Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Not the murder mashup!!!!!!! Absolutely superior + yes, we do have a chat about what ole Joe has had to say about things today 👀

Files

Comments

Dalal

Love when I see a new post from you guys!!

Gone Girl

Carolina stans rise

Ally ❤️

The last 24 hours have been 😳

Becky Tucker

Yay!!! Haven’t watched yet but can’t wait!!! 😛

Ileana Isabel

Besties!!!! Absolutely superior mashups today!!! I can't believe she just did that!

Katie LaFave

please also tell me you saw taylor commenting on the chiefs WAG's livestream!!

Abbie

With the absolute quickness!! Also Bonny your sweater I love🤩

Kirsten Marie

the way I ran here to hear their reaction to The Manuscript/Red mash up.

Natalee Bieber

you guys are so good at guessing omg

ton

I feel as if she’s refashioning a lot of Joe Lover songs into TK songs…. Em you are a witch predictor I swear!

imogen

I was so shocked that she didn’t save the manuscript for the last show of the tour!! Other options I think could be long live x New Year’s Day x yoyok. You’ll always find your way back home. Or she could just go craaaazy ending on a whole Taylor Swift medley

Tannis Pigeon

i love the zoom in on your predictions, you ladies are on fireeeeee with your guesses lately 🤣

TD2002

Y’all NEED to help me out with Mastermind. You guys are always guessing the surprise songs!!!!

Katie LaFave

EMILY YOU NEED TO BE AWARE OF THE SWIFTALERT APP AND PLAY MASTERMIND!!!!

Ally ❤️

The beginning of the lives were so hard tonight!

Ileana Isabel

I cannot believe Emily predicted again🤣🤣 girlie, you need to give me lottery numbers to buy lol Edit: and Bonny too 🙈🙈

Alex Nibblett

girls i need you to know that i did not see this on a livestream but when i saw the notification for carolina x nbnc i passed away, i am the #1 carolina stan to exist and i just love it forever and ever

Katie LaFave

yes matty healy is engaged. him and his fiance have been together since september

Mads

As a North Carolina girly, the love y’all have for Carolina feeds my soul

Evermore22

I’ve been waiting to watch Bonnie lose it over Carolina😭

Liz

Thank you for always discussing exactly what we are all fathoming between the interview + the engagement. All while blessing us with these reactions. We are not worthy! Absolutely can not wait for the London SS mashups! They are gonna be completely illegal.🔥

Austin Smith

Ok but the editing and zooming in on yalls faces when yall said the Manuscript and Red songs is sending me 😂❤️

Katie LaFave

the fact that Em said the manuscript and Bonny said a red song!!!

Allie

Emily is the TTPD Surprise Song Savant

Christine Violet

The murder mashup is literally so perfect I can’t even process it

Katie

EMILY IS PSYCHIC FOR REAL

Graciekay

RED BECAUSE LIVERPOOL STADIUMMMM

Courtney

Same I suck at it😅

Dion Jackson Jr.

I’m so scared for London’s surprise songs

Courtney

Hi chickens you’re the best!!

Katie LaFave

carolina on the guitar is sooo superior

ton

I also think that TTPD explores the repeated pattern of falling in and out of love and so the manuscript about looking back to move forwards when she wants to break the pattern makes a lot of sense!

Katie LaFave

THE MANUSCRIPT IS SOOO UNDERRATED!!!! THE BRIDGE GIVES ME CHILLS EVERY TIME

Alexis

I don’t know if you two realize that you’re witches always manifesting the surprise songs. 🤩

Kassie

Crazier, Carolina... Beautiful Ghosts mashup is next 😂😂

Katie LaFave

have you guys fathomed that the manuscript doesn't have a chorus?!

Grady

my theory on why she made the manuscript the final track is that, after the rerecords, she's moving on to her movie...and i think TS12 might be that movie's soundtrack 👀

Kirsten Marie

I think you guys are right. Her final message is that, just like Red, she will alchemize the pain and create art and put it into the universe to heal herself and others. Thus, the pain allll ovvveeeerrrrTTPD will also travel along the same path trudged by heartbreaks that have gone before. It’s hope for healing (through art) which is a gorgeous ending to a chaotic heartbreak album like red was.

Ally ❤️

I think The Manuscript is the closer because it teases her next direction from here- writing scripts about things she knows and directing…

Amanda P

Emily predicting the manuscript was not obvious at all!!!!!

Jalen O’Grady

Why is the manuscript literally the saddest song of hers to me?

Hettie

10/10 also enjoyed that Joe cleared up The Black Dog is not about him -- think he was extremely respectful of Taylor and their relationship.

Jake

I have always felt that the beginning verse of The Manuscript refers to Matty (her latest influential relationship) and then the next verse refers to Jake (her earliest influential relationship). The song covers the entirety of Taylor’s all encompassing loves and the themes each relationship throughout her life has had in common. She sees a pattern with all of the different men she’s dated in her life, all bringing her the same type of heartbreak and pain. The only thing that’s left is the imperfect writing, the manuscript, the poetry. It’s not edited, but it’s done and it has a central theme. Taylor knows what the agony had been for (aka coming into herself and also that all of her experiences led her to Travis and where she is currently). She may not understand WHY things happened the way they did, but now she does understand that every event in her life has served a purpose. It’s a genius song

Joe Weaver

Beautiful Ghosts & Macavity dedicated to Benjamin, Olivia & Meredith.

Richelle Watson

My take on maroon has kinda of been recently that is Taylor looking at her relationship with Joe and being reminded of Jake and rationalizing what was happening in the Joe relationship with everything she learned from Jake. So when she says that she wake with his memory over her, that's sort of the moment where she starts to directly "talk" (obv not actually talk but you know what I mean) to Jake and notice how much it effects she even till Joe. Idk if that makes sense but theyre my thoughts🤍❤

Joe Weaver

I was thinking she'd play Red All weekend because of that.

Caitlin Klei

I’ve always thought it was important Red reflection and the ATW short film because she was making the short film, and reliving the Red Era, while things were not well with Joe. Given that you’re losing me was written shortly after Red TV era, it’s possible that she has linked the breakdown of the Joe relationship, and the Red TV era.

F1Swiftie

I posted this originally April 25 in Discord somewhere :) Opinion: “The Manuscript” is about All Too Well I see the story of ATW/ATW10/short film from “The Manuscript.” She’s said that the song had its own journey even back in the rep tour era in 2018. Then with the re-records she released the fan requested 10 minute version which led to the short film. There isn’t another song that has had this type of journey and metamorphosis. 1. Relationship heartache leads to songwriting to understand and get through it 2. Song goes out into the world 3. Becomes a collage of memories of fans embracing the song 4. Offhand comment in an interview about it originally being a 10 minute stream of consciousness 5. Fans start asking for this 10 minute version 6. RedTV includes ATW10 7. ATW10 becomes a Short Film “French press” is JG to me. It goes along with “organic shoes and million dollar couch”. It’s been said that he was talking marriage and babies and that’s why she “left the scarf” with him and was upset (angry/confused/all the things) that he downplayed what had happened between them. Wanting the comfort of your mom when going through a rough time doesn’t change once you leave your parents’ house. I still laid my head in my mom’s lap and wanted her to pet my hair when I went through a tough breakup in my 20s. The re-recording process brought up a lot of things from the past (I think we can all agree on that) that maybe hadn’t quite been worked through to get past it. Actors hitting their marks and crying in time with the score = ATW10 Short Film. The behind-the-scenes showed the detail with which she worked the on-screen action within the framing of the song. Specific actions to go with specific words exactly in time with it: “the score”. In a broader sense, it can be about all of her work. That’s my take on it. All Too Well Speech Rep Tour 2018 “So you know when I write a song it’s usually me just trying to get past something and understand something I’m going through by writing about it. That was definitely the case when I wrote the next song I’m gonna play. On this tour we’ve had this tradition that’s come about where .. and it’s started with you. You guys were saying to me online “we really want you to play older songs that you don’t play very often.” And so I was like “ok.” And so this tradition kind of came about and I’m really glad you told me to do that because it’s really fun going back through and playing songs I hadn’t played in forever. And so this song is a song that .. it’s weird.. I feel like this song has two lives to it in my brain. In my brain there’s the life of this song where this song was born out of catharsis and venting and trying to get over something and trying to understand it and process it. And then there’s the life where it went out into the world and you turned this song into something completely different. You turned this song into a collage of memories of watching you scream the words to this song. Or seeing pictures that you post to me of you having written the words to this song in your diary. Or you showing me your wrist and you have a tattoo of the lyrics to this song underneath your skin. And that is how you’ve changed the song “All Too Well” for me.”

ttpd-24

I think the manuscript was the first song she wrote 2 years ago after fa the ATW… anthologies don’t go in order right! So she went back to the start!

Jessica

The way that u both immediately clocked the manuscript & red is the reason why u’re the BEST TS reactors out there. You know her SO well that u can predict these things! And i absolutely LOVE that!!!! 🤣

Nevara PUMPKIN Shaw

Okay seriously ladies, you don’t have to say it, but just blink twice if Taylor granted you some of her witchy powers in those letters??! Emily, idk like the manuscript - Bonnie, maybe something from Red…how!?

Courtney Schwarzbauer

I need y’all to fathom the parallels between SUBURBAN LEGENDS and like every Matty song on ttpd……just….😳

Abigail Stewart

I think having The Manuscript as the closer is more a reflection on how the experiences fans have with her work changes the meaning of said work for her. Atw10 and the film have become less about the breakup and more about the love and devotion of the fans. People asked for that version for ages and it has become and huge thing especially with the re-records and the film. She’s saying everything she went through was worth it because of how that heartbreak has turned into something so special for her fans and herself. That story is not hers anymore, it’s not about her experience it’s about the fans and what they’ve made it. And so I think she’s saying that maybe all of TTPD will become the same over the years. I think she recognises that with all her work/eras it becomes something different once she puts it out into the world and that helps her heal and move on and gives meaning to the experiences she’s been through and I think atw10 and the short film is the biggest example of that happening and so that’s why she has used it to close out TTPD.

Hettie

Also Bonnie and the artiste has me in tears <3

Claire D

Yes! Please go back through the albums, I’m curious to know if you look at some songs differently now or if you think meanings have changed with the additional information you’ve learned through listening to TTPD. Thanks for all of the surprise song reactions, I always look forward to them and and your thoughts on them😊💕 Also, love y’all going back and watching the better versions of the SSongs after the initial reaction.

ton

He actually said he hasn’t been to Vaux Hall which isn’t the same as the Black Dog isn’t about him…

Julia

You guys need to have a taylorswifthockey bro up as a backup - he wss having trouble like tess but YT let's you rewind and be behind the live time a little just in case their are issues it helps!

Melinda Mascoll

I read this entire article and I feel like the writer of it pulled the wool over their eyes when asking questions vs what they actually put in the article cuz there is zero chance him or his team would approve London boy in huge letters on the cover or the fact that half the article is the writer bringing up Taylor and then forcing these questions while he tries to shut them down respectively

ton

Em pronouncing it Vox Hall is so funny… it’s pronounced Voxall ie the H isn’t pronounced. I think in the article they phrase it as him saying “I’ve never been to Vaux-Hall”. So I think he’s actually commenting on the pronunciation 😂 being like Em’s

Nicole Gordon

RE: The Manuscript - I think it is about ATW and Jake and the Red era, but the whole of TTPD/Anthology album gives me the vibe that she really is going to leave all of those past relationships behind her and not write about them anymore. Like she has steeped herself in them during the re-records and of course she went through her most recent breakups, but the way she talks about looking back to move forward, and the bit about all of the bodies who’ve ever been on my body in Florida, and stuff I’m forgetting now just makes me think she’s laying the past down after this. So The Manuscript feels perfect as a closer to me because it is like she’s handing all of the songs off to us. Could be totally wrong and TS12 is full of Jake, John, Joe(s). But I think we might really be done.

Takara

Just fathomed “I wake with your memory that’s a real fucking legacy… ” - the memory of the heartbreak from jake she’s waking up with that because her relationship with Joe was falling apart and she was scared to go through that heartbreak again

Liz

C

I've always found interesting the narrative that Joe didn't "allow" Taylor to be Bejeweled. I think it's more likely that he wanted a private relationship which also suited her at the time because of everything that was going on. She then changed her mind, which she completely had the right to, because she realised that her career makes her so happy and it was not something she could just put it aside for a quiet life. Her priorities shifted and that didn't fit with the relationship anymore

S M

The quotes from Joe were actually fine, it was unfortunately the journalist/publication that made the whole article about Taylor and said some questionable things about her and I think made him seem way more bitter than necessary. Love you guys!! Ps did you see Taylor commenting on the chiefs live the other night?? 🥰🥰

Sarah

Whoaaaa how did I not fathom this yet!? It's so brilliant I have just been blown away every time and didn't notice that!

Christine Violet

I said this in the last post, but the Black Dog is definitely about Matty. In the Black Dog she mentions The Starting Line, and in Fresh out the Slammer she says “now we’re at the starting line, I did my time”

Ally ❤️

You need the London Boy article in Style. It’s pretty shady. It’s a full feature article cover story.

Katie LaFave

all these quotes are from a magazine interview that Joe did. he was asked about the breakup.

Devan

This might get long…. lol I always saw the Manuscript fitting because during the eras tour in the lover speech she always talks about how she wants these songs to bring new memories and age wants the crowd remember that night when they hear the songs. She wrote this album during the eras tour and I could see her reflecting on all this pain she is feeling in the moment and just really being like “why?!” (Think the prophecy) Then reflecting on ATW and how it has a completely changed meaning for her now. Also Reflecting on filming that short film and playing it each night to a stadium who know every word to the ten min. Version. Almost like a way to help her through her current heart ache. She could have been like “ I was DEVASTATED then (red) and look and what it is now. I know what the agony is for, these are not just my stories.” She wrote it Letting go of that pain she was suffering in alone and making new memories with this heart wrenching songs on the anthology. So while it is a red song and feels misplaced in some ways, I think all the reflection she did in the red record and the ATW film could have helped her through this heartbreak and agony knowing it would be worth it and she would survive stronger. But also I have no idea wha-so-ever I just have no one to share these Taylor theories with 😂😂😂 ❤️

Astoria

I think the manuscript as the album closer is her saying she used her past relationships frequently to write new music. The last lines “now and then I re-read the manuscript but the story isn’t mine anymore” I take less that it now belongs to the swifties and more that it’s a chapter in her life she’s closing and she won’t be using John, Jake, Matty as song inspiration going forward. Almost a step further that maybe she sees something different/real with Travis and doesn’t need other muses (collected like bruises). I know she said folklore was fiction but I truly think that’s what she needed Joe to believe, especially after she dropped “The 1” from the eras tour bc that song was so Matty coded. He was the tumblr prom king and Taylor was in her relationship formative years and I think Matty had been her muse since 1989. “Who else decodes you?” She asks in TTPD which I think is her saying Matty writes his songs about her and she understands, and the Manuscript (although it’s about Jake) is her sending a message (a code if Matty is still reading into her song lyrics) that she’s done. The past is a closed book and her music going forward will be inspired by fresh muses.

