Home
Creators
Search Recent Missing Random
Posts
Search DMs Popular Hash Lookup Tags Random
Importer
Import FAQ
Register Favorites Keys Review DMs Logout
Community
Telegram ThePornDude
Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

RANKING Surprise Song Mashups!!! 🫶 (Patreon)

Published:
2024-10-02 02:30:41
Imported:
2026-09
Tags:

Content

It's been a lonngggg timmmeeee comminggggg... 💓

BESTIES, we are just over 2 weeks away from the Eras Tour being back in Miami (HELP this break has gone so fast!!) and before we start getting more offensive mashups, we thought we would finally rank the ones Taylor has already done, given you asked so nicely 🥰

Please let us know below your top 10 favourite mashups!

Files

Comments

Czechgrl

Chickensssssssss!!!! 🫶🏼🫶🏼🫶🏼

Czechgrl

Love this!!!

amanda

HEYYYYYY 🐥

Lunar

YESSSS, LOVE LOVE LOVE!!

James Pullara

This is a superior ranking!!! Literally think about this every day 🤍🐣

Den

Yes! I really needed one of your videos today 😀

katie whomst

EMILY THAT COLOR LOOKS SO GOOD ON YOU

Kevin Triana

i love this ranking but ik damn well Taylor has some OFFENSIVE mashups ready for the return LOL

Aubrey McMichael

girllssss we are desperate for the merch announcement

Eliza

IVE BEEN WAITING YESSSSS i’ve been needing a cideooo like thisss

JeffreyC

The besties are BACK AGAIN!!!!!!

kylinb

the best thing to come home from work to!

Jenna Bolmgren

Yaaaas! I am going to Miami N1 with my 70yr old dad (we’re from Minnesota) and I cannot wait to fathom The Eras Tour Pt 2 😭 I’m so curious if there will be any more set changes, etc., but as a Mpls N1 girlie, I cannot wait to see her again before this epic tour wraps up. 🙌🫶✨ I made us “careless man” and “careful daughter” shirts. 🤪

mari

I've been looking forward to this one!!! idk if I could rank top ten but sweet nothing/hoax actually rewired my brain 🤯

Roas

I love the t-shirt Em!!

Ozwald

wow Hi love you queens xoxo

Amanda P

So excited for this 😭🥹🩷

August

🌞🙏🙏🧡🧡

Ozwald

Hey I recognise that shirt!

jazzy’s life

omg i’ve been wanting a video like this thanks girls!! i’m going to miami noght 2 i’m sooo excited

Jenna Bolmgren

Did you play the mashup bracket on Swift Alert?? It was so fun!

Paige Loftus

OMG prophecy x long story short was my show in lyon and i literally spit out my drink when you guys said that was your #1 😭😩🩷 it was and IS such a superior mash up. the prophecy is just unmatched and paired with long story short it has such a different depth and beauty and hope. GAHHHHH. luv u lil chickens.

kylinb

i think i am just as shocked as bonny that would've could've should've x ivy wasnt on emilys list

Sophie

The prophecy/long story short was also the first mashup that popped into my head! It definitely healed something inside me lol

Renee S Smith

Anything with Exile, Slut x False God, The Edley, Tavis mashup, Superstar x invisible string, The Prophecy x LSS,

Karen Valentino

Your downright silliness and obvious joy in doing stuff together makes my heart burst with happiness.

lucy lambert

merch teaser !!!!!!!! omg drop it already, looks so cute

mari

I really think the would've could've should've/ivy mashup is veryyy TTPD coded, and is deeply offensive to me as a result

VadersPetPig

We NEED a Florence album reaction pleaseeeee

mari

like you consumed me & drew me in then just left me & pretended I didn't exist & it feels like you did it on purpose so now I just wish you would have left me alone

Isabelle Gatapia

I’m soooo excited to watch this!!! I really hope the Great War + you’re losing me is on this list!!! Also YOYOK + long live or 15. Both amazing I need to really think hard though cause there’s so many!!

kylinb

my mashups are 1. i dont wanna live forever x dress 2. this love x ours 3. thank you aimee x mean 4. aotgylb x crazier 5. dear john x sad beautiful tragic 6. you are in love x cowboy like me 7. haunted x exile 8. marys song x so high school x everything has changed 9. long live x yoyok 10. clean x evermore

khushi04

MERCH ANNOUNCEMENT

Erica

Is that a secret C&R merch shirt Em?!?! 👀

Momo

I haven't watched this and it's the most illegal thing I've ever seen 💜💜💜💜

Nick Salgado

Hii, can you guys order Sarah Chappelle’s book Taylor Swift Style and react to it when you get it?? 🥹🥹

Renee S Smith

Controversial: I don't like Maroon

Samantha

My number one has to be sweet nothing x hoax. I died.

Bridie Carter

Sydney n2 new years day and PEACE. I honestly have not recovered. Peace was my best friends dream song and she honesty didn't comprehend it when Taylor switched.

Amanda P

omg prophecy x LSS is also my #1!!! 😭 also loved the Great War x You’re Losing Me and Cornelia Street x Maroon!! plus the Travvy mashups: Mary’s song x SHS x everything has changed, begin again x Paris and all the girls x crazier were SUPERIOR healed Tay mashups 🥹

katie whomst

I absolutely LOVED the ss refathomings, will love when they come back

brenda 🌸

Emily what is that SHIRT!

T

Who said they don't care about the refathomings...... I need to speak with them....

Alison Hernandez

BABES I RANKED THEM MYSELF BEFORE YOU FINISHED RANKING AND I ALSO HAD THE PROPHECY/LONG STORY SHORT AS NUMBER 1 , I SCREAMED THE SECOND YALL SAID IT

Katie LaFave

please do a few ss refathomings before the break is over!!!

