Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Videos

  • 449290011.mp4

Downloads

Content

Our beloved EVERMORE! We loveeeeee to talk about her and today we are re visiting these songs and trying to fathom if there might be a bit more truth to these songs then we originally thought or if maybe we had the energy WRONG?! Maybe some of these songs link to TTPD or at least make a bit more sense since that album. Enjoy these fathomings and let us know your thoughts below 🫶🏼

Files

Comments

Momo

😍😍😍 HIIIIIIIIIII

tyler

oh i’m so excited

Peter Oldham

OMG IM AT WORK FOR FIVE MORE HOURS BUT THE FACT THIS WAS UPLOADED IS GIVING ME A REASON TO LIVE

Alice Hannah

I’m SO EXCITED WHAT DO YOU SAY ABOUT COWBOY LIKE ME

IkSg9798

I almost screamed.

kienan

Oh shit… this is going to be a bit too superior. I just know it.

Ava Jeffs

EVERMORE MY BELOVEDDDDDDDDDD

Ava Jeffs

forevermore be fathoming

Amy

yessss it is here!! time to refathom!!

Carly

NEEDED THIS 🫶🤎

Ava Jeffs

my beautiful grandma forgotten child

Bethan

I’m so excited to watch this! You both look offensive, as always 🤎

Heidi Muller

Ah yes! The great re fathoming

Ava Jeffs

“iTS hER mOsT iMPorTaNT aLBuM” I scream as they come to take me AWAYYYYYY

Ava Jeffs

plot twist: taylor doesn’t talk about evermore because it’s her most personal album 🕺

Cher

I have never clicked so fast on anything ever

Paola H 🩵💛

Yaaaaas!! 🤎 Guys do you know if there is an option to see the videos offline???? . I’m flying tomorrow for hours and would love to watch it on the plane 😭

Keri 🫶🏻

my favorite album 🤎 sooooo excited for this!!

Alberto

literally who posts at least 2 superior videos a week that are most likely hours long!?? Only you beautiful souls could!!! 🥹🥹🥹❤️❤️❤️🫶🏼

Kathryn

Oh I haven't moved so fast in MONTHS 👏🏼 So excited

Marylovesowls

OMG I literally watched your evermore reaction yesterday for funsies!!! Omg what great timing!!!!!

Katie LaFave

call me delusional idc! i don't think any differently about folklore or evermore post the joe breakup or post matty healy! i don't think any songs on evermore are about matty and the only songs in my mind that are about joe are willow, long story short maybe gold rush, and the bridge of evermore! for me with tolerate it, i think about scott! with happiness i think it could be about abigail, but also scott! in my opinion, just like how a lot of folklore is about scott/scooter, i feel the same way about evermore! i actually think there is more storytelling on evermore than folklore

DEVILZSTAR

This! It feels like a glimpse into her head at a time where she was so confused, feeling forced to be happy when nothing truly made her happy. It feels like her most raw album in hindsight

Leelou

So excited for this one! 🫶🏻

hauntedwillow27

THE MOMENT WE’VE ALLLLLLLL BEEN WAITING FOR.

Jule

two hour long evermore video??? this is my dream 😭🤎

Kathryn

Could "like a priceless wine" be a Maroon link? 👀

j🪩

yesss!!!! can’t wait for the folklore and lover re fathomings as well 🤍

Katie K

Nearly 2 hours of evermore content?! Absolute blessed heaven 🙏🏻✨🤎

Mayra

I can feel your coziness from here in the states. Love evermore content!

Sammi

So so desperately needed this today. Thank you girls <3

Jenny

Emily!! I got the same dress and just received it! It’s so cute 🥰

Taylor

Omg I am so excited for this video!

hauntedwillow27

i also think it’s important to remember not every lyric in a song has to be about the same person. “swirled you into all of my poems” might literally mean she came up with a certain lyric about matty and put it in a song where it could also be about joe. that’s why i think something like the bridge of willow might fit more for joe but the other lyrics in the song fit more for matty. it’s interesting to think about!

Elle D

bonnnnyyyy omg you are really fathoming some things about willow im shook. the "wait for the signal and I'll meet you after dark" connection to potentially midnights writing sessions...

Abby

I just want to say thanks for having such excellent Patreon content… it really is clear you put so much effort to making the subscription really worthwhile and if I can just speak for the class for a second, we’re very grateful ☺️

Jenny

You guys are blowing my tiny mind with Willow and I need 2-3 business days to recover

Mex

girls, paring your fearless dress illustration with taylor's fearless heart photo is genius for your office art!🫶🏻🫶🏻🫶🏻

Clementine

The rain sounds are soooo calming!!!!

Megan C

My dreams have come true!!!! Thank you so much!!! Can't wait to listen! 🥰😭🍂🌱🤎

Megan C

So so so grateful!

Beth

I so agree. Or she put him there retrospectively- like with Cardigan. She didn’t write it about him, but she swirled him into that story because she thought at the time he fitted

kienan

Ok besties — like you said — we should lay out all possible options even if we don’t fully believe them. What if the songs Joe is credited on is simply for the melody/musical composition? What if Taylor asked him for the rights to the songs and wrote her inner, unexpressed feelings over them? Either as a way of trying to DO SOMETHING SAY SOMETHING before he lost her? Sometimes I just really can’t imagine them writing these songs together. And I always think about how Jack was strange about Joe being mentioned in the long pond film. I dunno. Just a thought

Renee S Smith

The more you say, the less I know reminds me of drilling the safe? Like you talk but you're not saying anything.

Jenny

didn't she say that he came up with concept of Betty though and some of the lyrics? About the boy apologising to the girl etc

Christine Violet

I just don’t know if I 100% believe her and Joe were truly writing songs together… like yes, technically they both wrote a part of each song that he is credited on, but I personally think it was more that he was messing around on the piano during Covid, created a melody or even a few lyrics, and she took that and created the rest. But I don’t know if I believe they ever sat down together and fully collaborated on a song where they would bounce ideas off eachother or mess around like her and Jack often do!

sebastián

i would even add that not every lyric has to necessarily apply to one of them, or anyone! i think that even though we all recognize taylor as an amazing incredible story teller, we can forget to give her imagination some credit. i truly believe she has to make stylistic choices that fit no narrative or real life event in particular, just bc it sounds better, it’s more poetic or beautiful, fits the song’s story or melody better. she is not always laying straight facts in her songs and that’s my hot take 🌚🌝

Jenny

I don't think it's impossible that 'everybody wants you, everybody wonders what it would be like to love you' is about Joe even if we don't understand it, it reminds me of 'I'm highly suspicious that everyone who sees you wants you' from Lover..

Christine Violet

I agree, I think depending on the song there could be different ways or degrees she incorporated Matty.. sometimes it could be just a line or two, sometimes it could be a song that she says is made up or non-autobiographical but really is about Matty, or sometimes it could be a song she makes seem like it’s about Joe but really it’s about Matty.

sebastián

to me it’s funny how the lyrics that fit some new theory are taken like facts but the ones that don’t are taken as “she’s saying them to distract us or joe” 😭

Christine Violet

She did, she said he was messing around on the piano and came up with part of the song… but I don’t think she says they wrote the rest of it together… what if she just took those parts and wrote the rest on her own?

Erica

Where did I hear she wrote Champagne Problems about Logan asking Rory to marry him and she said no? From Gilmore girls. I thought that was confirmed? And it follows the story perfectly. “Your sisters splashed out on the bottle” was so Honor 😂

Jenny

I'm not sure I believe she'd credit him if it wasn't a significant contribution though! I think if she can claim a song as self written she will because songwriting is so much a part of her identity as an artist. Just my opinion though! In her folklore grammy speech as well she said about writing songs with him in quarantine. I do agree with you that the collaboration would have looked very different to her and Jack, I think her collaboration with each person would look different and the partnership her and Jack have is very unique. But I do believe Joe made significant contributions to the songs he's credited on.

Mika B

Yesterday was April 9 the date that Jo and Taylor's breakup was announced 2 years ago!!

Christine Violet

No I agree with you, I just don’t think it was a joint collab in the moment. I think he created a big chunk of those songs on his own while messing around on the piano while in quarantine, which she does mention in long pond, but in order to complete the song, I just don’t know If I believe they sat together and wrote together. I feel like she just took his part and finished the song on her own. Obviously I don’t know what really happened, that’s just the vibe I get!

kienan

Oop, Bon, I see you say just that around the 58 min mark. Great minds…

Christine Violet

I went back and looked up all the quotes Taylor has said about writing with Joe, and I can admit you are right. I remember it very differently, I don’t know why but I don’t remember her talking so often about the process they had writing together. I honestly believed she had just said that he was messing around on the piano and she took those parts and created the rest of the song. But I’m clearly wrong, she has talked many times in the past about truly collaborating together. Thanks for calling me out, it made me do a little bit of fact checking LOL! ♥️

Emily Warfield

I hope you go through all the albums 🖤

sebastián

i honestly just have a hard time believing “what must it be like to grow up that beautiful with you hair falling into place like dominoes” is about matty…. 💀 shade aside i also think that she often talks about joe and how she found him so attractive and their physical connection was something strong and in contrast i can’t really recall if she ever talks about matty’s physical appearance because.. well… (SORRY) she tends to refer to their connection as something like kindred spirits and all that

Jenny

😂😂😂 I totally agree with you!

Alana1989xox

She's in a box in the Willow music video?! That just reminded me of the My Boy lyric ''he took me out of my box"!

Brenda1989

It’s crazy how in gorgeous his eyes are ocean blue she could sink and drown and die, in gold rush they’re eyes like sinking ships she almost jumps in and in so long London u say I abandon the ship but I was going down with it

hannahxxbishop

ladies the nail color is my absolute favorite color and i feel so seen that yall are wearing it this week (even tho it has nothing to do with me lol)

Jenny

yeah.. I think I get a bit uncomfortable assuming that he got more credit than he deserves bc we really don't know! And the opposite could also be true - he could have contributed more than we think? I would just hate to have my art questioned like that so there's a part of me that wants to acknowledge and respect his writing credit because the fact is it's there and she hasn't changed that or made any attempt to diminish it since they broke up, so I think it stands.

Rianne van Ladesteijn

I always took Joe’s writing credits as he wrote the music, coming up with a piano melody rather than him writing lyrics on the songs - which also maybe explains why jack poked fun at it because he didn’t do that much but was just playing some piano that then inspired Taylor to create a whole song. But that could just be an assumption I made out of thin air lol

Edith Ferrufino

"It is quite interesting... " Always makes me giggle, it's like a light bulb going off in your head in real time hehe

Jenny

Coming up with piano part of Exile is a pretty big deal though, it's the most recognisable part of the song! She also said he wrote all of Bon Iver's first verse..

Cooler Fan

I was under the impression that Bon did the piano re. her apple interview?

Jenny

In long pond she said Joe came up with the piano part and first verse, and Bon Iver wrote the bridge!

Kristen

bonny came PREPARED for willow 👀 i just started the video and i’m sat

Becky

Loving the rain sounds! Personally, I think Willow has an interesting duality. It seems to speak both about Joe and Matty. The lines that confuse me are in the bridge. "they count me out time and time again" - could this reference Tolerate it? Also "I come back stronger than a 90's trend" as in I could come back to you (Matty). Aaand...i just got to the part of the video where you go back to this exact idea. Lol.

Aisha Louise

oh no gold rush is soooo Alwyn coded

Emily Warfield

I’ve always viewed Dorothea as a friendship, I like the Selena theory

Brenda1989

“My baby’s fit like a day dream” to “where did my baby go”

Meredith

Matty ended his speech at the February 2020 NME awards “be a cowboy” (he and Taylor were videoed greeting each other at the show so she was in the audience when he said it)… feel like that’s such a link to cowboy like me.

Momo

I feel like I'm at church rn 😂💜

Chats & Reacts

Thank you bestie, it means a lot for you to take the time to notice and then let us know 🥹 we love you guys here so much and just want it to be the best space for everyone!

Chats & Reacts

Thats tea, and I definitely think you're right. I would bet there is a lot of songs over the years that have emotions or experiences drawn from more than just 1 muse!

Alexa

I’ve only watched until the end of the Willow discussion, but I agree with Bonny…the song has never fully made sense to me. I don’t think she is writing exclusively about Matty, but the music video is definitely something to consider. I haven’t watched it in a while, but doesn’t she depict the two lovers to have been connected since they were young?? (Lots of references in ttpd about that) Also, they sort of miss each other in passing for years and years before they finally end up together (it’s giving would it be enough to just float in your orbit 🫠). Love you guys!!

Catherine (YOYOK stan)

Loved everything and totally agree to the fathomings, I will say that when I first heard tolerate it back in 2020 my first thought was that it was about her relationship with Joe. But no one else thought it so I told myself I was delusional. Now since then of course everyone jumping in makes me feel validated 😂. My only point is that you guys didn’t bring up how the actor that plays the man in willow has a similar look and vibe to matty. Or am I the only one who sees this? Often times artists cast their love interest to look like their real life lover but in this case I thought how odd that this guy looks nothing like Joe. And now I see it’s because it was matty all along and she was being sneaky! Can’t wait for the next refathom!