Sarah

Haha yes she would kill it at mastermind omg!! They both would!

alden

Love him or hate him, Joe is the most superior man Blondie has ever dated (besides Travis ofc). It's sad that every good thing Joe did for Taylor over the years including literally SAVING HER from the darkest time in her life can be diminished to a single moment. Taylor wrote new years day, daylight and sweet nothing about this man. I can never bring myself to hate him 😭

Christine Violet

I think the idea is that she had some sort of relationship with Matty in the 1989 era and maroon is in reference to that time :)

Brent

I got the impression that the Charli XCX quote was taken out of context and twisted a bit, but i might need to look that up again

erin 🪻🎧☀️🇦🇺

I think about the manuscript in relation to tortured poets the way I think about emails i can't send as the opening track for that album. They both tell the story of a core heartbreak that affects her behaviour throughout the album. But, in contrast to sabrina, taylor chose to explain that heartbreak and thus her behaviour at the end (kind of like the position of the 'in summation' poem in the lyric booklet).

WN

Are you two going to go back and refathom her older albums after TTPD? Like the songs that connect like question? Maroon? That would be very interesting

Erica

I’m curious about This is What You Came For because it doesn’t fit on Rep to me… he was 1989/bleachella/karma bf 🙃 ya know? Would it be a Rep vault track then? Or a random TV single like eyes open?

Kailey's Corner

Assuming she wrote this while things were ending with Joe or even Matty. I think the ATW short film brought up memories to process from Jake, and either or both breakups felt similar. So The Manuscript is her YOYOK of the Red era, walking through what happened. Because writing TTPD was her ATW for the recent breakups, and much like the ATW process is done, so is the TTPD process. It’s like inception processing your feelings. She’s saying making the film brought her closure from Red era, and making this album/song is bringing her closure of the TTPD era!

Mckenzie Seims

Em on a roll with guessing the surprise songs!!!!

Kayla Knutson

What the hell, Emily!?! You correctly predicted another surprise song! I swear you girlies and Taylor are intrinsically connected since you can pick the same song on the same night out of every single song in her discography. NOOOOOOO. It’s simply alarming. That being said, WOW. What incredible mash ups tonight! The piano one sent me to the grave ☠️

TScout

Agree. I think people forget that that magazines and interviewers can take a lot of license and that the interviewee doesn’t get final approval by any means.

Clash Fan

On the comment about The Black Dog. Vauxhall is an area of London where in Victorian times the Vauxhall Pleasure Gardens were popular. In the 80's and 90's it was still primarily council housing mixed with industry. In other words very much not an area a posh boy like Joe would go. I know there has been a lot of reconstruction in that area since the 2000's and it's possible it's much nicer now.

Christie Lynn

The Manuscript makes perfect sense to me as an album closer. I think she’s reminding us and most importantly, herself, that all the agony before lead to such beauty and joy, and this agony will too. She tells us her stories, then we take them and turn them into something special to us, and give it back to her in a healing way. So essentially ending TTPD with a hopeful and encouraging message that she got through all of the past stuff and she’s getting through this too. Especially ending with “but the story isn’t mine anymore”…. Because it’s ours now. Just my two cents lol!

dachiefs1969

The live streaming is unwatchable. My god... some horrific sing alongs, where you can't hear Taylor. Wait 30 mins and the nice 4k version gets released. You can still react "live".

Emily Ann

Love you girls!! I have been having a moment with the Manuscript and think it’s actually the most perfect closer for the anthology because like you said, the reflection on red / all too well mirrors the kind of painful all-consuming heartbreak she’s been through on tortured poets. It connects to how she has talked about ATW – how that song no longer feels like it’s about that initial heartbreak for her so much as what it’s become for her fans…the story isn’t hers anymore, it’s ours. It’s like what she’s saying with ttpd: every song on the album tells part of the story—they make up the pages of the manuscript—and now that we’ve come to the end, she’s giving it to us and letting it go. The line that feels as if she’s maybe connecting all this back to the present moment is “One last souvenir from my trip to your shores” – like this book is the final token she’s bringing back home with her from the all the time spent in the UK relationships. She might revisit it from time to time, but she’s moved on and has left the story behind by sharing it with us.

Rafael Splinter

Actually Sweet Nothing was about Paul McCartney and his ex-wife, Linda. As Taylor herself made (pettily and) abudantly clear through her Twitter like hahah.

Hannah

I’m such a fraud. I still haven’t heard Carolina 🙈🙉🙊

Jenny Jin

I agree with everyone saying that the manuscript being the last song on ttpd might also be hinting that her next project will be her movie/writing for a different medium but drawing on her life experiences!

Jessie

I have been thinking that Taylor is on your Patreon hearing your predictions, but after this video I am convinced you two are just witches ><

TScout

I agree. And it’s the perfect way the close this chapter because she knows that even these TTPD songs she’s about to preform will change for her when played on stage. The eras tour allowed for Lover and Rep and Speak Now songs, etc to become Travis songs. It allowed Matty songs to be about theatrics and Female Rage the Musical. Preforming the songs is her way of “rereading them”, but she doesn’t attach the same meaning to them she once did. She has done for herself what she asks the audience to do with her songs. Apply new meaning. Allow them to be transformed.

TScout

Their minds are SO impressive.

TScout

Love this idea!

Christie Lynn

The Charlie XCX stuff has come back up because she is like best friends with Matty’s fiancé.

alden

oh damn i didn't know she explicitly said that .. well this is awkward LMFAOO

Lacey Morris

I agree with the privacy of a relationship. But, there is a difference b/n private and not being seen/supporting your partner.

Victoria

came here to say this!

Tess7

The lives today were so rough lol we were seasick from the one streamer. I knew she would sing Red with The Manuscript - because she couldn’t sing ATW after doing the ten minute version. I was thrilled to finally get that piano Red. I think the way The Manuscript ties into Tortured Poets is she’s directing it to us, the fans. We begged her for the longer version for years. When she re-recorded Red, she knew it was the perfect time to give us the whole story. We changed it for her over the years. We most likely changed the ten minute version for her too. The film was the last piece. She told us everything. The Manuscript is the story of us. Her relationship with us. She processed the pain in her music. She scolds us in other songs, (rightly so). She ends the album by saying men come and go, but we stayed. She loves us, and we love her. This woman is a master song writer. She’s done with all these past relationships and ready to focus on her new chapter.

Lilly Wall

I’ve also been fathoming the black dog recently and am realising that maybe Taylor out picked a pub in London to use that she may not have even visited. The pub has said that they are unaware of whether Taylor has ever even been there so Joe saying in the interview that he has never been there to me doesn’t mean the song isn’t about him. I simply just cannot get past the references to daylight in the song and the fact that it is a pub in London which we know they spent a lot of time

Jessie

This poor live streamer sounds like North West lolllllzzz

Rachel Bea

I get The Manuscript as a closer to the album. I think its position is partly exploring the impact that relationship had on all the ones that followed. I had a Jake at 19, it’s taken me years and several relationships to process our short time together. Now that she’s finally done with that story, she is a place where she can have a healthy relationship with herself and the people she loves. It’s beautiful.

Julie

I think a lot of Anthology songs link back to previous albums/relationships so The Manuscript wraps that part up well and seems (to me) to end all of these prior eras.

Jessikah

I remember when Charli XCX supported paramore and was very public about how her management had pushed her into it and she didn’t actually want to be there (she’d cancelled a solo tour for it I think). It came across so rude!

Riley H

I do think the Joe snippets are worse out of context, reading the article the interviewer repeatedly makes it about Taylor and imo he answers the questions pretty respectfully

Susan Coulter

I have a similar vocal range as her… and at least for me, if I’m singing in a higher register for 2 hours… the low notes just aren’t there without getting a chance to re-warmup properly!

TScout

Not speaking regarding Joe not showing up for her in any other way…. And I can’t verify this, but I did hear once upon a time that Joe’s family went to her doctorate ceremony and that he only missed it because of shooting. Maybe someone else can speak to this?

Annika 📍Melb, AU

I thought The Black Dog was about Matty 🤣 Joe wishes it was about him.

Natalia

emily’s secret song guessing powers have reached unfathomable levels

Katie Walmsley

I feel like the Matty “engagement news” a few days ago could have unearthed some further fathomings in Tay about what a small man he always was and how she may have been delulu about how she felt for him - further reckoning that her return to Matty was really a chapter in her healing journey from Joe. Hence the Liverpool N1 and N2 mashups. ❤️‍🩹

Ileana Isabel

On the topic of Joe, now that you mention it, I always thought it was interesting that they didn't show up or were pictured together in that film event (i forget the name of it, but the one where she wore the gold mirrorball-ish dress), even though they were both there! Like it's just interesting that he wouldn't want to show up with her or be photographed together or anything! And they were in the same event, even if it was for different things

Madelyn Denning

The manuscript is the all too well short film, but also the entire red album, and all of her other re-records too. In all of those stories, she had to look back in order to move forward. She is starting fresh✨ after the re-records and those stories aren’t hers anymore… they’re ours 💗

T

On the manuscript being the unofficial closer - she said in the summary poem the album was her plea for temporary insanity and mentions it's the worse men she writes best. If Jake really mentioned pushing strollers whether jokingly or not she is kinda laying out how these get love quick schemes start.... by dangling a serious future in front of her which she so desperately wants. And she was feeling burning red with Jake because of that hope and she was crazy about matty for the same reason.

paulina ⭐️

not Em continuing to have sixth sense with surprise songs 👏🤯

Tess7

I do not hate Joe. I do not think he was perfect though. I’m sure Taylor wasn’t either. She does allude to things in the last 2 albums. My mind still goes back to “Do something Babe, Say something babe, risk something- I got nothing, unless you’re choosing me.” I pulled him in when he was drifting away. Resentment. He was thinking of her. All that youth, for free. In one conversation, she tore it all down. She was mad as hell. Even when her reputation was at the bottom, she was still Taylor Swift. I don’t think Joe ever understood that. None of them did. Travis at least seems to get it. Joe has a movie coming out. He did this interview because he kind of had to. Just my thoughts- I wish him the best. I enjoyed hearing your reactions and thoughts, as always 😊

Clare

Btw- Charlie XCC is engaged to the 1975 drummer. There was also some odd videos from a listening session for her new album where the crowd were being very anti- Taylor.

Jessie

Also the lyrics of should've said no kind of suit Carolina as well - "should've know that what, what you did with her would get back to me"...!!!!

Hunter

The switch from “That was really a moment in time” to “ok well …” 😭

kai

just want to say charli xcx addressed the statement about rep tour back in 2019, and she says that all of her answers were boiled down to that one sentence and didnt include when she says she was grateful, and the context that she had previously been playing many 18+ gigs. this was her tweet https://x.com/charli_xcx/status/1158832179398533120 also it seems like she was unhappy opening for tours in general, and she decided then that she would stop and she hasn’t opened for anyone since

Laura R

For me, the effectiveness of The Manuscript as a TTPD closer is in its flip of the 'tortured artist' trope. She's been playing with that trope throughout the album, and, while The Manuscript's first half describes a lot of pain ('torture' if you will), the second half flips to a release of that pain. Clara Bow is SUCH a strong closer for the first half of the album, but it is still uncovering a type of torture that artists go through in the industry. I like that The Manuscript is really about letting go of pain... and like you said, it seems like that heartbreak from Jake really shaped how she navigated life for a long time, so maybe having that experience of releasing that pain with the ATW10 film made her feel like she can now process breakups differently. I mean, she still obviously feels the pain deeply... we have a double album about it... but maybe releasing the damage from that original breakup made her better equipped to feel the hurt of her current breakup in the moment but then let it go without carrying it with her so heavily moving forward.

Becky Tucker

Love you chickens!!!! 🐓 🩷

Laura R

Bonnie too with the Red (at least a song from the album) prediction! The girls were really on top of that mashup.

Peter Oldham

A note about The Black Dog that makes me think it’s about Matty and I’ve wanted to bring this up many times, and this is the perfect opportunity to. “I just don’t understand how you don’t miss me in the shower and remember how my rain-soaked body was shaking.” Wasn’t she with Matty during one of those massive rain shows on the Eras Tour? Nashville, was it?

T

And Bonnie again with youre losing meeee

Micaela

I wonder whether it works as a closer because she is fantasizing about the past again but this time it’s not making her insane like fortnight (or is it?) but she’s at peace that she’s doing it for the fans. It would make sense that going back to an old love and being hurt by it would make her think about another old love…

Ali

There is a song on Charli XCX’s new album where it appears she talks about Taylor. Says she hopes she doesn’t see her backstage at the 1975 shows and that her and Matty break up. Wild!

dachiefs1969

Imagine being Travis and having to hear everyone babble on about Joe, Jake, John, Matt, etc... he's a better guy than I am. LOL

tbeckett

Also she’s engaged/or in a relationship with a bandmate of Matty on the 1975

Tspd7

I LOVE THE ZOOM INS THERE SO FUNNY😂

Sara Harms

So will she end the tour with Clara Bow?

elise

I get sad with the idea that a lot of people are going back and trying to reassign songs. I feel like since ttpd the “paternity tests” are just getting out of hand and she has said that’s not what she wants which is why in my opinion she makes the songs intentionally confusing.

lucy lambert

i fear that with all of these songs she's done recently she's definitely gonna play renegade or the alcott soon !!!! i would DIE

Richard

I never got why people don't understand that the manuscript is a great closer. It is a perfect closure. It is about Jake in part but it is about Taylor's whole career. Part is Travis with dating people her own age and the end perfectly incapulates the whole album saying the story of work is ours now.

StatMatt

I think that Clara Bow and the Manuscript are kind of two sides of the same coin. Clara Bow reflects on the pain of being a famous artist, while the Manuscript reflects on how important her art is to both herself and her fans. That's why I love them both as album closers.

ton

Actually the Starting Line can work for either… yes Matty references their music in a song but the band could easily be a fave for Joe and Taylor as well as she had similar music exposures as MH would have so I don’t think it’s absolute. Any more than ATW is about Harry just because he likes sweet disposition ✌️

WeatherJoy

Emily but how are you brain melded with Taylor right now.

Christine Violet

For sure, but I just think it’s curious that in FOTS she uses the phrase “now we’re at the starting line” when referring to Matty, and then later in the Black Dog mentions the band by the same name. To me, it’s like a clue that the two songs are about the same person! Also I made a typo in my previous comment that made it look like I was talking about a 1975 song but I’ve edited it to make it more clear now! ♥️

Green Wolf Gaymer

As a Brit, "Only the young" would be perfect right now as we have a general election next month.

Katrina

Joe's comments were very respectful and I think he has every right to say his piece (just like Taylor did through her music) and then move on. Swifties need to just leave him alone.

Gordon Werner

We’re hearing from Joe most likely because Taylor is in the UK and he’s probably being harassed by the paparazzi

Ellie Vannest

you guys NEED to play Mastermind with how accurate ur surprise song guesses have been!!

Jenny M

I was just thinking that what would happen if she put Carolina on Reputation TV because it feels like the energy of that Album.

WeatherJoy

Hmmm I’m not convinced The Manuscript is just the Jake and All Too Well. It’s prob referring to it somewhat, but I just don’t feel the actors hitting their marks is the film. I still think for TTPD she’s not just singing about that. That is just not what Taylor would do imo. I think the reason you are struggling with it being a closer is because you are distracted by everyone’s All Too Well interpretation. It really really works for the entire album!! Here’s my interpretation and it hit me this way from the very beginning. TTPD is a breakup album and essentially more MH than Joe but both. And her whole life her dating life has not only been picked apart by public but also the subject of many of her songs. The manuscript is saying her dating life is over. And in looking back to what had led her to her final place she’s fathomed her story and the men that shaped her. Especially those first 2 John and Jake… she meshed it with Red because that second one is Jake and because the actors hitting their marks can be both the movie and the fact that it’s almost she and her “boyfriend” are the actors in the saga and drama that has been told all these years. So finally they are both hitting their marks! Her other relationships were never in synch And then we get to the tears fall in synchronicity with the SCORE which can be her song as in the movie score and also the score in a game which also brings to mind Travis. And at last knew what the agony had been for.. her career the ATW movie and her End Game relationship. This particular story is over. This aspect of her life is over. And the story has a life of its own beyond her specific details as she’s given it to us. All this being said I think Travis will be in London with her and their engagement will be announced while he’s there with her. We shall see if I’m right. But if you fathom this song is saying her dating life and all its drama is over at the end of TTPD it works perfectly as the closer.

