Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

NEW SHOW POLL

  • Fellow Travelers 373
  • PEN15 414
  • Tell Me Lies 447
  • From 188
  • Nobody Wants This 512
  • 2025-01-13
  • —2025-01-16
  • multiple choice
  • 1934 votes
{'title': 'NEW SHOW POLL', 'choices': [{'text': 'Fellow Travelers', 'votes': 373}, {'text': 'PEN15', 'votes': 414}, {'text': 'Tell Me Lies', 'votes': 447}, {'text': 'From', 'votes': 188}, {'text': 'Nobody Wants This', 'votes': 512}], 'closes_at': datetime.datetime(2025, 1, 16, 20, 0, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2025, 1, 13, 1, 21, 52, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': True, 'total_votes': 1934}

Content

Hey guys! This poll is shows to replace Never Have I Ever as we are finishing recording it tomorrow and we need another one to take it's current slot! We picked some shorter shows that we want to watch. Excited to see what you guys pick and as always please keep it respectful in the comments regardless of what is winning!

Comments

brooke

TELL ME LIES PLZZZZ

lulu belle

please do gilmore girls soon

Rhi

MISFITS!

Liv

Tell me lies is so good!

karly

TELL ME LIES🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻

Maddie

Omg I hope it’s Tell Me Lies 🤞🏼

Kara Mautz

TELL ME LIES IM BEGGING

Connor Strain

From is soooo good pleade watch!!!!

valentina

Omg FROM 😍 It’s so so so good

Makayla Brown

Nobody wants this!!! it’s sooo freaking good! Can’t wait for season 2

Sara

PEN15 YALL!!🙏

tia el

fellow travelersss!!! 🙏🙏

Kayley Sims

Nobody Wants This 😭🙏🏼

Jardyn

FELLOW TRAVELERS

Alana

I love when we can choose multiple

Aarron Denton

If from is on a poll I have hope lost could be (if the boys haven’t seen it ofc)

Laney Tapia

this is a hard decision between pen15 and tell me lies…i think i have to go pen15 but both are great

Jazmine Bell

PEN15 please guyssss 🙏🏾🙏🏾🙏🏾🙏🏾🙏🏾

Emely Marie

UGH I CANT CHOOSE 😭😭 I love the last three so much!!! I feel like “FROM” Would be a good show for the boys to react too because it’s a mystery show and has a lot of twists and turns. But tell me lies is sooooo good as well. And then nobody wants this is just the best rom com show of 2024 😭😭😭

Halima

Nobody Wants This because Adam Brody and Kristen Bell obviously

Imani

PEN FIFTEENNNNN

avery

PEN15🙏🙏🙏

dann

Idk any of these but I’m open/excited about watching new things

Invadertif13

Please check out outlander one of these days 🙏🏻 you just might love it

Lizzy deG

I’m actually begging for it to not be pen15 🥴🥴

jaxon lee

pretty little liars!! from producers of tvd

Sali Zellk

it feels like months since I’ve seen a poll about a show I was interested in… and i’m paying the highest tier hoping you guys will somehow go back to doing kdramas or anything that isn’t an american teen drama 😭 still love you guys that’s why I haven’t left and I loved the squid games reaction but yeah sadly none of these seem interesting to me so I will let the others decide what’s best :)

Hannah Bond

Fellow Travelers I beg! It's only 8 episodes and super impactful for the queer community❤️❤️

maple

y’all better vote pen15..

Bel Pop

Man I can’t believe you’re finishing up NHIE. It’s been a wild ride!

Rhi

It’s a sin

candyxo

rfhuirhfurhf From being on this list omg!! It's so good! I hope it will win a poll if not this one!

L

PLEASE PEN15 IT’S SO GENIUS AND RELATABLE AND WOULD MAKE FOR A CRAZY FUNNY REACTION!

L

and if yall don’t know what pen15 is… get hip! seriously it’s the best

Michelle

Pen15 would be so funny😭 if you love cringe funny

Kiana

TELL ME LIES

Laura

nobody wants this pleaseeee

Reagan N. S.

The way I know From won't win but absolutely would be a good one!!

J

dannngg I was really wanting One Tree Hill to make it on the poll

Rose c

I haven't seen any of these but I'm casting my vote for "From". I heard it was really good!

collette

FELLOW TRAVELERS I BEGGG

orangeflavor

I... have never heard of any of these, lol. Oh man.

Cristy

Nobody Wants This is soooo good.

