Modest Medusa Future books poll (Patreon)
Content
I've been considering the future of Modest Medusa books and would like to ask your opinion. I'd like to do a Kickstarter for Season 5 relatively soon, and Season 6 after that, but I'm also almost out of the original hardcover versions of Seasons 1 and 3, and I've been reprinting 2 for awhile. Keeping 3 books in print is a challenge, and that will only get harder with Season 4 and 5 (and the 24 Hour book, and the coloring book).
The way I see it I have 4 options going forward:
1: Keep doing individual softcover books, keeping everything in print at the same time. Keeping 5 books in print is expensive, however I can reorder small quantities (as few as 100) from a domestic printer whenever I need them instead of having to order 1000 from a Chinese printer. This allows me to do reprints to meet demand without having to run a Kickstarter to finance a large print run. On the other hand, it without a large backstock it also means I'm having to do reprints fairly often. We ran into this problem with Combine where issue 2 or 4 would go out of print and we'd have to find money to reprint while also financing the new issue.
2: Return to hardcover books. This is SUPER expensive, and would require ordering at least 1000 of each book at a time. But the books look nice and they sell well. People recognize the value and quality and are excited to buy them (and people have been noticeably less enthusiastic since I've started to phase the hardcovers out). But unlike option 1 I couldn't finance this myself, and would have to resort to a Kickstarter. And printing all 4 Seasons (plus 5) in hardcover would cost a LOT (Probably $40,000 or more). And I don't know if theres enthusiasm among my readers for another Kickstarter for old material. Even though my readership continues to grow I'm not sure if you'd all be willing to finance a $40K project for books many of you already own.
3: Do an omnibus collection of books 1-3. One big 500 page book. I think this would be softcover, and probably larger sized to accommodate the full sized pages in Season 3 (8x10 inches, like Combine was). I could print this domestically or overseas, depending on demand. I think it would be very nice looking, but would be an expensive book, both to produce, buy and ship. I would probably have to charge $25-30 for it, which is less than I charge for all three books now, but is still a lot. Shipping would be a nightmare too. For reference, shipping a Yeld book to Europe (where so many of you live) costs about $35. This book would be nearly TWICE as big! Also, one of the selling points of MM is that you can try the first book for $15, which is fairly cheap, especially for an impulse buy at a con. A $25-30 book is a tougher sell, even though I often sell all three in a bundle to new customers for more than that. The perceived value is important. And like option 2, I'd have to do a Kickstarter to finance it, and I'm not sure if there enthusiasm for that. If I chose this option I'd continue to do Kickstarters for new volumes (in hardcover or softcover, I'm not sure) and then reprint them as 2-3 volume omnibus' when they go out of print. So for example season 4, 5 and 6 would probably eventually be one volume.
4: Find a publisher to take over publishing and distributing the reprint collections. Leaving all this work to a publisher would free up a lot of time for me, but its also giving up a lot of control, so I have mixed feelings about that. I'm not sure if it would be more or less profitable (those of you who don't work in comics would be appalled o learn how bad some publishing deals are). It possibly would allow the comic to reach a bigger audience, which would be nice. However, I'm not sure if I could find an interested publisher.
So I think those are my best options. What do you all think? Comments appreciated. Also, please vote!
- Jake