Karen Valentino

My favorite mashup is Right Where You Left Me and All you Had to Do Was Stay. It’s kind of obvious, connecting them is not a stretch like some of her mashups. I was at Eras Tour the night before you in Santa Clara and when she sang RWYLM I was ecstatic. I strongly relate to the song and how surreal it felt when my marriage was falling apart, like cement boots, just feeling like I could barely lift my feet to take a step. And really it IS simple, in order for things to work both people have to want to be there, to stay. Ancient history now but still so resonant.

Katie LaFave

i hope that when you guys do a tier ranking after the tour is over, you think about the songs as they were performed live! like most of us don't love the production of closure, so that's why it was so incredible to hear acoustic and why it would be placed in a higher tier! for example and i know this is going to kill you guys, but LSS and the prophecy are in my bottom 5 on their respective albums. however mashed up they tell this incredible story so that's why it's one of my fav mashups!!

✨Bri✨

Emily’s shirt is soooo cute!!! If that’s a merch one I neeeeeed it!!!!! 🫶🏻

izzy

NOT EM THINKING SHE CAN WEAR THAT SHIRT AND NOT HAVE US DYING SORRY WHAT

Julia Fisher

here goes my top 10 (plus 1 honorable mention) - some are deeply obvious and some are my personal favs that I still haven't recovered from 1. loml/Don't You 2. I Hate It Here/the lakes 3. it's time to go/Better Man 4. Clean/Evermore 5. YOYOK/Long Live 6. Mary's Song/So High School/Everything Has Changed 7. Mirrorball/Clara Bow 8. The Great War/You're Losing Me 9. State of Grace/YOYOK 10. You Are In Love/cowboy like me Honorable Mention - The Prophecy/Long Story Short!!!

angel (plnkblue)

"WCS and Ivy don't make as much sense together as a narrative, as much as some of the other mashups" okay listen, I get you, but also consider how the WCS/Ivy mashup, when connected to various other songs in the WCS chronology (Dear John, The Great War, BTTWS, almost all of Speak Now) creates a fascinating reinterpretation of Ivy as being a song about the reclamation of the self, about returning to girlhood and breaking free from the trauma inflicted in WCS. In which the "husband" of Ivy represents the effects of the trauma instilled by this older man, and the secret lover represents a younger self/the embodiment of girlhood. Some of my favorite bits of analysis for this include: - The metaphorical links between Dear John--obviously connected to WCS in its own right--("I took your matches before fire could catch me / I'm shining like fireworks over your sad empty town") and how they reappear in Ivy ("It's a fire, it's a goddamn blaze in the dark and you started it"). How the "you" in question in Ivy represents the younger self, and how that "blaze in the dark" could be interpreted as the firework she becomes in Dear John. - "I can't stop you putting roots in my dreamland" vs Speak Now as an album with aesthetics of fairytales, dragons, enchanted balls and haunted castles. In this case, the "roots in my dreamland" becomes more of a negative thing that is represented by Dear John and the emotional turmoil inflicted by that relationship. This idea of "roots" representing trauma is also explored in The Great War, which uses flower imagery as a metaphor in its exploration of how that trauma manifests itself in the narrator's life, even years down the line. - "It's a war, it's the goddamn fight of my life and you started it" vs "I can't let this go, i fight with you in my sleep / Memories feel like weapons / Living for the thrill of hitting you where it hurts"; how, despite being deeply hurt by this relationship and still dealing with the emotional fallout well into adulthood, that younger self still is kicking and screaming somewhere and fighting to reclaim what was taken from her. This idea of a war/conflict is obviously also expanded upon in The Great War, where again, the effects of this trauma manifest in the narrator lashing out at her current partner unnecessarily, because she believes she may be back in the same situation that originally traumatized her to begin with. - "If clarity's in death, then why won't this die?" vs "How's one to know I'd meet you where the spirit meets the bones, in a faith-forgotten land? / My pain fits in the palm of your freezing hand"; recalling the fact that the younger self explodes into a firework at the climax of Dear John, this act of exploding right after "taking his matches" is representative of that initial loss of girlhood. She survived, but in that moment, a part of her died. (This idea of girlhood/a sense of self "dying" is also explored in Bigger Than The Whole Sky, and the interpretation of that song as grieving a loss of the self, given its direct lyrical connection to WCS). In Ivy, this part of her that died comes back to her in spirit, as evidenced by the meeting in the cemetery and the "freezing hand," and encourages her to take the steps necessary to properly heal and reclaim this lost sense of youthful joy. - This is already long af, but also consider: "Your touch brought forth an incandescent glow, tarnished but so grand" vs something like "Only when your girlish glow flickers just so do they let you know" and other songs like Mirrorball; if the "you" in Ivy represents this younger self, and Ivy as a whole can be read as a song about self-reclamation and rediscovering the joys of girlhood/femininity, then once again, we can look at the "husband" character as being representative of societal suppression of said femininity, and the brutal treatment of both the public and the internal music industry behind the scenes that works to steal that "girlish glow" from every young female star. Both the relationship trauma and the fame trauma go hand in hand in analyzing these two. There is truly an ENTIRE narrative within Taylor's music just about these themes, of trauma, self-reclamation, and how fame coincides with the romantic element to bring forth all the ups and downs of the tumultuous journey, and this is only the tip of the iceberg of what can be explored if people try to fathom songs in a new light!

