Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Submission format:

- 3 max suggestions per person
- Title of the scenario -> POD

Example:

What if Germany Won WW@ -> POD : dunkirk is a massive disaster

The best suggestions will be selected and put in a youtube community poll where the winner will be made into a video!

Comments

Brandon Gibson

What if the Holy Roman Empire and the Byzantine Empire came together.

smart lucker

What if Greece won the Greco-Turkish War? POD: King Alexander of Greece doesn't get bitten by a monkey

Finnegan

What if Spain colonized America instead of Britain

Tyler Tennis

What if Ronald Reagan was President earlier? POD: wins primaries earlier.

Tyler Tennis

What if sea levels rose/fell drastically in the 20th century? POD: really any time but probably post-WW2

smart lucker

What if England wins the 100 years war? POD: Joan of Arc is killed at the battle of Orleans, leading to an English victory.

Filip Sz.

What if arab conquests failed? POD the Roman-Sassanid war isnt as destructive to both empires, they defeat Caliphs and Islam is contained to Arabian penisula. What if St. Thomas mission to India was much more sucessful? POD: he lives longer and manages to convert local rulers to christianity What if Novogrod Republic defeated Muscovy instead of the other way around? POD: hard to tell one specific, maybe Muscovy doesn't manage to recover after war with Lithuania?

MacKenzie McInnis

What if the Easter Rising Succeeded? POD: German Support is more substantial leading to weapons actually arriving and Irish Republican Leadership is unified behind a single plan. What if the Pig War became an actual war in 1859? POD: Captain Hornby is not sent but instead a less cautious Captain is given orders by Governor Douglas to dislodge American Troops leading to shots fired between the two armies and a declaration of war. What if the Greek Kingdom of Baktria had survived and created a lasting Greek Influence deep in the heart of Asia? POD: The Baktrian Kingdom defeats Mithridates I and remains strong enough to resist northern Nomads and the Chinese Invasion surviving long enough thay Greek Culture become foundational to Afghanistan and Pakistan.

CenterMass45

What if the Kornilov Affair succeeded? POD: Kerensky ousted and Petrograd Soviets smashed.

smart lucker

What if Britain sued for peace after the fall of France? POD: Lord Halifax becomes PM after Chamberlain resigns

Jim Atwood

What if the postwar occupation of Japan was harsher? — No MacArthur, Hirohito displaced? Maybe Olympic goes forward and prompts harsher penalties. What if the US takes longer to join WWII? — No Pearl Harbor or Hitler declaration, Japan goes north against the Soviets instead What if Richard Nixon won in 1960?

DemiGodzillaZ

Well, here’s mines: 1. What if Alexander didn’t stop his military campaign in Asia? POD: Alexander the Great doesn’t listen to his army and continues with his campaign into India and eventually China 2. What if the French and Indian War didn’t happen? POD: George Washington doesn’t accidentally kill a French Patrol. 3. What if Spartacus’s rebellion succeeds? POD: Spartacus and his army escape to freedom rather than turning back to fight the Roman Army.

JosephG

What if the Macedonians never rose to glory? -> POD: Philip II was never born. What if Confucianism never caught on in China? -> POD: Either Confucius never existed or Qin Legalism was more lastingly successful.

Filip Sz.

First one is interesting. He'd either fail quickly or be "accidented" by his own people, but wondering how it would affect his legacy

Spatialex

What if Charlemagne's empire was reunified ? POD: Francis I of France wins the imperial election of 1519.

Spatialex

What if the War on Terror happened earlier ? POD: Bush Sr. takes Bagdad during the Gulf War.

Spatialex

What if Egypt lost the Suez Crisis ? POD: Eisenhower doesn't become president.

DemiGodzillaZ

True, but this one is about if he continues his campaign rather than listening to his army and returning home. I mean, I have to wonder what would happen if he did because would he have reached China and then have to fight the Chinese?

DemiGodzillaZ

Exactly! I am very aware that he already did a video on Alexander but not about what if he continued his campaign.

Jackson Jamieson

What if the Ottomans take Vienna? POD the Ottomans capture Vienna in 1683 and they cement their control over the region. What if the Arabs take Constantinople in 718? POD the rapid expansion of the Umayyad Caliphate manages to conquer Constantinople 700 years before the Ottomans do. What if Harald Hardrara Conquers England? POD William the Conquerer isn’t delayed by weather and crosses earlier meeting Harold Godwinson in battle. The Normans are defeated by the Anglo-Saxons who then rush north to defeat the Vikings (supported by lords in Northumbria) and subsequently are defeated. A new Anglo-Norwegian Empire is built under the Hardrara Dynasty

Zach Martin

What if Benjamin Butler accepted Lincoln's offer to become VP?

