Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

I've been considering the future of Modest Medusa books and would like to ask your opinion. I'd like to do a Kickstarter for Season 5 relatively soon, and Season 6 after that, but I'm also almost out of the original hardcover versions of Seasons 1 and 3, and I've been reprinting 2 for  awhile. Keeping 3 books in print is a challenge, and that will only get harder with Season 4 and 5 (and the 24 Hour book, and the coloring book).

The way I see it I have 4 options going forward:


1: Keep doing individual softcover books, keeping everything in print at the same time.  Keeping 5 books in print is expensive, however I can reorder small quantities (as few as 100) from a  domestic printer whenever I need them instead of having to order 1000 from a Chinese printer.  This allows me to do reprints to meet demand without having to run a Kickstarter to finance a large print run. On the other hand, it without a  large backstock it also means I'm having to do reprints fairly often. We ran into this problem with Combine where issue 2 or 4 would go out of print and we'd have to find money to reprint while also financing the new issue.

2: Return to hardcover books. This is SUPER expensive, and would require ordering at least 1000 of each book at a time. But the books look nice and they sell well. People recognize the value and quality and are excited to buy them (and people have been noticeably less enthusiastic since I've started to phase the hardcovers out). But unlike option 1 I couldn't finance this myself, and would have to resort to a Kickstarter. And printing all 4 Seasons (plus 5) in hardcover would cost a  LOT (Probably $40,000 or more). And I don't know if theres enthusiasm among my readers for another Kickstarter for old material. Even though my readership continues to grow I'm not sure if you'd all be willing to finance a $40K project for books many of you already own.

 3: Do an omnibus collection of books 1-3. One big 500 page book. I think this would be softcover, and probably larger sized to accommodate the full sized pages in Season 3 (8x10 inches, like Combine was). I could print this domestically or overseas, depending on demand. I think it would be very nice looking, but would be an expensive book, both to produce, buy and ship. I would probably have to charge $25-30 for it, which is less than I charge for all three books now, but is still a lot. Shipping would be a nightmare too. For reference, shipping a Yeld book to Europe (where so many of you live) costs about $35. This book would be nearly TWICE as big! Also, one of the selling points of MM is that you can try the first book for $15, which is fairly cheap, especially for an impulse buy at a con. A $25-30 book is a tougher sell, even though I often sell all three in a bundle to new customers for more than that. The perceived value is important. And like option 2, I'd have to do a Kickstarter to finance it, and I'm not sure if there enthusiasm for that. If I chose this option I'd continue to do Kickstarters for new volumes (in hardcover or softcover, I'm not sure) and then reprint them as 2-3 volume omnibus' when they go out of print. So for example season 4, 5 and 6 would probably eventually be one volume.

4: Find a publisher to take over publishing and distributing the reprint collections. Leaving all this work to a publisher would free up a lot of time for me, but its also giving up a lot of control, so I have mixed feelings about that. I'm not sure if it would be more or less profitable (those of you who don't work in comics would be appalled o learn how bad some publishing deals are). It possibly would allow the comic to reach a bigger audience, which would be nice. However, I'm not sure if I could find an interested publisher. 


So I think those are my best options. What do you all think? Comments appreciated. Also, please vote!


- Jake

Comments

Wendell Hong

Maybe you could make the hardcover books a stretch goal? I'd prefer a hardcover because they are more durable but i'd settle for softcover.

Jake Richmond

Well... Thats something I thought about before. But its not so simple. The difference between producing a soft cover book domestically and a hardcover on China is huge. For example, Season 5 (the next book) might have a $10,000 goal to produce 500 softcover books and ship them to backers. That would be about $4000 for printing, another $3000 for shipping, $500 for various extra rewards (stickers, prints, shirts, etc), plus kickstarter's cut and various odds and ends. If I offered Hardcovers as a stretch goal the costs would change. First, i'd have to print a minimum of 1000, and the printing cost would jump to about $8000. Thats not a bad deal (which is why I used a Chinese printer to begin with), but its a lot more money. Shipping from China is another $1500, and the additional weight of hardcover means that shipping to customers will be closer to $4000. Add on all the other things I mentioned before and that would be a $17,000 stretch goal. Which is probably doable. But that would mean that the project went from having a $7000 profit to $0 profit just to meet that stretch goal. And while having a profit isn't as important as getting the books made, it does allow me to do other things, like pay bills, but new equipment, attend cons, reprint out of print books, etc. Very often the extra income from Kickstarters gets me through the year. Thats all off the top of my head estimates though. Anyway, its not an impossible idea, but the cost increase in both printing and shipping have made "hardcover as stretch goal" daunting enough that I didn't try it last time. however, the printer we used fro Yeld has good rates for hardcover and did a good job, so I may look at that next time.