Jami Marie

Sweet nothing x hoax False god X slut Guilty as sin x untouchable Carolina x no body no crime Hits different/dbatc I hate it here/ the lakes

Meech

I just KNEW I would have the same #1 too. I don’t think I’ll ever get over The Prophecy x Long Story Short 😭😭

Yuli

Evermore/Clean is so personal to me I’m so glad she was mentioned x

Kami

This video has made me realise how thankful I am that 2023 Taylor from Mayy/June hadn't yet discovered mashups. I dunno if I could have handled that.

Yuli

Unsure if this is possible but i feel like a journal / notebook as a piece of merch would be so cute and wholesome

Katie LaFave

wow!!! paper rings has incredible instrumentals

Kristen

i have many of the same favorites as y’all, but one that i always think of that was just so fun to sing along to was thank you aimee x mean. i knew it was coming, but i am SO happy she did it. also a personal fave is foolish one x tell me why. 🫶

Kami

You're Losing Me may have come out after The Great War... but what are the odds it was written during the great war 🤔

Iga W.

Yes, to The Prophecy x long story short being your number one mashup because same 💞

Katie LaFave

please tell me Em your teasing new merch with that shirt cuz i loveee

Alex Parra

Superior! I mean. We're totally normal about this. The "oh I can't / stop you putting roots in my dreamland" and this imagery of girlhood as this sacred dreamland and ivy as the invasive plant that can't be stopped. "And now I'm covered in you / I regret you all the time" is insane. Also, the experience we had being in the server when the first message was sent and getting the mods to alert you and staying up all night to watch the show and then seeing you get WCS and ivy on the livestream was an adrenaline rush that cannot be topped!

Kent

Love both of your lists! I would just add Hits Different x DBATC as one of my all time personal faves! That megabridge she did was life changing

Kirsten Marie

Just love the chickens and can’t wait until Eras Tour is back! Had so much fun with this!

Katie LaFave

i am soooo shocked that neither of you put marys songs x so high school x everything has changed on your list!!!

Ozwald

👀

kylinb

agreed!

Mex

i would determine some of my top mashups based on how many times i've felt the need to rewatched your reactions to them. getaway car/august/ the other side of the door (i've seen that video a million times) because you and the mods faces are so shocked when she starts to sing august and i laugh every time when the girl behind you yells wtf?? i watched is it over now/out of the woods on the livestream and absolutely could not wait to see you guys lose your minds over it when the video hit patreon. bonny immediately trying to pull her hair out and emily screaming "it's a mashup!!!" is the perfect reaction! and for pure personal emotional reasons, king of my heart/the alchemy, because i got to witness it in person at the same time as you guys. getting to hear taylor taking the crown off of joe's head and placing it on travis in london made my black rep heart so happy

Lauryn

The lack of appreciation for sweet nothing x hoax amongst the fandom is so concerning ❤️❤️ it’s truly the most superior thing I’ve ever heard in my life

Lauryn

Same!!

Madeline

Is Em wearing C&R merch????

khushi04

i don’t think anything will ever beat haunted/exile for me 💜🩶

Samantha

I think it was so superior everyone blacked out and forgot it happened 🤣🤣

Karen

I love the secret song refathomings. I can't wait until you guys react to it again.

Alexis Brusby

LADIES!! I need your list to answer a question for me 🙏🏻🫶🏻 I FINALLY got tickets to a show. My first and only show will be Miami night three!! Has she done Tolerate It since it’s been taken off the set?!? I want it as my secret song on piano soooo badly!! It would be SO ILLEGAL 😭❤️

Mike Roach

I love this! Who needs coffee when I get a hit of C&R energy in the morning?! My top ones are also ones I saw live because of the impact that experience had on me, but also for being some of my actual favourite songs and just superior songs in general: - Fifteen / You’re on your own kid - Max Martin Medley (Message in a bottle / How you get the girl / New Romantics) - Say Don’t Go / Welcome to New York / Clean - Death by a thousand cuts / Babe And then I have to agree with Haunted / Exile, Getaway Car / Out of the Woods, Red / Maroon. Masterpieces. Thank you Aimee / Mean was so clever and fun!

Mike Roach

I was wondering where that shirt came from and where I can get one! I would love some C&R merch!

Ash

1. Evermore/clean 2. I don’t wanna live forever/dress 3. Dress/imgonnagetyouback 4. Cornelia street/maroon 5. The black dog/exile 6. Dear John/sad beautiful tragic 7. The 1/wonderland 8. TTPD/now that we don’t talk 9. Slut!/false god 10. Loml/don’t you I’m so surprised neither of you picked one of the dress mash ups! They were both perfect I couldn’t choose just one

maya zutra

Ok PERFECT TSHIRT EMWALD !!!!!!!!!!!!!

Chez

Girlies if you think we haven’t clocked that tshirt, you are wrong!! I need you to announce these asap

maya zutra

BONNY I was sweating the whole video waiting for you to say Cornelia/ Maroon 🥵🥵

maya zutra

She didn’t do tolerate it yet bestie 📝

Clive

exactly. what's a mashup list without that. also, for me, ivy is an all right song, but nothing to write home about.

maya zutra

The shock i had of Mary’s song so high school everything has changed not making the list ❤️‍🩹❤️‍🩹❤️‍🩹

sophie

the fact that when i now sing i hate it here i alwaysss do the „take me to the lakes“ part as well also just proves that it fits so well together

Clive

mary's song the alchemy other travis mashups

sophie

its also interesting in cornelia street/maroon that she starts with cornelia street and says „i‘ll never walk cornelia street again“ and then sings maroon, and never goes back to cornelia street because like she said she will never go there again 😭😭

Vanessa

The prophecy x long story short was soooo offensive😭 BUT Justice for **Mary’s song x so high school x everything has changed **All of the girls you’ve loved before x crazier **False god x slut **Cowboy like me x you’re in love **superstar x invisible string **king of my heart x the alchemy I think tay told soo many stories through her mashups & reclaimed so much of her old work to her current life and feelings and I just LOVE that for her. Just shows how amazing her story telling is and how unreal her discography is cause what do u mean you can take parts of all ur own songs and create superior songs with entirely new meanings ?!?

