Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

  • Upstream-Gabriel_Rockhill.mp3

Some files exceed the archive size limit and weren't saved: 1 file. Please note these limits are in place to keep this site running long term, without costing a fortune. You can favorite the creator though, certain milestones increase the limit.

Content

This is a publicly available episode—we post all of our episodes (both public and Patreon) on the Patreon feed here for those who like to have all of our content in the same place.

In this episode we're joined by Gabriel Rockhill to discuss his new book, Who Paid the Pipers of Western Marxism, which takes a fascinating dive into the world of anticommunist Marxism and the role that the CIA and other nefarious imperialist forces play in dividing and neutralizing the left. Gabriel Rockhill is a philosopher, cultural critic, and activist teaching Philosophy and Global Interdisciplinary Studies at Villanova University and he runs an educational nonprofit called the Critical Theory Workshop. He is the editor of multiple books, including Western Marxism: How it was Born, How it Died, How it can be Reborn, by the Italian Marxist Domenico Losurdo. 

The conversation opens with an overview of Who Paid the Pipers of Western Marxism, orienting us towards Gabriel's analysis of bourgeois intellectual production and its role in perpetuating anticommunism among the left. We then bring in the Epstein files and discuss their relevance to our conversation before exploring what led to Gabriel writing about the intellectual world war and the process of putting this book together itself. 

We then introduce the idea of intellectual warfare and the role that the intellectual world war plays in shaping our ideologies in the most insidious and pervasive ways. We explore why the US empire must control our minds in such a way in order to maintain its hegemony, and what this looks like in practice. Gabriel then tells us about the political economy of knowledge production and the role of the imperial professional-managerial class plays in intellectual production. 

We then discuss real world examples of how the compatible left was used by the financial-state-intellectual complex in its global war against communism—from the Frankfurt School to Noam Chomsky and beyond. We end with a commemoration of a left figure who embodies the opposite of the compatible, anticommunist left: Michael Parenti. 

Further resources:

Related episodes:

Intermission music: "Song for Alicia" by Haley Heynderickx and Max García Conover

For more from Upstream, visit www.upstreampodcast.org and follow us on Instagram and Bluesky. You can also subscribe to us on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you listen to your favorite podcasts.

Files

Comments

Nick

I have been WAITING for this lfg

Tom Servo

My tbr list is never going to recover from this podcast.

Saralia

Truly. I have added so many 😅

Brenda Bancroft

You may or may not know this but will Gabriel be releasing this book in audio format?

Ci Davis

Amazing discussion which I will respond to at the end. But I’ve just listened to the interlude song and what a great band - loved the choice and how well did that fit this conjuncture ❤️🇵🇸🇻🇪🎸

Elaina Martinelli

Nothing but an amen and gratitude from me. The Einstein/Chomsky comparison squeezed into the end was 👩🏻‍🍳💋🤌🏻. Would also like to uplift, echo, and point a blinking neon arrow to the gratitude Gabriel expresses for the work you do on this podcast, Della and Robbie! 🥰

JAK

Thank you for your national series. The enlightening conversations you are assembling on Venezuela are most helpful for providing a historical context for understanding US military action, providing understanding of sanctions as collective punishment and as external interference to turn a population against its government (also in your series on Iran). Brilliant work.

Upstream

thank you for the kind words!

Upstream

that whole album is incredible! Glad to hear it spoke to you

Upstream

I am unfortunately not sure but will make sure to ask him next time we are in conversation

CollectiveCreation

Wow. Another mind expanding episode of positive disillusionment for me. I’m very familiar with Chomsky’s “if the US could just live up to its ideals “handwringing “ and missing calls to action. So much has been hidden in plain sight from my best attempts to educate myself. Epstein and Palestine are like barium enemas pinpointing the cancer in the imperial digestive tract. Similarly, Seth Harp’s book The Ft Bragg Cartel shows how elites destroy lives and global possibilities on our dime.