Zach Martin

What if FDR was assassinated?

Zach Martin

Sequel to What If the Soviet Union Never Formed

Fake Skyler

What if Hideyoshi won the Imjin War?

Fake Skyler

What if England won the Hundred Years War?

Fake Skyler

What if the English or the Norwegians won in 1066? POD Harald Hardrada survives Stamford Bridge/William dies at Hastings

Ashe

What if the Spartacist Uprising Succeeded? Pod: KPD forms immediately after the start of the great war instead of just weeks before the rising.

Ashe

What if the soviet union won the soviet polish war (1920)? Pod: Warsaw is captured by the red army instead of held

vantachromia

What if Valery Sablin succeeded in his revolt?

vantachromia

What if Eugene Debs became president in 1912?

Ashe

What if the sino-soviet split never happened? Pod: Instead of Khruschev a more stalnist successor succeeds him after his death. (Kaganovich, Molotov, Mikoyan, etc)

vantachromia

What if Carter won a second term?

Mark Simmons

What if Michigan won the Toledo War? POD - Two Stickney kills Deputy Wood and turns the nation against the Ohioan cause

Mark Simmons

What if Islam Came Late? POD - the Prophet is born in AD 770 instead of AD 570

Ashe

This one might actually pair really well with the spartacist one as an additonal domino because the soviet union and spartacist germany may invade from both sides to create a shared border.

lojybtdty

What if Egypt had fallen during the latebronze age collapse, a la Hittite style? POD: Rather vague, but probably failure of Ramesses III to fend off the sea people What if Julius Caesar was killed during his conquest of Gaul? POD: Battle of the Sabis. During the battle, Caesar moved to the front line to boost morale, maybe a slip or a stray missile What if the secret of Greek fire had spread across Europe? POD: When the Bulgarians took Mesembria and Debeltos, they captured siphons and Greek fire, but didn’t have knowledge of how to use it

Ashe

I imagine the entente forcing something similar to brest litovsk onto a communist germany maybe creating a "provisonal german republic" by quickly occupying parts of western germany as a buffer

Mark Simmons

What if Scotland Were an Island? POD - prehistorically, the rift that created the Scottish Lowlands is more active, creating a sea barrier between the already-mountainous Scotland, and England.

Edgar Munoz

What if the business plot succeeded Pod: general butler doesn't snitch to government. What if the German 1848 revolution succeeded? POD: king Frederick William the 4th of Prussia acaccepted the the frankfurt parliament offer to be the emperor of Germany. What if the Russian constitutional crisis ended with the supreme Soviet removing boris yeltsin from the Russian presidency? POD: the pro-parliament protesters succeeded storm the TV station.

CleGuy

What if Reconstruction succeeds? - POD Andrew Johnson is assassinated What if the Soviet Union never falls. POD the August Coup succeeds

Jackson Jamieson

China was in the warring states period actually at this time the Qin hadn’t yet unified China I believe. But logistically crossing the Himalayas and Gobi Desert likely would have halted anything into China which had equally advanced armies

Terrablae

What if the Norman Conquest of England Failed? POD - William I of Normandy and his army is defeated at the Battle of Hastings in 1066 by King Harold and his army.

Finnegan

What if the mongols invaded Japan POD: the tornado just didn’t happen or they missed it

Rwfssqsfc

What if Russia joined Napoleon in 1801? POD- Emperor Paul of Russia isn’t assassinated and continued to form the League of Armed Neutrality against Britain (coalition of neutral nations opposed to Britain’s blockade of North Sea trade)

Tyler Stepharnoff

1. What is Frederick III of Germany hadn’t died of cancer and ruled the German Empire into the 1900’s. POD: Frederick cuts back on his tabacoo intake and doesn’t develope throat cancer in 1888. 2. What if the Japanese Imperials lost the Boshin War and causing the Meji restoration to fail? POD: The Monarchy loses the opening battle of Toba-Fushimi in 1868 allowing the samurai to keep their image and prestige. 3. What if British India remained unified after gaining independence in 1947? POD: Somehow an agreement is reached between the British, Hindus and Muslims to allow the Raj to remain intact after gaining dominion status. (Yeah this one I’m just throwing out there.)

DemiGodzillaZ

Yeah, I could see that. What occur with their journey back home would probably happen here if Alexander didn't obliged the wishes of his army. Then once they face the Chinese, Alexander would probably face his first lost.

Sirloinofice

What if the SDP established a German Socialist Republic after WW1? POD the SDP opposes Burgfriedenspolitik and is outlawed leading to a more radical November Revolution.