LovleyA

Haven’t seen any of these but I was just about to watch tell me lies like a week ago so I voted for that 🙂

Val

Fellow Travelers for sure

Anna H

For the love of god let it be Nobody Wants This

S

from is top tierrr but I already know it’s not going to win😂

ken

PEN15

Jayla

tell me lies is sooooo goodddd

Shae

TELL ME LIESSSSSSS

Nikki Sonrisa

Fellow Travelers would be great! it’s a love story but also shows important LGBTQ history. also: Jonathan Bailey!! 😍

Rhi

no more american shows! try some British shows

Johnie 💮

PEN15 is actual physical pain for me like I don't even see the humor lmao. Rob would combust. Idk any of the other shows though. Cant wait until I can vote on a show I have seen and enjoyed!

addie

Tell me lies!!

TK

YALL PLEASE VOTE FOR TELL ME LIES. PLEASE I PROMISE ITS SUCH A GOOD SHOW

S

FELLOW TRAVELERS WITH JONNY BAILEY AAAAA

S

Gonna mention Skam Norway in every suggestion so y’all will watch it some day 😭

orangeflavor

Literally had to look each of these up. Meanwhile I'm over here thinking "hmm, wonder if they'd ever watch Person of Interest?" 😂😂 Like girl, the disconnect.

Amanda

From is amazing and scary, the mystery keeps you engaged the whole time.

Savannah

You guys will LOVE tell me lies

💀

TELL ME LIES

orangeflavor

It makes me think I'm getting old, lol. There's a bazillion new 8-episode-style shows out and I'm over here rewatching my Buffy DVDs for the eighteenth time or whatever. 😂

Lana Pico

Nobody wants this!!!!!

Juy Ahmad

Nobody wants this! I need their reactions to this show 💯

capricornmom

haven't been into a show y'all have watched in awhile (no critique on you or anyone!! just personal taste/preference) so reallllyyy pulling for nobody wants this lmao, i think y'all would really like it! but fellow travelers is great as well

Taltal

Try watching Nobody wants this! One season! 10 episodes, short episodes! It’s a romcom/drama

Taltal

Try watching Nobody wants this! It’s one season so far. Short episodes. 10 episodes. RomCom/drama

Ash W

Rooting so hard for Nobody Wants This. It would be a great follow up to NHIE, a break from the various “school-set” shows (much as I love those), AND it’s a super quick watch with a phenomenal and hilarious cast!

Taltal

Right!? Wth. But it is realllyyyyy long, lol. And I feel this channel is more of the early 20’s age range-maybe mid 20’s (No hate!) or just it could be that people don’t like the older/slightly cheesy stuff like we do. 😆🤷🏻‍♀️

Kaylie

Tell Me Lies pls!!

elle

Omg please From it’s so good

Micki

I don't think I've clicked on a poll so quickly before lol. Come on, Nobody Wants This! 🙏🏼

Sali Zellk

haha well I know ppl like teen dramas that’s probably why they do them so much 😅 and I respect that but I know a big part of their early audience came bc of kdramas and the kdrama polls were definetly some of the most intense ones bc ppl were so passionate about their fav kdrama! sadly they completely stopped :/ I think they got some pretty mediocre recommendations for the last few ones they did and they got too bored and wanted to stop (I know it happened to me too when I started watching kdramas that’s why it’s important to give recommendations that would fit their taste and be easier to digest for mid-20s american men 😂). I wish they would get back to doing them even if it’s at a slower pace (like 2 ep a week)

Km

PEN15 is literally so fcking funny but so unbearingly cringe

Sarah

Jewish person here...nobody wants this has been fairly controversial for us. Not particularly interested in watching these guys watch it

Arianna

Noo From is so good and it’s losing so bad 😩

Salma

Tell me lies!!!!!

Makayla Breann

if fellow travelers loses again I stg

Taltal

Everyone, One Tree Hill next please! It’s just so nostalgic. 😅Cheesy but had you feeling all the feels.

Anna Tang

Pen15 is a masterpiece. It has parts that are hard to va watch but they are so funny at the same time!

Anna Tang

There are funny and cringe moments but also heartwarming moments - and it really captures the awkwardness everyone goes through in middle school.

J

LOVE one tree hill! was so wanting it on the poll!

V Baskar

PLEASEEEEE TELL ME LIES

Clo

FROM is one of the best shows out right now. You guys would absolutely adore it.

Taltal

You all!! If you haven’t seen any of these, give Nobody Wants This, a chance! It’s funny and a little serious! Also, there’s only 1 season, 10 episodes I believe!:)

Jenn

Yesss nobody wants this!!

Jenn

I hope yall do Gilmore girls next! Or the sopranos they’re totally different vibes but incredible shows!

L

the details are so perfect and relatable… down to every single character they meet along the way! anna & maya are geniuses it’s so relatable and i don’t think anyone’s done what they did on this show 🙏

Skye

Idk if tell me lies is gonna pull through. It’s probably gonna come in second again.. I hope it wins 😩

alex

please pen15

jaaaaaane

pen15 girlies we gotta band together and vote😭😭😭😭

Emely

PEN15 🤞🏽

Mae

pen15 is going to kill rob with cringe lmao

Emma

Pen15 Omg please just for ONCE let a good more niche show win 😭

Ash 💕

Nothing is better than FROM. It’s an incredible show.