Lukas Hruska

Really amazing episode - always love to hear Rockhills insights. And I need to read this book. I want to push back on some Chomsky stuff for three reasons: 1. The truth is important 2. Chomsky was and still is a force for good in the world (although certainly not perfect, and not as “good” as Parenti if that could be quantified) 3. I feel a personal debt of gratitude to Chomsky for setting me on the path of anti capitalism So on to the charges levied against Chomsky this episode: A. His writing and speaking is not as clear as parenti. As someone who’s read both I just want to push back and say that they are equally clear. Chomsky is not like the Frankfurt school authors in writing obscurely. He is renowned for his clear speaking and writing style, which I understood as attempting universal appeal. B. Parenti came from working class background and Chomsky did not. In fact, both were children of working class immigrants. Although I agree with the broader point that Parenti had to work harder than Chomsky for less success. I suppose Chomskys father being a teacher and parentis father being illiterate made parentis journey more inspiring and difficult and impressive, but I felt the argument overall was weaker than the main points, since I don’t think Chomsky was born with a silver spoon either. C. Chomsky as celebrity or media darling. This is not at all how I remember Chomsky. I always thought any celebrity status of Chomsky was due to grassroots support and the admiration of students, but maybe I’m wrong. He was never allowed on capitalist media (tv newspapers radio). So the capitalist class hardly considered him “compatible” or “accommodating” so they silenced and marginalized him as much as possible. D. Chomsky as capitalist accommodationist. Hard to square this with Chomskys book “consequences of capitalism” where he says capitalism is destroying the planet and causing war all over the world and destroying democracy everywhere it goes. I definitely agree with Rockhills main point that imperialists/capitalists benefit from Chomskys less savory positions. And that if there must be a left, it had to be “compatible”. That all checks out. E. Chomsky doesn’t support BDS. This is not entirely true. https://chomsky.info/20140811/ he basically supported BDS but recognized some issues with the BDS movement. Nevertheless - a Chomsky quote “I was strongly supportive of it [BDS]… they’re the right tactics”. Next I want to talk about the biggest Chomsky critique that even I cannot defend, and which I think everyone should focus more on rather than the more dubious claims above. And that critique is basically his IDEALISM (as opposed to a material dialectical understanding). This idealism leads him to strange conclusions that ignore reality in several places - a. His insistence that right wing fascist media deserve free speech one day after the revolution, ignoring the reality of fascists attempting to destroy the budding socialist countries (Cuba and Venezuela). b. His insistence that all states are (equally) evil, ignoring the reality that some states are far worse than others. (See his stance on Soviet Union vs USA or his stance on Syria - his support for overthrowing the “dictator” only for Israel to gain control of the territory or his stance on Venezuela [truly abhorrent especially in light of recent events]). c. His inability to give a solution to the problems in the world. There’s a kind of magic in idealism where if enough people know about the problems, the solution will magically appear and that’s simply not the case. This obviously ignores the reality of Marxism Leninism that provides the solutions to the world’s problems caused primarily by capitalism/imperialism. So in conclusion, the major critique of Chomsky is simply that he’s not ML. I am not of the belief that Chomsky is “poisoning the well”. Contrary to the general tener of this conversation, I see Chomsky as a more positive than negative figure on the left. Rather than use a “poisoning of the well” metaphor, I prefer a “stepping stone” metaphor. As in one could “step” from Chomsky to Marxist-Leninism/Parenti much easier (as evidenced also by the fact that rockhill, Robbie, and I all started with Chomsky and ended where we are today on ML). If Chomsky is in fact poisoning the well of communism he’s doing a bad job. Another point on this is that it’s way easier talking to an anarchist / chomskyist than with an average right winger / liberal. People who like Chomsky are at least anti war, anti capitalist, pro working class, and share with MLs a common enemy (billionaires and corporations). Last, the issues with Chomsky are so glaring and obvious and silly with regard to his idealism. That creates such a juicy opportunity for MLs to persuade chomskyists on HOW to get to a livable future and expand the movement. With regard to the elephant in the room (Epstein), there’s no real defense for someone that creates a relationship with such a monster. With that said I just want to bring up a few points that many are sweeping under the rug a lot - I. Epstein surely sought out Chomsky to ensnare him. IMO due to Chomsky criticisms of Israel and calling for things like arms embargo. II. There’s no evidence of Chomsky being a pedophile or tied to the cia or mossad. There is a lot of evidence to suggest the cia or mossad wanting to compromise Chomsky. III. We are only reading what the state department releases, aka what they want us to read. Of course if there are incriminating emails involving Epstein and Chomsky those will be released non-redacted. The goal of the right wing is to divide the left. The goal of the Trump administration is to distract us from our main goals. Anyways, sorry to ramble. I love upstream, it’s my favorite podcast. Great episode. Very thought provoking. 🤩🤩🤩

Upstream

"like barium enemas pinpointing the cancer in the imperial digestive tract" — now that's a sentence!!

Upstream

Thank you so much for this Lukas! I really appreciate you presenting these counterpoints here and I hope that folks who come across this comment can weight them against the claims made in the episode.

Lukas Hruska

Ah yes I feel the dialectics at work. Thank you 🫡 keep up the amazing content

MV Perry

The book is great and also very readable 👍

Sam F

I just bought this book, and the store had two full shelves of Chomsky and only a single book from Parenti in their Left Studies section... Discussion was great; looking forward to the read

Upstream

Wow. Good catch. and thank you, glad you enjoyed the discussion!