What are the Odds? 2 (Patreon)
Content
Support Tier Exclusive
The memory of the hotel room was still fresh in James’s mind as he stood before Oliver’s fancy desk. He tried to remain professional, but he could still remember how his boss looked naked and how his cock had felt buried deep inside him. Oliver could clearly remember as well, silently replaying in his mind how James’s body looked naked beneath him and how they had shared such a passionate night that he could still taste the man’s lips.
“So,” James said, forcing out an awkward laugh, “this is weird.”
Oliver leaned back slightly in his chair. “Extremely,” he admitted.
James sighed. “Just to clarify, I had absolutely no idea you were going to be my boss.”
“Don’t worry,” Oliver replied. “I know you didn’t.”
Another silence followed, though this one felt less tense and more painful.
Eventually, Oliver folded his hands together on the desk and cleared his throat. “I think the smartest thing we can do,” he said calmly, “is pretend the weekend never happened.”
James nodded almost too quickly. “Absolutely. Professional behavior only.”
“Good,” Oliver said. “Because you are still fully qualified for this job, and I don’t intend to create unnecessary complications.”
James chuckled and gestured between them. “I think the complications already exist.”
Oliver laughed, and some of the tension in the room eased. “Fair point,” he admitted, and then looked at James more seriously. “Are you sure you can work with me professionally?”
James straightened. “Yeah,” he said firmly. “I can.”
Oliver studied him for a moment before nodding. “Good,” he said. “Then let’s work.”
Somehow, despite everything, they actually managed to do exactly that.
The first couple of weeks turned into a surprisingly smooth routine, which only made things more confusing for both of them. Oliver had fully expected the situation to become a disaster given their previous encounter. He had imagined awkward conversations, constant tension, or James deciding the job was too uncomfortable to keep.
Instead, James walked into the role like he had been born for it. He kept Oliver’s schedule organized to the minute, remembered details from conversations Oliver himself forgot, answered calls before problems could escalate, and somehow stayed calm through the nonstop chaos that followed Oliver every day. By the end of the second week, Oliver had relied on James more than anyone else in the company.
It probably would have been easier if Oliver weren’t also extremely attracted to him.
James moved through the office with stunning grace, usually with his sleeves rolled to his forearms by midday as he carried folders, balanced coffee cups, typed emails at impossible speed, and somehow still found energy to joke with people. Oliver kept watching him without meaning to. When James laughed with someone near the doorway, Oliver’s brain betrayed him with memories of that same laugh against his mouth in the hotel room.
James obviously noticed the staring. One afternoon, he walked into Oliver’s office carrying three folders against his chest and stopped when he saw Oliver looking at him openly.
“You know,” James said, raising an eyebrow, “most bosses try to look less intimidating when they’re accidentally staring at employees.”
Oliver blinked once before leaning back in his chair. I wasn’t staring.”
James looked unconvinced. “Right.”
Oliver smiled and regained composure. “Did you finish the Morrison files already?”
James narrowed his eyes. “Wow,” he said. “Professional deflection. Impressive.”
Oliver laughed and held out his hand for the folders.
The problem was that neither of them seemed capable of fully forgetting what had happened between them. Every once in a while, Oliver would loosen his tie during a stressful meeting or roll his sleeves higher while concentrating on paperwork, and James would remember how those hands had felt against his waist and back. Oliver would lean too close while reviewing documents beside him, and James gasped at the clean scent of his cologne. It made concentrating painfully difficult.
Still, they kept trying to maintain some version of professionalism, at least outwardly, but the tension mostly slipped through in small moments neither of them knew how to control.
One afternoon, James handed Oliver a folder as they prepared for a client meeting, and their fingers brushed against each other. That should have been normal, but instead, both men froze. Oliver’s hand stayed against James’s for a second too long before he pulled away. James turned toward the desk and started reorganizing papers that were already organized.
“You okay there?” Oliver asked, clearly entertained.
James kept his attention locked on the papers. “Fantastic,” he said. “Why wouldn’t I be okay? Completely normal human interaction.”
Oliver laughed at that, enough to make James regret looking up at him.
Another night, they stayed late reviewing contracts while rain poured against the office windows. Most of the building had already emptied, leaving the executive floor unusually quiet except for the distant sound of thunder and the tapping of rain against glass.
