Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Here's another hard-hitting entertainment piece from Nutnfancy to you. And YES, you read that title correctly! Should the Navy SEALs have used something ELSE instead?! Well, strap on your life preserver and climb aboard for an original question and an original take on the answer. Asking the question might not be as absurd as you may think.

First, I'll take you back to the 1980s, both tactically and culturally, to examine what was happening in current events AND movies. Several landmark hostage-rescue operations took place, prominently featuring the MP5. And both were successful. Did this influence the SEALs? Yes...these influenced EVERYONE.

Then I'll summarize a slew of entertaining, fast-paced action movies that added to this momentum. One in particular (you'll know it) is probably representative of MP5 employment across many mission profiles. Its production was overseen and authenticated by eight Navy SEAL operators, who also performed many of the stunts.

But maybe you'll say, "That's what they had back then. It made sense at the time." OK. Then I'll explain why I disagree and remind you that the XM177 and CAR-15 were already proven weapon systems. Even back then! And suppressors were available too! Now I'm not saying here that the SEALS only used the MP5, for sure they were other centerfire assault rifles or such employed. But I'm saying the were a go-to system at the time.

Then I'll REALLY get cooking with my discussion on BALLISTICS. That's where we'll find some truth in our quest. Comparing 9mm and 5.56mm has been done before in TNP, but never in this context. I'll make you a believer...AGAIN. So this isn't a criticism of the SEALs. Like other Spec Ops teams, they're legit and serve us well. It's really about their safety in enemy territory, especially on unsupported mission profiles.

Their seemingly long-term adherence to and employment of this limited-caliber weapon system left them with capabilities that couldn't always match the heavier weapons they might encounter. The MP5 often had no business being out in "Indian country."

And don't get me wrong, I still LOVE the MP5 (and semi-auto clones like the MAC-5 shown here). They're fun, engaging, and absolutely have a purpose in narrowly defined engagement scenarios. It's just that I won't be reaching for one when things get spicy. And maybe the SEALs shouldn't have either.

Ref to the making of Navy SEAL movie: https://catalog.afi.com/Film/58628-NAVY-SEALS

My reviews on A Channel

MAC 5 MP5 Clone: You Won’t Stop at Just One (Mag, That Is) https://youtu.be/ZsV6Rg-4cnk Why the Uzi Kinda' Sucks by Nutnfancy https://youtu.be/E3hW-0ulIPE Attn World: The KelTec SU-16 Does Not Suck https://youtu.be/rlxph5UvtBQ Pistol Caliber Carbines Don't Suck [Afterall] by Nutnfancy https://youtu.be/INxDQZdkCzg

Files

Were the US Navy SEALs Stupid to Use the MP5?

Here's another hard-hitting entertainment piece from Nutnfancy to you. And YES, you read that title correctly! Should the Navy SEALs have used something ELSE instead?! Well, strap on your life preserver and climb aboard for an original question and an original take on the answer. Asking the question might not be as absurd as you may think. First, I'll take you back to the 1980s, both tactically and culturally, to examine what was happening in current events AND movies. Several landmark hostage-rescue operations took place, prominently featuring the MP5. And both were successful. Did this influence the SEALs? Yes...these influenced EVERYONE. Then I'll summarize a slew of entertaining, fast-paced action movies that added to this momentum. One in particular (you'll know it) is probably representative of MP5 employment across many mission profiles. Its production was overseen and authenticated by eight Navy SEAL operators, who also performed many of the stunts. But maybe you'll say, "That's what they had back then. It made sense at the time." OK. Then I'll explain why I disagree and remind you that the XM177 and CAR-15 were already proven weapon systems. Even back then! And suppressors were available too! Now I'm not saying here that the SEALS only used the MP5, for sure they were other centerfire assault rifles or such employed. But I'm saying the were a go-to system at the time. Then I'll REALLY get cooking with my discussion on BALLISTICS. That's where we'll find some truth in our quest. Comparing 9mm and 5.56mm has been done before in TNP, but never in this context. I'll make you a believer...AGAIN. So this isn't a criticism of the SEALs. Like other Spec Ops teams, they're legit and serve us well. It's really about their safety in enemy territory, especially on unsupported mission profiles. Their seemingly long-term adherence to and employment of this limited-caliber weapon system left them with capabilities that couldn't always match the heavier weapons they might encounter. The MP5 often had no business being out in "Indian country." And don't get me wrong, I still LOVE the MP5 (and semi-auto clones like the MAC-5 shown here). They're fun, engaging, and absolutely have a purpose in narrowly defined engagement scenarios. It's just that I won't be reaching for one when things get spicy. And maybe the SEALs shouldn't have either. Ref to the making of Navy SEAL movie: https://catalog.afi.com/Film/58628-NAVY-SEALS My reviews on A Channel MAC 5 MP5 Clone: You Won’t Stop at Just One (Mag, That Is) https://youtu.be/ZsV6Rg-4cnk Why the Uzi Kinda' Sucks by Nutnfancy https://youtu.be/E3hW-0ulIPE Attn World: The KelTec SU-16 Does Not Suck https://youtu.be/rlxph5UvtBQ Pistol Caliber Carbines Don't Suck [Afterall] by Nutnfancy https://youtu.be/INxDQZdkCzg

Comments

David Elkins

My answer is yes. But I also don’t think the seals are more inclined to do tacticool crap than the other SF communities do. Probably an unfair assessment and admittedly from just a GDC.