ArielStormborn

"So inviting, I almost jump in".... and then she dives into the water in Eras Tour before midnights??

Rebecca

He wants what's only yours? That's always struck me as a very suspicious line in Ivy

Grace

Thirded. The best use of my money by FAR

Grace

I do think gold rush can still be about Joe. Or even about multiple muses (I’m not always one to believe a song is about one experience). “Sinking ships on water” reminds me of So Long, London — “you say I abandoned the ship, but I was going down with it.” Although I suppose that lyric could go the other way— the relationship was sinking and she almost jumps into the waters of the unknown or another relationship.

Mackenzie

Omg Bonny’s Willow argument is finally making it make sense. I am fully convinced

Ellen Blair

“Unfortunately Matty Healy has given us some of the best songs she’s ever written” sums this entire last 5 years up so perfectly. 😭

Holly

All of the matty connections are making my head hurt hahahah how have i not fathomed

Renee S Smith

Renegade is the angry Joe song, SLL is acceptance

Aloha Record Sargent

Adding to the Willow discussion: "Wreck my plans" makes me think of "If you want to tear my world apart; Just say you've always wondered"

Ottie Rose

Ivy makes me think of “still alive, killing time at the ✨cemetery✨.. never quite buried”, and I see a link to Champagne Problems of her imagining if she actually did marry Joe that Matty would still have a piece of her soul and even marriage wouldn’t stop him putting roots in her dream land. Joe was just a no in Bon words lol. The Matty vibes are blowing my mind right now. Evermore was such an underrated album what the actual fuck.

sharon teles

where the spirit meets the bones / killing time at the cemetery never quite buried

Abby Thaine

“Saying god help her when I tell em he’s my man” - I can fix him “Wreck my plans that’s my man” -Willow 🙃

Taylor Bailey

I HAVE WAITED SO LONG FOR THIS VIDEO I AM SO EXCITED AHHH

Renee S Smith

This video made me mad. That Renegade kicker. It might be a hot toddy curse out a Joe Widow kind of night now.

Noah Dale

Loved this refathoming!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! was thinking maybe the "seven years in heaven" lyric in happiness may be about Scott and could be like the seven years between making debut and the development of Red when she started to get backlash for wanting to go in the Pop direction....

Renee S Smith

Its the worst men I write the best.

Debzie3

or august ...."slipped away like a bottle of wine cuz you were never mine" I am passing away

Renee S Smith

I didn't hear this album until she was with Travis (sorry football fan) but yea I clocked that right away. I was surprised people told me it was fictional. I was like nah, she felt every word of that deep down.

Sydney Bradshaw

Yes!! Ivy and loml are so linked because she also says in loml "I felt aglow like this, never before and never since" and in Ivy she says "your touch brought forth and incandescent glow"

Samantha

I agree, I honestly feel like that line speaks more to her insecurities than any sort of reality

Astoria

Also for Tis the Damn Season, the whole imagery is the girl's (Taylor's) hometown. In Thank You Aimee, she says "when I picture my hometown" and "hometown" is a metaphor for Los Angeles/Hollywood. So I think in Tis the Damn Season, "hometown" could be her early life in Hollywood, and Matty could be the guy she goes back to whenever they're passing through LA at the same time.

anxious_swiftie

Nobody talk to me for 1 hour and 53 minutes! My show is on!

Abby Thaine

The dive has always confused me and this could be it meaning. She “jumped in” to her longings/fantasies while making midnights

✨Bri✨

Alert!!! I just had a fathoming!!!! “Greet you with a battle hero’s welcome” is totally giving “fighting in only your army, front lines don’t you ignore me”. That whole line in you’re losing me is completely a reference to tolerate it, she was fighting there with him front lines but he ignored her or rather tolerated her!!!! Help.

Courtney

Such a superior re-fathoming. This made me look at evermore in a whole new light (in a good way of course)!!

Rachel Teater

Could Champagne Problems be about Joe and Taylor but switch the genders? Like Taylor was the one proposing and wanting to get married but Joe said no or just never could commit or agree to it. I think this also would go along with a lot of the lyrics talking about the female in the song having mental health issues that keep them from committing but never really having a reason (this being actually Joe's perspective). SUPER interesting considering they wrote it togther.

Laura R

Yeah, I also think the context of "everybody" could be the circles Taylor is in, not "everybody" as in he's super famous and has a bunch of fans. There are definitely people in my life who seem to attract everyone they come in contact with. Joe could be like that in his in-person circles.

GigiLou

I always enjoy seeing you chickens, even when I disagree with some of your takes ;) Regarding Tolerate It, it really is worth reading Rebecca and even then tying it back to how Taylor may have related to some emotions in the book. The 'Tolerate It' lyrics are very closely tied to the relationship in the book. If you want to do something different, it could be a fun Swiftie book club video and then discuss how she related to this crazy story (Hint: there's kind of a No Body No Crime connection!). I also feel confident that Happiness pulls from The Great Gatsby because there are very clear references, and I'm pretty sure Taylor has mentioned being a fan of the book. There's probably way more literary references that I don't pick up on because I haven't read the books! This is just to say, while I think she does feel emotionally tied to her songs in some way, she definitely grabs lyrics and stories from other sources - not sure it's so simple as Matty vs. Joe.

Laura R

I actually don't think Jack was diminishing Joe's contribution to the songs in Long Pond. He did a silly bit when Taylor formally told us WB was Joe, but that's very Jack generally and could also have been his way of breaking the tension. When Taylor described hearing Joe playing/singing the chorus of Betty, I took Jack's response as him being impressed. Not saying he was a super fan of Joe... He certainly came for him when he posted the date they made You're Losing Me. It's just the discourse around that particular interaction in Long Pond that I don't fully buy into.

Laura R

Low key, I think this might be why we didn't get an evermore long pond. 👀

Tess7

I thoroughly enjoyed this refathoming of evermore! You two little evermore girlies are just the best. Willow is a song, isn’t it? Gold Rush is one that made me wonder from first listen who she is writing about. A gold rush was literally everyone running to an area to stake a claim- everybody wants you. Who in Taylor’s life is like that? Not Joe or Matty lol Tis The Damn Season/ Dorothea are superior songs. Tolerate It- this masterpiece may have been inspired by a book, but she said herself, she could relate to it because of things in her own life. NBNC is Taylor finally just saying to hell with it, I’m killing him this time. Lol Cowboy like me is one of her best songs, no matter who the guy in it is. I do think the opening line - the tennis court was covered up with a tent like thing- is not Joe. Being grifters, could maybe be describing an actor, but also works for a showman that sings. I’ll stop there or I’ll write a book 😁 excellent job of taking us through the “what if’s”of this superior album called-evermore. 🫶

Alex

After watching this I thought of Need and listened again and I just gotta say it’s very interesting 👀 “cigarette smoke” “I would go anywhere that you lead” (Peter/wendy)“It's essential to me that you love me more than wishing, longing” “caught up in a feeling, it’s deceiving” JUST SAYING

Aloha Record Sargent

The cemetery in Ivy where she "meets" him = "killing time at the cemetery" ? In other words, they aren't really meeting in a cemetery, they are meeting to rekindle their never-quite-buried relationship.

Jamie Gibson

It's a NEED for me to hear any songs Matty and Taylor wrote during Midnights. Like I cannot actually believe there are songs out there during the rekindling of their longing for each other. WHERE ARE THESE SONGS

Aloha Record Sargent

The "house of stone" in Ivy reminds me of Chloe et al. "If you want to break my cold, cold heart, say you loved me"

Cat Tulo

this is teaaa

Renee S Smith

But that could also be how you might feel about someone you're too scared to be with? Like something you tell yourself as an excuse?

Amy Versprille

I think Matty and her were best friends / that was the worst part, they were texting or sending emails, then she says how he has haunted her so stunningly, he told her she was the love of his life about a million times. I think they have been talking for years - maybe it used to be a bit here and there about music but it blossomed and when Covid and she was lonely with Joe, things probably became more frequent and then oh no she was falling in love again, the more that you say - the less I know…we can see how she weaves him into all of her poems….🫶

Amy Versprille

I think Willow is totally a Matty song

Snoopy

Why is Evermore actually the best album to ever exist

Green Wolf Gaymer

With Ivy and the cemetery. loml also has cemetery references. "Still alive killing time at the cemetery" "where the spirit meets the bones" "never quite buried" Just saying.

Alexa

Thank you for this, it was fantastic! To be honest, I never thought much of the Willow music video and never quite understood it — but this refathoming has convinced me it’s a metaphor for her and Matty’s journey. It’s SO artistic now that I see it through this lens! ALSO — in The 1975 music video for Oh Caroline, which I believe is rumored to be about Taylor, Matty also explores this old/young narrative, where he remembers the times he had with a blonde girl, dancing in a way that feels so reminiscent of Delicate! It also looks like Willow premiered on December 10 2020 and Oh Caroline on December 9 2022. Funny coincidence... I also think it's interesting that she goes into the piano dressed as folklore (the start of this exploration, "what if it was Matty all along?") but exits dressed as (I guess) evermore (figuring out that yes, it was him all along)? Oh, these two. Part of me hopes their story isn’t over, because I selfishly want more art like this :)

Alexa

Re: Joe credits. I have a theory that he might not have necessarily written lyrics, but that those topics came up in their conversations and fights — maybe even some of the metaphors were his. She took inspiration from them and turned them into songs. I feel it would only be fair to give him credit if the narrative was born during an intimate conversation between the two of them.

Mary 🫶🏻🇨🇦

I hope the girls are alive after the Fearless cardigan release and the surprise Lorde snippet of new music to come 👀

Jenna Bolmgren

Like I said in my “unpopular opinion” comment, I don’t necessarily think we can be certain that all rep and lover songs are about Joe (and/or aren’t about Matty).

Starbuck1234!

Coney Island is a Joe song but she put Matty into the bridge. IMO, the gold clock is Matty. Were you waiting by the tree line by the gold clock, did i leave you hangin’ every single day? This is Matty. Think of Cardigan. The Highline. Leaving on the last train marked her like a bloodstain. One of the most famous Gold Clock’s in the world is at Grand Central Station, in NYC, where outside is a treeline aka a line of trees. We know cardigan is about Matty, she told us, and those lines about the Highline and the leaving on the train. And, that lyric about leaving on the train is right next to the Peter losing Wendy line. He got on a train! the Gold Clock part has to be Matty Healy leaving her hangin’. It didn’t work out, like all the others.

Starbuck1234!

I also think Ivy begins at the cemetery (cue loml). The old widow goes to the stone every day, grieving for the living. I think this is someone alive a well who is not grieving a person but grieving not being with who they love, or think they love, or who are day dreaming about. Its the ivy grows = the idea of that person grows until they are covered in that person. But cannot be with them, sneaking around in monuments that they stole, grieving for herself at the cemetery, the relationship, shouldve let it stayed buried. But it’s a war, and you started it. HE DID. He looked up Jack, he said hey Jack why don’t you produce my album, and HE was in her backyard at HER stomping grounds with Jack, and love bombed her. He did start it.

Lauren

I don’t think there is a single song in her discography pre-TTPD that was released that is originally about Matty. I think there are songs she made about him to fit their situation (cardigan), but their timeline doesn’t add up. She and Joe had a break in 2021 (inspires hits different, bejeweled, labyrinth …YLM). She goes out and then crumbles. If Matty were on her mind during this time, she would’ve gone to him. Taylor gets any man she wants (she does have trouble keeping them because they can’t handle it - which is NOT her fault). In fact, the first time she chose Matty EVER was in January of 2023 when she wore that short, sparkly dress to the concert. She was still choosing Joe before that (it’s why mastermind is the midnights closer). Heck she released AOTGYLB as a last ditch effort for Joe. So much of Taylor’s music about Joe is about them meeting while she was in a relationship with another man, her immediate crush on him, them playing cat and mouse, and then them finally confessing feelings. And then him not fully being into how famous she is and that she’s a POPstar. But he still chooses her, despite not always being 100% in.

Jami Marie

Wow, completely changing my view on evermore was not on my bingo card for today but here we are! So many things make more sense to me now, especially Willow and gold rush

Demons

Thank you! I’ve been saying the majority of this album is about matty!

Courtney McAlexander

“I’m never gonna love again” is not only in Cowboy like me but also Happiness by the 1975 (2022 album), which has other lyrics gems such as: I'm gonna stop messin' it up because I'm Feeling like I'm messin' it up because I'm Callin' out your name, and God help me, 'cause Oh, I'm never gonna love again, hey Why don't you grow up and see?

