Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Files

Better Call Saul REACTION 6x13 [Edited - Early Access]

Comments

Ryan Roach

I've watched the Jimmy/Chuck flashback scene a few times now, and I still don't understand it. Why is Jimmy being so standoffish and flippant with Chuck, when at that time he hero-worshipped Chuck? I also didn't like how the rewrote history and made Jimmy the villain in his dealings with Chuck. Chuck was "in the game" and gave as good as he got. I get that they're trying to say "Chuck was right" about Jimmy becoming a lawyer, but if Chuck had been more supportive, it's possible none of this would've happened.

Phil Jacke

I liked your discussion of the time machine and the question of whether a person can change. I think the courtroom scene does show that Saul is capable of change--he could've stuck with his original story to get minimal jailtime and some ice cream but he confessed to everything--even his involvement in Chuck's death (which wasn't even a crime) and at the end he time traveled back to being Jimmy again. The other thing to consider about the time machine is that this is something Jimmy has been thinking about for a long time--the conversation with Chuck happened before the conversations with Mike and Walt, and the book even made its way into Saul's mansion. But those conversations didn't change Saul because he was still thinking about money the whole time. I think the moment that changed Saul was when he heard that Kim had confessed. That's what convinced him to also confess. So as much as Saul's confession might have helped Kim (unclear how much it would help with the civil suit), Kim's confession helped Jimmy. Their relationship stopped being toxic and they finally made each other better

Phil Jacke

Rhea Seehorn said she thought that after Kim leaves the prison she would probably look for a legal way to lessen Jimmy's time in prison so maybe there's still hope he'll get out some day

Aaron Bone

I think the scene simply shows that despite both of them blaming it on the other brother, their strained relationship was a mutual effort--or due to a mutual lack of effort. Neither one is "the villain", they just gave up on each other in their own ways. I also don't think it's necessarily condeming Jimmy's choice to become a lawyer. It's a simple, brief, moment in time that Jimmy regrets. In thinking about all the hurt they caused each other, Jimmy remembered one moment where Chuck tried to engage with him as a peer and brother and Jimmy denies and deflects--a common defense mechanism he's shown in the past. In that response, it also speaks more to Jimmy's own insecurities and maybe also realizing that he was his own foil as much as Chuck was. Is it a bit of a retcon of Jimmy and Chuck's relationship in season 1? I don't think so. We've seen how their relationship can turn on dime when the dynamics shift and how sensitive Jimmy is about being compared to his brother (he refused to ask him for any advice when he decided to become lawyer). We also see Chuck's softer, more supportive side in flashbacks, so I think the interaction is well within character for the both of them. Details of the scene aside, the important part is that Jimmy's biggest regret is that he didn't do more to try and reconcile his relationship with his brother.

Brian Gonigal

If there was ever a moment in Breaking Bad when we got a halfway decent look behind the "Saul" mask at the real Jimmy MgGill, it was that scene in the basement of the Vaccuum repair place, where Jimmy pretty much abandoning his Saul persona when he tries to tell Walter "It's over, I'm not your lawyer anymore, I'm nobody's lawyer!", and nevertheless tries to give Walt one last piece of free legal advice, to quote: "Stay. Face the music. I mean, how much time have you got left? You walk in with your head held high, you'll be the John Dillinger of the Metropolitan Detention Center. How bad is that?" In the end, this is EXACTLY what Jimmy wound up doing, he took his own advice. In fact, for a long time I remembered this line as coming from the flashback scene with Walt in this episode, but no, it's from the original Breaking Bad "Granite State" ep, back when the writers themselves had no clear idea who the man behind the Saul Goodman facade really was. Just another example of the writers brilliantly using the earlier show to inform the path of the later one, and in the process creating really meangful retroactive foreshadowing from random bits of dialouge.

Florian Cuisinier

Walter's watch was said from the writers representing his only true, deep regret : Jessie's fate (that watch was Jesse's birthday gift). Hence him saving Jesse at the end of Breaking Bad. When I was watching Better Call Saul and was spending time making theories, wondering how the show could end... I had the same thoughts than you : In jail, and with Jimmy's trial, because it was the best fitting end for a procedural show (even if it's not a regular one, with only a few trials-centered episodes in it like Chicanery and Saul Gone), and because like you both said... Jimmy is not Walter White. He is not a murder machine psychopath, he is just a petty buffoon scammer seeking attention, but could not even handle a gun (I don't think we have ever seen him holding a gun once), and he immediately feels remorse after any stupid thing he does over the course of the show. Trial and infinite jail were definitely the most appropriate outing. Also, his fate was compared to the character of Raskolnikov in Dostoyevsky's Crime and Punishment : Raskolnikov is a young man who fantasizes about killing bad people as a good action towards society, and is tempted to kill the old, Leopold Strauss-lady he owes money to and because of whom he lives in poverty. From the second he kills her, and in the process someone else, he spirals down into madness, guilt, paranoia, spends the rest of the novel hiding in his room, thinking everybody out there knows what he has done, trying to do some good to overcome his guilt... And the only redemption he can get is to finally admit what he has done, turning himself in, and he can only have a fresh start once he accepted and accomplished his punishment/sentence, which he does. They did the same thing with Jimmy : Finally, he confessed EVERYTHING, even a moral crime with Chuck. But the writers deliberately made it ambiguous with the fingers guns at the end : We can always interpret it at he's still playing a show or not. Anyway, we all prefer to believe he REALLY, sincerely confessed everything in front of justice, himself, and God, of course inspired by Kim. Kim's fate is up in the air, but I'm hopeful with that new volunteer legal work she will continue trying to make amends for what she has done by keeping helping the other person like she aspired to when she was a lawyer.

Chris B

Thank You Guys for this journey. I enjoyed your reactions immensely. You are focused, you pay attention. You want and like to dissect every nugget of information the show threw at you. I appreciated that a lot!

Daniel

Vince Gilligan is currently working on a brand new show, unrelated to this universe, starring Rhea Seehorn. Nobody knows much about it and it has no name, but im beyond excited lol

Brian Strickland

I never understood the thought of going back through a show in the context of watching the reactions and experience of somebody else watching it for the first time, but when I was looking for content about one of the Star Wars projects I came across you two, and I will never question the point of this experience. If I didn’t like a show I probably won’t watch it, but what I can tell you guys are pretty picky about what you watch, and I appreciate that. I’m hoping y’all watch Andor S2 soon, which we’ve already hit on, and I would honestly love to see y’all’s reaction to The Acolyte… And looking forward to S2 of Ahsoka!!