Daniel K

Your friendship is so epic. ♥️♥️♥️

Ty

Okkkkk the way I was at Lisbon night 2 (Tortured Poets x Now that we don’t talk & Yoyok x long live) and one of each ended up on both of your lists 🫶🏻 Lisbon N2 confirmed superior!!!!

stefreedom

I was crying so much when she played Nothing New x Dear Reader at my concert. It was so special 🥹

paulina ⭐️

if i would rank them by the level of my devastation i think the great war x you’re losing me would win but after your ranking im more appreciative of hearing live mirrorball x clara bow 🙏 now im just praying she won’t sing forever winter because i might actually die

Sophie

Almost finished the vid and just noticed Em’s absolutely superior shirt! Very excited that c+r merch seems to be coming soon!!

Ebba

It is sooo difficult, but this is what I would say my top 10 is 1. The black dog X Come back be here X Maroon 2. It’s time to go X Better man 3. You are in Love X Cowboy like me 4. The great war X You’re losing me 5. I hate it here X The lakes 6. Loml X Don’t you 7. clean X evermore 8. Hits different X Death by a thousand cuts 9. I don’t wanna live forever X imgonnagetyouback 10. Haunted X Exile honorable mention is say don't go X welcome to new york X clean (my show :) )

Julia Lesmister

I love the re-fathomings of the secret songs and I look forward to you doing them again!

Julia Lesmister

I really loved the mashups that she did for Travis but I literally can’t remember anything, so couldn’t say what songs they were… just that I remember smiling my face off. So cute.

Ana Noronha

Came here to say this 👀

Ana Noronha

That tshirrrrrttttt, NEED ITTTT THANKSSS

Daniela Alpizar

going to miami n2, can’t even fathom what songs/mashups i will get 😭

ton

Saying look look 👀 👀 👀 when it starts!!! And the shirt.. Superior!

jo

i cant decide a full top 10 but one of my favs and a deeply underated mashup is dorothea/its nice to have a friend. its so cute and she sounded amazing singing it, so so superior

Lynny Smith

Fathoming that this is your job?? HELP?? Literally living that absolute dream 🥲

alex

That shirt! We see what your doing here girlies and we’re so ready for it 🤓

Marion

I cannot let this stand uncorrected; Taylor was *not* the first artist who commonly self-referenced her own work in her work and left Easter Eggs - Tori Amos did this as early as the early mid 90s.

Leander

I saw CS X Maroon live and my soul left my body. Just rewatched your reaction and cried with you Bonny. What the actual fuck are we going to do without The Eras Tour!?!

Leander

Witnessing live, that drop from The Bolter into GC was better than my wedding day.

Sarah

For me personally I love the You Are in Love/Cowboy like me mashup so much, so underrated.

Jesse Conner

Wait who said they don’t care about the re-fathoming? Because I for one love them and very much would watch every single one 🙋🏻‍♀️

Brenda1989

The Great War x You’re losing me did something irreversible to me. I will never unhear how she changed the meaning and said “but SHE survived the Great War”

Sarah

YES you mentioned some really amazing ones! I was waiting for one of them to choose false god x slut the whole time I was watching lol that's def in my top 10, also idwlf x dress!

Mona

the prophecy and long story short was my show!!!!!! I've never felt more seen that was FUCKED UP

Sarah

Omg are you me!? This top 10 is almost exactly what I would pick! I would swap out the 1 x wonderland for the great war x you're losing me but otherwise the same!!

chatsandreacts

I’m so sorry!! Not a Mary’s song Stan here 😅

Sarah

Omg how did I forget about that!? That's gotta be in my top 10, it was so devastatingly superior!!

Ellice Hulton

I’m very SUS of Emily’s T-shirt 👀

Sarah

Yes totally! The "singing this song at wembley" part made that mashup extra fun!

Sarah

Wow this is a lot of great food for thought, I need to go re listen to all these songs together after reading this, really interesting! Thanks for sharing!

Sarah

Oh I loved it's time to go x better man so much!! (as well as sooo many others on your list hehe it's so hard to narrow them down!)

Sarah

Ohh another very superior mashup!! I love RWYLM and it felt so obvious in hindsight for her to put it with AYHTDWS but I never thought of it before she played them together.

ellen.h

Are you seriously soft launching merch on us right now?! EXCUSEZ-MOI?!

learc

same omg ! they're 2 of my favorite songs AND they're perfect together ✨

Lara Ferreira

Superior yoyok | Long live It was rare I was there 😩😩😩

Shiv F

This mashup was EVERYTHING to me. I still rewatch it tear up because it was such an emotional mash up but also her giving us so much insight into how she was feeling, the anniversary of "tell me bout the time you first saw me" on the day he went to Eras Tour. Everything!

MsParis729

I haven't finished watching yet, but aren't you supposed to go from 10 to 1, to keep the suspense of what's your top mash-up? Or am I confused haha

Taylor

Are we just not going to talk about Emily’s shirt?? What is this? 👀

Ashley

Cowboy like me and you are in love killed me. Obsessssed.

Sarah

YES! I have been such a fan of cowboy like me since evermore came out and still cannot get over how its not a more popular and loved song, its so good. And You Are in Love is easily one of the best love songs Taylor has written which also needs more love.