Chloe

these were my surprise songs a 5 hour drive home later and i’m still not over hearing carolina

Ang ⋆。°✩

Thinking about The Manuscript as the album closer, and I think it's really powerful to reflect on how every heartbreak and breakup will always bring you back to the first time your heart was broken or the first time you were betrayed. It brings those feelings back.... all too well.

Jordyn

I wish you guys would have read the entire article. The quotes themselves weren’t too bad but crazy that he’s even speaking about her now. And the way it was all contextualized in the article and the descriptors of Joe vs Taylor were wild.

Dr Ozzy

I just find it odd that he has no problem speaking on his personal life now that they broke up but “wouldn’t even go into that side of the world” when asked simple questions about her in their relationship. Either you don’t want to talk about it or you do.

Dr Ozzy

My only issue with him giving that interview is if your response to “what’s your favorite song by your girlfriend” is “im not going to get into that side of the world” and you’re establishing a boundary (that you have every right to do!) then why is it now suddenly a topic you don’t mind discussing lol

libby

i interpret the first part of manuscript to be about her relationship with jake and then towards the outro it changes from it being about atw10 to every song taylor has written, which is fitting for the last song on ttpd bc all of these songs are for the fans now and she can now put every relationship that ended to rest.

Bex Sammartino

I think the narrative of The Manuscript is about the Red era up until the pronoun/perspective shift. At the end, Taylor switches from “she” to “I”, and this to me changes it from just about that time. It now becomes about all of her songs/videos/art about her own pain and heartbreak. The lyrics at the end are then about the entirety of her career.

rosie

after all these rogue songs i fear losing renegade before my show 🥲

Laura Donovan

I was at the show the piano was too wet to work and she did red on guitar and she made a joke the piano version was going to be sad and slow anyway. Glad she finally got to do it lol

Allison

She sang "actors" maybe it was for Jake and Joe 🤔🤔

Katrina

The relationship is over so there is nothing to protect, and I think this is really addressing the toxic Swifties more than revealing anything private about what when on between them. I can't blame him for saying nothing while in the relationship because the press, and even more so Swifties, would only demand more. It's not for us to decide what his boundaries should be.

Meredith

I may be remembering wrong, but didn’t she once say before playing maroon that it was about something that happened a really long time ago??

Amanda P

I agree!! I really think she’s fathoming that Matty isn’t even worthy of being sung about right now hence why she’s reflecting on the Joe relationship instead & doing less TTPD surprise songs!

Amanda P

I agree! I read the whole thing & he really didn’t say much in my opinion!

Den

The Manuscript lyric video is a movie script. I believe this means that same as filming All Too Well healed her, the new movie she is working on is doing the same but at a much larger scale. That is what links the All Too Well short film experience, the rest of her relationships she lists on the song and it being the album closer as well as the bonus song in each original variant. It is very important for her because a long format movie is her new way of healing thru her art.

Meredith

The pushing strollers line in the manuscript always feels like a connection back to Matty to me. He promised her something similar and then also ghosted. Maybe there are parallels she sees between the two relationships and knows that she can move on now. The manuscript for the all too well film, but also the TTPD album as a manuscript for her relationship with Matty. Neither story is hers anymore.

AE

This mashup confirmed something for me… I think the time she was filming the all too well music video, it was coinciding with the beginning of the end for her and Joe. The second great love for her was echoing what had happened before. But this time she knew to be the one to leave instead of left. That fundamentally, some of the same issues were the same. “You kept me like a secret, but I kept you like an oath.” I think the manuscript was written to show that film was a mirror to what was happening at the time and she needed to be reminded in order to move forward.

Katie Walmsley

Yes, +your point about staying away from TTPD songs! Makes total sense.

WeatherJoy

I’m not trying to say anything for sure. But this article comes out where he states it was a in long loving fully committed relationship with her and then she sings I know he did it but I just can’t prove it over and over. In light of Great War and Hoax and “my friends said it wasn’t right to be scared every day of a love affair.” Ummmmmm I know he did it but I just can’t prove it. I can’t shake this. 😬🤷🏼‍♀️

sleepless_dream (Lauren)

as much as I think the paternity testing is too much, I very strongly believe the song is mostly about Matty for a lot of reasons. one reason is that there's a Black Dog bar in Ireland I believe that MH went to after/during a tour he was on. Also, Matty covered the song Best of Me by The Starting Line and said "shout out to 30 year olds". idk if there's really any evidence of Joe dating younger women after Taylor. and if Taylor left Joe and Matty ghosted her, the lines about "I'll never leave, never mind" which are said to her by the love interest, and "tail between your legs you're leaving" don't make any sense for Joe. "you say I abandoned the ship" so she left Joe and he was holding on for dear life, not letting go. If he said that SHE was abandoning the ship, then it makes no sense for him to "tail between his legs he's leaving". the whole song screams Matty. the bar that has claimed to see joe, never actually said that, the bar owner was asked if a "blonde is ever there" and they were obviously alluding to Taylor herself, the bar owner simply replied "yes I see a blonde person in regularly" clearly hinting at Taylor coming in, not Joe. either way, it's obvious that they're milking it for profit, which makes sense. point being, the bar owner can't be used as solid evidence when we know there's another Black Dog bar in a different country that Matty has been to.

Liz

Re: Maroon. Joe doesn’t seem like someone who would be drinking his roommates cheap-ass screw top rose. Jake seemed way to pretentious as well. You know who loves wine, even cheap wine…Matty. But the lyrics ‘ How the hell did we lose sight of us again? Sobbin' with your head in your hands Ain't that the way shit always ends?’ That doesn’t sound like how we have heard about Matty through her songs. He ghosted her. He left in the middle of the night (Question). That does sound more like Joe. I hadn’t thought about Jake.

AE

Also I’ll add this: The Three Loves Theory posits that people experience three significant types of love throughout their lives, each serving a unique purpose. The first is often a youthful, idealistic love, sometimes seen as infatuation. (Jake) The second is a more complex love, where lessons are learned from hardships and challenges. (Joe) The third, regarded as the love we don’t see coming, is the love that offers a deep connection and acceptance. (Travis 🤞🏻 🤭)

Jess.

To me the Manuscript makes sense as the song she chose to join the og album given that the story she tell us is that Jake was the first one to put her through what Joe and then Matty did: the promises of marriage, house, children.

maddie (taylorsverion)

i think the manuscript is about a different person each line if you break it down it seems like each line or few lines change to describe a new person/relationship she was in!

sleepless_dream (Lauren)

I looooove Renegade and Alcott 😭 how funny if she sang Beautiful Ghosts 🤩 I want her to do every single song possible heeehehe sweeter than fiction? also I still want Need released 😢 (I don't like Only the Young though because it doesn't make sense, any one of any age can fight for what's right. I respect the feeling behind it, "don't give up and keep fighting" is a great message that we all need, but it's for all ages.)

Kami

Joe's only crime was for being a lousy boyfriend. And people don't know what to do with that.

Amanda P

There is another bar called the Black Dog in Ireland where Matty was touring in June last year, they even had a “Team Matty” sign (ugh)! The “rain-soaked body” reference screams Matty to me since it was pouring when she made the “I’ve never been so happy” speech & sang Question 🫣She also says “SOME bar called the Black Dog” which sounds like she’s never been, she’s just seeing his location there and is hurt he’s moving on so easily/hoping everything reminds him of her (so relatable tbh, SUCH A SUPERIOR SONG 😭)!

Jade

I think The Manuscript is a way for her to remember that making art is what will heal her and that’s why it comes at the end of TTPD because writing these songs allowed her to move on

Jackie

Gillette rain show was toward the end of may which is rumored about the time things bw them were falling apart! I only remember this bc Bill Belichick was at that show and praised her in his quote on the TNT relationship 😂

sleepless_dream (Lauren)

copy pasted this: as much as I think the paternity testing is too much, I very strongly believe the song is mostly about Matty for a lot of reasons. one reason is that there's a Black Dog bar in Ireland I believe that MH went to after/during a tour he was on. Also, Matty covered the song Best of Me by The Starting Line and said "shout out to 30 year olds". idk if there's really any evidence of Joe dating younger women after Taylor. and if Taylor left Joe and Matty ghosted her, the lines about "I'll never leave, never mind" which are said to her by the love interest, and "tail between your legs you're leaving" don't make any sense for Joe. "you say I abandoned the ship" so she left Joe and he was holding on for dear life, not letting go. If he said that SHE was abandoning the ship, then it makes no sense for him to "tail between his legs he's leaving". the whole song screams Matty. the bar that has claimed to see joe, never actually said that, the bar owner was asked if a "blonde is ever there" and they were obviously alluding to Taylor herself, the bar owner simply replied "yes I see a blonde person in regularly" clearly hinting at Taylor coming in, not Joe. either way, it's obvious that they're milking it for profit, which makes sense. point being, the bar owner can't be used as solid evidence when we know there's another Black Dog bar in a different country that Matty has been to.

Stephanie J.

I’m the last one at this party— BUT POTENTIAL FATHOMING: now knowing Joe gave so many poignant and respectful quotes this week, the Cornelia street x maroon and Great War x losing me mashups, do we think Tree, Taylor , and Joe’s camp coordinated this week out of respect for her history with Joe? Like doesnt all this feel very conclusive? Kind of shuts down a lot of the questions and rumors? I can imagine they are both respectable adults who want to move on but the public kind of won’t leave it alone. I wouldn’t put it past Tree to plan this all out so that Taylor, Joe, and the public can truly put all the noise to rest. Let her live her life with Travie!!!! P.S. I am so so so elated to have found your page this past year. I literally plan my day around having a little snack and working my way through past content. Such a joy to put my kiddies in bed and look forward to my chats and reacts time!

Sarah

The Manuscript is, I think, one of the main keys to understanding TTPD. Jake was her first love and it came with him dangling the promise of marriage and children, which we know was just a lie in the end. I’m sure that left a mark on Taylor and is forever a sore spot that she’s carried throughout her life and in all her relationships. It’s why there’s so much about marriage and having a family and broken promises on TTPD. Joe and Matty clearly stabbed her sore spot in different ways—Joe making her feel strung along without giving it to her, Matty weaponizing it to get her to be with him. None of the men in her life have given what she wants for 10+ years and it must hurt so badly after so many times. The Manuscript just happens to tell us where this pain originally stems from (Jake), and helps explain why these two recent break-ups almost (figuratively) killed her. The nice thing about The Manuscript is that Taylor knows the art she makes allows her to heal and process what she’s going through. So with an album that has her furiously exploring these topics and this pattern, her ending on a positive note is so ❤️ what a resilient queen.

Jordan

Wait is The Manuscript (a Jake song) on TTPD because TTPD is her first heartbreak album since Red?! Maybe she’s like reminding herself that she now sings songs from Red (All Too Well) that aren’t painful anymore. And while TTPD is painful now, in 10 years it will be like Red is today?! 😳 a genius. O M G

Eve Marriner

I like how she played Red in Liverpool’s Anfield Stadium as their football team and known as The Reds :)

sleepless_dream (Lauren)

he literally didn't say anything wrong I don't understand those tweets. what he said was actually great. and of course he's speaking up now, he's being harassed online and probably in real life by insane people. he's more mature and polite than I'd be.

sleepless_dream (Lauren)

copy pasted this comment I wrote: as much as I think the paternity testing is too much, I very strongly believe the song is mostly about Matty for a lot of reasons. one reason is that there's a Black Dog bar in Ireland I believe that MH went to after/during a tour he was on. Also, Matty covered the song Best of Me by The Starting Line and said "shout out to 30 year olds". idk if there's really any evidence of Joe dating younger women after Taylor. and if Taylor left Joe and Matty ghosted her, the lines about "I'll never leave, never mind" which are said to her by the love interest, and "tail between your legs you're leaving" don't make any sense for Joe. "you say I abandoned the ship" so she left Joe and he was holding on for dear life, not letting go. If he said that SHE was abandoning the ship, then it makes no sense for him to "tail between his legs he's leaving". the whole song screams Matty. the bar that has claimed to see joe, never actually said that, the bar owner was asked if a "blonde is ever there" and they were obviously alluding to Taylor herself, the bar owner simply replied "yes I see a blonde person in regularly" clearly hinting at Taylor coming in, not Joe. either way, it's obvious that they're milking it for profit, which makes sense. point being, the bar owner can't be used as solid evidence when we know there's another Black Dog bar in a different country that Matty has been to.

sleepless_dream (Lauren)

I think the daylight reference in the song can still be about Joe, but the person that's in the black dog, the person the song is mainly about, is Matty still. bcuz the smoke line is more about her situation, not who the song is about. everything else in the song fits Matty and too many things make no sense for Joe.

Kami

I'm going to strongly but gently push back on the emphasis of that "literally SAVING" her comment. It's not true and diminishes her greatly. Yes he was a crucial part of her support system but well she said it best herself "you don't need to save me....". She wanted him there but she'd have saved herself with or without him.

Ananya

Can I say something about Joe? He’s one of Tay’s exes who still gets support from swifties. He doesn’t really have a fan base (that I’ve seen) other than some swifties. The cheating rumors were fueled by the blind items before the release of TTPD. Also, for some reason I don’t see much hate towards him but after ttpd I saw several swifties turning against Taylor. Maybe it’s just algorithm.

The Renn Domino Experiment

I wonder if Matty disappeared because he wanted to get high and didn't want to do that in front of her. Taylor is in entertainment and probably sees a lot of drug use and the damage it causes. She may have avoided a relationship with Matty for so long because of the drugs.

tbeckett

Also on the front page of the magazine or article it has “London Boy” right out in front and Joe Alwyn in smaller font underneath it….

Carol

Em: I feel like she’ll do the manuscript. Bonnie: she could mash this with someone from evermore. She’s due to do something from Red. How? How do you girls always know????? 🤗

Ananya

Fortnight video where Taylor is in the rain on the telephone booth. Also, I don’t remember clearly but the night when Taylor performed at one of the 1975 shows, didn’t she have a telephone? Maybe I’m wrong.

Carol

Yes to all of this and same!!

Carol

Wow this makes so much sense. Thank you for this perspective 🙌

Kami

I really can't stomach that speech since realising it can't have been more than a week or two before it all came crashing down on her.

