Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

It's time, as we like to do every year, to look back at the predictions we made in December of 2020 and see how accurate we were.  Who was right? Who was wrong? And most importantly, who scored the most points?

Files

Comments

Peter Mancini

OK, listened to this short, sweet episode and I have some comments. For those that don't know, I was the one at Victory Points who came up with the game theory of this point system, with great development by Craig, Russ, and Hollywood.

Peter Mancini

Here are the observations. 1. I love how you all run it. I almost don't want to make it efficient because I greatly enjoy the funny arguments you run into. That said - we must address ambiguity. Rafe plays the game as intended. His predictions are very digital. Craig, being a writer, goes perhaps a bit too deep into the weeds on his predictions but that makes it funny. Russ, the master of ambiguity, puts in things like "they will create a website or a system"... ok, what is it. A website or a system? It is the players responsibility to catch these weak, non-digital like components of predictions. In such cases it is the players opportunity to demand more specificity. You should also make sure you have a clear method for falsification of the prediction. In fact, you can posit what they are even if it isn't your prediction. Consensus rules. This is just a note on procedure. In the case of major assumptions being thrown out in the preceding year, the group should either narrow the prediction to be more specific, or make it broader, to see if the prediction can be evaluated. So a prediction about a company that goes bankrupt can still possibly be evaluated if you know where the IP ends up, or narrow it to the IP specifically as it will still exist since it is capital. With predictions that depend upon a certain thing happening, with the prediction being the result, and that event has not yet happened, then I suggest either nullifying the prediction with no points won or lost, OR allow a revote with double points when the event has happened. This could be a prediction that lasts for years, contingent upon the result, and could have a dramatic impact on a future game! That said, its ok to simply nullify the prediction if this isn't desire. I am on the fence as to what is the best part of this episode. A) is it the winning and losing and the predictions, or, B) the ensuing arguments which are hilarious? I am 100% behind Patrons getting a poll to vote for or against prediction to see how we at home do. I'm 100% behind Patrons making their own predictions in the comments section of the Predictions podcast.

Peter Mancini

and yes, I gave up numbering after 1.