Taylor

The only one that came to my mind that yall don’t mention was 15/YOYOK, I legit cried at that one. I became a swiftie during the fearless era when I was in high school, and 15 was always special to me, because “when your 15 and somebody tells you they love you your gonna believe them”, and I did believe them. Dagger to the heart. But I need to know, did yall rewatch them while you were going through the list or did you just remember all this from memory? Cause wow I didn’t not remember them in that much detail. Also where can I find a good list of them? Because I want to rank them now too.

Clare

Super upset that none of the new Travis coded mashups made either of your top 10 lists, really! Even the not obs ones like: Cowboy like me x you are in love or slut x false God? Both of which she has sung twice and clearly loves them.

Mariana

I got 2 of those in the same night: TTPD x Now that we don't talk and YOYOK x Long Live - it was magicccccc ✨ Lisbon night 2

imogen

as someone who heard cornelia street x maroon. CAN CONFIRM IT WAS DEADDDLLLYYYYYYYY

imogen

EM UR SHIRT?!!?

Riri 13

BONNYYY HOAX x SWEET NOTHING HAPPENED!!!!!!

Ali ❤️‍🔥

Bonnie saying that her not finishing Cornelia street x maroon with Cornelia street is like SHE NEVER WALKED CORNELIA STREET AGAIN. BC SHE LOST HIM. I can’t. That just fucked me up.

zharfa

THE FACT THAT 3/4 OF MY SUPRISE SONGS ARE ON THE LIST MADE ME FEEL SUCH A BLASTTTTT. I GOT WCS/IVY, CLEAN/EVERMORE, AND THE STORY OF US/LONG STORY SHORT

Kelli E.

I absolutely care about the refathomings!!! Maybe if you needed to shrink them down you could group more shows together into one video but please keep doing them 😍

lane ♡︎

I was shaking in my boots when she did The Prophecy x LSS also cowboy like me x You are in love!!!! We are so blessed she even thought to do this 🪩🪩

lane ♡︎

I forgot about nothing new x dear reader 😭😭😭

Jule

Ahhh omg I’ve been so excited for this!! And THAT SHIRT? 👀 Here’s my top 10: 1. Hits Different/Death By A Thousand Cuts 2. I Hate It Here/The Lakes 3. You’re On Your Own Kid/Long Live 4. Is It Over Now/Out Of The Woods 5. imgonnagetyouback/Dress 6. The Prophecy/long story short 7. I Can See You/Mine 8. Cornelia Street/Maroon 9. Paper Rings/Stay Stay Stay 10. Would’ve, Could’ve, Should’ve/ivy

Celina

Could you rank all eras Tour Show? Which Show was the Most superior? In terms of surprise guests and mashup combos?😍

Eliza

i was there for peace x nyd AND marron x cornelia street I DIED

Keri 🫶🏻

Um WHERE is shs x Mary’s song x ehc???????

Leila

Haha love this! Xx

Leila

That was a Joyful video Bon & Em!! ✨💖Thank you so much! I really appreciate the weather update at the beginning and also what you are drinking (looks like Sabrina’s ice- lattes!) and i love your t-shirt Emily!! I’m with Bonny, the prophecy mash-up was my fave 🥺🔮

Leila

Haha!! So true. Its perfection, thats what it is! ✨

DemiMarie🤍🖤

This video has just made me more sure we need a mash up album 🤌🏻 How Superior it would be!🥹🫶🏻🫶🏻

Sam

Marys song x shs x everything has changed the storytelling!!! And All of the girls x crazier help

LindseyMarie

45 seconds in and I just have to stop and thank Emily for the weather update, your videos are simply not complete without that little check in and I love that it’s now a running bit😂 Omg, love you both so much🫶🫶

Jeebs

15/YOYOK is #1 for me

Nippy

Rank the albums!! Its timeeeee

StatMatt

Fifteen and You’re On Your Own Kid was one of my favorites!

Olivia🐱

My claim to fame is that I was there for The Prophecy x Long Story Short mashup!😮‍💨😍🇫🇷

Riley Bidwell

I Hate It Here and The Lakes I think is my favorite!!

Bethan

I was there for I Hate It Here x The Lakes. Simply superior! 😮‍💨🤍

Taylor Massey

My favorite is begin again x Paris 😭❤️

Miriam

Ummmmm Emily??? How are we not immediately talking about your SHIRT??? I’m so distracted… is that MERCH???? 🤩

Savvy

Definitely want refashionings!!! But I think they’d be more fun after the eras tour is over, next year! :)

Momo

RIP to Em's lost list ❤️‍🩹

Laurie Letendre

HUMMM HELLO SUPERIOR SOUNDS SHIRT?!?!????!!! EXCUSE ME 🫨🫨😍🤩 MERCH IS COMING BESTIES I CAN FEEL IT 🚨🚨🚨

justine

UMMMMM WTF IS EMILY WEARING

Aoife

I was also expecting this to get mentioned!! there's just soo many good combinations

Paige Jacobsen

False god and slut was an illegal mashup def in my top 10 😭

Alyssa Kay

My top 10 (in no particular order): This is Me Trying/Labyrinth The Great War/You’re Losing Me The Prophecy/Long Story Short Red/Maroon I Hate it Here/The Lakes Clean/Evermore I Don’t Wanna Live Forever/Dress Hits Different/DBATC YOYOK/Long Live The Bolter/Getaway Car 💕💕💕

marysia

I'm soo happy that red/maroon made the list (that was my concert) and the fact that mirrorball/clara bow is on both of your lists tells me that Warsaw truly won with mashups <3

rosie

my rankings change all the time but... 1. yoyok x long live 2. i hate it here x the lakes 3. hits different x dbatc (my show<3) 4. the prophecy x long story short 5. getaway car x august x tosotd 6. clara bow x the lucky one 7. the bolter x getaway car 8. would’ve could’ve should’ve x ivy 9. mary’s song x so high school x everything has changed 10. tim mcgraw x cowboy like me

marta k.