Sarah

Of course, I’m glad it made sense!! It’s something I’ve thought about a lot ever since the song came out lol It’s unfortunate how negative things we experience growing up so greatly impacts our present/future. Jake just happens to be an unfortunate blueprint man for Taylor. 😔

Ellen Blair

I’m from NC and Carolina has always felt Evermore to me. I love it. Evermore was always my favorite album but now it’s competing with TTPD. 😅😁

Madi

As a native North Carolinian I am personally offended Carolina wasn’t performed in my state🥲 that really hurttttt I love that song SO MUCH

Madi

I think she already owns Carolina tho since it came out in 2022

Emelie

Guys did you register that Joe said the breakup happened the week before it went public?? Maybe I missed you talking about it but I find it so interesting bc ttpd gave me the impression that the breakup happened earlier (maybe even mid 2022 already)…

Carol

Wait “este’s a friend of mine, we meet up every Tuesday”…. She’s playing in Cardiff on Tuesday and the girls are in the UK right now? 👀

Emelie

I feel like Travis couldn’t care less tbh 😄 everyone has a past

Alec Beasley

my perception of the manuscript being the official album closer is just to say that that’s what her art is to her. her realizing it’s true meaning. with every album she releases, “the story isn’t hers anymore” once it’s released

Carol

I agree. Especially how she ends the entire album with “the stories aren’t mine anymore” Feels like she’s telling us that although we might be shocked at who the album seems to be about, the moment has passed for her and she has moved on.

Emelie

Wow! What’s the song called?

Katie Wednesday

She’s been staying in a rented house in the Cotswolds and taking a helicopter to and from all the Liverpool shows every night! She will probably do the same for Cardiff

Silke Huybrechts

I think in The Manuscript she is reminiscing about the last time she felt this heartbroken, and how 'looking backwards might be the only way to move forward' and how 'at last she knew what the agony had been for'. So I think she knows that writing this manuscript, TTPD, will help her heal in the same way that writing Red helped her back then. She took the pain and turned it into art.

angel (plnkblue)

everybody: when she mashes songs up, that means she’s confirming who/what it’s about me: the manuscript is the most overtly speak now coded song since wcs, in this thesis i will—

angel (plnkblue)

I would also say that The Manuscript is as much about this chapter as it is those older chapters, because its the ultimate conclusion to the process that birthed TTPD, and is point blank explaining how TTPD as an album is an act of self-excavation, trying to understand why the main album’s story happened by tracing her own personal habits and trauma responses and how those impact the person she is today. All of it started in Speak Now, and once you see it, its impossible to unsee it. The Manuscript isn’t meant to be a closer that represents her at this moment, it represents her ending this single particular journey of self-examination, and realizing that the conclusion puts her right back where it all started: Speak Now era. I literally have a legitimate like 20k+ word essay I want to write on this whole thing because god people need to FATHOM.

Kiki

Girls you need to read the entire article from the "London Boy"

Pia Fleig

Emily, your predictions were spot on!

Aloha Record Sargent

The Manuscript is important as the album closer because it helps us understand *why* she writes about her relationships (which is what she is doing on TTPD). She needs to write what she knows -- looking backward is the only way to move forward. And it has a deeper meaning, because once she's written it down and given it to us, she is also helping us to understand our own pain, and then she can be free of hers. So The Manuscript helps us fathom why she wrote this album.

Carol

Write it ❤️

Pia ♡

for me The Manuscript is her closing thought on the tortured poet concept. because she is a tortured poet, she’s been through these things. but unlike matty, she doesn’t live in this self pity, she creates the art to work through these things. so it’s kind of a positive closer on the album concept.

ana

me at the beginning when you both mentioned the manuscript and red, already knowing she had in fact played the manuscript and red: 😳

Aloha Record Sargent

One problem with Maroon being about Joe: The very first time she played Maroon as a surprise song, in her intro speech at the piano, she said: "Midnights is all about nights throughout my life, things that keep me up, memories you keep going back to. So this one was something I wrote about from a long time ago" It seems she was giving us a hint that it was not about Joe, but about a relationship from her past.

nicole

Maroon really confuses me who the muse is, but I think this new interview almost confirms to me that it can’t be Joe. He said they were in a long, committed relationship. I just don’t think they were on again off again like everyone theorised. Sure, maybe they had rough patches, but his wording kind of puts an end to the theories that they had properly broken up or “lost” one another. I disagree though that there wasn’t enough pain with Matty. Chloe et al and Peter are so sad and so longing. Matty is also obsessed with red wine, and The 1 says ‘rosé flowing with your chosen family’ which could be his band mates.

CJ

The Manuscript is not only about Red or Jake. The lyrics cover so many different relationships and experiences. It was her closing the door for all of it.

Laura Blake

Me watching the grainy livestream of Carolina from North Carolina 😳🥹

angel (plnkblue)

I actually hope she doesn’t play Only The Young because even though there’s an election this year, it is an extremely contentious and tense race, even more so than 2020, and it is inextricably tied to the events happening outside of the US. Even though she is doing her last few US dates around that time, I fear that her playing that song and making any sort of speech before it will make a lot of people upset, especially given her general political silence in every other aspect.

Amy West

I belive charlie xcx is coming up more as a song in her new album seems to be linked to Taylor swift and there connection via matt as she is dating another member of the 1975

Trish 1387 🫶🏼🏈

The only answer to Maroon is to take Jack hostage give him a few drinks and get the answers needed. Maybe he will spill the tea on whatever we need to know on other songs. Gotta love Jack to set the record straight.

Trish 1387 🫶🏼🏈

1 sentence has been Joe’s usual comments about Taylor. That’s the most he has spoken in 6 yrs together. Why speak about it now when he wants to keep it “private”?

Danah

I am only just fathoming how well the Manuscript fits as the close to TTPD. In TTPD she takes us on a journey of her last year or so -- of drama, heartbreak and strong emotions. To close it, The Manuscript is a reminder to her and to us -- of how time and creativity can heal heartbreaks and turn them into art. She goes full circle back to a much earlier heartbreak at the album's very end. It's perfect as the closing song. As always, she is brilliant.

Amy Williams

She just had to perform Red at Anfield - iconic!

Sara Dumanske

i saw a theory that COMPLETELY justifies It’s Nice to Have a Friend: first thing to note is we’re in Pride month. second thing is the phrase “a friend of Dorothy” was used by queer people in the mid-late 20th century to safely tell someone you were queer (Dorothy as in Wizard of Oz, as in Judy Garland, know gay icon). SO “it’s nice to have a friend…. in Dorothea” in JUNE…. it’s perfect.

Maria

This

Jazzy92

I was watching old videos and it’s very interesting reading Taylor’s ‘prologue/instagram post’ introducing midnights now we have TTPD

Jess Brumby

I was going to say with the song Maroon and the way she uses it in her songs like Chloe et al., I think with “Maroon” she is describing the the general death of a “burning red” type of love. She has said that she thought love was Red but true love is actually Golden.. so now upon reflection, any “failed”relationship was actually a Red type of love, and now that that relationship is over it’s faded into Maroon. I don’t think it’s about a person in particular, more the description of a love that’s died and she is describing it as Maroon, a faded/deeper Red. Idk!! I think it’s nice to think of it like that. But let me know your thoughts!!

Maria

I think they probably had breaks and then got back together a few times, but it ultimately ended in early 2023.

nicole

I don’t think you ladies fathomed that Joe confirmed the breakup happened ONE WEEK before the announcement! So it really did happen when she took Invisible String off the setlist. It proves that while Midnights/Evermore/Folklore might have been breakdown albums, they absolutely weren’t breakup albums and they were together until the announcement. It also means that Matty and Joe were quite close to one another, but she does kind of confirm that anyway in FOTS.

nicole

Wow amazing pick up!

nicole

Joe says himself though that it was long and committed, kind of putting to rest that anything tumultuous happened in the relationship.

DeeAnne Herron

I've always linked The Manuscript to the prologue poem.

nicole

Matty’s mum also liked that photo The Black Dog in Cork put on their Instagram! I am so intrigued to see if she plays it in Ireland.

Hannah

Justice for Carolina ❤️

nicole

Wait… I just remembered The 1 also says ‘rosé flowing with your chosen family’ (potentially his band/roommates) 😧

Aloha Record Sargent

Yeah I only remember because of all the previous discussions about the song, when we are all debating about whether it was Jake or Joe!! So I went back to the video of that first secret song performance to get the exact quote. She was really telling us things…

Hannah

No I know the last few nights mashups have been the most offensive ones ever but I’m a massive Carolina and No Body No Crime stan. This floored me 🔥

Jaime Kelley

To me the outro of the manuscript really ties into her last relationship “one last souvenir of my trip to your shores” she references boats/ships/shores SO often when writing about Joe. So maybe while processing this big heartbreak, she was reminded of the heartbreak of red. And the end she says okay, this album (souvenir) is the last I’ll speak of you (Joe)

Liz

👀

Liz

I also feel like some of the most devastating songs she has written about painful heartbreak has actually been about Matty.

P.R. Dayvonne

Re: the manuscript, I don't think it's it's ABOUT the Red relationship (I mean it is, of course, but not the meaning). I think she's just using her biggest example - ATW10 and the music video - to talk about how her art passes onto us. But the verses work for both the red relationship and matty one cuz they were both short lived. At least that's what I think the connection is.

charlychops

Although its about Jake, but i really think the last verse is kind of summing up the whole last period. She's moving on from Red, but also its made her realise that shes over Joe and Matty and everything. Truely into a whole new chapter

Emmie

I always took that the bridge of the manuscript to be about the obvious of the short film but also was thinking her saying her tears fell with the score and dancing having the sparks could be a double reference to Travis. Like now she in a place where the spark is alive and watching him score and realising she in love for really with how good she feels. I think her putting the manuscript last was perfect as the whole concept of the tortured poet is that their art is fuelled by the torture they experience. For her this has been mainly been heartbreak and i think it’s quite symbolic in the album discuss how these where the hardest losses of her life but then go back to her first proper heartbreak and realise she is over that now and the same will happen for this one which will lead us into a album about maybe Travis. I get a feeling this album even though only mainly about Matty/Joe it has an undercurrent of her full life with her career and her hopes of love. So by the end she is say she may still right songs about the past (present can’t exist without the past vibe) but she isn’t in that place anymore she is doing it for us. Also I like how she acknowledges how sadly without the stuff with Kim may not have made those albums but doing the same with her first proper heartbreak that she sees how it impacted her art like a tortured poet as she wouldn’t have some of her tortured art without it.

charlychops

This is actually why i do like C&R. They do speak about it, but they don't just do that and look at the deeprr meaning behind the songs. I think they strike the balance between the gossip and analysis really well.

Danah

Some of her songs seem like composite sketches with multiple influences. But Maroon seems like Joe, to me. A key reason is that it feels like Taylor herself is telling us this by mashing it up with Cornelia Street. Not every mashup involves the same influence, but that one in Liverpool Night 1 felt pointed. Also, the vibes of the song feel very Joe -- with a slow sad loss developing over time (the lips I used to call home....and calling back to a memory of the one I was dancing with in NY). Also lyrics like, "How'd we end up on the floor anyway? You say, 'Your roommate's cheap-ass screw-top rosé, that's how.'" That sounds like a guy who wasn't exactly super wealthy/successful when they met. Not like Jake, who was a Hollywood actor, but it fits Joe well who was starting off as an actor. "Maroon" isn't necessarily a direct connection to "Red" -- rather, it's consistent with her using colors to represent emotions (blue, golden, red, maroon) and the way that most heartbreaks tend to take on a darker and more muted tone (after the initial first crushing heartbreak, like Jake) as you go along in life. Particularly a heartbreak that happens slowly as a relationship dies...something that is more maroon than red.

charlychops

100% I've always felt the last verse switches to singing to more recent relationships and being like, I've moved on from that and I've moved in from you in the same way

Leen

Yes!

Laura Houston

Omg I had the exact same realisation about Question…? when I listened to it in the car the other day. Also, I’m all in on The Manuscript being about Jake and the ATW short film.

Hannah

Same. I think we need to also take into account that the fact that she chose it as the album closer is a message in and of itself no matter the situation that inspired the song for her. She always says the songs are ours once they are released. It doesn’t matter if it is about Jake and that relationship for her, for someone listening to the album the manuscript is a song about closer no matter what relationships the person listening to the album is relating the songs to themselves. The manuscript is fully a closure song which makes it a perfect closer to a breakup album touching on the many phases of the breakdown of multiple relationships.

Claire Webby

This is such a good way of seeing it

Rime

I just love how respectful and gentleman Joe Alwyn has always been when it comes to their private life. It reminded me of how much I loved their relationship and loved how much effort they both put in protecting it from media and fans opinions and speculations. She said it in Miss Americana : they both agreed on keeping their relation private and she needed that. Fans were too eager to easily speculate that he was trying to dimish her shine (or worse), espacially with the upcoming of the Eras tour, which she never said he was doing in any of her song. I mean Rep tour was huge, she was already a world star et he was there for her. I always feel uncomfortable with people judging him in his relationship and comparing him to Travis. Just because Travis feed the empathetic hunger, as one would say, of fans by being public and open about her in interviews doesnt make Joe anyless supportive as a boyfriend. It just emphasises that Travis's more extraverted and media trained; In the end, what matter is that Taylor's boyfriend meet Taylor's needs not that of the Swifties. I'm just having a big moment with those joe songs mashups and I'll always miss him as her muse <3.

Dorka

wow your predictions were so on the spot!!

Marius

I think the reason she put the manuscript last is because she probably wanted to end the entire album with “the story isn’t mine anymore”. Something I think she touched on in either the prologue or the epilogue as well

Rime

I dont think he speak all of sudden about Taylor. I think he just finally adress the srutiny he's been under since the breakup . Questions about Taylor Swift must've burst since one year and a lot more since the tortured poet came out. He was bound to have a comment on that but he doesn't really say much and he's being as private and respectful as he's always been.

charlychops

I kinda hope she plays yhe black dog in Dublin because of this. I think joe mentioned the black dog in vauxhall as a way to say fu to people cashing in on their breakup, same as Taylor does her self, like How Did It End.

Lauren Dawson

about the maroon conversation: back in 2022 when she was announcing the songs, i duetted the maroon one and in my reaction i said something like “omg it’s like red!” and she liked that tiktok… i took that as confirmation it’s about jake and tying into red but after the mashup the other day i am so conflicted!! i feel like idk if she would like my tiktok saying it was like red if she didn’t intend it to be about jake???

Georgia

I really enjoyed this reaction - I think this is the perfect balance of getting to watch the surprise songs live but also check to see if anything else happens (like a better recording or recapping a section that may have been missed). Thank you for a lovely video to watch this morning ! x

Hannah

💯 it is literally a song about closure put as the album closure on a breakup album about multiple relationships. “And it’s not hers anymore” as she releases it. It’s the closure song for anyone listening to the album no matter what situations they are thinking of themselves.

Rime

Well...i don't think it's the same thing, he just finally adress the harrassment and srutiny he's been under since the breakup . He was bound to have a comment on that during his movie's promotions and interviews and he doesn't really say much in the end.

Karolina Hołub

I just have three points to Maroon being about Matty that I don't know if you consider: 1. Red wine. Is it kinda Matty thing? Even in prolog to TTPD she is saying something about stained wine lips right? And of course, Maroon is full of red wine. And also I think Halsey was also talking about him drinking red wine a lot btw? So I think it is just his thing. 2. The rubies that I gave up? So she left because she wasn't ready (too impare by my youth?) 3. The "Your roommate's cheap-ass screw-top rosé, that's how" that is not giving Jake at all, it could be Joe I agree, but somehow... it just feel Matty style so much

Pixie

I also think it‘s the perfect album closer, and message wise the most important one of the four vinyl bonus tracks, so makes total sense to me that it is the OG one 🤍

lauri

Emily should definitely start playing mastermind lol

Sarah

My impression is that Matty ghosted her this time around but COSOSOM implies to me that she left him back in 2015, “You needed me but you needed drugs more and I couldn’t watch it happen” and then further on “all to outrun my desertion of you”

Leah Close

clara bow on the last show would be pretty cool

Sarah

I think this speaks more to Taylor’s anxious attachment style than anything factual. Even Lover has the lyrics “And I’m highly suspicious that everyone who sees you wants you”. There was always an undercurrent of anxiety from Taylor’s side, and Joe probably never gave her the grand public expressions of love she needed to feel secure.

