time based on how useful they'd be in an interaction. You don't need 3 acres of palm trees, just have one clump of palm trees that looks convincing as a set for an interaction scene.
2026-11-08 01:34 I think you are over-reacting/overthinking. Just stick an (AI Content) tag on the environment names. Have any interactions using that environment have an (AI Content) tag so nobody's forced to get their rocks off while looking at an AI Jacuzzi or whatever. Or have an "opt in" that dynamically loads AI content from the cloud and if you aren't opted into AI, won't show you interactions that contain AI content. With that said, I am not a fan of AI. I would rather eke out the few hours a week I have to work on my stupidly detailed interactions than let AI steal my fun. AND you better not make version 2.0 break my stupidly detailed interactions because that would probably make me give up. I have thoughts about the environments. I feel they are too big, you're loading this huge asset into memory and using maybe one small area of it for an interaction. Nobody's going to animate a character walking down from the house to the beach, not even me. I would prefer to see smaller assets that can be loaded fast with scene changes. Take for instance RLD. Yeah it would be nice to have the doors open and show characters walking from the bar to a hotel room but it's not necessary. A "Fade Out" would be way more important here, you could "Fade Out" in the bar and "Fade In" in the hotel room. Those could be different scenes with different smaller environments. I guess I'm saying you don't need to use AI to create these big environments, just create smaller chunks like prefab sets and add them a bit at a time based on how useful they'd be in an interaction. You don't need 3 acres of palm trees, just have one clump of palm trees that looks convincing as a set for an interaction scene. Are you still reading this crap? Sheesh. Anyway I also think you could be adding tools for the users (such as fade out and fade in) to use in interactions instead of cruise ship lido decks and such. Without more characters milling about impacting performance, those types of environments just look weirdly empty.

I think you are over-reacting/overthinking. Just stick an (AI Content) tag on the environment names. Have any interactions using that environment have an (AI Content) tag so nobody's forced to get their rocks off while looking at an AI Jacuzzi or whatever. Or have an "opt in" that dynamically loads AI content from the cloud and if you aren't opted into AI, won't show you interactions that contain AI content. With that said, I am not a fan of AI. I would rather eke out the few hours a week I have to work on my stupidly detailed interactions than let AI steal my fun. AND you better not make version 2.0 break my stupidly detailed interactions because that would probably make me give up. I have thoughts about the environments. I feel they are too big, you're loading this huge asset into memory and using maybe one small area of it for an interaction. Nobody's going to animate a character walking down from the house to the beach, not even me. I would prefer to see smaller assets that can be loaded fast with scene changes. Take for instance RLD. Yeah it would be nice to have the doors open and show characters walking from the bar to a hotel room but it's not necessary. A "Fade Out" would be way more important here, you could "Fade Out" in the bar and "Fade In" in the hotel room. Those could be different scenes with different smaller environments. I guess I'm saying you don't need to use AI to create these big environments, just create smaller chunks like prefab sets and add them a bit at a time based on how useful they'd be in an interaction. You don't need 3 acres of palm trees, just have one clump of palm trees that looks convincing as a set for an interaction scene. Are you still reading this crap? Sheesh. Anyway I also think you could be adding tools for the users (such as fade out and fade in) to use in interactions instead of cruise ship lido decks and such. Without more characters milling about impacting performance, those types of environments just look weirdly empty.

Husky

I'd say it depends on what exactly AI was used for. If AI "created" the "base layout" of the map, regardless of whether it was a 2D layout or a 3D model, as long as the entire thing was later modeled by hand, I'd consider it about the same as simply taking inspiration from photos or other people's work, or recreating someone else's work in your own way. Especially for someone who hasn't done environment design before, it's essential to learn to build on the designs of experienced artists. I still think it would be better to take inspiration directly from various artists than using AI, but let's be honest, it's faster, and the resulting "image" is a combination of multiple works in a more unique way than copying 1:1 what someone else has already created or spending time trying to create everything from scratch. It would be more valuable, but in this case, I think the time investment was more important. I still emphasize that this is only ok if everything else and all assets were created manually on the base layout. The second thing is to use AI to help move the entire finished map to Unity, not to do everything for you, but to gather information on how to do it. With the current absolutely crappy search algorithms, AI is a great tool for sifting through tons of crap to find the information you need. I personally used AI when programming a remote-controlled car, not to write all the code for me, but to explain how individual functions work. Searching for it on Google was absolute torture, and this way I immediately had a clear, transparent list of what does what, and everything I needed. In short, as long as AI was used only to create a reference image/model and as a guide and guidance to achieve the goal, it seems absolutely rational to me. Help you create something, not create it for you. Also about textures - please, don't even think about using AI for that xD I'd keep the maps. There's still a some amount of work involved, no need to really waste it now, but if the AI ​​usage goes beyond what I've written, I simply wouldn't go any further and don't make more of them, keeping those in state for a potential remaster or something

