Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

  • Upstream-Inventing_Reality.mp3

Some files exceed the archive size limit and weren't saved: 1 file. Please note these limits are in place to keep this site running long term, without costing a fortune. You can favorite the creator though, certain milestones increase the limit.

Content

In this episode of our reading series, Robbie reads and provides real-time analysis of the opening chapter of the classic book, Inventing Reality: The Politics of the Mass Media by Michael Parenti. The text explores the role that the media play in capitalism using a materialist, Marxist-Leninist analysis. 

The reading begins with Robbie comparing and contrasting Inventing Reality with the better-known book on a similar topic, Noam Chomsky and Edward S. Herman's Manufacturing Consent: The Political Economy of the Mass Media. Robbie highlights the main antagonisms between Chomsky and Parenti in their approach to this topic and explores why these antagonisms exist. 

Robbie then dives into Inventing Reality, providing real-time analysis and commentary throughout. He presents Parenti's thesis and introduction to the content of the book before getting into some examples of how the media function under capitalism. Robbie uses the example of Skydance Media's merger with Paramount Global and the impact this had on CBS news and editorial coverage to explain Parenti's thesis on right-wing bias in the media. 

The text explores how the mainstream media covers race, gender, and class, and how this coverage is a result of the class position of those who own and control the media. This also explains why the mainstream media rarely if ever explore the structural causes of many of the issues they report on in society. Parenti explores the conservative nature of mainstream media through a variety examples, including coverage of candidates for political office. Robbie reads Parenti's analysis and then applies it to our current time, connecting the dots from the 1980s and 1990s when Parenti was writing the book to the present.

Robbie takes the example of skewed coverage of third-party candidates during elections to again parse out the differences between Inventing Reality and Manufacturing Consent, introducing Chomsky's concept of "structural filters" and contrasting it with Parenti's emphasis on property relations and class-struggle.

The reading ends with an exploration of how the media set the parameters around what is acceptable and not acceptable to discuss publicly—framing the limits of allowable discourse in a way that does not require them to always be controlling our minds in an Orwellian sense. Parenti argues that it's often much easier and more effective for our ruling class to  set the ideological tone and issue agenda with a much more insidious, subtle form of control than the nakedly brutish tactics of overt oppression. 

Further resources:

Related episodes:

For more from Upstream, visit www.upstreampodcast.org and follow us on Twitter, Instagram, Facebook, and Bluesky. You can also subscribe to us on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you listen to your favorite podcasts.

Files

Comments

Beast Law

I really wish I read inventing reality before manufacturing consent

Upstream

a sentiment echoed by many of us

Upstream

right? we can even bet on what words Trump will use in his speeches! his speechwriter was too 🙃

Kevin Wahl

Great episode. At around 1:15 when you starting talking about politics as a game/reality show of idolatry, I was immediately reminded of the book, “Amusing Ourselves to Death: Public Discourse in the Age of Show Business.” If you haven’t read that book, I highly recommend it. Probably my favorite non-fiction book about how American society has changed from a knowledge-based, typography/literacy populace into an entertainment medium with the rise of television. It was published in 1985 and just paints a picture of everything happening in our country currently. It even refers to news reporters as “Talking hairdos,” one of my favorite lines from the book.

Upstream

just added it to my list! thanks for the recommendation and glad you enjoyed the reading! 🫡🙏

Michael

So excited for this. Inventing Reality is one of the most significant and influential books I’ve read over the past few years so I’m really glad you chose this for a reading. Something everyone needs to read!

Fionn Ó Loingsigh

Thanks for this. Very hard to find copies for sale online, the few I've come by are really expensive. Have you got any recommendations on where to look? Cheers

Upstream

agree, such an important book! hope you enjoy the reading

Upstream

I believe I got mine on amazon through "Mary's Family Business" in 2023 for $19.80. it's now $44.99 from the same seller

Fionn Ó Loingsigh

Thanks. Would obviously rather boycott amazon but if it's the only option

Upstream

I don't think it is! Lulu Publishing seems to have em at $24.46 a pop

Lana

Great episode. Robbie, your speaking cadence is so good for audiobook readings! I nominate Robbie to make an audiobook version of this text! 😁