ahh the prophecy x long story short is also my fave & it made me so happy that two of the mashups i witnessed made the list (mirrorball x clara bow and red x maroon) 🖤🖤

Dani

I was at Amsterdam N3, and got Sweeter Than Fiction x Holy Ground on guitar + Mary’s song x so high school x everything has changed on Piano. Ngl i didn't fathom what was going on in the Arena, until i saw Travis and Taylor walking out together at the end 😅🏈❤️‍🔥

anna

my #1 yoyok x fifteen

Bria Bowen

I love love loved this! So much refathoming happening 😍😭 Only one I would add is Mary’s song x so high school x everything has changed

Alyssa

The Great War x You’re Losing Me was one of my mashups in Liverpool! Deeply superior - I found it hard to process! ‘I survived the Great War’ was just too much!

Kyle Duarte

can someone people tell me what is the website Emily & Bonnie use for tier rankings? Like with the ttpd ranking? Pleaseee lmk asap

Alyssa

Also, I sobbed like a baby watching the live stream of Epiphany x Mirrorball. I can’t imagine how the crowd even coped with that live into their actual eardrums!

Ariel

This wasn't a mashup, but I feel like one of her most powerful Surprise Song performances was "The Moment I Knew" on the day after-ish that she and Matty broke up. It was devastating in terms of what she was going through, but such an emotional performance.

Kamila

ahhhh this was so fun to watch <333

Alyssa

Another one of my mashups was the 1989 medley for the 89th show (Stockholm N2) - mashing up Say Don’t Go by changing the lyrics to ‘So I’ll go, I’ll go”…. ‘To New York!”, so not obvious. And then ending the medley with Clean (my favourite of all time song) was the one and only way to end that 1989 medley <3

ton

Thank you SO much for this. I love the reconnection with the music rather than just her life that seems to be a focus sometimes…. 🤣 I have NO idea how you recall the way she mashed songs but it was OFFENSIVE. In a year or two I really look forward to doing a proper review like you did! My faves tended to be everything with YOYOK, Getaways Car. I had Hits Diff with DBATC, black dog/CBBH/Maroon…. But also LSS/ story of us, Corn St Marroon, Clean EM. I’m still on the fence about Maroon interpretation as it could be a night of High Infidelity crashing into a Paradox 🤔 that leads to I lost you 🥺…. Thanks I LOVE the way you approach this, it’s so fun

ton

Great list

ton

Offensive list… love it!

ton

I think they couldn’t wait 🤣…. I kind of liked it this way though as the easier ones were at the top but harder to choose further down why cull some and not others 🤔

ton

Love these

ton

Great call

ton

I get it… both people wanting it included as meaningful for Tayvis but also not as the songs didn’t mesh that cleanly (ie lyrically and musically)

Lucy

TTPD x Now That We Don't Talk still has me singing "who's gonna hold you?...Now that we don't talk"😂 But there are too many superior mashups I don't know how you managed to choose a top 10!

Amanda Saul

The Alchemy x Treacherous was amazing I can’t listen to the Alchemy without hearing it 😩🥰

Jessica Tucker

I adore your re-fathomings of surprise songs and cannot wait for you to start them back up!!

Kathleen D

The look of genuine confusion on Bonnie’s face when Emily didn’t have Would’ve, Could’ve, Should’ve/Ivy on her top ten killed me lol

claudia jones

ummmm Emily’s tshirt !!! I’m sorry ?!?! ⭐️⭐️

Lefty

I would always love to see re-watches of the surprise songs, even if you did every one from the beginning. It'd be nice to see them all in good quality, in order, with no lag or stream switching. The surprise song reactions have been my favourite content, the entire vibe of it is peak comfy to me and I really will miss it when there aren't any more, so for this to be a chance for them to continue...I'm all for it. I can't think back to enough to think of a top ten but I do know that I really loved that Cornelia Street/Maroon mash up. How brutal to go from "hope I never lose you" to "and I lost you". I enjoyed the "I can see it...I can see you" moment when she did I Can See You and Mine. I also really liked when she switched thanK you aIMee from "and there wouldn't be this if there hadn't been...you, with your switching sides..." in Mean.

Katie Walmsley

Omg…to have been the soul who found Emily’s lost list on that plane 😭🫶

Christine Violet

I love the re-fathomings sooooooo much… definitely want you to continue doing them!!

Maryn

This was SUPERIOR! While in this little eras break I would love if you ranked tracked 5s and track 2s or actually any track #. I could watch you rank anything!!

Akchita S.

I loved this so much!! Your number one was a mashup I got to hear live and my life will never be the same!

Breejmc

Yayyy! This was such a fun video. I was missing the TS content so perfect timing. I absolutely love the surprise song refathomings 💖 it’s crazy how much she gives us during the acoustic sets. Great War/You’re losing me, Cornelia St/Maroon and Sweet nothing/Hoax are my top 3 most fucked up. Some more unexpected ones that I loved were This Love/Ours, Dear Reader/Nothing New and Tim McGraw/Cowboy like me. Sooo many good ones 😍 love you chickens!

Agos

My fav will forever be "is it over now & out of the woods". I was there in Buenos Aires for that first time and it was incredible

Wendy Davis

For me, Clara Bow is a masterpiece!

Sarah

Lol it was probably someone who had no idea what any of it meant 😂 it'd be so cool if a swiftie found it tho!