LucNukem

For what the SEALS do, something the size of an MP5 with a collapsed stock makes a lot of sense. Scuba, ship boarding, crawling out of submarines, raiding buildings, etc. It's not a ton shorter then a CAR-15 but a little bit makes a difference in some situations. Even unsurpressed, keeping the gun short while not being AS bad to shoot in the confines of a building or in a ship then a CAR-15 makes sense. Full auto MP5's are also easy to control. Even when I was a new'ish shooter a full auto MP5 was easy enough for me to handle, the little bit thay I did.

The Nutnfancy Project

Roger that, thanks for the comment. Points taken but if it is so awesome that way, compactness and all, why aren't they still using it?

LucNukem

Well they do have something that serves well in those niche scenarios where the size of a MK18 doesn't work, and it's the MP7.

Bravo

Agreed on all accounts. People say that having caliber commonality with your handgun is an advantage but unless you are Wild Bill and have to carry all your belongings on your horse that’s hard for me to see. I’m building a AR-9 now but just as a cheap throw away for home defense. Easier for the wife to handle. Quieter than a rifle as Id like to be able to grab and go no ear pro. Fun range toy for friends who are new shooters. You think maybe Blue team guys would have their snipers or DMs carry them instead of a pistol? Only thing I can think of.

TechNeck

coming out of Vietnam, the m16 platform was hated. The mp5k fit the bill for the seal mandate in 70-80s . their modern mandate? hell no the mp5 is outdated, heavy. unrealiable .. better more reliable PCC scare out now for cqb were over penitration matters. with a 16 inch barrel a 9mm will put down over 500ft lb of energy with 124gr. as for ammo.. 200% you can carry more.. i can put two 27 rd glock mags in a ar15 pouch... thats nearly double the ammo without taking up more realistate on my chest/waist. weight isnt everything . i regularly take a 9mm out to 200m, it still rings steel, i can fire faster and its still leathal. i find it very easy to put on target with a 3x scope. As for plates.. lv3 3+ and 4 all stop up to .308 no issues... so its not like your harder hitting rounds makes a like of difference if it hits a plate. 9mm has a lot of advantages, its much quiter, easy fallow up shots, packs smaller , shares ammo with many duty pistols across many nations

Carl Bailey

This is the same conversation as the guys who insist it must be mil-spec. Operators are guys too.

The Nutnfancy Project

Exactly. And yes there are times and places where the 9mm/PCC makes a lot of sense, just like in this video where I try to give credit for ship boarding and otherwise "guaranteed" closer ranged engagements. Home defense is another, represented in my PCC reviews mostly. And just like you I LOVE my AR9s and the MAC 5 shown here, really awesome guns...with just a few caveats. But there's no way I would go into bad guy extended-range country with them.

Matt Mann USA

The MP5 is a really great submachine gun if you need to be able to shoot quickly, quietly, and accurately in a CQB situation. It’s not what anybody would choose for general use outdoors. The MP5 has a free-floated barrel (for what that's worth at close-quarters), it has a high cyclic rate of fire at 800-900 RPM, and it’s almost recoil-free. I got to shoot the MP5 on only one occasion in 2001; its sights just don’t really wander around when firing full-auto, so you could effectively hit a badguy in the head with it multiple times from across the room with a controlled full-auto burst. The MP5SD has a ported barrel inside its integral suppressor that slows supersonic bullets down to subsonic speeds, so it can fire quietly using any 9mm ammo from any NATO country – subsonic ammo isn't necessary. A suppressed AR shooting standard 5.56 ammo can’t come close to being as quiet as a suppressed MP5; subsonic 5.56 ammo won't reliably cycle an AR without fine-tuning; and subsonic 5.56 ammo isn't much more effective against badguys than .22 LR. A suppressed AR in .300 Blackout, however, pretty well renders the MP5 obsolete. I think SEAL Team Six probably used the MP5 a lot back in the 80s since they existed specifically for counter-terrorist operations (which before 9/11 generally meant CQB), and Richard Marcinko seemed to be a fan of the platform. I think the other teams probably had MP5s in their armories more for weapons familiarization at the range and less for operational use, but maybe they got some use out of them back in the 80s and 90s too. In the early 2000s, the teams were transitioning from MP5s to the Mk 18. For civilians, non-NFA MP5s don’t have much First Kind Of Cool; you’re either going to have a semi-auto rifle chambered for 9mm or a really large 9mm pistol, and at a high cost. But for Tier 1 SOF doing CQB in the pre-300 BLK days – the MP5 made a lot of sense.