Mira Darling

Oooooh I love this, cannot wait to watch it!!! Been very drawn to your content lately and maybe it was just my intuition telling me that there is more of evermore to come 😍😍😍

Jackie

What’s getting me through it is that it was the romanticized ✨ idea ✨ of Matty that was the muse and then when they actually gave it a go the reality of him was the smallest man who ever lived 💀

Luli Swiftie

OMG! Taylor did run into him t the NMES 2020 there are videos of them talking HELP

Jackie

You guys need to break down the Zane Lowe Evermore interview now 😂 I haven’t watched it in forever and I feel like there would be so much more to fathom now

Rose Ellen

I always took the 'seven years in heaven' lyric to be a play on the teen game seven minutes in heaven

Lindsay

Bonnie is FATHOMING things

CDplayer

this video is so interesting!! luv the discussion sm

Laura

adding to the Willow discussion maybe being about Matty: willow being described by Taylor as her casting a spell on someone to get them to fall in love with her has always reminded me a lot of the Paris lyrics "I want to brainwash you into loving me forever". Which idk how you you guys feel but could also be about matty maybe? ALSO the priceless wine lyrics maybe being similar to those peter lyrics, wine is only priceless/expensive when it's still unopened. the fact that she never really "caught" Matty in the decade-long back and forth they had, aka the only "crossing your jet stream", is what made him priceless. when they finally gave it a go, he disappointed her; the wine bottle had been opened and lost all of its value/desirability

Nele

This discussion was so interesting! Sometimes I think that she wouldn't be that on the nose about it when she knows that Joe hears these songs and then I remember she straight up had "the 1" on folklore already 😄

Sami Ali

Bonny please tell us about how you have your hair up! I love it

Cole Jones

The conversation about Gold Rush reminds me of some lyrics in The 1975 song Change of Heart. Which is a song about how someone who was once romantically interested in him (Matty) changed their mind because he couldn’t get his shit together. Some of the lyrics are from the other person’s perspective speaking to Matty. And this song was written back in 2015 around the time they would’ve met/spent time together. “You’re mad thinking you could ever save me, not looking like that. You used to have a face straight out of a magazine, now you just look like anyone. I’ve just had a change of heart” That parallels “what must it be like to grow up that beautiful” so well.

Cole Jones

I would love for you guys to fathom some 1975 albums at some point. For research lol

Kiki

You being lowkey surprised that tolerate it is the number one looked at on Genius ... Me looking at my fifth favorite Taylor Swift song of all time 👀👀

Jana L

Maybe the „wreck my plans“ in willow is about Joe and it means he should wreck her „career plans“ (which bothered him anyway) - à la please step up & say something But I do think in it‘s about Matty 😄

Lucie S

20 minutes in and I am having a full mental breakdown, I cannot believe I didn't see Willow as a Matty song, it fits so much better !! Cannot wait to watch the rest of the video tonight when I'm back from work <3

Isaac

The Coney Island fathomings have destroyed me. I knew there was a reason it’s my second favourite on the island

Leijette Riopel

The train lyric in Willow also reminds me of the story she tells in “I Look in People’s Windows.”

Emelie

I don’t think I’m ready for this video 🥲

Sara🇸🇪

Also the fact that she told us she writes bad man best and don’t and can’t always write about people even if she loves them al lot… in folklore and evermore maybe matty was like just a muse but those feeling qrew as she and joe drifed apart…

Hayley 🫶🏻✨

Help I’m still thinking about willow. Did willow walk so guilty as sin could run? My mind is blown. Also I see my prints on your wall!!! 🫶🏻✨

Emelie

You’re talking about the tolerate it “gained the weight of you then lose it” and it’s giving so long London “my spine split from carrying us up the hill” 👀

Amy

i've been saying this since TTPD came out! in my mind it's 100% a connection

Amber

HOLD ON, okay if were thinking that songs from evermore can be about the matt man, which I firmly believe, what if and just hear me out, what if The Great War is about Matty, and the Great War was actually the 6 years she was with Joe. Because if you look at the lyrics, "diesel was desire, you were playing with fire", "my hand was the one you reached for all throughout the great war", and so many more. ALSO ALSO ALSO "I vowed not to fight anymore if we survived the great war", COULD BE INSTEAD OF FIGHTING LIKE ARGUING, FIGHTING FOR THE RELATIONSHIP WITH JOE OMG I just gave myself shivers. I also feel like there is something to say with this being able to link back to Peter, like she always thought he was gonna come back to her at some point and when they finally got in contact again she was like YES BOYSSS were so back like we've survived the great war of not being in contact, ya know. ALSO sorry I keep adding things but like "I vowed I would always be yours if we survived the great war", if your in a 4/5 year relationship at that point wouldn't you already have vowed to always be theirs regardless of some fight or break, like I think it makes more sense for the Matty situation kind of like if after all this time if we still find each other, if we survive this great war, I vow I will always be yours because clearly we are meant to be

karisa

Bonny truly seeing the vision about willow and trying to show it to Emily is so satisfying

Leijette Riopel

Guys - when you were talking about Ivy, I was screaming at the screen - LOML?!?!?! “Killing time at the cemetery, never quite buried.”!!!l It seems to be a lot of Matty in there. Also, I desperately need to talk about the fact that I strongly feel that the narrator in Ivy is NOT married. She is engaged to someone she doesn’t love. Her hand has been “promised to another”, and “promised to” is an old-timey figure of speech meaning engaged. Also, the sense of desperation and urgency that comes in the bridge gives me the idea that she is trying to escape before it is too late - “so tell me to run, or dare to sit and watch what we’ll become and drink my husband’s wine.” She is offering her lover a choice - to ask her to elope with him and run away before the wedding, because if he doesn’t, then this other man really will be her husband, and her lover would then be “drinking her husband’s wine”. They would really be having an affair, doing something immoral, and she doesn’t want their relationship to be something illicit.

karisa

The ending of champagne problems being the main hook of chloe or sam or sofia or marcus definitely means something but I can’t figure out what 🧐

Evie Cottrell

As a 20 year old watching these videos, i feel like i am learning sooo much about relationships from my two wise older sisters haha --- just from you both talking about your own experience in long term relationships

karisa

gold rush and cososom feel like sister songs

Rachel

wow I've just had so many fathomings

Bella

Yesss especially cause potentially some of these songs she felt were too vulnerable and so left them off folklore????

Alina

Can someone catch me up - who ranked these songs into “denial” etc? It sounded to me like Taylor did??? Did I miss something

Laura

Could "Every bait and switch was a work of art" relate to "Being this young is art"? We know Matty was in her world from the 1989 era so could the 'bait and switch' be them circling each other but never getting together?

Jazzyg

this video is big brain energy for sure hahaha years ago I commented on your 3am reaction on youtube connecting ivy and the great war and now I feel like I can finally fully fathom. I feel like I'm gonna be thinking about all of this for years

Jazzyg

Yes she did! She added songs from her discography into playlists on apple music leading up to the release of tortured poets. This was when everyone was speculating the album to be about the stages of grief. Taylor took the concept and made the playlists!

K

Bonny’s willow fathoming changed a lot of neuronal connections. With that much logical arguing I cannot argue

Alina

Omg!!! I’m freaking out ahaha thank you this is amazing

claudia jones

This video is iconic BUT I need to interrupt it and ask the girls have you seen that Lorde is teasing new music !!! Today is a day 😭🤍🤍🤍

Kelsey

They day you posted your last evermore video was the day we welcomed a puppy to our family, and I ended up calling her Willow! Tonight, we are chilling, and enjoying this new video together!!

Jazzyg

The "how dare you say that its...(over)" in down bad is so so sad. I'm sure that there is some grief in there over losing the escapism of writing these songs about Matty. Using him as a muse, looking through this lense, the longing and dreaming has now all been destroyed. Folklore and Evermore are such special escapism albums, to think that it's all "over" is really heartbreaking...

Heidi Muller

Matty said at an awards show that they are cowboys. Taylor was at that awards show.

ton

I think you guys should react to MH acceptance awards at the 2020 NME awards. It seems the first time they’d met up in a while. She’s there with Joe and pretty drunk in her acceptance speech I think. But the MH acceptance speech is TEEEEAAAA

ton

Pretty sure Betty is in denial because it has 1000 red flags in it 🤣

Leijette Riopel

I think it’s possible the Rep vault may be FULL of songs connected to Matty Healy. If she felt strongly enough to have pined for him for that many years, it’s unlikely she didn’t write any songs about him back around the time they first dated, so the Rep vault is likely where those songs would be. Hell, half of the songs actually on Rep could have been written about him and just masked to make it seem like they were about Joe. She has certainly proven she can hide things very effectively when she wants to.

Jade

For her next album, I wonder if she’s going to have some happiness and fun and magic with the inspo from Travis…. Like a really hyped up club/dance songs?

Jesse Conner

“Always taking up too much space and time” is very “monster on the hill”

Johanna M

Gold Rush now finally makes more sense being about Matty. I fully agree with your analysis on this song. Gold Rush also has the line "ships on water", which could link it back to Willow.

Kathryn

Could "my house of stone" represent the Lover house? And the Ivy all over it is folklore/evermore growing in her mind? Her imagination of this other love taking over the 'dreamland' that she tried to create in Lover. Because she's slowly realised that she hates it here 🥲

Johanna M

I remember when Swifties were calling evermore the album a collection of stories that end. I guess now the second big theme is longing (fantasy, dreams)! Wow!

Megan Zegveldt

My surprise songs in London were My Boy x Coney Island & I’m not saying it means Coney Island is about Matty but I’ve not listened to Coney Island the same since 😭🤣

Hanna Kulla

i’m sorry but ‘tis the damn season screams matty and tay i mean: you can run, but only so far lescaped it too, remember how you watched me leave.. like he watch her leave and move on with joe.. but if it's okay with you, it's okay with me we could call it even you could call me babe for the weekend.. like she’s playing it cool cause if it’s okay with him and if he’s not giving in to them then she won’t either

Hanna Kulla

also the lyric „use my best colors for your portrait“ like in her songs..

Michaela

What stuff did she say online about cardigan? Not sure what they're referring to towards the end of the video?

Bradi R

Why did you decide to blow my mind on a random Thursday morning

Maria

Yep this is when he said "be a cowboy" in his speach and a few months later we got Cowboy like me😏🤠

Sünne

When you broke down "eyes like sinking ships on water" my mind immediately went to her saying that matty with his eyes was sinking ships aka her and joe's relationship! Even if willow isn't about joe, she stills links him to ships in so long london and I just couldn't stop thinking about this interpretation of that line, omg!!!

Claudy

Just when I need it the most, you guys upload a 1h53m video about my favourite album.. 🤎🤎

Ali ❤️‍🔥

I’ve only just started- I really don’t agree that Willow is inspired by MH… I think the “wreck my plans” is more about her career. Like she’s made it clear at this point that she’ll live a quieter life to please JA even though that’s not really what she wants. I think Bonny to your point, it doesn’t make sense to write this about your bf of 4 years, but I think that we should remember she really wasn’t very happy and she felt left out of his life.

sydney

Brain being rearranged by my favorite girls discussing my favorite album.

Nicole

So happy you made this video!

DemiMarie🤍🖤

Haha Bonny's face on the cover of this video is sending me 🤣💀

Cee

THANK YOU GIRLS, THANK YOU SOOOOO MUCH FOR THIS VIDEEOOOOO!!!! ☺️💛

Taylor

Yall should rewatch the Zane Lowe Evermore interview

Taylor

I just cannot understand how if she had all these feelings and then wrote you’re loosing me in Dec 2021, how did it take more than a year after that for them to finally break up ??

Claudy

I saw something on Reddit where someone has some compelling reasons on why the “in lower case inside a vault” is about imgonnagetyouback.

ttpd-24

Matty also made a speech at an awards show referring to himself as a cowboy…. Taylor was also there.

Laura

I was on tik tok yesterday and saw a surprising theory about Tis The Damn Season + Dorothea which shocked me. It said that the two songs are actually written about Jack Antonoff's relationship with actress Scarlett Johansson. Is this in any way true? I saved the clip because it was so bizarre.

Emma

Wait could you also refathom the music videos from midnights, evermore and folklore post ttpd? Like not cause I have a specific reason why or something in them that I specifically is thinking of right now but just idk along with the prologues and albums I think the music videos from those three same eras could be due for a rewatch as well maybe 🤔 to see if and how they fit into/add to the storylines with some retrospective post TTPD perspective

Olivia✨

Wowwww you two chickens really said some thingssss in this video!!!!!

Renata

i do have to say that the first time i saw ivy in a “oh shit this is a matty coded song” way was when she mashed it up with wcs (at your show!!) like the narrative she painted with that song was so…overt? like you were someone so deeply embedded into my fantasies and desires and now i just regret you all the time 🙃 anyways i love the new light you shed on these songs, expanding on themes we might not have understood before when we didn’t know the depths of what was going through her mind. even though i think a majority of them aren’t as clean cut simply because i think her version of matty was just bits and pieces of his personality cobbled together with duct tape and delusion lol. plus i think she still had hope that joe could fill in that role of that fantasy she created in her head which is why (among other reasons) she fought for that relationship for so long. it makes me wonder if ts12 will explore any themes of letting go of using fantasy and escapism as a coping mechanism now that her reality is no longer disappointing and confusing. “everything this man *touches* turns to happiness fun and magic” could be such an easter egg for ts12, like it’s no longer in her head, it’s grounded in reality.