FwuffyBlue

I am on mobile and cannot format my comment, sorry. I would want to know how the AI was used, but knowing that this sort of workflow is becoming increasingly common in the industry and- to my understanding- already was to a degree before stuff like Gemini and Claude and ChatGPT were as commonplace as they are... I'm over it. I'm cool with it. There's a human making artistic and creative decisions and as long as the FINAL texture and model assets weren't created by genAI then fine. If there's generated assets visible and available to the end user, I'm not okay with it at all. For what it's worth, I think that what blacky does is incredible and I'd hate for anything to sour the relationship he has with you guys and the project/community. I have zero negative feelings towards the person behind it. As it stands for now, and maybe I'm partially selfish in saying so, but I'm of a mind that it's a waste to not release what was already made- a waste of water and compute time as much as a waste of human effort and time as well. Just... I wouldn't want any generated assets facing me as a user in anything else from now on.

FurryVNE Team

Thanks for the honest reply. I retrospect, it would've been better to be upfront about it from the very beginning. I think all of us was just so impressed by what Blacky had manged to accomplish while also being so eager to finally have a new environment after such a long drought, that we let our excitement cloud our judgment. I must also admit that I was not entirely aware of the extent to which AI had been used, or precisely which parts of the environment had been authored with its assistance. That's an error on my part that I didn't investigate that more closely before deciding to include it in the build.

FurryVNE Team

Regarding breaking interactions - the systems we're implementing are adding on top of the already existing foundation, and we're doing what we can to make everything compatible. These new features shouldn't impact existing interactions in any noticable way.

Aetherius15

Idk, this just feels sort of icky to me. As much as I have faith in this project, this better not happen again, I'd prefer for the team to stay away from AI as they can.

Aetherius15

It's not virtue signaling? It's funny that you think AI just generates on its own, i've seen your reply elsewhere, you ignore the fact that it scalps data from other artists without their knowledge and makes an abomination of their work. FVNE Team has the prerogative to shut this down and preserve artistic integrity, something we could use right now

Aetherius15

Acts of violence? You're joking, right? Id rather have skribble kid art than AI slop

Aetherius15

Nvm, if you're even praising AI for that, I think it's high time I cut off my subscription. This goes against my code as an artist, I hope you wise up and learn never to consider that again because that's a spit in the face of the artistic community.

FurryVNE Team

To be clear, that screenshot method was one of the users, not developer. I will not disclose user out of respect for the user privacy. Also to further disclose what exactly this particular person was doing - they were trying different colors and patterns.

Ruro

As long as the gens are reworked to suit the vision i don't see the problem, AI can do a lot of the tedious heavy lifting but it can't do everything, if the quality is there it's not because of AI. I see why people take issue with it, but it's not going away, and refusing it only puts you at a disadvantage.

【FANCY】

After watching the video and reading dev replies - if that's the direction you want to take FurryVNE in, then I want nothing to do with it. I'm considering cancelling my sub after New Year's. Also, you still haven't clarified what exactly was made with ai. Why the evasiveness?

Christopher Lee

I don't have a problem with whatever workflow or things Blacky did to create his maps. And, seeing from what he wrote in his Discord message, even more so. Seems to me he used AI in ways that made creating his map smoother, imo. I say keep doing great work, Blacky!

Ivee

Keep Blacky, keep the new maps, replace the skybox and paintings, don't use gen AI going forward. I simply think dropping Blacky or the new maps does more harm than good. It strikes me as cutting off your nose to spite your face. I think gen AI has some bad implications for IP rights. The criticisms there are valid. Please just learn from that and go forward. Do not try to prostrate yourself to please some of the people acting high-and-mighty in the comments here. That kind of purity culture is usually counterproductive and unhealthy, IMO.

Furry Fur Life

AI assisted work is something people need to accept will likely never be entirely avoidable. I'm against people using AI to entirely do the work for them of course, but I highly doubt that's what is taking place here. It is going to be used as a tool to assist workflow regardless of what anyone thinks. I think a fair way of dealing with the people who absolutely can't have AI in their lives is to just mark things with an 'AI assisted' tag. Just give the people the option to avoid it if it really bothers them so much. This is no different than when older people would refuse to learn technology such as computers. Things are going to advance whether people like it or not. AI assisted tag would be the play. Just give the minority that doesn't want it a clear way to avoid it.