TechNeck

i should have also pointed out. over pen on a boat us a big deal lol. as naval operators this is a huge deal. a 5.56 will pen 3/8 mild steel... thats the hual thickness of a lot of sub 200' boats and .308 will pen 5/8 mild steel . now your talking hual thickness of big boats. a single .308 sized hole will gyser 3 feet and let in hundreds of gallons per hour... lije a single hole will overwhel a puddle pump (garden hose pump) you punch half a dizen holes and you could overwhelm a boats bilge system

Stuart

Millennial here - I don't have a good feel for the available data in the 80's and 90's, but it seems like the thought back then was that the m16/m4 platform was somewhat unreliable and that 5.56 just punched tiny holes into people with no yawing or expansion based on experiences with malnourished tiny Vietnamese men - which may have been valid. With this train of thought, I can see why they may have turned to an MP5 and 9mm to solve these issues. Seals coming out of nowhere raiding enemies with silenced MP5s is just aura farming.

vatoslocos909

Is a M&P shield X review coming? Still debating on purchasing it

Squid556

Close friend was marine recon in the early 80s. The MP5 was an option to them, but it was seen as generally underpowered and redeemed only by full auto fire. The preferred option he mentioned were shortened and suppressed FAL rifles.

Bravo

100%

The Nutnfancy Project

Thanks Matt. Note to add: I'm talking about full-power 5.56 NATO ammunition use here, such as M855, not subsonic loads. A suppressor reduces muzzle blast substantially, but the bullet still generates a supersonic crack. But you gain significant sound reduction without any loss in power. Same way I shoot in TNP. I should have mentioned that specifically in the video. If ultimate quietness back then was the goal then perhaps MP5 made more sense.

Matt Mann USA

Although not about the MP5, this is related to your talking points in the video, and I think you’ll like it. It’s an excerpt from “Secret Commandos: Behind Enemy Lines with the Elite Warriors of SOG” by John L. Plaster (pages 129-131): It was almost dark by the time the Kingbees carried us back to Kontum. No one knew we were landing so the helipad was empty; we walked silently back to our team room. Only there did I notice the tape had been shot off my muzzle. I’d been in my first gunfight. It had all happened too fast to feel fear, and now I’d never felt such exhaustion. It was not until I looked at my dirt-smeared face in a latrine mirror that I noticed Quang’s blood sprayed across my jungle fatigues. I thought about our men’s wounds. An AK slug had torn away a lemon-size chunk of Hai’s thin biceps. Leaving the skin hanging hideously. Quang’s wound was worse. Those visions burned into my mind the deadliness of our calling as no logical explanation could. We’d dodged hundreds, maybe thousands, of AK rounds, and all it took was one bullet to almost kill Quang and to disable Hai for life. I thanked God it hadn’t been me. I threw water on my face, then noticed a man standing there, watching me. “Hi,” he said. “I’m Fred Abt” I turned and saw that he was a lieutenant colonel. He shook my hand and asked, “How’d it go out there, tiger?” He was short, gray-haired with blue-gray eyes that conveyed an almost grandfatherly sincerity. Until that moment, I had no idea our commander, Lieutenant Colonel Bahr, had rotated home and that Abt was our new commander. “Kinda bad, sir. But we got out of it.” He waited for more. I looked in the mirror, critiquing myself. “I ran out of ammo. Never again! Screw carrying a handgun! I need harness space for more magazines and grenades.” “That’s important,” he agreed. “Anything I can do?” “They didn’t hear my Swedish K, sir – the silencer. Unless I actually shot someone, they didn’t even know I was shooting, but when I did shoot this guy, he didn’t stay dead. Nine-millimeter sucks. I need a weapon that when I shoot somebody, they go down, they stay down. Sir, I need a CAR-15.” Abt patted my back. “I’ll see what I can do,” he said, and left… …After our [next morning’s] debrief I was called over to the supply room, where Dave Higgins handed me a CAR-15. Lieutenant Abt had come through. It bore serial number 905442, a number I’ll remember forever, for that weapon served me with perfect loyalty. Dave offered no explanation but I came away suspecting Abt had found it decorating some staff officer’s wall; I cared only that, after five months in recon, I finally had my own CAR-15, a weapon whose bullet generated four times the ballistic lethality of a Swedish K’s 9mm. Handing Higgins my suppressed Swedish K, I swore that I’d never again be seduced by a weapon’s sex appeal. Firearms are tools, I’d come to see, and the more exotic the tool, the more limited its usefulness.