Amanda Christon

Absolutely fucked up over Coney Island re fathoming 😭

Allie

Champagne problems, thinking about her not being sure if she wanted to say yes -- this makes complete sense because when we are in unfulfilled relationships, we often hyperfocus on what the other person is doing or not doing, and it can block our truth that we just aren't happy or it's us that doesn't want to be here too.

Allie

I've been DESPERATE to discuss this album since TTPD because there is just SO MUCH TO UNDERSTAND AND IT IS SO OBVIOUS

K

Agreed, my brain is not the same anymore after all these razor-sharp fathomings

Cassy

bonny, i am sooo with you on willow and it being a mh song rather than a ja song. “im begging for you to take my hand, wreck my plans” sounds more to me that she is begging mh to take her hand and lead her away from her plans to marry and live a life with ja. i think also that its in the denial category because she was in denial about her feelings for him atp and sticking with ja to just to give it a chance (especially it being lockdown at this time she probably felt she had little choice anyway). why would she feel the need to cast a spell on her so to wreck her plans ?? what plans?? unless she’s talking about the past but it feels strange to me she’d introduce a new album with old feelings 🤷🏼‍♀️. i can see both sides and i think we’ll never know but i am on team willow is a mh song (unfortunately)

Erin M

I’ve heard fan theories that a lot of Joe’s writing credit are actually just words he said to Taylor during an argument or a fight - which would make sense for songs like Exile or Coney Island

Laura

Wait.. what did Taylor say online re Cardigan (148:07)?

Allie

I think there's more to NBNC and how hoax and the Great War reference her being cheated on/her believing she had been betrayed and spun it into a fun song but actually "my husband is cheating, I want to kill him"

Emma

dying at the "cozy day" in 24 degree weather while I'm here in Scotland literally sunbathing in 17 degrees lmao

Cassy

also a willow tree often represents mourning or grief. “life was a willow and it bent right to your wind” i think implies that her life was depressing at this point and to use the word ‘wind’ here is intriguing to me because in loml she says “when you blew in with the winds of fate”… in willow it sounds like he came in like wind and disrupted the life she was currently living that she was already beginning to struggle with and so she easily bent to his wind

elli

Y’all had me gagged and frustrated with this video lmao. So many interested points but I fundamentally don’t love the idea of MH being so present on her previous work. TTPD is more than enough for me so I think I’ll choose denial in this case.

elli

Same haha. -1° and snowing in northern Sweden today. +24° is like peak summer here 💀

Madison Sturdevant

I'm still not over Midnights being a SEVENTIES esthetic??? The nineteen SEVENTY five??? "...Til nobody noticed my new esthetic" ?? And when you search "The 1" on streaming or wherever, look who comes up right below it. ;)

Mly

I'M DYING AND I'M ONLY GOING ON WILLOW

Astoria

Are we going to talk about timing in times like these (renegade) // the goddess of timing once found us beguiling (loml)

Astoria

Give me some tips to forget you (the Alcott) // I took the miracle move on drug (fortnight)

Haley

i think midnights and ttpd are definitely matty coded but folklore and evermore feel very joe and her realizing they weren’t as stable as she thought.

Andrea

I’ve personally always connected Dorothea to Jack because of the lyric “are you still the same soul I met under the bleachers?” given that Bleachers is the name of Jack’s band … so I love this theory lol

Laura Bolanos

I have avoided going back to refathom because I think it is hard to ignore what is now staring at us right in the face. Taylor is problematic and she has TOLD us that herself lol I realized how high I idolized her because she’s a magnificent writer and she has always been painfully biographical in her songwriting. Her pining for Matty was real. Swirling him into her poems was so real. Insinuating cheating is evident and I for one believe she did do it, especially if Joe and her were on and off. Even if she didn’t physically hook up with Matty there was an emotional affair going on and that is undeniable from her songs. Refathoming has also highlighted WHY she wrote The Archer, Anti-Hero, and Dear Reader. She has told us she is not the hero, she is not always in the right, she is not a role model but despite that we love her because she shines so bright. Even Smallest Man & LOML can shed a light to it… “cuz it wasn’t sexy once it wasn’t forbidden” and “Mr. Steal Your Girl then make her cry”… Honestly, this has been a pattern since Calvin (getaway car…?) she went from needing a reason to leave Calvin and did so with Tom, all the while she was infatuated with Joe and left Tom… once she realized her feelings had faded for Joe she unstitched herself from Joe and stitched herself back to Matty. All along she’s known her problematic tendencies, she’s not one to conform. To become Joe’s wife she would need to conform in some way and she knew it, she knew for a while it wouldn’t last. Joe did too. I don’t know Joe’s reasoning on staying with her, but if I got to know my partner after years and got to the conclusion it wouldn’t last, how would I be happy? Especially with a history of depression, how would I pull myself out of that if I know the person I love may be mine now but won’t be forever because he’s smart enough to see the writing on the wall? Taylor knew she would have to admit and acknowledge the not so glimmery side to her character (champagne problems) before she could make peace with the death of the relationship publicly. These albums lay it all out for us, pretty clearly. She even called it herself on the Ellen show, how she wanted to weave her stories so that years later it would all make sense. TTPD is the key to her map. It all makes sense now.

Elis Llinares

In Long Story Short, she talks about YOU (joe) and HE (Matty?). I don’t know just a thought.

Carrie

Willow is about MH not JA had me literally sick.

JentaSarabia

GIRLS CLOSURE IS DEF ABOUT MH and long story short talks about joe as you and he as matty (which fascinatingly enough is the opposite of in ivy)

Mly

I think the part of Willow's music video with the people dancing in capes is a reference to the music industry and that's why he was there too.

Allie

This dive into the willow music video is MIND BLOWING

Leah Rose

I want to point out that in September 2019, Matty Healy did a podcast on The Green Room where he legit said that if Taylor did an acoustic album, or a return to country sort of album, he'd help her set up the mics or something like that. Then you have folklore out not even a year later, and then evermore. I'm not saying he influenced her to go to alternative/folk more acoustic centered music. But he's been in her atmosphere for years at this point. Just an interesting connection I wanted to point out.

Julien Heideck

And there was one price I'd cheat (on Joe?!?!) to win.

Allie

"If I would have known how many pieces you had crumbled into, I might have let them lay" is sooooooooooo far away from "and I've read this one where you come undone, I chose this cyclone with you" 🤯🤯🤯

Kayleigh

“Gain the weight of you then lose it” reminds me of the beginning of so long London “my spine split from carrying us up the hill” her not being able to leave back then meant she just took more and more weight on from him until eventually it broke her, which is so deeply upsetting 😞

Mly

Thank you so much for this video. I needed it. I've been listening to Reputation, Folklore, Evermore, Midnight, and TTPD, and it's quite an experience. Being able to see Taylor's lyrical growth and experiences and put them together in such a creative and beautiful way is truly incredible. I will always be grateful to have lived in the right time to listen to Taylor's music and watch your videos. <3

Lucia

Don’t know if anyone has said this already: without trying to spoil anything, if you read Rebecca you might find out one other song from Evermore might be inspired by that book as well!!

JentaSarabia

Taylor did NOT direct an entire video of her and Postie writing each other letters to think closure is NOT about MH???! Ok I'm a closure stan so here's my take: in folklore era, Taylor was dreaming of Matty but kind of also giving up on the dream? like in The One, 'It would have been fun'. But I DO believe that song and that album brought them back together. I can imagine the tortured poet in MH being in awe of her lyricism and storytelling. So they started to write to each other. A LOT. Enter: the Guilty as Sin / Ivy period. He's consuming her every thought. She's unhappy. It's the middle of the freaking pandemic and she's freaking Taylor Swift. The story of him fascinates her. I think there's plenty of evidence pointing to the fact that they might have actually had a kind of affair or even that her and Joe broke up every once in a while which gave room for MH to come into the picture. The end of evermore is where she felt like she had to make a decision. Will she stay right where he left her? Or will she go? I think Closure is the aftermath: she didn't have a choice. MH got what he wanted (an ego boost) and told her that he actually didn't want to be with her. Ofcourse that pissed her OFF. (was ANY of it true?) She even mimics his dumb english accent in the song hahaha. He's exactly the type to say he wants to give closure and to remain friends after fucking someone over like that. So that's where it ended. Or did it? (it didn't. as we now know) Just for him to do the exact same thing to her again after her and Joe actually broke up. It's devastating.

JentaSarabia

the funny thing is I was getting frustrated because they are SO in denial about there being even more MH than they are currently fathoming hahaha

JentaSarabia

I think we need to remember that we don't know anything about the true timeline of their breakup. They could have been on a break for all that time. They could have been on but mostly off. In TTPD it seems like in this period, she was still trying to fight for something (that she didn't really even believe in), but that he was far gone.

JentaSarabia

what you said about the urgency and the escape before it's too late "so tell me to run" and elope with him before the wedding is giving BIG running with my dress unbuttoned screaming bdilh energy

JentaSarabia

oh this MAKES SENSE!!!! my jaw is on the floor

JentaSarabia

PUT YOURSELF ON THE DENIAL PLAYLIST, LAUREN

JentaSarabia

facts (looking at you, DBATC 👀)

JentaSarabia

and The One: 'In my defense, i have none, for digging up the grave another time'

JentaSarabia

THIS! Can you imagine her friends listening to willow and asking her who it's about and she has to admit it's about the rat???? embarrassing

Ella

I remember feeling like tolerate it was about Joe from first listen and immediately was floored at how she could so blatantly be calling him out and he didn’t seem to realise. I think that just reinforces the idea from the song though that she was paying such close attention to him and giving him all her love, but he wasn’t doing the same for her. I got the impression he never took the meaning of the songs in or maybe even really listened to them? And the whole narrative of tolerate it seems to fit what we know about their relationship in so many ways. That’s the vibe I got anyway! It seemed like going on to midnights she pushed the boundaries even more for how much she could blatantly say about their relationship in songs to see if he would notice or react. Lavender haze seemed to confirm the narrative with ‘you don’t ever say too much’ and ‘you don’t really read into my melancholia’. Red flags!! I think that’s why tolerate it was always one of my favourites and hit me so hard, because it seemed so deeply personal for Taylor (especially being track 5). I do wonder as well whether Covid played a big part in stopping her leaving in that 2020 period. It was obviously such a tumultuous and uncertain time in the world and it would have been scary to end a long term relationship in those circumstances.

Lisa

You are international heroes for decoding this, the CIA could never!

Prerna Singh

It's only a matter of time before we (as a fandom) start claiming that Invisible string is also about MH 😔. We have to remember that not every word is to be taken literally. We have seen the video of getaway car where Taylor and Jack came up with bridge lyrics on the spot - don't tell me jack thought of Tom hiddleston and came up those lyrics. Real life events inspire a concept, like a creative prompt, which eventually turns into a song. How can willow be about MH? Taylor's two major public appearances after evermore were at grammys and Brits and she wholeheartedly thanked Joe in her acceptance speech. I believe in the 2nd half of 2021 when she was working with Jack on midnights, she reconnected with MH (as Joe was filming in the UK). This may have inspired some songs about MH and then eventually she wrote you're losing me in dec 2021.

Kirsten

Okay in the willow video, Taylor and love interest are shown as kids and in loml she refers to her and Matty as just kids…

deckman916

stop making everything about matty

Phoebe 🌷

You guys have acctually really really fucked me up with the Willow music video like holy moly ! I have seen that music video loads of times but have I ever actually WATCHED it, it would seem not. I am forever unwell! 😳😱

peachysxnrise

GIRLS the alcott is 100% about matty and them meeting up to write for midnights!!!!!

Morgan

Listening to you all go through this made me realize even more how connected she was with Matty for so long!! The trauma she has had to process is insane!! I have been waiting and waiting for her and Travis to get engaged (I know a lot of people are) BUT when you listen to refathomings like this then you realize she probably doesn’t want to rush into something. She is probably still healing! Thank you for making this video!!

Alison

Being here is optional and you can enjoy the songs however you like. If you don't like someone's opinion on a song, you can simply ignore it.

Abigail Collins

i don’t really see many people saying this so i’m gonna put my interpretation out there haha. to me, i do take “i’d meet you where the spirit meets the bones” as a metaphor for meeting her lover at the cemetery but i think by meeting her lover there she is saying they would both be buried in the cemetery. i take it as her saying, if you died i would die too and meet you buried in the ground at the cemetery, even in a “faith forgotten land” where she is certain there is no afterlife where they are going to be reunited. basically she would kill herself romeo and juliet style even if she is sure they aren’t going to meet up in heaven in the aftermath. okay hopefully i explained that decently haha❤️❤️❤️

Geneva

I think her saying "swirled you into all of my poems" will be the death of us, because now everybody's going to gaslight ANYTHING she's EVER said about Joe as if their entire six-year relationship was a sham and it pisses me off lol. Like something that's so obviously about Joe is now being revisionist-historied to somehow warp it into a Matty narrative. It's just so exhausting what we Swifties do lol, and we can blame blondie herself for causing this behaviour 🤣

Geneva

THANK YOU. I felt like I was losing my mind with this video lmaoooo

Mercedes

I feel like so many people seem to believe that Taylor said folklore and evermore were entirely "storytelling" or fiction and maybe I'm just misremembering, but I don't think she ever said that. She DID say that she was writing songs that featured characters that were not her and that her imagination ran wild but I always interpreted that as her still placing very real moments, feelings, etc in those songs but just switching up /how/ she tells the story. Plus ALL of Taylor's songs involve a story - she is first and foremost a songwriter so she will of course tweak facts to make a good song, even in the most autobiographical of songs

Ava Demassio

OH MY GOD you connecting gold rush and tolerate it because they are both day dreams and they end the same way they start and GUILTY AS SIN IS THE SAME THING. wow. genius.