Lemon

What if the sassanid Persians stopped the Arabs at the Battle of Nahāvand and instead of losing they defeated them instead and stopped the Islamisation of Zoroastrian persia

Lemon

Though I admit this would probably be to little to late since the sassanids weren't in a great position militarily economically or stability wise even before the Arabs invasion since they'd been stuck in an endless slapping match with the Byzantines

Ben

What if Cody from Alternate History Hub suddenly became world dictator?

Wendy

What if the Soviet Union joined the Axis? POD: The Late 1940 Axis-Soviet talks succeed and the USSR becomes the fourth axis power

smart lucker

He'd be making alternate history on if he weren't world dictator how awful and bland the world would be

Vinny

I like the idea of looking at the other Chinese philosophers of that era, thinking about what those ideologies might have looked like in power.

Vinny

What if the Sexual Revolution happened in the Middle Ages? POD - Roman sylphium never goes extinct.

The FoE Three

What if the Mongol invasion of Japan succeeded. What if the New Union Treaty went through (orther name August Coup never happened)?

Byron Ritchie

-what if ancient Egypt colonised (among other places) and survived in Australia POD during the middle kingdom theological and technological developments allow the Egyptians to expand further culminating in an expedition around the early 18th dynasty which gets blown off course to Australia

Tim Fabregas

What if hurricane Andrew destroyed Miami in 1992. The eye goes over downtown and is way worse than our reality.

Tim Fabregas

What is the January 6 rioters were successful

Tim Fabregas

What if Cuba had a democratic revolution(pick any time between 1963 and now)

Vinny

Like a global warming kicks off early kind of scenario?

smart lucker

Technically no but in a way yes. I want him to go in more detail on how Germany was probably going to lose WWII anyways as Britain would've just redeclared war on Germany when it suited them best

Terrablae

Yes! I didn't see this when I made my suggestion later on but I am absolutely fascinated what Europe and the British Isles would've been like if basically the Norman Conquest Failed.

Terrablae

Scenario 2: What if the Great Depression Never Happened? POD - Hard to pinpoint due to a lot of contributing factors but the most logical main POD is that the Wall Street Crash of 1929 just does not happen. Scenario 3: What if the Airplane was never invented? POD - The Wright Brothers and Santos-Dumont just don't invent the airplane and others stray away from the concept.

Tommy

What if FDR was assassinated

Tommy

What if the American revolution never happened

kamden madan

What if the sack of Constantinople never occured? POD- The 4 crusade is called off before the sackings are able to occur.

Lunar Canadian

1: What if the US never expanded westward after independence? POD: Congress remains content with the lands gained after the Treaty of Paris/Congress or future presidents or the public never push for westward expansion 2: What if Turkey joined World War II? POD: After either Operation Barbarossa or the Fall of Greece, Turkey is strong armed into joining the Allies/Axis (I can see this being a dual scenario exploring either possibility)

Michael O

What if President John Tyler died in a naval gun explosion on the USS Princeton on February 28, 1844? POD: Tyler wasn’t below deck when it happened

The LaughingTree

1. What if FDR never became president-> POD : FDR dies of Polio in 1921 2.What if George Washington was assassinated in 1776→ POD: Thomas Hickey was successful in his plot to assassinated George Washington 3. What if Cody made a sequel to his video about Alexander Hamilton→ POD: Cody makes a sequel to his video about Alexander Hamilton

AlternateHistoryHub

All great picks! I'm not sure how much support any of them will get enough support in the poll, but either way great suggestions!

Filip Sz.

Not sure which one you refer to, but if first one - maybe both battles of Firaz and Yarmouz (if second one would even would happen if Arabs lost the first one) end up in serious defeats for Arabs?

BeaverNation57

1. What if Jeffery Katzenberg stayed with Disney? –> POD : Jeffery Katzenberg is promoted to President of Disney, because Roy Disney [somehow] died in the’80s. 2. What if Japan stayed with the Allies, and especially Britain? –> POD: Japan purchases the pacific islands from the Allies, but allows them to own buildings through a country-owned company and any new buildings must give a cut of its profit and resources to Japan. 3. What if Napoleon III was better, and less like Italy in the World Wars? –> POD: Everyone loved his mustache and goatee so much they let him win every battle.

Terry

1. What if the WWE Collapsed in 1995? -> POD: In the main event of Summerslam 1995, King Mabel breaks Kevin Nash’s spine by sitting on his back. 2. What if Lee Harvey Oswald assassinated Nixon? -> POD: Instead of canceling his visit to Dallas in April of 1963 (shortly after Oswald attempted to kill General Edwin Walker), Nixon goes, only to get shot (as Maria was unable to stop Oswald from leaving the house). 3. What if the Presidency had a three-term limit? -> POD: FDR’s intracerebral hemorrhage occurs in September 1944, before he could attempt to get his fourth term proper, thus in turn changing the creation of the 22nd Amendment.