Maja Gunhold

if she re-records 'you'll always find your way back home' that will be my last day on this planet cos my soul would be sucked out of my body to float up to heaven and drop down to hell at the same time

Kassie

What’s the link to Red?

Graciekay

The stadium is red and it’s the football club colours

Lindsay

Everyone in the comments discussing who the manuscript/maroon are about and I just wanna know who dared to try and message Bonny - what’s the beef?! 😂

Cecilia Sparke

How about Renegade mashed with This is me Trying?

Brittany Diamond

Agreed, Maroon is about Joe insofar as the entire album is trying to fathom why her relationship with him was going wrong by exploring her past for any and all possibilities. It's a direct reminiscence of Jake but it's implicitly referencing the similarities between how she and Jake broke down versus how she and Joe were breaking down at the time.

marta k.

we need this comments before swiftball 😭 i did guess carolina though

𝐃𝐄𝐌𝐈💖

I don’t normally comment but I just wanna say I’m so thankful that you girlies post these videos and how much effort u put into them,whenever I watch a video it feels like I’m just talking to my friends about Taylor and you both make me feel so connected!!!💖💖

Inés Fernández A.

I agree that the Manuscript is a reflection on ATW and RED but i don’t think that is all. In my opinion Jake was his first love, like real LOVE, and it broke her in ways that she didn’t comprehend until she was much older, affecting how she view relationships and how she behave in them (it happens to all of us) specially amidst the scrutiny that she suffered since them about her personal life. But, and here is an important point that we tend to forget, she made the Manuscript the bonus track in the standard version of the album so she wanted TTPD to end with this song. I think it talks about how music is her way of healing and processing, how she now is mature enough and healed enough to let go of things. In the end i think it’s her way of telling us that she is in other point in her life and that’s one more reason why I think that TTPD is not getting the tradicional promo, like this is it (no interviews, singles or MVs) this is raw Taylor letting it all out and moving on. (Hahaha I paused the video to write this and I just watch you mention the bonus track part🤣🤣)

Inés Fernández A.

With these I don’t mean that she will retire or anything like that, on the contrary I think she is more exited than ever to make music, at least that’s how she comes across from watching her at eras the last few months

Inés Fernández A.

First, the interview was leaked and posted (I read it on twitter) before the magazine was released so I don’t know how accurate it is. Now, about Joe, I think he didn’t say anything wrong, maybe he came across like trying to victimize himself a bit about the public scrutiny which I totally get, but the thing that always rubs me the wrong way about that is that he knew who she was, it’s not like she was an unknown up and coming singer when they met. Other than that I didn’t see anything wrong with his answers (well he answered which in itself is a change, but let’s leave it at that). Now, the problem with the article is the approach of the journalist and the snarky tone it’s uses in the article toward Taylor. It is very clear the opinion the author have about Taylor and it’s not a good one.

Elvia Kristoffersen

He is allowed to tell his side of the story unless he has signed an NDA. I dont think that he said much, only what the girls pointed out, that he was fully committed (not cheated) and when it ended. I also miss Joe as a muse, but I'm glad they both are happy/happier now.

Laura Gallan

Weeeeeeping for The Manuscript x Red mashup

Eirini

I think the only reason that Joe maybe decided to speak now was because the heat has died down a bit…. I do think he’s a bit scared of the public, so he wouldn’t want to address it when everyone was still talking about it etc, which I respect, but I do agree that him never showing up is actually sad… I am not sure about the NYU thing though, because I have a feeling that maybe Taylor didn’t even want him there… maybe they weren’t in the best place and she didn’t want to damage that milestone for her by having an unappreciative soon to be ex boyfriend there ?

chāruzu

did you end up getting tickets to London?!!!

Grace

Omg wait what song, I only skimmed through brat!!

Anna-Lisa

Didn‘t find anything about it in the comments but regarding the black dog topic: have you guys picked up that there is a bar called the black dog somewhere in ireland near a place that the1975 were playing around the break-up news? they had a #teammatty poster up after ttpd came out which could point that he visited the bar when they were in that area. it fits the fact that she is saying „into some bar“ and not into some pub in the song. i personally think the people of the black dog in london just got a good marketing game with all the pr they did right after ttpd came out. and i‘m not going to begin with the fact that matty healy covered a song by the starting line in one of their concerts 😄

Ali

Sympathy is a knife!

Sam

I’m not a Charli XCX fan and have never even listened to her music, but she did issue a clarification that I think does make some sense saying the sentence was taken out of context.. she said before Rep tour she had been playing only 18+ clubs so it was “weird playing for 5 year olds based on how she was used to performing.” She did go on to say that she was so grateful to open for Taylor and appreciated it. Maybe damage control but I can kinda see how it could have been taken out of context. But then again, she’s dating the 1975 drummer, so who knows how that factors in. 🤷🏼‍♀️

Daniel K

I don’t find it curious at all that Joe is speaking to his past relationship now. We’re talking about a very long, significant relationship that began in his mid-twenties that he’s now had over a year to process and conduct his own post-mortem of. He’s no longer the same person who, with Taylor, set the boundaries of how to navigate their relationship in a world that was preoccupied with its minutiae. It’s his to process however he sees fit, just like Taylor. 🤷🏽‍♀️

Farhana

I honestly think that The Manuscript is the best closure for the album, even more than Clara Bow and here's why. Red was her first break up album and a heartbreak that really rocked her. And TTPD puts her through similar but even worse heartbreak. It's doubly worse as it deals with fall out of 2 relationships and while the song is about the Jake and all too well situation I think it's much more than that. It's reflecting on how much breakups can break her emotionally but the reason it deserves the closure spot is because it comes with the realisation that yes we went through a heartbreak, she might again in the future but it's okay because she has her music and she has us. Cause through ttpd we went through alot but now she's realised no matter if things go wrong again and she's heartbroken she will always have her music to help her out and she will have us and that's why I think manuscript is the best closer ttpd had as its reflective but also looks into the future

HollyKP

I was at Liverpool night 1!! Soo good xxx

Erin M

If Taylor ever plays Only The Young, I think it would be in Indianapolis because it’s the weekend before the US presidential election

Ash94

I think getaway car would mash up with only the young really well!

Ash94

Me too!!!! ❤️❤️

maya zutra

THE MANUSCRIPT being the closing is also perfect bc the next new move will be her movie!!!!! 🎥

Polinaxyz

I personally think the Manuscript works really well as the album Closer for TTPD, no other Songs carries the message like this one. The Manuscript ist in my opinion the ONLY song on TTPD that shows true closure. This song might be about all too well the SF but it’s also about her healing through art. I think that TTPD was the art for her to heal from Joe and Matty, and even get some kind of closure from it. The Manuscript tells the story of the Shortfilm, but also could be a “metaphor “ for writing this album, reflecting on both heartbreaks, seeing the similarities, realizing the pattern and healing through creating art. Thats why she said she needed to make this album, she knew how to get over it, because it worked with her Worst heartbreak. That’s why she chose the very last lines to be “ The only thing that’s left ist the manuscript […] now and then I reread the Manuscript, but the story isn’t mine anymore.” Because we as fans are gonna do with this album the exact same thing as with ATW, we’re gonna change it for her and she knows it.

Nancy

Weirdly, I've been really loving the manuscript as the closing track. I can totally see why on a surface level it seems weird to have a reflection on red as the closer, but I think the overall message I've been taking from it, is that Taylor writing about her pain and giving it to the world is a truly healing experience. Ending this extremely emotional and painful album with essentially a case study of what her music and storytelling is able to do when it's out in the world, is a perfect note to end on. That last line alone is enough to convince me of how well it works as a closer to any album. "But the story isn't mine anymore"

laiz zorzo

And then 4 out of 5 pages of the interview are about Taylor, her fame and her relationships

laiz zorzo

About her singing in a higher register we have to remember she is sick, maybe it's easier for her like this

Joan Chan

To me, the Manuscript makes a lot of sense as an album closer for TTPD. It’s interesting how she gives these further details about how Jake was dong a version of love bombing and manipulative flirting bringing up babies before they’d even had sex (especially since she was so young), and that echoing how Matty lovebombed her with rings and cradles. In the Manuscript I hear her reflecting on how time and creating art has helped her release such a painful time, and I would imagine that brings her a lot of comfort as she uses her music to now release a whole other very painful time. It feels very connected to her summation poem as well, how she sees that she writes the worst men best, putting Matty into the archive with the rest of her works.

Pia Fleig

I didn't know that! That's so interesting!

alden

yeah i admit that could’ve been phrased better but he was crucial to her escape during that time and i wanted to draw emphasis to his role bc he loved her when the whole world (hyperbole) turned on her. and i personally know people that hopped on the hate train in 2016 that are now “swifties” (since midnights) who hate on joe so excessively and it’s kind of irritating. but i admit “literally saving her” might’ve been greatly hyperbolized as well. thanks kami :)

x

The Manuscript as the closer of TTPD to me is perfect. In my mind I visualize somebody writing down all of those memories and stories in a dark empty office. Then they just put it in a letter and leave it on a table for someone to find it. They pack up everything, every scrap of paper and trinkets, and leave the office permanently. (Perhaps this image of an office in my mind is due to the fortnight teaser). So it just feels very finalizing like a series finale. It feels like a full stop.

Jentallygirl

Really well said… and I’m sure with so many UK shows ramping up, he’s feeling much more pressure in general. A year feels like a reasonable amount of time to pass before reflecting and making it known that he does actually hear things, but still intends to generally remain private, even if we Swifties lose our minds over some completely offensive London mashups, lol… I’m glad he’s likely not weighing in more than what he’s already said. No matter what happens, Taylor needed (and deserved) so much more love and support from him and in the end he just wasn’t able to give it.

KyraB

I think while the Manuscript is mostly a reflection on the ATW and that relationship I also think it has elements of reflection on many past relationships. I think it being at the end of TTPD is her way of closing the book on all these past relationships and moving on from them. I think it is very likely moving forward in her music we will not get more autobiographical songs about those past relationships anymore. Will she use her emotions and feelings from those times in her life to draw inspiration for new songs of course she will all artists do.

SomDrum

I agree with what so many others have said about the Manuscript. I think that because she has said that TTPD was very much a life raft for her and that she needed the songwriting to get through a difficult and turbulent year, it makes sense that during that time she was also pulling from a previous experience where writing music helped pull the poison out of a relationship wound. The Manuscript is definitely about ATW (in my opinion), but it's also an example and reminder to herself of how this new music will hopefully become a healing force that's bigger than her, with time.

SomDrum

Also, because so much of TTPD talks about her experience on or around the Eras tour, I think that the Manuscript fits right into it. Like I really don't see the Manuscript being about the relationship itself as it is more about the process of making art out of heartbreak. I can only imagine the experience of singing ATW10 with crowds around the world and really giving it to us as the fans has further evolved what that song now means to her.

Ana G.

I think the manuscript is about the “the worst men, I write best” I think there are lines in this song the refer to her relationships with John, Jake, and Matty (during 1989 era) that’s why she weaved Red in there because those were very short but impactful relationships. Now years later she’s looking back on those heartbreaks and making peace with it all, and giving it to us like she said during ATW10.

Katie K

So I think the Charli XCX resurgence thing is because she’s just released a new album and one of the songs on there seems be potentially referring to Taylor. (For reference Charli is dating the 1975 drummer) the lyrics are “Don’t wanna see her backstage at my boyfriend’s show / Fingers crossed behind my back / I hope they break up quick.” 🤷🏼‍♀️ Idk I was at the Rep tour in London when she was the support act and I certainly wasn’t 5, I was like 27! 😂

Jesse Conner

Renegade x So Long London 🫠🫠🫠

Kirstie

Me three!! 😆

Kirstie

Loved this reaction! Please could I request that Ari chicken makes an appearance if Taylor ever does The Black Dog 🐕‍🦺💕

SomDrum

Re: The Black Dog, I have also always wondered if she changed the name of whatever pub or place that actually was. Like seeing a past relationship go into a place they used to frequent, yes, but it makes sense to me to hide the true location from the world to protect the privacy of everyone involved. Even when writing about an ex in anger or sadness, I can only imagine that Taylor would prioritize their safety, knowing that Swifties would descend on whatever place she mentions. Plus, the metaphor of the black dog works so perfectly in the song, I don't think it's a huge stretch to think it was a chosen name rather than a real one.

imogen

Maroon is about Joe and no one can change my mind

imogen

Like I’m as sure that maroon is about Joe like I’m sure that the lakes is about lakes

imogen

Also I think you’re right that the manuscript is more complex than being just about Jake and the atw experience. I think it’s definitely about Joe too and incorporating him being an actor, I think she also touches on matty and Harry

Jentallygirl

The Manuscript is so absolutely heartbreaking to me, but also so beautiful. ❤️ I feel like so many people focus on the song details, but I feel like that’s not the point in this case… the emotions make my heart ache for Taylor! The way she was seemingly so groomed by Jake, and at age 21 so damaged that she’s regressed to only being able to sleep with her Mom. On Midnights, Taylor gave us WCS, which allowed us to reframe and understand the real ANGER she likely still held for John after 12 years… I’m sure we’ll never really know the countless ways that damage truly impacted her. But with Jake, it feels like Taylor lost SO MUCH… and has had to spend the past 13 years finding her way back to the extraordinary woman she has become. 🫶 We’re so quick to think of these relationships as “limited”… but in her world at the time, they probably felt like EVERYTHING. To be able to learn how to trust herself again, to love herself, and to have the courage to consistently bare her soul to us through her music is so incredibly inspiring and emotional for me. She’s so brave… ❤️ And it really seems like she has a truly special love with Travis now… the kind of soulful connection that allows Taylor to trust him, and to trust herself, and to be forgiving and empathetic with HERSELF so she can release Joe and Matty and make room for the life and LOVE she has always wanted for her future. She’s so much more than her current/latest relationship, BUT I know from experience that having the right person loving you and supporting you makes all the difference in the world. Travis seems so emotionally secure and like a true partner for Taylor. I absolutely love that with The Manuscript she seems to finally be able to truly put that pain away in a drawer… or simply sharing the story with us, so that WE can also protect her. 💓🫶🥰 On a side note, I’ve always wondered if Taylor mentions anything similar to “the Professor” by way of advice in her NYU speech… basically helping to heal herself?? That’s simply too much backstory for me to sort thru, lol, but I’m sure *someone* has, lol… 👩‍🎓📚📜📓🙌🤷‍♀️😻🫶

Kellie Mahoney

I really don’t take The Manuscript as THE closer to TTPD, it’s a closer, but Clara Bow is THE closer. An Anthology is a collection of writing that while sharing or contributing to an overall theme, don’t have to relate to each other. I think people are forgetting that and trying to take the album as one whole story like her albums normally are. It’s called an Anthology for a reason. The first half of TTPD tells one story, the Anthology tells 15 different stories, some of them connect but not all of them which is why The Manuscrjpt can close that part of the album. It’s basically describing what each of the songs is doing for her and us.

Brenda1989

I think her lower register doesn’t carry as far in a stadium and so she say it higher bc it has more of an impact during an acoustic set in a stadium

Megan C

I’m just five minutes in, but do you two have psychic powers??? Your ability to predict songs is incredible!! I have a spreadsheet tracking albums by color and counting # of songs by album in Europe, but you are so amazing at your guesses!! PS- only exile on folklore has been played so far in Europe!