Christine

Me too! I never paid attention to it either, but now I’m like 😳 And Taylor is SO involved in video concepts…

Mika B

Please when you do folklore include the original cardigan lyrics (and other songs if there is) !!🙏🏼

Christine

Maybe that’s why we go August, so she could give us the perspective of someone that has cheated or been the other women. And cheating doesn’t have to be physical, can be just emotional

Mika B

This is the best video ever and the whole fandom needs to knows the things you said because it is deeply concerning!!!!

Kirsten

Tell that to Taylor, not me

Shannon

There’s so many other connections to Joe song in invisible string though - .. the lakes reference, the dive bar reference, the barbed wire / tolerate it connection, gave me the blues (I’m with you even if it makes me blue, don’t want no other shade of blue but you) and then purple pink skies (lover) Anddd I feel like her changing invisible string to the 1 after the breakup on tour also makes sense that invisible string is about joe. Also didn’t he confirm he worked at a yogurt shop as a teen? Could have sworn I read that somewhere.

Ava Demassio

ALSO in ivy, I do think she is talking about meeting in a cemetery in the first verse which connects to loml "still alive killing time at the cemetery never quite buried" !!!!!!!!!

Laura George

If where the spirit meets the bones is a cemetery, then we can link it back to loml when she says “should have let it stay buried” and “dancing phantoms on the terrace”.

Christine

All this really makes me wonder, as Taylor did in TTPD, why MH bothered with her all those years? Why lead her on, flirt with her, love bomb her, to just leave when the chips were down. No wonder she was questioning if he was writing a book or a CIA spy faking his feelings. So much effort on his part for nothing.

Phoebe 🌷

Glad I'm not alone! Yes she's so involved she will put so much thought in to the videos and she's the only one who truly understands what each part means to her, I'd love to see a storyboard of the video

Cecilia Sparke

It makes sense that there are lyrics that relate to both Joe and Matty in the same song, or you could interrupt lyrics for both men, because she would have had to talk about these songs and explain them to Joe. She'd need to evidence that they related to Joe whilst also disguising references about Matty. Like hiding in plain sight.

Cecilia Sparke

I also wonder if some of the Anthology tracks are vault songs from Folkmore: Peter and Chloe or Sam ...

Chats & Reacts

I understand bestie haha but for me its about understanding her feelings around a song rather than thinking about matty or joe, they help guide us for sure but thinking about her experience is really what we are trying to do with these refathomings.

Chats & Reacts

I knew about the speech but I forgot they were both there omg

Laura George

“Wait for the signal and I’ll meet you after dark”…and it’s an orb light. If the signal for him is the light (Betty’s porch light), then in Peter “the woman who sits by the window has turned off the light”. The thing that they had is over once that signal, that light…is out

Chats & Reacts

omg I was at the hair dresser yesterday and I spent the whole 3 hours reading the 1975 wiki page... lol send help

Christine

The girls have a video archived of them fathoming how Taylor categorized the songs. It’s a good watch:)

Christine

Or Cardigan: 'Cause I knew you, stepping on the last train, marked me like a bloodstain’ and I Can Fix Him (No Really I Can): The smoke cloud billows out his mouth like a freight train through a small town. PLUS The 1975 have a song About You rumored to be about Taylor with line “And I miss you on a train, I miss you in the morning’

Laura George

We should pay attention to the Gracie song “Us”. There’s surely something in there. I think Gracie has her own Matty and THAT is the secret

Rana

Look up Matty with suspenders. The character in the music video is giving Matty

Riley Bidwell

Wait, help! What did she say online about cardigan?? I can’t think of what the girlies are referring to there.

Abigail Collins

i do think long story short is undoubtedly about joe, even if she uses some similar metaphors to the matty songs. when she says “and he’s passing by” she is talking to her past self who is caught up in petty things (clearly the reputation version of herself).

Leijette Riopel

I believe they are referring to her parroting Matty’s actions at his own concert a few days before. They both appeared to be mouthing “this song is about you, you know who you are. I love you”. She did this at the Nashville show he flew in from Asia to attend - sort of their first official appearance together, and it happened during Cardigan.

Claire D

Every bait and switch is a work of art…when your impressionist paintings of heaven turned out to be fakes 🤔

sebastián

this is not about anyone in here bc i actually saw it on tik tok but there’s people out there saying that gorgeous, dress, cornelia street could be about matty and i feel like screaming 😭😭 ENOUGH ! next thing we know they’ll be sayin invisible string is not about joe either

Leijette Riopel

Yes, strong Gatsby references in Happiness - “I hope she’ll be a beautiful fool” is almost a direct quote from the book, and “The green light”, as in the light across the bay on Daisy’s dock, the one Gatsby stares at while pining for and plotting to get back his “The 1 that got away”???? ….connecting the Gatsby reference possibly to Matty is something I had never really considered before. Kind of messes with my head and previous understanding of what that song could be about….

Marisa

Evermore is just simply the best album she has ever made and that's all there is to it.

Geneva

That is certifiable behaviour 🤣

Leijette Riopel

I also always thought it was about Joe, but almost entirely because it was Track 5. The legend of Track 5, that it is the most vulnerable, personal song to her on each album tells me she was literally making a confession with Tolerate it. Perhaps the fandom just wasn’t caught up on what had been going on behind the scenes enough to be able to understand, or maybe fans didn’t want to see what she was really feeling about her relationship at that time, and assumed that the song was fiction. I think it she meant us to be able to see through the smoke screen, though, because she made it Track 5. She knows we all understand what a Track 5 is. By placing Tolerate It as track 5, she absolutely meant to let the fans know that all was not well in their little “paradise”. I feel very certain of that.

Leijette Riopel

The breakup news came out April 8, which is Matty Healy’s birthday, btw….

Hayley

SUPERIOR re-fathoming ladies, as always ✨ I had a few ivy fathomings of my own that you might find interesting… What if the lyrics, “my house of stone, your ivy grows and now I’m covered in you” & “I can’t stop you putting roots in my dreamland” are a way of saying my house of stone… jail… slammer… and your ivy grows and I’m covered in you because he’s frequently on her mind especially while her boredom is bone deep in the slammer, which then connects to “he don’t understand me, all those nights you kept me goin”… and then I can’t stop you putting roots in my DREAMland… I can’t stop thinking and dreaming about you and how you could possibly give me everything I need one day (impressionist paintings of heaven). Also, others have mentioned this but I wanted to add one other thing about the cemetery theory. Obviously she says in loml “still alive killing time at the cemetery”, which is a metaphor for never quite burying what they had when they were “kids”, so it could also be metaphorical for where they’re actually meeting in ivy, especially since she follows it with “in a faith forgotten land”, which means anywhere they meetup is going to be faithless because she’s being unfaithful to her fiancé/husband. ALSO….. “your touch brought forth an incandescent glow”….. “I felt aglow like this, never before and never since” Just sayin.

Megan Nash

Part of me feels like he did love her, but everything was too much for him.. The hate he got was insane and even his family and bandmates were getting dragged into it. I think they both thought he was the "brave man" he claimed to be, but the reality was way harsher than he could actually handle.

Jennifer Maureen

Honestly i think for both of them it was just that they never had the time to see if it would work and they had so much chemistry and so they were building it up in their imagination so much that it just couldn't live up to it and he just couldnt actually handle it.

Abby J

My rambling thoughts are, I don’t think that any relationship she was in was going to work fully until she explored the “what if” with Matty. He was always there dangling the carrot and keeping those daydreams alive and she wasn’t going to be able the change the prophecy until that dream of a relationship was brought to the real world. Obviously he occupied a lot of head space for her for a long time, consciously or not. Now that she has been there, the dream has been explored and failed to live up in reality now her next chapter can really start. I don’t mean just Travis (even though I hope so) but she is now rooted in more reality with a lot of things. All of that just feels like TTPD, the manuscript, the Eras Tour, the lover house burning was the end of one book and the next book will be something totally new. I don’t know if we can predict what’s next, and I would love a Travis album all loved up and happy but really she has a clean slate in her mind to go anywhere now and that is exciting! Sorry, this was not totally an evermore related rambling but fits into some of the convos you guys had. Thanks for letting me get that off my chest! 🤣🫶🏻

Abby J

Another thought, The connection of the willow and cardigan videos intrigues me with the invisible string and going into the piano in both, but also at the Grammys when she didn’t sing the love triangle in full but put willow in instead of Betty. When you can seem to attach Matty to cardigan after what she did on stage presumably towards him, then does that connect willow to him as well since she connects the two in other ways? I dunno, I am probably saying something many others have said or I am talking nonsense! Either tracks for me, but I love those songs no matter what so oh well! Haha

Liv

"I don't like anticipating my face in a red flush" and "You'll be flushed when you return" and "And how the blood rushed into my cheeks" are all very similar too

Laura

I've always taken the 7 years in heaven lyric in happiness as a play on the teenager game 7 minutes in heaven where you get dared to go into a closet with a boy and your expected to kiss (usually in movies its when the main character has their first kiss). I think about how Taylor had been with Scott from the very beginning, he was the first and only record label she was signed to and the success she had was heaven for a long, long time. I dont think the 7 years is meant literally!!

Abby J

I think they are referring to that one time she performed cardigan at Eras and she mouthed the “this song is about you, you know who you are, I love you” thing or whatever she said exactly on stage which was the same thing Matty had just done at a 1975 concert right before that. I think at least!

Lauren

I actually don’t think it was until 2022. She and Joe had a break in 2021 (hits different, bejeweled, YLM) and then she freaked out and went back. Trust if Matty was in the picture joever would’ve happened then.

Laura

the cemetery lyric in ivy immediately reminded me of "still alive killing time in the cemetery, never quite buried" in loml.... and I personally think loml is both a matty and joe song

CHAD FARR

Im so upset you havent reacted to Mayhem yet.

ton

And I feel there’s a lot of subtext in their speeches beyond the cowboy line alone possibly

Kami

The thing with Matty is that ultimately he was an escape hatch. If things had been great with Joe then he never would have factored in. That's why it became so convoluted and easy to get lost in direction.

kayla

I always found it interesting how prevalent the themes of long term relationships coming to an end are in this album. After you’re losing me it made so much more sense to me. That idea constantly being in the back of her mind. Somewhere deep down she knew this wasn’t gonna last and channeled it into “storytelling” songs about relationships ending. Almost like a Freudian slip

Shannon Nedselsky

I feel strongly that you gals need to compile a Matty playlist! The imagery and fantasy is too amazing!!! We need a condensed version of songs to listen to! 🥰

Mitch hansen

As an Evermore Stan i have been WAITING for this please more more more Evermore videos

Sean

Savvy

💀😂

Phoebe 🌷

Oo yeah I get what you mean, and she's definitely used actors who are dead ringers for her past boyfriends to hint to us who it's about. But I also think the suspenders look really fits the theme of the world the music video is in, because he also really has that like that old timey fairground worker sort of style.

karisa

“she made it clear with saying that fucking shit with cardigan… traumatized us all” 😭 say that!!!

paulina ⭐️

not me waiting for closure re fathoming because i’m more into non romantic muses of hers and closure refashioning being 1 second long 🤡😂

Caroline

No. You. Did. Not. 🫨

Jenny

Imo repeated themes / ideas don't always mean songs are about the same person or thing -example Maroon and Red don't necessarily have to be about the same person, same for ivy and loml etc. Take Mr Perfectly Fine as an example, that's where she first used the term 'casually cruel' and then it was used in all too well, but they literally can't be about the same person because all too well isn't thought to be inspired by Joe Jonas and she hadn't even met Jake when she wrote mr perfectly fine. I think the same is true for a lot of these links we're seeing now - she's repeating themes/ideas/imagery because she likes them or they fit. Don't get me wrong I'm not saying Matty was never a muse for her pre ttpd, I'm just not of the opinion that it's all over every song or that everything we thought before is now a lie lol Love your content girls and agree 100% with one of the comments below saying how grateful we all are for your effort and hard work. My intention is for my comment to read as just a different (hopefully interesting) take, not an insult to you guys or your opinions! 💖

Hannah

You two are really feeding us content 🫶 I’m just going to have to surrender to the fact that deciphering lyrics to figure out details of what or whom things can be about really ruins the art for me. I think it’s not doing Taylor or any artists any favours to assume that they can’t create art based on multiple inspirations from their and others life to make relatable art. I simply do not think her songs is an exact diary of her life chronologically even if she is amazing in telling us stories based on things she’s feeling and going through.

