Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Files

Severance REACTION 2x9 [Edited]

Comments

Alex

let's goo

Ryley Johnson

Weekend special drop for the finale? 🤠

NF

If Innies and Outies are not separate people, then do you believe Helana having sex with Mark S was not an ethical violation?

NF

Btw, I love the lively and passionate post ep discussion. Best part of the reaction. This show teases out so many fascinating topics to explore with valid views and counterviews. Really looking forward to next weeks recap discussion.

Moose

Wouldn't that be nice!? :D

Peter chitengi

My thing is where did the idea that if you create something/someone you can treat them however you want? I think ethics should exist in a vacuum because that's a very dangerous way to look at things and can be exploited as people would and have gotten away with horrible things in the name of a higher power and why i think they should be treated as different people even if we want to argue the machanics of them being one being is we have to look at the implocation's of thinking that because does that mean we can punish the innie's for things that the outies did? that's equivalent to punishing a baby because they were a horrible peron in a previous life if we could prove it

Demented Avenger

I feel like the innies and outies aren't separate people, but the same people on different timelines. To use a tired device, it's almost like they're are multiverse versions of one another living in the same universe.

Nythara

I love this show so much, exactly because of these kinds of philosophical discussions! To me, it all revolves around the question: Who are you? What makes you you? Is it the biological aspects, the body, the brain, the blood? Is it your experiences, your memories, your trauma? Or is it both? I totally get it when you say you see them as one person. I think the show plays with that idea too. Like how both the innies and outies sometimes say the exact same thing in different situations. For example: Innie Mark says “Irv isn’t dead, he’s just not here,” and later in the same episode, he says the same about Gemma: “She’s not dead, she’s just not here.” That mirroring is so intentional. But on the other hand, would I still be me if I hadn’t lived the same life? So much of who I am was shaped by my experiences. And to wrap up: My theory is that Lumon is trying to create the perfect human, someone unburdened by trauma or negative experiences. But then again… isn’t that exactly what makes us human? I don’t have answers to any of these questions and maybe for now, that’s the point: that we keep asking them. Love your reaction btw. ☺️

alaskan mitch

@Eric I believe you are correct on the "are they separate people" debate. For me, innies are just the purest versions of the outies. They are still the same people. The way Mark deals with things is the same way he deals with things outside. The way Helly acts is the way Helena suggests she wished she was (probably was this way as a child and was molded by the cult?)

Helly R

Also if they are not, then the drama of the show doesn't work. Is Helly R not totally justified in being upset in 206? There's really two questions, who are they fundamentally, in which case it's some half way point between nature/nuture but built on the same foundation, (can talk for days about that, and the show is interested in that), and whether or not they have separate autonomy. In the former cases, the innies are the "inner child" of the outties, imo, as Britt Lower likes to say, though that may diverge (or not) as the innies makes more memories. The answer in the latter is a clear yes. The finale is going to be...interesting.

Crawnch!

The town is called Kier. If you remember in the season one finale Burt is looking through his things and finds a map of the town with “Kier” on the front. It’s a company town just like the town Harmony went back to in the last episode was.

Crawnch!

I haven’t seen anyone else say this but I have a wild theory (that’s one of the fun things about a show like this..the theories!) I think Helena/Helly is pregnant. She’s had sex with Mark twice, once as Helena and once as Helly. At the beginning of this episode she uses the egg cutter to slice the egg. She splits it in two and then into multiple pieces, like a human egg divides after fertilization. She spreads the egg to reveal the boy on the plate (referring to the baby inside her). There’s two women on the plate who look alike pulling on the child on either side. Perhaps foreshadowing of the struggle for the child. Is it Helena’s or is it Helly’s? Who gets to decide? Something interesting to think about.

Taco Schenkhuizen

That's a very smart idea and very likely. It's also smart writing. If only one of Helly/Helena would have had sex with Mark, it would raise more difficult and invasive questions. It's going to be very strange for outtie Mark to have fathered a child without being present, though.

Tatyana Zinger

Yes, plus as the innies “lost their innocence” /purity, ie experience adversity in life - they become more like their outside selves - who obviously have lost that childlike innocence because they’re, well, fully fledged adults. Irving was a great example because he was a #1 Lumon loyalist until he became disillusioned with them because of the Burt retirement stuff (“lets burn this place to the ground”, then he was the most mistrusting of Milchick in the Woe’s hollow episode), and his outside self is clearly very rebellious since he was doing some covert anti-Lumon operations/spying… outttie Dylan, similarly, was told by Gretchen “he reminds me of how you used to be” and when Gretchen leaves, innie Dylan starts to lash out at Helly and says “sorry I guess I’m an a hole here too” - that negative experience caused his loss of innocence / for him to become more cynical and negative like his outtie. Love the storytelling and all that comes with it

Tatyana Zinger

Well, people don’t have to be separate people for that to be an ethical violation ie if someone had “sex” with someone when they’re unconscious or very altered by substances, we would justifiably call it rape even though it is that same body. Which I agree that was. I do think it’s more complicated than “they are the same person” OR “two different people”, mainly because we can’t use a framework of the real world to think about sci fi - we don’t really have an example of two separate consciousnesses inhabiting the same body… also I’ve seen Britt Lower talk about in interviews how she could see Helena and Helly coming to “natural reintegration” eventually, or that she might even already have started, ie when your inside and outside selves start to understand and empathize with each other well enough to merge naturally. It’ll be interesting if they toy with that idea.

Tatyana Zinger

One more thought with the relational bonds - love transcending Severance you mentioned with Burt/Irv, innie Dylan to his wife, Helena to Mark (though tbh I don’t know if this is her independent feelings for him because of her growing up in a cult and being lonely and all that) - you said interestingly it didn’t happen for Mark S and Miss Casey but don’t forget that Mark S did sculpt the tree that she crashed into in his wellness session with her in season 1- so there is some retained memory there. But all is messier by now because of the love triangle / hexagon…

Bella Lake

I hope one day your full length has the show visible. I don’t understand why you guys blur the show if we’re paying for it anyway. I’ve seen the show, I want to watch your reaction but it’s such a hassle to do the sync thing. Oh well, I’ll just watch you guys on YouTube.

Bella Lake

You’re right. I guess I’m not understanding how Patreon works but I do have other Patreon subscriptions that I can watch the full uncut reactions without having to sync with my own copy of the show. I guess they have a different type of Patreon. I’m new to all this sorry.