George Eakin

I have to push back on the use of the fish and water analogy. It is such a common analogy to say we don’t always recognize the very medium in which we exist. True enough. But saying fish do not know what water is, well, that is just blatantly false. Fish are masters of water, the ways they swim are beautifully in sync with currents, many even break the surface leaping into the air, or how they can swim against powerful currents. They know water with their very being. I realize this is a tangent, but dammit, someone has to speak up for the fish. Their intelligence is under appreciated by us mere humans. 🐠

Sara Way

I'm a DSA member who was on the campaign committee for our Democratic Socialist candidate for a state senate campaign in Utah and it was one of the most formative experiences for our chapter as a framework for organizing, building confidence talking about socialism with our neighbors (knocking on over 20,000 doors and gathering 2,000 signatures to get our candidates name on the ballot), developing members into leaders, and creating consistent membership engagement in the chapter. We were all very clear on our goal with the campaign to be about growing a socialist movement in Utah and I'm seeing a lot of chapters doing the same, found it interesting that you didn't mention DSA at the 1:21 mark, and I remember feeling like the episode "250 Years of Bourgeois Democracy w/ August Nimtz" also took the name "Democratic Socialists" to heart as to the motivations for participating in electoral campaigns. I love all the content put out by Upstream but am surprised to see what feels like a lack of curiosity, especially for what is happening in DSA outside of California and New York. Really enjoyed this episode.

Upstream

haha thank you!! i love reading out loud honestly, as you might probably know already from how many passages I read back to the author in interviews 😂

Upstream

Totally valid point!! thank you for speaking for the fish. you are like a Lorax for them 🙏

Upstream

very true that I am not as aware of the activities of DSA as say, PSL. But thank you for educating me on the incredible work that you all are doing out in Utah! shout out to DSA in Utah ✊

Sara Way

What I’m really communicating is that the lack of curiosity of DSA is leaving some reductive commentary in my opinion. I’d have found the 250 episode more valuable if I’d thought the primary motivation in dsa was to reform the Democratic Party but that’s a reductive placement to start the dialog about dsa trying elections. I’ve been listening for years and I’m bugged that these last few episodes have left me feeling glad I started organizing with dsa before this momentum started and I’m frustrated about the positioning you’re passively offering (especially for the rest of America trying to imagine what to do outside of New York or California). I’ve been hearing you say you don’t know much about dsa for a long time and at a certain point it’s a choice. I’d love for yall to jump into more deeper dialogue and criticism about it but you have to be curious for that to not be reductive is my two cents.

Upstream

When I said that I don't know that much about DSA I meant I'm not familiar with the differences between chapters in their on-the-ground efforts. From my understanding, the National Electoral Commission does endorse candidates running for office on the Democratic Party ticket, and this is where many, including many of our guests and ourselves at times, have criticized DSA because we believe that there is no reforming or restructuring the democratic party and believe that efforts need to be put into third party candidates. I understand that there is a lot of other organizing that takes place with DSA and that mutual aid, strike support, and housing justice are other major roles the org plays. And again, I know there is a lot of difference between DSA national office and the local chapters, and I know that local chapters do endorse and work with candidates on slates that have included PSL. I think you're making a fair point in that when DSA is criticized from the left it's often some of the policies taking place as national directives and not of local chapters more broadly. And just a response to the claim that it's a choice to not be interested—we've had many folks on the show associated with DSA, including Diana Morena, and as a writer I have written a number of pieces on DSA including on the efforts to build a tenants union in the Bay Area. So just wanted to clarify that.

Sara Way

We ran a democratic socialist on the democratic ticket and went the path of signature gathering to get on the democratic primary ballot and were endorsed by dsa national and nothing about the campaign or him was for or associated with the Democratic Party besides a D being by his name on the ballot. I’m speaking to that there is a lot of strategy activity happening to build a party, DSA national is not only interested in democratic candidates and is offering support to each chapter to run socialist candidates. Talk about a clean break vs a dirty break but at least talk about it.

Sara Way

We grew our membership by +160 members, with the most active and sustained engagement the chapters ever seen. So I personally struggle to see the value in an opinion that questions if it’s real party building or not because we didn’t run an individual candidate (a person we voted on as a chapter) third party. We’re focused on sustaining engagement, funneling people into our Immigrant solidarity working group and maybe a city council seat campaign (nonpartisan) to keep growing.