Cole Jones

Haha Matty may be a pos, but he’s definitely one of the most interesting characters in the TSCU. And he really is the only man in the music industry that even comes close to Taylor in terms of artistry imo (although still leaps and bounds behind her ofc). Which I guess is why Taylor saw him as her “twin”.

Maya

Just a thought “Wait for the signal meet me after dark, show me the places where the others gave you scars” makes me think about when Taylor and Matty were meeting up at the studio at night and that he was helping her write songs and sharing his experiences in previous relationships maybe? Idk

Laila

In ivy talking about cemetery around 1:06, I realized that also in loml Taylor sings about cemetery and that when she and Matty got together it was as if they dug their relationship out from it's grave and she wished she should have left it buried.

Darya 🤍

Wait a minute. She follows the invisible string but it leads to nothing. Even as she keeps following the string after the spell casting, he’s watching her walk away, choosing to follow the string and Joe. And once she gets to the empty end of the string, he’s still there.

Cecilia Sparke

There's a link between loml and Ivy with ' your touch brought forth an incandescent glow' and 'I felt aglow like this, never before nd never since'. I'm convinced Ivy is about Matty now.

Laila

Can I do a little request to revisit the TTPD epiloge please now that all the tracks of the album have been attempted to be fathomed?

Starsonscars

Re Willow: The only thing the (smallest) man ever wrecked was her party and a rental car!

Annika 📍Melb, AU

What superior snacks is Bonny snacking on? Should I get some? The kewpie dressing that Bonny recommended in the vlog was so so good!

Lia

Also in Ivy fatal flow is very similar to winds of fate in loml

Juliette B

Or maybe gold rush is about a momentary crush she had on someone we don’t even know about

Laura

got it, thank you!

Cristina

Now we need refathoming of the Apple music interview for evermore...I feel like she says some sneaky shit there

Cristina

I never thought about this before but could this the damn season & Dorothea be the same characters in champagne problems? Like at some point maybe they sort of start dating again and he takes a leap of faith but she has to say no because the small town love is not enough

lumera

I didn’t finish the fathoming yet but something peculiar I noticed after the willow re-fathoming is the lyric “They shake their heads saying, "God help her" / When I tell them he's my man in “I Can Fix Him (No Really I Can)” which links back into the willow line about that he’s her man

Laura

I have a question I wish the girls would answer, and it's not shade, just honest curiosity. What is the appeal behind the "retconning" for you? I've been wondering because I'm seeing disputes between fans either being very much for or against it, either way it seems like a very emotional subject. So I'm wondering, is it kinda like an Easter egg hunt, deciphering clues that Taylor "left" for us to find by dropping the line about swirling him in? Is it because feeling like you know who a certain song is about makes you relate to it better? I am still unsure how I feel about it tbh, on the one hand it's fun and gossipy, on the other it kind of takes away from the art and is also a lost cause because inspiration can come from many sources and we will never know unless she releases an all-telling memoir in 40 years time (which I admit I would totally read). Curious to hear all you guys' thoughts 😊

Marcady

omg thank you. I've always wondered why she mashed up theso two . We all know that wcs is not a Matty song but some of the lyrics totally match for the Matty situation.

Levis Thompson

‘wait for the signal and I'll meet you after dark’ that lyric really reminds me of august ‘meet me behind the mall'

Marissa

“Everybody wants you” for Matty Healy is insane (I think you might be right but its insane).

Cassidy

I'm sorry guys, I will always love and appreciate your interpretations, but nothing in this whole world will convince me that willow isn't about Joe. It just is so clearly her trying to force that "we're fated" and "we're meant to be" narrative. To me, it's so much her trying to make them work and saying even through all of the bad stuff we have been through, we are soulmates so that's my man, no matter what. It's so invisible string coded (as is the music video) and I just don't think Taylor was trying this hard to hide Matty at that point. Especially when she was consistently like "oh it's fictional" for the songs that were about Matty or her sadness with Joe, but she didn't do that with willow (and long story short tbh)

Cristina

Sorry one more fathoming from me but I always assumed the willow video references songs or lyrics from folklore she's wearing the cardigan and following the invisible string, the kids are a reference to seven, and when she's in the box it's you have my past behind glass but I got me and the part we decided it's reputation for some reason gives my tears ricochet (tho that connection was only made in the eras tour wtf)...this video makes no sense 😅

Cassidy

Also, I think one thing that really separates her writing about Matty and her writing about Joe is that with Matty, she sees them as the same, like they are twin flames and they're both crazy and that's why they are meant to be. For Joe, though, she puts him on such a pedestal, like they are so so different, like "your integrity makes me seem small" and all of willow is making him seem like this bigger and better thing. Also, for the spellcasting stuff, and her own description of the song, it feels so Mastermind-like

Lisa

I don't take this as shade at all, and I think this is an interesting subject you've brought up. ❤️ For me, it helps to understand a song a bit more to really unpack it, but I think we can all agree that there is definitely also a parasocial factor to it. I think when people start to have actual fights online about what the subject matter of a song is or how you should interpret it, it crosses a line (obviously), and I think to straight up ask Taylor (or any artist) about it (in an interview, for example) is not okay either. I also feel like time and place matter. This is quite a safe place to do very deep and explicit breakdowns/re-fathomings like this, I feel, because (hopefully) everyone knows how we mean it and already appreciates the music for what it is, so that we feel more free to have discussions like this. But I think it would be a bit much if this video was on YouTube for the big masses. Do you know what I mean? And I completely understand what you mean when you say it's a lost cause because it totally is! That's why I loved a line in Ariana's song Hampstead so much: [But I find something sweet in your peculiar behaviour / 'cause I think to be so dumb must be nice] because that's all of us in these silly little chats😂

Prerna Singh

I agree. What I meant was that we as a fandom should not try to re-think every song. My point was more about Willow - that how we used to link it to Joe and now we are forcefully trying to make it seem like it was all about MH. For example, in the video, they are talking about how the lyric "wherever you stray I follow" can be about MH. It can very well be about Joe - she literally moved to London for Joe and even visited Ireland/UK where Joe was shooting at the time - wherever he goes, she follows. And again it could be about something totally different - I don't think it's fair to re-assess every song and try and make it about MH.

Prerna Singh

I completely agree with you. And I too like all their videos but this one I couldn't watch beyond the first 10mins. The whole idea to make willow about MH really put me off

Prerna Singh

Completely agree with you. You have articulated my thoughts really well. Her songs can be based off of multiple short stories/life events - and not necessarily her own life, but even her friends and family. And even if a song is about her life, artists usually add bits and pieces which may not be completely true to make the song work as a complete piece of art.

Annie

twitter peeps are saying this video is just being a maylor for an hour. I hope that is not true, is that true? I am scareedddd

sharon teles

"i just sit here and wait grieving for the living" (she is at the cemetery grieving her living feelings for matty which she needs to grieve in order to get over him and be with her boyfriend) and in loml: "still alive killing time at the cemetery never quite buried" (because she couldn't bury / get over the feelings completely). Also the opal eyes mention in ivy and matty having this eye color. She really does prefer hiding in plain sight haha (dear reader) Also i think august is the girl he met in right where you left me: "you told me that you met someone" (and that someone is august because she says on the long pond that she thinks betty and james end up together {taylor and matty} and cardigan is about him "chase two girls lose the one" so i think the love triangle story is not really fictional) "when i felt like i was an old cardigan under someone's bed" is probably about joe tolerating her. Thank you for reading my afternoon train of thoughts!

Aubrey

I think the reason why the willow mv could be about either Joe or Matty is because Joe’s story was pretty similar to the Matty storyline. She was with someone else, she was friends with Joe, secretly wanted him and had to scheme her way into being with him. She had to overcome obstacles like her fame and her other relationships to be with him. So it’s easy for some of the songs on Evermore to be about both of them. She could be mixing her muses together too. I do agree with another post that says she put Joe on a pedestal and saw Matty as her twin flame. But I think she saw both of them as her saviors from very different situations

Rhonwena

Damn I really missed when you guys just focused on the music and not nit picking about who songs might be about

Nicole

Ivy and loml all so connected, like you were both saying. Another example I saw right after ttpd: "Our field of dreams, engulfed in fire. Your arson's match" from loml is really giving "Clover blooms in the field"..."so yeah it's a fire, it's a goddamn blaze in the dark and you started it" from Ivy

nikki

I know it’s a stretch with the pronoun usage to think this, but I like to think that in long story short when she says “I’m all about you,” she is talking to herself, saying she’s putting herself first. Self-empowerment Taylor.

Nicole

Oh this made me refathom that "the professor" who told her to write what she knew COULD in some ways be inspired by Matty, outside of the more obvious Therapist and/or Jack or Aaron perspective.

Maria

Well, Cardigan is abt Matty (she literally said so herself) and the Willow music video is a continuation of the Cardigan music video. That’s a pretty clear sign if you ask me😏

Nicole

"Do you really wanna talk about timing in times like these" has also always carried a COVID-19 "unprecedented times" vibes in some ways. You want to talk about marriage (or breaking down) when we are literally locked together I this house??

Eirini

I am socked by how much fathoming happened 🤯 I agree on everything, except long story short tbh… I don’t think it’s for the fans, I think it’s about Joe… “he passes by rare as the glimmer of a comment in the sky” might be a reference to Matty, but I do feel like she acknowledges that Joe helped her through the reputation era and she was trying to find reasons to feel like he is the right choice for her - I thought I was better safe than starry eyed!

Eirini

Also, not related to Evermore, but every time I listen to New Romantics I cannot stop thinking about the bridge of Down Bad: please leave me stranded, it’s so romantic/how dare you think it’s romantic leaving me safe and stranded 🤯 and we know that they were connected during 1989 era

Starsonscars

And… remember he is the Smallest Man Who Ever Lived

kayla ramoutar

i haven't watched the video (because i'm not matty fan and am not willing to look for different ways to interpret songs, i trust my own thoughts lol) but closure is one THOUSAND percent about karlie in a friendship way. it's giving friendship break up soooo much harder than romantic break up.

kayla ramoutar

you're literally so correct. i'm so sorry but just because the end of joe and taylor's relationship sucked doesn't mean ALL six years sucked. she loved him! she wrote love songs about him! to ascribe ALL those songs to m*tty is insane lol

paulina ⭐️

exactly that’s why i wanted to know some interpretations after some time with album if girls are leaning towards karlie or scott. i totally agree with you it’s very kloss coded, end of friendship. i’ve seen some theories that it’s about Kim that was trying to reach out but we do know now after ttpd that’s absolutely bullsh ps totally respect your decision to not listen! i don’t like sudden change into „everything is about matty” i don’t even like these conversations who is the main romantic muse of the song. im definitely more into career or friendship songs fathomings 🤗

Mads

Omg mind blown! That is such a good point!

Renata

yea, listening to that mashup after ttpd really opened my eyes lol. the “my boredom’s bone-deep” -> “if you’d never saved me from boredom i could’ve gone on as i was” pipeline is real. both of these men used her interest in them and her desire to Feel Something to reel her in without intending anything serious with her. very illening to think of !

elli

I totally get that and you make some really good points for things I’ve never fathomed which is why I was gagged multiple times lol. I just don’t want to believe them 😂

Jana Woodbury

There is a pub called The Garden Gate near the Heath. Cowboy - Matty's speech at the NME Awards in 2020. Taylor was there, both won awards, video of them hugging.

Jana Woodbury

Yes, Taylor Swift appeared on *Loose Women*, the ITV daytime talk show where Matty Healy’s mother, Denise Welch, is a panelist. Swift was a guest on February 18, 2009, during her early career, promoting her album *Fearless*. She performed her hit single "Love Story" and discussed topics like her rise to fame and body image. This marked her first UK TV performance. If they met back then they were only 19. She commented on his Tumbler posts pre 2013. She asked the band to tour with her and her tour ran March 2013 to June 2014. I do think she knew him prior to 2014. The 1975 has a song called Happiness too. And Paris. Many songs are connected.

Mia Leone

Thank you so much for this video!!!! I’ve been rethinking all of these songs and it was so affirming to hear you discuss it, too. I love how you rewatched Willow and included Renegade and The Alcott in the fathoming. Love you girls!

Josh

i REALLLYY think you guys need to refathom The Alcott. Its honestly one of the most underrated and forgotten about songs, but truly has so much in it that I think explains the Joe breakup and also the reconnection of her and Matty!!

Hannah Steppe

in coney island “wondering where did my baby go” it links back to call it want you want on rep “my baby’s fit like a daydream walking with his head down im the one he’s walking to” !!!!!! where is that guy she once knew and called her baby?!?

Kris

This could be a stretch, but I just realized a possible connection of the lyrics in willow of the “open shut case” now makes me think of TTPD and the theme of all the files and it being like reviewing the case of her relationships!

CB

Kami

"Talk about timing in times like these" is 1000% about marriage/proposal imo. How often is it said that "oh nows not the right time" to brush of questions about proposing, turn it around a few months and "I wouldn't marry me either" pops up. It's evidently been a prominent issue at this time that's she begrudgingly realised he doesn't want to give her everything.