DD

I agree - the storytelling in Mary’s Song Mashup was next level amazing. And her happiness ❤️

DD

I agree. Loving the song or not, the storytelling in this one was next level. She claimed it for her own story and happiness ❤️🥰

tayblessings

how did neither say marys song x shs x everything has changed!!!!

Soraia Ferreira

YOYOK/Long Live will forever be my number 1 cause it’s simply offensive but also cause it was my show 🫶🏻

Sarah Louise

When it’s all over (😭😭😭✨🫶) you need to rank a top 20, not a top 10!!

Annika 📍Melb, AU

The way my whole body erupted in goosebumps when you were talking about clean/evermore, and my eyes filled with tears when you were explaining YOYOK/Long Live 😭

Annika 📍Melb, AU

I think next year for the refathomings would be perfect when we’re all in post Eras depression again. 😂🙈

Analice

OMG I forgot about some of this and they're soooo incredible!! I loved seeing your opinions on them and I was wishing you would put one from my shows and you guys put both from the same night (TTPD x Now that we don't talk and YOYOK x Long Live). My fave is yoyok x long live because I was there and they're both so special to the fans and I died when I fathomed that she said all of that "tell them how I hope they shine because" and then started to talk about all that she had to go through. It's just perfect.

Malina

Same!!!🫶🫶

Cassandra

OMG I almost was like WHERE IS YOYOK AND LONG LIVE 😂😂💕💕

Nele

funnnnnnnnn 🤍🤍🤍

jordan alexis

I totally agree that refathoming mashups is more important than non mashups!

Courtney T

literally one of my faves

Nicole F

marys song x so high school x everything has changed felt really special to me because it felt like she created an entire story using three songs from three different decades of her life. blows my mind!

Isabelle

I KNOW, Why is no one mentioning ittt

Raneem

Superior sounds?? 👀 incoming merch

Raneem

The manuscript/red is a standout for me. I remember when watching that having a visceral reaction and just sitting there tearing up

Megan C

Same and I have full body chills listening to E talking about it now.

Megan C

Loved this- thank you! Your lists included most of my top 10s except my most haunting #1- Sweet Nothing x hoax. I also loved I Look in People's Windows x Snow on the Beach (it was so great sonically), and Manuscript x Red. Another fave was Say Don't Go x Welcome to NY x Clean because I loved how she transitioned "so I'll go, I'll go........... to New York." Perfection. And the story it told!

Hannah Elisabeth

For the New Year’s Day x Peace mash up - I think she’s structured it like that because the mash up is about Joe until the end when there it’s her and Travis “you and me forevermore” maaaaybe?

Tess7

I have been on a little road trip, celebrating our anniversary, so I am just now watching this- your excitement when discussing the superior things Taylor does is unmatched. I just love listening to you talk about these songs. There are so many mashups that were so offensive, but in this moment, my top 2 are your last 2 lol The Bolter/Getaway Car is a fave and Is It Over Now/OOTW I must mention All Of The Girls/CRAZIER- that was a moment lol The crowd knew every word - after the tipsy video discussing the merits of Crazier’s song writing…..Taylor said Bonny must fathom Crazier lol I really enjoyed this video and now I see you’ve uploaded the loml breakdown….idk if it gets better than this 😊

Lauren

Yoyok X fifteen was and forever will be my TOP mash up. I connected to fifteen when it came out and I connected to yoyok when that came out... And she does that to me? 😭 Way too much absolutely iconic. 🙌

Norah Brooks

I was waiting for Mary's Song/So High School/Everything has changed! So Illegal!!!!!!!!!!

DeeAnne Herron

Haunted x Exile. I just love how much she LOVES hearing the crowd sing the duet bridge with her.

Zephyrz

yesss!!!! the great war/you're losing me!!!!

Brittney Wall

My comfort watch videos are all of your album reactions since folklore!! I know it sounds meta, but I would love to see your reactions to your first initial reactions to some of these albums!!

Bea Hanna

If that tee isn’t your own merch I will need you to be giving the deets because it’s so cute & perfect and C&R coded I need it!! 🩷 And if it is - TAKE MY MONEYYYYYYYY

Camille Messonnier

Forever grateful to have experienced your favorite mashup (The Prophecy x long story short) in Lyon, my city 🤍🤎 I couldn’t believe what was happening 🥹 Thank you for this amazing video girls 🫶

Bellibel

Yes please!!!!

Amy

100% agreed on Sweet Nothing x hoax - I was so surprised Em didn't include it on her list! There are far too many concerning mashups to choose from though

aiyla

is that merch i see

Juliana Martinez

i’m so surprised no one mentioned his different and DBATC!!! so fun omg!!!

Andrea

Loved every second of thissss

Andrea

also as suggestion: please please please react to post’s new album if you haven’t heard yet 🥹

Rachel B

Anyone else hoping for a video from the girlies before Eras tour starts back up that’s a predictions for the end of the tour and/or reacting to fans Taylor conspiracy theories 🥺

Marina

Saaaame! This was so amazingly beautiful and meaningful <3

Marina

I was so lucky to hear Nothing New x Dear Reader live - it was such a special and raw mash-up, Taylor is just incredible.

Chloé

I share 6 mash ups with Bonny in my top 10 <3 So happy you 2 had The Prophecy x Long Story Short as your number cause it's one of my favorite mash ups ever and I was lucky enough to witness it with my own eyes and i cried so hard !! It was way too offensive and too much to handle !!

Chloé

Same !! And i had manifested The Prophecy for DAYS before the show I couldn't believe what was happening !!

Marisa Landsverk

The one I’m hoping for by end of tour is Tim McGraw (first song) + The Manuscript (most recent). Both songs discuss what the songwriting process is like and how it circles back around to helping you process your life. I would die.

