Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hi everyone. I've been trying to decide how to solve a problem. I'd really like to hear your input.

I'll be launching a Kickstarter for the next Modest Medusa book (season 5) later this month. But I'm also nearly out of Seasons 1-4, so I'll need to reprint those as well. Keeping all my books in print has become difficult.

So here's my question. Would you prefer:

1. That Modest Medusa Seasons by published individually, and stay in print individually. So that you can always buy Season 1 or Season 3 or Season 5 as individual volumes?

2. Modest Medusa Seasons are published individually, but after a few years are collected into one large omnibus collection. For example, Modest medusa seasons 1-3 would be available as a single large volume, while 4 and 5 remain available individually. Eventually 4 and 5 would be collected with Season 6 n a single volume, and Season 7 would be available individually.

I know a lot of you already own these books, so this may not matter much to you. But hopefully you're planning on getting new books as they're released. This question has become a huge problem for me, and its one of the reasons I've been slow to release new books.  I need to figure it out so I can move forward. your input would really help.

As some of you know, I wasn't super pleased with how the 4th book came out. The print quality wasn't nearly as nice as the hardcovers, and overall I felt like it was a poorer product. Ideally, I'd love to reprint the series in hardcover, but its juts not feasible. My first runs of the hardcovers were 1500 copies each, and I got a good deal from my printer on those because of the large quantities. I think if I could afford to print that many again I could sell them in a few years, but I just can't afford to print 1500 copies of 5 different hardcover books. Its just way too expensive.

My new plan is doing what I'm going to call "Treasury Editions" of the books. These will be larger sized softcover books (9 x 12 I think) printed on higher quality paper, possibly with French Fold covers. They'll be sized to match the Yeld book and of similar quality. They won't be hardcover, but they'll be big and pretty. They unfortunately won't match the previous printings, but since I'm no longer doing hardcover books thats kind of out the window anyway.

What do you all think? I'd really like to hear your opinions.

Comments

Evgeny Sandu

Well, as an owner of only books 1&2, I wouldn't benefit much from the option 2 (omnibuses). The higher-sized soft-covers printed individually would be totally OK for me, but once again — only if postal delivery to Russia will be of sensible price. As well as the overall price, of cause.

Jake Richmond

Yeah, I would need to keep individual book in print for awhile, even if I decide to do teh omnibus. Which is a complication. Shipping is another complication. International shipping is just so damn expensive. I've been looking into international fulfillment centers and distributors, but I haven't really found a good solution yet.i don't want any of you to have to pay $30 or 50 in shipping for a $15 book (or even a $40 one), but thats where we are right now. I'd love to find a Russian distributor willing to carry my books, but I don't even know where to start with that.

Barry Deutsch

I think omnibus books combined with the large-format individual books is the option that makes the most sense. And the large-format books sound neat. That's pretty much what Fantagraphics has been doing with the Love and Rockets reprints for years - individual books appear, and are eventually allowed to go out of print once the omnibus editions with the same materials are put in print.

Anonymous

I have 1-4, but I bought them recently and would have probably been even happier with an omnibus. I think that's a great idea, especially if it saves you money. Meanwhile, the rest of us can feel like we have the cool first prints! It would be a bit of a pain to have to buy 6 in only the omnibus, but I totally would! Heck, I think we here all buy the books because we love the comic and want to give you money for it. In the end I'm happy with whatever is best for you!

Wendell Hong

Option 2 seems the best compromise.

Michael Butchin

I think a Print-on-Demand plan is better. That way, you never have to worry about anything going out of print, and even late-comers (like me) can still purchase the beginnings of the story.

Wilhelm Fitzpatrick

For my own part, I think the smaller format books fit the comic better. Also outside of my RPG collection where that size is "standard" I find smaller books easier to shelve and manage. A higher quality softcover if possible would be great. In the end, I'll back your play, whatever it may be :)

Evgeny Sandu

It sounds like it's a problem only with Outbound from US. Delivery from China to anywhere in the world is ridiculously cheap. Of cause it all starts with the amounts. We've got plenty of agencies that can print (both in Russia, China, Ukraine, Poland, wherever), but below a certain amount it will just not worth it. So how many could there be, roughly?

Anonymous

I personally prefer #1, single volumes... Collected volumes are great, but I can't always afford them... They would make great gifts for others who one knows will enjoy them, though

Jake Richmond

My original print runs for the first 3 MM books was 1500 copies each. Thats not a large amount, but its enough to get an okay discount from most printers. My sales split is about 30% international, 60% domestic, and that includes Kickstarter sales, convention sales, sales to stores and sales on my site. So here's the problem... I could find a Chinese warehouse to hold on to a few hundred books and send them to international customers as they're sold. Thats a good idea. But it means that I'm contracting a warehouse for years and years, which is an additional monthly or yearly fee that I'm not sure I can afford. Bu I'm also not sure I can't. I need to look into it more.

Jake Richmond

I appreciate that. Thanks. I want to make the individual volumes attractive enough that readers might want to seek them out and own them instead of waiting for an omnibus. Or maybe in addition to the omnibus. I've been trying to think how to add to the value of the individual volumes without increasing the cost and without making them something that people feel compelled to buy so they don't miss out (for example, adding a bunch of exclusive bonus comics)

Jake Richmond

I think so too. But I'm also really curious if people will actually put down $40 for a book. Its a lot.

