Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

  • Upstream-Gregg_Castro.mp3

Some files exceed the archive size limit and weren't saved: 1 file. Please note these limits are in place to keep this site running long term, without costing a fortune. You can favorite the creator though, certain milestones increase the limit.

Content

This is a publicly available episode—we post all of our episodes (both public and Patreon) on the Patreon feed here for those who like to have all of our content in the same place.

The hyper-individual, anti-collectivist ideology that defines and permeates Western societies has profound consequences in multiple realms, from mental health to ecological health to economic health—it's a way of living and thinking that has stained our society from the start.

No one knows this more than those individuals and cultures who have, for thousands of years, practiced life in a different way. And among those are many Indigenous cultures and nations which have prioritized a way of life that emphasizes the collective over the individual—not erasing the individual, but weaving the individual back into the fabric of society and the web of life. 

One of the defining questions of our time is this: how can we learn from Indigenous wisdom to reimagine the world? How can we reimagine the scarcity, competition, and hoarding that defines Western society and replace these values with reciprocity, interconnectedness, and gratitude? And how does connecting with the natural world help us as we reimagine?

This is the question asked in the latest book by Robin Wall Kimmerer: The Serviceberry: Abundance and Reciprocity in the Natural World. And we've brought on a terrific guest to help us unpack Robin's book and share their own wisdom and experience in relation to it. 

Gregg Castro is the Culture Director for the Association of Ramaytush Ohlone and a writer and activist within the California Indigenous community focusing on issues regarding cultural preservation, protection, education and traditional practices. 

In this conversation, Della and Gregg talk about their insights and takeaways from The Serviceberry while sharing about their own experiences. Gregg tells us about his childhood growing up in the South San Francisco Bay Area—a region once known for its vast orchards—and talks about how the natural world and the traditional wisdom of his ancestors has shaped his life and his values. They talk about key takeaways from the Indigenous practices and principles of the potlatch, the honorable harvest, and seven generation thinking. And finally, they explore how we can all unplug, unwind, and contribute to a more just and beautiful world based on the lessons of nature and Indigenous wisdom.

Further Resources

Related Episodes:

Intermission music: "Tsitsutsa Tsigesv (When I was a Boy)" by Agalisiga

Artwork: John Burgoyne

For more from Upstream, visit www.upstreampodcast.org and follow us on Twitter, Instagram, Facebook, and Bluesky. You can also subscribe to us on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you listen to your favorite podcasts.

Files

Comments

Glen Real

Thank you for sharing such a meaningful conversation. You guys are knocking it out of the park ☺️

Chelsey

Love this so much. Thank you so much for sharing such heartfelt wisdom. So grateful. We all need these reminders everyday ❤️

Upstream

thank you Chelsey, glad it resonated! ♥️

Ci Davis

I really loved this, though I have the last 30 minutes to listen to. It has been running through my mind since and I loved the book. I found it so interesting that you guys presented this because it sits apart from a lot of the anti imperialist and Marxist presentations, but in a good way. What I have been thinking of that Indigenous wisdom and epistemologies and cosmologies are often seen as in contradiction to dialectical and historical materialist analysis. I am wondering if that has to be the case and how to reconcile a Pluriverse with Marxist ways of thinking. I wonder if that presented an interesting to question to you as you were producing this episode. I’m off to finish it now and thanks for this ❤️💚🙏🏽

Liz Mooney

Earlier this year, I finally read Jason Hickel’s Less Is More, and I basically believe it is essential reading for every human and have made a point of recommending it whenever I can. The way it succinctly and accessibly weaves together so many of the ideas that came up in this conversation and shines a light on our interconnectedness with all living things and how we can still make ecological, economical, and spiritual (for lack of a better word) changes that will usher in a new era that eschews the scarcity myth and allows us to thrive in the world of abundance that already exists, has resonated so deeply with me and has given me hope for the future in a way that I never was able to tap into before. So for anyone who hasn’t already read it, and enjoyed this conversation, I highly recommend it in addition to the books discussed in this episode.