L

i’m saying! it’s been a while since i’ve had a show to watch with them i think it’s been since big little lies or severance honestly not that it’s anyone’s problem but i’m desperate for another show to get excited about 😂😭

Emma

Seriously.. like I know this is a democratic process but my taste has diverged sooo much from the content that gets voted on these days 🥲

Jazz

every time fellow travelers doesn't win a poll an angel loses its wings

-t

tell me lies is the most insane shown please react

becca

FELLOW TRAVELERS IS SO UNDERRATED

becca

i finished nobody wants this in one night its >>>>

Poppy

So sad From isn’t getting the love it deserves

S

arguably the best show in this selection I fear. but it’s alr, not too many people know the show

Ash W

Jewish person here too 🙋🏻‍♀️ Maybe I'm too optimistic, but I loved Nobody Wants This and would assume/hope the guys would handle the immersion into a different cultural world in that show with the same openness they have in other shows. I've recommended this show a lot since it came out in part because I feel like it’s such a positive but nuanced representation of our faith and culture. I definitely get where you’re (probably) coming from, but I think the guys have a good history of being open minded and always trying to stay respectful.

karma!!

pen15 i beg

Bruce Ray

From is so slept on smh

I’m Tired

Nobody Want this IS SO GOOODD!!!!!

Ky

One Tree Hill 😩

Aileenn Chong

wait i thought y’all don’t like the travellers 😭😭

Aileenn Chong

please watch pretty little liars

Apoka

Dang I didn't watch any of those 😭 I just picked randomly

claudia

tell me lies or nobody wants this ughhh please

claudia

one tree hill nextttt

nessa

Still hoping for Maid to make it on a pole one day especially if we’re talking shorter shows

Abyane

I should have known that “FROM” is so underrated that not many people would vote for it

Aya

Maybe one day! I swear nobody is reacting to it.

Aya

I liked nobody wants this but I feel like we’re always watching the same type of romance or like teen drama lately. The vampire diaries, originals, sex lives, never have I ever. I wish everyone would vote for new stuff so we have multiple genres going. From would be so cool and would mix it up.

Abyane

Next time guys do a “underrated show poll“ could be interesting:)

Apoka

I did, cuz I remember pen15 going against Dark at some point

val

yall need to watch series of unfortunate events trust🙏🙏

Sophie Sjösten

Can’t wait for Nobody Wants This! Will be fun rewatching it with you!

Addison Leavitt

Pen15 is in my top 4 favorite shows of all time and I joined patreon just to vote for it 🤭

L

yay! welcome 🤝 need it to win so bad

Trisha Pillay

Fellow travelers being 4th hurts my soul

Brittany Popka

Definitely agree with you on that. So many great shows on Apple that they could react to. Morning show, Platonic, shrinking. So many good ones and they’re also funny and heartwarming like Ted Lasso, which cannot wait for the next season 😍

Anne27x

I’m so sad fellow travelers won’t ever win :( it’s too underrated to win. I’d so hoped you guys would just choose to watch it some day

Ash W

Fwiw, they did also just cover squid games. I also feel like Nobody Wants This is different from all the other more soapy or young adult romance driven shows that have been being covered. There’s a maturity to the characters and more nuance in a lot of the discussions had in that show. It's also a quick watch so there will be opportunity for a genre switch pretty quickly even if it does win.

Aya

I get that. I did enjoy nobody wants this. Its definitely a good watch. But it just always feels like we’re watching so many things that are very similar in style or tone. Like I said TVD, Originals, Sex Lives, and never have I ever all happening at once just gets repetitive. Squid game is one out of how many I just mentioned.

I’m Tired

I’m sure fellow travelers will get watched eventually with how much they love Jonathan Bailey

lenajuli

I will never give up hope for Fellow Travelers...

Bless

Omg they should have added on my block 😭

sandrinegeller

You will love Nobody Wants This! I was so surprised by how good it is!

Amelia

From is so good and so underrated. I watched first season at one day. And I think it would be fun to see reactions from some other genre than „teen” drama

Anne27x

I hope so but I doubt it :( it keeps losing in the polls and they watch what the voters want the most

Hannah Bond

The fact they want to watch it though still gives me hope! Like at least it’s still making the polls! Thats a good sign! We just gotta keep suggesting it in the polls❤️

missdaytona68

i think y’all should give a chance to “from”

Cindy S.