Upstream

Hey Sara, I'm not sure if there's something I'm missing here because I feel like there might be some misinterpretation or miscommunication happening. At the 1 hr 21 mark of the reading, I shout out organizations like "PSL and others" who are utilizing the electoral sphere to spread a message that goes well beyond the electoral realm. I could be wrong, but I don't recall mentioning DSA in any way at all, let alone criticizing them? This comes after I criticize how some individuals treat candidates like celebrities and use Graham Platner to illustrate why putting all of our organizing energy into the electoral realm and into a single candidate is a flawed strategy. It sounds like this is not what you and your chapter are doing, and that you've found a way to do exactly what I was lauding, which is not focusing all of your energy on the electoral realm or on a single candidate and doing other kinds of organizing as well. It sounds like you're doing really well and have found success in growing your membership, which is fantastic.

Sara Way

Hope this is coming off more hungry than nitpicking, this last few comments for me rlly are stemming off the 250 episode and then the lack of representation of the great work happening in dsa and being supported by dsa national when you drop other organizing groups. The positing of talking about the origins of two party in America being interchanged in dialog with dsa endorsing democrats felt lacking in perspective/positing of what’s going on rn. I’d love to see a revisit that looks deeper at what people are doing within dsa and without dsa to utilize elections outside endorsing democrats which isn’t a primary strategy I see happening. All love xx there will be a lot that comes up with the next presidential runs and I don’t want our work, and work like ours, getting lost in the national conversation

Upstream

No, I totally hear what you're saying and I'm sure you might know that we have our From the Frontlines series that we're always adding onto—if you feel like you and/Bitch "or your chapter might be interested in coming onto the show at some point to talk about the work that you're doing and put it into the context of the discussion that you initiated here, we would be very open to starting that dialogue. Feel free to reach out to me directly if this sounds of interest to you robert@upstreampodcast.org

Robin Page

I really appreciate the intro and your explanation of the differences between manufacturing consent and inventing reality. Also thank you for providing these readings in general for folks who may not have the time 💚

Itsahashtaglife

"I also prefer to get my analysis from people who don't fly on planes with Jeffery fucking Epstein" lmfao 🤣

Upstream

my pleasure! glad you apprecited the episode

Ja Ja

Loved every single comments he made while reading, which appeared to be annoying in the beginning. Anyway, everything Parenti said and Robbie read unfortunately corresponded to today’s reality of the media/mainstream narratives on our poor beloved Iran…

Upstream

thanks! glad that you found the episode relevant and worthwhile. we will likely pick up other chapters from this text in the future for similar episodes

Erik Eriksen

Thanks for sharing this, very important work. Obviously love Parenti and Upstream. The question of why is a very important one. I'm reminded of this interview with Chomsky and a journalist, the last quote by Chomsky is the kicker- "if you believed something different, you wouldn't be sitting where you're sitting" We just heard Dr. CBS (excellent episode, maybe my favorite guest), say paraphrasing " if Liberal democracy is the furthest left you can go, there's no need for repression" Brings me to my point, I think it's important to identify that Chomsky is not wholly wrong. Most people (the workers i.e. journalists, anchors, copy writers, advertisers etc) believe what they are saying in totality, as a function of liberal indoctrination. The crucial part is the material, class analysis that Chomsky ignores and Parenti correctly identifies. Often times not all, but enough, of the individuals holding executive power understand their position well enough to make decisions and take action that align with their class interests. I just want to stress the dialectic point that the metaphysical / idealist rationale is not totally wrong, it is just not the complete picture let alone the dominant aspect of the contradiction. Thanks for everything I love upstream P.s. went to buy a used copy of this book and it's like 50 bucks where chomskys is 10.... https://youtube.com/shorts/AnFUWrjr25A?is=gS6LHXqxM5FTVfDr

Aelyth Savage

Robbie, do you have reading list that you've shared somewhere? I love Upstream and am really trying to beef up my socialist knowledge base.

Upstream

there's a reading list which is just books I've read over the past few years but I stopped updating it last year. It's a featured story on my personal instagram page!

Jean LaBonte

Absolutely fantastic episode. Found myself talking shit about Chomsky’s Epstein link as soon as you brought him up and then you said it out loud and I was saying “fuck yeah” to myself with a big grin as I’m out for my evening walk. I’d tune in to your further readings from this excellent book.

James

So useful how resonant Parenti’s analysis is for today still. I see lots of parallels with social media - I wonder what he would have made of it, whether he would have seen a distinction between ‘content’ and news, or whether he would have seen more similarities in the corporate ownership