Kami

Yes! So much of the album is blatantly laid out in the epilogue. (Plus I genuinely think it's some of her best work, I love reading it)

Kami

I always want them to do a mini follow up fathoming with the comments fathomings cause I think that'd inspire some great discourse amounst them.

Phoebe 🌷

100% agree with you on this and that squeeze my hand stuff is so so similar to the Cornelia Street ending !

Phoebe 🌷

oh my god, the clover fields could be her field of dreams ! Wow never connected that !

Laura

Ah love this Lisa! And yes so thankful for this community and the safe space 🥰

Juliana Martinez

now GOLD RUSH. i do feel is about joe. how many times has taylor sung about gold and that being tied to joe? countless. it reminds me of a song like gorgeous, thinking it’ll never work out but thinking someone is really hot. both songs have the same energy. and the hair falling down like dominos reminds me of joe’s side part, longer hair that just sits perfectly.

Juliana Martinez

this fathoming is specifically to understand where taylor was at when she wrote evermore. they have tons of song breakdowns analyzing lyrics and stuff on their youtube. they even have a whole evermore video on just analyzing the songs and the lyrics. these refathomings are more for getting more personal into taylor’s mind (in a very parasocial way hahah)

Anna K

This is absolutely insane and I cannot process this right now. This whole video and all these comments are just too damn much! (Although, I do love the refathomings… 😆 I’ve always listened with the ear of how they affect me and my personal connection with them but it’s also eye opening to listen to everyone else’s interpretations, picking up on things I’ve never noticed before. God, I love this channel. 😂)

jkar

Yesss, I had the same exact thought!

Elis Llinares

Have you ever fathomed that in the summer of 2022, Taylor ans Joe took a vacation to the Bahamas? They stayed at Lenny Kravitz’s home in Eleuthera? (The reason I know this is because I was in Eleuthera just around the same time).

Elis Llinares

So just before Midnights came out but after You’re Losing Me was written.

Annie930

I paused at 15 minutes to type this, so apologies if this is addressed later in the video, but in Willow: "there was one prize I'd CHEAT to win," gives Matty. And also "you know my train could take you home" is giving I Look in People's Windows. "North bound I got carried away/ as you boarded your train."

Kayla Knutson

I was waiting for them to make the connection between cowboy like me and I can fix him as well. Soooo many things make sense when fathoming I can fix him as the continuation of the cowboy like me story.

Enzo Reis

1:21:27 I think that Long Story Short it's about Joe. We know from these lyrics from Renegade that Joe would show up whetenever Taylor was leaving and change it: "But do you know you're demolishing me? And then you squeeze my hand as I'm about to leave". Even in Cornelia Street in the lyrics: "I packed my bags, left Cornelia Street Before you even knew I was gone But then you called, showed your hand I turned around before I hit the tunnel Sat on the roof, you and I". But even so, in these happy songs we can already see signs that it wasn't a long-lasting relationship. Even in a beautiful song like Long Story Short she's still saying: "And we live in peace. But if someone comes at us This time, I'm ready." Which shows that their relationship was a constant battle. Taylor had to always be in full autopilot protection mode, since Joe couldn't handle Taylor's fame, so she had to constantly fight against everything to protect him and keep the relationship intact. So I find it interesting that even the most romantic songs that were written for Joe, have these clues and signs that we weren't seeing and that even Taylor didn't want to see.

Enzo Reis

@Kayka Knutson you took my words! I was about to say this. There's definetly a connection between Cowboy Like Me and I Can Fix Him. 🥺💖

Enzo Reis

1:26:02 Of curse Bonnie it shows that Matty Healy was always there in disguise. This scene is the representation of the lyric: "Swirled you into all of my poems Now we're at the starting line, I did my time." Because after that scene she comeback to the place that she was in the beginning of the video and he is there. But, even when she was casting a spell in her mind, to him return to her, he already was there. Meaning Matty was already thinking about Taylor and returning to her life, which makes sense that they would start to talk again as "friends" even tho they both knew that they never were just friends. And that they connection would grow more in Midnights. Willow is their returning to each others life and thinking about each other.

Enzo Reis

Yes! I think Evermore the song is Joe and Taylor's reconciliation.

Enzo Reis

I think the first lines in It's Time to Go is about Matty Healy: "When the dinner is cold and the chatter gets old You ask for the tab Or that moment again, he's insisting that friends Look at each other like that".

Enzo Reis

1:49:33 I think TS12 is gonna be about Travis, the Taylor negativity that has been happening since 2024, the Blake Lively situation of her calling Taylor one of her dragons and the Kayne law suit thing and maybe some Joe phatoming since she said it in How Did It End that there's stil things for her to unpack.

Fede

plus, the whole cemetery thing too in both songs!

Jennifer🫶🏻

I believe the ‘open shut case’ in willow is her saying, I’ve realised that my relationship with Joe (who I thought was the one) is not working out, it’s clear that our childhood promise (ending up together) will be endgame.

Akchita S.

I have followed y’all since the first Lover video and I am honestly exhausted by all of these re-fathomings becoming about the men and paternity testing each song. I don’t think that Matty was that deeply engrained in her mindset during the Evermore season. In some cases, yes, I definitely think that it’s important to the story to know who it’s about but it also shouldn’t be all that we hold on to (Lover for example). I think that Taylor borrows and expands on previous songs in different ways (such as You All Over Me having the “clean” lyric and her writing Clean which is essentially expanding on that concept). I’m saying this all respectfully and people can disagree as they wish.

Pia Fleig

So many train analogies in Marty coded songs!

Marissa

Such a great refathoming - thanks so much for this video! 🥰👏

CamilleC

I think it's easier to believe that Matty and her met before the 2014' picture and that her and Joe had more pauses in their rs. I think a lot of fans don't want to believe in Matty cause if his antics but it's right there, if he hadn't ghosted her she could be with him still, i wonder if it's why fans don't like ttpd that much? A little too real 🤷 he's a great muse even if we don't want him to be 😅. I wonder about cruel summer too and i wonder if in shake it off he is the fella with the hella good hair 🙃👀

majesticwestwick

Every line in Gold Rush seems to be about Matty, except for “what must it be like to grow up that beautiful?” … I don’t get why she would write that about Matty, because he’s one of the least attractive of all her exes.

majesticwestwick

She went from dating Tom Hiddleston to Joe Alwyn to Matty, and Matty is the one that’s so beautiful?? … I don’t think so

sillychicken

I think there’s also a link with ivy cemetery imagery to the loml lyrics “still alive, killing time at the cemetery, never quite buried”

Vanessa

THANK YOU. finally someone else says it.

Vanessa

agreed. thank you for this refreshing take

C

I almost didn't press play on this video after seeing the thumbnail but I gave it a try anyway and already with willow they're trying to say it's about Matty.....what is happening......and every comment agreeing with this too is making me feel insane. I'm looking wondering if it's time to unsubscribe from the Patreon

Nicole Gordon

I agree that it makes sense to look at Evermore in the context of Matty Healy. But I also just happened to watch part of the Evermore Zane Lowe interview the other day and she talked about latching onto the storytelling as a way to process what she’s going through without totally putting her life on blast for the world, and I think about how she was working on re-records simultaneously with a lot of this, and I think about how people argue about who TTPD songs are about ….. and I just can’t help thinking that this might actually be the start of her really taking experiences past and present and putting them into the songwriting soup. So you really can see some songs where things happened in multiple relationships, etc… I think I kind of am at the place for most songs where the answer to “is it X or is it y” is “yes” at least for a good portion of her recent songs.

Sam

Love this! So much of Evermore was perplexing to me for so long (even as my fave album) but now understanding this missing Matty piece in her life I feel like the album makes soooo much more sense. Willow is a huuuuuge lightbulb moment!

Hunter

God this is why I love being a swiftie, it’s like a continuos show that keeps having new seasons and I’m locked in 😭 - this was actually so much fun to decipher with you two!!

Frida

I don't know where to write this comment, but I need you to see this before you re-fathom folklore and I haven't seen you talk about this before🫶 Because of personal experience, I have always seen this is me trying as being about the different perspectives of two people going through a break-up. Vers 1 is about one person, and vers 2 is about the second person. Both verses explore that the two people have their own ways of acting and coping during a break-up, and that they are both just trying their best. The bridge is what they both are feeling, but maybe cannot say to the other person. After the news about Joe and Taylor came out, I now see this is me trying as maybe being about the two of them. With the first verse about Joe, because of all the references in other songs to blue and depression, and the fact that it seems he didn't communicate his feelings in a good way - "And maybe I don't quite know what to say". The second verse I interpret to be Taylors perspective, especially with all the lyrics in newer songs that hint to her coping with her feelings by using alcohol (ex Hits Different, Fortnight, Dear Reader ..). The "Pouring out my heart to a stranger" really reminds me of the Dear Reader bridge, and just the fact that Taylor writes really personal songs which she shares with us (literal strangers). And the "they told me all my cages were mental", could refer to Joe and Taylors relationship and that people though she was just self-sabotating their relationship, that "the cages" was just in her head. I could have said so much more about all the lyrics in the song, but then this comment would be a book haha😅 Maybe you have already seen this connection and already talked about it, but I just needed to share this with you guys if not!

Sam

This is one of my fav videos you guys have done!! Ive fathomed so much ty!

Jenn Hamel

BONNY WITH THE TRUTH ABOUT WILLOW FINALLY

Pia Fleig

Have you guys ever watched the YT videos from a channel called The Song Decoder? She goes into a lot of details about all the songs that are definitely and potentially about Matty. What's really interesting is how certain metaphors appear in those Matty coded songs (all the way to the 1989 vault songs): stars and planets, boy/childhood, the ocean, trains, cars, and then obviously all the mentions of cigarettes and alcohol.

Kate Reinwald

Whether we want to admit it or not, guessing who Taylor is writing about and following her life is a huge part of what makes being a fan so fun. There is nothing wrong with doing that. Further, Bonnie and Emily do it in a very respectful and loving way. If these types of videos aren’t your vibe, then perhaps skip them?

Kate Reinwald

Marty 🤣🤣 he is totally Marty from now on

Akchita S.

I disagree that guessing who Taylor writes about is a *huge* part but to each their own. I would absolutely skip if I knew that it’s what was going to happen. Maybe in the future it’ll be more clear but I’m allowed to feel however I do!

nina

I do think it’s hard to try get a full understanding of what a song is about without acknowledging who it’s about, particularly with folklore and evermore being portrayed as heavily fictional, it’s hard to understand what she’s trying to say without the context of if it is non-fiction, the reason (person) why

Michaela

Interesting that in the willow MV she's stuck in a box and trying to get out, given the lyric "he took me out of my box"

Tayler Sale

Girls this fathoming has exploded my brain! I never thought about so many of Evermore songs that way. Superior fathoming!! 🤍

Jordan 🌻

I’m on my 3rd listen of this video, I love listening to you guys untangle the knots Taylor spun up for us! Thanks for being such a comfort during these crazy times 🫶🏻

Sam

“While you were out buildin other worlds where was i?” = “I didnt opt in to be your odd man out” kind of reminds me of that

Jennifer

Fantastic video. I just want to say again that in ivy she isn't married but engaged. Her hand has been promised to another, she's betrothed, with her hand is promised in marriage . Then she's imagining how this might play out, "what we'll become" which is him drinking her husband's wine in the future.

Riley Swain

I've fathomed that “Your midas touch on the chevy door” isn’t JUST that everything he touched turned to gold -- it's something you think is positive at first but the midas touch is actually a CURSE because it means you can’t touch the people you love ever again. 😭

Emma

Love re fathoming evermore. So many iconic songs! I don’t know about anyone else but the pouring rain throughout this whole video is so therapeutic!

Breezy Bumbles

I need business (probably) decades to absorb all this information. But I am so fascinated to look at these songs through this perspective. Taylor blows my mind every single day.

Madison Sturdevant

Wait I feel like this explains why we never got an Evermore Long Pond. She couldn’t do the little conversation bits about these songs, she knew Jack would give it away that they’re all about Matty!!!! (Jk — but seriously! How is she supposed to sit there and explain Willow on camera if it’s not about Joe)??

liinailu

About ivy and the cemetery image. It reminds me of the lyric in loml “still alive, killing time at the cemetery”. Just found it interesting

Madison Sturdevant

I once saw a TikTok that said maybe Joe has writing credits because she used lines he said to her, either in conversation or in a fight, weaving his words into her songs. Or maybe she just overheard him playing a little piano bit and used that to write songs, (like maybe she used his piano bit to write Coney Island about the demise of their relationship). Just interesting thoughts to ponder. :)

Abby B

is it just me who misheard "that somehow seems so hollow now" in down bad as "that stone house seems so hollow now" and was making a connection back to ivy?!?! i literally just looked up the lyrics for the first time because i was SO sure that was the lyric and it's not... whoops!