Rames

Thank for this episode. It’s very positive during these chaotic times. We are not alone, respect all life, and stay grounded are my takeaways. I’m listening to all episodes in the archives and finished Everyday Utopia and Radical Imagination with Kristen Ghodsee right before this one. There are so many parallels and hope to build on. Appreciate your work 🫡

Upstream

thank you so much for the kind words and I'm really glad to hear you enjoyed the episode (and hopefully the last 30 minutes as well!). I'm very curious to hear from you specifically what parts of Gregg's worldview or analysis stand in contradiction with Marxism? I can certainly respect that there are very different focuses and perhaps even some elements that would need to be reconciled, but I'm not sure I see any glaring incompatibility so I'm very curious to know more about where your question is coming from

Upstream

thank you so much Liz! You put it so well and yes, I can definitely see how Jason's work is very much aligned with the ideas in this episode. There can often be very mechanical approach by certain thinkers so it's very refreshing to get that spiritual and ecological balance in there, like you suggested

Upstream

Very happy to hear that this episode and some of our past episodes of helped with that positivity and grounding, which seems so important in such tumultuous times ♥️

Ci Davis

I finished the episode 😀. You have asked a number of questions and suggested things that I did not intend to claim. My position is trying to understand how we develop a strategy to change this clearly collapsing global economy and to move towards a future that is based around equity and the meeting of human needs. The Western left have conceded so much ground in the last 45 years, which is why we have an environmental catastrophe, military hyper imperialism, and worsening injustice across the planet that has slowed a genocide to play out in front of our eyes. With that context how does revolutionary change come about? The Marxist analysis I think is the most rigorous attempt, through the understanding of dialectics, to present credible ways forward. However, have you ever been to a communist meeting in which issues such as gratitude, enoughness, reciprocity, our spiritual connection to each other and to all the non human and more than human world. Indeed my understanding is that scientific Marxism is grounded in the enlightenment and dualist thinking. That is in contrast with pluriversal ways of being and knowing. I don’t say that there odd a glaring incompatibility, indeed I suggested they should be reconcilable, but from the current left position I don’t see much willingness to move in the direction that Gregg discusses. I see it from indigenous communities, for example Vandana Shiva or Chico Mendes, or the communities in the Ecuadorean Amazon, but rarely in those western let groups who discus the usual topics of this platform. I want to be able to find ways to bring Marxism and the Pluriverse together, without resorting to individual change (idealism) or incrementalism or finding communicative strategies (such as creative disruption) that de-emphasise the need for revolutionary consciousness and strategy. The fact that you had this discussion I think is important but IMO so is the question that I raised as I think the left need to connect beyond the scientific inquiry of the enlightenment and therefore connections to these indigenous ways of thinking becomes essential if we are to avoid the economic catastrophe that greed and technological optimism is leading to.

Upstream

Thanks so much for clarifying, I couldn't agree more with so much of this! totally, there's definitely not a focus on the more spiritual or emotional aspects of life when it comes to much of Marxist analysis, and I think that that isn't exactly the point of the Marxist analysis. Like you say, I think Marxism-Leninism, as it is a science, doesn't really dive into those topics traditionally (although early marx certainly did). I do think there is room however for those elements to be brought in, and not that I'm suggesting you are saying this but just to underscore that I don't think there's an incompatibility there. I think Breht O'Shea's vision of spirituality and Marxism is actually really inspiring, and I think that a lot of Marxists could take a lot from opening themselves up to that side of the world more because Marxism-Leninism alone, despite being an excellent tool for revolution, again, doesn't focus at all on that. and yet I think at the same time a balance needs to be met because a lot of of the groups that focus entirely on the touchy feely stuff (which is good!) can get lost in that and never really get to a point where they're looking outwards, you know? like you say, it's a delicate balance trying to weave these two components together in a way that is effective and also doesn't lose sight of the revolutionary goals. Just curious if you've heard our episode on Marxism and Buddhism with Breht? It might help answer or at least grapple with some of these questions. But I love this topic and I think there's definitely a lot of room for us to explore this more! thank you for starting this excellent discussion