rugarou

"its funny that I think AI just generates on its own" , "I ignore the *fact* that it scalps data from other artists without their knowledge" lets examine those two "statements" because this is where a lot of you fail this test. an AI model is "trained" with images. it didnt steal them, no more than you steal other ppls work simply by looking at it. however we arent generating images here, its code, it didnt look at someones code and say im gonna take that, it learned to code then executed the instructions you gave it, so wheres the theft???? what exactly was stolen?? nothing, nor was anything plagiarized either. even if you were feeding it images its still not "taking other ppls work" and doing anything with it aside from examining the picture and making either a mean,or median image from it. this doesnt mean it takes an image and stencils over it and draws over the top of someones work, and if its producing abominations its because you havent tuned it. the masses can misunderstand how AI works, not really my thing, but I DO work with AI and without it and this whole "I dont understand AI so Im scared of it" nonsense is exactly that nonsense. additionally, how about some of you stellar users out there start cranking out assets then? yall sit in judgement of what ppl do yet offer no solution of your own. Im about options and results, not fear and loathing, but Im also about understanding the thing Im dealing with rather than calling it voodoo or witchcraft. in the same vein, fvne is tool, why yall using it? yall can just make your own characters in blender? just learn blender? hey you can animate in blender also, why not just animate in blender? why be lazy and use a tool to make your job or process fun and enjoyable when you can do it the hardest way possible just to satisfy someone elses perception of it? thats what we are talking about here so yes that makes it virtue signaling. virtue signaling: im better than you becuase i did a thing the way i consider to be pure. if you got beef with AI thats fine but for this? theres ppl out here putting dicks on characters half the size of the dick, speak more of abominations... yall out here acting like rembrandt or picasso are being put out of work over this, btw most artists starve anyways except musicians. and AI isnt simple to use, yall out here saying this shit about oh he snapped his fingers and poof excellence happened, that is NOT how that goes either. heres a novel idea, how about before you denounce the thing, you first go and make a map like he did, and find out what thats about first, see how *simple* and *easy* that is? I have argued with blacky and i have supported blacky, same with some of you others, what im not going to do is follow a hype train chanting some shit repeating stuff "others said" with no information. so go on and explain the process by which AI steals work, cause those datasets wouldnt be a few gigs, theyed be terabytes. Im willing to bet you dont even know how to build a workflow. AI is an engine, a lora is an instruction set for the model, you train the instruction set. they are not a single piece, nor are images generated with a model and a single "lora" and code defintely is not this way. most of the AI fear thats being discussed is how AI gens images or movies from an image, thats not what happened here, at all, thats a very base understanding of a thing ppl dont know how to use. additionally, FVNE is a small team, literally. I know most of you want this to be in infinite development but thats what will cause this project to fail. AI can code a new one for you tho right? cuz its so easy? ppl playing skycraft and all that? anyone can do it... except they cant. ppl that make those claims have not done anything like that and dont know how, thats why yall think its easy, cuz you dont *know* and prolly havent done the work to begin with.

BadluckBeast

Not a fan of genAI/don't want to encourage its use but I don't think you need to boot someone for experimenting with it. When it comes to 3D environment art in particular there aren't a lot of uses I can think of for it that aren't covered by prebuilt assets to begin with? So I think using it is shooting yourself in the foot both in terms of general sentiment, assurance of the quality of the assets you're getting and just learning proper workflows in general. Even without the baggage of how AI works and all the negative impacts its had on other industries and education that make me opposed to it on principal, I'm just far more confident in code, assets, decisions etc. made by humans. edit: based on the discord post Blacky made I think if you replaced the generated assets I'd have less issue with it, asking a bot for architectural advice is a nothingburger compared to if large chunks of the map were being generated. Also the colliders (that were apparently generated?) need to be looked at either way as they've been behaving kind of strangely.

_Scyll4s

We have to accept that AI tools are here. They exist and people use it for personal or professional reasons. If you don't, somebody else definitely will. That said, I think it's important to adapt to these situations. AI can help with a lot of stuff, but that doesn't mean it has to do everything or be present in any or all departments. What I'm personally against is the thought of "we fill any gaps with AI" or "We will use 100% AI for something." Human work and creativity are essential to bring life to any project, but also their understanding of what AI can do to help that project going forward, and not just take over the boring tasks. Just like when the internet came along in the past, it came to help and facilitate our lives. AI is here, to facilitate and help, but we have to be responsible and smart about how to use it, just like the internet. Great vlog btw! Cheers!

Kallista Veil

I'm on the hill ( Due to my job ) Where anything that is AI assisted is fine. It's Generative AI that is the main issue. Assisted AI is a supportive tool while Gen AI is what everyone has a problem with. I feel like everyone hates AI as a whole after Gen AI became an issue. AI can be extremely helpful as a tool. I also hate anything that is as a whole Generated with AI. In my line of work, AI is used to help condense and troubleshoot code. It helps renovate and provide more ease of access to my job. We don't use Gen AI, even when clients send us clearly Gen AI work to upload to their sites, we turn that down due to our beliefs in Gen AI. We don't do any graphics ourselves as it's all client based. Yet we still feel strongly about it. As long as Blacky was only using AI for assistance, I feel it's okay.