Ryls

We really need her to give us documentaries like the long pond sessions for every album it would be so interesting watching her go back over every album and explaining why/what each song really is about

Megan C

I've saved this until i could reluatwn to the original breakdowns and holy sh*t... the willow refathoming has me almost falling onto the floor!! I never thought of the perspective of it being about MH 🤯🤯🤯🤯

Kate Kidd

I think Champagne Problems is about Rory and Logan for Gilmore Girls 😂😂 It’s like an identical story.

Megan C

Besties... this video is superior. Hellllllpppppppp! I have listened to it at least five times. Holy sh*t that willow and gold rush are Matty songs. I do think evermore could be too (but also the fans and also maybe a bait and switch!).... let us not forget the Peter x evermore mashup! This was so incredible. My mind is blown. I can't wait for folklore refathoming but take your time because I will be reeling from this evermore refathoming for quite some time. ♥️♥️♥️♥️

Megan C

💯!!!!!!

Hailey&amp;Madison_h

for the cemetery imagery i do think one it in 2 ways one like u said they meet a cemetery (bc it’s a place not many people go so they can’t get caught/ spotted) and 2 like Bonny said either that she/ her current relationship is dying and then in the second verse the watching the old widow goes to the stone everyday is like her watch the widow and thinking they life is better for it that they loved some enough to go to their grave and that she doesn’t feel that way rn with her husband

Hailey&amp;Madison_h

sorry to double comment here but after watching the willow music video… taylor comes to the end of the invisible string that is gold… and the man doesn’t touch the invisible string except for the first time when they are kids… so if he is Matty then he is there the whole time but he isn’t the sting the he is adjacent to the string he was there but the string was also there… matty and joe but she isn’t looking for the string she is just going along with it but she is looking for Matty…. idk just what i thought i about while watching with u all i totally could be wrong hahah

Talita Fontes

can we talk about how she only made two MV for folklore and evermore, and both songs were about matty??

Katie LaFave

surprised that while you were fathoming tolerate it, that you didn't realize that the bridge ends after "what would you do if i" cuz i'v heard you guys mention before that you thought "break free & leave us in ruins" was also part of the bridge!

LewJamBla

I honestly always saw "times like these" as being about Covid, since it was released during those times. Back when everything was so uncertain and we were just taking it one day at a time, so talking about "times in times like these" always hit me as being about that.

Ally ❤️

I think I’ve said this before… but here I go again: The poem that Taylor narrates on Rep Tour before getaway car (“Why she disappeared”) seems to reference her “desertion” of Matty as - even calling him out him out in similar words “Avoiding old haunts and sidestepping shiny Pennies…wary of …charmers, dandies, and get love quick schemes…” I think she really is referencing Matty here.

Alison Howat

“Carry your baggage up my street” gives me “carried the weight of the rift” And “pulled him in tighter each time he was slipping away” gives me “pulled your body into mine every god damn night”

Fi🌸

I always think Ivy is so similar to the lady chatterly’s lover story like it’s literally the story I wonder if she watched that and made the song too

Jazmín Bicego

i have SO much to say but also about Ivy: not only the cemetery ties it to loml, but also the incandescent glow !!! I FELT A GLOW LIKE THIS NEVER BEFORE AND EVER SINCEEEEEE

Fi🌸

I saw the 1975 live 3 times back in the day and matty has so much charisma 😅 it makes total sense Taylor would write about him like this

Brittany Fitzgerald

She sang Gold Rush as a surprise song when Matty was in the audience too! It was definitely partially because of The Eagles tshirt line (Philly), but still curious.

Bella

I was thinking the same thing!!

Coffee @ Midnight

I would also like to point out (and I’m not sure if it’s been said here or not yet), but Taylor ran into Matty in early 2020 right before the pandemic at the NME awards (the 1975 were performing and won an award, Taylor was there for her Lover nominations). Taylor was there with Joe, but there’s video of her interacting with Matty a few times during the night and notably she left the floor when the 1975 won an award (possibly to congratulate them backstage, but she could have been going to get another drink or go to the ladies room for all we know). The point here is that I think that may have been the reconnection point that explains why she was ruminating on him during the time she was writing folklore & evermore. After running into your hot flame ex situationship when you’re having mixed feelings about your current long term relationship, its natural to be wondering what “could have been” and perhaps “just may be still” especially when that starts flowing into a time that this ex starts working with your best friend collaborator.

Samm Delamoneda

I love you guys so much, as someone who had her own Matty every song you guys called out for him are the ones I thought of while hearing ttpd for the first time

Samm Delamoneda

Also folklore being black and white means something to me 👀

Samm Delamoneda

I think it’s metaphorical for like “rich famous and popular” he’s a British nepo baby

Emilie

I always thought of Lover as being more of an album about HER being the Lover and not about A lover (Joe) and it always made me very suspicious when she talked about Death by a Thousand Cuts being based on stories about breakups etc because she lies a lot about that when she wants to hide something.. and I really feel that Lover has some parts about Matty too, even in Cruel Summer, and maybe some feelings were projected onto Joe that weren't really about him per se. I say this because I've been there too, and as much as I believe that she loved Joe at some point VERY intensely and that she would die to see him smile at some point, I believe that this whole relationship may have been born from the desire to avoid getting hurt by trying to make it work with Matty at that time ("I thought I was better safe than starry eyed"). And that explains a lot in my head. After all, it was "YEARS of labor locks and ceilings".

Emilie

omg bonny just talked about "i thought i was better safe than starry eyed" after i typed and sent all of this lol

Emilie

and i am so so sorry as i say this but i do not think joe EVER wrote a song with taylor. i just don't

Emilie

and the evermore bridge says it ALL. it's not about the fans. it is the prologue to midnights AND tortured poets. IF joe wrote anything it was like a comma or something.

Kristina

I’m 11 minutes in and I’m genuinely fucked up about willow. How am I getting through the rest of this 😭😭

Riley H

In the section of coney island where she references her past relationships, she says "a universe away", which felt a little out of place personally. I had a realisation that this could possibly reference Matty, especially looked at in relation to Down Bad (alien references) and Peter ("underneath the same moon in different galaxies"). Just a thought and might be reaching but thought I would share

isabel

i think ivy doesn’t necessarily have to be a married woman, but just a taken woman who is daydreaming about a different partner than her own

Pratibha

With this hindsight, I must say 'tolerate it' as track 5 makes complete sense. It's her most vulnerable track and she hid it there and we couldn't make sense of it until we got TTPD!!!

Stephanie

I always took “motion capture put me in a bad light” is about Cats. They used motion capture to turn the actors into cats, and the movie was widely panned, therefore putting her in a bad light.

Em Wilkins

for me "fades into the grey of my day-old tea" has always been a reference to joe (very sadly, because man who would want to be described like that?) but he is british and english tea is an obsession here and it's almost referencing his depressive periods, like she's saying i was blushing pink and so giddy to see you, but then i dropped back into reality and the colour drained from my face again as i faded back into my actual life and relationship, which is getting stale, because i realise "it could never be".

asquared13

Thank you. I don't doubt there are hints to someone other than her 6 year relationship throughout her discography but a lot of fans are reaching too hard and also trying to reconfigure song retroactively to fit them into narratives around Taylor's love life. I think it takes away from her incredible skill of writing about moments and feelings without them always being autobiographical. I think a lot of fans need songs to fit a specific person in Taylor's life because it's the only way it makes sense to them. From the way Taylor speaks I feel like she wants us to interpret these songs as parts of our lives & experiences.

Chevonne

for Willow's first lyric, lets remember that Joes metaphor is a ship, so its not a vague lyric!

Jade

holy shit Emily you look MAGIC in this

Katrina

Am I the only one confused about why no body, no crime was skipped? Isn’t it actually inspired by a shitty ex of Este’s that took money from her to take another woman to the Mediterranean? Or am I totally out to lunch on this? Lol

Andreea

The way gold rush begins and ends with the same lyrics — just like Guilty As Sin? — has me thinking things

RL

With the ‘stray’ lyric in Willow i don’t know if it’s spelled the same, but i thought of a stray dog, like maybe black dog. and in that song it kinda all stems from her checking his location and following where he goes. (that is if all of this has matty woven into it)

RL

In Ivy, “where the spirit meets the bones” could also be a double meaning, like spirits as in liquor hitting the teeth, at this event or party or wherever they’ve come in from the snow to. It’s giving Lorde’s “Liquor wet lime” line, when it’s just a really poetic way to say we took some tequila shots.

Marjorie Dwyer

Um HOUSE OF STONE, YOUR IVY GROWS?! The wall behind them in the last scene of the willow mv is stone!!

Ashley

You guys were SAYING SOME THINGS about Coney Island omg.

Dany Rv

At what point do you stop watching the re fathoming videos???

Shar

I was thinking this! Maybe lines were inspired by their actual conversations and she felt he deserved credit?? I just can’t imagine him writing these devastating songs with her about themselves???

khalil El annan

Gain the weight of you = My spine split from carrying us (so long london)

moi_la_desi

Hey Girls, I love your re-fathoming videos and come back to them all the time. You're often clocking things that (kinda) get confirmed at a later time. For this episode I just have one feedback: The eating sounds are really off putting to me. Maybe I'm the only one and ofc you can make your videos the way you want to. But maybe recording time and snacking hour needn't overlap necessarily? 🫶🏻

JD IHateItHere

I always suspect he contributed melodically as he fiddled on the piano. Her hearing it and crediting him as a way to stitch him to her and carry the weight of them up the hill.

Melissa

The last minutes convo about TS12 when we knew nothing… and now we’re about to listen to The Life of a Showgirl!

August Evermore

On Willow. The “mythical thing” kind of links to Labyrinth. The labyrinth of Greek myth has a ball of string used for the hero to find his way back after defeating the minotaur. I’ve not thought this through but it just popped into my mind.

LiliaC

Ivy actually gives Love in the Times of Cholera vibes. I had never read the lyrics before.

Em Wilkins

for me, in willow, the lyric "there's one prize i'd cheat to win" isn't necessarily her saying that *did* happen and she *did* cheat, but more saying "if you gave me an indication you wanted this, i'd do it". also i hear gold rush as "i love you, but i don't like how you make me feel", and almost trying to remind herself of that by repeating that she doesn't like it like "you know this taylor, you know you don't like the uncertainty, you know you don't want to feel like you're fighting other people for this guy, you KNOW you don't like to feel so out of control and you KNOW it can never be".

Ally ❤️

Golly ladies! This refathoming is so, so good!! This is the content that no one else could offer! I appreciate the deeper dive. And it all just proves what you both have always said: you only understand an album in the context of later albums as the narrative continues. She is (as my husband says) a modern day Mozart; a lyrical and musical savant. ❤️

Ally ❤️

When Emily described the cold stone house in Ivy, I could only think of COSOSOM “If you want to break my cold, cold heart… just say you loved me the way that I was…”

Gokce Mutlu

I didn't realize until I read your comment but yes I can imagine for different people it might feel differently.

Alevtina

Also the parallel between “wreck my plans, that’s my man” in willow and “when I tell’em he’s my man” in I can fix him after he did wreck her plans.

Lori Bland

I wish you guys would consider releasing the Evermore & Folklore reactions in full on Patreon. I'd love to watch the full videos without all the cuts.

Renee S Smith

I think Willow is about Joe honestly. It has the same energy as Do something, say something, risk somethinf

Serene

The way that Selena just spilled that Dorothea was actually about Selena and their friendship. 😂

Barb 🔆

So not worth the comment

Barb 🔆

I agree. IMHO based on the music, Matty and Taylor seem to be way more then quick fling, ten yr from afar fantasy, six weeks then implosion. There seems to be Def on and offs back and forth with Joe and times with matty prior to 2023.

Soph

I know y’all brushed over closure and I definitely agree it’s not actually about matty but a fun connection to him in it is when she says “with my tears and my beers and my candles” and in his song when we are together he says “shes more into scented candles” so i just thought thats a silly connection over candles. It’s those little back and forth lyric parallels over YEARS of song writing that fucks me up

Alevtina

She made up stories about her and an idea of a man who Matty could be but isn’t. So the storytelling lie wasn’t really a lie in the end.

Ilka van Schalkwyk

It's interesting to me that her friends tried but she didn't hear it watched her daily disappearing...and the one thing that got through to her in her Joe unhappy haze ended up being a quick brush with Matty.

Cynthia

As a new subscriber I am in total awe of your discussions. Your in-depth knowledge of Taylor's body of work is mind blowing. You are THE BEST available bar none (I've listened to a few others that also try hard...) you eclipse them all. Thank you so much! I've loved listening to the hours of discussions and thoughts.

Kenz

With a lyric like “wait for the signal and meet me after dark” to having Illicit Affairs as a song, amongst other small lines possibly pointing to infidelity whilst in her relationship with Joe? 😬 to then disguise as storytelling. I’m not saying she’s a cheater cause I wouldn’t want that, buttt I also don’t know if I can’t easily remove it from the realm of possibility. Especially also, sorry another thought, in Fortnight she says “my husband is cheating I want to kill him” maybe in their on and off again more than we know (just watched your midnights refathoming) Joe did cheat once or more so then she started maybe crossing lines with Matty after that?!? Sorry for that long rant, thinking out loud as someone catching up on all these videos 😅