It might not ever win on a poll, but don’t lose hope. A few years ago, I was happily surprised when they announced they would be reacting to Normal People. It had landed on polls, but never won; they still decided to watch it. And while I’m not a fan of The Vampire Diaries, it’s another show that they surprised everyone with (it was never even on a poll because they had always requested 3-4 season show recs). And if a show ever ties (like Yellowjackets and The Summer I Turned Pretty), they just watch both. There are more examples, but you get the gist. And as someone already pointed out, the fact that Fellow Travelers keeps making it onto polls is a good sign because it means the guys are aware of and interested in it.

missdaytona68

i would be so fun to see them watching something different than this teen netflix shows with the same narrative.

candyxo

FROM HIVE STAND UP! Lol I'm hoping it wins a future poll or honestly, they just pick it themselves to watch since they do want to check it out and the reactions would be *chefs kiss*

snallahej

Screaming! Fellow travelers!!! Yes, this show. Limited series, really important topics.

Jada S

fellow travelers is so good!

Sumaya

TELL ME LIES then nobody wants this afterwards!!

David C Witkin

Fellow Travelers! Then Nobody Wants This (It's hysterical!)

Jordyn

Pen15 and then tell me lies there both amazing shows but different

Jessica

Hoping that Rivals can make it onto the next poll 🙏

arkilla

Yall have no taste, FROM is crazy good

Anne

Fellow travelers is amazing with VERY important topics but I am also not gonna watch someone else watch it 😅

Aisha Abdi

i feel like from would be the perfect show to watch rn since its different from what yall usually watch. id love to see the theories and u can never go wrong with the horror/thriller genre

Sami

It’s relatable for a lot of the audience since it’s coming of age

jay milly

This would LOVE Pen15

Sylvia Johnson

If Tell me Lies doesn’t win can you guys still watch it after whatever show wins because it’s so good !!!!

Bruce Ray

From being last is so disrespectful honestly...

Brooke P

Fellow Travelers!!!

tia el

i sooo so hope they decide to watch it one day - what an incredible show i'd love to see their reactions!!

tia el

fellow travelers i will never give up on youu 🙏

Katelyn Diaz

FELLOW TRAVELERS MY SHAYLA SOO GOOOOOOD AND UNDERRATED

Beth Reeves

yall would love pen15 so much and its only 2 seasons

Camila Miranda

i hope on the next poll, From is there

Misty R

Tell Me Lies, pretty please! 😉

Sarah

I don't doubt they'd be open minded and respectful! More so I actually don't see the show as a particularly positive representation of Jewish women specifically

Tabitha V

The fact that tell me lies will probably get second place again hurts me a little 🥲 lol

Grace Porter

please watch tell me lies at some point. I NEED UR REACTION

Caroline Zera

You really can’t go wrong with Tell Me Lies or Nobody Wants This. They’re both so good in their own way

maiya

PEN15 PEN15 PEN15 PEN15 PEN15

jenna wallace

pls watch beef its on netflix a24 and one season short watch

lauren

bro pleeease pen15 😭

temi alaka

EVERYONE VOTE TELL ME LIES

BexFangirl

Hope Fellow Travelers wins one day

Cindy S.

@Taylor you can always change your vote (and also cast your vote for multiple shows).

Nabs.shani

wait why cant i vote?

Lana Pico

I been wanting to Nobody Wants this again... excited to do it with you guys!

Brittany Popka

Is that on amazon prime? I love Jonathan Bailey so much so I definitely want to watch it!

Britney Norton

I just this Patreon just so I could vote for Tell Me Lies. Your guys jaws will be on the floor!!

Savannah

I feel like they’ll probably do both since nobody wants this is so short

a!

tell me lies losing who has it worse than me

a!

since nobody wants this is only 10 episodes if it wins pls watch tell me lies too i beg 🙏🙏

becca

fellow travelers you will get your justice one day

L

yall boys think pen15 will potentially have it’s time at some point this year even if it doesn’t win this poll or next? 🥺🤲 i just need a glimmer of hope 😂

Clo

Pls include FROM in future polls I beg of you 😞

rebecca

i need them to watch Rivals on disney+ one day. looooved that show

Salma

I guess tell me lies won’t win this round but i have faith it will on the next one. I’m okay with nobody wants this

Karina

FROM is last??? Some of you haven't seen it and it shows. You guys are missing out!!!

Clo

One of these days we’ll get a reaction 😭😓😂

Becca Elizabeth

I know you guys aren’t asking for a new movie to watch right now, but a super good suggestion is My sisters Keeper and Damsel. They are great movies!

Ash W

Y'know, I totally get this. I did feel like they got more depth and more positive qualities as the show went on but that is an area I'm really hoping to see more improvement with in s2. I'm also holding out eternal hope to someday get some representation of non-affluent Jews.

Carley

I want to request the show Nancy Drew, but I feel like no one has seen it or knows about it, or maybe everyone else hates it 😅 but I thought it was so fun and really good, I loved it! I also love Nancy Drew computer games so the show being dark and mysterious like some of the games was the best, kept me hooked all season. I doubt y’all would do a show that no one else has done reactions to, but it could be great 👀😂🙏