Lauren

One of the things I’m kind of getting from TTPD and its anthology is she’s reflecting on her habits. There are quite a few similarities between JM and MH. And I think there are similarities between JG, Calvin, and Joe. Btw Calvin gets a mention because I think he was really jealous of her.

Katrina

If he cheated Taylor would have explicitly said so, that's not the type of thing she would be mysterious about lol. And she's the one that was planning a love affair with Matty, maybe she was afraid of herself cheating.

Megan C

This is so well put. I always wonder about the professor. V unlikely, but Stevie Nicks (because of the poem in the album, the Time quotes, and Clara Bow references… I feel like maybe they have a sweet relationship)? Or Aaron? I always think of how they wrote WCS and maybe Hits Different (and I like to group High Infidelity in there) after folklore won AOTY.

Catherine (YOYOK stan)

I personally think the manuscript is a perfect overall album closer. Ttpd was primarily of a torrid love affair that ended like a tidal wave and in this song she says she revisits this particular love affair not to reminisce per say but to remind herself of what she’s overcome in love. This relationship that affected her so deeply and I’m sure particular moments that reminded her of current breakups of both Matty as well as Joe the manuscript of it all tells her it’s going to be okay. The agony the tears were all for something. She states the professor which to me could be a therapist or a confidant that tells her that this low place you’re currently in is not foreign ground..go back and revisit this land and see that you have been here and you have overcome it to her betterment. And she ends with but the story isn’t mine anymore which is so perfect cuz it’s like therapy for all of us. Her songs are therapy that can help heal us through those horrible moments in love. It’s honestly genius and I hope i did it justice explaining how I’ve processed this song. I think it’s my favorite closer of all her albums. 💕

Lauren

Trust your instincts about MH! I do not think she was pining after him for 10 years. They had a brief fling between Harry and Calvin that took place after 1989 was submitted. She only started re-considering him in 2022(ish) when Jack brought him in to help with writing midnights. And because Taylor had convinced herself that she and Joe were fated because of 2016, he used the second chance trope and the fact that some of his songs talk about her to win her over. Even the surprise songs she sang during their time together showed the cracks. He was NEVER home. He was just a dream turned nightmare and a broken wish.

Ashley

I think the manuscripts’s importance lies with “the story isn’t mine anymore “ — she has said every eras tour show she wants you to listen to the songs for what they mean to you and not to once they ment to her. She knows ttpd is another break up album, but like what the fans did with Red and atw, she knows these heartbreaks will turn into something else!

Brian Bohnert

The old Charlie XCX comments are popping up again because on her new album, Charli has a song called Sympathy is A Knife that is allegedly about Taylor - If you don’t know, Charli is engaged to the drummer of The 1975 which explains a lyric in the song.

TScout

I only recently discovered Charlie was in a band with Matty’s fiancé for years and friends with her since like 2016. And Charlie is also engaged/dating a guy from The 1975. I also didn’t know Matty’s fiancé is an actual “internet starlet”. So Taylor’s reference makes so much sense in Chloe et al now. I always thought that song was about Matty for so many reasons, but if there were any doubts, that really seals it.

Megan C

Yes! It matches the note in the epilogue that she wrote, and how she says in the concert “you’ll make new memories with these songs tonight” in the Lover speech (I know that isn’t exactly right)

Angie

I think it would be really cool if she plays Clara Bow as her last Surprise Song to close out the tour with the knowledge that she is a living legend and has just finished a world wide tour in the biggest stadiums and arenas with sold out tickets everywhere

Megan C

I do feel like my perspective on Maroon has switched this weekend based on the mashup and listening to Bonny and Emily. Something I have been wondering since TTPD released is what, if anything, Joe knew about the meanings of the Midnights songs (and prob folklore and evermore) when they were released. I know we’ll never know, but it’s such a mind f@ck for me. Did they pretend Maroon (just as an example- I know it could be about many people) or Midnight Rain or Bejeweled was just about another person or an abstract concept? Or just written about a time things were rough and then things were better when it was released so it’s okay? Again, I know we’ll never know, but I think about this a lot. He seems so fiercely protective of his privacy that it is so confusing and confounding to fathom that he knew that he was (or maybe wasn’t!!) the subject of some of these songs while they were still together.

Molly Keran

The Manuscript ties into the theme of the tortured poet -- MH is one kind of "tortured poet," being pretentious, self-destructive, and harming people along the way, and Taylor realizes that she is a different kind of tortured artist: she takes the agony and turns it into something that then becomes meaningful to others. MH holds on to his pain (see the title track) whereas Taylor realizes she needs to release it.

Liam Mcfarlane

“Do you think I know how to say this fucking place? Vauxhall?!” *says it right* 😂

Stacy Schindler

I think maroon is Jake. “You left a real fucking legacy” I think fits him better than Matty even. She’s been writing songs about him for the past 15 years… if we think manuscript is him then that’s quite a legacy

Megan C

I wonder if Joe spoke about Taylor now to get ahead of chatter before the London shows? Adjacent question- do you think Travis will go to the London shows? Maybe the last one? I'm projecting, but I imagine playing in London will bring up so many emotions for her.

Chelsea

It’s interesting ending TTPD with the Manuscript when the next new work we will get from her will likely be a movie. It feels like the kind of natural transition that You’re Losing Me as the last bonus track provides between Midnights and TTPD

WeatherJoy

Well that’s kind of my point. She’s not explicitly saying so because she can’t prove it. The Great War, Hoax, You’re losing Me, So Long London, Fresh out The Slammer, Tolerate It, Peace all weave a tale. Clearly their relationship wasn’t working but Taylor has made it very clear she was wanting to marry him. I gave you all that youth for free?! I think when women have an intuition that something is amiss they are generally right.

skizzo

so what are officially the Matty songs on Midnights? Labyrinth, perhaps Glitch, what else?

WeatherJoy

Honestly it feels a bit demeaning though to say she needed grand public displays to feel secure. And that’s what was missing. I highly doubt that. 🤷🏼‍♀️ I’ve said this before and I’ll say it again. I feel that people who were Swifties throughout her Joe years attached and have a certain solidified view of Joe, but without the inside actual experience of being in a relationship with him that Taylor had obviously. She is and has said many things that should be clear. I left all I had and you left me in the house by the heath… I could go on and on. But clearly through 6 years of trying and saying I’d marry you with paper rings he still wasn’t ready to commit. Also her friends seemed pretty relieved when she finally left him. Keleigh saying So Long London was the one she couldn’t wait for, Ryan unfollowing him.. and so on. Something was very not right.

noah

red on piano is actually everything

Leila

I’m just reading it now 😕

noah

i really don’t feel like joe is a frightful man. they just learned the right steps to different dances

Jen Mays

I think that the placement of the Manuscript at the end of the album is a means of communicating that she's in a healthier state of mind these days. Even though it was a reflection of the Red period, that relationship essentially framed her response and actions during every relationship since. It's what made her The Bolter, it's what made her sacrifice everything she was and loved to "give up everything" and be left behind in the Heath---it's all because of the patterns and pain that the Red relationship created. So all of the breakup and heartache that came earlier in TTPD does, ultimately, get wrapped into The Manuscript because that's what she had been using for so long to define what love was. And now, at the end of all this, she's breaking the cycle. She's not approaching love with that lens anymore---that's no longer the manuscript she's going to follow.

Audrey Iocca

I’m so happy to finally hear the sad piano version of red. My show was N3 foxborough with the haunted piano after the rainiest rain show and she was going to play a sad version of red and instead had to do it on guitar, which was great, but I always wondered what that would sound like!!

Amy mcguire

Dont you think thisnwhole tour was planned with the idea that she would still be with/dating Joe or even Matty?? Im sure the whole british segment is very nostalgic and sad for her knowing thats why it was planned that way (with sooo many london, cardiff, liverpool dates). I wonder if cardiff was significant for her and Joe?

epiphany

i don’t find the timing from joe weird at all. this is his first press tour since the breakup as he hasn’t had a project come out since then until now. journalists will be asking questions so he setting he’s record straight and will probably move on now. and his comments were fairly respectful and mature so i don’t see anything to really criticise about it 🤷‍♀️ (not aimed at bonny and em, more so the fans being weird about it)

Elis Llinares

You ladies were talking about dreams and I ended up dreaming I was walking with you to your house. In the dream, I tell you “wow… this year I came to your place more often than to my best friend’s house.” Then Emily says “Oh my God, you’re right! But I never once offered you tea.” 😂😂😂😂 That was it, the dream turned weird after that with family fights and a possible end of the world situation. 😅

Michaela

The Manuscript is a perfect album closer. There are two things in particular that I want to point out about it. First is that it describes her first experience of being promised marriage and kids by a man, then having the rug pulled out from under her, which can be seen as kind of setting her on this path of relationships where she's desperate for someone to follow through on those promises, and which made her vulnerable to being taken advantage of. Second is the final line, "The story isn't mine anymore." While the song as a whole is about the Red era relationship, this line represents a bittersweet realization that she's giving away the Matty story to the public, when it's been her luxurious little secret for ten years ("the greatest of luxuries is your secrets" and "swirled you into all of my poems" in folklore, evermore, and midnights). For someone as famous as Taylor, whose dating life is under a microscope, it must have felt very special that no one knew about her pining for Matty for so long. So TTPD is the catharsis of making art out of pain, but on the flip side it has the sadness of her letting go of one of the few things that was truly hers.

karis

I’d love to see joker and the queen x king of my heart 😂

Camille Platts-McPharlin

Had a fathoming listening to you talk about the Manuscript! In it she says you have to look back to move forward, so maybe looking at her break up from Jake and how she was able to move forward has helped her in figuring out how to move forward from Joe and Matty. Her self reflection on her first big break up and what all has come from it must have helped her navigate the loss of her most significant romantic relationship. Just knowing there is a light at the end of the tunnel, and it won’t be hard forever.

Viviana

I think that in "The Manuscript" she compares the pain that the relationship with Matty and the relationship with Jake caused her, both were short but intense, where she fell hard and it ended abruptly by them! Phrases like "She knew what the agony had been for" and "But the story isn't mine anymore" are more about how it hurts now but she's going to get over it and it's going to become a memory and she'll probably end up forgetting all that pain. She said several times that singing All Too Well with fans made her forget everything about the relationship she was referring to and became a memory with fans, it's her telling herself "if I got over that, I can get over this too."

Gemma

Wouldn’t it be cool after the tour, Taylor did an album that was solely of mashed up songs she did on tour. Like fifteen x yoyok, haunted x exile, etc..

Julia toniato

Renegade x hoax maybe is a good mashup

Korinna Garcia

I think The Manuscript being the last TTPD song is perfect because she’s telling us that All Too Well short film and Red is that manuscript and now she knows what it was all for and she made it through and TTPD is The Manuscript for Joe and Matty and it’s a poetic work of art… now she knows what it was all for. She made it through again and all that’s left is the manuscript, being TTPD.

Katy Magner

The girl engaged to matty didn’t steal her man. She stole her problem

mieke

i was indeed deeply unwell when she played the manuscript 😭😭😭

mieke

i totally agree with you, lauren!

RuthGA

I think The Manuscript is her reflecting on Red and the All Too Well short film and accepting that maybe that experience was the foundation of how she would see and react to love in the future. I think it closes TTPD because she's trying to tell us that she has healed from all her past relationships. Just like All Too Well short film closed the chapter of Red; TTPD closes the chapter on not only Joe and Matty but on all previous relationships. She's ready to move on and start a new chapter of her life.

Katy Magner

Renegade and hoax!!! She hasn’t played it. She could just do a bridge like today with red so it’s doesn’t tear out her heart and since they’re not a very similar sound. But omg that would be insane!!!!

Lu

The thing about the Joe interview that got me, apart from him doing like a whole interview about her now when he never wanted to talk about her when they were together, was that the interviewer was SO disrespectful, to us, to Taylor, to her new relationship, it all sounded really unprofessional

Liv

Renegade with peace (but sped up a bit) would be illegal. Or even this is me trying. "This is me trying to tell you to get your shit together" lol

Alexandria Gangi

Emphasizing question being about Matty especially after her rain show speech at Gillette before she sang question and was like “I’m the happiest I’ve ever been … everything finally makes sense” etc !!!

Sarah

Haha that's hilarious, sounds like the kind of weird dreams I have!

Sarah

Question?

Marissa

I loved your video as always! 🫶🏼 About Joe: I think he was really respectful, and answered these questions in the best way possible. It was actually quite lovely, I think. People are acting like he suddenly was very talkative but he really only repeated things he basically said before within the context of the break-up. And one thing about The Black Dog. I get that he had to say something, once, to be done with it. People should really stop hating on him, he never says anything bad about her and seems like a good guy. They just didn’t work in the end. He never used her for her fame and never will. Just leave him be.

Chasity Mcdonald

I took that lyric from So Long London as her saying she was scared about the future and health of their “love affair” not of him having an actual love affair.

Chasity Mcdonald

I feel like one of the obvious things I notice in TTPD is that Taylor has a complicated and shifting view of her own fame and how to best navigate it. She does still want privacy or the ability to live her life without feeling like she has to justify or explain every choice she is making. She has boundaries and she deserves them. Joe has stricter ones and he deserves them. Famous people don’t owe people full access into their feelings and thoughts. I think sometimes fans are so eager to KNOW Taylor that they create a little fan fiction in their mind about what she wants now or wanted from Joe. I think that it is important to remember that most stories in life don’t have a villain. Obviously the relationship dynamic worked for awhile until it didn’t.

Lucy

It was rare, I was there😭 How did you girls go to multiple shows back to back? I haven't left my bed today, I'm so exhausted😂

Abby Thaine

I interpret the song like this as well. It doesn’t make sense to me for it to only be about Jake on TTPD. Maybe if it was Midnights but not TTPD.

Courtney Brooks

Got me heated with the Charlie thing. The nerve of that girl. Disgusting. Tacky. Classless.

Staci DaSilva

My two cents about Maroon - would Taylor or Joe have had a roommate when they started dating? That roommate line always confuses me anyway. Is it his roommate or hers? Who knows. Maybe it’s a bit of a composite of Joe and Jake.

natis_georce13

Carolina is so underrated. Like how do people not know it

Leander

This was illegal. I feel like she only played Red because it was Anfield. I think if it was elsewhere, she may have played another Red song. I was surprised (as an ironic joke) that she didn’t play Forever Winter given the British summer and her runny nose 🥹

Brooke Noelle

Why the Manuscript works as the closer (at least my thoughts 🙃): 1. I think the parallels between Red and TTPD are quite apparent. Breakup albums, fast-paced love-bombing romances, a mix of pop and country sounds, a bajillion songs on them, less cohesive yet some of her best individual songs, etc. It makes sense to me that she would reflect back onto the last time in her life that she felt these types of feelings and wrote these types of songs. 2. I really think she is writing about much more than only Joe and Matty on this album, so to say we heard so much about them then suddenly about Jake just feels off to me. I think a lot more of the original album is about them (largely Matty), but I don’t really feel that way about The Anthology. I think we could all zoom out a touch when interpreting the 2nd half of the album. JACK is the one who said it was a crazy unhinged moment (first half where he mostly produced and is about Matty) yet AARON said they worked for over 2 years (2nd half where he mostly produced and feels to be about much more). 3. She starts the album by talking about running into someone she loves and has loved and how she hates his “wife” and it’s all ruining her life etc. It very much sounds like something torturing her that she thinks will never end. She then ends the album by reminding herself of the last time she felt so truly tortured and heartbroken and how those feelings did, in fact, end. She made it through all the times of singing about him to us, through all the times his face and name was in headlines, through knowing about him in the biz, through friends of hers working alongside him, all of those times he was “in her backyard” if you will. That story isn’t hers anymore and this story won’t be either someday soon :) 4. She has told us a bunch that we took ATW from her and that basically the story went from hers to ours. She also said, in her IG caption upon releasing TTPD, “The story isn’t mine anymore.” I think she wants us to take this the same way we took ATW and all her songs about Jake and heartbreak and to change the story for her again. This song is showing how she went from the lowest low to making the film and story she always wanted to, one of her biggest successes, largely due to us. I think she is trusting us to turn this around for her again <3

Brooke Noelle

PS I do NOT think Maroon is about Matty. Or Question. No no no.