Jake Richmond

I'm a big fan of POD, but I've been very unsatisfied with my available POD options. The last MM book (Season 4) was printed by a POD printer iI have a good relationship with, but I felt like it was below my quality standard, and the second printing was worse. Nick and I offer a POD version of Yeld through DrivethruRPG, and its just awful. I'm embarrassed by how poor it is. If I can find a POD printer that does quality work I'd be very happy to use them. But so far I haven't. But I'm pen for recommendations. Because, honestly, I'd love to just order books as I need them. I do that with the 24 Hour Modest medusa book and its so great. But thats a cheap black and white book.

Jake Richmond

Thanks. I was really happy with the hardcover size, until I got to season 3 and realized that the format doesn't work well for my larger pages. So I've been thinking about gong larger for awhile, especially as the comic continues to have more larger pages. But I also tried out a smaller format with the 1st softcover printing of Season 2. It was tiny. Just too small. I have considered something more squareish. Maybe 8 x 9 instead of 6 x 9. But thats such an nontraditional size that printers sometimes get weird about it.

Jake Richmond

Thats a real concern. having individual volumes keeps things cheap for the readers and lets them buy one at a time. Having big volumes is convenient for some readers, but it out prices others. I'm actually really worried about that.

Michael Butchin

Ah, I'm sorry. I've only ever used POD for standard print books. I had no idea they were shoddy for four-color comics.

Jake Richmond

No need to apologize. POD isn't actually inherently inferior. I've had some very nice books printed with POD printers. When I was still producing Combine we did that with a POD printer and they did a great job. But the POD printers I've dealt with in the past have either gone out of business or started producing inferior stuff. I've had trouble finding one that does good and consistent work. But I should keep looking. If I can find one I may change my plans.

Nathanael Cole

As a reader of large amounts of things, I prefer Omnibus editions. Single book, easier to shelve. Have you looked into going the Print on Demand route for future releases? The initial print orders can then be fulfilled without ordering a massive amount of stock that you then have to sit on.

Nathanael Cole

Just seeing this thread after I also suggested POD. Can you tell me more about what was so poor about DriveThru? I've been nothing but happy with all the various books I've ordered there, hardback and soft, both my own books and the POD versions of books I've kickstarted. The only times I was dissatisfied, it turned out I was actually submitting incorrectly formatted files, and the issues vanished once I corrected.

Jake Richmond

I mentioned this to someone else, but I'v been really unsatisfied with the quality of POD over the last few years. both of the places I've used regularly have had a dramatic drop in quality, i printed my last book with a POD printer I've been happy to use before,but i wasn't happy with how it turned out. Similarly, the Yeld books that are available through Drivethru's POD program are embarrassingly poor. If I can find a POD printer I'm happy with then I'd be willing to do that, for exactly the reason you mentioned. But right now i'v got a box full of samples from various printers that offer POD services, and all of them are poor. If you have have a recommendation i'd love to hear it.

Jake Richmond

I've had very mixed results from POD books through Drivethru. I think they use Lightning Source? Thats the same company that I printed Panty Explosion Perfect with, and I was really happy with the results. But since then (about 7 years ago) I've gotten some very poor books from them. They seem to handle printing for black and white books pretty well, but color is very washed out. i also feel like the paper quality and binding is poor. We offer Yeld through them, mostly just to give customers the option to get it there instead of trying to find my store or IPR, but the copies I ordered as samples were really poor. To the point that I'm embarrassed to offer them for sale. I do also have a few books from Drivethru that I think look pretty good. So I think its hit or miss. But I don't want to offer a product thats hit or miss, you know? I mean, I've been in situations in the past where I get an order from a printer and its just awful. So unless I can find a reliable POD printer I'd rather pay for a larger batch up front from a printer that i know will do a good job. Also, I didn't mention it before but the profit margin for me is a big deal. Being able to make an extra $2-6 on each book (depending on the book) is pretty huge for me.

Evgeny Sandu

A few hundred books take as much space as.. your toilet room. That's not even a warehouse, it's a small space in a large multi-purpose warehouse. I'm sure that it should be available for very reasonable price and for a flexible term. As for the printing volumes, even 3×1000 pages sound like a small amount to me. I hope that it's not true and that there is a Chinese printer that could take the order. However, you'll need a Chinese friend to do negotiations. I don't have any, unfortunately. Maybe your readers could help there? There are a few guys who I'd ask, but most likely they are in a totally different business.

Jake Richmond

you'd be surprised how much space it takes. I get 36 books in a box, and the boxes are 10 x 9 x 14 inches. It adds up fast! But really, the problem is that foreign warehousers and distributors who handle this kind of stuff charge a LOT. That cost is usually offset by companies selling 10,000+ units. i just don't sell that much. I think I've settled on a printer now, although I' always looking for a better deal. if you have any recomendations I'd take a look.

Catharine Marr

Sorry I'm late to the comments. Id be happy with soft covers (perhaps print on demand) or even just getting the PDFs but whichever is your best option, I'm happy to back your play. We all enjoy your work and your comics and just want to support you!