Mid-Month Update, State of the Elliott (Patreon)
Content
Hi, all!
With the launch of PMF 7: LIFE AFTER HELL, I’m currently between projects. As such, this mid-month post is gonna be a bit nuts-and-bolts about my experience with publishing, the state of my series(es), and where we’re going from here. This launch and the recent experience with Cozy Shadows have me seriously rethinking my reliance on Amazon. That reliance hasn’t been without reason, but I think those reasons have hit diminishing returns and I need to change my approach. This behind-the-scenes stuff may not mean much to many of you here, but if it interests you, read on.
First, always, up front: Thank you all so much for being here (or to many of you, for STILL being here). This Patreon really keeps me going between releases. Secondly, thank you SO MUCH to everyone who picked up PMF 7: LIFE AFTER HELL, and especially to everyone who has left a review, shared my books around, or sent me a note about it.
Reactions have been overwhelmingly positive, which is a real relief. I’ve been nervous all along about the turn in direction and tone this book takes for the series. While I feel like it’s a natural progression, inevitably it wouldn’t be for everyone. The series has been very much military sci-fi for most of its run, so I expected some backlash to a change away from that. While I’ve seen a couple reviews to that effect, it really has only been a few. My sense of the series and the audience was the readers connected with Tanner and the rest of the cast more than the uniforms and military structure, and that seems to be accurate. Tanner doesn’t want to be a soldier. He never did. That was always the story and the character I set out to write.
Now for the unfortunate news: while the reactions have been encouraging, the actual sales & Kindle Unlimited reads have not. Life After Hell launched with a little better than half as many sales as Devil in the Details last year. It’s not a flop, but it’s not what I reasonably hoped for. Historically, PMF has the larger audience and sells better than Good Intentions, so this doesn’t feel like a good sign. It’s possible that those readers who weren’t interested in a less-military PMF just didn’t pick up the book at all, or quietly dropped it after reading a bit on KU. But that goes against what limited data I have and I’m not used to unhappy readers being quiet :).
There are a couple of clearer culprits: first, it looks like the first and biggest batch of new release notifications from Amazon went out on July 3rd. That means it probably got buried by the 4th of July for a lot of Americans (my biggest market). While I try to keep my own notifications list and do my own announcements, it’s always been clear that the largest share of my ongoing readership just clicks the “follow this author” button on Amazon and makes no other contact. I can’t blame them for that at all, but again, it means things can get buried and it leaves me too dependent on Amazon. Additionally, a hiccup on my upload dashboard meant Life After Hell didn’t attach to the series until I got that fixed just yesterday (July 15th).
Again, the book IS selling. It even caught me an email from a Big Five publisher about audio (no promises, may go nowhere because reasons, but nice to see). I’m hoping to do a couple more things to improve its performance. If it turns out that readers just trickle back to the series over time rather than rushing to a new release, that’s fine. I’m mainly worried series readers won’t know it came out at all. But I was already looking hard at pivoting away from the Amazon-exclusive approach, and this plus Cozy Shadows has me more serious about that.
Early sales show far more sales of PMF 7 than Kindle Unlimited reads, and Cozy Shadows has made surprising sales even with 1) being very clearly labeled as previously-published material and 2) no KU at all. I’ve also had several people reach out to ask if there’s any way to buy my books outside of Amazon. What this tells me is that I should probably look at doing an indie or “wide” release at first with new titles and only going exclusive for KU later. This may hurt the sales rankings on Amazon, but I’m growing skeptical of the benefit vs cost there. At the very least, I think it’s worth a try.
Secondly, and I’ve been ruminating about this for a while: I think it’s time to give Royal Road a shot to broaden my audience. I see Tess Irondale work on projects that started on RR for a while now, and I certainly got MY start on another free online platform… just, um, a little different in tone. :) I have a project in mind for that and I need some running room first, so I don’t want to give it away. But odds are good that my next big project starts there—with early cross-posting of segments/chapters here to the Patreon, as many RR authors do. That means more traffic here, which hopefully means more value to you supporters.
So.
Poor Man’s Fight will continue. Good Intentions will continue, probably sooner than PMF, and I very much want to do a sequel to Grand Theft Sorcery. Wandering Monsters 3 is closest to the front-burner right now, but as I say, plans are slightly in flux. I’ll let you know as soon as they’re ready to show.
In the meantime, the next chapter of Never Too Many is written and ready for the monthly story post here on the Patreon! With that, I’m gonna get back to work on the next big thing. Thank you again for being here!