Cryptdk

By this purist logic, nobody would ever be allowed to create anything ever again. You can't use a pencil to draw because you didn't invent the pencil, drawing a circle is plagiarism because you're not the first person to do so, you can't use a calculator to do math because you didn't do the math yourself.

vml

I remember saying "It's about time!" when Blacky gained an official role on the team. While this topic is about more than just him, I fully agree with where Blacky was coming from. Generally after the news of the Unity delay, updates and communication got sparse. We got great things but it largely felt like the devs were locked in on what they wanted and a lot of popular requests were not acknowledged or relegated to coming out Soon(TM). Communication nowadays is better than the YL1 days, but still. So when we got the new map, it felt like a lot of boxes the community wanted were being ticked. And we were getting more frequent WIP updates! So it didn't feel like we were holding our breath on whether there'd be any news by the end of the month. Admittedly, it's easier to explain and show off art assets than break down code changes, and there was a lot to figure out with butt deformations before it went live. And taking time out of development to jingle keys for your audience, well, takes time. So do I want to see the momentum here slow down? No. But do I want it if it means AI's involved? Mostly no. In theory I don't want AI in the final result, but reality has proven it winds up there eventually.

vml

To add on one more thought, I remember there was a winter discount or something which got an AI generated promotional image. That received a lot of negative attention, was taken down, and apologized for. So it's not great to be told about AI involvement only after someone called it out. This was a lesson that should have already been learned to be upfront about AI.

william whittington

I'm sorry, But I cannot condone the usage of AI. I'm sure Blacky meant well, but no. Like BtheDestroyer I'm out. Thank y'all for all the enjoyment the game brought, goodbye.

BtheDestroyer

Wrong, people give permission to reuse what they've done and you can give credit where appropriate. There's a difference between referencing someone else's work and saying "my work is based upon..." and pretending you invented everything yourself. There's also a difference between someone saying "you can use my drawing however you like" and you just taking their drawing without permission.

FurryVNE Team

Thanks for the honesty. We've got amazing things coming. Keep an eye out for the public updates. You're welcome back at any time.

Dation Panigin

I don't want the map, but I also don't necessarily want Blacky to be booted. People make mistakes, and if Blacky is understanding of the community's stance on AI, and willing to make environments without it, then I see no reason that they should *have* to step down.

Mocchanyen

Lmao people whining about the use of AI Not using AI nowadays is totally self-limiting and self-destructive. "bUt iT's PlaGiaRisM" please explain to me WHERE IS THE THEFT!! The model was fed with tons of content and was trained on it. Images and text was taken to find patterns and tune a network on it.00 It took your instruction and put something together based on what it "learned" so where is the theft?? If I look at your images, and then draw something myself, did I now steal your content because it inspired my drawing? Do you purge any information from the internet out of your mind before you create something? EVERY SINGLE COMPANY is using AI to generate stuff, code, images, whatever ... this is the industrial revolution of our time, we have no choice. By putting your stuff online you give up any ownership whatsoever, not because I say so, but because it is fully and totally uncontrollable. There is NOTHING anyone could EVER do about it other than not putting anything on the internet. And even then, you aren't save, they are cutting off book spines of old books that never made it on the internet, so they can scan everything and use it for model training... We can literally reverse engineer compiled binaries now, just look at artcraft, closed-source is dead. You can decide whether you gonna use this as an advantage to accelerate development of your product and make processes more efficient, or fall behind and get outperformed and eaten by the competition. This is not my opinion, this is the industrial capitalism that we live in right now.. Don't get me wrong, I'd rather live in a world where AI was never invented if I could choose.. but I can't

Mocchanyen

I'm 100.0% on your side!

Mocchanyen

lmao I'll double my payment to compensate for you leaving good by lmfao

Nathan@Saber-40

I understand both sides for having their own valid reasons regarding Artificial Intelligence, given that it’s a touchy subject; As for me I think AI should be used ‘only’ for generating rough ideas, and other minor things to assist artists and creator’s, in the process weather it be assisting on creating character assets or assisting with entertainment . And on a different note regarding environments in FurryVNE, I agree with environments being the core of all interactions and scenes, but I feel that Templates and characters are what truly makes FurryVNE, shine giving each environment it’s own different creative spark. Allowing people to create and their own unique characters; and true that some character templates haven’t been created or stuck in the development & design process, due to certain technical difficulties or other circumstances. An lastly I for one, would love to see you guys continue to create new character templates and more amazing content in the foreseeable future. 🐘🐘🐘