Were the US Navy SEALs Stupid to Use the MP5? (Patreon)
Content
Here's another hard-hitting entertainment piece from Nutnfancy to you. And YES, you read that title correctly! Should the Navy SEALs have used something ELSE instead?! Well, strap on your life preserver and climb aboard for an original question and an original take on the answer. Asking the question might not be as absurd as you may think.
First, I'll take you back to the 1980s, both tactically and culturally, to examine what was happening in current events AND movies. Several landmark hostage-rescue operations took place, prominently featuring the MP5. And both were successful. Did this influence the SEALs? Yes...these influenced EVERYONE.
Then I'll summarize a slew of entertaining, fast-paced action movies that added to this momentum. One in particular (you'll know it) is probably representative of MP5 employment across many mission profiles. Its production was overseen and authenticated by eight Navy SEAL operators, who also performed many of the stunts.
But maybe you'll say, "That's what they had back then. It made sense at the time." OK. Then I'll explain why I disagree and remind you that the XM177 and CAR-15 were already proven weapon systems. Even back then! And suppressors were available too! Now I'm not saying here that the SEALS only used the MP5, for sure they were other centerfire assault rifles or such employed. But I'm saying the were a go-to system at the time.
Then I'll REALLY get cooking with my discussion on BALLISTICS. That's where we'll find some truth in our quest. Comparing 9mm and 5.56mm has been done before in TNP, but never in this context. I'll make you a believer...AGAIN. So this isn't a criticism of the SEALs. Like other Spec Ops teams, they're legit and serve us well. It's really about their safety in enemy territory, especially on unsupported mission profiles.
Their seemingly long-term adherence to and employment of this limited-caliber weapon system left them with capabilities that couldn't always match the heavier weapons they might encounter. The MP5 often had no business being out in "Indian country."
And don't get me wrong, I still LOVE the MP5 (and semi-auto clones like the MAC-5 shown here). They're fun, engaging, and absolutely have a purpose in narrowly defined engagement scenarios. It's just that I won't be reaching for one when things get spicy. And maybe the SEALs shouldn't have either.
Ref to the making of Navy SEAL movie: https://catalog.afi.com/Film/58628-NAVY-SEALS
My reviews on A Channel
MAC 5 MP5 Clone: You Won’t Stop at Just One (Mag, That Is) https://youtu.be/ZsV6Rg-4cnk Why the Uzi Kinda' Sucks by Nutnfancy https://youtu.be/E3hW-0ulIPE Attn World: The KelTec SU-16 Does Not Suck https://youtu.be/rlxph5UvtBQ Pistol Caliber Carbines Don't Suck [Afterall] by Nutnfancy https://youtu.be/INxDQZdkCzg