Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

I stand by what I said: record labels are parasites that actively prevent art from happening.But—the worst they'll do is a takedown, which is functionally my song blooping out of existence. It'll be a polite letter from Distrokid, informing me that I did too well. But record companies, to quote a redditor, want a piece of the pie, not to burn down the bakery.If the song does well enough that they notice me, well, that's a good problem to have. By that point, I've already achieved exposure, and unless my version eclipses the original (for example, are you aware who originally wrote Hurt? bc It wasn't Johnny Cash), nobody cares, and if my song actually eclipsed the original, they're going to want to make a deal, not take me to court.Yeah, so it really comes down to paying a $12 cover license and letting what happens, happen. I, personally, feel that this song is a cover; I can't imagine anybody hearing it and not immediately recognizing it as a cover of Noah Kahan's Stick Season with a potentially derivitive chorus, but on a scale of a Caleb Hyles cover to a Reinary cover, I think I'm closer to Caleb Hyles—its a massive switch in instrumentation and genre, but I didn't change the lyrics, structure, or key (if I did, I can't remember, but it wouldn't be like a minor key to a major key). Probably the biggest change is a mid-song tempo-shift, which might be a bit brilliant on my part, if I do say so, myself.All that out of the way, I'm a neurotic creature, and I desperately need everybody to be honest with me when y'all hear it—did I cover the song or did I reinvent it

Comments

Celes ~{ 🍪🖤🐈 }~

It sounds like you covered it. Like you said, the worst that happens is the song is pulled.

AsaSpades{🍪🖤🐈}

Is it a Patreon exclusive thing or will you upload it to YouTube aswell? I know someone who loves the original and I would definitely send it to them if its on YouTube.

Charli Morgan

right? like, it gets a takedown if it gets big but not HUGE. if it gets huge, they'll probably help promote me which is 🤮 but also I won't say no to free advertising. dont worry; it'll be a cold day in hell before I ever sign my name away to some corpo fuck, chooms

Charli Morgan

so, it kind of has to be a spotify/youtubemusic/streaming "exclusive" because legal. So they don't get money from streams if I distribute here, and if I "sync" it with video, that is an entirely separate kind of license. that is what I am legally required to say.

AsaSpades{🍪🖤🐈}

Ok cool I can send them the Spotify link too. So that works out, very excited for it.

Charli Morgan

I love this song and I really think I did it justice. the ending needs work but the first 2 minutes are absolutely solid. idk. I just sick of my broke hand so I recorded vocals last night, did left handed stuff with keyboard, uhhh yeah idk. I'm jsut fucking bored not being able to work. I LOVE my work and it hurts that I can't do more than a few minutes before my left hand triggers the ADHD and I have to stop. I want to do more but I can't right now. 😭

AsaSpades{🍪🖤🐈}

Its a beautiful song, and I can't wait to hear what you've done with it, I know its going to be amazing. Sorry to hear about the hand, but I just think about all the amazing things your going to be making once its healed, we'll be here waiting excitedly for them 😊💚

A

I’ll make sure I listen to the original first to give it an honest appraisal.

A

When you said it’s “Vermont” you weren’t kidding eh. Looking forward to your take on it!

RitalinGamer

I haven't listened to the song yet; I just want you to know I could feel myself age when I realized I knew the NiN version originally.

Seph[🍪🖤🐈]

Your feelings on record labels are 1000% valid. Capitalism hates art and strangles artists. I’ll have to go give stick season a listen.

Charli Morgan

I just like I just want to publish my song you know? like fuck the labels so much.