James stood beside Oliver’s desk while they reviewed schedules on the same tablet screen. Oliver leaned closer to point at a section near the bottom just as James turned his head to answer him. They ended up way too close, close enough that James could see the faint shadow of stubble along Oliver’s jaw and the tiny green flecks hidden inside his hazel eyes. Oliver’s attention dropped briefly toward James’s mouth.
Neither of them moved immediately, and the silence between them felt heavy and awkward but also dangerously intimate. It was evident that both wanted to close the remaining distance instead of stepping away from it. But it wasn’t the right time or place to move closer.
James stepped back so quickly he nearly hit the desk behind him. “Sorry,” he said.
Oliver cleared his throat and straightened. “You’re fine,” he replied, smiling shyly.
Moments like that kept happening constantly after that: intense eye contact during meetings, accidental touches that lasted a little too long, and awkward silences when they were alone together in Oliver’s office late at night. The more time they spent together, the more obvious it became that pretending the weekend never happened was becoming impossible.
The worst part was that they genuinely liked each other, and not only physically.
James liked Oliver’s dry sense of humor and his calm demeanor during stressful situations. Oliver liked how James could walk into a chaotic room and somehow make everybody calmer within minutes. They worked well together, laughed easily together, and trusted each other far faster than either of them expected. But it only made the tension between them even harder to ignore.
About a month after their night at the hotel, James started feeling like his body had declared war on him. At first, he blamed stress because the workload at Vale Strategic Consulting was intense, Oliver’s schedule was brutal, and James spent most days moving so fast he barely sat down. It felt reasonable to assume his body was finally protesting.
The problem was that it didn’t feel like normal exhaustion because the fatigue was overwhelming in a way James had never experienced before. Every morning, James woke up tired, no matter how much sleep he got. He would drag himself out of bed already feeling heavy and sluggish. By the time he reached the office, he usually wanted another nap, and by noon, it felt like he had already lived through an entire workday.
One morning, he stood in front of the coffee machine staring blankly at it while Oliver walked into the break room.
“You look dead,” Oliver said.
James blinked slowly. “I feel dead,” he replied.
Oliver frowned as James grabbed the counter for balance. “Did you sleep at all?”
“Nine hours,” James said.
“Okay. That’s concerning,” Oliver added.
“You’re concerning,” James replied weakly before shuffling toward his desk.
The fatigue kept getting worse after that. James’s whole body felt strangely sensitive all the time, and even his clothes started bothering him. Tight collars irritated him, strong smells made his stomach twist unexpectedly, and sometimes the office felt too hot even when everyone else seemed comfortable.
Not long after that, the hunger started. James had always eaten a lot because of his build, but suddenly it became ridiculous enough that people openly commented on it. He would finish breakfast and somehow feel starving again less than an hour later. The hunger felt as if his stomach was permanently empty, no matter how much food he shoved into it.
One morning, he finished a breakfast sandwich, two protein bars, yogurt, and a coffee before 9:30. At 10, he was standing in the office kitchen eating crackers straight from the box.
One of the analysts walked in, stopped, and stared at him. “James,” she said carefully, “where is all of that going?”
James looked down at the open cracker box in his hands. “I genuinely don’t know anymore,” he admitted, but didn’t stop eating.
By lunchtime, he was usually hungry enough to become irritable. One afternoon, James spent an entire meeting distracted because he could not stop thinking about strawberries—cold strawberries specifically. The craving hit so suddenly and intensely that his mouth watered while one of the clients talked.
Oliver noticed James staring blankly into space. “You okay?” he asked.
James looked at him with complete seriousness. “I need strawberries,” he said.
Oliver blinked. “What? Right now?”
“Immediately,” James replied firmly.
The client looked confused as James rubbed both hands over his face.
The cravings only became stranger after that. A few days later, James looked ready to fight someone because the cafeteria had run out of grilled cheese sandwiches.
Oliver found him standing in front of the empty tray, looking devastated. “James,” Oliver said slowly, “it’s a sandwich.”
James looked personally betrayed. “They told me they had more ten minutes ago.”
Oliver stared at him for a second before sighing. “Okay,” he said. “Come on.”
Twenty minutes later, Oliver was sitting across from James at a café down the street while James demolished two grilled cheese sandwiches with alarming focus.
Oliver watched him for a moment before asking, “You sure you’re not secretly dying?”
James swallowed another bite. “I hope not.”