Anonymous

Have you considered a pre-order system? Some game companies, like GMT Games, have a system where they take orders for a game and once they hit a certain order limit they put the game into production. They collect credit card info at the pre-order but don't charge for the game until it ships. I realize the logistics of this might be more than a one-man operation can handle and Kickstarter might be a better option. However, collecting pre-order information of some kind might make it easier to gauge when to start a Kickstarter and what reprints to offer.

Jake Richmond

I did something like this waaay back when I first started publishing games (in 2008?). It worked okay, but it was small scale. But I feel like Kickstarter is just a more efficient way of doing a pre-order. On the other hand, its a good point about using a pre-order to gauge interest.

Tycho Aussie

Print the Omnibus version; offer the volume 1 as a print on-demand book to tease new readers into wanting the remaining volumes? But really, it depends on where your revenue is coming from: If the older volumes aren't bringing in significant revenue, why not let a publisher handle it? That frees you to keep creating new and current stuff. Maybe take a look at publishers such as Andrews McMeel Publishing, who handles titles such as Endtown. Or, perhaps give Dave &amp; Liz a call over at <a href="http://www.vividpub.com/" rel="nofollow noopener" target="_blank">http://www.vividpub.com/</a> - I hear they are looking for original content authors to collaborate with when it comes to publishing.

Jake Richmond

I've been meaning to explore publishers and see if anyone is interested. But I haven't had much time for the last... 4 years. Thats changing. But I've also wary of a bad deal. I know several creators who have deals with publishers so poor that they lose money. But I won't know till I look, I guess. If I do the omnibus I will have to offer SOMETHING as a low priced intro. I'm hesitant to keep a first volume in print though, even through POD. I feel like "but this book to try out the series, now if you like it buy this other book which you've already read 1/3rd of" is a real interest killer. I could do a Vol1, and then a vol 1-4, but... ugh. A better answer might be an intro volume that isn't exactly vol 1. A stand alone Medusa story that introduces the character and world that I can offer for $5-10. Also, thanks for the resources I'll check those publishers out.

Anonymous

What would be the logistics of doing a hardcover for the initial Kickstarter, kind of an incentive for first/early supporters, and softcovers for subsequent reprints? Is that feasible?

Anonymous

It may be wise to plan on publishing yourself, but spend a little bit of time trying to make contact with larger graphic novel publishers. If they're willing to take on and champion the project, to advertise it and get it retail shops via distributors, then it might be well worth it. You'd probably want to look at publishers who have taken other popular web comics and turned them into successful commercially-available graphic novel lines (off the top of my head I'm thinking of Blood Stain (published by Image) or Kill Six Billion Demons (Image)). You don't want to mess with small-fish publishers, because they won't be able to do anything you're not already doing, but a big publisher may be able to do marketing and getting-in-front-of-retailers that you can't.

CyberSkull

I've got 1-3 hardcover, but I think your best bet going forward is an omnibus.

Jake Richmond

Thats kind of where we are now, unintentionally. Its a good idea, but it leaves me with two problems. First, it turns out new readers don't like having a mix of soft cover and hardcover books. One or the other is fine,. but the number of people who pass up buying books because I don't offer all in one format is really surprising. This happened during the last Kickstarter, where a bunch of backers dropped out or asked for refunds after they found out some of the book weren't available as hardcover. I could offer hardcovers JUST for Kickstarter backers, but that would mean that new backers wouldn't have a chance at older hardcover, and creates kind of the same problem. Also, doing a run of only 300 hardcovers (thats about how many backers I average) would be VERY expensive. Plus, I'd still have to produce a softcover to sell to people beyond the Kickstarter (which is kind of the whole point), so that needs to either be factored into the Kickstarter cost. Its not a bad idea (the Foglio's do it for Girl Genius), its just expensive and complicated.