Chats & Reacts

yes thank you!! This is why we feel Maroon isn't a Matty song

Chats & Reacts

We have fathomed this? We have spoken so many times about all of these points? 😂

nicole

100% I know you have - That’s why I pointed out that you guys didn’t mention in the interview that Joe addressed and basically confirmed all of these points. People must have agreed too! Not sure why you’re laugh reacting at me about it though… Not the nicest response to receive 🙁

Chats & Reacts

yesssss Jess I really love this and actually completely agree!!

Chats & Reacts

LOVE THISSSS and completely agree with all your points 💓

Ida Tøien

I never really "got" Joe. I don't know him, obviously, I've never seen anything with him in it, but he seem a little too bland? Taylor seems more colorful and sparkly, so it was always a weird match for me. Also, there is a true disconnect in my head, where someone who wants to be an actor, wants to do acting as his job, is that unprepared(?) or "allergic" to attention?

Chats & Reacts

I think you're right. Personally I do feel that I can understand her current silence, especially with her current global influence and actively being on a world tour and thereby having safety concerns for herself and thousands of fans. We saw in Miss Americana how Scott was so scared for her safety when it came to speaking up about American politics, the exact topic and scenario she wrote Only The Young for. So I think right now she's probably best to stay silent on everything.

Chats & Reacts

AHAHAHAHAH omg the info I'd love to force out of that man 😩

Chats & Reacts

Love this interpretation, it would make perfect sense for her to bring it all back to the current heartbreak at the end of the song!

Chats & Reacts

OMG I never thought about "score" possibly having a double meaning, I just defaulted to it being the score of the short film - but I love that it works both ways! SO many of her lyrics are like this, she is a genius!!

Giovana Saraiva

Well, wanting to have an acting career doesn’t mean wanting to be famous. He has always said he didn’t like the fame aspect of it, which isn’t unusual, especially for British actors. A lot of A-list actors have said the same thing and live very private lives like Rachel Weisz and Daniel Craig, Saoirse Ronan, Paul Mescal, Cillian Murphy, Daniel Radcliffe, etc. Taylor herself wrote several songs about how fame/the music industry destroyed her spirit, but she loves being an artist and performing so she chose to keep doing it despite the negative aspects.

Chats & Reacts

I totally understand where you're coming from. The craziest thing is that I think most swifties also saw his privacy/silence as a respectful thing while they were together, and the narrative just completely changed as soon as we discovered the breakup. Which doesn't sit well with me because it tells me that swifties will ALWAYS change their tune based on any perceived wrongdoing towards Taylor (and we have absolutely been guilty of that sometimes too). The same is almost bound to happen to Travis if they don't last. I am 100% sure swifties will find a way to hate him, because we used to love Joe the way we currently love Travis and at that time I could never have imagined how people would come to hate on Joe like they do today. I kind of think it's a little bit of both - there is no doubt that keeping things private ultimately is going to work, to an extent, for someone like Taylor who is constantly in the public eye and needing to keep things to herself. But it obviously was just a little *too* private for her, and THAT IS OK. There doesn't need to be a villain in this story! It just wasn't meant to be, and many people refuse to see it that way!

Chats & Reacts

I do have to agree!!! This is exactly why I've had an attachment to her liking the tiktok I edited into this video about the Red/Maroon comparison. It just makes too much sense to me and I don't know why she'd be liking multiple things about this comparison if it's incorrect

Chats & Reacts

Hmmmmm yes I do see how that's kind of a valid thing to feel!

Chats & Reacts

We've said a few times how Midnights is a deeply confusing album without context, and it's SO evident in the first few breakdowns we did on Youtube (up until after Sweet Nothing) how EASY it was to rationalise every song being about someone other than Joe, until we found out the truth. Sometimes I wonder if that was the same experience for him. Like, even Bejeweled, which is soooo obvious now, we thought was just about Calvin Harris and Joe was the guy who said her aura is moonstone! It worked logically for us because she so rarely let us into the growth of their relationship, and really just continued to give us songs that reflected on their beginnings, so it felt like she was just continuing to do that. In saying all of this, she did say in her folklore AOTY speech that Joe is the first person she plays every song to. If that was the case, then he must've known the songs were about him (unless she convinced him otherwise) and maybe it made sense for a rough patch they went through. Alternatively, if she was no longer playing her songs to him first, he would've known that and probably could've deduced that the songs were about him that way too. It's veryyyy interesting to fathom!!!!

Raegan Williams

What if she releases a movie that’s about the seasons of a break up and how it shapes your future self , and that’s the manuscript 😬

Jeebs

That part in Guilty as Sin “If long suffering propriety is what they want from me They don't know how you've haunted me so stunningly” makes me believe the back and forth with Matty is reflected in more songs than we might think.

Emzies

Thank you!! I can not understand the aggressive switch some Swifties feel and act towards an ex. Creating narratives and passing them off as truths is dangerous and, as we’ll all know, there are some who take it to a scary level. But as for me, I’ll never let go. Joe is my favorite. Differences in desires and temperament that lead to a breakup are just what happens sometimes. You said it great! There’s no reason to make villains of anyone.

Chats & Reacts

I definitely don't think she planned lots of UK shows just because she had a British boyfriend. That would be such a financial waste if it was simply all relying on that, especially given that it's clear things were rocky with her and Joe long before the Eras Tour started. It is most definitely just necessary she does so many dates there because there is a demand for it. It is the ONLY place she has ever consistently gone in Europe, I am sure a lot of European fans are used to travelling there for her shows, not to mention the huge population they have there!

Emzies

I’ve been married to my husband for over 21 years. I have a very outward, more assertive, jovial personality while he…may as well be a Brit. 😄 He’s introverted, feels uncomfortable in social situations, and gets mentally drained quickly in those environments. I don’t care if he doesn’t accompany me to social events. I don’t care if he’s not up for having a photo taken with me. What I do care about is him being comfortable and happy, and I don’t need him and will never ask him to be anything other than he is. I knew who he was when I fell in love with and when I married him. I don’t need public displays of validation from him because I’m confident in who we are because he shows up for me in other ways.

Emzies

He probably doesn’t.

Emzies

I’ve been married to my husband for over 21 years. I have a very outward, more assertive, jovial personality while he…may as well be a Brit. 😄 He’s introverted, feels uncomfortable in social situations, and gets mentally drained quickly in those environments. I don’t care if he doesn’t accompany me to social events. I don’t care if he’s not up for having a photo taken with me. What I do care about is him being comfortable and happy, and I don’t need him and will never ask him to be anything other than he is. I knew who he was when I fell in love with and when I married him. I don’t need public displays of validation from him because I’m confident in who we are. He shows up for me in other ways.

Ileana Isabel

Yeah, I see your point. I guess it depends on what the other person wants

Emzies

I agree. The narrative that Joe hid her away or silenced her is absurd.

Hannah S

I don’t think that using Red imagery always means a song is about Jake explicitly. I think she’s just using the language that she’s built with us through her body of work to say “I am once again heartbroken and it burns as badly as it did the first time.”

Ida Tøien

That makes me a little more annoyed with him for not supporting her some more, considering they were it the same sort of situation. If anyone knows the downsides of being in the spotlight, she does.

Hannah S

Also do you think she would ever do a mashup that includes her verse on “Gasoline” ? That would be so interesting!

Ida Tøien

@Tarot X I know what acting is, thank you. I have actual family members who are actors. When they made the choice to try to make a living from it, they were also aware that attention would come with it, should they be lucky enough to make it. I know it's not the main part of the job, but it is a part of it.

Madeline

Although I believe the interpretation that The Manuscript is about re-recording All Too Well and the short film I don’t take that at the main theme of the song, more like a moment that pushed Taylor to reflect on her career and how she has used writing to get through tough times. To me is the perfect album closer for Tortured Poets. I cry every time as its ends with “and the story isn’t mine anymore” just like how this story she’s just told us of two heartbreaks is now ours.

Tarot X

What about Chloe? I have people who swear that it sounds like a early John Mayer song. And in Would've Could've Should've there is the wondering and Ghost/Phantom. There are some overlap even though the direct muse are different. The same with Midnight Rain. Things fame caused her and cost her. Imo. Leading to The Prophecy (hope for change) and The Manuscript (a want to move on). The Joe situation derailed Midnights & Rebound hell Matty derailed TTPD. I really would love Taylor to have a frank host discussion on the shared themes of both albums.

Tarot X

Forget to say another reason to think Chloe is a song about cost & consequences of fame is she watches her past lover/s in her head while he actually sees her. Kind of like in Midnight rain.

Dibbs Storey

Hi it’s me I’m not a problem i promise 😉 I was there last night it was rare it was rare. Anxiety issues. At first I was just a little disappointed that we got Caroliner not one I listen to really. But, then Nobody no crime do all was good. I think she was in a poetic mood last night. It was the best night of OURlives in LOVERpool last night. I now will listen more to Carolina Peace to you guys✌️. You’re my Taylor channelling. Xx

Vanessa

Maybe she’s been playing less ttpd songs/matty songs because she heard about his engagement… and needed a little breather from singing even more songs about him 😅

Katie Scott

Okay I have to talk about the manuscript and how I fathom: To me this is the most perfect album closer for this album because since the Jake relationship she had written about her trust issues and has left every relationship she’s been in, a lot of the time because these guys either didn’t value her or were untrustworthy. And especially with Joe shes written about how much her demons of past relationships have haunted her and how those bad things bleed into her present. When she did she ATW short film I think she fathomed this pattern and looking back at the Joe/Matty situation she can see the fingerprints of that devastating heartbreak on it. To me this is her saying I understand how my past brought me here. And I’ve written out all the pain and torment here too…but I won’t let it haunt me this time.

Jessikah

She played Red in Liverpool also maybe because their colour is red? Like a little nod to the city/team??

Danny

She’s been doing the higher register for several songs recently it gives them a different feel. She did it for gold rush and It’s nice to have a friend if I can recall

Ebru

That’s the line I get stuck on too. Because the wine is also cheap. Jake was wealthy before he became an actor. Unless he did it as a method acting thing. That doesn’t make sense.

Ebru

Gabbriette used a Charli xcx’s song on her latest reel 🧐

Annika 📍Melb, AU

Haha true! But he’s putting out media statements saying he’s never been to the Black Dog which is embarrassing for him to assume it’s about him when it’s not.

Alec Beasley

but i do also think its is about ATW10.. she just stylistically made it the album closer for that reason alone

Lindsey Rinehart

Exactly this! No way Jake or Joe had a vinyl shelf with incense burning. This must be Matty. 🤷🏼‍♀️

Jaime Kelley

Omg also she changes from “he” to “you” at the end

Emzies

All I have seen is one interview that’s been discussed and shared by other publications and platforms, and the interviewer asked him about The Black Dog. (If it was his favorite, or if he would recommend it.)

Taliah

So I ended up being able to go to this show which I'm so unbelievably grateful for and Carolina is my all time favourite song! Now, I've been saying since the START OF THE TOUR that I've accepted she'll probably never play Carolina bc it's not on any of her albums so WHEN I TELL YOU I SOBBED AS SOON AS I HEARD THE FIRST WORD I BLOODY MEAN IT!! the video I was able to get is rather humbling but one of my faves lol I'm just the luckiest gal maybe ever

Lauren

I very much feel like Jake would’ve had this.

Lauren

I disagree! I think she’s retconned a lot of her work because it applies to him or reminds her of him. Cardigan was not written with Matty in mind, but parts of it do really fit them. Matty was NOT a thought in her head romantically until they reconnected for the 1989 re-record. And he convinced her to leave Joe because he could love her better and their “meet cute” was better and proof of destiny.

Lauren

I think it’s because she wants to stretch the TTPD songs out a bit more! She sort of bulldozed through them the first few shows!

olivia

i think the manuscript fits as the ultimate album closer because the next project she's going on to is the film, so she's ending this era with an explanation of how she discovered her love for directing and filmmaking. all of her music before this has been the manuscript, now she's making the real thing!

Abby Thaine

I think she and Matty got engaged *at* a Charlie xcx show

Ninabean

Sonically, Renegade x Ivy or High Infidelity would be ICONIC on guitar!

Elizabeth

Since she’s been doing the mashups so often I’ve been thinking of ones I would personally love if she did and ones that would work together. Cowboy like me x Sad Beautiful Tragic would be my dream mashup and Foolish One x The 1 would be amazing!!

Brain Tornado HQ

I have a theory that all the "hallway" songs are about Joe. Specifically, the layout of the home they lived in together. "You were standing hollow-eyed in the hallway" "Is that your key turn in the door down the hallway" "And now you're running down the hallway, you know what they all say..." "Were you standing in the hallway with a big cake, happy birthday..."

Stephanie E. May

Travis will be on a short break from the NFL before his full-time workouts start up again in mid-July (after the 4th). I think we will see him at one of the shows coming up!

Stephanie E. May

I’m new to the group, grandma-millennial here! I have a single ticket in New Orleans in October and I’m so excited! Hopefully my seat mates will include me in the party

Stephanie E. May

I think she’s been sick (the nasal congestion we’ve seen)? Her lower register could be more affected by an upper respiratory infection.

Stephanie E. May

Maroon can also be used as a verb and the noun form has multiple meanings. Maroon — a firework that makes a loud bang, used mainly as a signal or warning Maroon — leave someone trapped and isolated in an inaccessible place, especially an island

Lisa Lautzenheiser

I have a theory that the manuscript is about all her past relationships, there are different lyrics that don’t match just one person and shes rereading the manuscript of all her past relationships tied into one song.

Inés Fernández A.

Agreed, i thought the same: they had a fling in the past and that when she was at a low point here comes this “understanding” friend with whom you connect on an artistic level and you feel seen, he used the “I’m here for you and we have something special” and she fell for it. I don’t think for a moment that this was a star crossed lovers kind of thing.

Katherine

Okay even more than the reactions I loved watching you also suffer through the glitchy stream with us all haha.

Charlotte Madgwick

Have you decided where you will do a meet up in London? The Barbican could be a vibe ✨ it has both outside and inside public space (in case it’s raining) would be so fun to meet you! xx

Nicole

I can also see a way that the way she hurt from the relationship with Jake being short but passionate and back and forth and manipulative, there could really be a lot of parallels for her for what she just with through with Matty. Edit: I paused to type this and then you guys kind of hit the same point 😂

Caroline

does anyone else think on Maroon when she says "the lips i used to call home" that's she's referencing her own lip color? Like instead of the lips being someone else's she used to have, she means maroon is the color of her own lips she's using to call her man at home? They were the color maroon, perhaps even referencing the fact that she wore darker lip shades during the rep era.