Marisa Landsverk

One another thing about these two songs is they already have the same chords. The end of Tim McGraw chorus into The Manuscript bridge is a G.

Hannah Grace

Unsure if anyone has said it but a coldplay Moon music reaction would be awesome. i have just finished my first listen, was quite a experience

Julieann Challacombe

hands down my fav mashup was cowboy like me x you're in love. I remember watching that grainy live stream and thinking "this mashup was made for me" and i still cant cope. I think about it all the time lol. also plz excuse my juvenile grammar, im typing with one hand as i lay in bed with a glass of savy b in the other

kuma

My favorite one is still Come Back... Be Here X Daylight and imgonnagetyouback X Dress

Stevie

I definitely need a video compilation of all surprise songs and mashups on streaming or hardware when the tour is over. These moments have been so precious and special. I was lucky to witness a few live but during her concerts I was so overwhelmed by what happened around me that I would love to reconsider.

Stevie

And thank you 🙏🏻 very much for sharing your thoughts!! Very relatable!!

noah

i was just rewatching your old livestreams and it’s the best energy everrrr. i would love if y’all did more livestreams 🫶

Zosia Dabrowski

Friends I have the deeply concerning privilege of being able to learn a custom-arranged Taylor Swift medley with my choir and the director is looking for song suggestions so I'm using this video for ideas!!! Came at a perfect time thank you

Joanne

I definitely agree on HauntedxElixe, we got it Edinburgh N3 and singing the duet back to Taylor is a memory I’ll never forget 💜 Also my brag for the rest of my life is guessing TheBolterxGetawayCar from one strum of the guitar on N2 in Edinburgh. What a mashup! 💚

Kasey

I need more breakdowns of the mashups!!!! Even if it’s when the tour is over. You might have said that in this video but I can’t remember. How superior would it be if she released a live album of all the mashups???

Kasey

Ok just kidding I just finished the video and YES I need a refashioning!!! So glad you touched on that Emily.

Emma

3/4 of my mashups are there 😭 😍😍

Emma

How I wish I could relive it all 😭😭😭

ava

mashups from all 3 nights of liverpool here hahaha we rlly won

ava

i love the refathomings!!

Germaine Quek

One of my favourite mashups was i hate it here x the lakes and better man x its time to go

Louise

my favorite is I hate it here × the lakes, I relisten to it all the time "I hate it here ... so take me to the lakes" is sooooo offensive

Natalie

What list are they looking at???!! Of all the mashups??!

Sarah

Wow that's def something to brag about! My brag is getting that mashup completely correct on mastermind! The first time I got a fully correct guess for a surprise song mashup!

David Arch

Do you have all of the audio of all of the mashups or are you just going from memory of the live?

Christin

I missed the weather update 😔

Alyssa Kay

A random, fun video suggestion for Patreon! I recently found this quiz where you have 25 minutes to name every single Taylor Swift song! I think it could be really entertaining to watch you guys do this because you wouldn’t think your mind would go blank, but it really does. When I took it I completely forgot some obvious songs 😂 I’ve done it twice and the first time I got a 198/274 and the second time I got a 230/274 https://www.sporcle.com/games/Kyborgen/taylor-swift-all-songs

Inês Melo

Lisbon N2 was offensive and Bonny agrees 👀

Kirstie

The prophecy x long story short is my number 1 mash up, I felt so excited when you also chose this one!! 💕🤩

ELIJAH HATCH

Cornelia Street/Maroon is a favorite of mine along with Nothing New/Dear Reader and there’s another one I literally can’t remember but I know it’s in my brain somewhere😂

Breezy Bumbles

GUYS……I just fathomed that Taylor Swift has been to EVERY SINGLE Taylor Swift show ever! Every one! Why is my brain?????

Breezy Bumbles

TTPD (the song) is in my top 5. It’s so good I can’t even begin to explain. The production and melodies pierce my soul like no other song.

Ravioli

The prophecy × LSS mash-up felt like sending hope. Even when all seems lost and lost for good, this feeling also shall pass. The perspective of eternity, loneliness for eternity, becomes a moment. No one stays alone for ever.

Alyssaa

Mary’s song x so high school x everything has changed literally changed my life it was perfect

Breezy Bumbles

I need to rewatch every single mashup to actually remember what she did. I tried to do this with you guys but I quit immediately when I realized that I don’t remember ANYTHING! My memory is garbage lately and it’s actually concerning.

Breezy Bumbles

Yes. Let’s keep doing the surprise songs refathomings!

Vanessa Lesser

Pleaseeeee update this with the final leg of the tour. We need more mashup refathomings of this superior video!!! Ahhhhhhhh

Vanessa Lesser

I’m revisiting as well. It’s deeply concerning how i need to relive the eras tour all over again. I blacked out hahaha

Vanessa Lesser

Also Petermore destroys me. I can’t believe this woman. and the last shows mash up? Stoppp. We need a mashup album bc these are completely new songs. Bonny and I had almost all the same favs. Love u guys!! Xx

Ally ❤️

I think my favorite has to be the Travis Mashup: Mary’s Song x Everything Has Changed x so High School

Nicki

It's gotta be All of the Girls You Loved Before x Crazier and Mary's Song (Oh My My My) / So High School / Everything Has Changed. SO GOOOOOOOD i need them on spotify permanently

Kathryn

Oh my god, i needed to reply to you because I got both of these!!😍and i will quite literally never get over it! 💕

Lizzie Johnson

My fave is the cliche Cassanda x Mad Woman x IDSB... my 2nd fave is Haunted x Wonderland, but I realise you didn't know of either of these when you made this video haha

Chanelle

I would absolutely LOVE seeing you girlies revisit this now that the eras tour has almost been over for a year (HELP)