Jake Richmond

You're right, I do need to invest some time in approaching publishers and gauging interest. Being represented by a publisher would also help me out at cons a lot.

Jake Richmond

Thanks for teh feedback, everyone.I'll consider what you've said.

CyberSkull

It should be easier to keep in stock and easier for people to get the whole collection that way.

Anonymous

I like the soft covers, but the hard covers do make a 'premium' item that some people would go for. If you get a publisher to handle the distribution, it would certainly make it easier, but I can understand your concern there too. FInding a good one might be a challenge. For the omnibus, i like the idea of an omnibus edition for the "final" books, maybe O1 &amp; O2, if there are too many to be reasonable in a book...

Jake Richmond

The softcovers have their appeal. Some readers prefer them, and they're much cheaper to ship since they're about half the weight. I can also print small runs on demand, which has both benefits and drawbacks. I'm not sure ho hard finding a publisher will be, but looking into that will be my goal for next month. I've seen some absolutely awful deals, even from large publishers like Image and Darkhorse, so I'm wary. But it may be worth it. I think I'd have to limit an omnibus to about 500 ages, so that would be Season 1-3, and then ... I was about to say 4-6, but 6 by itself will be over 300 pages when its done, and with extras I always do for books, maybe closer to 330. Well, I can figure that out when the time comes.

Dizzy Valiel

I'm Iate here, but for what it's worth... , I feeI Iike getting books is sort of Iike, for coIIectors? I'm on patreon obviousIy but I have no idea what I'd actuaIIy do with physicaI books. To that end, it makes me think that making it more... coIIectabIe, wouId be the most sense. HonestIy, if making them more Iimited(or just not making them at aII unIess there's an immidiate demand) seems Iike a good decision to me.(Though the appeal of third party pubIishing is massive, especiaIIy if they couId bring in new readers.)

Jake Richmond

I see what you're saying. I think theres different audiences. A lot of readers discover teh comic through the books, or ONLY read the books, so having books is important (besides being a source of income for me). But for a lot of readers who primarily get the comic online books are unnecessary, or a novelty or collectors item, or just a way to support the comic. So having a fancier, more collector oriented book that is more worth owning makes sense, especially since that seems to appeal to both audiences.

Evgeny Sandu

I seriously cannot understand why there's such a HUGE price for shipping anything from China (the hardcover factory) to Europe. Are you saying that you plan to receive those at home first, and THEN ship to the readers? This does not make sense to me. IMHO, what you need is a warehouse/distributor in china, next to the factory. Everything is cheaper to ship from China, and warehouse costs are not high either. I'm one of the collectors, so I'll probably vote for the hardcovers. My Kids will be reading those books in 3-5 years, so I would want them to be as safe as possible for the time being. By the way, I have only Seasons 1 and 2, and You probably have to check your statistics as for how many of us did buy s3 at all. I did not buy it because of incredible shipping costs, and S5-6 are what I was waiting for, hoping that shipping 3 at once will be cheaper.

Jake Richmond

I don't even know if warehousing in China is possible. I suppose it might be, but shipping books from China to Europe won't be cheaper than shipping them from the US to Europe, as far as I know. Warehousing books in China and shipping them on demand to buyers would also involve hiring someone in China to handle that. Maybe theres a service that does that? I can't imagine it would be cheap. I also wouldn't be able to inspect books to make sure that they don't have printing errors or damage. Or sign books. Additionally, I need to have books on hand anyway, since I take books with me to sell at conventions, school appearances and store signings. So even though warehosuing books in China would save me money on the initial bulk shipping cost, I don't think its feasible, unless theres specifically an affordable warehousing, fulfillment and shipping service out there. Which I guess is worth looking into. I am looking for a European warehousing and fulfillment service, since about 40% of my customers are in Europe. That would hopefully allow me to reduce shipping costs quite a bit. So far I haven't found a service that really matches my needs, but I'm still looking. I can't blame you for not buying Season 3 due to shipping costs. Unfortunately theres not much I can do about that right now, since I don't set international shipping rates. I know that a lot of international buyers are turned off by the shipping cost as well, but unless I can find an international distributor I can't really do anything about it. That said, sales of Season 3 have been consistent with Season 1 and 2, so even though the price understandably scared off some buyers, interest has remained healthy.