Ally ❤️

Listening to The Manuscript again today… seeing that it appears to be about ATW10 and the making of the short film… I feel like the last statement, “but the story isn’t mine any more” really speaks to her moving on from the pain of dating men and processing break ups by writing songs. It’s the end of all the endings… she just knows there’s more… now all that pain just fades into memory… wrapped up like folklore. I feel it’s a perfect ending to the larger double album.

Jen Witek

I think Joe had to say what he said about Black Dog because even The Black Dog bar has said "a certain blonde" has been into the bar when asked about if it was about Joe. I feel like Joe and Taylor have to be relieved in a way that the album is out and all the speculation about it being Joe was wrong. The storm is over for them and only the truth is out now.

kayla ramoutar

renegade x me on the piano, who says no?

Chloé

I can't decide who I think Maroon is about but I will say the line "the lips I use to call home" is interesting cause from our perspective Matty has never been her "home" and yet in Fresh Out the Slammer she sings "Now pretty baby I'm running back home to you"...

kirstie b

so much joe hate on X it’s so undeserved. do people not have empathy how hard on him it must be? he said it himself. people are so ignorant and mean. and we don’t fuking know what went on.

Aubree Cole

I think that the Manuscript is such an amazing closing track because it’s reflecting on how her art helped her get through her first big heart break, just as TTPD was doing that for her during its creation. She is the “Tortured Poet” because she uses art as an expression of her pain. I feel like in the manuscript, she is reflecting on why being the tortured poet leads to healing.

Fede

I don't even know if it makes sense but your chat about The Manuscript as an album closer made me think about how it kinda portrayes like, the healthy way/side of being a TORTURED POET? as opposed to what she refers to and kinda makes fun of in the title track 🤔

kirstie b

i encourage people to read the entire article. the author was kinda annoying about the taylor thing. he pushed it. i was not cool that about the 5th paragraph in, he talked about “we all wanna know about…” just unclassy and didn’t need to be said. seems like poor joe rehearsed what he was going to say.

kirstie b

40:48. this was SO WELL SAID BY JOE. this is exactly what happens. and it toxic and destructive. brilliant joe.

kirstie b

emily, he was doing an article on his new movie, kind kindness

kirstie b

very important! joe did not BREAK HIS SILENCE. he was doing an interview about his upcoming movie. the ARTICLE WAS ABOUT JOE. he probably knew he’d get questions about taylor and thought he best answer them. he spoke brilliantly. people have no empathy for what he’s been through as well.

Inés Fernández A.

Sorry but if the new Joe quotes that just came out are real he just lost the little sympathy that I had for him. Yesterday's interview was fine, the journalist was a disgrace but JOe was OK, this new article is mean, uncalled for, and vengeful.

Erika Hutchcraft

Kind of bs seeing what she said on her current album

V. Babida

Completely unrelated, but girls when you have a chance pls could you react to Sabrina’s rolling stone cover story! Thank you love you ❤️

Brain Tornado HQ

I have always thought this! Though, I imagined she was calling home to a friend or to her mom after finding a great love and losing that same love.

Lauren

Swifties on twitter are mean about him (and should stop giving him clout), but Tay is getting it worse from a wider audience (and has been since she entered the industry). The rude things a small group of people are saying about him are nothing compared to the heinous shit said about her, her tour, her craft, and her sexuality every day. It wasn’t long ago there was extremely viral AI porn of her: MILLIONS of interactions that spread to other platforms. He can miss me with some of his complaints, especially the ones that address her songwriting. He knew he was dating Taylor Swift, she wrote reputation and lover for him, and all of her big swings on TTPD are saved for MH.

Brooke Noelle

I could write so much about how I actually think Maroon, Question, and Chloe & Friends are all likely about Harry, but idk if anyone wants or needs another multi-point dissertation from me haha! I have thought of making a doc of sorts with all of it though 🤔 maybe I shall. Aside from that, I think Hoax was our first glimpse into something she has started to practice regularly now - braided poetry. Usually there is one main plot line or overarching theme with a big conflict with 2 (or more) supporting subplots with smaller conflicts. I think Taylor is the chairman of TTPD and the members are all her muses, past and present. They make up the “department.” Her life, love life, and the patterns she wants to break are the main thread weaved throughout this album, esp The Anthology. The men, the friends, the enemies, the biz partners, all of them, are all braided together as the supporting sub-arcs of her story. I don’t think all the songs are necessarily about 1 thing or person each. I think she has woven together a full and complete tapestry of her life here and has maybe left it a bit more vague on purpose, like Midnights. She did say she started immediately after turning in Midnights, so I really think she stayed in a reflective place, creating some of what became the 2nd half of the album… then Matty burst in, fucked her all up, and she created the 1st half with Jack.

Brooke Noelle

Also, all the braids she wore leading up to this release 👀

Yaya

Joe deserves no sympathy and his team regularly uses daily mail so it’s definitely from his team

Yaya

The black dog is not about that rat I just don’t get how you guys don’t get how clearly it is about joe 😭

Yaya

Joe is clearly lying to save his ass it’s very clearly about him

Starbuck1234!

Guys I don’t think the Manuscript is about Jake, i think only the second “verse” is, but do you really think Jake was that creepy to use the drivers license line on her? And why would he, she was 20. It was John, creep, seeing how old she was to make sure she was 19 and not 17. Only a creep would use that line on a child. Then, later she wished she was 30, that’s Jake and the French press. THEN, she dated boys her own age. THEN, she dated Joe. The Looking back isn’t a movie, there are no actors, its her remembering all of her life, loves and lost loves, and in her mind it plays out the same every time just like a movie, just like actors. It’s a metaphor. She is not looking back at the all too well short film.. She is looking back at her entire life, and the tears fell in synchronicity to the score, the score being the songs she wrote about her life for the past 20 years. That’s why it is a perfect closer to this album, it is looking backward at her entire life and loves and this is just one more chapter in the manuscript. She didn’t end this entire 31 song anthology about Jake Gyllenhall. No.

Aly J

Agree, it’s a total look back and not just one relationship. I feel like Eras + TTPD is a whole huge part of life that she’s found closure with (the manuscript) and moving forward we’ll see an entirely new and fresh transformation for her.

Aly J

How is The Starting Line reference about Joe and not Ratty?

Aly J

What is the new article?

Inés Fernández A.

A daily mail article commenting on the interview with quotes from an insider on Joe’s team. The link is in the chat.

Cara M

Yeah, you have to seriously wonder why she’d put a song that Matty has sung and transplanted that on Joe. I do think most of the songs have two muses at the same time

Inés Fernández A.

I also think is a Joe song the “6 weeks of breathing clean” (“rarest air”), i still miss the smoke (people forget that she used Joe lighter in the cover of midnights), “best laid plans”, … The starting line reference is why people assume it’s ab MH but when i first heard I thought it was referencing a band not a song, and it turns out there is a band called the starting line, so i don’t know about that. Also I don’t see how you share your gps location with a 4 week relationship, but maybe that’s just me. And, as some said before, I also think there are reference to both in MOST songs

Maria Carmen

Such an interesting interpretation, thank you!! This helps me fathoming ♥

Kate Reinwald

The Manuscript is a song that gives heartbreak a purpose. A purpose that she may not have understood during the Red Era, but now she does and is able to see the purpose in her break up with Joe. Which make The Prophecy that much more interesting. If her purpose in life is to create art that allows others to heal, she is questioning if she will ever heal and find true happiness herself. Or if she is destined to continue the pattern of heart break to help others through music- as a Tortured Poet.

Kate Reinwald

ALSO- I find it really intriguing that the title of the album is The Tortured Poets Department and NOT The Tortured Poet’s or Poets’ Department.

Roxanne Metivier

I don't know if anyone mentioned that, but with the US presidential elections at the end of the year, I think she could perform Only the Young in Indianapolis the weekend before the election. And maybe she'll do a mashup with something else. like you said MAATHBP.

ella 💜

How I see The Manuscript as the TTPD album closer is more that she's reflecting on a break up, maybe her first true heartbreak in her eyes, and she's almost comparing it or thinking about it as shes going throw that again but with joe. "Looking backwards might be the only way to move forward" does give the all too well short film but it also gives midnights and her looking back at her past to move forward from the breakup. And then at the end , "the story isn't mine anymore" She feels she's left her pain in the all too well movie and in ttpd.

Liv Baker

the murder mashup tops the list

Stephanie Marie

The owner of the black dog mentioned a blonde guy being there

majesticwestwick

“Only the young can run” might seem like a dig at Joe Biden though lol

Lilly Wall

oh my goodness! I have just fathomed something. Joe said in the interview that the news of their breakup broke one week after it happened. Arlington shows were one week before the announcement. In Florida there is a lyric “so you pack your life away just to wait out the shitstorm back in Texas”. I am shockedddd is she talking about the shows being a shitstorm because they literally broke up that week and she had to then do it with a broken heart for the first time!?!?!?

Lilly Wall

Also just fathomed again that Florida shows were the week after I am unwell

Marissa

I think The Manuscript is really all about her fathoming her legacy and life's purpose. Of course a huge part of that is All Too Well, but I think reducing it to just that and not everything else she has done is missing the main point. I think she has always thought a lot about her legacy, but this last couple of years she must have been more than ever (rerecords, eras tour, 4th album of the year win). When she says "one last trip to your shores" I think she's talking about her time on earth and fathoming what will be left after she is gone. Her work (the manuscript) will be impactful for decades to come, and it lives inside the fans and people who enjoy it and will continue to relate to it in new ways, even after she passes away. And that was worth all the agony and pain she had to go through in order to make it. That is why it is the album closer.

TheYo Show

Yup. That's what I thought when I looked up the tour dates!

TheYo Show

I think The Manuscript is about all from the age she got a license to John & Jake, to Joe's "shores," tbh.

TheYo Show

Yes! Like a reflection on all her past relationships. The line "one last trip to your shores" ONLY fits with Joe since he's from London. That doesn't fit Jake. I think the movie stuff is too literal

rachel long

No longer robbed of red on piano!!!! Yayyyyy

Chloe

If you listen really carefully you can hear me dying in Section 4😭😭😭😭 Best night of my entire life🥹

Rachel

Guys, I love you, but I think you missed that Joe dropped that article and she immediately introduced a mashup about murdering men, and threw in a real hard “HE DID IT”. I think you need to open yourselves to the possibility that Joe is an unreliable narrator and possibly very manipulative.

Cambryn Adams

Idk how well it would blend together as a mashup but imagine she did So Long London and then Renegade... like Renegade saying "is it insensitive for me to say get your shit together?" and So Long Londons line of "you sacrificed us to the gods of your bluest days".. or maybe there's a better song to fit Renegades narrative. She quite frequently talked about Joe's "blues" (like Peace's "if your cascade ocean waves blues come." or Hoax's "don't want no other shade of blue but you.") But on the other hand, maybe a different song instead of So Long London would be more plausible since, like Emily has been saying, I can't imagine her not playing the full song for So Long London for the first time ever. Just some interesting thoughts lol

Deborah Bontjer

I thought the Manuscript to be the closer of all her past relationships, flings, etc. up until the moment she got toghether with Travis (and at last, she knew what the agony had been for, the entire torrid affair). And she mentions the relationships that affected her the most - John: you're a professional (good with words, songwriter) - Jake: at the age of him she wishes she was thirty, atw10 ofc After that she only sings that she now dates boys her own age, so my theory doesn't really work hahaha but if it is a wrap up of all her past relationships, I feel like it's the perfect album closer 🌟

alex

Same Deborah! For me it’s the most superior album closer of hers, the ending makes me so emotional 🥺 it feels like an end of an era

Brutus

omg you guys are gonna go back thru the albums and share your thoughts??

kirstie b

i was wondering about that! was that pre matty or post?

Ana

I think that making this short film helped her a lot with finally closing the wound. If you listen to All10Well a lot of it sounds like going through the very traumatic experience and then trying to remember it in details, all these "i was there" repeated throughout the song sound like the reassurance that what she remembers is true. And then she directed a short movie about it to tell her version of the story through visions and other actors, for example with Dylan and Sadie reenacting the same dinner scene and the big fight must have felt overwhelming and at the same time cathartic -- this is the way it went down, she doesn't have to reassure herself anymore about the details. Now there is a manuscript of everything that went down the way it did. That's why I think "the manuscript" is so important and was even announced with the standard edition of TTPD -- it was affecting her and her relationships all these years but now she can finally move on and be in a healthy relationship, with her partner and herself. That's why we turn the most traumatic experiences into art -- to materialise it, release it and be free from it.

Victoria

I get the sense that pub is capitalizing big time on their connection to Taylor tbh. I don’t even think the song is about Joe

Katie Walmsley

Matty was at that rain show! I feel they broke up between then and Chicago when she broke down crying whilst singing that she just lost the love of her life in I Don’t Wanna Live Forever

Victoria

The pub owner could also be lying because they want to capitalize on Swiftiemania lol...which they are. To me, the song is very clearly about Matty. The way she says "some bar called The Black Dog" implies she doesn't know it, and I feel like she would know a bar that Joe frequents.

Jen Witek

Agreed and am curious if the pub would lie to the public about that. Seems shitty to do.

Juliette

lol you are reading too much into things....

Gina Bina

I would love to know when she wrote The Manuscript. It's one of the self-written without other collaborators, so its possible she wrote it when she was finishing up Midnights, but didn't feel it belonged with that album, but also didn't feel it belonged on the original tracklist for TTPD, so it became a bonus track. I think anyone/everyone who has been deeply wounded by a relationship still has those scars. I also think its possible that she reflected on it post-MH maybe to understand why there was so much hurt coming from both of these short relationships - perhaps even drawing parallels between the two because they were both whirlwinds and it seems like maybe even some of the same "over promising" or even gaslighting about the future. That line where she mentions the pushing strollers... really stuck out to me because that was new information that potentially JG had brought their future up (even if it was meant to be in a teasing way)

Emma

Charli is also engaged to someone in The 1975, so she and Gabbriette run in the same circle. Plus Charli literally name checks her in 360

Kate Harney

I totally agree, she is trying to understand the pain she was feeling post MH and using the manuscript to get through it like we all have with the help of Red. My favorite line is “then she dated boys who were her own age” because her and Travis were both born in 1989 and he seems like a dartboard dude. To me Travis is as american as Connor Kennedy who she dated after Jake so the story has a parallel to post MH. I also think this will be her last JG song “one last trip to your shore”

Katherine McClintic

this really makes me think of her post "no more scores to settle" like there is this story or pattern of retrospect she's been stuck in and now I am releasing it fully and letting it belong to everyone else

Sam

I feel like Maroon is definitely an enigma. And I sometimes wonder if it isn't just about one specific person, but maybe a conglomeration of various moments in different relationships. Like maybe it's more a reflection on feelings that's she's had, that through her creativity she's tied into one song/story, but it's not literally about one relationship. I feel like that about a lot of the songs on Midnights actually. That maybe a specific moment inspired them (a certain midnight in her life) but then she took creative license with that moment and turned into a story by weaving together various threads of her life where she felt something similar, whether or not all those moments were with the same person

Breezy Bumbles

Do you think the professor in The Manuscript was an NYU professor giving her advice for her honorary doctorate speech? That was around the time of making the All Too Well short film right? Idk. Just thinking…

Luli Swiftie

I think is the guy of the tribecca film festival

Deb

Only the Young is a song that really appeals to young tweens in the USA. It perfectly reflects the kid's anxiety about the school shootings and the March for Your Lives rallies that the survivors of the shootings organized. I think it was written "simple" to appeal to that target audience.