The nausea started soon after, and that part scared James more than the hunger because it hit randomly and violently. Certain smells suddenly turned his stomach without warning. Coffee, which he normally loved, became completely unbearable some mornings. Greasy food was dangerous, and strong perfume made him dizzy.
One morning, Oliver walked into the office with breakfast sandwiches, and James immediately went pale.
“Oh, hell no,” James said, pressing a hand over his mouth.
Oliver stopped mid-step. “What?”
James pointed weakly toward the bag. “The eggs are trying to kill me.”
“What does that even mean?” Oliver asked, looking confused.
“I don’t know, but if they come closer, I’m going to throw up,” James said, moving away.
Oliver stared at him in complete disbelief while James hurried toward the bathroom.
After that, Oliver stopped pretending he wasn’t worried. James noticed how Oliver started watching him during meetings, especially whenever James rubbed his abdomen absentmindedly or looked exhausted enough to collapse into his chair. Somehow, snacks started appearing in Oliver’s office every afternoon—protein bars, fruit, crackers, and bottled water. Oliver never mentioned it directly, but James noticed.
The moment that genuinely frightened him happened one morning while he was getting dressed for work. James buttoned his shirt before work and paused—the shirt felt tighter. He frowned and looked down at himself in the mirror. His midsection looked slightly different. There was a faint curve low on his abdomen beneath the fabric.
James pressed a hand against it. “No way,” he said.
At first, he assumed he had gained weight from eating nonstop for weeks, but over the next several days, the shape became harder to ignore. His shirts tightened faster than they should have. His abdomen looked smoother every morning, and the slight rounding never disappeared even after he skipped meals.
People at work started noticing too.
“Damn, Bennett,” joked one of the accountants during lunch while James worked through his second plate of food, “the executive lifestyle is hitting you fast.”
James looked down at the mountain of food in front of him and laughed awkwardly. “In my defense,” he said, “I’ve been hungry for an entire month straight.”
James laughed, but privately, he was starting to panic. Something about it all felt wrong. His body felt heavier every day, and the slight softness around his middle had started becoming strangely firm. And worst of all, all the symptoms kept getting more intense instead of better.
One evening, Oliver found James alone in the conference room after hours, sitting slumped in a chair, with his head resting on the table beside a pile of unfinished paperwork. Oliver stopped in the doorway for a second when James lifted his head. He looked terrible. His face had gone pale from exhaustion, dark circles sat beneath his eyes, and one hand rested absently against his subtle belly as if trying to soothe an ache without even realizing it.
“James,” Oliver said carefully as he walked closer, “you look awful.”
James rubbed his face, trying to sit up straighter. “Thanks,” he said. “Very supportive.”
Normally, Oliver would have laughed, but this time the concern on his face stayed firmly in place. “Okay,” he said, crossing his arms, “we’re done pretending this is stress.”
James sighed heavily and leaned back in the chair. “I’m fine.”
Oliver gave him a look that clearly indicated he did not believe James was fine at all. “You almost fell asleep standing up this afternoon,” he pointed out. “And at lunch, you ate enough food for three people.”
James weakly pointed a finger toward him. “I was hungry.”
“It’s not only that,” Oliver said patiently. “Your shirts are getting tighter every week, you’re exhausted all the time, and yesterday you nearly threw up because you smelled eggs.”
James looked down at his middle without meaning to.
Oliver crouched slightly beside James’s chair so they were more level. “Hey,” he said more gently, “you need to see a doctor.”
“It’s probably just stress or stomach problems or something,” James said, groaning. “I don’t have time to spend all day in a waiting room right now.”
“Then make time,” Oliver replied firmly.
James dropped his hands and looked at him. “I won’t—”
“No,” Oliver interrupted. “I’m not joking anymore. Something is clearly wrong, and you’re getting worse instead of better.”
James opened his mouth to argue again, but Oliver didn’t let him.
“Please,” Oliver said, and those words stopped James, not because of the insistence itself but because of the tone. Oliver looked worried, and somehow that affected James more than being ordered to go to a doctor ever could.
For a few seconds, they looked at each other.
Then James finally sighed and nodded. “Fine,” he said. “I’ll make an appointment.”
Oliver smiled kindly. “Good,” he said softly.
...
********
PS: Plot submitted by a Support-tier member as part of the tier's benefits.